Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2025 MPHC-JBP 60132
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 173(1) of Motor Vehicle Act, 1988
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2025 MPHC-JBP 60132
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 173(1) of Motor Vehicle Act, 1988

    Smt. Shobha Chatterjee v. Ashish @ Ashok

    NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2025:MPHC-JBP:60132

    1 MA-265-2010

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

    AT JABALPUR

    BEFORE

    HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE HIMANSHU JOSHI ON THE 14thOF NOVEMBER, 2025 MISC. APPEAL No. 265 of 2010

    SMT. SHOBHA CHATTERJEE

    Versus

    ASHISH @ ASHOK AND OTHERS Appearance:

    Shri Kapil Patwardhan - Advocate for the appellant. Shri Shreyas Dubey - Advocate for respondent no.3. Ms. Shikha Paliwal - Advocate for respondent no.2.

    ORDER

    The instant appeal under Section 173(1) of Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 has been preferred by the claimant/appellant seeing enhancement in the award dated 06.11.2009 in M.C.C. No. 3011/2007 passed by 9th Additional Motor Accident Claims, Tribunal, Bhopal whereby the learned Claims Tribunal awarded Rs.1,07,631/- towards compensation to the claimant. The respondent No. 1 and 2 have been directed to indemnify the claimant whereas on account of breach of policy condition by the respondent No. 2, the insurance company has been exonerated from its liability to pay compensation.

    2. The concise account of the case are that on 01.02.2007, claimant/appellant met with an accident while going towards Teekamgarh in Tata Sumo bearing registration number MP-05-B.A.-0105 due to rash and negligent driving of of respondent No. 1. The respondent No. 1carelessly crashed the car into parked truck.

    3. Learned counsel for the claimant/appellant argued that the learned

    1

    Claims Tribunal erred in assessing the compensation in proper perspective and awarded lower amount. The injured is a stage artist and on the date of accident, she was going to perform his show. She caused permanent disfigurement in her face which certainly cause impact in her livelihood which she earns through her stage performances but the learned Tribunal has not awarded single penny under the head of permanent disability or for loss of earning capacity or future income. The doctor advised her to go through plastic surgery to which huge amount is required to be spent. The tribunal has awarded lower compensation amount in all the heads which requires to be enhanced. He further argued that the learned Claim Tribunal also erred in fixing the liability upon the respondent No. 1 and 2 whereas it should have been imposed upon the insurance company as the claimant did not hire the car on rent from the respondent No. 2. He prays to allow the appeal. Learned counsel for the appellant has placed reliance on the decision of Apex Court in the case of Rekha Jain vs. National Insurance Company Ltd. [SLP (C) Nos.5649-51 of 2012], Manuara Khatun & Ors. vs. Rajesh Kr. Singh & Ors. [SLP

    (C) No.5805/2013] and Mostt Mano Devi and ors. vs. New India Assurance Company Ltd and Ors. [2025 (1) TAC 70 (S.C.)]

    4. On the other side, counsel for the respondent No. 2 argued that looking to the injuries caused to the claimant, the learned Tribunal has awarded excessive compensation. She further argued that the owner of vehicle has not breached any terms and condition of insurance policy and thus, finding recorded recorded by the Tribunal fixing the liability to pay the compensation upon the respondent No. 2 is perverse and deserves to be set aside.

    5. Learned counsel for the insurance company supported the award submitting that not interference of this Court is required. In support of his

    2

    contention learned counsel for the Insurance Company has placed reliance on the decision of this Court in the case of United India Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Poonamchand & Ors. (M.A. No.2762/2007).

    6. Heard all the parties and perused the record.

    7. There is no dispute the the accident was occurred due to rash and negligent driving of respondent No. 1 which was registered in the name of respondent No. 2.

    8. On perusal of impugned award, it appears that the learned Tribunal has awarded the compensation as under :-

    Head Amount of Compensation (in rupees)

    Medical Expenses 12,631/-

    Future Treatment 50,000/-

    Pain and Suffering 10,000/-

    Special Diet 10,000/-

    Attender 5,000/-

    Loss of Income 20,000/-

    Total 1,07,631/-

    9. On examining the records, it appears that the statement of Dr. Vikram Singh Tomar reveals that though he stated before he Tribunal that the claimant suffered with permanent disfigurement in her right side of face but his statement in the cross examination does not inspired with confidence to prove that the claimant suffered with any permanent disability. The medical certificate does not record any functional or physical permanent disability. It is settled preposition of law under the Motor Accident Claims that compensation for loss of future earning capacity or permanent disability can be granted only when permanent disability is proved. Since no such disability is proved, the Tribunal did not commit any error in not awarding the compensation under the head of permanent disability or loss

    3

    of earning capacity/future income.

    10. However, though permanent disability is not proved, the claimant is still entitled to adequate compensation under non-pecuniary heads even temporary disfigurement or pain must be compensated considering the nature of the injury and its impact on the victim's life. Facial injuries have been judicially recognized to justify higher compensation under pain, suffering and disfigurement.

    11. Considering the claimant's profession (stage performer), injuries to the face affect her vocation, though without permanent disability, this Court deems it appropriate to enhance the compensation as under :-

    Compensation Awarded Compensation Awarded

    Head by the Learned Tribunal by this Court

    (in rupees) (in rupees)

    Medical Expenses 12,631/- 12,631/-
    Future Treatment 50,000/- 1,50,000/-
    Pain and Suffering 10,000/- 50,000/-
    Special Diet 10,000/- 15,000/-
    Attender 5,000/- 10,000/-
    Loss of Income 20,000/- 40,000/-
    Face disfiguration - 1,50,000/-
    Total 1,07,631/- 4,27,631/-

    12. The enhanced amount i.e. Rs.3,20,000/- (Rs.4,27,631/- - Rs.1,07,631/-) shall also carry the same interest as has been awarded by the learned Tribunal. The rest of conditions imposed by the learned Tribunal be as it is.

    13. So far as the question regarding exoneration of insurance company from its liability to pay compensation is concerned, this Court feels agreement with the finding given by the learned Tribunal as it has been duly proved that the claimants hired the vehicle from respondent No. 2 which was insured under private package policy, and thus, the vehicle was being driven in violation of policy conditions.

    14. In the present case, since, the insurer has successfully discharged its

    4

    burden by proving that the vehicle was being driven in violation of policy conditions, therefore, the insurance company has rightly been exonerated from ultimate liability.

    15. However, keeping in view the principles laid down in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh,{(2004) 3 SCC 297}, and considering the rights of the innocent third-party victim, this Court deems it proper to direct the Insurance Company to pay the awarded compensation to the claimant in the first instance and thereafter recover the same from the owner and driver of the offending vehicle in accordance with law. Hence, the Insurance Company is exonerated from liability qua the insured, but a direction of pay and recover is issued.

    16. Accordingly, the appeal is disposed off.

    (HIMANSHU JOSHI)

    JUDGE

    mn

    5

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Smt. Shobha Chatterjee v. Ashish @ Ashok
    (Nov 14, 2025)