COMMON ORDER:
Heard Sri K. Prathik Reddy, learned counsel appearing for the Petitioners, Ms. Radha Reddy, learned Assistant Government Pleader for Land Acquisition, appearing for Respondent Nos. 1 to 4, Ms. S. Swathi, learned Assistant Government Pleader for Irrigation, appearing for Respondent No.5, Learned Government Pleader for Municipal Administration and Urban Development appearing for Respondent No. 6 and Sri Putta Krishna Reddy, learned Standing Counsel for Municipalities appearing for Respondent No.7.
2. Since all these Writ Petitions arise out of a common set of facts, challenge the same acquisition proceedings, involve substantially identical questions of fact and law, and seek substantially similar reliefs, they were heard together and are being disposed of by this Common Judgment.
3. The principal challenge in this batch of writ petitions is directed against:
-4-
(i) Gazette Notification No.249 dated 18.11.2020 issued by Respondent No.6 under Section 10A of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (for short, "the Act"), granting exemption from the applicability of Chapters II and III of the Act; and
(ii) Notification dated 22.05.2021 bearing Proc.No.G2/2256/2019 issued by Respondent No.1 under Section 11(1) of the Act proposing acquisition of the subject lands for the project described as "Kotha Cheruvu Bund Development".
4. The petitioners seek a declaration that the aforesaid notifications and all consequential proceedings initiated pursuant thereto are illegal, arbitrary, violative of Articles 14 and 300-A of the Constitution of India, contrary to the provisions of the Act, and liable to be set aside, together with such further or ancillary reliefs as this Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.
5. Having regard to the multiplicity of writ petitions and the varying extents of land involved, it is considered appropriate, for the sake of convenience and clarity, to set out the particulars of the writ petitions, the names of the petitioners, the survey numbers
-5-
and the extents of land involved in the acquisition proceedings in the following tabular statement:
S.No W.P.No. Name of the
Petitioner/s
Sy.No. Extent
(in Sq. yards)
1 W.P.No.18264 of 2021
Vennamaneni Srinivas Rao
1511 399
2 W.P.No.18266 of 2021
Bojja Nagaraj 1513 125 Md.
Jahirroddin
98
Sd. Fareed 40
3 W.P.No.18291 of 2021
Marripalli Yellava
1511D 699
Md. Nayeem 93
4 W.P.No.18295 of 2021
Vennamaneni Sridhar Rao and
Vennamaneni Rama
1511 380
5 W.P.No.18316 of 2021
Chindurla
Shailaja,
1511B Name has not been
mentioned in
the notification but extent of
219.91 was mentioned in affidavit
Deva Kamala Name has not been
mentioned in
the notification
but an extent
of 200.59 was
mentioned in
the affidavit
Venkat Reddy
216 and 198 as per notification
-6-
6 W.P.No.18321 of 2021
Patha
Sudhakar
1511B 211
Ravula
Umadevi And
Laxman
141
7 W.P.No.18334 of 2021
Gajabimkar Babu and Sd. Jakeer
1513 114
8 W.P.No.18337 of 2021
Vangapalli Devadas
1511A 4124
1511E 662
9 W.P.No.18512 of 2021
Chepuri
Shankaraiah
1508 968
1509 2904 as per notification whereas in the affidavit they stated 3630
FACTS IN BRIEF:
6. The petitioners in this batch of writ petitions claim to be the absolute owners and possessors of various extents of land situated in Sircilla Village and Municipality, Rajanna-Sircilla District, more fully described in the tabular statement extracted hereinabove. According to the petitioners, they and their predecessors-in-title have been in peaceful possession and enjoyment of the subject properties for several years and are exercising all rights incidental to ownership. The lands belonging to the petitioners form part of
-7-
Survey Nos.1508, 1509, 1511, 1511-A, 1511-B, 1511-D, 1511-E and 1513 of Sircilla Village.
7. The acquisition proceedings were initiated pursuant to a requisition made by the Commissioner, Sircilla Municipality, seeking acquisition of land admeasuring Ac.4-28 guntas situated around Kotha Cheruvu, in Sircilla Town fro the purpose of development and strengthening of Kotha Cheruvu Bund and development of the surrounding area. In furtherance thereof, the Government issued Gazette Notification No.249 dated 18.11.2020 under Section 10A of the Act granting exemption from the applicability of Chapters II and III of the Act. Thereafter, Notification dated 22.05.2021 bearing Proc.No.G2/2256/2019 came to be issued by Respondent No.1 under Section 11(1) of the Act proposing acquisition of the subject lands.
8. It is the case of the petitioners that they were not aware of the issuance of the notification under Section 11(1) of the Act until individual notices under Section 15 of the Act dated 22.07.2021 were served upon them on or about 27.07.2021 inviting objections to the proposed acquisition. Upon receipt of the said notices, the petitioners submitted representations seeking copies of the notifications issued under Sections 10A and 11 of the Act and requested reasonable time for submitting detailed objections. They
-8-
also raised preliminary objections to the acquisition proceedings and reserved their right to submit comprehensive objections upon receipt of the relevant documents.
9. According to the petitioners, upon making enquiries regarding publication of the notification issued under Section 11(1) of the Act, they found that the statutory requirements relating to publication had not been complied with. It is contended that the notification was not published in newspapers having circulation within Rajanna-Sircilla District and that publication was allegedly confined to editions circulated elsewhere. It is further alleged that publication was not effected in the affected locality. The petitioners contend that such non-compliance deprived them of an effective opportunity to raise objections to the acquisition proceedings. Upon obtaining copies of the notifications, the petitioners claim to have discovered that substantially similar acquisition proceedings had earlier been initiated in the year 2018 in respect of the very same lands and for substantially the same public purpose. According to them, the respondents had then invoked Section 10A of the Act and proceeded with acquisition by dispensing with the requirement of Social Impact Assessment.
10. The petitioners assert that the notifications issued in the year 2018 were challenged before this Court in W.P.No.202 of 2019
-9-
and batch and that this Court had granted interim orders suspending the operation of the notifications issued under Sections 10A and 11 of the Act.
11. It is the specific case of the petitioners that without withdrawing or lawfully terminating the earlier acquisition proceedings, the respondents have initiated a fresh round of acquisition proceedings in respect of the same properties and for the same public purpose. According to the petitioners, the present proceedings constitute a continuation of the earlier acquisition exercise under a different guise and are intended to overcome the interim orders passed by this Court in the earlier batch of writ petitions.
12. Aggrieved by the exemption granted under Section 10A of the Act, the notification issued under Section 11(1) of the Act and all consequential proceedings undertaken pursuant thereto, the petitioners have instituted the present batch of writ petitions.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
(a) Submissions on behalf of the Petitioners:
13. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners contends that the notification issued under Section 10A of the Act is ex facie arbitrary, illegal and contrary to the statutory scheme of the
-10-
enactment. It is submitted that Section 10A permits exemption from the applicability of Chapters II and III of the Act only where acquisition is demonstrably required in public interest. According to the petitioners, the impugned notification neither records nor discloses any specific public interest warranting invocation of the extraordinary power under Section 10A. The absence of such foundational satisfaction, it is argued, renders the exemption unsustainable and vitiates all consequential proceedings.
14. It is further contended that the respondents have deliberately mischaracterized the nature of the project in order to bring it within the ambit of Section 10A. While exemption is sought on the premise that the project relates to an irrigation or infrastructure project, the notification issued under Section 11 describes the public purpose merely as "Kotha Cheruvu Bund Development". According to the petitioners, development or beautification of an existing tank bund cannot by any stretch of imagination be equated with an irrigation project. It is therefore contended that the classification adopted by the respondents is artificial and intended solely to avoid compliance with the mandatory requirement of conducting a Social Impact Assessment under Chapters II and III of the Act.
-11-
15. Learned counsel further submits that the impugned proceedings constitute a colorable exercise of power. It is contended that substantially similar acquisition proceedings relating to the very same lands and public purpose had earlier been initiated in the year 2018 by invoking Section 10A of the Act and that the said proceedings were suspended by this Court in W.P.No.202 of 2019 and batch. It is argued that without withdrawing the earlier notifications in accordance with law and without resorting to the provisions governing withdrawal of acquisition proceedings, the respondents have initiated a fresh round of acquisition proceedings by merely altering the description of the project from "Bund Development of Kotha Cheruvu" to
"Kotha Cheruvu Bund Development". Such cosmetic variation, according to the petitioners, does not alter the substance of the acquisition and initiation of parallel proceedings for the same lands and public purpose is wholly impermissible in law.
16. Learned counsel also contends that the notification issued under Section 11(1) of the Act is vague and suffers from non- compliance with mandatory statutory requirements. It is submitted that the notification fails to adequately disclose either the necessity or precise nature of the proposed development. It is further alleged that mandatory publication requirements prescribed under the Act
-12-
were not complied with, thereby depriving the petitioners of a meaningful opportunity to submit objections. Continuation of the acquisition proceedings, it is contended, would result in deprivation of property protected under Article 300-A of the Constitution.
(b) Submissions on behalf of Respondent Nos.1 to 4:
17. Per contra, a counter affidavit has been filed on behalf of Respondent No.3 opposing the writ petitions. Learned Assistant Government Pleader for Land Acquisition submits that the writ petitions are misconceived both on facts and in law and are liable to be dismissed. It is submitted that the acquisition proceedings were initiated pursuant to a requisition made by the Commissioner, Sircilla Municipality, seeking acquisition of land admeasuring Ac.4-28 guntas situated in Sircilla Village for development of Kotha Cheruvu Bund and its surrounding areas. The project, according to the respondents, is intended to address issues of public importance affecting the residents of Sircilla Municipality and adjoining localities.
18. Learned Assistant Government Pleader contends that all requisite records were obtained from the Survey and Land Records Department and that exemption from the applicability of Chapters II and III of the Act was duly granted by the Government in exercise
-13-
of powers conferred under Section 10A of the Act. Pursuant thereto, notification under Section 11(1) of the Act came to be issued in accordance with law. It is further submitted that the earlier round of litigation initiated in respect of the notifications issued in the year 2018 resulted only in an interim suspension of the notification issued under Section 11(1) of the Act and that there was no adjudication by this Court declaring either the exemption granted under Section 10A or the acquisition proceedings themselves to be illegal.
19. Learned Assistant Government Pleader further contends that the notification issued under Section 11(1) of the Act on 24.07.2018 had lapsed by operation of Section 19(7) of the Act, no declaration having been made within the stipulated period prescribed thereunder. Consequently, the earlier notification ceased to have legal effect by operation of law. According to the respondents, once the earlier notification stood lapsed by statutory operation, there was no necessity for the Government to invoke Section 93 of the Act or issue a separate order formally withdrawing the earlier proceedings. It is therefore contended that issuance of a fresh notification under Section 11(1) dated 22.05.2021 pursuant to a valid exemption granted under Section
-14-
10A cannot be characterized as initiation of parallel acquisition proceedings.
20. Learned Assistant Government Pleader further submits that the acquisition is intended to serve a bona fide public purpose, namely, strengthening and development of Kotha Cheruvu Bund, prevention of flooding, stabilization of groundwater levels, protection of nearby roads and habitations from recurrent inundation during rainy seasons, and addressing drinking water requirements of Sircilla Municipality and surrounding areas. It is asserted that the project is not confined to beautification or recreational development, as alleged by the petitioners, but forms part of a larger infrastructure and water management initiative intended to secure public welfare and environmental sustainability. The respondents further contend that classification of the project as an irrigation and infrastructure project is fully justified and that invocation of Section 10A of the Act was made strictly in public interest. It is therefore submitted that the allegations of mala fides, colourable exercise of power and circumvention of statutory requirements are wholly unfounded.
21. Learned Assistant Government Pleader lastly submits that the petitioners have approached this Court prematurely and that adequate opportunity is available to them to raise objections in
-15-
accordance with law. According to the respondents, no irreparable prejudice would be caused to the petitioners and the writ petitions are therefore liable to be dismissed.
(c) Submissions on behalf of Respondent No.6:
22. Written instructions have been filed on behalf of Respondent No.6. Learned Government Pleader for Municipal Administration and Urban Development submits that the acquisition forms part of a larger policy initiative aimed at preservation and protection of Kotha Cheruvu and its surrounding ecosystem from encroachments, unauthorized constructions and ecological degradation.
23. It is submitted that Kotha Cheruvu is an important water body situated within the municipal limits of Sircilla and that preservation of the lake and its catchment area is essential for maintaining groundwater levels, environmental balance and public welfare. Learned Government Pleader further submits that the subject lands fall within the buffer zone of the lake as reflected in the Master Plan and that in terms of Rule 3(a)(i) and (ii) of G.O.Ms.No.168 dated 07.04.2012, no construction or developmental activity is permissible within the Full Tank Level (FTL) area and buffer zone of water bodies. It is contended that in compliance with the statutory framework governing protection of
-16-
water bodies and the circular instructions issued by the Commissioner and Director of Municipal Administration, measures have been undertaken for preservation of existing lakes including Kotha Cheruvu in order to prevent depletion of water resources and ecological imbalance.
24. According to Respondent No.6, acquisition of Ac.4-28 guntas of land surrounding Kotha Cheruvu is necessary to ensure protection of the lake, preservation of ecological balance, maintenance of groundwater levels and water security within the municipal limits. Learned Government Pleader submits that the acquisition is supported by overwhelming public interest and that exemption under Section 10A was rightly invoked having regard to the nature and importance of the project. It is therefore contended that no grounds are made out for interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
POINTS FOR CONSIDERATION:
25. In the light of the pleadings, submissions and material placed on record, the following Points arise for consideration:
(i) Whether the Respondent authorities have established the existence of a valid and demonstrable public interest warranting invocation of Section 10A of the Right to Fair Compensation and
-17-
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, as amended in the State of Telangana?
(ii) Whether the impugned Gazette Notification dated 18.11.2020 issued under Section 10A of the Act satisfies the statutory requirements for granting exemption from the applicability of Chapters II and III of the Act?
(iii) Whether the acquisition proceedings initiated through Notification dated 22.05.2021 issued under Section 11 of the Act are sustainable in law in the absence of compliance with the mandatory safeguards contemplated under Chapters II and III of the Act?
(iv) Whether the impugned notifications are vitiated on account of the earlier acquisition proceedings initiated in respect of the same lands and for substantially the same public purpose?
(v) To what relief?
DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS:
Point Nos. (i) and (ii):
"Whether the Notification dated 18.11.2020 issued under Section 10A of the Act is sustainable in law and whether the project in question falls within the categories contemplated thereunder?"
-18-
26. Since Point Nos. (i) and (ii) are interconnected and arise out of the same statutory framework, they are taken up together for consideration.
27. The controversy in the present batch of writ petitions centres around the legality of the decision of the State Government to invoke Section 10A of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (for short, "the Act"), and thereby exempt the proposed acquisition from the operation of Chapters II and III of the Act. The challenge assumes significance because the lands sought to be acquired belong to the petitioners and the impugned notifications directly affect their rights protected under Article 300-A of the Constitution of India.
28. The Act, 2013 was enacted replacing the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 with the avowed object of introducing transparency, accountability, participation and fairness into the process of compulsory acquisition. Parliament consciously departed from the earlier acquisition regime and introduced a rights-based framework intended to balance developmental needs of the State with the rights and interests of landowners and affected families. The statutory scheme recognizes that while acquisition may be necessary for public purposes, compulsory deprivation of property
-19-
must be preceded by meaningful safeguards ensuring informed decision-making and minimization of adverse consequences. The legislative framework revolves around four principal components, namely, identification of a public purpose, assessment of social impact, determination of compensation together with rehabilitation and resettlement, and procedural safeguards ensuring transparency and accountability. The existence of a public purpose alone does not justify acquisition. The acquisition must also satisfy the substantive and procedural safeguards consciously incorporated by Parliament.
29. Section 3(za) defines "public purpose" to mean the activities specified under Section 2(1) of the Act. Thus, the Legislature has consciously restricted the concept of public purpose to identified statutory categories rather than leaving it open-ended. Section 2(1) contemplates acquisition for strategic purposes, infrastructure projects, industrial corridors, housing projects, planned development and other specified categories. For ready reference both sections 3(za) and 2(1) of the Act are extracted hereunder:
Section 3(za) of the Act defines "public purpose" as follows:
"(za) 'public purpose' means the activities specified under sub-section
(1) of Section 2." Section 2: Application of Act:
(1) The provisions of this Act relating to land acquisition, compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement, shall apply, when the appropriate Government acquires land for its own use, hold and control, including
-20-
for Public Sector Undertakings and for public purpose, and shall include the following purposes, namely: —
(a) for strategic purposes relating to naval, military, air force, and armed forces of the Union, including central paramilitary forces or any work vital to national security or defence of India or State police, safety of the people; or (b) for infrastructure projects, which includes the following, namely: —
(i) all activities or items listed in the notification of the Government of India in the Department of Economic Affairs (Infrastructure Section) number 13/6/2009-INF, dated the 27th March, 2012, excluding private hospitals, private educational institutions and private hotels;
(ii) projects involving agro-processing, supply of inputs to agriculture, warehousing, cold storage facilities, marketing infrastructure for agriculture and allied activities such as dairy, fisheries, and meat processing, set up or owned by the appropriate Government or by a farmers' cooperative or by an institution set up under a statute;
(iii) project for industrial corridors or mining activities, national investment and manufacturing zones, as designated in the National Manufacturing Policy;
(iv) project for water harvesting and water conservation structures, sanitation;
(v) project for Government administered, Government aided educational and research schemes or institutions;
(vi) project for sports, health care, tourism, transportation or space programme;
(vii) any infrastructure facility as may be notified in this regard by the Central Government and after tabling of such notification in Parliament;
(c) project for project affected families;
(d) project for housing for such income groups, as may be specified from time to time by the appropriate Government;
(e) project for planned development or the improvement of village sites or any site in the urban areas or provision of land for residential purposes for the weaker sections in rural and urban areas;
(f) project for residential purposes to the poor or landless or to persons residing in areas affected by natural calamities, or to persons displaced or affected by reason of the implementation of any scheme
-21-
undertaken by the Government, any local authority or a corporation owned or controlled by the State.
30. However, the existence of a public purpose does not automatically justify acquisition. Parliament has incorporated Chapters II and III as substantive safeguards intended to ensure that acquisition is genuinely necessary and proportionate to the object sought to be achieved. Chapter II of the Act deals with Social Impact Assessment. Sections 4 to 9 require a scientific evaluation of the social, economic and environmental consequences of acquisition, consultation with local bodies, public hearings in the affected area and appraisal by an independent Expert Group. The purpose of the exercise is to ascertain whether acquisition is necessary at all, whether alternative measures are available and whether the extent proposed to be acquired is the minimum necessary for the project.
31. Chapter III supplements these safeguards by imposing restrictions relating to acquisition of agricultural lands and by protecting larger concerns relating to food security. These provisions collectively constitute the heart of the statutory framework and represent the Legislature's attempt to ensure that acquisition remains a measure of last resort rather than a matter of administrative convenience. The significance of these provisions becomes immediately apparent because the impugned notification
-22-
seeks to dispense with the operation of both Chapters II and III. It therefore becomes necessary to examine the scope and ambit of Section 10A.
32. Section 10A, as applicable in the State of Telangana, empowers the appropriate Government to exempt specified categories of projects from the application of Chapters II and III. The provision reads thus:
10A. "Power of State Government to exempt certain projects The State Government may, in the public interest by notification in the Official Gazette, exempt any of the following projects from the application of the provisions or Chapter I and Chapter III of this Act, namely: -
(a) such projects vital to national security or defence of India and every part thereof, including preparation for defence or
defence production;
(b) infrastructure including electrification and irrigation projects;
(c) affordable housing and housing for the poor people;
(d) industrial corridors set up by the State Government and its undertaking (in which case the land shall be acquired up to such distance on both sides of designated railway lines or roads and as specified by the Government for specific projects from time to time and notified as such in State Gazette; and
(e) infrastructure projects, including projects under public-private partnership where the ownership of the land continues to vest with the Government:
Provided that the State Government shall, before the issue of notification, ensure the extent of land for the proposed acquisition keeping in view the minimum land required for such project".
33. A plain reading of Section 10A reveals that the provision is in the nature of an exception. The Legislature has not declared that
-23-
all projects falling within the categories enumerated therein shall automatically stand exempted. On the contrary, exemption may be granted only where the Government is satisfied that public interest warrants such exclusion. The expression "in public interest" is neither ornamental nor surplusage. The Legislature consciously employed the phrase while conferring the exemption power and thereby imposed an additional condition precedent governing its exercise. The existence of public purpose and the existence of public interest are therefore distinct concepts. Public purpose justifies acquisition; public interest under Section 10A must justify exclusion of statutory safeguards.
34. The Court is therefore unable to accept the submission that classification of a project as an infrastructure project automatically results in exemption under Section 10A. Such an interpretation would render the phrase "in public interest" redundant and defeat the legislative intent underlying the provision.
35. The respondents seek to justify invocation of Section 10A by contending that the project concerns development of Kotha Cheruvu Bund and therefore falls within the category of infrastructure and irrigation-related projects. This submission necessitates examination of the precise nature of the project.
-24-
36. The notification issued under Section 11 describes the public purpose as "Kotha Cheruvu Bund Development". Significantly, neither the notification under Section 10A nor the notification under Section 11 identifies the precise statutory category under which the project is sought to be classified. While broad assertions are made regarding flood control, environmental protection, groundwater recharge and development of the surrounding area, the notifications themselves do not disclose whether the project is treated as an irrigation project, an infrastructure project or some other category contemplated under the statute.
37. The petitioners contend that Kotha Cheruvu is an existing water body and that developmental facilities already exist around the lake. According to them, the acquisition is substantially intended for further development and beautification of the surrounding area. Though the respondents dispute this characterisation, they have not placed before the Court any Detailed Project Report, technical feasibility report, hydrological assessment or engineering study clearly disclosing the precise nature and scope of the proposed works. This aspect assumes significance because exemption under Section 10A cannot rest upon nomenclature alone. The Court is required to examine the substance of the project and not merely the label attached to it.
-25-
Mere description of a project as an infrastructure or irrigation project cannot relieve the State of its obligation to establish the factual basis upon which such classification rests.
38. The burden of establishing applicability of Section 10A necessarily lies upon the respondents. When valuable statutory safeguards are sought to be excluded, the Court would expect the acquiring authority to place before it sufficient material demonstrating the exact nature of the project and the reasons why it falls within the exempted category. The record presently available does not disclose any such exercise. Even assuming that the project falls within one of the categories enumerated in Section 10A, the respondents are still required to establish the existence of public interest warranting exclusion of Chapters II and III. On this aspect, the impugned notification is completely silent. No urgency is recorded. No special circumstances are disclosed. No material is referred to indicating why compliance with the Social Impact Assessment process would frustrate or prejudice the project.
39. Equally absent from the record is any material demonstrating compliance with the proviso to Section 10A, which obligates the Government to ensure that the extent of land proposed to be acquired is the absolute bare minimum necessary for execution of the project. No material has been produced
-26-
indicating examination of alternatives, reduction of acquisition area or determination of minimum land requirement. The Court is therefore left only with broad assertions of public benefit unsupported by contemporaneous material. Administrative satisfaction affecting valuable rights cannot rest upon such assertions. The existence of public interest must be demonstrable from the record and cannot be presumed merely because the notification reproduces the language of the statute.
40. This Court is therefore of the considered opinion that the respondents have failed to establish the jurisdictional facts necessary for valid invocation of Section 10A. The notification dated 18.11.2020 neither discloses the basis for exemption nor demonstrates the existence of public interest warranting exclusion of Chapters II and III. The respondents have further failed to establish compliance with the proviso to Section 10A.
41. Point Nos. (i) and (ii) are accordingly answered in favour of the petitioners.
Point No. (iii):
"Whether the impugned acquisition proceedings are vitiated in view of the earlier acquisition proceedings initiated in the year
-27-
2018 in respect of substantially the same lands and for substantially the same public purpose?"
42. The next contention advanced on behalf of the petitioners pertains to the existence of earlier acquisition proceedings initiated in the year 2018 in respect of substantially the same lands and for substantially the same public purpose. According to the petitioners, the impugned proceedings constitute a continuation of the earlier acquisition exercise and have been initiated with a view to overcome the challenge mounted before this Court in W.P. No.202 of 2019 and batch. The respondents, on the other hand, contend that the earlier proceedings stood lapsed by operation of law and, therefore, initiation of fresh proceedings cannot be faulted.
43. The material placed before the Court discloses that acquisition proceedings concerning the lands surrounding Kotha Cheruvu were earlier initiated in the year 2018. As in the present case, the Government invoked Section 10A and thereafter issued a notification under Section 11(1) proposing acquisition of the subject lands. The public purpose was then described as "Bund Development of Kotha Cheruvu". The said notifications were challenged before this Court in W.P. No.202 of 2019 and connected matters, wherein interim orders came to be granted. The
-28-
respondents contend that the earlier notification issued under Section 11(1) dated 24.07.2018 lapsed by operation of Section 19(7) of the Act, no declaration having been issued within the prescribed period. There can be no dispute that where acquisition proceedings lapse by operation of law, the State is not permanently divested of its power to acquire land. Subject to compliance with statutory requirements, fresh proceedings may be initiated if public purpose continues to subsist.
44. However, the issue before this Court is not whether fresh acquisition proceedings could have been initiated in law. The issue is whether the respondents have demonstrated any fresh circumstances, independent consideration or material change warranting a fresh invocation of the extraordinary power contained in Section 10A. This distinction assumes significance because the challenge in the present case is directed not merely against acquisition but against exclusion of the statutory safeguards enacted under Chapters II and III of the Act. The Court has therefore compared the earlier and subsequent proceedings. Such comparison reveals that the lands proposed to be acquired remain substantially identical. The public purpose remains substantially identical. The object sought to be achieved remains substantially identical. The only noticeable variation is in the manner in which
-29-
the project is described. Whereas the earlier proceedings referred to
"Bund Development of Kotha Cheruvu", the subsequent proceedings describe the project as "Kotha Cheruvu Bund Development". The variation is one of form rather than substance.
45. Significantly, the respondents have not placed before this Court any revised Detailed Project Report, fresh feasibility study, updated engineering assessment, hydrological survey or any other contemporaneous material demonstrating that the project underwent any substantial transformation between the year 2018 and the issuance of the impugned notifications in 2020 and 2021. Nor have they disclosed any changed circumstances necessitating a fresh exemption under Section 10A. The absence of such material assumes considerable importance. When the State seeks to invoke an exceptional statutory power for a second time in relation to substantially the same lands and substantially the same project, the Court would ordinarily expect the record to disclose the reasons which persuaded the Government to once again dispense with the safeguards contemplated under Chapters II and III. No such reasons are forthcoming from the record.
46. The chronology of events also cannot be ignored. The earlier notifications were challenged before this Court and interim orders came to be granted. During the pendency of those proceedings, the
-30-
respondents invoked Section 10A once again and initiated another round of acquisition proceedings without placing on record any material indicating substantial changes either in the project or in the circumstances necessitating acquisition. Though such conduct may not by itself establish legal mala fides, it nevertheless invites closer scrutiny of the decision-making process.
47. The Court is therefore of the considered opinion that while the respondents may not have been legally barred from initiating fresh proceedings after lapse of the earlier notification, they were nevertheless required to demonstrate that the subsequent exercise represented a fresh and independent application of mind to the statutory requirements. The record does not disclose any such exercise. On the contrary, the substantial identity of the project, the lands and the objective sought to be achieved lends considerable support to the petitioners' contention that the respondents failed to undertake the scrutiny required before invoking Section 10A for a second time.
48. The circumstances surrounding the earlier acquisition proceedings, when viewed in conjunction with the deficiencies already noticed in the impugned notification dated 18.11.2020, further reinforce the conclusion that the respondents failed to
-31-
establish the jurisdictional facts necessary for exercise of the exemption power.
49. Point No.(iii) is accordingly answered in favour of the petitioners.
Point No.(iv):
"Whether the notification dated 22.05.2021 issued under Section 11(1) of the Act can survive independently?"
50. The answer to this point substantially follows from the findings already recorded on Point Nos. (i) to (iii). It is not in dispute that the notification dated 22.05.2021 issued under Section 11(1) of the Act was preceded by the notification dated 18.11.2020 issued under Section 10A. Indeed, the respondents justify non-compliance with Chapters II and III solely on the basis of the exemption granted under Section 10A. The notification issued under Section 10A thus constitutes the very foundation upon which the subsequent acquisition proceedings rest. Once the foundation is found to be legally unsustainable, the consequential proceedings cannot ordinarily survive unless they are capable of independent existence under the statutory framework.
51. Admittedly, no Social Impact Assessment was conducted in the present case. No public hearings were held. No appraisal by an
-32-
Expert Group took place. No exercise contemplated under Sections 4 to 9 of the Act was undertaken. Similarly, the safeguards embodied in Chapter III were not complied with. These omissions were justified entirely on the footing that a valid exemption under Section 10A existed.
52. The Court has already held that the respondents failed to establish the existence of public interest warranting exclusion of Chapters II and III and that the notification dated 18.11.2020 does not satisfy the statutory requirements governing exercise of the exemption power. Once that finding is recorded, the inevitable consequence is that the acquisition proceedings ought to have complied with the ordinary statutory framework. The safeguards contained in Chapters II and III are not procedural technicalities capable of being cured at a later stage. They constitute substantive components of the acquisition process itself. Compliance therewith goes to the root of the jurisdiction to proceed with acquisition. Their exclusion can be justified only through a valid exercise of power under Section 10A. In the absence of a valid exemption, the acquisition proceedings initiated under Section 11 stand deprived of their statutory foundation. The notification dated 22.05.2021 therefore cannot survive independently and is liable to be set aside.
-33-
53. Point No.(iv) is accordingly answered in favour of the petitioners.
CONCLUSION:
54. The discussion undertaken hereinabove demonstrates that the Act, 2013 treats Social Impact Assessment and the safeguards embodied in Chapters II and III as integral components of the acquisition process. Section 10A operates as a limited exception and can be invoked only upon demonstration of circumstances warranting exclusion of those safeguards. The burden of establishing the existence of such circumstances necessarily rests upon the acquiring authority.
55. In the present case, the respondents have failed to demonstrate the precise statutory basis upon which the project has been classified as an exempted project under Section 10A. They have further failed to place on record any contemporaneous material indicating the existence of public interest warranting exclusion of Chapters II and III, any exercise undertaken in compliance with the proviso to Section 10A, or any material demonstrating a fresh application of mind while initiating the subsequent proceedings after the earlier acquisition exercise of
2018.
-34-
56. Consequently, the notification dated 18.11.2020 issued under Section 10A cannot be sustained. Once the exemption notification is held invalid, the consequential notification dated 22.05.2021 issued under Section 11(1), admittedly issued without compliance with Chapters II and III of the Act, must necessarily fall.
RESULT:
57. Accordingly, all the Writ Petitions are allowed.
58. Gazette Notification No.249 dated 18.11.2020 issued by Respondent No.6 under Section 10A of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, granting exemption from the applicability of Chapters II and III of the Act, is hereby declared illegal and is accordingly set aside.
59. Consequently, Notification dated 22.05.2021 bearing Proc. No.G2/2256/2019 issued by Respondent No.1 under Section 11(1) of the Act, insofar as it relates to the lands of the petitioners covered by the present batch of writ petitions, is also set aside.
60. It is, however, made clear that this judgment shall not preclude the respondent authorities from initiating fresh acquisition proceedings, if so advised and if the public purpose
-35-
continues to subsist, strictly in accordance with the provisions of the Act, including compliance with Chapters II and III and all other mandatory statutory requirements.
61. There shall be no order as to costs.
62. As a sequel, all pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand closed.
___________________________________
VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY, J
Date: 08.06.2026
AS