Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2026 MPHC-JBP 3458
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2026 MPHC-JBP 3458
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner (plaintiff) filed a suit for declaration of title, recovery of possession and permanent injunction in respect of part of land in Survey No.615/2. The trial Court framed six issues; Issue No.2 concerned alleged encroachment by the defendants and Issue No.3 concerned entitlement to recovery of possession. The trial Court's judgment found that the defendants had encroached on the petitioner's land and that the petitioner was entitled to recovery of possession. When the draft decree was prepared, the trial Court omitted any decree for recovery of possession and recorded only a decree of permanent injunction. The petitioner objected (captioned under Section 152 CPC) to this omission; the trial Court held the objections not maintainable and proceeded to finally sign the decree on 13.11.2025. This revision challenges that final order. The High Court initially ignored an office objection as to maintainability of the revision and proceeded to consider the matter.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial Court erred in finalizing and signing a decree that omitted recovery of possession when the judgment expressly found the petitioner entitled to recovery of possession.
  2. Whether objections under Section 152 CPC seeking correction/amendment of the decree are maintainable once the decree has been finally signed.
  3. Whether the trial Court was obliged to correct an apparent error in the draft decree (even if the objection was wrongly captioned) before signing the decree.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court analyzed the record and noted a discrepancy between the judgment and the final decree: the judgment expressly found encroachment by the defendants and that the petitioner was entitled to recovery of possession, but the decree omitted recovery of possession and only granted permanent injunction. The Court considered the petitioner's objection (framed under Section 152 CPC) which the trial Court had summarily rejected as not maintainable and then signed the decree. The High Court held that, irrespective of whether the objection was incorrectly captioned, the trial Court, when pointed out to the anomaly between judgment and decree, was under an obligation to correct the decree before final signing rather than mechanically signing it. The High Court further held that now that the decree has been finally signed, objections under Section 152 CPC would be maintainable. On that basis the High Court directed the trial Court to pass a specific order under Section 152 CPC and ensure that the decree conforms to the judgment.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is disposed of with a direction to the trial Court to pass a specific order under Section 152 CPC and ensure that the decree is in accordance with the judgment; the trial Court was directed to pass appropriate orders within 30 days.

Implications: The direct effect is that the trial Court must revisit the decree under Section 152 CPC and correct the omission so that the decree reflects the judgmental finding of entitlement to recovery of possession. The opinion does not discuss broader legal implications or establish a new precedent beyond the case-specific direction.

    Mahendra Prasad Tiwari v. Smt. Chinti Yadav

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

    AT JABALPUR

    BEFORE

    HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK JAIN ON THE 14thOF JANUARY, 2026 CIVIL REVISION No. 1364 of 2025

    MAHENDRA PRASAD TIWARI

    Versus

    SMT. CHINTI YADAV AND OTHERS

    Appearance:

    Shri Atul Kumar Pathak - Advocate for the petitioner. Shri Amit Mishra - Panel Lawyer for the respondents / State.

    ORDER

    As by way of present revision challenge is made to the final order, therefore office objection as to maintainability of revision is ignored.

    2. In present revision challenge is made to the order dated 13.11.2025 whereby the trial Court has finalized the decree and proceeded to finally sign the decree and rejected the application of the plaintiff-petitioner under Section 152 CPC for amendment/correction of the decree. 3 . The plaintiff had filed a suit for declaration of title, recovery of possession and permanent injunction. The trial Court framed as many as six issues and issue No.2 related to whether the defendant has encroached on land of the petitioner-plaintiff in Survey No.615/2 and issue No.3 related to consequential issue that whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief of recovery of possession. Upon trial, the court marked the conclusions against the issues. The issues and the conclusions arrived thereupon are as under:-

    1

    वाद  एवं िन कष

    क. वाद  िन कष

    1.

    या वाद  थत ाम कैथहा तहसील रामनगर जला सतना म..  थत भूिम आराजी नंबर 615/2 रकवा 0. 105 हेटेयर के अशं भाग का नजर नशा अनुल)न "अ" के अनुसार भूिम वामी है ?

    "सा*बत"

    2.

    या ितवाद +मांक 1 लगायत 4 ने ाम कैथहा तहसील रामनगर जला सतना म..  थत भूिम आराजी नंबर 615/2 रकवा 0.105 हेटेयर के अशं भाग का नजर नशा अनुल)न "अ" के अनुसार वाद क, भूिम म- अवैध िनमा ण काय कर िलया है ?

    "सा*बत"

    3.

    या वाद ाम कैथहा तहसील रामनगर जला सतना म. .  थत भूिम आराजी नंबर 615/2 रकवा 0.105 हेटेयर के अशं भाग का नजर नशा अनुल)न "अ" के अनुसार 0र1 आिधप3य ा4 करने का अिधकार है ?

    "सा*बत"

    4.

    या वाद ाम कैथहा तहसील रामनगर जला सतना म. .  थत भूिम आराजी नंबर 615/2 रकवा 0.105 हेटेयर के अशं भाग का नजर नशा अनुल)न 'अ' म- दिश त भू-भाग पर क5जा ाि4 के प6ात थायी 5यादेश ा4 करने का अिधकार है ?

    "सा*बत"

    5. या वाद 7ारा वाद का उिचत मू:यांकन कर पया 4 ;यायशु:क अदा <कया है ? "हाँ"

    6. अनुतोष एवं ?यय ?

    "िनण य के अिंतम

    पैरा के अनुसार"

    4. Further, the substantive part of the judgment indicates that the Court categorically arrived at a finding that the defendants have encroached upon the land of the petitioner and also that he is entitled to recover possession of the land. Paragraph 18 of the judgment is as under:-

    "18. वाद +मांक 2 के संबंध म- वाद ने अिभविचत <कया है <क ितवाद +मांक 1 लगायत ितवाद +मांक 4 के 7ारा वाद त भूिम पर अवैध िनमा ण कर िलया गया है। इसके संबंध म- वाद के 7ारा .पी. 7 एवं .पी. 8 है। जो वाद त भूिम म- ितवाद के 7ारा <कये जाने वाले िनमा ण के संबंध म- जनपद पंचायत रामनगर एवं सी.ओ., तहसीलदार को <कया गया िशकायती आवेदन पC है। जब<क उपरो1 द तावेजD के खंडन म- ितवाद के 7ारा कोई अिभसाHय  तुत नहं <कया गया है <क उसके 7ारा वादगण क, आराजी पर अवैध Iप से क5जा नहं <कया जा रहा है। उपरो1 *ववेचना के आधार पर जहां यह माणत पाया गया है <क ितवादगण 7ारा वादगण के वािम3व क, भूिम पर अवैध Iप से ह तJेप <कया गया है तब ऐसी  थित म- वादगण अपने वािम3व क, आराजी का 0र1 आिधप3य ितवादगण से ा4 करने के अिधकार है।"

    5. Surprisingly when the draft decree was proposed, the Court did not frame any decree in the matter of recovery of possession and passed an order of permanent injunction in respect of the land in Survey No.615/2 though the

    2

    Court had already arrived at a finding that the defendant has encroached upon the land and proceeded to record in the judgment that the defendant is required to handover the vacant possession of the land to the plaintiff but surprisingly, without mentioning in the decree the relief of recovery of possession, the trial Court only passed a decree of permanent injunction though permanent injunction should have been consequential to recovery of possession. There is a clear error in the decree whereby the trial has skipped to record in the decree the recovery of possession though in the judgment the trial court categorically arrived at a finding that the defendant has encroached upon the land and the plaintiff is entitled to decree of recovery of possession.

    6. When the petitioner-plaintiff submitted objection to the said decree though captioned under Section 152 the trial Court held that such objections are not maintainable under section 152. Irrespective of the position that once the decree had not been finally signed then whether objections under Section 152 were maintainable or not, but once the trial Court had been pointed out with the position that despite noting in the judgment that the petitioner is entitled to recovery of possession, then in the decree recovery of possession was not mentioned, then the trial Court should have woken up to this anomaly and it was not required of the trial Court to have mechanically signed the decree by holding that Section 152 CPC is not made out. The error in the decree was being pointed out and even if the trial court came to conclusion that the application is wrongly captioned but if the objection was there and there was error in the decree then the trial Court was under obligation to correct the error in the decree before it being finally signed. The

    3

    (VIVEK JAIN)

    JUDGE

    trial Court summarily scuttled the objection holding that Section 152 is not made out and then went ahead to sign the decree.

    7. Now as the decree has been finally signed, therefore the objections under section 152 CPC would indeed be maintainable.

    8. Therefore the trial court is directed to pass a specific order under section 152 CPC and ensure that the decree should be in accordance with the judgement and not contrary to the judgement.

    9. Let the trial Court pass appropriate orders within 30 days, petition is disposed off.

    nks

    4

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mahendra Prasad Tiwari v. Smt. Chinti Yadav
    (Jan 14, 2026)