Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Acts
  • SECTION 19 ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS ACT 1985
  • rule 11 of the CCS (CCA) Rules.
  • clause (b) of sub-rule (1) of rule 16 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 makes provisions
  • Rule 11 of CCS Conduct Rules,
  • rule 16 (1) (b) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965,
  • sub-rules (3) to (23) of rule 14
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Acts
  • SECTION 19 ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS ACT 1985
  • rule 11 of the CCS (CCA) Rules.
  • clause (b) of sub-rule (1) of rule 16 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 makes provisions
  • Rule 11 of CCS Conduct Rules,
  • rule 16 (1) (b) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965,
  • sub-rules (3) to (23) of rule 14
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    MAHESH KUMAR v. GOVT. OF NCTD

    1

    O.A. No. 89/2016 (C-III, item -26) Central Administrative Tribunal Principal Bench: New Delhi O.A. No. 89/2016

    Reserved on: 17.02.2026 Pronounced on: 12.03.2026 Hon'ble Mr. Manish Garg, Member (J) Hon'ble Mr. B. Anand, Member (A) Mahesh Kumar S/o Lakhi Ram HC in Delhi Police,

    PIS No.28862362,

    Aged about 49 Years

    R/o Vill : Majra Kath,

    Tehsil : Neemrana,

    Alwar, Rajasthan

    …Applicant

    (By Advocate: Mr. Anil Singhal) Versus

    1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi Through Commissioner of Police, PHQ, IP Estate, New Delhi.

    2. Joint. C. P (HQ) PHQ, IP Estate, New Delhi. …Respondents

    (By Advocate: Mr. Hanu Bhaskar)

    2

    ORDER

    By Hon'ble Mr. Manish Garg, Member (J) In the present Original Application filed under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, the applicant has prayed for the following reliefs:-

    1. "To quash and set aside the impugned orders dated 16.12.2013, 28.10.2014, and 20.07.2015, along with all consequential benefits.

    2. To direct the respondents to hold Review DPC to reconsider the case of the applicant for inclusion of his name to the Promotion List 'D-I' with effect from 26.09.2013, in view of the changed circumstances, i.e., the award of punishment of censure on 22.11.2005, when the DE was initiated, since the punishment will relate back to 22.11.2005 for the purpose of promotion as per the Judgment dated 06.08.2010. Secondly, the name of the applicant was not on any Secret List as on 26.09.2013, as his name had already been removed from the Secret List with effect from 22.11.2005 vide Order dated

    25.02.2015.

    3. To direct the respondents to hold Review DPC to reconsider the case of the applicant for inclusion of his name in Promotion List 'D-I' with effect from 27.10.2014, in view of the changed circumstances, i.e., the award of punishment of censure on 22.11.2005, when the DE was initiated, since the punishment will relate back to 22.11.2005 for the purpose of promotion as per the Judgment dated 06.08.2010. Secondly, the name of the applicant not being on any Secret List as on 27.10.2014, since his name has already removed from the Secret List with effect from 22.11.2005 vide Order dated

    25.02.2015.

    4. To direct the respondents to promote the applicant to the rank of ASI on an ad hoc as well as regular basis with effect from the date his immediate junior was so promoted in pursuance to Order dated 16.12.2013 and/or Order dated 28.10.2014, along with all consequential benefits.

    5. To award costs in favour of the applicant and to pass any other order or orders which this Hon'ble Tribunal may deem just and equitable in the facts and circumstances of the case."

    2. Highlighting the facts of the case, learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the present Original

    3

    Application has been filed challenging the impugned orders dated 16.12.2013, 28.10.2014 and 20.07.2015 whereby the applicant's case for promotion to the post of ASI was first kept in sealed cover and subsequently he was declared

    "unfit" solely on account of a prolonged departmental enquiry initiated on 22.11.2005, which ultimately culminated only in a minor penalty of censure dated

    21.02.2014.

    2.1. Learned counsel for the applicant further submitted that the applicant had already been acquitted in the criminal case and no adverse ACR was ever communicated to him. Further, his name stood removed from the Secret List with retrospective effect from 22.11.2005.

    2.2. Learned counsel contended that in view of the law laid down by the High Court of Delhi in W.P.(C) No. 3306/2010 - Union of India & Anr. vs. Dr. A.K. Khare & Anr. dated 06.08.2010, the minor punishment, though prospective, relates back to the date of initiation of the departmental enquiry and therefore could not legally operate to deny the applicant consideration for inclusion in Promotion List 'D-1' from 26.09.2013 and 27.10.2014; the said judgment was carried upto the level of Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in SLP (C) CC No. 3932/2011 and

    4

    was dismissed vide order dated 07.03.2011, and the said decision has also been followed in O.A. No. 4643/2018.

    2.3. Learned counsel thus argued that the core issue in the present matter is the arbitrary and illegal denial of promotion despite changed circumstances, non- communication of adverse material, and misapplication of the sealed cover procedure, thereby warranting a review DPC and grant of consequential benefits.

    3. Opposing the Original Application, learned counsel for the respondents refuted the applicant's contentions, submitting that the applicant's case was rightly kept in sealed cover by the DPC held on 26.09.2013 due to the pendency of the departmental enquiry dated 22.11.2005 and his inclusion in the Secret List and Agreed List, and that his case could not be considered prior to the culmination of proceedings as he fell within the doubtful category.

    3.1. Learned counsel further contended that although the applicant was acquitted in FIR No.123/03 and the departmental enquiry culminated in a penalty of censure dated 21.02.2014 on corruption charges, the Government of India Instructions on Departmental Promotion Committee (para 17.6.2) clearly provide that where any penalty is imposed, the findings in the sealed cover cannot be acted upon and the case is to be considered by the next DPC in the

    5

    normal course having regard to the penalty. Learned counsel further submitted that as per para 3 of Standing Order No. A-44 (copy of which is not placed on record), an officer awarded a minor punishment within the preceding five years on corruption or mora2l turpitude charges is not to be empanelled; accordingly, the DPC held on 27.10.2014 and subsequent DPCs in 2015 and 2016 found him "unfit" in view of the censure, and these findings have not been challenged.

    3.2. Learned counsel for the respondents further submitted that though the applicant was eventually found fit in 2017, the sealed cover could not be opened and the subsequent unfit assessments remain unassailed, and as the censure on corruption charges continues on record despite removal of his name from the Secret List, his claim for retrospective promotion cannot be granted, and he was duly informed vide reasoned U.O. dated 20.07.2015.

    4. Heard learned counsel for the respective parties and perused the pleadings available on record.

    5. ANALYSIS :

    5.1. In State of Punjab and others v. Lal Goyal, reported in (1995) 2 SCC 570, the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India was dealing with a situation where, owing to inordinate delay and uncertainty in the conclusion of

    6

    departmental proceedings, the sealed cover procedure was adopted. In paragraph 12 of the judgment, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under:-

    "12. Applying the balancing process, we are of the opinion that the quashing of charges and of the order appointing en- quiry officer was not warranted in the facts and circumstances of the case. It is more appropriate and in the interest of justice as well as in the interest of administration that the enquiry which had proceeded to a large extent be allowed to be completed. At the same time, it is directed that the respondent should be considered forthwith for promotion without reference to and without taking into consideration the charges or the pendency of the said enquiry and if he is found fit for promotion, he should be promoted immediately. Ibis direction is made in the particular facts and circumstances of the case though we are aware that the Rules and practice normally followed in such cases may be different. "

    5.2. The rule position with regard to the impact of the penalty of censure is as under:-

    (1) Enquiry mandatory in certain types of the penalty of withholding of increments:-

    It has been decided in the meeting of National Council held on the 6th and 7th November, 1967, that in cases where increments are withheld for a period of more than three years or where increments are stopped with cumulative effect or where such stoppage is likely to affect adversely the pensionary entitlement, the procedure of holding an enquiry should invariably be followed.

    As the Ministry of Finance etc. are aware, clause (b) of sub-rule

    (1) of rule 16 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 makes provisions for holding an enquiry in the manner laid down in sub-rules (3) to

    (23) of rule 14 ibid in every case in which the disciplinary authority is of the opinion that such an inquiry is necessary. In view of the decision of the National Council, mentioned in the preceding paragraph, it has been decided that, notwithstanding the provision contained in rule 16 (1) (b) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, if in a case it is proposed, after considering that representation, if any, submitted by a Government servant, to withhold increments of pay for a period exceeding three years or to withhold increments of pay with cumulative effect for any period or if the penalty of withholding of increments is likely to affect adversely the amount of pension payable to the Government servant, an enquiry shall invariably be held in the manner laid down in sub-rules (3) to (23) of rule 14 ibid. [MHA OM No. 7/3/67-Ests. (A) dated the 19th January, 1968]

    7

    (7) Promotion of employees on whom any penalty has been imposed -

    The Staff Side of the National Council, at its meeting held on 27thand the 28thJanuaray,1971 raised the following points :-

    (i) 'Censure' should not be a bar to eligibility to sit for a departmental/promotional examination or for promotion;

    (ii) Where the responsibility of an employee for any loss is indirect, he should not be debarred from being considered for promotion during the period of recovery of the loss; and

    (iii) A distinction should be made between stoppage of increments and reduction to a lower stage of the pay scale and in the former type of cases, the employees should not be debarred from being considered for promotion.

    2. As regards the first point, under existing instructions, every person eligible for promotion and in the field of choice has to be considered for promotion. The fact of the imposition of the minor penalty of censure on a Government servant does not by itself stand against the consideration of such person for promotion, as his fitness for the promotion has to be judged, in the case of promotion by seniority, on the basis of an overall assessment of his service record, and in the case of promotion by selection on merit, on the basis of his merit categorisation which is again based upon an overall assessment of his service record. So far as the eligibility of a Government servant who has been awarded the penalty of censure, to appear at a departmental/promotional examination is concerned, the same principles would apply, viz. that he cannot, merely because of the penalty of censure, be debarred from appearing at such an examination. In case, however, the rules of such an examination lay down that only those eligible persons can be allowed to appear at the examination who are considered to be fit for the purpose, the fitness of an eligible candidate, who has been awarded the penalty of censure, to appear at the examination has to be considered on the basis of an overall assessment of his service record and not merely on the basis of the penalty of censure.

    3. As regards the other two points mentioned in paragraph 1 above, while it is not possible to lay down any hard and fast rules in this regard, and it is for the competent authority to take a decision in each case having regard to its facts and circumstances, it is considered necessary to reiterate the existing instructions on the subject. Recovery from the pay of a Government servant of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused by him to Government by negligence or breach of orders, or withholding of increments of pay, are also minor penalties laid down in rule 11 of the CCS (CCA) Rules. As in the case of promotion of a Government servant, who has been awarded the penalty of censure, the penalty of recovery from his pay of the loss caused by him to Government or of withholding his increment(s) does not stand in the way of his consideration for promotion though in the latter case promotion is not given effect to during the currency of the

    8

    penalty. While, therefore, the fact of the imposition of such a penalty does not by itself debar the Government servant concerned from being considered for promotion, it is also taken into account by the Departmental Promotion Committee, or the competent authority, as the case may be, in the overall assessment of his service record for judging his suitability or otherwise for promotion or his fitness for admission to a departmental/promotional examination (where fitness of the candidates is a condition precedent to such admission). [Cabinet Sectt.(Department of Personnel) OM No. 21/5/70- Ests.(A) dated the 15thMay, 1971].

    (7A)

    The attention of the Ministry of Finance etc. is invited to MHA OM No. 39/3/59-Estt.(A) dated 31.08.1960, OM No. 7/28/63- Estt.(A) dated 22.12.1964 and OM No. 22011/3/77-Estt.(A) dated 14.07.1977 [since revised and consolidated vide OM No. 22011/4/91-Estt.(A) dated 14.09.1992] which lay down the guide-lines for following the 'sealed cover' procedure and for granting benefits with retrospective effect on the "complete exoneration" of the official concerned. The scope of the term

    "complete exoneration" was very wide, resulting in denial of benefits even to those who had not been awarded any of the prescribed penalties as a result of disciplinary proceedings but were only issued a warning. There is also in vogue the practice of issuing "recordable warning" to Government employees which affect their career prospects. The matter has, therefore, been examined carefully and the following decisions have been taken :-

    (i) As clarified in the Ministry of Home Affairs OM No. 39/21/56-Estt.(A) dated 13.12.1956, warning is administered by any authority superior to a Government employee in the event of minor lapses like negligence, carelessness, lack of thoroughness, delay etc. It is an administrative device in the hands of superior authorities for cautioning the Government employees with a view to toning up efficiency and maintaining discipline. There is, therefore, no objection to the continuance of this system. However, where a copy of the warning is also kept in the Confidential Report dossier, it will be taken to constitutes an adverse entry and the officer so warned will have the right to represent against the same in accordance with the existing instruction relating to communication of adverse remarks and consideration of representations against them.

    (ii) Where a departmental proceeding has been completed and it is considered that the officer concerned deserves to be penalised, he should be awarded one of the recognized statutory penalties as given in Rule 11 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. In such a situation, a recordable warning should not be issued as it would for all practical purposes, amount to a "censure" which is a formal punishment and which can only be awarded by a competent disciplinary authority after following the procedure prescribed in the relevant disciplinary rules. The Delhi High Court has, in the case of Nadhan Singh

    9

    Vs. Union of India also expressed the view that warning kept in the CR dossier has all the attributes of "censure". In the circumstances, as already stated, where it is considered after the conclusion of disciplinary proceedings that some blame attached to the officer concerned which necessitates cognizance of such fact the disciplinary authority should award the penalty of "censure" at least. If the intention of the disciplinary authority is not to award a penalty of "censure", then no recordable warning should be awarded. There is no restriction on the right of the disciplinary authority to administer oral warnings or even warnings in writing which do not form part of the character roll.

    (iii) Where the departmental proceedings have ended with the imposition of a minor penalty, viz, censure, recovery of pecuniary loss to the Government, withholding of increments of pay and withholding of promotion, the recommendation of the DPC in favour of the employee, kept in the sealed cover, will not be given effect to. But the case of the employee concerned for promotion/confirmation may be considered by the next DPC when it meets after the conclusion of the departmental proceedings. If the findings of the DPC are in favour of the employee, he may be promoted in his turn if the penalty is that of "censure" or "recovery of pecuniary loss caused to the Government by negligence or breach of orders", In the case of employees who have been awarded the minor penalty of

    "withholding of increments" or "withholding of promotion"

    promotion can be made only after the expiry of the penalty.

    (iv) If a recordable warning has been issued to an officer as a result of disciplinary proceedings before the issue of this Office Memorandum and the case of the officer concerned for promotion is still under consideration, he should be treated as having been "censured". The officer will also have the right of representation against such warning and such representation shall be dealt with by the competent authority as if it were an appeal under the relevant disciplinary rules.

    [Deptt. of Peronnel & A.R. O.M. No. 22011/2/78-Estt.(A) dated the 16thFebruary, 1979]

    5.3. The only question that now falls for consideration is the impact of the imposition of a minor penalty of censure upon the applicant. The Delhi Police Rules are silent on the specific consequences of such a penalty, except to the extent that it has been reflected in his record as "Indifferent Service Record."

    10

    5.4. Whenever the relevant service rules are silent on a particular aspect, the provisions of the CCS Rules and the clarifications issued thereunder, being model rules, are required to be followed. The question, therefore, that arises for determination is whether, and from which date, the applicant would be entitled to promotion in a case where only a minor penalty of "Censure" has been imposed.

    5.5. Rule 5(viii) of the Delhi Police (Punishment and Appeal) Rules, 1980 enumerates "censure" as one of the prescribed penalties. Under Rule 6, the punishment mentioned at Serial No. (viii) is classified as a "minor punishment" and may be awarded by the authorities specified in sub-section (i) of Section 21 of the Delhi Police Act, 1978, after issuance of a show cause notice, grant of reasonable opportunity to submit a written reply, and consideration of oral representation, if sought. Rule 12 also contemplates situations where, despite acquittal in a criminal trial—for instance, on account of non- identification—the Disciplinary Authority may still form an opinion regarding the conduct of the delinquent and impose a minor penalty such as censure. In the present case, the penalty of censure itself has not been challenged; rather, the limited issue raised concerns the effect of such minor penalty on the applicant's entitlement to promotion.

    11

    5.6. A plain reading of the expression "Indifferent Service Record" may give the impression that the penalty of censure is not akin to withholding of increment or withholding of promotion, both being distinct and separate penalties. However, a clear distinction must be drawn between denial of promotion as a substantive penalty and postponement or keeping promotion in abeyance during the currency of a punishment. Where sealed cover procedure is adopted and promotion is deferred on account of the currency of a penalty, the recommendations of the Selection Committee remain in a sealed cover and are not acted upon. Even a penalty of censure, during its operative currency, renders the officer blameworthy for that period, and consequently his eligibility for promotion effectively arises only after the currency of the penalty is over. During such currency, promotion stands deferred, which may incidentally result in deferment of seniority and consequential delay in promotion. Such deferment, being a natural consequence of the penalty and the applicable procedure, cannot be assailed as amounting to double jeopardy.

    5.7 The Government of India recommendations in this regard are as follows:

    12

    Promotion of employees on whom any penalty has been imposed-

    The Staff Side of the National Council, at its meeting held on 27th and the 28th January 1997 raised the following points:

    (i) Censure should not be a bar to eligibility to sit for a departmental/promotional examination or for promotion.

    (ii) Where the responsibility of an employee for any loss is indirect, he should not be debarred from being considered for promotion during the period of recovery of the loss; and

    (iii) A distinction should be made between stoppage of increments and reduction to a lower stage of the pay scale and in the former type of cases, should not be debarred from being considered for promotion. It is uncontested that where the DP conduct Rules are silent, the provisions of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 will apply as provided below:-

    Rule 11

    (i) Censure.

    (ii) Withholding of his promotion.

    (iii) Recovery from his pay of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused by him to the Government by negligence or breach of orders.

    (iv) Withholding of increments of pay. From the above clarification issued by the DOPT from time to time, it does appear that the currency of punishment is no bar to promotion but there is a distinction between denial of promotion and deferment/keeping in abeyance.

    5.8 The clarification has been issued vide [Cabinet Sectt.(Department of Personnel) OM No. 21/5/70-Ests.(A) dated the 15thMay, 1971]., wherein it has been clearly spelled

    13

    out as under that , every person eligible for promotion and in the field of choice has to be considered for promotion. The fact of the imposition of the minor penalty of censure on a Government servant does not by itself stand against the consideration of such person for promotion, as his fitness for the promotion has to be judged, in the case of promotion by seniority, on the basis of an overall assessment of his service record, and in the case of promotion by selection on merit, on the basis of his merit categorisation which is again based upon an overall assessment of his service record. So far as the eligibility of a Government servant who has been awarded the penalty of censure, to appear at a departmental/promotional examination is concerned, the same principles would apply, viz. that he cannot, merely because of the penalty of censure, be debarred from appearing at such an examination. In case, however, the rules of such an examination lay down that only those eligible persons can be allowed to appear at the examination who are considered to be fit for the purpose, the fitness of an eligible candidate who has been awarded the penalty of censure, to appear at the examination has to be considered on the basis of an overall assessment of his service record and not merely on the basis of the penalty of censure. ( Ref :[Cabinet Sectt.(Department of Personnel) OM No. 21/5/70-

    14

    Ests.(A) dated the 15thMay, 1971]. Further it has been clarified that Where the departmental proceedings have ended with the imposition of a minor penalty, viz, censure, recovery of pecuniary loss to the Government, withholding of increments of pay and withholding of promotion, the recommendation of the DPC in favor of the employee, kept in the sealed cover, will not be given effect to. But the case of the employee concerned for promotion/confirmation may be considered by the next DPC when it meets after the conclusion of the departmental proceedings. If the findings of the DPC are in favour of the employee, he may be promoted in his turn if the penalty is that of "censure" or

    "recovery of pecuniary loss caused to the Government by negligence or breach of orders", ( Ref: Vide [Deptt. of Peronnel & A.R. O.M. No. 22011/2/78-Estt.(A) dated the 16thFebruary, 1979].

    5.9 As in the case of the promotion of a government servant who has been awarded the penalty of censure, the penalty of recovery from his pay of the loss caused by him to the Government or of withholding his increment(s) does not stand in the way of his consideration for promotion, though in the latter case promotion is not given effect to during the currency of the penalty (emphasis supplied). The present

    15

    case is that of the imposition of the punishment of censure only.

    5.10 In the present set of circumstances of the case, one cannot ignore that since the applicant suffered incarceration due to long-pending inquiry proceedings since 2005 and the name of the applicant had been kept in the Secret List, the question of withholding of increment or promotion does not arise in his case, more so keeping in view of the fact that the Disciplinary Authority imposed the punishment to that of

    "Censure" only .

    5.11 At best, the case of the applicant would have fallen to a certain extent in light of the explanation carved out under Rule 11 of CCS Conduct Rules, which reads as under:-

    "The following shall not amount to a penalty within the meaning of this rule, namely:

    (iii) non-promotion of a Government servant, whether in a substantive or officiating capacity, after consideration of his case', to a Service, grade or post for promotion to which he is eligible."

    5.12 The applicant was acquitted in FIR No.123/2003 on 28.6.2010. The applicant was awarded a minor penalty of censure on 21.2.2014. The currency and effect of the minor penalty is otherwise six months, which ought to have ended on 20.08.2014. On the date of the DPC held on 27.10.2014 , the effect of the censure penalty had already otherwise expired by efflux of time.

    16

    6. CONCLUSION :

    6.1. In view of the foregoing, this Tribunal holds that the minor penalty of censure imposed on the applicant cannot operate as a bar to his promotion. Accordingly, the OA is allowed, and the respondents are directed to convene a Review DPC meeting in respect of the DPC held on 27.10.2014 by opening the sealed cover; if the applicant is found otherwise eligible, the consequential promotion orders shall be issued. The respondents shall also undertake the appropriate exercise for re-fixation of pay and grant of seniority on a notional basis, placing the applicant at par with his immediate junior. The entire exercise shall be completed within two months from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this order.

    6.2. Pending M.A.(s), if any, shall stand disposed of. No costs.

    (B. Anand) (Manish Garg)

    Member (A) Member (J)

    /as/

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    MAHESH KUMAR v. GOVT. OF NCTD
    (Mar 12, 2026)