JUDGEMENT
1. This complaint is filed U/s.35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 against the Opposite Party No.1 to 3 on the allegations of deficiency of service, and thereby seeking direction, against the Opposite Parties to reimburse medical expenses of Rs.2,81,500/-, and Rs.1,00,000/- as compensation with interest @18% P.A., from the date of complaint till its realization towards the mental agony, tension, caused to the complainant.
2. The Brief facts of the complaint are:
a) It is the case of the complainant that, she had obtained a mediclaim insurance policy Bg No.422200/48/2025/3514, prev. policy No.422200/48/2024/1778, from Opposite Party No.1 & 2. The policy is valid from 16.12.2024 to 15.12.2025, the complainant had obtained the said policy several years back and has been continuing the same.
2
b) The complainant further submits that, for hysterectomy and Oophorectomy, as per the her doctor's advice, she got admitted to Aster CMI hospital, No.43/2, New Airport Road, NH 7, Dr. Puneeth Rajkumar Road, Sahakar Nagar, Bangalore.
c) The complainant further states that, when the complainant got an advice from her doctor to go for the aforesaid surgery itself, the complainant informed the same from the aforesaid hospital to the Opposite Party No.3, who according to the Opposite Party No.1 & 2 is their claim authority, therefore, it is very clear that, even before admitting to the hospital for the aforesaid surgery, the complainant had informed, the same to the Opposite Party No.3. The complainant got admitted to the aforesaid hospital on 16.01.2024, and got discharged on 18.01.2025 and underwent surgery referred above in the hospital stated supra.
d) The complainant further contended that, she has spent not less than a sum of Rs.4,70,210/- towards the hospital charges and surgery expenses. The Opposite Parties ought to have sanctioned legitimate claim of the complainant at least upto Rs.4,00,000/-, which is the value of the insurance policy obtained by the complainant. She
3
had opted for cashless payment facility directly from the Opposite Parties to the hospital, the complainant was surprised to see that, the Opposite Parties initially had only sent only a sum of Rs.40,000/- to the hospital instead of a sum of Rs.4,00,000/-
e) The complainant further contended that, instead of complying the demand made in the notice, the Opposite Party No.3 issued a reply notice dtd 13.02.2025, under the caption/heading 'without prejudice' and mentioned that, 'total admissibility of the claim is only Rs.1,18,500/-, thereafter, the Opposite Party No.3 has a sent a sum of Rs.78,500/- to the complainant through NEFT. The complainant has received the same under protest/without prejudice, therefore, in total the Opposite Parties have paid only a sum of Rs.1,18,500/-, the repudiation of the claim on the ground that, the complainant has opted for modern treatment method of Robotics is unsustainable under law. Hence, prays to allow the complaint.
3. After admission of the complaint, commission issued notice to Opposite Party No.1 to 3 for appearance and put forth their defence, Opposite Party No.2 has appeared through their counsel and filed their written version. Inspite of receipt of notice to Opposite Party
4
No.1 & 3 failed to appear on the date of appearance, hence, Opposite Party No.1 & 3 was placed exparte.
4. Defence Version of the Opposite Party No.2:[Insurance Co.,]
a) The Opposite Party No.2 admits that, the issuance of individual mediclaim policy No.422200/48/2025/3514 to the complainant for the period from 16.12.2024 to 15.12.2025 covering a sum insured of Rs.4,00,000/-, however, the claims under the said policy is governed by the terms, conditions, exclusions, limitations and exceptions of the policy.
b) The Opposite Party No.2 admits that, the complainant got admitted to Aster CMI hospital, Bangalore, on 16.01.2025 and got discharged on 18.01.2025, after she underwent surgery is admitted as true. The fact of the complainant had spent not less than Rs.4,70,210/- may be true, but that, the Opposite Party ought to have sanctioned claim of the complainant at-least upto Rs.4,00,000/- is denied as false.
c) The Opposite Party No.2 submits that, the complainant was initially approved with a cashless facility of Rs.40,000/- thereafter, though the complainant was charged with Rs.4,70,210/- upon her
5
discharge on 18.01.2025 by Aster CMI hospital, Bangalore, for the surgery she underwent, the claim of the complainant was processed and the admissible claim amount came to be Rs.1,18,500/- only as per the terms and conditions of the policy, as such, the complainant was paid balance of admissible claim amount of Rs.78,500/- by Opposite Party No.3, without any delay and within a reasonable period of lodging the claim.
d) The Opposite Party No.2 further submits that, Aster CMI hospital, Bangalore, where the complainant underwent surgery is a Preferred Provider Network (PPN) hospital, which is a special set up by GIPSA (General Insurance Public Sector Association), where the hospitals that, align with their policies and prices join in. Accordingly, the said hospital ought to have charged the agreed package cost of Rs.1,18,500/- to the complainant for the surgery she underwent as detailed in the letter dtd 13.02.2025 sent to the complainant by Opposite Party No.3, neither this Opposite Party can be legally compelled to make good the complainant's over charged bill amount of said hospital to the extent of sum insured under the policy, when the policy is a binding contract between
6
the insurer(this Opposite Party), and the insured(complainant), and insurer is liable to made good the claim strictly in accordance with the terms and conditions of the policy. It is explicitly stipulated under the benefits of the above mediclaim policy that, 'any expenses in excess of reasonable and customary charges as defined under 2.43, or in excess of the negotiated prices (in case of network hospitals) shall not be borne by the insurer,' hence, when the admissible claim amount as per the GIPSA-PPN agreed packages for the treatment of specified ailment of complainant was settled by this Opposite Party at Rs.1,18,500/- within the time-line specified under the policy no irregularity, illegitimacy, discrepancy or deficiency could be attributed to this Opposite Party, by the complainant as averred in para 10 to para 12 of the instant complaint.
e) The Opposite Party No.2 further states that, the complainant admittedly underwent advanced method of treatment, viz, Robotic surgery for her ailment, the insurer's liability in respect of said treatment, as per clause G of policy condition 3.1.7 is '10% of sum insured subject to maximum Rs.1,00,000/- per policy
7
period', it is further stipulated in the policy condition that, the said sub limit is on the cost incurred due to modern treatment methods of robotics and associated expenses and this amount is over and above the limit for conventional surgery for that, ailment. The complainant was suitably informed of this policy provision and the calculation of admissible claim was also furnished by Opposite Party No.3 vide letter dtd 13.02.2025, thus, as the legitimate admissible claim was settled by this Opposite Party, the instant complaint is legally not tenable and liable to be dismissed, as such, prays to dismiss the complaint with cost.
Evidence and documents relied upon by the complainant
5. In order to prove her case, the complainant has filed chief Affidavit evidence of herself as CW-1 and produced 24 documents, which are marked as Anne.C-1 to Anne.C-24, and answered the interrogatories.
Evidence and documents relied upon by the Opposite Party No.2
6. In the same way Opposite Party No.2 has adduced evidence of Mr. Hemanth Kumar, Deputy Manager, The Oriental Insurance Co., Ltd., Legal Hub, Court road, Udupi, by filing their chief examination
8
affidavit as RW-1, produced 3 documents, which is marked as Anne.R-1 to Anne.R-3, and answered the interrogatories served on them.
7. Counsels for the complainant and Opposite Party No.2 have filed their written notes of arguments.
8. Heard oral arguments by both the learned counsels.
9. Points that arise for our consideration are:
1) Whether the complainant proves deficiency of service on the part of the Opposite Parties as alleged in the complaint?
2) Whether complainant is entitled for the reliefs claimed?
3) What order?
10. Our findings on the above points are as under:
Point No.1:-In the Affirmative.
Point No.2:-Partly in the Affirmative. Point No.3:-As per final order.
9
REASONS
POINT NO.1:
11. Ongoing through the averments of the complaint, written version, affidavits, interrogatories, reply and detail verification of documents produced by both the parties, the only issue that, arise for our consideration, is whether the Opposite Parties are liable to reimburse balance medical expenses, as claimed in the complaint?
12. In order to substantiate her case, the complainant has adduced her evidence as CW-1, marked 24 documents, wherein the relevant documents are, Anne.C-2 is the policy issued by the Opposite Party No.2, Anne.C-3 is the discharge summary, Anne.C-4 is the vidal health card issued by Opposite Party No.3, Anne.C-5 is the cashless authorization letter issued by Opposite Party No.3, Anne.C-6 & 7 cash paid receipts, paid by the complainant for medical expenses, being the hospital charges, Anne.C-12, is the cashless authorization letter issued by Opposite Party No.3, Anne.C-17 is the claim denial letter, Anne.C-23 is the copy of the split bill issued by ACMI hospital.
10
13. We have gone through the above documents produced by the complainant, out of which the policy issued by the complainant, Anne.C-2 is issued through vidal health insurance TPA Pvt. Ltd., i.e., Opposite Party No.3, in favour of the complainant, Dr. Sunitha Naik, for the basic sum assured for Rs.4 lakhs, is the mediclaim policy covering hospitalization expenses for medical and surgical treatment taken as inpatient at any nursing home/hospital in India as defined in the policy, by paying Rs.15,443/- as the premium, policy is valid from 16.12.2024 to 15.12.2025. Initially the policy was issued in the year, 2011, and further it came to be renewed from time to time regularly with the sum assured upto Rs.4 lakhs, which is under, the present complaint.
14. When the policy was in existence, the complainant had obtained treatment for hysterectomy and Oophorectomy, at Aster CMI hospital, Bangalore, as in patient, from 16.01.2025 to 18.01.2025, underwent surgery, for the same, by incurring medical expenses of Rs.4,70,210/-.
15. After the discharge the complainant submitted claim form to the Opposite Party with all the documents, the claim was declined
11
and was initially approved for Rs.40,000/- only, by denying the other part of the claim, the complainant issued notice, and questioned the above approved amount to be very low, hence, again the Opposite Party approved another Rs.78,500/-, as final approval, denying the other claim, as per the Anne.C-5, C-12, & C-17, by the Opposite Party No.3 i.e., TPA/vidal health insurance, for the reason stated as under:
This has reference to your notice dtd 06.02.2025 on the short settlement of your pre-auth claim No. BLR-0125-PA- 0005186 for hospitalization at Aster CMI hospital, Bangalore, from 16.01.2025 to 18.01.2025, the claim was processed & approved for Rs.40,000/- i.e., the limit prescribed for robotic surgery, in fact this sun limit is on the cost incurred due to modern treatment methods of robotics associated expenses, this amount is over and above the limit for conventional surgery for that, ailment which we have inadvertently missed. We have now ascertained the cost of conventional surgery for 'Hysterectomy + Bilateral Salphingo Oophorectomy + Bilateral Pelvic Sentinel Lymph Node Biopsy done, policy provision No.1 i.e., Preamble provides that, insurance company will pay such expenses which are medically necessary, reasonable and customary, the insurance company & the TPA have agreed package (GIPSA-PPN) for various surgical procedures which satisfy policy provisions.
The hospital Aster CMI hospital, Bangalore is a GIPSA-PPN hospital & is supposed to charge GIPSA-PPN package, the agreed package are as under:
| Procedure |
PPN Package |
| Hysterectomy |
Rs.64,400/- |
| Bilateral Salphingo Oophorectomy |
Rs.7,070/- |
| Bilateral Pelvic Sentinel Lymph Node Biopsy done |
Rs.7,070/- |
12
| Robotic Assistance (@10% of sum insured) |
Rs.40,000/- |
| Total Admissibility |
Rs.1,18,500/- |
| Less already paid |
Rs.40,000/- |
| Net Payable |
Rs.78,500/- |
Ongoing through the above cashless partial authorization letter
issued by Opposite Party No.3, has allowed Rs.1,18,500/- as
admissible claim towards the mediclaim of Rs.4,70,410/-, but
disallowed, the other part of the claim. Whether, disallowing the
other part of the claim, is the matter to be considered.
16. The Opposite Party No.3, which the TPA third party Administrator vidal health insurance, inspite of receipt of notice for appearance, failed to appear, and were remained absent, did not wish to contest the complaint, it is well settled as per the judgments of Hon'ble Apex Court in AIR 1999 Supreme Court 1441- Vidhyadhar Vs. Manikrao and another, the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has held that 'If the defendant did not appear even after service of summons, the court can draw adverse inference. Hence, adverse inference is drawn against the defendants'. i.e., in the instant case on hand too, the Opposite Party No.3, inspite of service of notice, and sufficient opportunity was
13
given to putforth their defence, and contest the matter, but did not wish to appear, and putforth their defence, hence, the Averments/Pleadings/Allegations made in the complaint, and Documents placed on record, are unchallenged, undisputed, and unquestioned by the Opposite Party No.3, as such, complaint against Opposite Party No.3 deserves to be allowed and accepted.
17. It is pertinent to note that, Anne.C-5, C-12, & C-17 have all been issued by Opposite Party No.3, which is nothing but repudiation/rejecting the partial claim of the complainant, admittedly, Opposite Party No.3 is a third party administrator, for the policy issued by Opposite Party No.1 insurance Co., the reason for denial of the claim by the TPA, is the clause G of policy conditions 3.1.7 which is 10% sum insured, subject to minimum per policy period, it is further contended in their written version of Opposite Party No.2, that, "sub limit is on the cost incurred due to modern treatment methods of robotics and associated expenses and this amount is over and above the limit for conventional surgery for that, ailment." As such, the Opposite Party No.2 & 3 have restricted to claim for robotic surgery to 10% of Rs.1 lakh,
14
maximum, which is against the IRDA regulations, as defended by the complainant and for this, the complainant has produced and relied, several judgments for the same.
18. The complainant has vehemently argued and brought to our notice at the time of our argument, that, TPA is not competent to deny/reject or repudiate the claim of the policy holder, TPA s only a facilitator who has limited power/right between the policy holder and the insurance Co., and also referred the IRDA Guidelines/Regulations TPA (Third Party Health Insurance) Regulations 2016. The complainant has also brought to our notice and relied upon 2 citations and IRDA, Regulations/ Guidelines regarding Robotic surgery, and its claim, which as are under:
i) IRDAI Guidelines, ref, IRDAI/HLT/REG/CIR/177/09/2019, Guidelines on standardization of exclusions in health insurance Contracts, dtd 27.09.2019.
Chapter V Modern treatment methods and advancement in technologies:
1. To ensure that, the policy holders are not denied availability of health insurance coverage to modern treatment methods insurer shall ensure that the following treatment procedures shall not be excluded in the health insurance policy contracts. These procedures shall be covered (wherever medically
15
indicated) either as in patient or as part of domiciliary hospitalization or as day care treatment in a hospital.
G. Robotic surgeries.
2. Subject to product design sub-limit may be imposed for any of the above treatments.
3. Insurer may endeavor to cover any other modern treatment methods
ii) The Hon'ble SCDRC, Gujarat, Ahmedabad, in Appeal No.638/2022, between the oriental insurance Co. Ltd., V/s Shirishbhai H Dhodakiya, decided on 24.11.2022,
wherein it is held, at Para 9 to 12, which the same is herein reproduced below:
Para-9: The relevant portion of the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDA) guidelines applicable to the present case is given in the chapter-V which reads as under:- " CHAPTER V Modern Tratment Methoda and Advancement in Technologies To ensure that the policyholders are not denied availability of health insurance coverage to Modern Treatment Methods Insures shall ensure that the following treatment procedures shall not be excluded in the health insurance policy contracts. These Procedures shall be covered (wherever medically indicated) either as in- patient or as part of domiciliary hospitalization or as day care treatment in a hospital. F. Intra vitreal Injections."
Para-10: As per the record, the treatment was taken during the policy period and after the guidelines issued by the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDA). Therefore The Oriental Ins Co.Ltd vs Shirishbhai.H.Dhodakiya on 24 November, 2022 Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/164460313/ 3 Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDA) guidelines are applicable to the present case.
Para-11: In this case in spite of specific guidelines issued by the IRDA, the appellant Insurance Company
16
has not followed such guidelines and repudiated the said claim. There is nothing require to be interpreted to follow the guidelines. The date from which the guidelines is effective. The date of treatment and period of policy also suggest the applicability of Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDA) guidelines.
Para-12: We have considered the grounds stated in memo of appeal, reasons stated in impugned Judgment and order, documentary evidence produced on record, argument advanced by the learned advocate by the parties and facts and circumstances of the case. We are satisfied that the order passed by the Learned District Commission is legal, proper and correct in Eye of law. Therefore it does not required interference, as a result the appeal is required to be dismissed.
iii) Another reportable judgment of Hon'ble SCDRC, Gujarat, Ahmedabad, in Appeal No.356/2023, between the new India Ass.Co.Ltd V/s Rajesh Dilsukhrai Dave, decided on 29.04.2023, wherein it is held, at Para 9, 9.1, which the same is herein reproduced below:
Para-9: The relay is also made on the IRDAI guidelines dated 27 September 2019 which was made effective from 1 October 2020 onwards. As per the IRDAI guideline no.3.19 is coverage or modern treatment or procedure mentioned guideline no.3.19.7 is reads as under page no.303;
"3.19.7 Robotic surgeries, upto 50 % of sum insured subject to Maximum of Rs.5 lakh."
Para-9.1: The limit policy period that the treatment and procedure in robotic surgery is mentioned at 3.19.7. The limit mentioned is upto 50 % on sum insured subject to maximum of Rs. 5 lakh. It is pertinent to not that the complainant was operated on 06.09.2019 and this guidelines came into force from 1 October 2020. Therefore, it is after
17
the because of action arose for payment. Hence, these guidelines cannot be applicable in the case of the complainant.
iv) Another reportable judgment of Hon'ble SCDRC, Chandigarh, in Appeal No.219/2010, between Grewal Eye Hospital Pvt. Ltd. V/s Sandeep Khunger & Anr, decided on 11.02.2020, wherein it is held, at Para 15, which the same is herein reproduced below:
IMPORTANT POINT
Policy holder may choose the best of the medical treatment.
Subject: Consumer Dispute - Medical negligence Consumer Protection Act, 1986 -Section 15 & 17 - Indian Evidence Act, 1872, Section 91 - Appeal - Health Insurance policy - unfair trade practice by hospital - insured advised by hospital to undergo robolazr cataract surgery with IOL implant left eye, costing Rs.1.49 lacs- agreed rate of cataract surgery between hospital and insurance company was Rs.48,000 - hospital or a medical doctor cannot impose cost of the machinery or its maintenance charges, upon the patient - claim in respect of remaining amount of Rs.1,01,000/- has been repudiated by insurance company - Robolazr cataract surgery is one of the best technologies for the removal of cataract policy holder may choose the best of the medical treatment it cannot be inferred that the liability of the insurance company restricted to the extent of Rs.48,000/- held that, insurance company, is liable to make payment of the entire amount, which is reasonable in terms of the policy.
Para-15: In the circumstances enumerated above, the insurance company, has no right to compel the patient or policy holder to go for a basic or phaco surgery, the
18
policy holder may chose the best of the medical treatment for e.g., if a policy holder is ready to deliver a baby, she can't be compelled by the insurance company, to go for a natural way to give birth and in case she chooses caesarean operation, she cannot be denied the charge thereof, solely on the ground that, she chose cesarean operation instead of natural way of giving birth to a baby.
Therefore, ongoing through the above quoted judgments and the IRDAI regulation, it is crystal clear, and observed that, the insurance Co., cannot reject the treatment obtained towards the Robotic surgery or modern treatment, obtained by the patients, as per the direction of their hospital, or the treating doctor. As per the IRDAI Guidelines and Regulations 2016.
19. It is also pertinent to note that, the TPA is not competent to reject/deny nor repudiate the claim of the complainant, it is the insurance Co., who is obligated to do the same. The Opposite Party while replying to the interrogatories putforth by the complainant, has even admitted the fact that, TPA are not authorized to reject/ repudiate/deny the claim, on behalf of the insurance Co., which the same is are herein reproduced below:
19
Questions Answers Q-14: As per the IRDAI Ans: No.
guidelines, whether the TPA can reject or repudiate the claim directly?
Q-16: The only reply given for Ans: True subject to the
Ex.C8 is by the Opposite Party correction that, this
No.3 marked as Ex.C12 isn't it? Opposite Party is not aware if Opposite Party No.1 has
replied to Ex.C8.
Q-17: Till Ex.C8, you have not Ans: The health claim of the
repudiate the claim of the complainant was under
complainant, isn't it? Answer the process when Ex.C8 was
question specifically, if you have issued on behalf of the
any documents to show contra, complainant.
kindly produce it, don't avoid.
Q-18: Hospital has intimated Ans: Hospital has not intimated the estimation of cost of surgery the estimation of cost of surgery to the Opposite Parties including to Opposite Party No.1 & 2 as Opposite Party No.3 before the per Ex.C-5, in respect of claim surgery, which is marked as under health policies, concerned Ex.C5, isn't it? hospitals will inform the TPAs (Third Party Administrators) who
are authorized to process the
claim.
Q-19: Did any of the Opposite Ans: Opposite Party No.3 being Parties reply for the same? If the TPA has replied to the so, kindly produce the hospital as per Ex.C-5. documents in that, regard.
As such, in the instant case on hand too, all the letters issued by the TPA, to the complainant disallowing the partial claim, on behalf of the insurance Co., is not justified as per the directions of the IRDAI, below are the IRDAI guidelines, 2016, for TPA, and supporting judgments are herein referred as under:
20
That, as per the regulations of the IRDAI 2016, (TPA) and other judgments of Hon'ble NCDRC, and SCDRC, supporting the case of the complainant is herein referred as under:
i) IRDAI (Third Party Administrator Health Services) Regulations 2016
ii) Hon'ble NCDRC, New Delhi, between Lok Nath vs Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., decided on 16.10.2024,
wherein it is held, at Para 9 & 10, which the same is herein reproduced below:
Para-9: We have carefully gone through the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (Third Party Administrators - Health Services) Regulations, 2016, referred to above. Clause 3 of the said guidelines.
Para-10: A perusal of the Clause 3(2)(b) clearly shows that TPAs are not competent to reject or repudiate any of the claims directly. Hence, in the present case, the claim of the Petitioner herein having been rejected directly by the TPA and not by the Insurance Company/Competent Officer of the Insurance Company or by TPA with written approval of the Insurance Company for such repudiation, is not valid and this itself is a sufficient ground to quash the repudiation letter dated
23.02.2015.
iii) In another reportable judgment of Hon'ble SCDRC, Panjab, Chandigarh, between Rulda Singh vs United India Insurance Company Limited on 19 September,
21
2017, decided on 19.09.2017, wherein it is held, at Para 23 & 25, which the same is herein reproduced below:
Para-23: Health Services to be provided by the TPA have been specified in IRDAI (THIRD PARTY ADMINISTRATORS-HEALTH SERVICES) REGULATIONS, 2016, issued vide Notification F. No.IRDAI/REG/5/117/2016, Dated 14.3.2016 and the same read as under:- "Health services by TPA
3. (1) A TPA may render the following services to an insurer under an agreement in connection with health insurance business:
a. servicing of claims under health insurance policies by way of pre-authorization of cashless treatment or settlement of claims other than cashless claims or both, as per the underlying terms and conditions of the respective policy and within the framework of the guidelines issued by the insurers for settlement of claims.
b. servicing of claims for Hospitalization cover, if any, under Personal Accident Policy and domestic travel policy. c. facilitating carrying out of pre-insurance medical examinations in connection with underwriting of health insurance policies: Provided Rulda Singh vs United India Insurance Company Limited on 19 September, 2017 Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/129313221/ 7 that a TPA can extend this service for life insurance policies also d. health services matters of foreign travel policies and health policies issued by Indian insurers covering medical treatment or hospitalization outside India e. servicing of health services matters of foreign travel policies issued by foreign insurers for policyholders who are travelling to India:
Para-25: Thus, we are of the opinion that the claim of the complainant was illegally and arbitrarily rejected by the TPA, against the aforesaid instructions of the IRDA. Since the Insurance Companies use the PPN or hospitals empanelled by the TPA and, resultantly, TPA ask the hospital to give commission on every claim, if they want to be enrolled in PPN. This has been observed by the regulators. Resultantly, the patients/consumers are over-charged by the hospitals, since they have to pay some commissions to TPAs to use the power on behalf of the Insurance Companies. They have no right to solicit business, like agents for the Insurance
22
Companies. Their only job is to serve and process the claims. Accepting and rejecting the claims at their own by the TPAs is illegal, arbitrary, null & void and is not sustainable in the eyes of law.
Hence, ongoing through the above quoted judgments, the TPA are not competent to reject or repudiate any of the claims directly, in the instant case on hand too, the claim of the complainant having been partially denied/rejected directly by the TPA and not by Insurance Company/Competent Officer of the Insurance Company or by TPA with written approval of the Insurance Company for such repudiation, is not valid and this itself is a sufficient ground to quash the denial of the claim. Hence, on the above facts and circumstances of the case, discussed above, relying on the Hon'ble Apex Court, NCDRC, SCDRC, wherein it is observed that, Robotic surgery obtained by the complainant, shall be reimbursed in entirety, further, it is also observed that, TPA Opposite Party No.3 in the instant case, is not competent to deny/reject/repudiate partial claim, of the complainant, which the same deserves to be quashed, and claim of the complainant shall be honoured. The Opposite Party No.1 & 2 shall reimburse, the balance medical expenses as claimed by the complainant. therefore, complainant has proved deficiency of service,
23
and unfair trade practice on the part of the Opposite Party No.1 to 3.
As such, we are of the considerable opinion, to Answer Point No.1 in the Affirmative.
Point No.2:
20. In view of our discussions and reasons assigned in Point No.1, and relying on the observations, and directions made in the judgments of Hon'ble Apex Court, Hon'ble NCDRC, & Hon'ble SCDRC, the complainant has proved deficiency of service, and unfair trade practice, on the part of Opposite Party No.1 to 3, hence, we direct,
a) Opposite Party No.1 & 2 to pay reimburse medical expenses, to the tune of Rs.2,81,500/-, with interest @6% P.A., from the date of complaint i.e., 04.04.2025, to till its realization, to the complainant,
b) Opposite Party No.3, to pay penalty/ fine, of Rs.50,000/- for the violation of Regulation No.3 of the IRDAI, (TPA Health Services), Regulations 2016, to the consumer welfare fund.
c) Opposite Party No.1 & 2 to pay compensation of Rs.50,000/- towards the deficiency of service, mental agony, unfair trade
24
practice, and inconvenience caused, to the complainant, along with Rs.10,000/- towards the cost of the litigation, which shall be as per the final order. Hence, we Answer Point No.2 partly in the Affirmative.
POINT NO.3:
21. In view of our discussions and reasons assigned in Point No.1 & 2, relying on the observations, and directions made in the judgments of Hon'ble Apex Court, Hon'ble NCDRC, & Hon'ble SCDRC, and following the extensive law under C.P. Act, 2019 as on today, we pass the following;
ORDER
The Complaint filed by the complainant U/s.35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, against the Opposite Party No.1 to 3, is hereby partly allowed with cost.
The Opposite Party No.1 & 2 are directed to reimburse balance medical expenses, to the tune of Rs.2,81,500/-, with interest @6% P.A., from the date of complaint i.e., 04.04.2025, to till its realization, to the complainant.
25
The Opposite Party No.3/TPA is directed to pay penalty/ fine, of Rs.50,000/- for the violation of Regulation No.3 of the IRDAI, (TPA Health Services), Regulations 2016, payable to the consumer welfare fund.
The Opposite Party No.1 & 2 are further directed to pay compensation of Rs.50,000/- towards the deficiency of service, mental agony, unfair trade practice, and inconvenience caused, to the complainant.
The Opposite Party No.1 & 2 are also liable to pay Rs.10,000/- towards the cost of the litigation, to the complainant. The Opposite Party No.1 to 3 are liable to pay the above said amounts within 45 days from the date of pronouncement of this order, failing which, the above said amounts shall carry penal interest @8% P.A. from the date of default, to till its realization, to the complainant.
If, Opposite Party No.1 to 3 fails to comply the above said order, the complainant may initiate Civil/Criminal proceedings U/s.71/72 of C.P. Act, 2019 against the Opposite Party No.1 to 3.
26
Copy of this order as per statutory requirements, be forwarded to both the parties free of cost and file shall be consigned to record room.
(Page No.1 to 27 are dictated to the Stenographer, directly on the computer, corrected by us, then pronounced in the open court, on this 07th day of August, 2026.)
Sd/- Sd/-
Smt. Sharadamma.H.G Sri. Somashekarappa K Handigol
Lady Member President(I/C)
District Consumer Commission District Consumer Commission Dakshina Kannada Dakshina Kannada
27
-:ANNEXURE:-
Documents Marked & Witnesses examined Witnesses examined on behalf of complainant CW:-1: Dr. Sumita Naik, R/at Sanjay Apartment, Shivabagh, Kadri, Mangalore.
| Anne.C-1: |
Copy of Aadhar card of the complainant. |
| Anne.C-2: |
Copy of Insurance policy. |
| Anne.C-3: |
Original discharge summary issued by Aster CMI hospital, dtd 18.01.2025. |
| Anne.C-4: |
Original health card standing in the name of the complainant. |
| Anne.C-5: |
Copy of cashless authorization letter issued by Vidal health, dtd 18.01.2025. |
| Anne.C-6: |
Copy of advance receipt dtd 16.01.2025. |
| Anne.C-7: |
Copy of advance receipt, dtd 18.01.2025. |
| Anne.C-8: |
Copy of legal notice dtd 06.02.2025 issued on 05.02.2025 by the complainant to the Opposite Parties. |
| Anne.C-9: |
Copy of Postal receipts. |
| Anne.C-10: |
Copy of postal acknowledgement regarding service of notice to the Opposite Party No.2. |
| Anne.C-11: |
Copy of postal acknowledgement regarding service of notice to the Opposite Party No.3. |
| Anne.C-12: |
Copy of reply notice dtd 13.02.2025 issued by the Opposite Party No.3 to the complainant along with postal envelop. |
| Anne.C-13: |
Copy of notice dtd 27.02.2025 issued by the complainant to the Opposite Parties. |
| Anne.C-14: |
Copy of postal receipts. |
| Anne.C-15: |
Copy of postal acknowledgement regarding service of notice to the Opposite Party No.2. |
| Anne.C-16: |
Copy of postal acknowledgement regarding service of notice to the Opposite Party No.3. |
| Anne.C-17: |
Copy of undated letter issued by the Opposite Party No.3 to the complainant in response to the notice dtd 27.02.2025 issued by the complainant. |
| Anne.C-18: |
Copy of notice dtd 12.03.2025 issued by the complainant to the Opposite Parties. |
| Anne.C-19: |
Copy of postal receipts. |
| Anne.C-20: |
Copy of postal acknowledgement regarding service of notice to the Opposite Party No.1. |
| Anne.C-21: |
Copy of postal acknowledgement regarding service of notice to the Opposite Party No.2. |
| Anne.C-22: |
Copy of postal acknowledgement regarding service of notice to the Opposite Party No.3. |
28
Anne.C-23: Copy of split-bill pertaining to the complainant dtd 16.01.2025 to 18.01.2025 issued by Aster CMI hospital.
Anne.C-24: Original certificate of U/s 63 of BSA.
Witneses examined on behalf of Opposite Party No.2:
RW-1:- Mr. Hemanth Kumar, Deputy Manager, The Oriental Insurance Co., Ltd., Legal Hub, Court road, Udupi.
Documents marked on behalf of Opposite Party No.2:
| Anne.R-1: |
Copy of policy terms and conditions. |
| Anne.R-2: |
Copy of policy schedule 422200/48/2025/3514. |
| Anne.R-3: |
Copy of letter dtd 13.02.2025 issued by Vidal health insurance TPA Pvt. Ltd. |
Sd/-
Date:07.08.2026 President(I/C)
29