Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Oral Judgment — High Court of Judicature at Patna (13-05-2025)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Om Traders (a partnership firm and two-wheeler dealer in Bihar), filed this writ petition challenging tax-related orders arising from alleged clerical errors in GST returns for April 2019. The petitioner submitted Form GSTR-1 on 10.05.2019 and Form GSTR-3B on 20.06.2019. While GSTR-1 showed a total taxable value and IGST figures, the corresponding figures in GSTR-3B were different due to an inadvertent mistake in GSTR-3B (excess IGST reported and mismatching CGST/SGST figures). The petitioner sought rectification of GSTR-3B to match GSTR-1.

The petitioner applied for rectification on 17.05.2019; that request was rejected by an Assistant Commissioner (remarks dated 06.05.2020) who advised paying CGST/SGST liabilities first and then applying for refund of excess IGST, noting that the taxpayer was under the State authority and asserting no provision permitting head-to-head adjustment. Subsequently, a show cause notice/assessment (GST DRC-01) was issued (31.05.2024) and an order dated 23.08.2024 raised a demand under CGST and SGST for April 2019. The petitioner approached this Court by way of writ petition (Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.16509 of 2024) seeking quashing of the impugned orders and directions for rectification.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order dated 06.05.2020 (respondent no.2) refusing rectification and advising payment of CGST/SGST first and then refund of IGST should be set aside as contrary to principles of natural justice and Article 265 of the Constitution.
  2. Whether the demand order dated 23.08.2024 (Form GST DRC-07) raising tax, interest and penalty for April 2019, based on alleged inadvertent clerical error in GSTR-3B and without regard to GSTR-1 and available IGST credit, is arbitrary and contrary to law.
  3. Whether charging interest on the disputed tax that arose solely from an inadvertent clerical error in GSTR-3B is illegal and arbitrary, particularly given availability of IGST credit adjustable under Rule 88A of the CGST Rules.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The discrepancy between GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B for April 2019 was an inadvertent clerical error limited to figures (total taxable value, IGST, CGST, SGST) and required rectification of GSTR-3B to align with GSTR-1.
  • The petitioner relied on the judgment of the Bombay High Court in Aberdare Technologies Pvt Ltd & Anr. v. Central Board of Indirect Taxes & Customs (Writ Petition No. 7912 of 2024 dated 29.07.2024) — subsequently the Special Leave Petition (diary no. 6332 of 2025) was dismissed on 23.01.2025 — to contend that the petitioner is entitled to rectification/amendment of returns and similar relief.
  • The relief sought is corrective (rectification of figures), not a substantively different tax position; therefore the impugned administrative directions and demand should be quashed and rectification permitted.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents relied on the Assistant Commissioner's remarks dated 06.05.2020: the taxpayer was supervised by the State Authority (Bihar Sharif Circle) and the grievance had been addressed to the proper authority; there is no provision to adjust erroneous IGST payment against CGST/SGST liabilities, and the taxpayer must pay CGST/SGST liabilities first and then claim refund of IGST.
  • Respondents also relied on Section 49(5) of the CGST Act (as cited before the Court) and urged the writ petition be dismissed on that basis.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Aberdare Technologies Pvt Ltd & Anr. v. Central Board of Indirect Taxes & Customs and ors (Writ Petition No. 7912 of 2024, Bombay High Court, 29.07.2024); Special Leave Petition (Civil) diary no. 6332 of 2025 dismissed by Supreme Court on 23.01.2025 Permitting amendment/rectification of GST returns (GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B); directing authorities to open portal and allow amendments or accept manual applications and process them. The Patna High Court relied on this authority (and the Supreme Court confirmation) to allow rectification in the present case and to direct the concerned authorities to permit amendment/rectification of GSTR-3B on par with GSTR-1 within a specified timeframe.
Engineers (I) Pvt Ltd. v. Union of India & ors. (referenced by the Bombay High Court; paras 7–23; note of paras 12–18) Authority relied upon by the Bombay High Court when directing that portal be opened and that amendments/rectifications be permitted (as reflected in the quoted directions in the Aberdare decision). The Patna High Court noted that the Bombay High Court had relied on this decision when issuing directions to permit amendment/rectification, and followed the reasoning in Aberdare which relied on Engineers (I) Pvt Ltd.
Kerala High Court judgment dated 12.11.2018 in W.P.(C) No. 35868 of 2018 (referenced in the taxpayer's grievance letter) Observed (as cited by the taxpayer) that tax authorities may be mandated to transfer tax to the correct head when GST is paid inadvertently in the wrong head. The Assistant Commissioner's remarks considered this judgment but stated it was not squarely applicable to the present facts; the Patna Court recorded this reference as part of the administrative history but based its decision primarily on recent Bombay High Court/Supreme Court authority.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded as follows (based solely on the contents of the opinion):

  1. The Court identified the disputed issue as whether the petitioner could rectify Form GSTR-3B so that it corresponds with Form GSTR-1 filed for April 2019. The factual matrix showed a clerical/error discrepancy between GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B in taxable values and tax heads (IGST/CGST/SGST).
  2. The Court noted there is no administrative portal-based system permitting rectification of a return once filed (as described in the record), and recorded that the petitioner had applied for rectification which was rejected by the Assistant Commissioner on 06.05.2020 with directions to pay CGST/SGST first and seek refund of IGST thereafter.
  3. The Court observed that it repeatedly asked the State counsel whether rectification would cause any loss to the State exchequer; the State counsel could not demonstrate such a repercussion on the record.
  4. The Court relied on the recent Bombay High Court decision in Aberdare Technologies (and the Supreme Court's dismissal of the SLP upholding that decision), and also noted the Bombay High Court's reliance on Engineers (I) Pvt Ltd. The Court treated those authorities as directly applicable to the present factual scenario of inadvertent clerical mismatch between returns and the need to permit rectification.
  5. On that basis, the Court concluded the petitioner had made out a case to interfere with the impugned administrative order dated 06.05.2020. The Court set aside that order and directed the concerned authorities to permit rectification of GSTR-3B to match GSTR-1 within a timeframe, subject to procedural steps described in the order (manual application, timelines, and consequential grievance redressal).
  6. The Court did not elaborate further statutory construction beyond recording the parties' reliance on statutory provisions and administrative remarks; its decision was grounded on the factual finding of inadvertent error, absence of shown prejudice to the exchequer, and the persuasive force of recent higher-court authorities permitting amendment/rectification in identical circumstances.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The writ petition is allowed.

Direct orders and consequences as set out by the Court:

  • The impugned order dated 06.05.2020 is set aside.
  • The concerned authorities are directed to rectify Form GSTR-3B to match the contents of Form GSTR-1 for April 2019 within one month from receipt of the order.
  • The petitioner is directed to submit a manual application for rectification (if portal access is not available) and the authorities are directed to accept and process the same in accordance with law.
  • The concerned authority is directed to redress any consequent grievance of the petitioner within two months from the date of the order.

Broader implications:

The Court based its decision on existing higher-court authorities (Bombay High Court decision in Aberdare Technologies and its affirmation by the Supreme Court) and therefore did not purport to lay down a novel legal principle in this opinion. The immediate effect is a direction for rectification and administrative compliance in favour of the petitioner; the opinion does not state that it establishes a new precedent beyond applying the cited authorities to the facts before the Court.

    Om Traders v. Union of India

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA

    Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.16509 of 2024

    ====================================================== Om Traders a partnership firm having its office at H. No.- 956A, Om Traders, Ramchandrapur, Biharsharif, Nalanda- 803216 Bihar through its Authorized Signatory Pankaj Kishore (Male, aged about 48 Years) Son of Shri Indra Deo Prasad, resident of near Kali Asthan Tilhapar, Bhaisasur, Biharsharif, District- Nalanda, Bihar- 803101.

    ... ... Petitioner/s

    Versus

    1. Union of India through the Secretary, Finance, North Block, New Delhi-

    110001.

    2. Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs, Ministry of Finance, Government of India through its secretary having its office at North Block, New Delhi- 110001.

    3. Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs, Grievance Ministry of Finance, Government of India through its secretary having its office at North Block, New Delhi- 110013.

    4. Commissioner of CGST and Central Excise, having its office at Bir Chand Patel Path Patna- 800001.

    5. State of Bihar, through the Commissioner of State Tax, Bihar, Patna having its office at Vikas Bhawan, Patna- 800001.

    6. Joint Commissioner of State Tax, Biharsharif, Patna East, Bihar.

    7. Goods and Services Tax, Network Having its office at word mark 1, Aerocity, Indira Gandhi International Airport, New Delhi 110037. ... ... Respondent/s

    ======================================================

    Appearance :

    For the Petitioner/s : Mr. D.V.Pathy, Advocate Mr. Sadashiv Tiwari, Advocate

    Mr. Hiresh Karan, Advocate

    Mrs. Shivani Dewalla, Advocate

    Mrs. Prachi Pallavi, Advocate

    For the Respondent/s : Mr. Anshuman Singh, SR. SC, CGST Mr. Vikas Kumar, SC-11

    ======================================================

    CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P. B. BAJANTHRI

    and

    HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE S. B. PD. SINGH

    ORAL JUDGMENT

    (Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P. B. BAJANTHRI) Date : 13-05-2025

    In the instant petition, the petitioner has prayed for the following relief(s):-

    1

    2/9

    i) the order dated 06.05.2020 (as contained in Annexure - P 6) passed by the respondent no. 2 for the Tax period 2019-20 only on the ground that the grievance was already addressed by the proper authority under the State Act and that there is no provision of adjustment of erroneous payment of tax under one head i.e. IGST with the liability of other head i.e. CGST and SGST and advising payment of erroneously payment of tax again and claim refund without reference to the respondent no. 1 to whom the application was addressed being contrary to the settled principles of natural justice and also Article 265 of the Constitution of India be set aside and quashed.

    ii) the order dated 23.08.2024 and also the summary of order in Form GST DRC - 07 (as contained in Annexure - P 9 series) passed by the respondent no. 6 raising demand of tax, interest and penalty amounting to Rs. 2,49,45,852/- for the month of April 2019 occurring only on account of an inadvertent clerical error in clicking the "submit"

    button while uploading the said return and the subsequent correction in GSTR 3B for the month of May 2019 without taking notice of the statement/return of outward supply in Form GSTR 1 for the month of April 2019; the auto populated statement of purchase in Form GSTR 2A reflecting purchase of goods and availability of ITC by way of IGST and also the provisions of Rule 88A of the CGST Rules (hereinafter called the Rules) permitting order of adjustment of IGST with CGST and SGST and the manner elaborated in Circular No. 98/17/2019/GST dated 23.04.2019 issued by the Central Board of Indirect Taxes in absence of a tax liability under IGST being contrary to Article 265 of the Constitution of India and is arbitrary be set aside and quashed.

    3/9

    iii) the charge of interest on disputed tax arising only on account of an inadvertent clerical error in filling up the return in Form GSTR 3B particularly, in view of availability of ITC in the electronic credit ledger by way of IGST adjustable with the tax liability under the CGST and SGST under Rule 88 A of the Rule being illegal and arbitrary be set aside and quashed.

    2. Brief facts of the case are that petitioner is a two wheeler dealer having a business in the State of Bihar. He was purchasing two wheelers from the manufacturer and the manufacturer are outside the State of Bihar. Therefore, there would be a IGST transaction. For the month of April 2019, GSTR 1 was filed on 10.05.2019 and GSTR 3B was filed on 20.06.2019. In filing GSTR 1, there is no error committed by the petitioner. While filing GSTR 3B, the petitioner inadvertently committed error under the column of total taxable value is indicated Rs. 8,23,83,871.09/-. in GSTR 1 total taxable value has been shown as 8,46,81,924.41/-. Similarly, IGST has been shown as Rs. 2,24,72,258.31/- whereas Rs. 34,347.02/- has been shown under GSTR 1. To the above effect, petitioner noticed that he had committed error while submitting GSTR 3B and it is not tallying with the GSTR 1 insofar as total taxable value and total integrated tax. Similarly, total CGST and total SGST. In this regard,

    4/9

    petitioner had submitted application to rectify GSTR 3B on par with the figure mentioned in GSTR 1 on 17.05.2019, the same was rejected on 06.05.2020. Resultantly, show cause notice was issued for assessment GST DRC-01 on 31.05.2024. Petitioner had submitted return submission on 16.06.2024. In this backdrop, impugned order has been passed by the concerned authority on 23.08.2024 while demanding certain amount of tax under the heading of SGST and CGST for the month of April 2019. On 06.05.2020, Assistant Commissioner of CGST and CX Ranchi Zone, Patna, office of the Chief Commissioner of GST and Central Excise (Ranchi Zone) passed the following remarks:-

    Details for registration number : CBOEC/E/2020/01342
    Name of complainant INDRA DEO PRASAD
    Date of Receipt 17/03/2020
    Received By Ministry/Department Central Board of Excise and Customs
    Grievance Description
    To, Central Board of Indirect Taxes & Customs, Department of Revenue, Ministry of Finance, Govt. of India. Sub: Request for adjustment of excess payment of IGST towards CGST and SGST. Dear Sir/Madam, We are carrying on business under trade name “Om Traders” at Bihar Sharif in Bihar and registered under Bihar Sharif Circle bearing GST No. 10AAAFO7986P1ZP. Due to mistake in filing of GSTR-3B for the month of April 2019, excess amount of GST tax has been paid in IGST instead of CGST and SGST. I had intimated this error to the concerned authority and requested for adjustment of excess paid GST tax in wrong head to the correct heads. But after several reminders since May 2019, my issue has not been resolved yet. I would like to draw your kind attention in a similar case, the Hon’ble High Court of Kerela in its

    5/9

    judgment dated 12/11/2018 under WP(C) No. 35868 of 2018 has mandated the tax authority to transfer the tax in correct head when GST is paid in wrong head inadvertently by the petitioner. So, I request the department to kindly transfer excess payment of GST in wrong head to correct heads. Attached letter contains full details with supporting documents for your kind reference. Thanks & Regards, Indra Deo Prasad Partner M/s Om Traders, Ramchandrapur, Bihar Sharif, Nalanda, Bihar 803101
    Current Status Case closed
    Date of Action 06.05.2020
    Remarks
    The matter raised in the instant Grievance under Grievance under CPGRAMS Reg. No. CBOEC/E/2020/01342 dated 17.03.2020 was examined by the jurisdictional Authority (CGST and CX, Patna East Division) who informed after examination that GSTIN – 10AAAFO7986P1ZP of M/s Om Traders, Ramchandrapur, Bihar Sharif was verified from the taxpayers list on GST Application Portal and it was found that the said taxpayer was supervised by the State Authority i.e. Bihar Sharif Circle and thus their grievance was already addressed to the proper authority. Further he added that as per existing law of GST, there was no provision of adjustment of erroneous payment of tax amount under one head i.e. IGST to liability of other Head i.e. CGST/SGST. As there exists liability of CGST amounting to Rs. 1,12,18,955.27 and SGST amounting to Rs. 1,12,18,955.27 against the said taxpayer, they are required to pay liability first and then apply for the refund of erroneous payment made under IGST through IGST through ITC amounting to Rs. 2,24,37,911.54 to the concerned State Authority/proper authority. So far as the judgment of Hon’ble Kerela High Court dated 12.11.2018 in WP © No. 3586 of 2018 quoted by the taxpayer is concerned, it is not squarely applicable in the case as it relates to a particular case for specific reason. Under the above circumstances, the grievance CPGRAMS Reg. No. CBOEC/E/2020/01342 dated 17.03.2020 is disposed off from this office.
    Officer concerns to
    Officer Name Sujit Kumar Sadhu (Assistant Commissioner of CGST and CX Ranchi Zone Patna
    Organisation Name Chief Commissioner of GST and Central Excise (Ranchi Zone)
    Contact Address Central Revenue Building Annexe, Birchand Patel Path, Patna,
    Email Address ccu-cexranchi@nic.in
    Contact Number 06122504035

    The same was not complied by the petitioner, in this

    backdrop, the petitioner filed present CWJC contending that it is

    6/9

    only a rectification of GSTR 3B on par with the GSTR 1 filed on 20.06.2019 and 10.05.2019 respectively.

    3. In support of the aforementioned contention, learned counsel for the petitioner relied on decision of the Bombay High Court dated 29.07.2024 passed in writ petition no. 7912 of 2024 in the case of Aberdare Technologies Pvt Ltd & Anr vs. Central Board of Indirect Taxes & Customs and ors. Central Board of Direct Taxes and customs preferred Special Leave Petition (civil) diary no. 6332 of 2025 and it was dismissed on 23.01.2025, while upholding the judgment dated 29.07.2024 passed in writ petition no. 7912 of 2024 in the High Court of Judicature at Bombay Civil Appellate Jurisdiction. The petitioner is entitled to same relief.

    4. Per contra learned counsel for the respondent resisted the aforementioned contentions and submitted that petitioner has failed to take the advise of the Assistant Commissioner of CGST and CX Ranchi Zone, dated 06.05.2020 which is narrated supra. Insofar as making payment of CGST and SGST and to claim IGST before the concerned authority. Further, he relied on Section 49(5) of the CGST Act and apprise this Court to dismiss the present writ petition.

    5. Heard learned counsel for the respective parties. Disputed issue in the present lis is whether petitioner is permitted to rectify GSTR 3B on par with the GSTR 1 filed on 20.06.2019 and

    7/9

    10.05.2019 or not? In the government, there is no system of rectification of any return once it is filed. However, petitioner had submitted application to rectify GST 3B on par with the GSTR 1 relating to certain total taxable value, total integrated tax, total CGST, total SGST. He had committed error insofar as mentioning total taxable value while submitting GSTR 3B and it is not in accordance with the GSTR 1. In the absence of any system to modify or to carry out necessary correction in GSTR 3B the concerned authority has proceeded to advise the petitioner to pay CGST and GST thereafter claim refund and it is not supported by any statutory provision. Further, we have noticed and repeatedly ask the State counsel as to whether rectification of GSTR 3B on par with the GSTR 1 has any repercussion insofar as loss to the State exchequer or not? On this point, he could not apprise this Court.

    6. Be that as it may in identical situation, Bombay High Court had an occasion to decide the matter insofar as rectification of GSTR 1 and GSTR 3B in the case of Aberdare Technologies Pvt Ltd & Anr vs. Central Board of Indirect Taxes & Customs and ors cited supra and it has been confirmed by the Supreme Court.

    7. Bombay High Court relied on Engineers (I) Pvt Ltd. Vs. Union of India & ors. (para 7 to 23) it has taken note of para 12 to 18 and directed as under para 4 reads as under:-

    8/9

    "In the circumstances, we direct respondents to open the portal within one week from the date of this order being uploaded and inform petitioner to enable them to amend/rectify Form GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B within one week. If the portal is not opened for whatever reasons, petitioner shall file application to amend/rectify Form GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B manually and respondent nos. 2 and 3 are directed to accept and process the same in accordance with law. If these respondents are going to take a stand contrary to petitioner's interest, they shall give notice to petitioner atleast five working days in advance and give personal hearing."

    8. The same was affirmed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. In the present case also it is error committed by the petitioner insofar as filling up of certain figures in the GSTR 3B return and it is not tallying with the GSTR 1 to that extent petitioner's request is for rectification of the same. Thus, petitioner has made out a case so as to interfere with the impugned order dated 06.05.2020 and it is set aside. The concerned authorities are hereby directed to rectify form GSTR 3B on par with contents of GSTR-1 within a period of one month from the date of receipt of this order. In this regard, petitioner is hereby directed to submit a manual application. The concerned authority is hereby directed to

    9/9

    redress the consequent grievance if any, of the petitioner within a period of two months from today.

    9. With the above observation the present writ petition stands allowed.

    (P. B. Bajanthri, J) ( S. B. Pd. Singh, J)

    Ankit Kumar/-

    AFR/NAFR AFR
    CAV DATE NA
    Uploading Date 16.05.2025.
    Transmission Date NA

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Om Traders v. Union of India
    (May 13, 2025)