Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2026 MPHC-GWL 6511
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2026 MPHC-GWL 6511
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was appointed as a Peon (Class-IV employee) in the respondent School on 08.07.1984 and had completed 28 years of service. A charge-sheet was issued against the petitioner, and according to the petitioner the list of witnesses and documents was not supplied; an inquiry was thereafter conducted in which, he contends, proper opportunity of hearing was not afforded, leading to termination of his services. The petitioner approached the Labour Commissioner/Labour Court, which rejected his claim and upheld the dismissal. The petitioner filed this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking, inter alia, reinstatement, back wages and consequential reliefs (see prayers 7.1–7.3 reproduced in the petition).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the domestic inquiry conducted against the petitioner complied with the principles of natural justice (adequacy of notice, supply of documents/witness list, opportunity to be heard and to lead defence evidence).
  2. Whether the appointment of a junior/colleague-advocate of the employer as Inquiry Officer rendered the inquiry invalid.
  3. Whether the Labour Court's award upholding termination is amenable to interference by this Court in exercise of supervisory jurisdiction under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution.
  4. Whether the standard of proof applicable to the domestic inquiry should be akin to a criminal trial.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Petitioner was terminated without proper opportunity of hearing and without a fair inquiry; documents and management witness statements were not supplied.
  • No seizure memo, panchnama or map of place of alleged recovery were prepared; no items were recovered from petitioner.
  • Petitioner, being illiterate, was not allowed assistance to have statements read/explained and his signatures were obtained on papers he did not understand.
  • A junior/colleague-advocate of the employer was appointed as Inquiry Officer with mala fide intention; no opportunity was granted to engage an advocate during inquiry.
  • Labour Court failed to consider the written submissions of petitioner. Reliance placed on judgments including Prem Nath Bali, Chatrapal v. State of Uttar Pradesh, and Indian Bank v. Praveen Kumar.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The inquiry was conducted in accordance with the Rules of the Scindia School and the Standing Orders; those Rules do not require documents to be annexed to the charge-sheet.
  • The charge-sheet was duly served; documents were supplied (Labour Court observed so) and a video CD was furnished on 27.08.2014 as directed.
  • Petitioner admitted the charges in his reply to the charge-sheet (Ex.2) and to the show-cause notice; petitioner suppressed material facts.
  • The Labour Court recorded that proper opportunity to lead defence evidence was afforded; petitioner did not place complete statements on record.
  • Appointment of a colleague-advocate as Inquiry Officer was made per Service Rules and is permissible; the inquiry was a domestic in-house inquiry, not a civil or criminal trial, and the applicable standard of proof is governed by Service Rules.
  • Termination was for serious misconduct (selling tobacco, cigarettes, bidi, gutka within school premises) and punishment was commensurate; scope for interference under Article 227 is limited.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Prem Nath Bali v. Registrar, High Court of Delhi and another AIR 2016 SC 101 Relied on by petitioner regarding fairness of inquiry and related principles. The Court held the judgment relied upon is not applicable to the present case because action against petitioner was in accordance with Service Rules and petitioner had admitted guilt.
Chatrapal v. State of Uttar Pradesh reported in 2024 (I) MPWN 48 Relied on by petitioner (as authority on inquiry/fairness). The Court found this authority inapplicable on the facts since the petitioner admitted guilt and Service Rules were followed.
Indian Bank and others v. Shri Praveen Kumar Relied on by petitioner (authority cited). The Court held the ratio of this judgment has no application to the facts of the present case.
Iswarlal Mohanlal Thakkar Vs. Paschim Gujrat Vij Company Ltd. & Anr. (Civil Appeal No.4558 of 2014) Consideration of the scope of interference by High Court in awards/orders of Labour Court (Article 227). Cited to explain and constrain interference by this Court with the Labour Court's findings absent serious error of law or perversity.
Shalini Shyam Shetty v. Rajendra Shankar Patil [(2010) 8 SCC 329 : (2010) 3 SCC (Civ) 338] Limits on High Court's interference under Article 227; exercise of power to be kept to minimum. Quoted to reinforce that the High Court should not reappreciate evidence and must exercise superintendence with caution.
Harjinder Singh v. Punjab State Warehousing Corporation [(2010) 3 SCC 192 : (2010) 1 SCC (L&S) 1146] Illustration of jurisdictional error where High Court unjustifiably interfered with Labour Court award. Cited to demonstrate circumstances where interference by High Court is improper; used to support restrained approach here.
Jai Singh and Others Vs. Municipal Corporation of Delhi and Another (2010) 9 SCC 385 Nature and scope of Article 227; well-recognised principles governing High Court superintendence. Quoted at length; relied upon to emphasize that Article 227 must be exercised with great care and not as an appellate power to correct all errors.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the record and concluded that the inquiry was conducted in accordance with the Rules of the Scindia School and the Standing Orders, which do not require annexure of documents with the charge-sheet. The charge-sheet was held to have been duly served. The Labour Court had previously directed supply of documents and observed that all documents had been supplied, with a video CD furnished as directed.

The Court noted that the petitioner had admitted the charges in his reply to the charge-sheet (Ex.2) and in reply to the show-cause notice. The Labour Court recorded that proper opportunity to lead defence evidence was afforded; the petitioner, however, did not place complete statements on record. The appointment of a colleague-advocate as Inquiry Officer was found to be permissible under the School's Service Rules and not inherently illegal. The Court emphasized that the inquiry was a domestic/in-house inquiry governed by Service Rules, not a criminal trial, and the applicable standard of proof is governed by those Service Rules.

Relying on Supreme Court authorities concerning the limited scope of interference under Article 227 (including Iswarlal Mohanlal Thakkar, Shalini Shyam Shetty, Harjinder Singh and Jai Singh), the Court held that absent perversity or a grave legal error, this Court should not reappreciate evidence or act as an appellate forum to overturn the Labour Court's well-reasoned award.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is dismissed.

Direct effect: The petition seeking reinstatement/back wages and related reliefs is dismissed and the Labour Court's award upholding termination remains undisturbed. The Court did not indicate the setting of any new legal precedent and limited its decision to the facts and applicable Service Rules in this case.

    Prayagnarayan v. Principal Scindia School Fort Gwalior

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

    AT GWALIOR

    BEFORE

    HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANAND SINGH BAHRAWAT ON THE 19thOF FEBRUARY, 2026

    WRIT PETITION No. 2148 of 2016

    PRAYAGNARAYAN

    Versus

    PRINCIPAL SCINDIA SCHOOL FORT GWALIOR

    Appearance:

    Shri Prem Singh Pal - learned counsel for petitioner. Ms.Chitra Bais - learned counsel for respondent.

    ORDER

    This petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, has been filed seeking following relief(s):

    "7.1 यह क, अनेचर पी/1 एंव अनेचर पी/2 तथा अनेचर पी-3 आधारहन होने के कारण िनर त करने क कृपा क जाव , एवं ितयािचकाकता मांक-1 को आदेिशत कया जावे क, यािचकाकता को दनांक 11/07/2012 से %यूट पर मा(य कये जाने के आदेश देने क कृपा क जाव ।

    7.2. यह क, यािचकाकता को अनेचर पी-1, 2, 3 के अनुसार काय से पथृक करने एवं काय पर रखने तक क अविध का ,पछला सम त वेतन भी भुगतान करने हेतु िनद1िशत कया जाव ।

    7.3 यह क, अ(य कोई सहायता, अनुतोष (यायालय (यायहत म उिचत समझे वह यािचकाकता को ितयािचकाकतागण से दलाने क कृपा क जाव ।"

    2. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that petitioner was appointed to the post of Peon (Class-IV employee) in the respondent School on 08.07.1984. It is further submitted that petitioner completed 28 years of

    1

    service without any allegation or misconduct. However, all of a sudden, a charge-sheet was issued to petitioner and along with the charge-sheet, the list of witnesses and documents was not supplied. Thereafter, an inquiry was conducted. It is further submitted that at the time of inquiry, proper opportunity of being heard was not afforded to petitioner and thereafter his services were terminated. Petitioner filed a petition before the Labour Commissioner, Gwalior; however, the Labour Court rejected the claim of petitioner and upheld the order of dismissal. It is further submitted that the services of petitioner were terminated without affording proper opportunity of hearing, without conducting a fair inquiry and without following the principles of natural justice. It is further submitted that the documents and copies of statements of the management witnesses were not supplied to petitioner. It is further submitted that neither any item was recovered from the petitioner nor were any map of the place, seizure memo, or panchnama prepared. No proper opportunity was provided to petitioner to defend himself. It is further submitted that the Labour Court failed to consider the written submissions filed by petitioner. It is further submitted that with mala fide intention, a junior and colleague-advocate of the employer was appointed as the Inquiry Officer to conduct the inquiry and the respondents did not grant any opportunity to petitioner to take assistance of an advocate during the inquiry proceedings. It is further submitted that petitioner is an uneducated person and at the time of inquiry, no opportunity was given to have the statements read over and explained to him by any other person. The aforesaid aspect has also not been considered by the Labour Court. It is

    2

    further submitted that the petitioner has not admitted the charges. During the inquiry, his signatures were obtained on certain papers and being an illiterate person, he had no knowledge of what was written therein and merely affixed his signature. Learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the judgment rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Prem Nath Bali v. Registrar, High Court of Delhi and another AIR 2016 SC 101 and rendered by High Court of Madhya Pradesh Chatrapal v. State of Uttar Pradesh reported in 2024 (I) MPWN 48, and rendered by Delhi High Court Indian Bank and others v. Shri Praveen Kumar .

    3. Per contra, learned counsel for respondent submits that entire enquiry was conducted in accordance with the Rules of the Scindia School and the Standing Orders. Under the said Rules and Standing Orders, there is no provision requiring copies of documents to be annexed along with the charge-sheet. The charge-sheet was duly served upon petitioner as per the applicable Rules and there was no illegality in its service. It is further submitted that petitioner had filed an application (Annexure P/5) dated 24.02.2014 before the Labour Court and vide order dated 29.04.2014, the Labour Court disposed of the said application by observing that all documents mentioned therein had already been supplied to petitioner. Only a video CD was directed to be supplied which was accordingly furnished to petitioner on 27.08.2014. It is further submitted that petitioner suppressed material facts regarding his admission of guilt. In his reply to the charge- sheet, petitioner admitted the charges levelled against him as reflected in Ex.2 (Page No. 11 of the reply). Learned counsel for respondent further

    3

    submits that Labour Court has recorded a finding that proper opportunity to lead defence evidence was afforded to petitioner during the enquiry. However, with mala fide intention, petitioner did not file the complete statement and placed only his affidavit and a portion of the cross- examination has not been submitted / filed. It is further submitted that learned Labour Court considered all the written submissions made by petitioner and thereafter passed the impugned order. The appointment of a junior and colleague-advocate of the employer as the Inquiry Officer is permissible and there is no illegality in such appointment, as the same was made in accordance with the Service Rules of the School. It is further submitted that petitioner never sought assistance of an advocate during the inquiry proceedings. As per the Service Rules, the inquiry was a domestic inquiry and such in-house inquiries are not akin to civil suits or criminal proceedings. The Inquiry Officer provided full opportunity to petitioner to defend himself. Learned counsel for respondent further submits that the services of petitioner were terminated on account of serious charges of selling tobacco, cigarettes, bidi, gutka and other such items within the school premises. The State and Central Governments have issued directions and framed rules prohibiting the sale of such items within specified areas of school premises. The petitioner was residing within the school campus, where students used to reside in hostels attend classes and use the playgrounds. It is further submitted that the entire statement of claim filed by petitioner was duly considered by the Presiding Officer of the Labour Court while passing the impugned award. The procedure for conducting an inquiry

    4

    and taking disciplinary action is specifically provided in the Service Rules of the School; therefore, the Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules are not applicable. It is further submitted that the standard of proof applicable to domestic inquiries is governed by the Service Rules of the School, and petitioner is erroneously contending that the standard of proof should be akin to that of a criminal trial. The inquiry was conducted in a fair manner and petitioner himself admitted his guilt in his reply to the charge- sheet as well as in his reply to the show-cause notice dated 29.06.2012 (Annexure R/9). It is further submitted that punishment imposed upon petitioner is commensurate with the gravity of the misconduct. While exercising supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India this Court does not correct mere errors of fact or law and the scope of interference is very limited. It is further submitted that the charges levelled against the petitioner are serious in nature and have been duly proved in a full-fledged domestic/departmental inquiry. The Inquiry Officer found the petitioner guilty of the charges and thereafter his services were terminated after affording proper opportunity of hearing. The Labour Court has considered all the plea and facts and grounds and objections raised by petitioner and recorded findings based on the material available on record. In the absence of any perversity, the award cannot be interfered with by this Court under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India.

    4. Heard learned counsel for parties and perused the record.

    5. On perusal of record, it is gathered that entire enquiry was conducted in accordance with the Rules of the Scindia School and the Standing Orders. Under

    5

    the said Rules and Standing Orders, there is no provision requiring copies of documents to be annexed along with the charge-sheet. The charge-sheet was duly served upon petitioner as per the applicable Rules and there was no illegality in its service. Petitioner had filed an application (Annexure P/5) dated 24.02.2014 before the Labour Court and vide order dated 29.04.2014, the Labour Court disposed of the said application by observing that all documents mentioned therein had already been supplied to petitioner. Only a video CD was directed to be supplied which was accordingly furnished to petitioner on 27.08.2014. Petitioner suppressed material facts regarding his admission of guilt. In his reply to the charge-sheet, petitioner admitted the charges levelled against him as reflected in Ex.2 (Page No. 11 of the reply). Labour Court has recorded a finding that proper opportunity to lead defence evidence was afforded to petitioner during the enquiry. However, with mala fide intention, petitioner did not file the complete statement and placed only his affidavit and a portion of the cross- examination on record. Learned Labour Court considered all the written submissions made by petitioner and thereafter passed the impugned order. The appointment of colleague-advocate of the employer as the Inquiry Officer is permissible and there is no illegality in such appointment, as the same was made in accordance with the Service Rules of the School. Petitioner never sought assistance of an advocate during the inquiry proceedings. As per the Service Rules, the inquiry was a domestic inquiry and such in-house inquiries are not akin to civil suits or criminal proceedings. The Inquiry Officer provided full opportunity to petitioner to defend himself. The services of petitioner were terminated on account of serious charges of selling tobacco, cigarettes, bidi, gutka and other such items within the school premises. The State and Central Governments have issued directions and framed rules prohibiting the sale of such

    6

    items within specified areas of school premises. The petitioner was residing within the school campus, where students used to reside in hostels, attend classes and use the playgrounds. The entire statement of claim filed by petitioner was duly considered by the Presiding Officer of the Labour Court while passing the impugned award. The procedure for conducting an inquiry and taking disciplinary action is specifically provided in the Service Rules of the School; therefore, the Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules are not applicable. The standard of proof applicable to domestic inquiries is governed by the Service Rules of the School and petitioner is erroneously contending that the standard of proof should be akin to that of a criminal trial. The inquiry was conducted in a fair manner and petitioner himself admitted his guilt in his reply to the charge-sheet as well as in his reply to the show-cause notice dated 29.06.2012 (Annexure R/9). Punishment imposed upon petitioner is commensurate with the gravity of the misconduct. While exercising supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India this Court does not correct mere errors of fact or law and the scope of interference is very limited. The charges levelled against the petitioner are serious in nature and have been duly proved in a full-fledged domestic/departmental inquiry. The Inquiry Officer found the petitioner guilty of the charges and thereafter his services were terminated after affording proper opportunity of hearing. The Labour Court has considered all the plea and facts, grounds and objections raised by petitioner and recorded findings based on the material available on record. In the absence of any perversity, the award cannot be interfered with by this Court under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India.

    6. The Supreme Court in a case of Iswarlal Mohanlal Thakkar Vs. Paschim Gujrat Vij Company Ltd. & Anr. (Civil Appeal No.4558 of 2014) has considered

    7

    the scope of interference in the matter of award/order passed by the Labour Court while entertaining the petition under Article 227 of the Constitution by the High Court. The observation made by the Supreme Court is as under:-

    "9. We find the judgment and award of the Labour Court well reasoned and based on facts and evidence on record. The High Court has erred in its exercise of power under Article 227 of the Constitution of India to annul the findings of the Labour Court in its award as it is well settled law that the High Court cannot exercise its power under Article 227 of the Constitution as an appellate court or reappreciate evidence and record its findings on the contentious points. Only if there is a serious error of law or the findings recorded suffer from error apparent on record, can the High Court quash the order of a lower court. The Labour Court in the present case has satisfactorily exercised its original jurisdiction and properly appreciated the facts and legal evidence on record and given a well reasoned order and answered the points of dispute in favour of the appellant. The High Court had no reason to interfere with the same as the award of the Labour Court was based on sound and cogent reasoning, which has served the ends of justice.

    It is relevant to mention that in Shalini Shyam Shetty v. Rajendra Shankar Patil [(2010) 8 SCC 329 : (2010) 3 SCC (Civ) 338], with regard to the limitations of the High Court to exercise its jurisdiction under Article 227, it was held in para 49 that:

    "The power of interference under Article 227 is to be kept to the minimum to ensure that the wheel of justice does not come to a halt and the fountain of justice remains pure and unpolluted in order to maintain public confidence in the functioning of the tribunals and courts subordinate to the High Court." It was also held that:

    "High Courts cannot, at the drop of a hat, in exercise of its power of superintendence under Article 227 of the Constitution, interfere with the orders of tribunals or courts inferior to it. Nor can it, in exercise of this power, act as a court of appeal over the orders of the court or tribunal subordinate to it." Thus it is clear, that the High Court has to exercise its power under Article 227 of the Constitution judiciously and to further the ends of justice. In the case of Harjinder Singh v. Punjab State Warehousing Corporation .. [(2010) 3 SCC 192 : (2010) 1 SCC (L&S) 1146] this Court held that: "20. … In view of the above discussion, we hold that the learned Single Judge of the High Court committed serious jurisdictional error and unjustifiably interfered with the award of reinstatement passed by the Labour Court with compensation of Rs 87,582 by entertaining a wholly unfounded plea that the

    8

    appellant was appointed in violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution and the Regulations.""

    7. Further, in a case reported in (2010) 9 SCC 385 parties being Jai Singh and Others Vs. Municipal Corporation of Delhi and Another, the Supreme Court has dealt with the nature and scope of Article 227 of Constitution and observed as under:-

    "15. We have anxiously considered the submissions of the learned counsel. Before we consider the factual and legal issues involved herein, we may notice certain well-recognised principles governing the exercise of jurisdiction by the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. Undoubtedly the High Court, under this article, has the jurisdiction to ensure that all subordinate courts as well as statutory or quasi-judicial tribunals, exercise the powers vested in them, within the bounds of their authority. The High Court has the power and the jurisdiction to ensure that they act in accordance with the well-established principles of law. The High Court is vested with the powers of superintendence and/or judicial revision, even in matters where no revision or appeal lies to the High Court. The jurisdiction under this article is, in some ways, wider than the power and jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. It is, however, well to remember the well-known adage that greater the power, greater the care and caution in exercise thereof. The High Court is, therefore, expected to exercise such wide powers with great care, caution and circumspection. The exercise of jurisdiction must be within the well-recognised constraints. It can not be exercised like a "bull in a china shop", to correct all errors of judgment of a court, or tribunal, acting within the limits of its jurisdiction. This correctional jurisdiction can be exercised in cases where orders have been passed in grave dereliction of duty or in flagrant abuse of fundamental principles of law or justice."

    8. Giving anxious consideration to the facts and circumstances of the present case, this Court finds that the judgment in Prem Nath Bali, Chartapal and Shri Praveen Kumar (supra), relied upon by learned counsel for petitioner, is not applicable to it. The action taken against petitioner was strictly in accordance with the Service Rules of the School. Moreover, the petitioner himself had admitted his guilt; therefore, the ratio laid down in the aforesaid judgment has no application to the facts of the present matter.

    9

    (ANAND SINGH BAHRAWAT)

    JUDGE

    9. In view of the foregoing discussion and considering the facts and circumstances of the case in their entirety, this Court is of the considered opinion that the present petition, being sans substance, is hereby dismissed. Ahmad

    10

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Prayagnarayan v. Principal Scindia School Fort Gwalior
    (Feb 19, 2026)