Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2024 DHC 7477
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • Section 20 (b) (C) to 20 (b)(ii)(B)
  • Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • section 2 (iii)(b) of the NDPS Acts
  • Section 29 of the NDPS Act, 1985
  • Section 37 of the NDPS Act, 1985
  • Section 29 read with Section 20(B)(ii)(c) of NDPS Act, 1985
  • Section 29 read with Section 20(B)(ii)(c) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985
  • Section 37 b (ii) of the NDPS Act
  • S. 2 (iii)(b)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2024 DHC 7477
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • Section 20 (b) (C) to 20 (b)(ii)(B)
  • Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • section 2 (iii)(b) of the NDPS Acts
  • Section 29 of the NDPS Act, 1985
  • Section 37 of the NDPS Act, 1985
  • Section 29 read with Section 20(B)(ii)(c) of NDPS Act, 1985
  • Section 29 read with Section 20(B)(ii)(c) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985
  • Section 37 b (ii) of the NDPS Act
  • S. 2 (iii)(b)
Smart Summary

Summary of Judgment: Bail Application No. 1256/2024

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a first bail petition under Section 439 CrPC filed by Ravina Kumari (the petitioner) seeking regular bail in FIR No. 146/2023 registered under Section 29 read with Section 20(B)(ii)(c) of the NDPS Act, 1985 at Police Station Badarpur, Delhi. The petition arises from an incident on 19.04.2023 at about 2:30 P.M., when the petitioner (a pillion rider) and co-accused Hari Ram (driver of the Honda Scooty) were apprehended. A black backpack carried by the petitioner allegedly contained 23.465 kg of ganja and the co-accused's backpack allegedly contained about 4.0 kg. The Investigating Officer obtained four days custody/remand of the petitioner on 24.04.2023. Investigations were completed and a chargesheet was filed. The petitioner remained in custody since 19.04.2023.

The petitioner contends that the recovered 23.456 kg included leaves, stalks and stems (which, she argues, are not part of the statutory definition of "ganja") and that excluding those would reduce the actual quantity to about 3.465 kg (well below the commercial quantity threshold of 20 kg). The Forensic Science Laboratory report confirmed the seized exhibits as "ganja" on physical, chemical, microscopic and TLC examinations, but the petitioner challenged the inclusion of non-tops material in the weighed quantity. The State opposed bail on the ground of the gravity of offence and the assertion that commercial quantity was recovered.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to regular bail despite the alleged recovery of a quantity described as commercial quantity under the NDPS Act.
  2. Whether, for the purpose of quantification under the NDPS Act, the weight of leaves, stalks and stems (non-flowering/fruting tops) must be excluded when a heterogeneous mixture (flowers/tops mixed with leaves/stems) is seized.
  3. Whether a prima facie discrepancy in the measured/analysed weight of the seized material (due to inclusion of non-tops material) makes the applicability of the bar under Section 37 of the NDPS Act a matter for trial rather than for denial of bail at the interim stage.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The seized quantity attributed to the petitioner (23.456 kg) included leaves and stems which do not fall within the statutory definition of "ganja" (flowering or fruiting tops), and therefore the actual quantity of ganja may be only about 3.465 kg.
  • The Forensic Report and seizure documents indicate that leaves/stalks/stems were included in the weighed sample.
  • The petitioner has clean antecedents, is a mother of an 8-year-old child and has ties to family; she is not a flight risk nor likely to tamper with evidence.
  • All witnesses are police officials (no public witness), casting doubt on the authenticity of seizure; reliance placed on authorities holding that weight of leaves/stems must be excluded and discrepancies may warrant bail.

State's Arguments

  • The total recovery in the case amounted to approximately 28 kg of ganja (23.456 kg from the petitioner and 4.015 kg from the co-accused), which is commercial quantity exceeding 20 kg.
  • FSL confirmed the contraband as ganja; therefore bar under Section 37 of the NDPS Act would apply.
  • Prosecution witnesses are yet to be examined; if bail is granted, there is a likelihood of the accused re-offending or absconding.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ibrahim Khwaja Miya Sayyed v. State of Maharashtra (2023) SCC Online Bom 2873 Observed that while granting bail, the weight of leaves and stems has to be excluded while weighing the alleged seized quantity of the contraband material. The Court relied on this authority to support the proposition that non-tops material should be excluded and that discrepancies in weighing can be determinative at trial rather than for summary denial of bail.
Kunal Dattu Kadu v. Union of India (2022) SCC Online Bom 1770 The opinion states that to ascertain whether material seized was ganja, it must be ascertained whether the flowering and fruiting tops are accompanied by seeds and leaves; weight of seeds/leaves/stems has to be excluded. Used to endorse the legal approach that in heterogeneous mixtures the weight of placebo material (stems/leaves/seeds) should be excluded for quantification under the NDPS Act.
Shri Sandip Ashok Raut v. State of Maharashtra (2015) SCC Online Bom 4543 The opinion records similar observations as in Kunal Dattu regarding exclusion of seeds/leaves/stems when determining quantity. Relied upon to support the principle that exclusion of non-tops material is required in assessing whether seized quantity is commercial.
Rajesh Sharma v. State of Rajasthan (2024) SCC Online Raj 485 The provided opinion records that similar observations have been made in this case (regarding discrepancies/quantification); the specific rule in the opinion is that similar observations were made. The Court cited it as another authority where doubts on actual amount of recovery led to favourable consideration at bail stage.
Bettanayaka v. State of Karnataka (2020) SCC Online Kar 3916 The opinion notes this case as offering similar observations; the specific principle is recorded generally as aligning with exclusion of non-tops weight where appropriate. Cited to demonstrate consistent judicial approach to quantification discrepancies in ganja seizures.
Ratanlal Kharadi v. State of M.P. (2019) SCC Online MP 6083 The opinion records it amongst cases making similar observations about weight/quantification; no further specific principle is detailed in the provided text. Referenced to show precedent weight in favour of excluding non-tops material where there is a doubt on actual drug content.
Ratnesh v. State (2017) SCC Online Del 9883 The opinion records it as a similar authority; the provided text does not elaborate a distinct rule beyond noting similar observations. Used as part of the body of case law indicating that discrepancies in quantification can be relevant to bail decisions.
Suresh Kumar v. State (2016) SCC Online Del 1209 Coordinate Bench gave benefit to accused where weight was not precise and FSL showed seeds (not covered by definition of ganja) were weighed along with flowering tops; doubt on actual amount of recovery can benefit accused. The Court applied this reasoning to hold that when a doubt exists as to the actual quantity of recoverable contraband, that unexplained discrepancy may favor the bail applicant.
Lavlesh Kumar v. State (2015) SCC Online Del 12574 The opinion references the case but does not specify in the provided text the exact rule or principle cited from it. The Court listed it among authorities relied upon by the petitioner; the provided opinion does not record a specific application beyond citation.
K. Kavitha v. ED (SLP(Crl) No. 10785/2024) The opinion references the SLP number but does not state the principle relied upon in the provided text. Included in the list of authorities cited by the petitioner; no specific application is detailed in the opinion excerpt provided.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by identifying the statutory definition of "ganja" under Section 2(iii)(b) of the NDPS Act: "the flowering or fruiting tops of the cannabis plant (excluding the seeds and leaves when not accompanied by the tops)". From the definition the Court extracted three analytical categories:

  • Category A — homogeneous material consisting of flowering buds and fruiting tops (falls within "ganja").
  • Category B — homogeneous material consisting of stems, seeds, stalks and leaves (does not fall within "ganja").
  • Category C — heterogeneous mixtures where flowering/fruting tops are mixed with stems/leaves/stalks/seeds.

For Category C (the situation in this case), the Court held that only the actual content (Category A) — the flowering/fruting tops — is relevant for determining whether the seized quantity meets the statutory thresholds (small or commercial quantity). The weight of "placebo" material (stalks/leaves/stems/seeds — Category B) should be excluded when calculating the quantity of ganja.

The Court noted that the FSL confirmed the seized exhibits were "ganja" on various tests but also observed that the entire substance including stems/stalks and dried leaves had been weighed together without quantifying the weight of the flowering or fruiting tops. The total weighed quantity in the record was about 24.145 kg (the opinion notes this was only 4.145 kg over the commercial threshold). Given that the non-tops material was included in that weight, the Court found a prima facie discrepancy as to the actual quantity of ganja recovered.

Citing earlier authorities (including Ibrahim Khwaja Miya Sayyed, Kunal Dattu Kadu, Shri Sandip Ashok Raut and others), the Court observed that where such a discrepancy on weight exists, the question of whether the recovered material amounts to commercial quantity is a matter for trial. Where there are reasonable grounds to believe the accused may not be guilty of offences dealing in commercial quantity because of such discrepancies, the rigours of Section 37 (which would otherwise bar bail) do not necessarily apply at the bail stage.

On the personal factor side the Court recorded that the petitioner has no prior criminal record, is not shown to be likely to tamper with evidence or influence witnesses, and is not a flight risk. Balancing these material facts with the noted discrepancy, the Court concluded that bail was appropriate subject to conditions.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: Petition allowed; the petitioner is admitted to regular bail.

The Court granted regular bail to the petitioner in FIR No. 146/2023 (Sections 29 and 20(B)(ii)(c) NDPS Act) on furnishing a personal bond of Rs. 25,000 and one surety of like amount, and on further conditions which included:

  • Appear as and when the trial court takes up the matter.
  • Provide and keep working mobile numbers (petitioner and spouse/surety) and not change them without informing the IO.
  • Inform the IO of the address where she will be available in Delhi.
  • Not indulge in any criminal activity and not communicate with or approach witnesses.

The Registry was directed to communicate the order to the Trial Court and the concerned Jail Superintendent. The petition was disposed of.

Implications: The direct effect is that the petitioner was released on regular bail subject to conditions and the trial will continue. The Court treated the quantification dispute (inclusion of non-tops material in the weighed sample) as a matter to be resolved at trial rather than by denying bail at this stage. The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel binding precedent beyond applying and following existing authorities addressing quantification issues in ganja seizures.

    RAVINA KUMARI v. STATE OF NCT OF DELHI

    BAIL APPLN. 1256/2024 Page 1 of 9

    $~1 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

    % Date of decision: 20th September, 2024

    + BAIL APPLN. 1256/2024

    RAVINA KUMARI

    R/O - D/O Sh. Ranveer Singh, R/O -Village Malikpur, Karai, Kirali, Agra, Uttar Pradesh. .....Petitioner

    Through: Mr. Satyam Thareja & Ms. Harshita, Advocates.

    versus

    THE STATE (NCT OF DELHI)

    Through it's SHO P.S. Badarpur, Delhi .....Respondent Through: Ms. Richa Dhawan, APP for State. S.I. Satyanarayan, PS Badarpur, Delhi.

    CORAM:

    HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA

    J U D G M E N T (oral)

    1. This first Bail Petition under Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 has been filed on behalf of the petitioner seeking grant of regular bail in FIR No. 146/2023 registered under Section 29 read with Section 20(B)(ii)(c) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (hereinafter referred to as "NDPS Act, 1985") at Police Station Badarpur, Delhi.

    2. Briefly stated, on 19.04.2023, on the basis of secret information at

    1

    about 02:30 P.M., the petitioner/Ravina and co-accused Hari Ram were apprehended while she was travelling as a pillion rider on a Honda Scooty driven by the co-accused. On the search of black colour backpack which the petitioner/Ravina was carrying, 23.465 kg of Ganja was recovered, while 4.0 kg of Ganja was recovered from the black coloured backpack of co- accused/Hari Ram.

    3. The IO obtained 4 days custody/ remand of the Petitioner/ accused on 24.04.2023. On completion of investigations, the Chargesheet has been filed in the Court.

    4. The FIR no. 146/2023 under Section 20/29 NDPS Act was registered on 19.04.2023 by P.S Badarpur on a false and concocted complaint of the Complainant. The investigations in the present FIR are complete and the Chargesheet has also been filed before the Trial Court. However, she has been in Custody since 19.04.2023 despite being a mother of an 8 year old girl child and she has not been able to live with her husband as well.

    5. It is pleaded that there is alleged recovery of 23.456 kg Ganja from her carry bag, included the leaves and stalks/ stems which does not fall in the definition of contraband material. Thus, without the stems, the actual quantity of Ganja would only be mere 3.465 Kg., i.e. much lesser than the commercial quantity of 20 kgs.

    6. Even the Forensic Report dated 01.07.02023, reflects that the weighed sample which is in small quantity also includes the weight of leaves, stalks/stems. Similarly, the FIR dated 19/4/2023 and the seizure Memo establish that along with the alleged flowering buds of cannabis/ 'ganja', the leaves and stalks/ stems have also been seized by the I.O. only

    2

    to falsely implicate the Petitioner and make out a case of recovery of commercial quantity, from her. The petitioner has placed reliance on the decision in Ibrahim Khwaja Miya Sayyed Vs State of Maharashtra 2023 SCC Online Bom 2873 wherein it was observed that while granting bail, the weight of the leaves and stems has to be excluded while weighing the alleged seized quantity of the contraband material.

    7. The petitioner has submitted that she is a law abiding citizen who has clean antecedents and she belongs to a respectable family with deep roots in the society. Furthermore, all the witnesses are police officials and there is not even single public witness which puts the authenticity of seizure of alleged contraband material, under cloud. The alleged case property i.e. the contraband material is already seized and is not likely to be tampered. Also, there is no possibility of the applicant tampering with the witnesses and the evidence. Moreover, there is no possibility of the applicant committing the same offence while on bail as she has clean previous records. Thus, the requirements of Section 37 b (ii) of the NDPS Act stands satisfied for enlargement of bail to the Petitioner.

    8. Therefore, the petitioner has sought regular bail in the present FIR no. 146/2023 dated 19.04.2023 U/s 20/29 NDPS Act.

    9. Ld. Counsel for the Petitioner has placed reliance upon Kunal Dattu Kadu Vs Union of India 2022 SCC Online Bom 1770, Shri Sandip Ashok Raut Vs State of Maharashtra 2015 SCC Online Bom 4543, Rajesh Sharma Vs State of Rajasthan 2024 SCC Online Raj 485, Bettanayaka Vs State of Karnataka 2020 SCC Online Kar 3916, Ratanlal Kharadi Vs State of M.P. 2019 SCC Online MP 6083, Ratnesh Vs State 2017 SCC Online Del 9883,

    3

    Suresh Kumar Vs State 2016 SCC Online Del 1209 and Lavlesh Kumar Vs State 2015 SCC Online Del 12574, K. Kavitha vs ED SLP(Crl) No. 10785/2024, to buttress the arguments advanced.

    10. The Status Report has been filed on behalf of the State and is taken on record, wherein the present petition is opposed on the ground of gravity of the offence. It is submitted that it is a clear case of recovery of about 28 kgs of Ganja and the same comes within the Section 29 of the NDPS Act, 1985 against the petitioner as well as co-accused, Hari Ram as they were travelling together on the Honda Scooty. The FSL has confirmed that the contraband in both the backpacks was Ganja and the petitioner and co- accused were carrying commercial quantity of Ganja which is more than 20 Kgs. The bar of Section 37 of the NDPS Act, 1985 would thus, be applicable. Moreover, the prosecution witnesses are yet to be examined and if the bail is granted to the petitioner, there is likelihood of the petitioner indulging in the same offence and even jumping the bail.

    11. Therefore, the present petition has been opposed on behalf of the State.

    12. Submissions heard and judgments perused.

    13. The case of the prosecution is that allegedly total 28 kg of Ganja, (23.456 Kg from the Petitioner and 4.015 Kg from the co-accused Hari Ram), was recovered, which was placed in white colour plastic sacks, marked as A & B and sent for forensic examination.

    14. Though it is not in dispute that Ganja was recovered, the petitioner has taken a specific plea that the recovered quantity of 23.456 kg Ganja included the leaves and stalks/ stems which does not fall in the definition of contraband material and the actual quantity of Ganja would only be

    4

    mere 3.465 Kg., i.e. much lesser than the commercial quantity of 20 kgs.

    15. At this juncture, it becomes apposite to analyse whether the recovered material falls within the definition of "Ganja"?

    16. The definition of Ganja is provided under section 2 (iii)(b) of the NDPS Acts which reads as under :-

    "(b) ganja, that is, the flowering or fruiting tops of the cannabis plant (excluding the seeds and leaves when not accompanied by the tops), by whatever name they may be known or designated;"

    17. From the definition, it is evident that flowering buds and fruiting tops of the cannabis plant would be covered under section 2 (iii)(b) but merely leaves /seeds and stalks would not form a part of the definition of "Ganja"

    unless accompanied by the flowering and fruiting tops.

    18. This can be represented accurately by the below Venn diagram:-

    19. Thus, the intention of the Legislature appears to be clear that in case of Ganja, if it is merely Category A i.e. a homogenous mixture of flowering buds and fruiting tops, then the same would fall within the meaning of

    "Cannabis", however, if it is merely Category B i.e. a homogenous mixture of seeds/leaves/stalks without the fruiting tops and buds, then the same would not attract the provisions of the NDPS Act.

    20. Though the position with respect to homogenous mixtures i.e. Ganja/

    Cannabis A

    Flowering Buds +

    Fruiting tops

    B

    Stems + Seeds + stalks

    C

    5

    Category A & B is clear, there is often a conundrum surrounding the quantification of Category C, i.e. the overlap between Category A and Category B constituting the heterogenous mixtures which include both the flowering tops and fruiting buds, along with the stems/ leaves and seed.

    21. From the framework of the entire NDPS Act and a reading of S. 2 (iii)(b), it emerges that if the material seized is a heterogenous mixture/Category C, constituting of Category A mixed with Category B, the placebo material such as stalks/leaves/stems (Category B) would not constitute an actual part of the drug and only the actual content and weight of the narcotic drug (Category A) would be relevant for determining whether it would constitute small quantity or commercial quantity.

    22. Similar observations have been made in the cases of Kunal Dattu Kadu (Supra) and Shri Sandip Ashok Raut (Supra) and it was held that to ascertain whether the material seized was Ganja, it will have to be ultimately ascertained whether the flowering and fruiting are accompanied by the seeds and leaves as the weight of these seeds/leaves/stems, has to be excluded.

    23. Axiomatically, the weight of seeds/stalks and stems (Category B) should be excluded while calculating the actual quantity (Only Category A) recovered.

    24. Evidently, the present case is of a recovery falling within Category C. The Chargesheet records that when the Petitioner/Ravina was apprehended, blue coloured plastic polythene bag was recovered from her which contained

    grass-like flowery-leafy material along with its stems, which appeared to be

    "Ganja" and was seized vide the seizure memo. On weighing, the recovered Ganja on the electronic weighing machine, the total weight of the quantity recovered, was about 24.145 Kg.

    6

    25. The FSL Report confirmed that on physical, Chemical. Microscopic and TLC examination, exhibits 'SA-1' and 'SB-1' were found to be "Ganja".

    26. Pertinently, the recovered quantity of about 24.145 Kg was just 4.145 kgs more than the commercial quantity. Since, the entire substance including stems/stalks and dried leaves were weighed together without quantifying the weight of the flowering or fruiting tops, the quantity of 'Ganja' seized from the Applicant may be less than commercial quantity so as to attract Section 20 of the NDPS Act. The weight of actual Ganja recovered is a matter of trial.

    27. It has been consistently held that if there is a prima facie discrepancy in what was seized and what was analysed and weighed and there are reasonable grounds to believe that the petitioner is not guilty of offences dealing in commercial quantity. Consequently, the rigors of Section 37 of the NDPS Act, 1985 for grant of regular bail, would not become applicable as has been held in the case of Ibrahim Khwaja Miya Sayyed (Supra).

    28. In the case of Suresh Kumar (Supra), the Coordinate Bench of this Court gave benefit to the accused under Section 20 (b) (C) to 20 (b)(ii)(B) by observing that the weight of the contraband was not precise and the actual quantity of Ganja seized could not be determined because the FSL reflected that seeds, which do not come within the definition of Ganja, were weighed along with the flowering and fruiting tops. Thus, when there is a doubt on the actual amount of recovery of contraband, then this unexplained discrepancy would result in a benefit accruing in favour of the bail applicant.

    29. Similar observations have been made in the case of Rajesh Sharma (Supra), Bettanayaka (Supra), Ratanlal (Supra) and Ratnesh (Supra).

    7

    30. In light of the above discussion, it is settled that if there is the discrepancy in weight, as in the present case, the same would be a matter of trial.

    31. Admittedly, the petitioner has not been involved in any other crime previously and has clean antecedents. Moreover, there is nothing to show that the petitioner is likely to tamper with the evidence or influence the witnesses. Considering the background, it can also not be said that she is a flight risk.

    32. Considering the nature of allegations and the petitioner's clean antecedents, coupled with the fact that the trial is still ongoing, the present petition is allowed and the petitioner is admitted to regular bail in FIR No. 146/2023 registered under Section 29 read with Section 20(B)(ii)(c) of NDPS Act, 1985 at Police Station Badarpur, Delhi, upon his furnishing a personal bond in the sum of Rs. 25,000/- and one surety of the like amount to the satisfaction of the learned Trial Court, and further subject to the following conditions: -

    a) Petitioner shall appear before the Court as and when the matter is taken up for hearing;

    b) Petitioner shall provide her mobile number and also the mobile number of their spouse/surety to the IO concerned, both of which shall be kept in working condition at all times and they shall not change the mobile numbers without prior intimation to the Investigating Officer concerned;

    d) Petitioner shall inform the IO, the address where she shall be available in Delhi;

    e) Petitioner shall not indulge in any criminal activity and shall not

    8

    communicate with or come in contact with the witnesses.

    33. The Registry is further directed to communicate this Order to the learned Trial Court and as well as to the concerned Jail Superintendent.

    34. Accordingly, the present petition is disposed of.

    (NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)

    JUDGE

    SEPTEMBER 20, 2024

    9

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    RAVINA KUMARI v. STATE OF NCT OF DELHI
    (Sep 20, 2024)