Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges

    S RAMACHANDRAN S/o. R Y SOUNDARARAJAN v. THE SECRETARIAL TEAM MANAGER

    1

    Date of filing 07.02.2025 Date of allotment to Addl. DCDRC 02.02.2026 Date of Order 24.02.2026

    IN THE ADDITIONAL DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION,

    TIRUNELVELI

    PRESENT : THIRU. M. PIRAVI PERUMAL, B.Com., B.L., ADCL - PRESIDENT TMT. P. SHANMUGAPRIYA, M.SC., D.L.L.A.L - MEMBER - I C.C. NO. 19/2025

    th

    TUESDAY THE 24 DAY OF FEBRUARY 2026

    S. Ramachandran, S/o. Late R. Y. Soundararajan, Door No. 44, Veeraraghava Colony, C N. Village, Tirunelveli - 627 001. ....Complainant .. Vs ..

    1. The Secretarial Team Manager, (legal), Aditya Birla Health Insurance Company Limited, th 9 Floor, One World Centre, Tower -1, Jupiter Mill Compound,

    Senapati Bapat Marg, Elphinstine Road,

    Mumbai - 400 013.

    2. The Branch Service Manager, Aditya Birla Health Insurance Company Limited, Sri Kousikan Complex,

    24/D/13, S N High Road,

    Tirunelveli - 627 001.

    3. The Relationship Manager, Aditya Birla Health Insurance Company Limited, th R-Tech Park, 10 Floor, Nirlon Compound, Off Western Highway,

    Goregaon, Mumbai - 400 063.

    4. The Grievance Redressal officer (GRO)., Aditya Birla Health Insurance Company Limited, th 7 Floor, Modi Business Centre, Kasarvadavali, Mumbai - Thane - 400 615. ….Opposite parties This complaint is coming for hearing through video conferencing before us on this th 09 day of February 2026, in the presence of Thiru. A. Haja Mohideen, Counsel for the st th

    complainant and of Thiru. R. Anbarasu, Counsel for the 1 to 4 opposite parties and

    2

    perused the documents filed by both side and the case having stood over to this day for consideration, this Commission passed the following:

    ORDER

    THIRU M. PIRAVI PERUMAL, B.COM., B.L., ADCL - PRESIDENT

    1. The crux of the complaint is -

    The complainant, having reposed utmost faith in the representations of the opposite party insurance company, had availed a Group Active Health Insurance Policy on 28.09.2021 bearing Certificate No. GHI-CB-21-2000439 and Unique ID No. GAHCF12109241707301 for a sum assured of Rs. 5,00,000/- covering himself and his wife, and had diligently renewed the same from time to time. On 31.12.2022, when his wife was advised to undergo right eye cataract surgery at Aravind Hospital, Tirunelveli, the claim was repudiated citing a two-year waiting period applicable to re-cataract surgery, compelling the complainant to proceed under CGHS cover. Subsequently, on 15.11.2023, pre- authorization for left eye cataract surgery was initially granted however, owing to the detection of a retinal complication, the hospital declined to proceed and returned the approval. Thereafter, on 17.11.2023, a request for pre-authorization for administration of Avastin injection costing Rs. 5,000/- for macular edema was rejected on the ground that the ailment was attributable to a pre-existing condition, namely Diabetes Mellitus of 12 years' duration and Hypertension for 10 years. The complainant submits that he had, with utmost candour, disclosed the diabetic history at the proposal stage, even furnishing the HbA1c value (point 7), and was expressly assured by the opposite party that such disclosure sufficed and that he need not harbour any apprehension. Notably, the policy documents for the years 2021, 2022-2023, and 2023-2024 did not specify any pre- existing disease, reflecting "NA," whereas in 2024-2025, Diabetes Mellitus was suddenly recorded as a PED. Again, on 03.01.2024, a fresh pre-authorization request through Dr. Agarwal Eye Hospital, Tirunelveli, a network hospital, for left eye cataract surgery along with Razumab injection was repudiated on the untenable allegation of non-disclosure of diabetes and hypertension, and documents were sought, which were duly furnished. Shockingly, the opposite party unilaterally cancelled the subject policy, allegedly on the premise that PED patients were ineligible under the scheme, though this came to light only through internal sources. Upon complaint before the Insurance Ombudsman, the opposite party settled Rs. 48,129/- against a claim of Rs. 50,565/- without assigning any reason for short settlement, leaving a balance of Rs. 2,436/- unpaid though the cancelled policy was eventually restored, it remained unlawfully cancelled from 24.02.2024 to 06.08.2024, a

    3

    period of nearly six months. The complainant submits that the arbitrary repudiations, unilateral cancellation, shifting stands regarding pre-existing disease, and partial settlement without justification constitute gross negligence and clear deficiency in service, causing immense financial hardship and mental agony, and therefore prays that the opposite party be directed to pay the balance reimbursement of Rs. 2,436/-, interest at 18% per annum on Rs. 50,565/- from 03.01.2024 till realization, compensation of Rs. 2,00,000/- for mental agony, and the costs of this complaint.

    2. The crux of the opposite parties written version is -

    The opposite parties have denied all the averments and allegations set out in the complaint as false, incorrect, and not admitted, save and except those expressly admitted herein. They submit, at the outset, that the present complaint is wholly misconceived and does not disclose the existence of any consumer dispute as against the opposite party, and is therefore not maintainable either in law or on facts. The opposite party contends that the policy in question constitutes a concluded and binding contract between the parties, the rights and obligations of which are governed strictly by its terms, conditions, exclusions, and endorsements, and that any claim for reimbursement must necessarily be adjudged only in accordance with the stipulations contained therein. It is further submitted that the doctrine of utmost good faith governs contracts of insurance, and any non- observance or breach of policy conditions, whether by way of non-disclosure, misrepresentation, or otherwise, would absolve the insurer of liability as per the contractual framework. The opposite party asserts that it is a regulated entity functioning under the supervision and control of the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI), and that every policy issued by it, including the standard terms and conditions forming part thereof, has been duly scrutinized and approved by the said regulatory authority, thereby ensuring transparency, legality, and compliance with statutory norms. The opposite party denies that there has been any arbitrariness, unfair trade practice, negligence, or deficiency in service on its part, and maintains that all decisions pertaining to repudiation, partial settlement, or cancellation were undertaken strictly in accordance with policy provisions and underwriting guidelines. It is emphatically contended that no wrongful loss or legal injury has been occasioned to the complainant by reason of any act or omission attributable to the opposite party, and consequently, no cause of action survives for claiming compensation, interest, or any other relief. On these grounds, the opposite party submits that the complainant is not entitled to any relief whatsoever and prays that the complaint be dismissed inlimine with costs.

    4

    3. The complainant to prove his case had filed proof affidavit along with 19 documents and the same has been marked as Exhibit A-1 to A-19. On the side of the opposite parties, st The 1 opposite party had filed proof affidavit along without document.

    4. The points for determination are -

    1. Whether there is deficiency in service on the part of the opposite parties ?

    2. If so to what relief the complainant is entitled for ?

    5. POINT NO. 1 & 2

    We upon a meticulous and anxious consideration of the pleadings placed on record, this Commission is constrained to observe that the defence projected by the opposite party insurance company is conspicuously bereft of substance, specificity, and evidentiary support. The complainant has narrated, with chronological precision, the sequence of events commencing from the inception of the policy, the disclosure of the medical history, the repeated repudiations of pre-authorization requests, the unilateral cancellation of the policy, and the eventual partial settlement pursuant to intervention by the Insurance Ombudsman. These assertions, being assertions of fact, called for a pointed, issue-wise rebuttal supported by documentary evidence, policy extracts, underwriting notes, proposal forms, or any contemporaneous correspondence. However, the opposite party has chosen to file a stereotyped and generalized written version, replete with abstract propositions of law regarding the binding nature of insurance contracts and regulatory oversight by IRDAI, without traversing a single material allegation in a manner known to law.

    6. It is by now trite that an insurance policy, though contractual in nature, does not operate in a vacuum. When an insurer seeks to repudiate liability, it does not suffice to merely allege breach or suppression in broad and unsubstantiated terms. The burden squarely rests upon the insurer to discharge, by cogent, credible, and affirmative evidence, three essential elements first, the precise policy clause on which reliance is placed second, a clear demonstration of how that clause is attracted to the facts of the case and third, the factual substratum establishing that the insured was indeed guilty of material non- disclosure or misrepresentation warranting repudiation. In the present matter, this foundational burden remains wholly undischarged. Not a single clause of the policy has been extracted or placed on record. There is no identification of any exclusion, warranty, or condition precedent allegedly breached. Even more strikingly, no documentary evidence

    5

    has been adduced to substantiate the allegation that the complainant suppressed a history of diabetes or hypertension. A repudiation so serious in consequence cannot be sustained on conjecture, presumption, or bare assertion. On the contrary, the complainant has made a categorical and specific pleading that his diabetic history, including the HbA1c value, was expressly disclosed at the proposal stage. He has further asserted that the said disclosure was accepted and that he was assured of its sufficiency. These averments are neither vague nor evasive they are precise and unequivocal. The insurer, if it sought to controvert this assertion, was under a clear obligation to produce the proposal form—the foundational document embodying the disclosures made by the insured at the inception of the contract. The conspicuous failure of the opposite party to place the proposal form on record is not a mere procedural lapse it strikes at the root of its defence. The proposal form constitutes the primary evidence of what was or was not disclosed. In the absence of this document, the allegation of suppression remains unsubstantiated and legally infirm. Indeed, such withholding of the best available evidence justifies the drawing of an adverse inference—that had the proposal form been produced, it would have supported the complainant's case and belied the plea of non-disclosure. The repudiation of an insurance claim is a serious matter with significant civil consequences. It cannot be upheld on the strength of ipse dixit. Where the insurer fails to produce the governing policy clause, fails to demonstrate its applicability, and fails to produce the proposal form to substantiate alleged suppression, the repudiation is rendered arbitrary and unsustainable. The finding, therefore, must be unequivocal the insurer has not merely failed to prove suppression it has failed to lay even the minimal evidentiary foundation necessary to justify its denial of liability.

    7. We find it equally telling and in our considered view, decisively so—is the admitted position emerging from the policy schedules placed on record. For the policy years 2021, 2022-2023, and 2023-2024, the column relating to pre-existing disease was unequivocally marked as "NA." These entries were not isolated or accidental they were repeated across successive renewals, thereby evidencing a consistent underwriting position adopted by the insurer over a substantial period of time. It is only in the policy schedule for 2024-2025 that Diabetes Mellitus is, for the first time, reflected as a pre- existing disease. This abrupt incorporation, after years of recording "NA," constitutes a material inconsistency of the highest order. Such a significant alteration in the insurer's own records cannot be brushed aside as inconsequential. It demands a cogent and convincing explanation. Strikingly, no such explanation is forthcoming. The written version

    6

    is conspicuously silent as to how and on what basis this change was effected. There is no underwriting note indicating reassessment of risk. There is no endorsement reflecting any declaration by the insured. There is no internal communication, medical review, investigation report, or discovery of fresh material that could justify the sudden alteration. Above all, there is no documentary evidence to demonstrate that the complainant suppressed any material fact which later came to light and warranted rectification of the policy records. In the absence of such foundational material, the belated insertion of Diabetes Mellitus as a PED appears unilateral and unexplained. The insurer cannot be permitted to modify its own records retrospectively and thereafter rely upon such altered entries as a ground for repudiation, without first establishing the factual and legal basis for the change. To countenance such a course would be to sanction arbitrariness. The bald plea of non-disclosure, bereft of documentary substantiation, cannot be elevated to a legally sustainable defence. Repudiation of an insurance claim is not a matter of discretion or convenience it must be anchored in demonstrable evidence. Where the insurer's own policy schedules for multiple years negate the existence of any declared pre-existing disease, and where no material is produced to explain a subsequent contradictory entry, the inevitable inference is that the plea of suppression is an afterthought. The insurance repudiation must rest on proof, not presumption on records, not rhetoric on evidence, not conjecture. In the present case, the insurer has failed to cross even that minimal evidentiary threshold. The finding, therefore, is inescapable, the alleged non-disclosure stands unproven, and the repudiation founded upon it is wholly unsustainable.

    8. In auxiliary and of no less consequence the unilateral cancellation of the policy by the opposite party assumes grave and disquieting significance. The policy in question was not a fresh or isolated contract it had been renewed year after year, thereby creating a legitimate expectation of continuity and good faith performance. After such sustained renewals, any abrupt termination, particularly in the absence of a clearly articulated and contractually supported justification, invites the strictest judicial scrutiny. It is an elementary principle that cancellation of a subsisting health insurance policy must be traceable to an express provision of the policy and must be effected in conformity with the procedure prescribed therein. Yet, in the present case, the opposite party has failed to produce even the most basic documentary foundation for its action. There is no notice of cancellation placed on record. There is no reasoned order communicating the grounds for such termination. There is no reference to any specific policy condition authorizing cancellation under the alleged circumstances. Equally absent are any underwriting

    7

    guidelines demonstrating that persons with a declared pre-existing disease stood disqualified from renewal. No regulatory instruction, circular, or internal directive has been produced to justify the drastic step taken. In effect, the cancellation is left unsupported by any contemporaneous record, rendering it opaque and arbitrary. In the realm of consumer jurisprudence, cancellation of a health policy, particularly mid-term and in the backdrop of a pending or anticipated claim, is not a matter to be treated lightly. Health insurance contracts are instruments of social security, intended to provide financial protection during medical exigencies. To permit an insurer to cancel such a policy unilaterally, without demonstrable adherence to contractual and regulatory safeguards, would undermine the very purpose of insurance and erode consumer confidence. We find the silence of the opposite party on this crucial aspect is telling. When serious allegations of arbitrary cancellation are made, the burden lies heavily upon the insurer to justify its conduct with precision and transparency. Its failure to do so, coupled with the subsequent restoration of the policy, further weakens its stance. The act of restoration implicitly acknowledges that the earlier cancellation was either procedurally flawed, substantively unjustified, or both. This sequence of events, unexplained cancellation followed by eventual restoration—strongly militates against the propriety and bona fides of the insurer's action. It reinforces the inference that the cancellation was not grounded in any valid contractual or regulatory basis, but was instead an arbitrary exercise of power. The finding, therefore, must be emphatic, the unilateral cancellation, unsupported by evidence and unaccompanied by a reasoned justification, cannot withstand legal scrutiny and stands vitiated by manifest arbitrariness.

    9. We further note that the partial settlement of Rs. 48,129/- as against the claimed amount of Rs. 50,565/-, without assigning any reason whatsoever for the deduction of Rs. 2,436/-, is not a trivial discrepancy but a matter that bears directly upon the fairness and transparency of the insurer's conduct. In insurance adjudication, even a minor deduction must be traceable to a specific policy clause, tariff provision, sub-limit, co-payment condition, or documented exclusion. A deduction cannot rest on unexplained arithmetic. In the present case, the opposite party has not placed on record any calculation sheet, break-up statement, policy clause, or internal assessment explaining the basis of the reduction. There is no indication that the deducted amount pertained to a non-payable item, a room rent capping, a co-pay percentage, or any other contractual limitation. The absence of such justification renders the deduction wholly opaque. Significantly, the act of part settlement itself carries legal implications. By admitting and paying a substantial

    8

    portion of the claim, the insurer has, in effect, acknowledged the admissibility of the claim under the policy. A part payment, in such circumstances, undermines any sweeping plea of total non-liability. It reinforces the inference that the hospitalization and treatment were otherwise covered events. The burden, therefore, shifts heavily onto the insurer to demonstrate why a specific component alone was excluded. The opposite party has failed to discharge that burden. A mere remittance of a reduced sum, without an accompanying explanation, cannot be treated as a lawful discharge of liability. It reflects arbitrariness rather than adjudicated assessment. Insurance claims must be processed with transparency and reasoned decision-making deductions must be defensible with reference to contractual terms. In the absence of any clause-based justification or documentary substantiation, the shortfall of Rs. 2,436/- remains unexplained and unjustified. Consequently, the inevitable conclusion is that the balance amount continues to be payable. The insurer cannot, by unilateral deduction unsupported by evidence, curtail the complainant's rightful entitlement under the policy. The finding, therefore, must be unequivocal, the deduction is arbitrary, lacks contractual foundation, and the withheld amount is liable to be paid in full.

    10. It is well settled that deficiency in service under consumer jurisprudence is not confined merely to an outright repudiation of a claim. The expression is of wide amplitude and comprehends within its fold any act of omission or commission which falls short of the standard of fairness, reasonableness, transparency, and good faith expected of a service provider. Arbitrary, capricious, inconsistent, or unsupported decision-making, particularly when it results in harassment, delay, financial strain, or mental agony to the insured, squarely attracts the mischief of deficiency in service. In the present case, the cumulative conduct of the opposite party leaves little room for doubt. There have been repeated repudiations on shifting and mutually inconsistent grounds. At one stage, the claim is resisted on the plea of non-disclosure at another, the records reflect contradictory positions regarding the existence of a pre-existing disease. Policy schedules for earlier years negate the presence of any declared PED, yet subsequently the same is introduced without explanation. The policy itself is unilaterally cancelled for nearly six months, only to be restored later, without any cogent justification placed on record. Throughout this sequence, the insurer has failed to produce the foundational documents, proposal form, underwriting notes, cancellation notice, or clause-based reasoning, to substantiate its actions. We are of the view that such conduct cannot be dismissed as a mere administrative lapse. It reveals a pattern of opaque and shifting decision-making that has

    9

    compelled the complainant to pursue what ought to have been a straightforward claim. The harassment occasioned by repeated repudiations, the uncertainty created by contradictory stands, and the financial insecurity caused by cancellation of a health policy strike at the very purpose for which insurance is obtained. Health insurance is not a commercial luxury it is a safeguard against medical contingencies. Conduct that undermines that safeguard inflicts not merely pecuniary loss but also mental distress. The defence that the policy terms are approved by the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) does not advance the case of the opposite party. The regulatory approval of standard policy wordings does not confer immunity upon arbitrary or selective application of those terms. Approval of a template does not validate misapplication in a particular case. An insurer cannot cloak itself in regulatory sanction while simultaneously failing to demonstrate that its actions conform to the approved terms and to principles of fairness. What is subject to scrutiny here is not the validity of the policy form in abstract, but the manner in which it has been invoked and enforced in concreto. Therefore, even assuming the policy terms are regulatory-compliant, their invocation must still withstand judicial scrutiny on the touchstone of reasonableness, transparency, and evidentiary support. In the absence of clause-based justification and documentary substantiation, regulatory approval offers no shield. When viewed cumulatively, not in isolation, the repeated repudiations, contradictory positions on pre-existing disease, unexplained unilateral cancellation, partial and unexplained deductions, and persistent failure to produce material documents unmistakably constitute deficiency in service. The finding must therefore be emphatic and unambiguous, the conduct of the opposite party falls far below the standard expected of an insurer and squarely attracts liability under consumer law for deficiency in service.

    11. This Commission, therefore, records a clear and categorical finding that the opposite party has utterly failed to discharge the burden of proof that lay squarely upon it. Allegations of non-disclosure, breach of policy condition, or justification for repudiation cannot be sustained on mere assertion they require cogent evidence. In the present case, no such evidence has been forthcoming. The insurer has neither produced the foundational documents nor adduced any material capable of substantiating its defence. We find equally significant is the failure of the opposite party to specifically rebut the detailed and pointed allegations raised by the complainant. The pleadings of the complainant are precise, fact-specific, and supported by documentary circumstances. In contrast, the written statement filed by the insurer is generic and omnibus in nature. It

    10

    reiterates standard defences in abstract form, without correlating them to the facts of the case or supporting them with documentary proof. Such a pleading, bereft of particulars and unsupported by evidence, carries little probative value. It is a settled principle of adjudication that specific assertions, when not specifically denied or effectively controverted, assume evidentiary significance. The opposite party has not produced the proposal form to counter the plea of disclosure. It has not produced underwriting notes to justify the alleged suppression. It has not produced a reasoned cancellation notice to explain the termination of the policy. The absence of these critical documents leaves the complainant's version substantially unshaken. The surrounding circumstances further fortify the complainant's case. The eventual restoration of the policy militates against the insurer's plea of fundamental breach. Likewise, the partial settlement of the claim through intervention of the Ombudsman indicates that the claim was not inherently untenable. These developments are inconsistent with a position of total and justified repudiation rather, they lend credence to the complainant's assertion that the denial of benefits was unwarranted. When viewed holistically, the evidentiary balance tilts decisively in favour of the complainant. The defence rests on broad averments unsupported by material evidence, whereas the complainant's case is corroborated by the conduct of the insurer itself and by the sequence of events on record. The Commission is, therefore, left with no hesitation in concluding that the opposite party has failed to rebut the complainant's case in any meaningful or legally sustainable manner. The finding is emphatic, the insurer's defence lacks evidentiary foundation, while the complainant's pleadings stand substantially proved and unrebutted.

    12. In view of the foregoing analysis, this Commission has no hesitation in holding that the conduct of the opposite party constitutes clear and unequivocal deficiency in service and reflects arbitrary and unfair handling of the complainant's claim. The repeated repudiations on shifting grounds, contradictory stands regarding pre-existing disease, unexplained deduction, unilateral cancellation of a subsisting health policy for nearly six months, and persistent failure to produce foundational documents collectively demonstrate a sustained departure from the standards of fairness, transparency, and good faith expected of an insurer. The repudiation and partial settlement were unsupported by cogent evidence or clause-based justification, and the subsequent restoration of the policy further undermines the insurer's defence. Accordingly, the complainant is entitled to the balance reimbursement of Rs. 2,436/-, together with interest at a reasonable rate on Rs. 50,565/- from 03.01.2024 till the date of realization, the award of interest being

    11

    necessary to compensate for the unwarranted withholding of legitimate dues. Having regard to the prolonged uncertainty, repeated repudiations, and unlawful cancellation of policy coverage, which undeniably caused mental agony and financial distress, the complainant is further entitled to reasonable compensation and litigation costs, both to redress the individual grievance and to reaffirm the obligation of insurers to act with fairness, diligence, and accountability.

    13. Having regard to the entire factual matrix of the case, this Commission is firmly and unequivocally of the considered view that the conduct of the opposite party reflects a persistent pattern of arbitrariness and procedural impropriety. The repeated repudiations on shifting and inconsistent grounds, the conspicuous failure to substantiate serious allegations of non-disclosure with any documentary evidence, the unilateral cancellation of a subsisting health policy for a considerable duration, and the partial settlement of the claim without assigning any reasoned basis for deduction, collectively demonstrate a course of action that falls far short of the standards of fairness, transparency, and accountability expected of an insurer. The complainant, who had duly disclosed his medical history at the inception and renewed the policy in good faith year after year, was unjustifiably compelled to run from pillar to post and to invoke multiple remedial mechanisms, including intervention by the Insurance Ombudsman, merely to secure benefits that were contractually due. Such avoidable hardship, prolonged uncertainty, and financial insecurity, particularly in the context of a health insurance policy intended to provide peace of mind during medical exigencies—inevitably caused mental agony and distress. The cumulative effect of these actions leaves no manner of doubt that the opposite party's conduct squarely falls within the ambit of deficiency in service under consumer law and warrants not only restitution but also compensatory relief. Accordingly, in the interest of justice and to meet the ends of equity, this Commission deems it just and proper to award compensation of Rs. 20,000/- towards mental agony and inconvenience suffered by the complainant, along with litigation costs quantified at Rs. 10,000/-, payable by the opposite party, so as to meaningfully redress the grievance and reinforce the obligation of insurers to act with diligence, fairness, and good faith.

    In the result, the complaint is allowed in part and (i). the opposite parties are jointly and severally directed to pay the balance reimbursement amount of Rs. 2,436/- (rupees two thousand four hundred and thirty six only) to the complainant.

    12

    (ii). the opposite parties are jointly and severally directed to pay interest at the rate of 9 % per annum on Rs. 50,565/- (rupees fifty thousand five hundred and sixty five only) from 03.01.2024 till the date of actual realization. (iii). the opposite parties are jointly and severally directed to pay a sum of Rs. 20,000/- (rupees twenty thousand only) to the complainant as compensation for the mental agony, hardship, and inconvenience caused to the complainant on account of its deficiency in service,

    (iv). the opposite parties are jointly and severally directed to pay a sum of Rs. 10,000/- (rupees ten thousand only) as costs of this complaint. Time for compliance - 45 days from the date on which the copy of this order is made ready for delivery, failing which the entire award amount shall carry interest at the rate of 9 % per annum from the date of default till realization.

    This order is dictated by the President to the Steno-Typist, directly, typed by her and th corrected, signed and pronounced by us in open Commission, today on this 24 day of February 2026.

    Sd/- Sd/-

    P. SHANMUGAPRIYA M. PIRAVI PERUMAL

    Member - I President

    Complainant side witness:-

    PW1 : S. Ramachandran (complainant)

    Documents filed by the complainant:-

    Ex.A1 ----------------- Group Activ Health- Certificate of Insurance for the period from 28.09.2021 to 27.09.2022 Xerox
    Ex.A2 ----------------- Group Activ Health- Certificate of Insurance for the period from 28.09.2022 to 27.09.2023 Xerox
    Ex.A3 ----------------- Group Activ Health- Certificate of Insurance for the period from 28.09.2023 to 27.09.2024 Xerox
    Ex.A4 ----------------- Group Activ Health- Certificate of Insurance for the period from 28.09.2024 to 27.09.2025 Xerox
    Ex.A5 ----------------- Group Activ Health- Policy Terms and Conditions Xerox
    Ex.A6 22.03.2024 Certificate of Authenticity issued by Honey Translation services Xerox
    Ex.A7 16.03.2024 Certificate of Authenticity issued by Honey Translation Xerox

    13

    services
    Ex.A8 31.12.2022 Letter regarding pre-authorization request is denied, to the complainant Xerox
    Ex.A9 16.11.2023 Letter regarding pre-authorization request is denied, to the complainant Xerox
    Ex.A10 17.11.2023 Letter regarding claim could not be processed issued by the opposite parties to the complainant Xerox

    Ex.A9 16.11.2023 Letter regarding pre-authorization request is denied, to Xerox

    Ex.A12 On various dates Gmails sent between the complainant and the opposite parties Xerox
    Ex.A13 25.06.2024 Award No. IO/CHN/R/HI/0303/2024-2025 in the case of complainant and opposite party passed by Insurance ombudsman Xerox
    Ex.A14 08.01.2024 Medical bills issued by Dr. Agarwals Eye Hospital Xerox
    Ex.A15 21.11.2023 Certificate and clarification to provide reimbursement and cash bills issued by Aravind Eye Hospital Xerox
    Ex.A16 26.06.2024 Gmails regarding network hospital near Tirunelveli Xerox
    Ex.A17 22.03.2017 Order in CC No. 199/2014 passed by DCDRF, Chennai(North) Xerox
    Ex.A18 06.07.2023 Order in F. A. No. 214/2018 passed by SCDRC, Chennai Xerox
    Ex.A19 10.04.2024 Order of the NCDRC, New Delhi in the case of Care Health Insruance Limited Vs Harjinder Singh Sohal Xerox

    Opposite parties side witness:- st R.W.1 : Nitin More (Chief Manager of 1 opposite party)

    Document filed by the Opposite parties:- -Nil- Sd/- Sd/-

    P. SHANMUGAPRIYA M. PIRAVI PERUMAL

    Member - I President

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S RAMACHANDRAN S/o. R Y SOUNDARARAJAN v. THE SECRETARIAL TEAM MANAGER
    (Feb 24, 2026)