JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. A.R. Bhuyan, the learned Senior Counsel assisted by Ms. S. Laskar, the learned counsel; Ms. S.B. Choudhury, the learned counsel; and Mr. B.M. Deka, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioners in the instant batch of writ petitions.
118
Mr. P.N. Goswami, the learned Senior Counsel as well as the Additional Advocate General, Assam assisted by Mr. I. Kalita, the learned counsel appears on behalf of the State of Assam and Mr. R. Borpujari, the learned Standing Counsel appears on behalf of the Revenue and Disaster Management Department of the Government of Assam.
2. The present batch of writ petitions is a sequel to the litigation that culminated into the judgment pronounced by the Supreme Court in Abdul Khalek & Others Vs. State of Assam & Others
reported in 2026 SCC OnLine SC 184..
3. This Court in the present batch of writ petitions inter alia called upon to decide if the Respondent Authorities' actions were in compliance with the Supreme Court's directions in Abdul Khalek (supra). It is under such circumstances; this Court finds it relevant to take note of the observations and directions passed by the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra). Paragraph Nos. 11 to 13 of the said judgment are quoted here under:
"11. We had heard learned senior counsel for the appellants/writ Petitioners as well as learned Solicitor General on 16.01.2026, and had expressed our concern to maintain the rule of law while ensuring protection of environment. Thereupon learned Solicitor General sought time to seek instructions and has filed an additional affidavit on 18.01.2026. Paras 3 to 9 of the said additional
119
affidavit read as under: —
"3. That this is the Constitutional obligation of the State Government, more particularly in light of the fact that as per the statistics given by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, Government of India. As per the data 3,62,082.62 hectares is under encroachment, in other words, a total of 19.92% of the forest area is under unauthorized illegal encroachment. It is Constitutionally imperative that this unauthorized and illegal occupation as well as continuing illegal and non forest activities are immediately removed.
3.1 That the first step for removal is to issue a notice on the alleged unauthorised occupant to enable him to show the evidence of him being in authorised occupation of the forest land.
3.2 That the recipient of the notice comes before a Committee of forest officials as well as revenue officials and produces the evidence, if any, available with him which can according to the notice, entitle him to stay in the Reserved Forest areas.
4. That the actions are taken for removal of encroachment areas only, if it is found that there is an illegal and unauthorised encroachment in the Reserved Forest area. If the land of the noticee is found to be within revenue limits, outside the notified forest area, the details are sent to the Revenue Department and the present drive which is confined only to evicting the Reserved Forest area has nothing to do with what the Revenue Department may or may not do thereafter.
5. That if the notice is found to be in unauthorised occupation of a Reserved Forest area, after scrutinising the documents placed by him, a
120
Speaking Order is passed and served upon him giving him 15 days notice to vacate the unauthorised occupation. It is only thereafter that the actions are taken to remove the unauthorised occupants.
6. That so far as the controversy concerning existence of some Gaon Panchayat is concerned, it is submitted that there can be a Gaon Panchayat in a forest area. This is provided for in Section 5 in Assam Panchayat Act,
1994.
"5. Establishment of Gaon Panchayat - (1) The State Government may, by notification, declare any local area comprising a revenue village or a group of revenue village or a Forest villager or Tea Garden area or hamlets forming part of revenue village or Forest village or Tea Garden area or other such administrative unit or part thereof to be a Gaon Panchayat with population of its territory not less that six thousand and more that ten thousand;…."
7. That the concept of a Forest Village is a unique concept in Assam. A person entitled to stay in forest village finds his name mentioned in the statutory register called 'Jamabandi Register' maintained by the Forest Department for the forest village and the person holds a document for the land under possession. Additionally, the title holders under Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006 are also legally authorised to occupy the forest land and are not liable for eviction. The rights mentioned above are inheritable but not alienable or transferable.
8. That individual whose name is mentioned in this register or hold rights under Forest Rights Act, 2006 are not unauthorised occupants. However, there are several unauthorised inhabitants who have encroached
121
upon lands outside the Gaon Panchayat limits and in some cases inside the Gaon Panchayat limits which fall within the boundaries of Reserved Forests.
9. That it may be pointed out that a right to reside in Reserved Forest areas falling within a Gaon Panchayat is inheritable but non-transferable. There would be a separate set of documentary evidence showing authorised occupation within Reserved Forest areas which are falling under a Gaon Panchayat. Any unauthorised occupant residing inside Reserved Forest areas albeit falling under a Gaon Panchayat is liable to be evicted following the same procedure as pointed out above."
12. Thus, from perusal of aforesaid additional affidavit filed on behalf of the Respondents, the following policy decision to remove unauthorised occupation from the reserved forest has been taken:
(i) The Respondents shall constitute a committee comprising forest officials and the revenue officials.
(ii) The said committee shall issue notice to the alleged unauthorised occupants and shall give them an opportunity to adduce evidence to show that they have the right to occupy the land which is in their possession.
(iii) The action for removal of encroachment shall be taken, only if it is found that there is an encroachment in the reserved forest area.
(iv) In case the noticee is found to be within the revenue limits, outside the notified forest area, the details of the noticee shall be sent to the revenue department. In such cases, revenue department shall decide the future course of action.
122
(v) The action is being taken by the State to remove encroachment from the reserved forest areas and has nothing to do in respect of the matters which may be referred to the revenue department.
(vi) If an unauthorised occupation is found in a reserved forest area, after scrutiny of the documents, a speaking order shall be passed and shall be served on the concerned person giving him 15 days notice to vacate the unauthorised occupation and only after expiry of the period of notice, the action shall be taken to remove the unauthorised occupants.
(vii) Occupation of a Gaon Panchayat in a forest is permissible if there is a sufficient proof as per the Jamabandi Register maintained by the Forest Department or as provided under the Forest Rights Act.
13. In our opinion, the course of action to be adopted by the State Government while removing the encroachment from the reserved forest contains sufficient procedural safeguards. The process sought to be adopted by the State Government for removal of encroachment conforms to the principles of fairness, reasonableness and due process. Learned Solicitor General has assured us that the mechanism evolved by the State shall be complied with objectively and with fairness while taking action for removal of unauthorised occupation in the reserved forests. The parties are directed to maintain status quo in respect of land in occupation of the appellants/writ Petitioners till speaking order is passed and till expiry of notice period of 15 days. All contentions are kept open to be agitated before the committee. It is clarified that this Court has not expressed any opinion on merits of the claim of the parties, as the same has to be examined by the committee."
4. In the backdrop of the above, this Court finds it pertinent to take note of the brief facts which led to the filing of the present
123
batch of writ petitions as well as the stand taken by the Respondent Authorities.
CONSPECTUS OF FACTS
WP(C) No. 1649/2026
5. 89 (Eighty Nine) Petitioners joined together to file the instant writ petition, challenging the various Speaking Orders dated 07.03.2026 which are collectively enclosed as Annexure-14 (colly) to the writ petition.
6. Some Petitioners claim to be residents of the villages of Barpani Bagan, Longjap N C (Longjap 500-700 Area), Longjap Padumoni (Hatipara FV), Juripar in the Barpani Gaon Panchayat under Jugijan Anchalik Panchayat in the district of Hojai while others claim that they reside in the villages of Dapara and Dumai Hagi in the Chankhola Gaon Panchayat and of village Kachua in the Kachua Gaon Panchayat, both under the Kathiatoli Anchalik Panchayat in the district of Nagaon.
7. The Petitioners aver that they are living in the previously mentioned villages and exercising rights over the lands with due knowledge, permission, and authority of the concerned State
124
Respondent Authorities. The documents so enclosed to the writ petition to substantiate the rights of the Petitioners are Aadhaar Cards, Voters' List, Voter Id Cards, Identity Cards, Ration Cards, Job Cards etc. It is the assertion of the Petitioners that the respective villages where they reside, have been notified as Panchayat Villages under Sub-Section (2) of Section 5 of the Assam Panchayat Act, 1994 vide Notification dated 15.10.2024. In addition to that, the Petitioners also claim that some of them have been issued certificates of permanent residence issued by the concerned Gaonburahs and collectively enclosed as Annexure-3 (colly) to the writ petition. Further to that, the Petitioners claim that 2 (two) out of the 89 (eighty nine) Petitioners have been also issued certificates by the Forest Range Officer, Kampur, Nagaon wherein it is mentioned that these Petitioners were allotted lands of Taungya Plantation under the Lutumai Forest jurisdiction. The certificates in respect to those 2 (two) Petitioners i.e., Petitioner No. 3 and Petitioner No. 37, are enclosed to the writ petition as Annexure-4 (colly).
8. It is the further case of the Petitioners that on 08.10.2025, the Divisional Forest Officer, Nagaon Forest Division, had issued a notice informing the Petitioners that they were occupying lands falling under the Lutumai Reserved Forest and the Petitioners were
125
directed to vacate their lands within 30 days of issuance of the said notice. The Petitioners therefore filed a writ petition before this Court, registered and numbered as WP(C) No. 6167/2025. The said writ petition was disposed of vide an order dated 17.11.2025 with certain directions to the effect that the Petitioners could submit representations and those representations would be disposed of by Speaking Orders.
9. It is also mentioned in the writ petition that in the meantime, some other persons, being aggrieved by the orders passed in WP(C) No. 4257/2025 and WP(C) No. 4258/2025, approached the learned Division Bench of this Court, by filing 2 (two) Writ Appeals, being Writ Appeal No. 251/2025 and Writ Appeal No. 252/2025. The learned Division Bench of this Court vide the judgment and order dated 18.08.2025 disposed of the said Writ Appeals by passing certain directions.
10. Be that as it may, following the order dated 17.11.2025 whereby the Petitioners have been granted liberty to submit representations, the Petitioners submitted representations. The Divisional Forest Officer, Nagaon Forest Division, Nagaon rejected the representations of the Petitioners vide an order dated 21.11.2025 and directed the Petitioners to vacate the forest lands
126
on or before 29.11.2025. Under such circumstances, the Petitioners again approached this Court by challenging the order dated 21.11.2025 passed by the Divisional Forest Officer, Nagaon Forest Division by filing another writ petition which was registered and numbered as WP(C) No. 6764/2025. The said writ petition was disposed of vide judgment and order dated 28.11.2025 with a direction upon the concerned Respondent Authorities to conduct a joint verification of the entire area claimed and occupied by the Petitioners in presence and participation of the Petitioners, and also provide the Petitioners an opportunity to submit documents in support of their claims.
11. In the meantime, some of the persons, aggrieved by the judgment and order dated 18.08.2025 passed by the learned Division Bench of this Court in Writ Appeal No. 251/2025, approached the Supreme Court under Article 136 of the Constitution. The Supreme Court, vide the judgment dated 10.02.2026 in Abdul Khalek (supra) issued various directions.
12. In pursuance to the directions issued in Abdul Khalek (supra), notices were issued to each of the Petitioners on 21.02.2026. The Petitioners submitted replies. Pursuant thereto, the impugned Speaking orders were passed on 07.03.2026, holding inter alia that
127
the Petitioners were in unauthorized occupation of Lutumai Reserved Forest and this aspect was found on the basis of a joint field verification by the Forest and Revenue officials using ground survey and GPS coordinates, which showed that the Petitioners' occupation fell within the notified limits of the Lutumai Reserved Forest. It was mentioned in the Speaking Orders that despite opportunities, the Petitioners could not produce any document conferring right, title or authority over the land under their occupation. The Petitioners were directed by the various Speaking Orders to vacate the unauthorized occupation in Lutumai Reserved Forest within 15 days of the issue of the Speaking Order, failing which action would be taken. It is under such circumstances, the present writ petition was filed on 18.03.2026.
13. This Court, vide order dated 31.03.2026 issued notice and taking into account the undertaking furnished by Mr. P.N. Goswami, the learned Additional Advocate General, Assam, that no steps would be taken pursuant to the Speaking Orders, this Court did not pass any interim directions. However, subsequently, vide an order dated 07.04.2026, this Court directed the Respondent Forest Department not to take any steps for eviction of the Petitioners from the reserved forest in question.
128
14. The records reveal that the Respondent No. 6 filed an Affidavit-in-Opposition and the Petitioners have also filed an Affidavit-in-Reply to the said Affidavit-in-Opposition filed by the Respondent No. 6. There is also an Additional Affidavit filed on behalf of the Respondent No. 2.
WP(C) No. 1615/2026, WP(C) No. 1616/2026, WP(C) No. 1620/2026, WP(C) No. 1633/2026 and WP(C) No. 1691/2026
15. The factual matrix of the Writ Petitioners in the above batch of writ petitions is similar to the facts of the Writ petitioners in WP(C) No. 1649/2026. Under such circumstances, this Court for the sake of brevity, would not like to repeat the stand of the Petitioners in these writ petitions save and except observing that the Petitioners in these writ petitions claim to be residents of various villages which fall within different notified Gaon Panchayat and they have been issued public documents viz. Aadhaar Cards, Ration Cards, Voter IDs, Electricity connections as well as certificates issued by the Panchayat Authorities. All these Petitioners were issued Notices on 21.02.2026, pursuant to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra) and the Petitioners filed their replies/representations. Thereupon, Speaking Orders were passed on 07.03.2026 against all the Writ Petitioners asking them to
129
vacate within 15 days. Under such circumstances, the Writ Petitioners have filed the present batch of writ petitions. Affidavits- in-Opposition were filed by the Respondent Authorities and thereupon the Petitioners replied by filling Affidavits-in-Reply. Additional Affidavits were also filed by the State Respondents.
WRIT PETITIONS PRIMARILY BASED UPON TAUNGYA
RIGHTS
16. A set of writ petitions were filed wherein the Petitioners claimed rights on the basis of settlements granted to the Taungya, and some Petitioners asserted that the original Taungya settlement holders had sold the rights to them and as such they cannot be evicted from the reserved forests. The Writ Petitioners espousing such rights are in WP(C) No. 1688/2026, WP(C) No. 1690/2026, WP(C) No. 1694/2026 and WP(C) No. 1708/2026. The factual matrix of the said writ petitions are narrated herein under:
WP(C) No. 1688/2026
17. 82 (Eighty Two) Petitioners joined together to file the writ petition assailing the impugned Speaking Orders dated 07.03.2026. It is the case of the Petitioners herein that the Petitioners are in continuous, peaceful, open, uninterrupted possession and
130
occupation of a plot of land admeasuring 300 Bighas situated at village Matikhula under Nagaon Forest Division for more than 75 (seventy five) years along with their families, tracing their occupation from the time of their ancestors. It is the further case of the Petitioners that they belong to a Revenue Village called Ranipukhuri under Kampur Revenue Circle of Nagaon District, and some of the Petitioners have been paying the land revenue to the Government of Assam in respect to the lands under their occupation. Some of the revenue receipts have been enclosed as Annexure-1 (colly). The Petitioners also state that they have been issued public documents viz. Voter Identity Cards, Aadhaar Cards, PAN Cards, and Ration Cards showing inter alia that the Petitioners are residents of village Matikhula. These documents are enclosed as Annexure-2 (colly) and Annexure-3 (colly). It is the further case of the Petitioners that on 14.12.1977, the Government of Assam recognized the feasibility of settlement within the Lutumai Reserved Forest Area and the Under Secretary to the Government of Assam, Revenue (Settlement) Department, Development Branch issued a communication to the Deputy Commissioner, Nagaon directing settlement of approximately 8,824 Bighas of land in favour of local inhabitants of a nearby village adjacent to Village Matikhula. It is the claim of the Petitioners herein that such Governmental actions clearly establish that portions of the land
131
within the reserved forest were, even as per the State's own assessment, suitable for human habitation and settlement. The Petitioners herein also claim that the Petitioners are entitled to parity of consideration before any action is taken.
18. It is also the case of the Petitioners that in the year 2004, the ancestors of the present Petitioners approached this Court by filing a writ petition being WP(C) No. 2947/2004. This Court, vide an order dated 29.11.2006, disposed of the writ petition thereby directing that the Petitioners shall not be evicted from the lands in question without following the procedure established by law. It is also the case of the Petitioners that on 30.11.2022, the Office of the Range Forest Officer, Kampur Range forwarded a petition submitted by the Petitioners seeking allotment and regularization of the land in favour of Non-ST residents residing within the Lutumai Reserved Forest Area. However, despite the passage of substantial time, the Respondent Authorities did not take any decision.
19. It is the further case of the Petitioners that the Petitioners were issued eviction notices on 08.10.2025 alleging that the Petitioners were in illegal occupation of land within the Lutumai Reserved/Protected Forest Area. The Petitioners submitted a
132
representation before the Divisional Forest Officer, Nagaon Forest Division on 22.10.2025 wherein they respectively prayed for a joint verification and proper boundary demarcation of the alleged forest area in their presence and further requested the authorities to refrain from taking any coercive action. It is the case of the Petitioners that though this representation was pending, the Respondent Authorities selectively initiated eviction proceedings in 2025. It is alleged that approximately 1,200 families have been living in the area for decades, but eviction notices were issued only against 120 families, predominantly belonging to the Muslim community. The Petitioners being aggrieved by the issuance of the notice and the non-consideration of their representation approached this Court by filing a writ petition which was registered and numbered as WP(C) No. 6290/2025. The learned Coordinate Bench of this Court vide an order dated 06.11.2025 disposed of the writ petition thereby granting liberty to file representation and for due consideration. In pursuance thereto, representations were filed.
20. The Divisional Forest Officer, Nagaon Division thereupon passed an order on 21.11.2025 rejecting the Petitioners' representation as baseless. It was alleged that neither any opportunity of personal hearing nor joint verification were carried
133
out. The Petitioners were asked to vacate the land by 29.11.2025, failing which, forcible eviction with police aid threatened.
21. The Petitioners further alleged that pursuant to the judgment passed in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra), the Petitioners were issued notices on 21.02.2026 by the Office of the Divisional Forest Officer, Nagaon Division directing the Petitioners to submit their representation along with documentary evidence in support of the claim for authorized occupation. The Petitioners submitted representations on 26.02.2026 and thereupon the impugned Speaking Orders were passed on 07.03.2026.
22. The records reveal that the Respondent No. 4 had filed an Affidavit-in-Opposition. A Rejoinder Affidavit was filed by the Petitioners against the Affidavit-in-Opposition filed by the Respondent No. 4. Further to that, an Additional Affidavit was filed by the Respondent No. 1.
WP(C) No. 1690/2026
23. 177 (One Hundred Seventy Seven) Petitioners joined together to file the writ petition challenging the impugned Speaking orders dated 07.03.2026 issued by the Divisional Forest Officer, Nagaon Division. The Petitioners herein claim to be residents of the villages
134
of 9 No. Kheroni, Padumoni, Hatijur, Chankhola and Kandapara in the Barpani, Chankhola and Ulumguri Gaon Panchayat under Binnakandi and Barhampur Anchalik Panchayat in the district of Nagaon.
24. To substantiate the Petitioners' occupation, they have enclosed their Aadhaar Cards, Voters' List, Voters' IDs, Identity Cards, Ration Cards, etc., as Annexure-1 (colly) to the writ petition. The Petitioners claim that the lands under their possession falls within the notified villages under the Assam Panchayat Act, 1994, and the Petitioners have also been issued certificates by the concerned Panchayat Authorities. It is the case of the Petitioners that the lands under their possession were formally allotted to them by the Government of Assam in the Forest Department itself, as evident from the official certification issued to the Petitioners by the Forest Range Officer, Kampur, Nagaon in the year 1974. It is claimed by the Petitioners that some of the Petitioners have been issued Taungya certificates by the Forest Range Officer, Kampur Range in the year 1974, which are collectively enclosed as Annexure-4 (colly) to the writ petition.
25. This Court has duly perused Annexure-4 (colly) to the writ petition. A perusal of those documents show that after eviction of
135
700 evicted families from Kaki Reserved Forest and 300 evicted families of Lutumari Longjap Reserved Forest, certain applications were forwarded by the Joint Secretary to the Government of Assam, Forest Department to the Deputy Commissioner, Nagaon for due consideration. In addition to that, Annexure-4 includes a telegram dated 12.12.1974 which shows that those evictees of the Kaki Reserved Forest and Lutumai Reserved Forest were requested to give shelter under Taungya system on temporary basis.
26. The records reveal that the Petitioners being aggrieved by the notice dated 08.12.2025, issued by the Divisional Forest Officer, Nagaon Forest Division filed 3(three) writ petitions before this Court which were registered and numbered as WP(C) No. 223/2026, WP(C) No. 224/2026 and WP(C) No.7391/2025. This Court disposed of the said writ petitions vide separate judgment and order, by taking into account that in the meantime, the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra) was pronounced and thereby directing the Respondent Authorities to take steps in accordance with the directions passed in Abdul Khalek (supra). Pursuant thereto, notices were issued on 21.02.2026, and the Petitioners submitted replies on 27.02.2026. Thereafter, the impugned Speaking Orders were passed on
07.03.2026.
136
27. The records further reveal that an Affidavit-in-Opposition was filed by the Respondent No. 6, and a reply thereagainst filed by the Petitioners. In addition to that, an Additional Affidavit was also filed by the Respondent No. 2.
WP(C) No. 1694/2026
28. 21 (Twenty One) Petitioners joined together to file this Writ Petition challenging the impugned Speaking Orders dated 07.03.2026. It is the case of the Petitioners that they are residents of villages Podumoni Tongia (Hatipara Forest Village) in the district of Nagaon for many years. It is the case of the Petitioners that the rights of possession of the Petitioners are claimed from original Taungya certificate holders who were issued Taungya certificates by the Government under a Taungya system in 1974.
29. The Petitioners have enclosed the telegram dated 12.02.1974 to claim that original Taungya holders were allowed to do plantation, pursuant to a letter dated 13.02.1974. The Petitioners, however, admit that though the Petitioners are not the original landowners or the recorded landholders of the lands in question, but they have been residing with due knowledge of the local administration. To substantiate the same, the Petitioners have enclosed the Voters' List, Identity Cards, Ration Cards, Electricity
137
Bills etc. as Annexure-3 (series) to the writ petition. The records further reveal that on 08.12.2025, the Divisional Forest Officer, Nagaon Division issued notices upon the Petitioners of eviction on the ground that the Petitioners were under occupation of the Lutumai Reserved Forest. The Petitioners approached this Court by filing a writ petition being WP(C) No. 223/2026. In the meantime, the Supreme Court passed the judgment in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra) and this Court vide judgment and order dated 12.02.2026 disposed of the said writ petition, thereby directing the Respondents to take steps in consonance with the directions passed by the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra).
30. The record further reveals that pursuant thereto, notices were issued to the Petitioners on 21.02.2026, and the Petitioners filed replies/representations. Subsequent thereto, the impugned Speaking Orders dated 07.03.2026 were passed.
31. The records further reveal that the Respondent No. 5 filed an Affidavit-in-Opposition. Affidavit-in-Reply has also been filed by the Petitioners against the Affidavit-in-Opposition filed by the Respondent No. 5. In addition to that, an Additional Affidavit was also filed by the Respondent No. 2.
138
WP(C) No. 1708/2026
32. 15 (Fifteen) Petitioners joined together to file the writ petition challenging the impugned Speaking Orders dated 07.03.2026 issued by the Divisional Forest Officer, Nagaon Division. The Petitioners herein claim to be residents of village 9 No. Kheroni Tongia under Nagaon Forest Division, Assam. The Petitioners claim to be in continuous, peaceful, open, uninterrupted possession and occupation of approximately 60 Bighas of land for many decades. It is claimed by the Petitioners that possession of the Petitioners are lawful and was duly delivered by the Taungya settlers by way of sale and gift, who were permitted by the Forest Department to occupy and cultivate the land under the Taungya Settlement Scheme in the year 1974. Reference was made to the letter dated 07.06.1974 as well as the order dated 13.02.1974. It is the specific case of the Petitioners herein that they have been conferred rights to remain in possession and occupation of the land under their possession upon being transferred to them by the original Tongia settlers in whose name the land was initially allotted by the Forest Department. An eviction notice was issued to the Petitioners on 08.12.2025. The Petitioners being aggrieved filed a writ petition before this Court, which was registered and numbered as WP(C) No. 224/2026.
139
33. In the meantime, the judgment of the Supreme Court was rendered in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra), and accordingly, this Court disposed of the writ petition being WP(C) No. 224/2026 vide judgment and order dated 12.02.2026 thereby directing the Respondent Authorities to take steps in terms with the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra). Pursuant thereto, notices were issued to the Petitioners on 21.02.2026. Representations were submitted by the Petitioners on 27.02.2026. Thereupon, the impugned Speaking Orders dated 07.03.2026 were passed.
34. The records reveal that pursuant to the filing of the instant writ petition, Affidavit-in-Opposition was filed by the Respondent No. 4. The Petitioners also filed an Affidavit-in-Reply. In addition to that, an Additional Affidavit was filed by the Respondent No. 1.
WRIT PETITIONS CLAIMING RIGHTS ON THE BASIS OF
PATTA ISSUED AND PAYMENT OF LAND REVENUE TO THE
REVENUE DEPARTMENT
35. The third set of Writ Petitioners claim that the lands under their occupation are revenue lands. Some of them were granted Annual Pattas and some are paying Touzi Mouza (penalty for occupation of Government lands). The writ petitions espousing this
140
cause of action the writ petitioners in WP(C) No. 1618/2026 and WP(C) No. 1628/2026. The factual matrix of the said writ petitions are mentioned herein under:
WP(C) No. 1618/2026
36. 13 (Thirteen) Petitioners filed the instant writ petition challenging the impugned Speaking Orders dated 07.03.2026 issued by the Divisional Forest Officer, Nagaon Division. The Petitioners claim that they are in possession of 100 Bighas of land at Village Juripar since the days of their forefathers by erecting dwelling houses and planting trees, etc. It is the case of the Petitioners herein that the village falls under the Revenue Village. An allotment was given by the District Administration and the Petitioners are paying land revenue. However, no such documents in that regard enclosed to the writ petition. The Petitioners were issued eviction notices on 21.11.2025 by the Respondent No. 6 stating inter alia that they were residing over lands falling under the Lutumai Reserved Forest Area, which the Petitioners claim that these lands were outside the reserved forest land as they have been allotted lands by the District Administration. The Petitioners thereupon filed a writ petition before this Court which was registered and numbered as WP(C) No. 7443/2025.
141
37. The learned Coordinate Bench of this Court vide an order dated 19.12.2025 disposed of the writ petition with a direction to the Petitioners to file representation before the Divisional Forest Officer, Nagaon Forest Division within a period of 7 (seven) days, enclosing all relevant documents in support of their claim. The Divisional Forest Officer, Nagaon Forest Division was directed to consider the same and pass a reasoned order by following the law within 15 (fifteen) days. It was also observed that in the circumstance, the Petitioners failed to submit the representation within the specified period, the Respondent Authorities shall be at liberty to proceed with the eviction notice dated 21.11.2025.
38. In the meantime, in view of the judgment passed by the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra), notices were issued to the Petitioners for submitting evidence. The Petitioners submitted representation on 27.02.2026 along with certain documents. Pursuant thereto, the impugned Speaking Orders were passed on 07.03.2026, which is the subject matter of challenge in the present writ petition.
39. Be that as it may, an Additional Affidavit was filed by the Petitioners on 01.04.2026 whereto the Petitioners enclosed a sale deed as well as certain revenue receipts in respect to various plots
142
of land.
WP(C) No. 1628/2026
40. 20 (Twenty) Petitioners filed the writ petition challenging the various impugned Speaking Orders dated 07.03.2026 issued by the Divisional Forest Officer, Nagaon Division. It is the case of the Petitioners that the Petitioners are residing over a plot of land at Village Longjap, 700 Acre (Padumoni) covered by Dag No. 368 and Patta No. 1140, since the days of their forefathers, by erecting dwelling houses and planting trees, etc. On 21.11.2025, the Respondent No. 6 had issued notices to the Petitioners informing the Petitioners that they are in possession of the Lutumai Reserved Forest Area, though it is the claim of the Petitioners that the land under their possession is outside the reserved forest area. It is the further case of the Petitioners that the Petitioners were asked to vacate within 15 (fifteen) days. The Petitioners thereupon filed writ petitions before this Court, which were registered and numbered as WP(C) No. 412/2026, WP(C) No. 7454/2025, WP(C) No. 7462/2025, WP(C) No. 7452/2025, WP(C) No. 7464/2025, WP(C) No. 7406/2025, and various other writ petitions.
41. The said writ petitions were disposed of thereby granting the Petitioners an opportunity to submit their respective
143
representations and directions were issued for consideration of the representation. In the meantime, the judgment of the Supreme Court was passed in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra) and notices were issued to the Petitioners on 21.02.2026. The Petitioners submitted their representations and thereupon the Speaking Orders dated 07.03.2026 were passed, which are the subject matter of challenge in the present writ petition. It is also relevant to take note of that the Petitioners have also filed an Additional Affidavit, thereby enclosing certain allotment cards issued in respect to the Lutumai De-Reserved Area as well as various unregistered Deeds of Sale of Government lands. Certain land revenue receipts have also been enclosed. There is however nothing to show how the Allotment cards in respect to the Lutumai De-reserved Area has any relation with the Petitioners.
42. In the backdrop of the above pleadings, let this Court now consider the respective submissions made by the learned counsels for the parties.
SUBMISSIONS MADE BY THE LEARNED COUNSELS FOR
THE PARTIES
43. Mr. A.R. Bhuyan, the learned Senior Counsel as well as the
144
other learned counsels appearing on behalf of the Petitioners submitted that the impugned Speaking Orders assailed in the present batch of writ petitions have been passed mechanically without taking appropriate steps for proper verification, which is required in terms with the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra). The learned counsels appearing on behalf of the Petitioners further submitted that the verification required to be done, whether the land under the occupation of the Petitioners falls within the forest land or revenue land was not carried out in accordance with the directions passed by the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra). The learned counsels submitted that the manner the verification were to be carried out ought to have been on the basis of the original map which was prepared at the time when the reserved forests were constituted by appropriate Notifications. As the original maps were not taken into consideration, the verifications made, cannot be said to be accurate, thereby permitting the Respondent Authorities to carry out any eviction in view of the directions passed by the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra).
44. The learned counsels for the Petitioners submitted that the Petitioners are in occupation of various lands which are villages notified under Section 5(2) of the Assam Panchayat Act, 1994 and
145
in that regard referred to the Notification dated 15.10.2024, issued by the Panchayat and Rural Development Department of the Government of Assam. The learned counsels, therefore, submitted that when the Petitioners are in occupation of lands which are within respective Gaon Panchayats, the same cannot be construed in any manner to be lands within the reserved forests in question. The learned counsels further submitted that the various documents which were produced would show that the Petitioners have been in long possession of these lands and would be evident from the Aadhaar Cards, Voters' Lists, Voters' ID Cards, Identity Cards, Ration Cards, etc. which are enclosed to the writ petitions. The issuance of these documents would clearly show that the Government has recognized the Petitioners' possession in these lands.
45. Mr. A.R. Bhuyan, the learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of some of the Writ Petitioners submitted that though some of the Petitioners admit that they are within the reserved forest, but they have been either permitted under the Taungya system to occupy and hold the lands by the Forest Officials of the Government of Assam prior to the enactment of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and some have obtained derivative title from those persons who have been allotted lands under the
146
Taungya system. The learned Senior Counsel, therefore, submitted that under such circumstances, these persons cannot be said to be unauthorized occupants thereby initiating steps for eviction. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the said aspect have not been considered while passing the Speaking Orders assailed in the present batch of writ petitions.
46. The learned Senior Counsel also submitted that in terms with various communications issued by the Forest Department of the Government of Assam in the year 2003, as well as the Government of India, those persons who have been residing prior to 1980, ought to be regularized, and this aspect would be further apparent from Clause 4.3.1.1 of the Assam Forest Policy, 2004. The Petitioners in the present writ petitions have been residing in these lands, even prior to the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 coming into force and even assuming that these lands fall within the reserved forest, the Petitioners' cases should have been regularized, rather than taking steps for evicting the Petitioners.
47. Per contra, Mr. P.N. Goswami, the learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the State Respondents submitted that in terms with the judgment passed by the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra), a Committee was constituted by the
147
Respondent Authorities comprising of Forest Officials and Revenue Officials vide Notification dated 17.02.2026. The Committee, thereupon, carried out the verification of the boundaries of the 4 (four) reserved forests which are the subject matter of the present batch of writ petitions. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that on the basis of the original map and by employing scientific methods, field survey was conducted and the geo- coordinates of the boundaries of the reserved forests were ascertained which were accurate to the extent of around 2 centimeters and after ascertaining the boundaries, notices were issued to each of the Petitioners taking into account these Petitioners were found to be in occupation of lands within the reserved forests and asking them to produce any documents to substantiate as to on what basis they are in occupation of reserved forest. In that regard, the learned Senior Counsel referred to the contents of the notices which have been issued and submitted that replies thereagainst were filed by most of the Petitioners. In these replies, the Petitioners did not provide any documents which would substantiate their right to remain within the reserved forest. The learned Senior Counsel submitted that Voter Cards, Aadhaar Cards, Ration Cards, or Certificates issued by the Panchayat Authorities cannot be construed as documents entitling the Petitioners to remain in occupation within the reserved forests. The learned
148
Senior Counsel further submitted that all these aspects were duly taken into consideration, and thereupon Speaking Orders were passed in each of the cases thereby clearly indicating that the Petitioners failed to substantiate their rights to remain within the reserved forests.
48. Mr. P.N. Goswami, the learned Senior Counsel for the State Respondents submitted that in terms with the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra), 15 (fifteen) days time was granted to the Petitioners to vacate. The learned Senior Counsel, therefore, submitted that this Court may not like to interfere, as the authorities have carried out the proper fact-finding exercise. To substantiate the said argument, the learned Senior Counsel drew the attention of this Court to the maps which have been enclosed to the Additional Affidavits so filed, wherein the boundaries of the reserved forest were duly delineated. The learned Additional Advocate General further submitted that for the convenience of this Court, apart from the maps clearly delineating the boundaries, separate maps have also been enclosed to show the Petitioners' occupation within the reserved forests with coloured marks. The geo-coordinates of the 4 (four) reserved forests as well as the geo-coordinates of the Petitioners' possession which are ascertained on the basis of scientific analysis were also
149
mentioned in the Affidavits as well as in the Additional Affidavits.
49. Insofar as the Taungya system is concerned, the learned Senior Counsel submitted that the Taungya system was a colonial era arrangement under which Jhumming communities and local inhabitants who traditionally practiced slash-and-burn agriculture were given 5 (five) years to raise forest plantation, after which they were asked to vacate the area. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the Forest Department neither promised any permanent settlement nor constituted any framework for their settlement in any forest village permanently. Referring to the wireless message dated 12.02.1974 and subsequently the letter dated 07.06.1974, which forms the basis of the Petitioners claiming rights under the Taungya system, the learned Senior Counsel submitted that the perusal of the documents refer to about 300 evicted families of Lutumai Reserved Forest. The purpose of the letter was to make some temporary arrangement post-eviction.
50. The learned Senior Counsel further elaborating his submissions on the rights of Taungya submitted that the word
"Taungya system" is used in the Forest Department to denote a system of plantation introduced during the British era for Jhumming communities and local inhabitants who traditionally
150
practiced slash-and-burn agriculture, under which certain area of land was allocated to these families who did slash-and-burn agriculture to clear the undergrowth first and to clear plantation between the planted rows, i.e., crops and vegetables such as cotton, ginger, turmeric, etc. This continued until 5 (five) years till the plantation matured and became tall enough, achieving a height of 5-6 meters. Thereupon, the Taungya communities moved to other parts of the forest where regeneration and plantation were required. The learned Senior Counsel therefore submitted that from the letter dated 07.06.1974, it can be deduced that the 300 families in the Lutumai Reserved Forest were allowed as temporary shelters at best for 5 (five) years and after which they were expected to move out of the forests. There was never a promise by the Forest Department regarding permanent settlement or the Forest Department constituted any framework for their settlement in any forest village permanently.
51. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that on 25.10.1980, the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, (for short, "the Act of 1980"), came into force, and as per Section 2 of the Act of 1980, no forest land can be used for non-forest activity without the prior concurrence of the Central Government. The learned Senior Counsel therefore submitted that under such circumstances, it is
151
not possible at all to provide settlement to these families within the Reserved Forest after the coming into effect of the Act of 1980.
52. Mr. R. Borpujari, the learned Standing Counsel for the Revenue and Disaster Management Department submitted that a policy of the Government is a deliberate statement of intent which the Government proposes to adopt to address socio-economic, political or environmental issues. The policy of the Government is dependent on the availability of material resources, and as such no right is created on the basis of the policy. A right would be created only when the policy of the Government is made effective by issuance of appropriate executive orders in the form of Notification etc. Referring to Clause 4.3.1.1 of the Assam Forest Policy, 2004, the learned Standing Counsel submitted that the Government's policy was to consider rehabilitation of those persons who were permitted to reside prior to 1980 with the approval of the Competent Authority. This policy would depend upon the availability of material resources with the Government and in that regard the Government of Assam had framed Assam Land Policy, 2019 which stipulates various criteria. The learned Standing Counsel further submitted that under no circumstances, the Petitioners herein can be allowed to reside within the reserved forests.
152
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION
POINTS FOR DETERMINATION
53. The following points for determination arises:
(i) Whether the Respondent Authorities prior to passing of the impugned Speaking Orders followed the procedural safeguards mandated by the directions passed by the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra)?
(ii) If the answer to the first point for determination is in the affirmative, have the Petitioners been able to show any documents/evidence to substantiate their right to remain inside the Reserved Forests?
(iii) What order(s)/direction(s) are required to be passed in the present proceedings?
FIRST POINT FOR DETERMINATION
54. This Court, in the previous segments of the instant judgment, quoted paragraph Nos. 11 to 13 of the judgment rendered by the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra). From a perusal
153
of the contents of the said paragraphs, it would be apparent that the Supreme Court observed that the procedures so mentioned in the Additional Affidavit filed by the Government of Assam on 18.01.2026 for the approval of the Supreme Court were held to contain sufficient procedural safeguards.
55. The materials on record show that the Governor of Assam had constituted Committees of Forest Officials as well as Revenue Officials vide a Notification dated 17.02.2026. The contents of the said Notification being relevant are reproduced herein under:
"GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
ENVIRONMENT, FOREST AND CLIMATE CHANGE DEPARTMENT
DISPUR, GUWAHATI-6
ORDERS BY THE GOVERNOR
NOTIFICATION
ECF No. 700588/521: The Government of Assam has been following a procedure for eviction of unauthorized occupants from any unauthorized occupation in general and from the notified forest land/reserved forest land in particular. The said procedure was also placed before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of C.A. No. 001464 - 001465 of 2026 (@ SLP(C)) No. 23647-23648 of 2025 with W.P.(C) NO. 1046 of 2025, CIVIL APPEAL NO. of 001466 of 2026 (@ SLP(C) NO. 32624 of 2025), CIVIL APPEAL NO.001467 of 2026 (@ SLP (C) NO. 32296 of 2025), CIVIL APPEAL NO. 001468 of 2026 (@ SLP(C) NO. 32993 of 2025), CIVIL APPEAL NO. 001469 of 2026 (@ SLP (C) NO. 34412 of 2025), CIVIL APPEAL NO. 001470 of 2026 (@ SLP(C) No. 34556 of 2025) and W.P. (C) NO. 65 of 2026.
With a view to formalize and codify the procedure being followed and with a view to ensure that no deviation from the procedure takes place, it is found desirable to issue the present Notification.
154
The Governor of Assam, therefore, is pleased to constitute a District-level Committee to remove encroachment from notified forest land/reserved forest land of the State Government/under the control and being managed by the Government of Assam. The Committee shall comprise of the following members:-
1. District Commissioner Chairman
2. Divisional Forest Officer Member Secretary
3. ADC Revenue Member
4. Concerned Range Officer Member
5. Concerned Circle Officer Member
Terms of Reference:
The following shall be the role & responsibilities of the Committee:
1. The Committee shall issue notice to the alleged unauthorized occupants and shall give them an opportunity to adduce evidence to show that they have legal and Statutory right to occupy the land which is in their possession.
2. The action for removal of encroachment shall be taken, only if it is found that there is an unauthorized encroachment in the forest area reserved forest area.
3. In case the noticee is found to be within the revenue limits, outside the notified forest area/reserved forest area, the details of the noticee shall be sent to the Revenue department. In such cases,
155
Revenue department shall decide the future course of action.
4. If an unauthorized occupation is found in a forest/reserved forest area, after scrutiny of the documents, a Speaking Order shall be passed and shall be served on the concerned person giving him 15 days' notice to vacate the unauthorized occupation and only after expiry of the said period of notice, the action shall be taken to remove the unauthorized occupants.
5. The occupation in a Gaon Panchayat in a forest shall be permissible only if there is a sufficient proof as per the Jamabandi Register maintained by the Forest Department or as provided under the Forest Rights Act.
6. Member Secretary of the Committee will issue notices and sign the Speaking Orders on behalf of the Committee.
Special Chief Secretary to the Govt. of Assam
Environment, Forest & Climate Change Department"
56. It is apposite herein to observe that a perusal of the said Notification appears to be in pursuance to the directions passed by the Supreme Court in Abdul Khalek (Supra). It is of importance to note that the Terms of Reference categorically mentioned that the Committee(s) so constituted would only take steps for eviction in respect to Forest lands and not Revenue lands. Further the Terms of Reference made it clear that one of the document amongst
156
others which would be taken into consideration are the Jamabandi (record of rights) maintained by the Forest Department and entries made in the said Jamabandi.
57. In view of the Terms of Reference contained in the Notification dated 17.02.2026 as well as the directions passed by the Supreme Court in Abdul Khalek (supra), the Reserved Forests in question were required to be delineated with precision so that only in respect to the Forest lands eviction proceedings are carried out and not in the revenue lands. The records, more particularly the Affidavits filed by the Respondent State would show that the Forest Officials along with the Committee members conjointly took steps to survey the Reserved forests in question in order to ascertain the boundaries. The method employed to ascertain the boundaries of the 4 (four) reserved forests have been in detail described in the enclosures to the Additional Affidavits filed by the Respondent State.
METHODOLOY EMPLOYED TO ASCERTAIN THE
BOUNDARIES OF THE RESERVED FORESTS AND
DIGITIZATION OF THE BOUNDARIES.
58. This Court finds it relevant to reproduce the contents of Part-I of the Report enclosed to the Additional Affidavit filed by the
157
Respondent State in WP(C) No. 1615/2026.
"PART I
GENERAL METHODOLOGY FOR SURVEY AND DIGITIZATION OF RESERVED
FORESTS
2. OVERVIEW
The methodology consists of two logically connected stages. The first stage is documentation-based. The original gazette notification constituting the Reserved Forest is read together with historical georeferenced Survey of India (SoI) toposheets and contemporary orthorectified and georeferenced satellite imagery (Orthoimage), and plotting the notified boundary in GIS software. The second stage is field-based. The plotted boundary is physically verified on the ground using a Differential Global Positioning System / Differential Global Navigation Satellite System (DGPS / DGNSS) rover with Real Time Kinematic (RTK) correction from SoI Continuously Operating Reference Stations (CORS Network), by a team comprising a qualified survey expert and officers of the Forest Department, together with members of the designated committee. Coordinates of existing boundary pillars and of any encroachments found within the notified area are captured, plotted on the same geo-referenced base map, and thereafter verified.
The combination of these two stages ensures that every corner point of the Reserved Forest boundary, and the location of every encroachment, can be expressed in absolute latitude/longitude coordinates in the WGS-84 datum, and can be visually verified against real-world ground features captured in the satellite imagery.
158
3. STAGE 1 - GEO-REFERENCING OF THE NOTIFIED BOUNDARY
3.1 Collection of Primary Records
For each Reserved Forest, the following primary records are collected from the Divisional records, the State Archives and, where available, from the Revenue Department:
· The original gazette notification declaring the area as Reserved Forest, along with the Schedule describing the boundaries and the area statement;
· The original sketch map accompanying the notification. · Survey Methodology and Ground Verification
· Survey of India toposheets covering the Reserved Forest. · Recent satellite imagery.
3.2 Preparation of the Geo-referenced Base Map
The reference layer is an orthoimage, a georeferenced and geometrically corrected aerial or satellite image in which every pixel carries a precise latitude and longitude coordinate in the UTM coordinate system. The original SoI toposheet, which in itself carries a known geographic coordinate system, is used as the outer framework. Where two or more adjacent toposheets are required to cover a single Reserved Forest, the toposheets are stitched (mosaicked) together in GIS software to produce a single continuous geo-
159
referenced base map of the area. Identifiable ground control points (GCPs) such as road junctions, bridges, river confluences, existing forest department pillars and other stable landmarks are marked both on the SoI toposheet and on the satellite image. The two layers are then digitally superimposed into alignment in GIS software. The result is that the notified boundary of the Reserved Forest, when overlaid on this composite base, can be visually checked against actual ground features.
3.3 Plotting of the Notified Boundary
The boundary description in the gazette notification typically given as a sequence of numbered pillars with bearings, distances and natural features such as streams, ridges, roads and river banks is translated into a digital polyline in GIS software. Each pillar is assigned its latitude and longitude coordinates.
4. STAGE 2 — GROUND VERIFICATION USING DGPS / DGNSS ROVER
4.1 Survey Equipment and Accuracy
The field survey is carried out using a DGNSS RTK Rover. The essential components of the rover are: a DGNSS antenna and receiver which receives signals from GPS, GLONASS, Galileo, Gagan satellite constellations and processes the signals to compute position; a data collector / controller (a handheld touch-screen unit running survey software, which displays the real- time position and provides navigation guidance); a communication module which connects to a Continuously Operating Reference Station network over mobile internet, to receive real-time corrections); and a survey pole (typically a 2-metre carbon-fibre pole fitted with a bubble level for precise vertical
160
placement).
Field Procedure and Encroachment Recording
A standard, unaided GPS receiver has a horizontal accuracy of only ± 5 to 10 meters — sufficient for navigation, but not for land-boundary demarcation, which requires centimeter-level precision. The RTK rover, by receiving live differential corrections from a Base Station or CORS network, refines its position accuracy to approximately ± 2 to 3 centimeters. This is the accuracy required for a reliable demarcation of the Reserved Forest boundary and for the unambiguous fixing of the location of any encroachment within it.
4.2 Step-by-Step Field Procedure
Each survey point, whether a notified boundary pillar, a newly identified corner or an encroachment is captured through the following five-step procedure:
(1) Load Coordinates. The corner-point coordinates extracted from the geo- referenced base map prepared at Stage 1 are loaded into the hand-held controller of the rover.
(2) Navigate to Point. The rover guides the surveyor to the exact coordinates through a real-time position display with arrow guidance.
(3) Receive Corrections. On arrival, the rover receives RTK corrections from the Base Station or CORS network and refines accuracy to approximately ± 2 to 3 centimeters.
(4) Mark the Point. Once the displayed position matches the target coordinate within tolerance, the surveyor places a permanent boundary
161
marker at that point or, where a pillar already exists, records its exact coordinate.
(5) Record and Verify. The final coordinate is stored digitally in the controller and an accuracy report is generated for each point. The coordinates are also verified by Revenue Department officials on the ground as per Digital India Land Records Modernization Programme (DILRMP) guidelines.
4.3 Composition of the Survey Team
The survey is conducted by a survey expert recognised for DGPS/DGNSS work in the State, accompanied by officers of the Committee and Forest Department.
4.4 Recording of Encroachments
At every point where an encroachment (a dwelling, cultivation, commercial structure, settlement or other permanent occupation) is found within the notified Reserved Forest boundary, the rover captures the exact coordinates of the corner points of that structure or holding. The coordinate sets are tabulated against the name of the noticee / petitioner to whom the Department has issued a notice under the Assam Forest Regulation, 1891.
5. FINAL MAP PRODUCTION AND INTEGRATION
On completion of the field survey, the captured pillar coordinates and encroachment coordinates are plotted on the geo-referenced base map prepared at Stage 1. Where the Reserved Forest is covered by more than one toposheet, the toposheets are merged (mosaicked) in GIS software to produce
162
a single continuous map at an appropriate scale (typically 1:50,000 for the final map, with larger-scale inset maps where required). The notified boundary is rendered as a prominent line so that it can be clearly distinguished from the underlying toposheet symbology. Notified pillar coordinates are shown as distinctively coloured dots and encroachment points are shown as numbered dots keyed to an annexed schedule giving the name of the noticee / petitioner corresponding to each number.
The result is a single GIS-based decision support map on which (a) the notified boundary of the Reserved Forest, (b) each boundary pillar captured on the ground, and (c) each encroachment identified within the Reserved Forest, are simultaneously visible with real-world coordinates, and can be independently verified by any observer against SoI toposheet features, Google Earth imagery and direct field inspection."
59. By carrying out the aforementioned methodology, the reserved forests in question were surveyed and boundaries were digitized. In the instant batch of writ petitions, there are 4 (four) reserved forests which are: Lutumai Reserved Forest; South Nambor and Doyang Reserved Forest; Jamuna Moudanga Reserved Forest and Borpani Reserved Forest.
60. It is relevant for the purpose of the present analysis to deal with the Notifications issued constituting the above mentioned 4 (four) reserved forests; the survey conducted by the Committee constituted and how the boundaries in respect to the 4 (four) reserved forests were ascertained with geo-coordinates. Each of
163
the 4 (four) reserved forests are dealt with as herein under:
LUTUMAI RESERVED FOREST
61. In terms with Section 17 of the Assam Forest Regulation, 1891, (for short, "the Regulation"), a Notification was issued on 07.08.1928 constituting a reserved forest w.e.f. 01.09.1928 of an area admeasuring 9,216 Acres. In the said Notification, the boundaries of the Reserved Forest so constituted were specifically mentioned. A sketch map was prepared by Sri A.G. Patton identifying the various boundary pillars in terms with the Notification dated 07.08.1928. Subsequent thereto, vide Notification dated 13.10.1965, issued under Section 28 of the Regulation as amended by the Assam Forest (Amendment) Regulation III of 1912, an area of 1,200 Acres out of 9,216 acres was de-reserved vide the said Notification. The area which was de- reserved was identified with specific boundaries. Subsequent thereto, vide another Notification dated 29.04.1972, issued under Section 28 of the Regulation, a further area of 1,204.0598 hectares (approximately 2,976 Acres), were de-reserved for the purpose of settlement with landless people. At this stage, this Court finds it relevant to take note of some of the Annexures enclosed to WP(C) No. 1628/2026, which would show that allotment cards issued in respect to the Lutumai De-reserved Areas. This de-reserved area
164
was also delineated in the said Notification with specific boundaries.
62. The Respondent Authorities while carrying out the survey and digitization of the boundaries of the Lutumai Reserved Forest navigated to each of the boundary pillars identified by the 1928 Notification with the help of the original sketch map prepared by Sri A.G. Patton. Thereafter, the pillar schedules of 1965 and 1972 de-reservation Notifications were taking into consideration using the coordinates extracted from the geo-reference base map. The maps prepared, copies thereof have been enclosed to the Affidavit filed by the Respondents, indicating the boundaries with a purple polyline. It is also seen from one of the maps enclosed wherein the location of the Petitioners in the batch of writ petitions in respect to the Lutumai Reserved Forest was shown with blue dots. The geo-coordinates of the Lutumai Reserved Forest have been mentioned in Annexure-B to the Additional Affidavit filed by the Respondent No. 1 in WP(C) No. 1708/2026 and taking into account the relevance for the purpose of the present dispute, the boundary geo-coordinates of the Lutumai Reserved Forest are reproduced herein under:
| Lutumai RF Boundary Coordinates |
| Point ID |
Latitude |
Longitude |
165
| P1 |
26.060421 |
92.644285 |
| P2 |
26.063552 |
92.651894 |
| P3 |
26.067117 |
92.660013 |
| P4 |
26.069768 |
92.666053 |
| P5 |
26.072917 |
92.673667 |
| P6 |
26.045759 |
92.682941 |
| P7 |
26.043637 |
92.69121 |
| P8 |
26.046743 |
92.692187 |
| P9 |
26.044031 |
92.709322 |
| P10 |
26.022605 |
92.715027 |
| P11 |
26.021231 |
92.690999 |
| P12 |
26.028586 |
92.669824 |
| P13 |
26.043683 |
92.664508 |
| P14 |
26.036033 |
92.643132 |
| P15 |
26.051033 |
92.64654 |
63. WP(C) No.1708/2026; WP(C) No. 1690/2026; WP(C) No. 1694/2026; WP(C) No. 1688/2026; WP(C) No. 1628/2026; WP(C) No. 1618/2026 and WP(C) No. 1649/2026 are writ petitions relating to Lutumai Reserved Forest.
JAMUNA MOUDANGA RESERVED FOREST
166
64. This reserved forest is a consolidated reserved forest formed through a series of Notifications issued by the Chief Commissioner/Governor of Assam in exercise of the powers conferred by Section 17 of the Regulation.
65. The Moudanga Reserved Forest was first notified vide Notification dated 15.05.1917 in respect to an area of 1,105 Acres w.e.f. 01.07.1917. Jamuna Reserved Forest was constituted vide Notification dated 21.09.1915 in respect of an area of 748 Acres w.e.f. 01.11.1915. Vide Notification dated 27.07.1918, an area of land admeasuring 1,440 Acres was added to the Moudanga Reserved Forest w.e.f. 15.09.1918. Vide Notification dated 29.05.1929, an area of 508 Acres was added to the Jamuna Reserved Forest w.e.f. 01.07.1929. On 22.04.1957, in exercise of powers under Section 28 of the Regulation, a Notification was issued whereby an area of 115.0 Acres was de-reserved from the Jamuna Moudanga Reserved Forest to accommodate persons evicted from reserve, and by Notification dated 02.11.1973, a further area of 826.44 Acres was de-reserved for the purpose of Agricultural Farming Co-operation. At present, the Jamuna Moudanga Reserved Forest contains an area of 2,859 Acres.
167
66. The survey which was carried out and the coordinates extracted from the geo-referenced map are inscribed in the final map with a prominent purple line notifying the boundary pillar's coordinates. The houses of the Petitioners in relation to the Jamuna Moudanga Reserved Forest have been inscribed in another map with blue dots for the convenience of this Court. On the basis of captured coordinates, the boundaries of the Jamuna Moudanga Reserved Forest are mentioned at Annexure-H to the Affidavit-in- Opposition filed in WP(C) No. 1616/2026. The geo-coordinates of the Jamuna Moudanga Reserved Forest are mentioned herein under:
Point ID Latitude Longitude
P1 26.136225 92.911505
P2 26.139581 92.931462
P3 26.132538 92.930014
P4 26.125282 92.942118
P5 26.124221 92.954002
P6 26.13271 92.963797
P7 26.129195 92.966218
P8 26.115971 92.96219
P9 26.113663 92.967513
P10 26.111128 92.966787
168
| P11 |
26.109881 |
92.971065 |
| P12 |
26.110169 |
92.974796 |
| P13 |
26.115826 |
92.976294 |
| P14 |
26.114144 |
92.982632 |
| P15 |
26.100584 |
92.976095 |
| P16 |
26.108564 |
92.950256 |
| P17 |
26.123752 |
92.923064 |
| P18 |
26.122159 |
92.919595 |
| P19 |
26.129439 |
92.91341 |
67. WP(C) No. 1616/2026; WP(C) No. 1633/2026; and WP(C) No. 1620/2026 are writ petitions relating to Jamuna Moudanga Reserved Forest.
DOYANG AND NAMBOR SOUTH RESERVED FOREST
68. The Doyang and Nambor South Reserved Forest are 2 (two) contiguous reserved forests situated in the erstwhile Sibsagar District (presently within Golaghat Forest Division) of the State of Assam. On account of the 2 (two) reserved forests adjoining each other and sharing natural boundary features along the Dhansiri
169
River and its tributary system, the Respondent Authorities have carried out a single joint survey and digitization exercise. Be that as it may, the constitution of each of the two reserved forests is dealt with herein under:
Doyang Reserved Forest
69. The Doyang Reserved Forest was constituted as a reserved forest by the Revenue Department vide Notification dated 31.07.1888 issued by the Chief Commissioner of Assam in exercise of powers conferred by Section 19 of the Indian Forest Act, 1878. The said Notification was published and declared lands in the Schedule annexed thereto to be reserved forest w.e.f. 19.04.1888. The said Notification specifically describes the boundary of the Doyang Reserved Forest.
Nambor Reserved Forest
70. Nambor South Reserved Forest was originally constituted vide Notification dated 17.10.1878 issued under Section 34 of the Indian Forest Act, 1878. The extent and boundaries of the Nambor Reserved Forest thereafter have been modified from time to time by a series of additions and partial de-reservations, each issued by the Chief Commissioner or the Governor of Assam in exercise of
170
the powers under the Regulation.
71. On 13.03.1896, under Section 17 of the Regulation, an area of 872.5/6 acres in Barpathar Mauza, Naga Hills was declared to be an addition to the Nambor Reserve w.e.f. 01.04.1896. Vide another Notification dated 06.04.1896 issued under Section 28 of the Regulation, an area of 8.26 Acres in Barpathar Mauza, Naga Hills District was declared to cease to be a reserved forest. Vide another Notification dated 01.11.1926 issued under Section 28 of the Regulation, a portion of the Nambor Reserve in Sibsagar District, Golaghat Subdivision, Barpathar Mauza, admeasuring 2,016 Acres were declared to cease to be reserved forest.
72. A joint field survey of the Doyang Reserved Forest and the Nambor South Reserved Forest was undertaken as a single contiguous exercise across the combined boundary system of the 2 (two) reserved forests for the reason that both the reserved forests are connected and share a natural boundary.
73. In the first phase, the team navigated to each of the identifiable corner points and pillars along the boundaries of the 2 (two) reserved forests, being the points identified from 1888, constituting Notification of the Doyang Reserved Forest, the 1878
171
original constituting Notification of the Nambor Reserved Forest, and the pillar schedules contained in the subsequent additions and de-reservation Notifications in respect to the Nambor Reserved Forest. On the basis thereof, by applying the methodology, the final map of the Doyang and Nambor South Reserved Forest were prepared and the boundary was put with a purple line. The occupations of the Petitioners in those lands within the boundary have been mentioned with yellow dots in another map for the convenience of this Court. The geo-coordinates of the Doyang Reserved Forest and Nambor South Reserved Forest are separately reproduced herein under:
| Doyang RF Boundary Coordinates |
| Point ID |
Latitude |
Longitude |
| P01 |
26.370102 |
93.971503 |
| P02 |
26.368184 |
94.033106 |
| P03 |
26.406219 |
94.065659 |
| P04 |
26.399365 |
94.087851 |
| P05 |
26.382423 |
94.08404 |
| P06 |
26.376027 |
94.091614 |
| P07 |
26.385105 |
94.108163 |
| P08 |
26.398538 |
94.097275 |
| P09 |
26.403066 |
94.116248 |
172
P10 26.360902 94.130665
P11 26.346445 94.1777266
P12 26.335959 94.137784
P13 26.318359 94.121738
P14 26.283674 94.084263
P15 26.252596 94.052202
P16 26.207232 94.033368
P17 26.16771 94.001742
P18 26.242329 93.990539
P19 26.286729 93.980162
P20 26.336345 93.970303
Nambor South RF Boundary Coordinates Point ID Latitude Longitude
P01 26.135791 93.85611
P02 26.146684 93.892101
P03 26.146163 93.947358
P04 26.087788 93.933249
P05 26.036178 93.905955
P06 25.906655 93.964793
P07 25.896554 93.944277
P08 25.882504 93.92417
173
| P09 |
25.93528 |
93.863261 |
| P10 |
25.983917 |
93.83879 |
| P11 |
26.026127 |
93.80448 |
| P12 |
26.110745 |
93.844574 |
74. WP(C) No. 1615/2026 is the writ petition relating to Doyang and Nambor South Reserved Forest.
BORPANI RESERVED FOREST
75. Borpani Reserved Forest was constituted as reserved forest vide Notification dated 20.06.1919 issued by the Chief Commissioner of Assam in exercise of the powers conferred by Section 17 of the Regulation and was published in the Assam Gazette on 25.06.1919.
76. The field survey was conducted by taking into account the boundary pillars mentioned in the 1919 Notification and the original sketch map using the coordinates extracted from the geo- referenced base map. On the basis thereof, final map was prepared, which is delineated by a green line. The Petitioners in the present batch of writ petitions have been identified with blue dots, and the other encroachers in the Borpani Reserved Forest have been identified with green dots. The geo-coordinates of the
174
Borpani Reserved Forest are reproduced herein under:
| Borpani RF Boundary Coordinates |
| Point ID |
Latitude |
Longitude |
| P1 |
26.018107 |
92.5777870 |
| P2 |
26.024930 |
92.591543 |
| P3 |
26.023564 |
92.593941 |
| P4 |
26.020127 |
92.592897 |
| P5 |
26.017569 |
92.598872 |
| P6 |
26.014940 |
92.604958 |
| P7 |
26.028607 |
92.608228 |
| P8 |
26.030569 |
92.614084 |
| P9 |
26.036222 |
92.631253 |
| P10 |
26.037833 |
92.637341 |
| P11 |
26.034028 |
92.640283 |
| P12 |
26.030235 |
92.640855 |
| P13 |
26.027178 |
92.645729 |
| P14 |
26.021525 |
92.645953 |
| P15 |
26.014977 |
92.646832 |
| P16 |
26.014718 |
92.652568 |
| P17 |
26.005212 |
92.654021 |
| P18 |
26.005216 |
92.646558 |
| P19 |
26.003097 |
92.636976 |
175
| P20 |
25.995221 |
92.632540 |
| P21 |
25.989972 |
92.620394 |
| P22 |
25.984113 |
92.611421 |
| P23 |
25.982269 |
92.598311 |
| P24 |
25.978182 |
92.578135 |
| P25 |
25.999940 |
92.586066 |
| P26 |
26.005545 |
92.578519 |
| P27 |
26.007307 |
92.564985 |
| P28 |
26.037237 |
92.599223 |
77. WP(C) No. 1691/2026 is the writ petition relating to Borpani Reserved Forest.
78. On the basis of the above delineated maps and the geo- coordinates obtained, and having found that the Petitioners herein along with other encroachers are residing within the reserved forests, respective notices dated 21.02.2026 were issued to each of the Petitioners in the present batch of writ petitions. The Petitioners submitted their representations on various dates, as have been mentioned while narrating the facts hereinabove. Thereupon, the respective impugned Speaking Orders were passed
176
by considering the documents which have been submitted by the Petitioners, and also providing 15 (fifteen) days' time to the Petitioners to vacate their occupation on the lands falling within the reserved forests.
79. This Court has also taken note of that not only in the maps which are placed before this Court wherein the 4 (four) reserved forests have been delineated as per the geographical coordinates with boundary lines on the basis of geo-coordinates, the Respondent Authorities have also provided before this Court the location of the respective Petitioners within those reserved forests in the maps itself. In addition to that, the Respondents have also placed before this Court the respective occupation of the Petitioners with geo-coordinates to show that their occupation is within the reserved forests.
80. The above therefore shows that the Petitioners in the present batch of writ petitions are residing within the 4 (four) reserved forests. In addition to that, the procedural safeguards mentioned in the Additional Affidavit dated 18.01.2026 filed in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra) which were held by the Supreme Court to be sufficient, have been duly complied with. Under such circumstances, it is the opinion of this Court that the impugned
177
Speaking orders are in consonance with the directions passed by the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra) insofar as the procedural safeguards are concerned.
81. The above, therefore, decides the first point for determination.
SECOND POINT FOR DETERMINATION
82. Having decided the first point for determination in the affirmative, the second point for determination arises as to whether the Petitioners have been able to show any documents/evidence which would entitle the Petitioners to occupy lands within the reserved forests.
83. At the outset, it is relevant to take note of that the Petitioners are neither Forest Dwelling Scheduled Tribes nor come within the ambit of "other traditional forest dwellers" as defined in Section 2(o) of the Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006 (for short, "the Act of 2006"). This aspect was duly admitted during the course of the hearing and recorded in the orders dated 31.03.2026 and 07.04.2026. Apart from that, nothing is produced by the Petitioners to show that they have been vested with rights by any authority under the Act of 2006 to the effect that they fall within the
178
category of "other traditional forest dwellers". Further to the above, the Petitioners have failed to show that their names have been recorded in the Jamabandi maintained by the Forest Department of the Government of Assam.
84. In the backdrop, let this Court take note of the documents/evidence submitted by the Petitioners in the present batch of writ petitions before the Respondent Authorities and the pleas taken by the Petitioners. The pleas so taken can be segregated into three groups. They are:
(a) One set of Writ Petitioners claim right on the basis of certain public documents being issued to them and the area where they are occupying falling within the Notified Panchayats. The public documents referred by the Petitioners are Voter IDs, Aadhar Cards, Electoral Rolls, Ration Cards, Electricity connection, etc. In addition to that, the Petitioners have claimed rights on the basis of certain certificates issued by the concerned Panchayat Authorities. This set of Petitioners are hereinafter referred to as "the First Group".
(b) The second set of Petitioners claim rights on the basis
179
of the Taungya system which was prevalent on the basis of the Rules for establishment and control of Forest Villages. It is relevant to mention that these Rules were notified on 06.12.1930 and made in exercise of power under Sections 72(e), 74 and 75 of the Regulation. The Petitioners in this group claim that they are either Taungyas or have derived titles from Taungyas who were issued allotments. The documents for derivative title are based upon the Agreement to Sale or Un-registered Sale Deeds. This group of the Petitioners is hereinafter referred to as "the Second Group".
(c) The third group of Petitioners claim that the lands under their occupation are revenue lands inasmuch as the revenue authorities have issued Annual Patta or accepted Touzi Mouza (i.e. penalty for occupation of Government lands). This group, this Court would refer to as "the Third Group".
85. For the purpose of deciding the rights and claims of each of the 3 (three) groups referred to herein above, this Court finds it pertinent to take note of the statutory provisions holding the field. It is relevant to observe that the Doyang and South Nambor
180
Reserved Forest were initially constituted under the Indian Forest Act, 1878 (for short, "the Act of 1878") and subsequently various Notifications have been issued under the Regulation. Insofar as the other 3 (three) reserved forests, they were constituted under the provisions of the Regulation. Accordingly, this Court finds it relevant to take note of some of the provisions of both the Act of 1878 as well as the Regulation.
INDIAN FOREST ACT, 1878
86. The Act of 1878 was enacted empowering the local Government to constitute Reserved Forests. Chapter-II of the Act of 1878 comprises of various Sections i.e., Section 3 to Section 26.
87. Section 3 of the Act of 1878 empowered the local Government to constitute any forest-land or waste-land which is the property of the Government or over which the Government has proprietary rights, or to the whole or any part of the forest-produce of which the Government is entitled, as a reserved forest in the manner stipulated in the subsequent provisions of the Act of 1878.
88. Sections 4 and 5 of the Act of 1878 are relevant and as such, the same are reproduced herein under:
181
"4. Notification by Local Government- Whenever it is proposed to constitute any land a reserved forest, the Local Government may publish. a notification in the local official Gazette-
(a) declaring that it is proposed to constitute such land a reserved forest;
(b) specifying the limits of such forest; and
(c) appointing an officer (hereinafter called "the Forest-Settlement-officer") to inquire into and determine the existence, nature and extent of any rights alleged to exist in favour of any person in or over any land comprised within such limits, or in or over any forest-produce, and to deal with the same as provided in this chapter.
Explanation 1.-For the purpose of clause (b) of this section, it shall be sufficient to describe the limits of the forest by roads, rivers, ridges or other well known or readily intelligible boundaries.
The officer appointed under clause (c) of this section shall ordinarily be a person not holding any forest-office except that of Forest-Settlement-officer. Nothing in this section shall prevent the Local Government from appointing any number of officers not exceeding three, not more than one of whom shall be a person holding any forest-office except as aforesaid, to perform the duties of a Forest-Settlement officer under this Act."
5. Bar of accrual of forest-rights- During the interval between the publication of such notification and the date fixed by the notification under section nineteen, no right shall be acquired in or over the land comprised in such notification, except by succession or under a grant or contract in writing made or entered into by or on
182
behalf of Government or some person in whom such right was vested when the former notification was issued; and no fresh clearings for cultivation or for any other purpose shall be made in such land."
89. The above quoted Section 5 of the Act of 1878 would show that during the interval between the publication of such Notification under Section 4 and the date fixed by the Notification under Section 19, no right shall be acquired in or over the land comprised in such Notification, except by succession or under a grant or contract in writing made or entered into by or on behalf of the Government or some person in whom such right was vested when the Notification under Section 19 was issued. Further to that, fresh clearings for cultivation or for any other purpose were prohibited.
90. Now let this Court take note of Section 9 of the Act of 1878. The said Section is quoted herein below:
"9.Extinction of rights- Rights in respect of which no claim has been preferred under section six, and of the existence of which no knowledge has been acquired by enquiry under section seven, shall be extinguished, unless before the notification under section nineteen is published the person claiming them satisfies the Forest-Settlement-officer that he had sufficient cause for not preferring such claim within the period fixed under section six."
91. A perusal of the above-quoted Section shows that once a
183
Notification is published under Section 19, any right or claim over the area notified shall stand extinguished.
92. Section 19 of the Act of 1878 is relevant inasmuch as the Doyang Reserved Forest was constituted in terms with the said provision. Section 19 of the Act of 1878 reads as under:
"19.Notification declaring forest reserved: When the following events have occurred (namely),-
(a) the period fixed under section six for preferring claims has elapsed, and all claims (if any) made within such period have been disposed of by the Forest-Settlement-officer; and
(b) if such claims have been made, and the period limited by section sixteen for appealing from the orders passed on such claims has elapsed, and all appeals (if any) presented within such period have been disposed of by the appellate officer or Court; and
(c) all lands (if any) to be included in the prоposed forest, which the Forest- Settlement-officer has, under section ten, elected to acquire under the Land Acquisition Act, 1870, have become vested in the Government under section sixteen of that Act,
the Local Government may publish a notification in the local official Gazette, specifying definitely, according to boundary-marks erected or otherwise, the limits of the forest which it is intended to reserve, and declaring the same to be reserved from a date fixed by such notification.
184
From the date so fixed, such forest shall be deemed to be a reserved forest."
93. A perusal of the above quoted provision stipulates that once the Notification is published specifying definitely, according to boundary marks erected or otherwise, the limits of the forest which is intended to be reserved, shall be deemed to be a reserved forest.
94. Section 22 of the Act of 1878 bars acquisition of rights except provided. The said Section being relevant is reproduced herein under:
"22. No right acquired over reserved forest, except as here provided- No right of any description shall be acquired in or over a reserved forest, except by succession or under a grant or contract in writing made by or on behalf of the Government or of some person in whom as here such right was vested when the notification under section nineteen was issued."
95. A perusal of the above quoted provision makes it very clear that no right of any description shall be acquired in or over a reserved forest except by succession or under a grant or contract in writing made by or on behalf of the Government or of some person in whom such right was vested when the Notification under Section 19 was issued.
185
96. Section 23 of the Act of 1878 further stipulates that a right vested in terms with Section 14(c) cannot be alienated by way of grant, sale, lease, mortgage, or otherwise without the sanction of the local Government.
97. Section 34 of the Act of 1878 is relevant inasmuch as the South Nambor Reserved Forest was constituted under the said provision. The said provision is quoted herein below:
"34.Forests under conservancy administration when this Act come into force- Within twelve months from the date on which this Act comes into force in the territories administered by any Local Government, such Government shall, after consideration of the rights of the Government and private persons in all forest-lands or waste-lands then under its executive control for purposes of forest-conservancy, determine which of such lands (if any) can, according to justice, equity and good conscience, be classed as reserved forests or protected forests under this Act, and declare, by notification in the local official Gazette, any lands so classed to be reserved or protected forests, as the case may be:
Provided that such declaration shall not affect any rights of the Government or private persons to or over any land or forest-produce in any such forest, which have, previous to the date of such declaration, been enquired into, settled and recorded in a manner which the Local Government thinks sufficient:
Provided also that if any such rights have not on such date been so enquired into, settled and recorded, the Local Government shall direct that the same shall be enquired into, settled and recorded in the manner provided by this Act
186
for reserved or protected forests, as the case may be; and until such enquiry, settlement and record have been com- pleted, no such declaration shall abridge or affect such rights."
98. A perusal of the above quoted provision would show that the said provision empowered the local Government to declare vide Notification in the local Official Gazette any land so classed to be reserved or protected forest, as the case may be.
ASSAM FOREST REGULATION, 1891
99. Let this Court now take into consideration the relevant provisions of the Regulation. Chapter-II of the Regulation is with the heading "ReservedForest". Section 4 to Section 28 of the Regulation is contained in the same Chapter.
100. Section 4 of the Regulation empowers the State Government (the Provincial Government then) to constitute any land at the disposal of the Government, as a reserved forest. Section 5 of the Regulation provides for issuance of Notification informing all concerned the proposal of the Government to constitute a Reserved Forest.
101. Section 6 of the Regulation stipulates that once the Notification is issued under Section 5 of the Regulation, the Forest
187
Settlement Officer shall issue a proclamation in the language of the country of the contents of the Notification issued under Section 5 of the Regulation. Section 7 of the Regulation specifically bars accrual of rights over the area which is mentioned in the proclamation from the date of the proclamation to the date of the Notification issued under Section 17 of the Regulation. Section 7 being relevant is reproduced herein below:
"7.Bar of accrual of forest rights after proclamation-
(1) During the interval between the publication of such proclamation and t he date fixed by the notification declaring the Forest to be reserved as hereinafter provided, no right shall be acquired in or over the land comprised in such notification except by succession or under a grant or contract in writing made or entered in to, by or on behalf of, the Government or some person in whom such right or power to create such right was vested when the proclamation was published; and on such land no new house shall be built or plantation formed, no fresh clearing for cultivation or for any other purpose of trade or manufacture expect as hereinafter provided.
(2) Nothing in this section shall be deemed prohibit any act done with the permission in writing of the Forest Settlement Officer, or any clearing lawfully made for jhum cultivation by persons; in the habit of practicing; such cultivation on such land."
102. It is notable that there exists a stark difference between
188
Section 5 of the Act of 1878 and Section 7 of the Regulation inasmuch as in terms with Section 7 of the Regulation, things done with the permission of the Forest Settlement Officer or any clearings lawfully made for jhum cultivation by persons in the habit of practicing such cultivation on such land is not barred. This aspect is relevant taking into consideration the submissions made by the learned Additional Advocate General as regards the concept of Taungyas. Apart from that, it is also notable to take note of Section 10(4) of the Regulation which categorically stipulates that practice of jhum cultivation is a privilege and not a right and is subject to control, restriction and abolition by the State Government.
103. Section 17 of the Regulation stipulates about the Notification to be issued, after carrying out the exercise as required under Sections 8 to 14 of the Regulation. It is also seen that upon issuance of the Notification under Section 17 of the Regulation, such forest shall be deemed to be a reserved forest. Section 17 being relevant is reproduced herein under:
"17. Notification declaring Forest reserve.
(1) When the following events have occurred, namely:
189
(a) the period fixed under Section 6 for preferring claims has elapsed and all claims, if any made within such period has been disposed of by the Forest Settlement Officer; and
(b) if such claims have been made, the period fixed by Section 15 for appealing from the order passed on such claims has elapsed, and all appeals, if any, presented within such period have been disposed of by the appellate Officer; and
(c) all lands, if any, to be included in the proposed reserved forest which the Forest Settlement Officer has under Section 11, elected to acquire under the Land Acquisition Act, 1870, have become vested in the Government under Land Acquisition act, 1870, have become vested in the Government under Land Acquisition Act, 1870 (X of 1870);
the State Government may publish a notification in the official Gazette, specifying the limits of the forest which it is intended to reserve, and declaring the same to be reserved from a date fixed by such notification.
(2) From the date so fixed such forest shall be deemed to be reserved Forest."
104. Section 18 of the Regulation clearly stipulates what rights shall extinguish upon publication of the Notification under Section 17 of the Regulation. Section 18 of the Regulation is reproduced herein under:
"18. Extinction of right not claimed. Right in respect of which no claim has been preferred under Section 6 and
190
of the existence of which no knowledge has been acquired by inquiry under S. 8 shall thereupon extinguish, unless before the publication of such notification, the person claiming them has satisfied the Forest Settlement Officer that has had sufficient cause for not preferring such claim within the period fixed under Section 6."
105. Sections 21 and 22 of the Regulation are of vital importance for the purpose of the present proceedings inasmuch as Section 21 of the Regulation categorically mentions about the bar to acquisition of any rights. Section 22 of the Regulation bars any rights saved under Sections 12 and 13 of the Regulation from being alienated without the previous sanction of the State Government. Section 21 and 22 of the Regulation being relevant are reproduced herein below:
"21. Acquisition of right over reserved Forests. No right of any description shall be acquired in or over a reserved forest, except by succession or under grant or contract in writing made by, or with the previous sanction of the State Government or some person on whom such right, or the power to create such right, vested when the notification under Section 17 was published.
22. Alienation of right in reserved forests.
(1) Notwithstanding anything herein contained no right contained under Section 13 shall be alienated by way of grant, sale, lease, and
191
mortgage or otherwise without the previous sanction of the State Government:
Provided that, when any such right is continued for the beneficial enjoyment of any land or building, it may be sold or otherwise alienated with such sanction.
(2) The benefit of any right continued under Section 13 shall not be leased, sold or bartered, except to the extent by the order record under that section."
106. Section 24 of the Regulation imposes penalty for trespass or damage to the reserved forest.
107. Section 25 of the Regulation prohibits certain acts in reserved forest, and imposes punishment with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than 1 year and may extend to 3 years or with fine which may extend to Rs. 5,000/-, or with both. The said Section prohibits clearing or breaking up of land for cultivation or any other purpose.
108. Section 26 of the Regulation, however, provides an exception to Section 24 and Section 25 in respect to practice of jhum cultivation permitted under Section 10; the exercise of rights in accordance with the Rules, if any, made by the State Government under Section 13 of any right continued under the Section; the
192
exercise of any right created by grant or contract in the manner described in Section 21 or any act done with the permission in writing of the forest officials specifically empowered to grant such permission. Section 26 of the Regulation is reproduced herein under:
"26.Acts excepted from Sections. 24 and 25. Nothing in Section 24 or Section 25 shall be deemed to prohibit -
(a) any practices of jhum cultivation permitted under Secttion 10, or
(b) the exercise in accordance with the rules, if any made by the State Government under Section 13 of any right; continued under that section, or
(c) the exercise of any right created by grant or contract in manner described in Section 21, or
(d) any act done with the permission in writing of Forest official specially empowered to grant such permission."
109. The analysis of the above provisions of Chapter-II of the Regulation makes it clear that no right can be conferred or exercised in Reserved Forest, unless the rights existing prior to the Notification issued under Section 17 of the Regulation were saved under Sections 12 and 13 of the Regulation. In addition to that, no
193
right of any description can be acquired in or over a reserved forest in terms with Section 21 of the Regulation except by succession or under grant or contract in writing made by, or with the previous sanction of the State Government. The exceptions contained in Section 26 of the Regulation are only for the purpose of avoiding the penal consequences mentioned in Sections 24 and 25 of the Regulation. Under such circumstances, it is the opinion of this Court that there can be no rights to occupy and possess lands within the Reserved Forest except as provided and saved under Sections 12 and 13 and permitted in terms with Section 21 of the Regulation.
110. Chapter-III of the Regulation is in respect to "Village Forests".
Section 29 of the Regulation is relevant and the same is reproduced herein under:
"29. Constitution of village forests.
(1) The State Government may, by notification in the official gazette, constitute any land at the disposal of the Government a village forest for the benefit of any village community or group of village forest for the benefit of any village community or group of village communities and may, in like manner, vary or cancel any such notification.
(2) Every such notification shall specify the limits of such village forest."
194
111. A perusal of the above quoted Section would show that the State Government, may by Notification in the Official Gazette constitute any land at the disposal of the Government, a village forest for benefit of any village community or group of village forests for the benefit of any village community or a group of village communities, and may in like manner vary or cancel any such Notification. It is also the requirement of law that such Notification shall specify the limits of such village forests. It is relevant to observe that neither the Petitioners nor the State Authorities placed before this Court any Notification issued by the State Government constituting a village forest under Section 29 of the Regulation. It is also of importance to note that a perusal of Section 29 of the Regulation mentions about constitution of Village Forest in lands at the disposal of the Government but do not specify that such village Forests can be within the Reserved Forests. This aspect is of importance in view of Section 2 of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 to which this Court would deal at a subsequent stage of the present judgment.
112. Section 30 of the Regulation empowers the State Government to make Rules for Village Forests. The said Section, also being relevant, is reproduced herein under:
195
"30. Powers to make rules for village forests.
(1) The State Government may make rules for regulating the management of village forest prescribing the condition under which the community or group of communities for the benefit of which any such forest is constituted may be provided with forest produce or with pasture, and their duties in respect of the protection and improvement of such forest.
(2) The State Government may, by such rules, declare any or the provisions of Chapter II of this Regulation to be applicable to village forests."
113. Section 31 of the Regulation is very relevant, and the same is reproduced herein under:
"31. Inquiry into and settlement of rights. All claims to any rights other than the rights of village community or group of village communities for the benefit of which such village Forest is constituted shall be inquired in to recorded and provided for in the manner prescribed by Chapter II of this Regulation."
114. A perusal of the above Section would show that all claims to any rights other than the right of village community or group of village communities for the benefit of which such village forest is constituted shall be enquired into, recorded and provided for in the manner prescribed by Chapter-II of the Regulation.
196
115. The analysis of the various provisions of the Act of 1878 and the Regulation insofar as it relates to Reserved Forests, it is abundantly clear that no right of any description could be acquired or created unless saved under Sections 12 and 13 and permitted under Section 21 of the Regulation. Likewise rights must be saved and permitted under Section 18 of the Act of 1878, to occupy and possess the lands within the Reserved Forests. At the cost of repetition, acts permitted under Section 26 of the Regulation cannot be said to confer rights to occupy and possess lands within the reserved forest. The acts permitted under Section 26 of the Regulation are only culled out exception to the penalty to be imposed otherwise in terms with Sections 24 and 25 of the Regulation.
116. Under such circumstances, Voter IDs, Electoral Rolls, Aadhaar Cards, Electricity Connections, Ration Cards, etc. as well as Certificates issued by the Panchayat Authorities though may show that the Petitioners are residents of the lands under their occupation but under no circumstancescan be a claim of any right to remain in possession of lands within the reserved forests.
117. At this stage, this Court also finds it relevant to take note of another stand taken by the Petitioners that the lands under their
197
occupation are lands falling within panchayats and as such, it cannot be said that the lands are within the reserved forest. The said contention of the Petitioners is totally misconceived. In this regard, it is relevant to observe that Forest Dwelling Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers have all along been residents within the forests since time immemorial. Though the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 was enacted with a purpose to conserve forests, but forests cannot be conserved by a handful of forest employees alone without the active participation of the real stakeholders i.e., the Forest Dwelling Scheduled Tribes or the Other Traditional Forest Dwellers. It may be relevant also to mention that these Forest Dwelling Scheduled Tribes or the Other Traditional Forest Dwellers protect the forests as forest is their sole source of sustenance.
118. The amendments carried out by the 73rdConstitutional Amendment Act, 1992, established the third tier of governance in India by institutionalizing local Self-Government. The said amendment to the Constitution empowered Rural Panchayat Raj Institutions.
119. The States on the basis of insertion of Part IX to the Constitution, i.e., Article 243 to Article 243O and the Eleventh
198
Schedule to the Constitution, enacted respective Legislations and in the State of Assam the Assam Panchayat Act, 1994. It is of importance to take note of the Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act (PESA), 1996 whereby the Panchayat Raj Institutions were extended to the areas coming within the ambit of the Fifth Schedule to the Constitution which are predominately areas under the Tribal population.
120. Therefore, in order that the Forest Dwelling Scheduled Tribes as well as Other Traditional Forest Dwellers can also be a part of local Self-Governance, the Notification dated 15.10.2024 was issued extending the Assam Panchayat Act, 1994 to these areas also. This Notification was issued in exercise of powers conferred under Section 5 of the Assam Panchayat Act, 1994. By this Notification, lands falling within the reserved forests cannot be de- reserved or there can be any change to the character and status of the Reserved Forests in question. The reason being that Section 2 of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 prohibits, except with the prior approval of the Central Government, the de-reservation of any reserved forest or any part thereof, pursuant to any law made by the State. Therefore, the said Notification has no relevance to the present batch of writ petitions as no claim can be made based on the said Notification.
199
121. The issuance of any Notification under Section 5 of the Assam Panchayat Act, 1994 therefore would not aid the Petitioners to claim that the lands under their occupation are outside the reserved forests.
122. The above analysis would be sufficient in the opinion of this Court to conclude that the Petitioners in the first group have not been able to place any material/evidence to show that they had any right or authority to occupy lands within the Reserved Forest in question.
123. Let this Court now analyze the claim of the second group of Writ Petitioners who claim rights based on the Taungya system or derivative rights from the Taungya settlement holders. The learned Additional Advocate General had submitted that the Taungya system is understood in the Forest Department as a system of plantation introduced during the British era for jhumming communities and local inhabitants who traditionally practiced slash- and-burn agriculture.
124. This Court for the purpose of understanding the claim of rights under the Taungya system finds it relevant to again relate back to the provisions of the Regulation. The Regulation insofar as
200
the Reserved Forest is concerned categorically mentions what rights a person acquired upon a Notification issued constituting a reserved forest. Chapter-II of the Regulation only saves those rights as stipulated in Sections 12 and 13 of the Regulation and permitted rights as mentioned in Section 21 of the Regulation. These rights also cannot be alienated except with the previous sanction of the State Government as is the stipulation of Section
22.
125. This Court further finds it relevant to take note of Sections 10 and 26 of the Regulation. The above provisions clearly show that there is no conferment of any right to occupy and reside over the reserved forest. Section 10 of the Regulation only permits jhumming cultivation as a privilege and not a right. Section 26 of the Regulation as already stated above only stipulates that the acts mentioned therein would not be an offence coming within the ambit of Section 24 and Section 25 of the Regulation. It is the opinion of this Court that a provision providing an exception to an offence, cannot be said to confer a right.
126. The above analysis would therefore show that no right within the reserved forest can be created without the previous sanction of the State Government since a grant or contract in writing by any
201
authority without the sanction of the State Government would be nonest in the eyes of law.
127. Let this Court now analyze the rights conferred under the Taungya system. The word "Taungya" is of Burmese origin. It means cultivation in the hills. "Taung" means hill and "Ya" means cultivation. The Taungya system is an agro forestry arrangement during the British era. The system allowed landless or poor cultivators to grow crops on forest lands during the early years of plantation establishment, in exchange for tending young forest trees planted alongside. Once the tree canopy closes (usually 3-5 years), these cultivators move to a new plot of land within the forest and the cycle repeats. There is no right of ownership or even tenancy created by way of the Taungya system. It permits temporary settlement for the purpose of carrying out the activities as permitted and thereupon they are asked to proceed to new plots of lands. Not adhering to such directions empowers the forest officials to evict these Taungya settlers.
128. At this stage, if this Court takes note of the Statements and Objects of the Act of 2006, it would also show that no rights at any point of time were created on the forest lands since first steps were taken by the British to regulate forest in India i.e., the Indian
202
Forest Act, 1865. A further perusal of the Statements and Objects of the said Act of 2006 would show that for the first time, the Legislature recognized the historical injustice done to the Forest Dwelling Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers for not conferring any rights upon the forests which was the basis of their sustenance. It was only by the Act of 2006 that rights were conferred for the first time upon the Forest Dwelling Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers by Section 4 of the said Act of 2006. It is the opinion of this Court that unless and until the Petitioners come within the ambit of Other Traditional Forest Dwellers, no rights of the Petitioners can be recognized over the lands under their occupation in the reserved forest.
129. In the previous segments of the instant judgement, this Court duly observed that the Petitioners do not come within the purview of the Act of 2006 and as such merely claiming rights under the Taungya system would not confer any right to reside within the reserved forest.
Before proceeding to the next group, this Court finds it relevant to clarify that a person claiming rights under a Taungya system and if able to prove that the person would come within the ambit of Forest Dwelling Scheduled Tribes or Other Traditional Forest
203
Dwellers would have rights under Section 4 of the Act of 2006. Further to that, if their names are recorded in the Jamabandi maintained by the Forest Department they shall have rights, however subject to Section 2 of the Act of 1980.
130. The third group claims rights on the basis of Annual Patta being issued and further payment of land revenue to the revenue authorities of the State. It is therefore the claim of this set of Writ Petitioners that they are in occupation of revenue lands and not of reserved forests.
131. This Court while deciding the first point for determination, dealt with the way the four reserved forests in question were surveyed and the boundaries digitized. This Court also took note of the methodology employed by the Respondent Authorities. Nothing could be placed by the Petitioners to show that there was any deficiency in the methodology employed. The learned counsels for the Petitioners though made submissions that while employing the methodology, the Respondents have not consulted with the original map made at the time of constitution of the reserved forest, but the said submission do not appear to be sound, rather an attempt to buy time. This Court opines so as it is apparent from the records that the Respondent Authorities in the Forest Department along
204
with the members of the Committee constituted vide Notification dated 17.02.2026 had carried out the verification. This verification was carried out by not only taking into consideration the various boundaries specifically described in the Notifications but also taking into account the original map.
132. In that view of the matter, the geo-coordinates of the boundaries of the four reserved forests which have been quoted while deciding the first point for determination are construed as the geo-coordinates of the four reserved forests which are the subject reserved forests of the present proceedings.
133. In the backdrop of the above, let this Court take note of whether the Revenue Authorities can confer any right over the land, if inside a Reserved Forest or for that matter payment of land revenue by the Petitioners would confer any right to the Revenue Authorities or even to the Petitioners in respect to land falling within a reserved forest. The answer to the same is available at Section 4 of the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, 1886 which is reproduced herein under:
"4. This Chapter shall apply to all and except the following:—
(a) Land included in any forest constituted a reserved forest under the law for
205
the time being in force:
(b) Any land which the State Government may, by notification exempt from the operation of this Chapter."
134. From the above, it would show that the Revenue Authorities have no authority to confer right over lands falling within the reserved forests. The logical analogy therefore would also be that payment received by the Revenue Authorities over the land within the reserved forest would not confer any right to the Revenue Authorities to claim the land as revenue land and similarly no right can be claimed by the Petitioners having paid the land revenue upon land falling within reserved forests.
135. Under such circumstances, it is the opinion of this Court that if the land under the occupation of the Petitioners falls within the geo-coordinates of the reserved forests, the Petitioners have no rights over such lands to remain in occupation.
136. It is therefore the opinion of this Court that the Petitioners in the present batch of writ petitions have not been able to make out a case to justify their occupation of lands within the reserved forests. Accordingly, it is therefore the opinion of this Court that the impugned Speaking Orders qua each of the Petitioners were
206
passed by taking into consideration relevant factors and as such do not call for any interference.
137. The above, therefore, decides the second point for determination.
THIRD POINT FOR DETERMINATION
138. This Court in the foregoing paragraphs of the instant judgment had arrived at an opinion that the procedural formalities as per the mandate of Abdul Khalek (supra) have been duly complied with by the Respondent Authorities. This Court also held that the impugned Speaking Orders which have been assailed in the present batch of writ petitions do not call for any interference on the ground that the Petitioners herein have not been able to substantiate any right to reside over the land falling within the 4 (four) reserved forests which are the subject reserved forests.
139. The third point for determination, however, raises a tricky question relating to problems to be faced by the Petitioners, if they are evicted after residing within the reserved forests for years and decades and on the other hand the essential requirement for conservation of forests.
207
140. The learned counsels appearing on behalf of the Petitioners have strenuously argued with compassion as regards the plight of the Petitioners who after residing in the lands under their occupation, by constructing dwelling houses would be rendered homeless. Submissions were made that these Petitioners belong to the vulnerable section of society. In that regard, references were made to various communications issued by the State Government as well as the Union of India as regards rehabilitation to those persons who have been residing in the reserved forest prior to 1980. In that regard, specific reference was also made to Clause 4.3.1.1 of the Assam Forest Policy, 2004. The learned counsels appearing on behalf of the State, however, submitted that conservation of forests is of paramount importance and the Petitioners do not deserve any sympathy as the Petitioners apart from being trespassers to reserved forest lands also knew their fate when they trespassed into the reserved forest lands.
141. For deciding the aforesaid issue so raised, this Court finds it very relevant to take note of the settled principles which should guide this Court while interpreting laws relating to forests.The considerations are as follows:
(A) Article 48A, which forms a part of Part-IV of the Constitution of
208
India containing the Directive Principles of State Policy, imposes an obligation upon the State to protect and improve the environment and to safeguard the forests.
(B) Clause (g) of Article 51A of the Constitution of India, imposes a fundamental duty upon every citizen to protect and preserve the natural environment, including forests, rivers, lakes, and wild life, etc.
(C) Article 21 of the Constitution, which confers a fundamental right on the individuals to live in pollution-free environment. Forests are, in a sense, lungs which generate oxygen for the survival of human beings. Our forests play a very important role in our ecosystem to prevent pollution. The presence of the forests are necessary for enabling the citizens to enjoy their right to life in a pollution-free environment, which is a facet of Article 21 of the Constitution.
(D) Article 14 of the Constitution provides the Right to Equality. Forest plays a pivotal role in controlling the pollution which significantly affects the underprivileged on account of depletion of forests. His Lordship M.M. Sundresh, J. in the case of Stateof Telangana Vs. Mohd. Abdul Qasim (Died) per Legal Representatives
reported in (2024) 6 SCC 461 have spellbindingly explained the
209
inter play between Article 14 and Article 21 of the Constitution in relation to protection of forests. Paragraph Nos. 44, 45, 46 and 47 being relevant are reproduced herein below:
"44. The word "environment" shall not be understood from a narrow perspective. Albert Einstein once observed "environment is everything that is not me". In our considered view, the environment would include both animate and inanimate. One cannot segregate these two segments, which are broadly differentiated only for the ease of human understanding.
Why we need forests?
"Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature, unaware that this Nature he's destroying is this God he's worshiping."
Hubert Reeves
Canadian Astrophysicist
45. Human beings indulge themselves in selective amnesia when it comes to fathom the significance of forests. It is the forests which give life to the Earth by replacing carbon dioxide with oxygen, thereby providing a hospitable environment for the steady growth of diverse life forms. It is the spirit of the forest that moves the Earth. History shall not be understood from the jaundiced eyes of humans but through the prism of the environment, the forest in particular.
46. Forests not only provide for and facilitate the sustenance of life, but they also continue to protect and foster it. They continue to tackle the ever-increasing carbon dioxide emissions produced by humans in the name of development, while striving to sustain all species. Despite the unblemished, selfless and motherly service rendered by forests, man in his folly continues with their destruction, unmindful of the fact that he is inadvertently destroying himself.
47. Consequent to the advent of agriculture, man has destroyed a significant
210
portion of forests at his own peril. Forests serve the Earth in a myriad of ways ranging from regulating carbon emissions, aiding in soil conservation and regulating the water cycle. Water being a life source, its availability for all life forms is heavily dependent upon the aquifers created by forests. Forests also play a pivotal role in controlling pollution, which significantly affects the underprivileged, violating their right to equality under Article 14 of the Constitution of India. It is the vulnerable sections of the society who would be most affected by the depletion of forests, considering the fact that the more affluent sections of society have better access to resources as compared to them. Therefore, the protection of forests is in the interest of mankind, even assuming that the other factors can be ignored."
(E) Public trust doctrine is a part of our jurisprudence. Under the said doctrine, the State is a trustee of the natural resources such as seashore, running waters, forests, etc. The public at large is the beneficiary of these natural resources. The State being a trustee of the natural resources is under a legal duty to protect these natural resources. The public trust doctrine is a tool for exerting long- established public rights over short-term public rights and private gains.
(F) Another principle of importance is the precautionary principle, which has been accepted as a part of the law of our country. A conjoint reading of Articles 21, 48A, and 51 A(g) of the Constitution would show that the State is under a mandate to protect and improve the environment and safeguard the forests.
211
The precautionary principle requires the Government to anticipate, prevent, and remedy or eradicate the causes of environmental degradation, including acting sternly against the violators.
(G) The principles of sustainable development are another facet which is required while interpreting and applying the law relating to environment. In the case of Rajeev Suri Vs. Delhi Development Authority reported in (2022) 11 SCC 1, the Supreme Court explained the expression "sustainable development" as a development to be sustainable, with ideas of preservation of natural environment for present and future generations. It stipulates controlled development. The primary requirement underlying this principle is to ensure that every development work is sustainable and this requirement of sustainability demands that the first attempt of every agency enforcing environmental Rule of law in the country ought to be, to alleviate environmental concerns by proper mitigating measures. The Supreme Court observed that while one is entitled to a developed society, they are equally entitled to an environmentally secure society.
(H) The concept of environmental Rule of law is another facet which is required to be taken note of. In the case of Citizens for Green Doon& Others Vs. Union of India & Others reported in
212
(2023) 17 SCC 711, the Supreme Court dealt with this concept and observed that the principles of sustainable development may create differing and arbitrary metrics depending on the nature of individual projects. The Supreme Court advocated and accepted the need to apply and adopt the standard of environmental Rule of law. The Supreme Court observed in the said judgment that environmental Rule of law integrates the critical environmental needs with the essential elements of Rule of law and provides the basis for reforming environmental governance. It prioritizes environmental sustainability by connecting it with fundamental rights and obligations. It implicitly reflects universal moral values and ethical norms of behavior, and it provides a foundation for environmental rights and obligations. The Supreme Court observed in clear and categorical terms that without the environmental Rule of law and the enforcement of legal rights and obligations, environmental governance may be arbitrary, i.e., discretionary, subjective, and unpredictable.
The above considerations, in the opinion of this Court tilt the balance in favour of the environment vis-à-vis, the private rights of the Petitioners.
142. At this stage, this Court finds it relevant to take note of the
213
interplay between the Regulation and the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 inasmuch as the said aspect would throw light on the permissibility in allowing the Petitioners to reside inside the reserved forests.
143. A combined reading of the aforesaid two statutory enactments would show that the concept of forest in the Regulation is different from the concept of forest under the Act of 1980. An analysis of the provisions of both the enactments would show that their spheres of operations are not the same, though there may be some overlap. The Regulation deals with Reserved Forests (Chapter-II), Village Forests, (Chapter -III) and Protected Forests (Chapter-IV). Chapter-IVA of the Regulation contains provisions which apply to forests which are not vested in the State Government. The forests referred to in Chapters III and IV of the Regulation are categories of forests on lands vested in the State.
144. A perusal of Chapter-II of the Regulation would show that there is an elaborate procedure for declaring any land vested in the State Government as a reserved forest. Only upon following the procedure laid down in Chapter-II of the Regulation, the land vests in the State Government, which can be declared as a reserved forest. It would also be seen from a perusal of Section 17 of the
214
Regulation that once a Notification has been issued in the Official Gazette declaring a particular land as a reserved forest, prohibitions contained in Sections 24 and 25 of the Regulation would apply. A perusal of Section 21 of the Regulation would show that there is a bar of acquisition of any right in or over a reserved forest except by succession or under grant or contract in writing made by or with the previous sanction of the State Government or some persons on whom such right or power to create such right vested when the Notification under Section 17 of the Regulation was published. Section 22 of the Regulation further bars any alienation without the previous sanction of the State Government.
145. Chapter-III of the Regulation shows that the State Government is empowered under Section 29 of the Regulation to constitute any land at the disposal of the Government as a village forest for the benefit of any village community or group of village communities. It is of relevance to mention that Section 29 of the Regulation do not state that a reserved forest can be notified as a village forest.
146. In the backdrop of the above, let this Court now deal with the Act of 1980. The said Act of 1980 is a complementary enactment dealing with matters concerning conservation of forests. A perusal
215
of the Statements of Objects and Reasons of the Act of 1980 would show that deforestation was causing ecological imbalance and leading to environmental deterioration. The Statements of Objects and Reasons acknowledge widespread concern due to deforestation taking place on a large scale in the country.
147. In the case of Narinder Singh & Others Vs. Divesh Bhutani & Others reported in (2023) 17 SCC 779, the Supreme Court dealt with the reasons for enactment of the Act of 1980 and also explained the scope of Section 2 of the Act of 1980. Paragraph Nos. 39, 41, 42, 43 & 44 being relevant are reproduced herein under:
"39. It must be borne in mind that the 1927 Forest Act is a pre-Constitution legislation. The said legislation is confined to only three categories of forests. The 1980 Forest Act has not repealed the 1927 Forest Act. In a sense, the 1980 Forest Act supplements the provisions of the 1927 Forest Act. During the last four decades, there has been a realisation of the adverse impact of deforestation on the environment. The depletion of the green cover was one of the consequences of deforestation. Cutting down forests led to environmental degradation. Since the forests absorb carbon dioxide, its destruction considerably affects the ability of the nature to keep emissions out of the atmosphere. This is one of the causes of global warming. The law relating to the environment gradually evolved during the last three decades in the light of the constitutional provisions and ever-increasing awareness and growing concern about environmental degradation. Perhaps, to prevent large- scale deforestation, the legislature thought it fit to come out with another
216
legislation for protecting the forests.
41. Section 2 overrides all the laws applicable to a particular State which will include not only the laws of that particular State but also the relevant Central laws applicable to that particular State. Clause
(i) of Section 2 applies to a reserved forest within the meaning of any law for the time being in force in that State. Clauses (ii), (iii) and (iv) of Section 2 apply to "any forest land". As clause (i) specifically refers to a reserved forest within the meaning of any law in force, it is obvious that clauses (ii), (iii) and (iv) apply to any other forest, whether or not recognised or declared as such under any law in force in that State. Hence, clauses (ii),
(iii) and (iv) of Section 2 apply to any forest land which may not be necessarily a reserved forest or a protected forest or a private forest governed by Chapter V under the 1927 Forest Act. Restrictions imposed by Section 2 [except clause
(i) thereof] apply to every forest land in respect of which no declarations have been made either under the 1927 Forest Act or any other law relating to the forests in force in that State.
42. Before we deal with the concept of a forest under the 1980 Forest Act, we must note here that this enactment does not provide for an absolute prohibition on the use of any forest land or a part thereof for any non-forest purposes. The State Government or any other authority can always permit the use of any forest land or any portion thereof for non-forest purposes only with the prior approval of the Central Government. In a sense, this enactment provides for permissive use of forest land for non-forest activities with the prior approval of the Central Government. Therefore, the owner of a private land which is a forest within the meaning of Section 2 can convert its use for non- forest purposes only after obtaining requisite permission of the State Government or competent authority concerned. However, the State
217
Government or the competent authority, as the case may be, cannot permit such use for non-forest activities without obtaining prior approval from the Central Government. This provision has been made to check further depletion of already depleted green cover and to ensure that only such non-forest activities are permitted by the Central Government which will not cause ecological imbalance leading to environmental degradation. Considering the scheme of the 1980 Forest Act, the title-holder of a private land which is a forest within the meaning of Section 2 is not divested of his right, title or interest in the land. But there is an embargo on using his forest land for any non-forest activity.
43.The object of the embargo on permitting non-forest use of forest land without prior permission of the Central Government is not to completely prevent the conduct of non-forest activities. This provision enables the Central Government to regulate non-forest use of forest lands. While exercising the power to approve non-forest use, the Central Government is under a mandate to keep in mind the principles of sustainable development as evolved by this Court including in its decision in Rajeev Suri. The embargo imposed by Section 2 ensures that the development and use of a forest land for non-forest use is governed by the principle of sustainable development. In a sense, Section 2 promotes the development work on forest land only to the extent it can be sustained while alleviating environmental concerns. The power given to the Central Government under Section 2 must be exercised by adopting scientific and consistent yardsticks for applying the principles of sustainable development.
44. Now, coming to the meaning of "forest" or "any forest land" covered by Section 2, this Court in 1997 Godavarmancasehas explained the legal position. Paras 3 and 4 of the said decision read thus: (SCC pp. 269-70)
218
"3. It has emerged at the hearing, that there is a misconception in certain quarters about the true scope of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 (for short "the Act") and the meaning of the word "forest" used therein. There is also a resulting misconception about the need of prior approval of the Central Government, as required by Section 2 of the Act, in respect of certain activities in the forest area which are more often of a commercial nature. It is necessary to clarify that position.
4. The Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 was enacted with a view to check further deforestation which ultimately results in ecological imbalance; and therefore, the provisions made therein for the conservation of forests and for matters connected therewith, must apply to all forests irrespective of the nature of ownership or classification thereof. The word "forest" must be understood according to its dictionary meaning. This description covers all statutorily recognised forests, whether designated as reserved, protected or otherwise for the purpose of Section 2(i) of the Forest (Conservation) Act. The term "forest land", occurring in Section 2, will not only include
"forest" as understood in the dictionary sense, but also any area recorded as forest in the government record irrespective of the ownership. This is how it has to be understood for the purpose of Section 2 of the Act. The provisions enacted in the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980for the conservation of forests and the matters connected therewith must apply clearly to all forests so understood irrespective of the ownership or classification thereof. This aspect has been made abundantly clear in the decisions of this Court in Ambica Quarry Works v. State of Gujarat, Rural Litigation & Entitlement Kendra v. State of U.P. and recently in the order dated 29-11-1996 (Supreme Court Monitoring Committee v. Mussoorie Dehradun Development Authority). The earlier decision of this Court in State of Bihar v. Banshi Ram Modi has, therefore, to be understood in the light of these subsequent decisions. We consider it necessary to reiterate this
219
settled position emerging from the decisions of this Court to dispel the doubt, if any, in the perception of any State Government or authority. This has become necessary also because of the stand taken on behalf of the State of Rajasthan, even at this late stage, relating to permissions granted for mining in such area which is clearly contrary to the decisions of this Court. It is reasonable to assume that any State Government which has failed to appreciate the correct position in law so far, will forthwith correct its stance and take the necessary remedial measures without any further delay."
(emphasis supplied)
148. It may also be very relevant at this stage to observe that in the State of Assam, the Indian Forest Act, 1927 has not been applied on account of the Regulation. However, the order passed by the Supreme Court in the case of T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad Vs. Union of India reported in (1997) 2 SCC 267 which is referred to by the Supreme Court in the case of Narinder Singh (supra) at paragraph No. 44 as quoted herein above shows that the Act of 1980 integrates the Regulation with the Indian Forest Act, 1927, thereby bringing within the fold of Section 2 of the Act of 1980, any statutory recognized forest which includes a reserved forest declared under the Regulation.
149. The above principles of law as laid down by the Supreme Court would show that no right can be created by any State Law or
220
even a Central Law applicable to the State without the previous approval of the Central Government. It would show that though the Central Government has the power to grant the approval but such approval has to be granted by considering the principles of sustainable development which have been laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of Rajeev Suri (supra).
150. The above perspective if applied to the present facts and what had been opined herein above to the effect that till date neither any rights were created in favour of the Petitioners nor any rights accrued upon them, this Court cannot permit the Petitioners to reside within the Reserved Forest by issuance of a writ, direction or order. It is observed that in the present circumstances if a direction is issued to the Respondents not to evict, it would not only be transgressing upon the powers reserved upon the State Government as well as the Central Government under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 but also would be interfering with the constitutional duties and obligations reposed upon the State.
151. This Court also finds it very relevant to take note of another judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Nature Lovers Movement Vs. State of Kerala & Others reported in (2009) 5 SCC 373 wherein the Supreme Court dealt with the very concept of regularization of encroachment on forest land. The Supreme Court
221
observed in the said judgment that for the purpose of regularization, there has to be a policy of the State to regularize pre- 25.10.1980 occupation/encroachment of forest land and thereupon, the regularization can only be permissible after obtaining the prior approval of the Central Government. It was further observed that after 25.10.1980, i.e., the date of enforcement of the Act of 1980, no State Government or other authority can pass an order or give a direction for de-reservation of the reserved forest or any part thereof, or permit use of any forest land or any portion thereof for any non-forest purpose, or grant any lease, etc., in respect of the forest land to any private person or any authority, corporation, agency, or organization which is not owned, managed, or controlled by the Government. It was further observed that if any forest land or any portion thereof have been used for non-forest purpose for a particular length of time prior to the enforcement of the Act of 1980, the tenure of such activity cannot be extended by way of a renewal of a lease or otherwise after 25.10.1980 without obtaining the prior approval of the Central Government.
152. This Court now finds it relevant to take note of a very recent judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of A. John Kennedy Vs. State of Tamil Nadu & Others reported in 2026 SCC OnLine SC
222
1001. The said judgment is of significant relevance to the present point for determination. It is relevant, however, to observe that there exists an important distinguishing fact which separates the present proceedings with the judgment of the Supreme Court in A. John Kennedy (supra) i.e., the Petitioners in the present proceedings claim rights to remain within the reserved forest post the Notifications issued constituting the reserved forests, whereas in the case of A. John Kennedy (supra), the persons whose rehabilitation was in issue, they were there even prior to the Notification constituting the reserved forest in that case. Be that as it may, Paragraph Nos. 50, 56, 57, 60, 63 and 64 being relevant are reproduced herein under:
"50. This Court is not entirely averse to the submissions of State, and it is cognizant of the fact that eviction of thousands of persons who have been resident in forest areas for extended periods, many of whom are economically vulnerable. The task is onerous and one involving considerable administrative, logistical and humanitarian complexity. However, having said that, this Court is equally of the view that the obligation to protect ecologically sensitive regions cannot stand indefinitely deferred on account of such challenges, and that what is required is a structured, time-bound and adequately resourced institutional response that simultaneously addresses the imperatives of environmental protection and human rehabilitation.
56. This Court is also concerned by the material placed on record which indicates that certain government amenities and facilities continue to remain functional within encroached forest areas. The State has itself acknowledged that three PDS
223
shops continue to operate, albeit on a reduced basis, in Arasaradi, Vandiyur and Nariyuthu hamlets, and that six Anganwadicentres remain operational within encroached forest areas. While the State has indicated that a proposal for complete withdrawal of such services is under consideration and that no new services or infrastructure have been sanctioned, this Court is of the view that the continued operation, even on a limited basis, of such facilities within encroached forest areas must be brought to an end within a defined short timeframe. The extension of government facilities to encroached areas, however limited, inevitably legitimizes illegal occupation and creates disincentives for voluntary relocation.
57. The position regarding government employee encroachers also requires close attention. The CEC has identified 118 serving or retired government employees as encroachers within SMTR. While the State has initiated steps, including issuance of notices and the recovery of 15 hectares from such officials, the proceedings against a significant number remain pending. Government employees occupy a position of public trust, and encroachment upon protected forest land by persons holding such positions constitutes a particularly grave dereliction of duty that warrants the most expeditious and strong institutional response. The State must ensure that disciplinary and legal proceedings against all identified government employee encroachers are pursued and concluded with the urgency that the situation demands, without awaiting the outcome of the broader eviction programme. Further, removal of these encroachments is absolutely essential and must be completed by the next date of listing.
60. This Court has, in a catena of decisions, consistently affirmed that the protection of wildlife, forests and ecological systems constitutes not merely a statutory obligation but a constitutional imperative flowing from Articles 21, 48A and 51A(g) of the Constitution of India. This Court in T.N. GodavarmanThirumulpad v. Union of India2, emphasized the approach that conservation must be eco-centric and not anthropocentric, recognising that non- humans too have intrinsic value and that the approach has to be nature centred
224
where humans are a part of nature. The Court further observed, with reference to the principle of restitution and Article 8 of the Convention on Biological Diversity, 1992, that constitutional Courts are duty-bound to ensure not only prevention and mitigation of environmental degradation, but also restoration of damaged ecosystems to the fullest extent possible, while safeguarding against future ecological harm.
63. This Court is fully alive to the humanitarian dimension of the issues involved. A significant number of the persons presently in occupation of forest land within the Agasthyamalai landscape are economically vulnerable, many have been resident in these areas for extended periods, in some cases spanning over eight decades, under circumstances that were not entirely of their own making, including dam construction workers who settled in forest areas during infrastructure development activities, and communities that migrated into forest areas during severe drought conditions prevailing in the 1950s and 1960s. The complexity of the rehabilitation task is real and cannot be understated.
64. This Court is also conscious of the fact that rehabilitation and eviction must proceed simultaneously and in a coordinated manner, and that no person should be displaced without adequate alternative provision being made for their resettlement. The approach of the State in categorising encroachers, distinguishing between those with permanent habitations and forest-dependent livelihoods, those with temporary structures, and those engaged only in agriculture, provides a useful and rational framework for prioritising and sequencing eviction and rehabilitation operations. This Court endorses this approach and expects the State to pursue it with greater speed and rigour."
153. The above observations of the Supreme Court are relevant for the purpose of weighing the balance between private rights to continue to reside within the reserved forests on one hand and the
225
requirement to maintain the forests. The Supreme Court in unambiguous terms observed that protection of forests is of paramount importance than the private rights of the persons to continue to reside within the reserved forests.
154. The said judgment also refers to rehabilitation and directions being issued. It is however of relevance to note that the aspect of rehabilitation in the present cases before this Court would however be different than the case which was before the Supreme Court in
A. John Kennedy (supra) inasmuch as the Petitioners herein entered the reserved forest in question after the same were notified; and the Petitioners knew the fate of the consequences of trespassing into reserved forests and setting up dwelling houses by raising constructions. However, in the case of the persons referred to in the judgment in the case of A. John Kennedy (supra) they were residing within the reserved forest much prior to the forest being declared as a reserved forest. This aspect would be apparent from paragraph No. 1 of the order of the Supreme Court in the case of A. John Kennedy Vs. State of Tamil Nadu reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 776.
155. This Court also finds it relevant to take note of the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra), wherein
226
the Supreme Court had taken note of the data placed by the State of Assam apprising that 3,62,082.62 hectares of forest lands in the State of Assam were under encroachment or in other words, a total of 19.92% of forest area was under unauthorized illegal encroachment. The Supreme Court in the said judgment, more particularly, at paragraph Nos. 9 and 10, clearly observed that it was imperative upon the State to protect and improve the environment and to safeguard the forest and wild life of the country. Paragraph No. 9 of the judgment in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra), being relevant, is reproduced herein under:
"9. Forests constitute one of the most vital natural resources of the nation. They are not merely repositories of timber or land capable of alternate use, but complex ecological systems indispensable for maintaining environmental balance. Forests regulate climate, preserve biodiversity, recharge groundwater, prevent soil erosion, and act as natural carbon sinks mitigating the adverse effects of climate change. In a country as ecologically diverse and climatically vulnerable as India, the role of forests assumes even greater significance. Encroachment upon forest land has emerged as one of the gravest challenges confronting environmental governance in the country. The Constitution casts a clear and unequivocal obligation upon the state to protect forest and the environment. Article 48A, forming part of Directive Principles of State Policy, mandates that the State shall endeavor to protect and improve the environment and to safeguard the forests and wild life of the country. Though, Directive Principles are not enforceable by Courts, they are fundamental in governance of the country and must guide the State in formulation and implementation of policy. Article 51A(g) of the Constitution imposes a
227
fundamental duty upon every citizen to protect and improve the natural environment, including forests. These constitutional provision reflect a collective responsibility on the part of citizen as well as the State to prevent, regulate and remedy the environmental harm."
156. Considering the above, it is therefore the opinion of this Court that the question of restraining the Respondents to perform their constitutional obligations reposed upon by law would not be in the interest of justice. Under such circumstances, this Court opines that the Petitioners herein who are residing within the geo- coordinates of the reserved forests in question are required to be evicted as per law.
157. In the above perspective, this Court finds it relevant to take note of Clause 4.3.1.1 of the Assam Forest Policy, 2004. The said Clause being relevant is reproduced herein under:
"4.3.1.1 Government of Assam shall endeavor to identify pre-1980 encroachers who were allowed to enter the forest area by any competent authority, with a view to finding a solution to their land related problems."
158. This Court takes note of Clause 4.3.1.1 of the Assam Forest Policy, 2004 which appears to be based upon the National Forest Policy of 1988. This Clause in the Assam Forest Policy, 2004 would only come in aid of the Petitioners for being considered for
228
allotment of land as per the terms and conditions set out in the Assam Land Policy, 2019. The said Clause 4.3.1.1 under no circumstances can be construed that the Government had proposed that land would be allotted within the reserved forest if the Petitioners entered the reserved forest prior to 1980 with the permission of the Competent Authority. In fact, the State Government on its own even if it wished, cannot do so in view of Section 2 of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980. It is however the opinion of this Court that if the Petitioners are able to show before the Revenue Authorities that they entered the reserved forest prior to 1980 with the specific permission of the Competent Authority of the State Government prior to 1980, such Petitioners' claim for allotment of land in terms with the Assam Land Policy, 2019 should be prioritize. The said observation is however subject to the Petitioners fulfilling the other parameters required as per the Assam Land Policy, 2019.
CONCLUSIONS
159. The instant batch of writ petitions stand disposed of with the following observations and directions:
(i) The impugned Speaking Orders dated 07.03.2026, which
229
are assailed in the present batch of writ petitions qua each of the Petitioners were passed after following the necessary procedural safeguards as mandated in the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (Supra).
(ii) The impugned Speaking Orders dated 07.03.2026 qua each of the Petitioners were passed by taking into consideration the relevant factors and considerations.
(iii) The finding of facts arrived at by the authorities concerned that the Petitioners in the batch of writ petitions are occupying land within the reserved forests are based upon a proper survey conducted by the Committee constituted vide Notification dated 17.02.2026 along with Forest officials and the digitization of the boundaries of the Reserved Forest in question. Under such circumstances, these findings of facts cannot be questioned in the writ proceedings.
(iv) The findings in the impugned Speaking Orders qua each of the Petitioners that the Petitioners have failed to show documents/evidence of creation of rights to remain in the reserved forest, are in accordance with the settled principles of law and as such, do not call for any interference.
230
(v) Aadhar Cards, Election IDs, names in the Electoral Rolls, Electricity Connection, Certificates issued by the Panchayat Authorities cannot be regarded as documents which would entitle the Petitioners to reside within the Reserved Forests.
(vi) The Notification issued under Section 5 of the Assam Panchayat Act, 1994 is only a Notification extending the benefits of the Panchayat Raj Institutions to the Reserved Forests. The said Notification issued under Section 5 of the Assam Panchayat Act, 1994 would under no circumstances change the character of the Reserved Forests. The reason being Section 2 of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 categorically bars any State Law or any Central Law applicable to the State from de- reserving a Reserved Forest or portion thereof without the approval of the Central Government.
(vii) A perusal of the provision of the Regulation would show that no rights have been conferred upon persons carrying Jhumming cultivation or under the Taungya System to reside within the Reserved Forests, except those persons who come within the ambit of Forest Dwelling Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers as defined in the Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of
231
Forest Rights) Act, 2006. Furthermore, no person can claim derivative rights, when no rights have accrued upon the persons claiming rights under the Taungya System. Apart from that, there is a bar under Section 22 of the Regulation from alienation without the previous sanction/approval of the State Government.
(viii) The Petitioners herein have failed to show that they come within the scope of Forest Dwelling Scheduled Tribes or the Other Traditional Dwellers as defined in Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006 and under such circumstances, they have no right to remain within the Reserved Forests. The Petitioners herein have also failed to show that their names have been recorded in the Jamabandi prepared by the Forest Department of the Government of Assam.
(ix) The Revenue Authorities of the State of Assam cannot confer any right over any lands falling within the Reserved Forests by virtue of Section 4 of the Assam Land and Revenue Regulations, 1886. Therefore, issuance of any Patta or accepting revenue by the Revenue Authorities in respect to lands falling within the Reserved Forests would not create any
232
right or interest to remain within the Reserved Forests.
(x) All the Petitioners have failed to show any right to remain within the subject reserved forests.
(xi) The right to protect the environment and safeguard the forests and wild life are rights falling within the realm of public rights and these rights outweigh the private rights of the Petitioners to reside within the Reserved Forests.
(xii) The Petitioners cannot be permitted to reside within the boundaries of the Reserved Forests which have been specifically outlined by the geo-coordinate locations of each of the Reserved Forests as quoted hereinabove.
(xiii) It is the constitutional obligation cast upon the State to protect and improve the environment and to safeguard the forests and wildlife. Under such circumstances, the steps taken for eviction of the Petitioners in the present batch of writ petitions as well as all other encroachers by issuance of notice are in consonance with the constitutional goals enshrined under Article 48A of the Constitution.
(xiv) This Court grants a period of 30 (Thirty) days to the
233
Petitioners to take steps for removal of their belongings and make alternative arrangements. Failure to do so, this Court directs the officials of the State Government including the District Administration, the Police Administration as well as the Forest Officials to take active steps for removal of the Petitioners from the reserved forests in question.
(xv) This Court further directs the Managing Director, APDCL to disconnect the electricity connections, after 30 (Thirty) days from the date of the instant judgment of the Petitioners as well as all encroachers of the Reserved Forests against whom Speaking Orders have been passed pursuant to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Abdul Khalek (supra).
(xvi) This Court further observes that diversion of lands within the Reserved Forests are not permissible for setting up of Schools, Dispensaries, Hospitals, Anganwadis, Fair Price Shops, Electric and Telecommunication Lines, Roads, Community Centres, etc. unless the Central Government provides for diversion of these facilities. This Court also observes that Section 3(2) of the Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act,
234
2006 provides when such diversion is permissible. Under such circumstances, this Court directs the Chief Secretary, Government of Assam to take appropriate steps for due compliance in respect to the facilities provided within the Reserved Forests in question as outlined by the geo- coordinates' boundaries of the respective Reserved Forests as mentioned in the body of the instant judgment. This Court further observes that in the circumstances on account of the compliance as directed above, any Forest Dwelling Scheduled Tribes and/or Other Traditional Forest Dwellers, duly recognized, are effected, the concerned Authorities of the State are directed to do the needful so that they can avail such facilities in the adjoining areas falling in the Government khas lands or private lands outside the Reserved Forests. The Chief Secretary, Government of Assam is also directed to ensure the same.
(xvii) The Chief Secretary, Government of Assam is further directed to ensure that the Forest Department of the Government of Assam does not permit any use of the lands upon being cleared from encroachers for any non-forest purpose.
235
(xviii) The Chief Secretary, Government of Assam shall ensure that the Forest Department of the Government of Assam takes effective steps for reforestation of the lands upon being cleared from encroachments.
(xix) This Court duly takes note of the maps produced before this Court. In the said maps which contain the photographic image of the reserved forests, the Respondents have indicated the possession of the Petitioners as well as other encroachers. In view of the findings in the present judgment, there cannot be any person residing within the reserved forest except is permissible under the rights saved under the Regulation as well as the Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006. Under such circumstances, it is the constitutional obligation of the State to evict all other encroachers within the reserved forests by following the procedural safeguards
236
1886 in terms with the Assam Land Policy, 2019. In the circumstance, the Petitioners can show that the Petitioners were allowed to settle in the reserved forests, prior to 1980 by the Competent Authority, the Revenue Department of the Government of Assam shall prioritize such applications for allotment. In respect to the other Petitioners, the same shall be done in accordance with the principles and procedure laid down under the Assam Land Policy, 2019.
(xxi) Interim orders passed earlier stands vacated.
(xxii) All writ petitions stands disposed of.
160. Before parting with the records, this Court finds it relevant to remind ourselves of the words of our Father of the Nation, taking into consideration the subject involved.
"What we are doing to the forests of the world is but a mirror reflection of what we are doing to ourselves and to one another."
— M. K. Gandhi
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
237