AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    KHIRA BAG W/o. LATE SRIDHAR BAG v. MD. SHREE JAGANNATH NETRALAYA

    1

    1

    IN THE DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION,

    KALAHANDI, AT: BHAWANIPATNA. ODISHA.

    C. C. No.84 of 2025.

    Date of Filling:-9th

    June 2025.

    Date of Order: 30th

    April 2026.

    CORAM:-

    Shri Aswini Kumar Patra. ……..President. Smt.Jyotsnarani Mishra. …….Member IN THE MATTER OF:-

    Khira Bag, aged about 75 years, W/o : Late Sridhara Bag, At: Pakhnaguda, Po: Charbahal, Ps:, P.S:Koksara, Dist: Kalahandi, Odisha. ……………. Complainant.

    Versus.

    1. Managing Director/Prop.ShreeJagannathNetralaya, A Unit of Vision India Foundation,

    PardeshiPada, Bhawanipatna,

    Dist:Kalahandi,Odisha,766001.

    …………....Opposite party

    Present:-

    For the complainant: Sri Bharat Bhusan Panda, Advocate. For the O.P : Shri P.K.Sahany, Advocate

    2

    JUDGEMENT.

    Sri A.K.Patra, President

    1. The present complaint is filed under Section 35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, alleging medical negligence and deficiency in service against the Opposite Party (OP), "Shree Jagannath Netralaya," resulting in the permanent loss of vision of the complainant.

    2. The complainant seeks the following relief(s):-(i) Direction to the Op to pay compensation of Rs.49,00,000/- for loss of vision and (ii) to pay Rs.80,000/- towards mental agony. (iii) to award Cost of this litigation.

    3. The brief case of the Complainant is that:-The Complainant, an elderly widow, sought treatment for her right eye at the OP's facility. Having already lost vision in her left eye, she relied entirely on the successful treatment of her right eye. She was admitted on 16.10.2024, operated upon on 17.10.2024, and discharged on 18.10.2024.Post-discharge, the complainant realized that she had lost all vision in the operated eye. Despite multiple follow-up visits between 21.10.2024 and 02.11.2024, her vision was not restored. The complainant alleges that the use of her BSKY Health Card (No. 1505811502) resulted in a deduction of Rs. 7,725/-, and she personally incurred expenses of Rs. 60,000 to Rs 70,000/-. She is now 100% disabled as per the Government of India certificate dated 16.01.2025.

    4. The complainant , to substantiate her claim, has filed the following documents:-(i) Original discharge card from "Shree Jagannath Netralaya" dt 18.10.2024, (ii )Photo copy of the disability certificate dt.16.01.2025 showing 100% disability of vision of her both eyes ,(iii) Photocopy of the unique disability ID;0D 357022048008609 dt.16.01.2025 issued by Govt. of India,

    3

    (iv) Original drug prescription dt. 02.11.2024, dt.21.10.2024, dt.24.10.2024 and dt. 31.10.2024 of the Ophthalmologist of the hospital of the opposite party on dt.21.10.2024,(v) Photocopy of the voter ID card of the complainant vide No.OR/14/097/038715,(ix) Photocopy of the Aadhar Card of the complainant vide No.4673 3617 0529,(x) Photocopy of the BSKY card vide No.15050811502. The complaint petition is supported by an affidavit of the complainant .

    5. Defense of the Opposite Party:-The OP failed to file a written version within the statutory period; hence, in light of New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Hilly Multipurpose Cold Storage Ltd., their written defense was not accepted. However, they participated in the hearing and argument.

    6. During course of hearing the complainant filed her evidence on affidavit corroborating the complainant averment and documents. So also she has filed the evidence affidavit of her son Sri. Ugresan Bag who corroborates the complainant averment and documents of the complainant but nothing more. On the other hand the Learned Counsel for the Opposite party filed the evidence affidavit of one Sri.Nursing Tripathy ,MD Jagannath Netralaya, Bhawanipatna. The evidence on affidavit of Op without pleading/Written Version got no meaning.

    7. However, the learned counsel for the Op filed his notes of arguments for proper adjudication of this complainant is taken in to record .Ld. Counsel for the Op argued that, the treatment was provided "free of cost" under a government welfare scheme; therefore, the complainant is not a "consumer" per Indian Medical Association v. V.P. Shantha and that, there was no proof of payment or deduction from the BSKY card. It is further contended that, the disability certificate indicates pre-existing conditions (Corneal Opacity), and no expert opinion was producedby the

    4

    complainant to prove surgical negligence as alleged . Op urged to dismiss the complaint with cost.

    8. Points for Consideration

    i. Is the Complainant a "Consumer" under Section 2(7) of the C.P. Act, 2019?

    ii. Is there a "Deficiency in Service" or "Medical Negligence" by the OP?

    iii. Is the Complainant entitled to the relief sought?

    9. DISCUSS AND FINDINGS WITH ANALYSIS:-

    I. Maintainability and Consumer Status:-

    The OP contends that service rendered free of cost excludes the complainant from the definition of a consumer. However, the complainant has provided her BSKY Card (No. 15050811502)

    details. Under the "Biju Swasthya Kalyan Yojana", the State Government reimburses empaneled private hospitals for services rendered.

    As per the ratio in Indian Medical Association v. V.P. Shantha, where the insurance policy premium or government scheme pays for the treatment, the person remains a "Consumer." The hospital does not provide "free" service; it receives payment from a third party (the Government) for the patient's benefit. Thus, the Complainant is a Consumer underC.P.Act .

    II. Medical Negligence if any:-

    The core of the matter lies in proving negligence. We have perused the Disability Certificate (No. OD3570220480008609) and the Discharge Card.

    5

    Law is well settled that, in a medical negligence cases, the onus is on the complainant to prove a breach of the "Duty of Care." As per Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, a professional may be held liable for negligence if they lack the requisite skill or fail to exercise reasonable competence.

    Here in this case, the complainant has failed to place any expert medical opinion on record to correlate the surgery on 17.10.2024 with the 100% loss of vision. Medical science recognizes that surgeries carry inherent risks, and a "failed" outcome is not automatically "negligent" without proof of deviation from standard protocols.

    III. Observations on evidence forgranting the relief sought:

    The Commission notes with sympathy that, the complainant is an old widow who is now 100% blind. However, a court of law must decide on cogent evidence. The complainant alleged a deduction of Rs. 7,725/- from her BSKY card but failed to produce a transaction statement or a receipt from the hospital. The complainant never tried to bring the record of payment either from the Op or from the related Govt. functionary. Similarly, the claim of spending Rs. 60,000 to Rs.70,000/- on medicines remains un-substantiated by bills.

    10. Conclusion: -While the Commission acknowledges the tragic circumstances of the complainant, the legal requirements for establishing medical negligence under the Consumer Protection Act have not been met. There is no technical evidence placed on the record to prove that the "Bullous Keratopathy" or "Corneal Opacity" mentioned in the records was caused by the surgeon's error/negligence rather than age-related degeneration or known surgical complications. No receipts were filed to prove the specific financial loss or the payment of consideration to the OP.

    6

    11. Under Section 38(6) of the Act, the Commission must decide based on the evidence placed on record. In the absence of a nexus between the OP's action and the blindness, alleged negligence cannot be presumed. This Commission found no merit in the complainant.

    ORDER

    Based on above discussion and findings, this complaint is hereby dismissed. Under the circumstances, no order as to costs is made. Dictated and corrected by me.

    Sd/-(A.K Patra)

    President

    I agree

    Sd/-(J.R Mishra)

    Member

    Pronounced, in the Open Commission today on this 30th

    Day of April 2026 5 under the seal and signature of this Commission. The pending application if any is also stands disposed of accordingly. Judgment could not be pronounced on time in want of Coram . The judgment be uploaded forthwith in the website of the Commission and free copy of this order be supplied to the respective parties or they may download the same from the e-jagriti to treat the same as copy of the order received from this Commission .Ordered accordingly.

    Sd/-(J.R Mishra) Sd/-(A.K Patra)

    Member President

    Memo No. 222 Date. 30.04.2026

    Free Copy to both parties /learned counsel for both parties for their reference. Parties are at liberty to collect the required documents/papers if any from the record within one month of receiving of this order for their future reference. By order of Hon'ble President,

    Sd/-

    . DCDRC, Kalahandi.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    KHIRA BAG W/o. LATE SRIDHAR BAG v. MD. SHREE JAGANNATH NETRALAYA
    (Apr 30, 2026)