Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition

    BASIL THOMAS v. CANARA BANK

    IN THE DEBTS RECOVERY TRIBUNAL-2, KERALA

    AT ERNAKULAM

    PRESENT: SRI.SOVAN KUMAR DASH

    PRESIDING OFFICER

    Dated this the 23rdday of April, 2026

    Securitization Application No.507/2022

    Between Basil Thomas, Aged 51 years, S/o. K.J. Thomas, Kanjirathinkal House, Kollappally,

    Pala - 686 651. …Applicant. And

    1. The Authorised Officer, Canara Bank,

    Chempakathumkal Buildings, Near St.Thomas Press, Pala - 686 575,

    Represented by its Senior Manager.

    2. Canara Bank, Chempakathumkal Buildings, Near St.Thomas Press, Pala - 686 575,

    Represented by its Senior Manager.

    3. Mrs. Jeena Sajeev, W/o. Sajeev Joseph, Chemplayil House, Athinad P.O.,

    Lalam, Kottayam - 686 651. …Defendants This Securitization Application having been heard on 06.03.2026 in the presence of Advocate Mr. Aby George

    1

    SA 507/2022 2 representing Advocate Zakir Hussain for the applicant and Advocate Ms. Ruby P.Paulose for defendant Nos.1 and 2 and Advocate Mr. V.Philip Mathews for defendant Nos.3 and stood over to this day for consideration, the Tribunal delivered the following:

    F I N A L O R D E R

    This SA is filed by the applicant under S.17(1) of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred to as 'the SARFAESI Act') praying to set aside all the securitization measures including the demand notice, possession notice and the sale held on 30.01.2023 in favour of the 3rddefendant.

    Brief facts of the case:

    2.1 Applicant, his wife Mrs.Salma Basil and his brother availed loans separately from the defendant bank by creating security interest over the subject matter property of an extent of

    4.05 Ares in Lalam Village in Kottayam District. The applicant stood as a guarantor in respect of a loan of Rs.25,00,000/- by creating security interest over the property of an extent of 2.72 Ares in the same village. It is claimed that all the loans were availed for cardamom cultivation. Due to default in repayment, the defendant bank proceeded with the securitization measure by issuing demand notice on 18.09.2019 in respect of loan of the applicant, his wife

    2

    SA 507/2022 3 and brother. It is claimed that no reason is assigned by the defendant in classifying the loans as 'NPA'.

    2.2 The applicant claimed that he approached the Manger of the defendant bank to settle the loan by 'OTS' and the first defendant bank agreed for an OTS for an amount of Rs.43,00,000/- But the applicant could not remit the entire amount. He remitted only Rs.8,45,000/- as per OTS and the same was cancelled. Despite representation, the defendant did not reconsider the same. The applicant approached the Hon'ble High Court of Kerala in WP(C) No.27176/2022 which was disposed directing the applicant to submit a fresh proposal for settling the loan account and the defendant was directed to consider the same within one month. Accordingly, the applicant submitted a representation, but the same was not duly considered by the defendant.

    2.3 The defendant issued a possession notice under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act in respect of subject matter property

    2.72 Ares and 4.05 Ares of land on 18.08.2022. It is claimed in the SA that the statutory requirement in issuing possession notices were not duly followed. Hence the possession notices are illegal and the defendant bank cannot proceed further. During pendency of the SA, the defendant issued sale notices on 11.01.2023 in respect of both the items of properties fixing the sale date in respect of 4.05 Ares of land on 30.01.2023 and in respect of other

    3

    SA 507/2022 4 item of property of an extent of 2.72 Ares on 12.02.2023. The applicant claims that the sale notices were not issued as per the statutory requirement. The same was not affixed or published in leading newspapers and hence the sale proceeding is vitiated.

    2.4 The applicant has also alleged that before putting the property for sale, the property valuation of the subject matter property was not taken and the reserve price was fixed without considering the market value of the property. The 3rddefendant, being the neighbor of the applicant, colluded with the Authorised Officer and secretly purchased one item of properties of an extent of 4.05 Ares of land at a bid of Rs.40,10,000/- and also the sale certificate was issued and registered in her favour without the knowledge of the applicant. The property was not sold as per the proper valuation which affects the interest of the applicant over the said property. The applicant has also produced valuation report of the subject matter property which would fetch an amount of Rs.1,25,00,000/-. The 3rddefendant, in collusion with the Authorised Officer, succeeded in purchasing the property at a throw away price which is not legally sustainable. Hence the applicant amended the SA in challenging the sale with a prayer to set aside all the securitization measure including the demand notice, possession notice and the sale held on 30.01.2023 in favour of the 3rddefendant.

    4

    SA 507/2022 5

    3. The defendants no.1 and 2 filed written statement denying the averments and claimed inter alia that all the statutory measures are duly complied in issuing the demand notice as well as possession notice. So also, the sale notices were issued after following all the statutory requirements. Before putting the property for sale valuation from the approved valuer of the bank was taken and accordingly reserve price was fixed. After completion of sale proceeding sale certificate is already issued in favour of the auction purchaser. The same having not challenged within the statutory period of 45 days, the claim of the applicant in respect of such sale is also not legally sustainable. Further all the statutory requirements having been duly complied, the applicant has no right to interfere with the same and hence the SA, being devoid of any merit, may be dismissed.

    4. The 3rddefendant filed a separate written statement in denying the claim of the applicant and claimed that the entire consideration amount was deposited by her after the auction and hence her interest may be protected.

    5. From the respective case of the applicant and defendants, the following points are emerged for adjudication in this case:

    (i) Whether the securitization proceeding initiated by the defendants suffer from any illegality or defect or irregularity to intervene with the same?

    5

    SA 507/2022 6

    (ii) Whether the sale conducted in favour of 3rddefendant suffer from any illegality?

    (iii) Whether the claim of the applicant in respect such sale is barred under law?

    (iv) Whether the applicant is entitled to get any relief in this proceeding?

    FINDINGS:

    Point No.(i):-

    6. There is no dispute that the applicant, his wife and his brother availed separate loans from the defendant bank by mortgaging the subject matter property of an extent of 4.05 Ares of land and also the applicant stood as guarantor for the loan of an amount of Rs.25,00,000/- by mortgaging his separate property of an extent of 2.72 Ares. Due to default in repayment, all the loans turned to 'NPA' as per the details furnished below:-

    Sl. No. Account No. Limit NPA Date
    a) 43591400000224 Rs.10,00,000/- 30.06.2019
    b) 43591400000408 Rs. 5,00,000/- 30.06.2019
    c) 43598010004056 Rs.10,00,000/- 10.06.2019
    d) 43598010003732 Rs.15,00,000/- 30.09.2019
    e) 43598010003885 Rs.15,00,000/- 10.06.2019
    f) 43598010004056 Rs.10,00,000/- 10.06.2019

    7. The demand notices under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act are issued separately for both the items of secured assets calling the applicant to discharge the outstanding amount. It is also

    6

    SA 507/2022 7 seen from the materials on record that due to non-discharge of claim amount, the defendant issued 2 separate possession notices on 18.08.2022 and the relevant documents regarding service of the possession notice, affixture and publication in 'Business Line' and 'Deepika' daily both in English and vernacular language are produced. The applicant claimed generally that all the statutory measures are not duly complied. To disprove such contention the defendant produced all relevant documents showing compliance of the statutory requirement. Hence the contention of the learned counsel for the applicant that non-compliance of the statutory requirement in issuing the possession notices is not acceptable.

    8. Besides the same, the applicant did not raise any objection against the demand notice rather he approached the defendant for 'OTS' which was accepted for an extent of Rs.43,00,000/-. But the applicant remitted part payment and did not comply the terms and conditions of OTS. Hence the OTS was cancelled. The applicant approached the Hon'ble High Court of Kerala in WP(C) No.27176/2022 which was disposed directing the applicant to approach the bank afresh for OTS. The applicant claimed that he approached the defendant by Ext.A5 application but the same was not duly considered by the defendant. The defendants no.1 and 2 claim that the Hon'ble High Court of Kerala

    7

    SA 507/2022 8 directed the applicant to remit 25% of the total dues. But the applicant did not comply the direction nor settled the liabilities. Hence the proposal was not accepted. In such premises, the Tribunal has no jurisdiction to intervene with such OTS proposal nor it can direct the defendant to reconsider the same.

    9. By submitting OTS, it can be presumed that the applicant has voluntarily waived his right to challenge the securitization proceeding and subsequently he cannot turn back and claim that the measure taken under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act is not duly complied as per the statutory requirement or there is any lapse in the securitization proceeding.

    10. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the judgment reported in (2022) 2 SCC 221 in the case of Arce Polymers Private Limited

    v. Alphine Pharmaceuticals Private Limited and others, at paragraph 18 held as follows:-

    "18. ……….. Taking into consideration the entire facts of the case, which perspicuously reflect disingenuous conduct on part of the Borrower to gain indulgence, unfulfilled assurances and promises, their unwillingness to pay, and in light of the law laid down by this Court, we are of the view that the Borrower has waived and is estopped from challenging violation of Section 13(3A) of the SARFAESI Act and hence, the first issue is decided in favour of the Bank………"

    Keeping in view of this ratio, the applicant cannot raise any issue in challenging the securitization measure. In absence of proof of any illegality in the securitization proceeding, the applicant has no valid

    8

    SA 507/2022 9 reason to challenge the demand notice as well as possession notice issued under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act and point No.(i) is answered against the applicant.

    Point Nos.(ii),(iii) & (iv):-

    11. During pendency of the SA the defendant bank issued sale notice on 11.01.2023, marked Annexure-A8 in respect of the property of an extent of 4.05 Ares of land fixing the date of sale on 30.01.2023 at a reserve price of Rs.40 lakhs. The defendant also issued another sale notice Annexure-A9 on 11.01.2023 in respect of other item of property of an extent of 2.72 Ares fixing the sale on 13.02.2023 at a reserve price of 27 lakhs. The sale in respect 2.72 Ares of land did not fructify.

    12. Before putting the property for sale, the defendant obtained valuation report from their approved valuer, marked Annexure-R6 dated 07.10.2022 in respect of 4.05 Ares and another valuation report, marked Annexure-R7 dated 07.10.2022 in respect of the other item of property of an extent of 2.72 Ares. As per the valuation report Annexure-R6, the approved valuer ascertained the present fair market value of the property would be Rs.40 lakhs, realizable value of the property is Rs.36 lakhs and distress value is Rs.32 lakhs. In respect of other item of property, the present fair market value of the same was determined as Rs.26,88,000/-, the

    9

    SA 507/2022 10 realizable value of the property was Rs.24,19,000/- and the distress value is Rs.21,50,000/-. The approved valuer has also obtained fair value certificate in respect of both the properties by searching at the Sub-Registrar office, which are available with the valuation report. Based upon such valuation report, the reserve price was fixed and the property was put to sale.

    13. In respect of 4.05 Ares of land the 3rddefendant was the highest bidder of an amount of Rs.40,10,000/- against the reserve price of Rs.40 lakhs, which is deposited and sale certificate was issued in her favour and registered on 28.12.2023 at the Sub- Registrar Office. The applicant challenged the sale notice Annexures-A8 and A9 by way of amendment on 06.02.2023 by filing IA No.426/2023, which was allowed.

    14. The learned counsel for the applicant raised the following contentions in respect of the sale held in favour of defendant No.3 on the following grounds: -

    (1). All the statutory requirements in issuing the sale notice were not duly complied and Rule 8(6) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules is violated.

    (11) The property was put to sale at a nominal price without ascertaining the market value of the property and hence the sale is vitiated.

    10

    SA 507/2022 11

    15. To refute the contentions, the learned counsel for the defendant bank produced Annexure R3, R4 & R4(a) and R5 & R5(a) documents showing service of sale notice, publications in two daily newspapers, both in Malayalam and English language and affixture of the sale notice at the subject matter property along with an affidavit of the Authorised Officer. No counter affidavit is seen filed by the applicant in denying the same. In absence of counter proof affidavit, the contention of the learned counsel for the applicant regarding non-compliance of the statutory requirement is not acceptable.

    16. The learned counsel for the applicant also contended that there is no clear notice to the applicant before putting the property for sale. Hence the same violates Rule 8(6) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the defendant would contend that the impugned sale notice is not the first sale notice and it is subsequent sale notice. Rule 9(1) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules postulates that it is necessary on the part of the Authorised Officer to serve, affix and publish notice of sale, not less than 15 days to the borrower for any subsequent sale. It is not required to serve 30 days' notice to the applicant before putting the property for sale in pursuance to subsequent sale notice. The relevant documents produced by the

    11

    SA 507/2022 12 defendants indicate compliance of all the statutory requirements in putting the property for sale and hence the contention of the learned counsel for the applicant on this aspect has no force.

    17. In respect of the other item of property, the defendant produced all the relevant documents regarding compliance of statutory requirement. But the same did not fructify. In such premises, challenge to such sale notice in this proceeding renders infructuous.

    18. The defendant produced valuation report in respect of

    4.05 Ares of land, marked Annexure-R6, which indicates that the approved valuer has obtained GLR (Guideline rate) from the office of the Sub-Registrar. Fair value certificate is also produced. By adopting GLR, the valuation of the property was determined as Rs.12,46,450/-. In column 5 of the valuation report, the approved valuer has taken the valuation of the property as Rs.4,00,000/- per cent and the total valuation of the property is ascertained as Rs.40,00,000/-. In the report the approved valuer has stated that no transaction was found in the locality prior to determination of valuation. He ascertained the valuation after considering the characteristics of the plot and value of land by adopting PMR. He concluded that the market value of the property is Rs.40 lakhs, realizable value of the property is Rs.36 lakhs and distress value is

    12

    SA 507/2022 13 Rs.32 lakhs. Accordingly, the reserve price was fixed by the Authorised Officer on the basis of market value of the property as Rs.40 lakhs. The Addl. defendant no.3 purchased the said property at an offer price of Rs.40,10,000/- which is above the reserve price.

    19. The learned counsel for the applicant would contend that valuation report obtained from registered valuer of Government of Kerala as Engineer A-Grade are produced marked Annexures A-11 and A12 which indicate that the valuation of 4.05 Ares of land would be Rs.1,20,00,328 and Rs.1,05,09,750/- respectively. In both the valuation reports, nothing is mentioned about the Government valuation and how the valuers determined the market value of the subject matter property. In absence of the same, such valuation reports cannot be accepted as correct valuation to discard the valuation report obtained by the defendant nos.1 and 2 from the approved valuer who is registered under Section 34 AB of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957.

    20. In a Judgment of the Hon'ble High Court of Judicature at Madras in the case of M/s. Lucky Footwear Components v. The Authorised Officer, Indian Bank (Judgment dated 29.10.2025 in C.R.P.No.5237 of 2025) at paragraph 11, it was held as follows:-

    "11……………..The case of the bank that the secured asset was valued by approved valuer of the bank, who is a registered valuer under Section 34AB of the Wealth-Tax Act, 1957, has not been

    13

    SA 507/2022 14 disputed by the petitioners. The case of the petitioners seems to be that according to their own valuer, the value of the property is much more. The petitioners rely upon the report of the approved surveyor, who does not appear to be an approved valuer registered under Section 34AB of the Wealth-Tax Act."

    Accordingly, the Hon'ble High Court of Judicature at Madras has accepted the valuation of the approved valuer of the bank who is registered under Section 34 AB of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957.

    21. The valuers engaged by the applicant have not stated that they are registered under Section 34 AB of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957 and also their valuation reports do not indicate how they ascertained the valuation of the property. Hence the valuation report obtained by the bank from the approved valuer, having more authentic, supersedes the valuation reports produced by the applicant. There is no other illegality in any manner in putting the property for sale at the valuation determined by the approved valuer. Hence the contention of the learned counsel for the applicant has no force and acceptable.

    22. Learned counsel for the defendant contended that the claim against the sale is barred by limitation as the applicant has not challenged the sale within 45 days of the issuance of sale certificate. It is seen from the proceeding that the applicant filed amendment application bearing IA.No.426/2023 in challenging the sale notice on 06.02.2023 which is within 45 days from the date of

    14

    SA 507/2022 15 issuance of sale notice dated 11.01.2023 and the date of sale on 30.01.2023. Hence, the claim of the applicant is not barred under law of limitation. But, as the applicant has failed to establish any illegality or irregularity in the securitization proceeding as well as in the sale proceeding, he is not entitled to get any relief in this SA. Hence all the points are answered accordingly.

    Hence it is ordered:-

    ORDER

    23. In view of the foregoing reasons, this SA, being devoid of any merit, is hereby dismissed with costs of Rs.20,000/- (Rupees twenty thousand only) payable by the applicant to the defendants proportionately due to delay caused by him in the securitization proceeding without any valid reason.

    (Dictated to Steno, corrected and pronounced by me in the open Tribunal on this the 23rd day of April, 2026).

    [SOVAN KUMAR DASH]

    PRESIDING OFFICER

    15

    Documents on the part of the applicant Annexures Date Particulars of documents

    Annexure-A1 18.09.2019 True copy of the demand notice issued by the Authorised Officer, Syndicate Bank.

    Annexure-A2 04.10.2019 True copy of the demand notice issued by the Authorised Officer, Syndicate Bank.

    Annexure-A3 12.08.2022 True copy of representation submitted by the applicant.

    Annexure-A4 True copy of the Judgment in W.P.(C) No.27176 of 2022.

    Annexure-A5 27.09.2022 True copy of the representation submitted by the applicant for One Time Settlement.

    Annexure-A6 18.08.2022 True copy of the possession notice affixed by the 1stdefendant.

    Annexure-A7 18.08.2022 True copy of the possession notice affixed by the 1stdefendant.

    Annexure-A8 11.01.2023 True copy of the sale notice issued by the 1stdefendant for the sale of 4.05 Ares of

    property.

    Annexure-A9 11.01.2023 True copy of the sale notice issued by the 1stdefendant for the sale of 2.72 Ares of

    property and a building therein.

    Annexure-A10 28.12.2023 True copy of the sale certificate registered as document No.2759/1/2023 of Meenachil

    Sub Registry Office.

    Annexure-A11 True copy of the valuation report of the approved valuer Mr.Sajan C., MIE,

    Engineer-A, Registration No.C1-4418

    /2000/138/EA, Madathil, Ullanad P.O.

    Annexure-A12 True copy of the valuation report of the approved valuer Mrs.Anila Saju, Engineer-

    A, Registration No.G6/2113/17/207/EA, C-

    21, Joseph Arcade, Palai.

    16

    Documents on the part of the defendant Nos.1 and 2 Annexures Date Particulars of documents

    Annexure-R1 19.08.2022 True copies of paper publications in & 1(a) Business Line and Deepika Daily.

    Annexure-R2 True copies of photographs of affixture of & R2(a) possession notice in respect of 4.05 and

    2.72 Ares. Annexure-R3 11.01.2023 True copy of acknowledgment card for proof of serving sale notice.

    Annexure-R4 13.01.2023 True copies of paper publication in & R4(a) Mathrubhumi Daily and The Hindu.

    Annexure-R5 10.01.2023 True copies of photographs of affixture of & R5(a) sale notice.

    Annexure-R6 07.10.2022 Valuation report in respect of 4.05 Ares of property.

    Annexure-R7 07.10.2022 Valuation report in respect of 2.72 Ares of property.

    Annexure-R8 21.10.2022 True copy of acknowledgment card for proof of serving sale notice.

    Annexure-R9 23.10.2022 True copies of paper publication in & R9(a) Mathrubhumi Daily and The Hindu.

    Annexure-R10 21.10.2022 True copy of photographs of affixture of sale and affixture report notice.

    Annexure-R11 Copy of CERSAI Certificate in respect of secured assets.

    Documents on the part of the defendant No.3 … NIL

    PRESIDING OFFICER

    17

    IN THE DEBTS RECOVERY TRIBUNAL-2,

    KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

    PRESENT: SRI.SOVAN KUMAR DASH

    PRESIDING OFFICER

    Dated the 23rdApril, 2026

    SA No.507/2022

    Between Basil Thomas, Aged 51 years, S/o. K.J.Thomas, Kanjirathinkal House, Kollappally, Pala - 686 651. …Applicant And

    The Authorised Officer,

    Canara Bank,

    Chempakathumkal Buildings,

    Near St.Thomas Press,

    Pala - 686 575,

    Represented by

    its Senior Manager & 2 Ors. …Defendants

    FINAL ORDER

    18

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    BASIL THOMAS v. CANARA BANK
    (Apr 23, 2026)