AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners filed a revisional application under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 seeking to quash the First Information Report (FIR) No. 753 of 2023 dated 15th September 2023 and Charge Sheet No. 499 of 2024 dated 31st August 2024 under Sections 406 and 420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The FIR arose from a complaint by Shri Ranjit Singh alleging that the petitioners, owner and manager of Arjun Enterprise, had requested River Bed Materials (RBM) from him which he supplied via truck from January 2019 to January 2020 for Rs. 1,38,872/-. The petitioners allegedly failed to pay this amount, resulting in accusations of cheating and criminal breach of trust. The matter is pending before the Learned Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Jalpaiguri.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the allegations against the petitioners constitute the offences of criminal breach of trust under Section 406 IPC and cheating under Section 420 IPC.
  2. Whether the criminal justice system can be invoked in a dispute that essentially concerns recovery of money and alleged breach of contract.
  3. The distinction and coexistence of offences of criminal breach of trust and cheating in the facts of this case.
  4. Whether the FIR and charge sheet should be quashed under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The dispute concerns unpaid commercial invoices and does not disclose any ingredient of criminal breach of trust or cheating.
  • There was no entrustment of property to the petitioners; hence, misappropriation or conversion cannot be established.
  • The petitioners did not fraudulently or dishonestly deceive the complainant to induce delivery of property.
  • The complaint was filed after over three years since the last supply, indicating an attempt to circumvent limitation laws applicable to civil recovery suits.
  • The criminal justice system is being misused as a tool for recovery of money, which is impermissible.
  • Relied on the judgment in Delhi Race Club (1940) Ltd. & Ors. Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Another (2024 INSC 626) to emphasize the distinction between cheating and criminal breach of trust, asserting that both offences cannot coexist simultaneously on the same facts.

State's Arguments

  • Upon receipt of the complaint, the police registered a case, and investigation yielded sufficient material to establish offences under Sections 406 and 420 IPC.
  • The complainant alleged that the petitioners requested supply of RBM but failed to pay, thus prima facie case is made out.
  • Investigation included seizure of 31 loading slips issued by the petitioners’ firm, corroborating supply of materials.
  • The charge sheet was submitted after collecting adequate evidence against the petitioners.
  • The judgment relied upon by the petitioners is distinguishable on facts and circumstances.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Delhi Race Club (1940) Ltd. & Ors. Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Another (2024 INSC 626) Distinction between criminal breach of trust and cheating; both offences are independent and cannot coexist simultaneously on the same facts. The Court applied this principle to analyze the complaint and found no ingredients of both offences coexisting; emphasized that criminal intention for cheating must exist from inception.
Hari Prasad Chamaria v. Bishun Kumar Surekha & Ors., (1973) 2 SCC 823 Cheating requires dishonest or fraudulent intention at the time of inducement; mere breach of contract or subsequent failure to pay does not constitute cheating. The Court relied on this precedent to conclude that the complaint did not disclose commission of cheating, as no dishonest intention at the time of transaction was shown.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court carefully considered the facts and legal principles governing offences under Sections 406 and 420 IPC. It noted that criminal breach of trust requires entrustment of property or dominion over property, coupled with dishonest misappropriation or conversion. In the present case, the property (River Bed Materials) passed to the petitioners upon delivery, negating entrustment. Without entrustment, criminal breach of trust cannot be constituted.

Regarding cheating, the Court observed that the offence requires fraudulent or dishonest intention from the very beginning of the transaction to induce delivery of property. The complaint and investigation did not establish such intention at inception. The dispute essentially concerns non-payment for goods supplied, which is a civil matter.

The Court also highlighted the distinction between breach of contract and criminal offences, emphasizing that misuse of the criminal justice system for recovery of money is impermissible. It relied on authoritative precedents to clarify that offences of cheating and criminal breach of trust are mutually exclusive and cannot coexist simultaneously on the same facts.

Given these considerations, the Court found the FIR and charge sheet to be flawed and invoked its inherent powers under Section 482 CrPC to quash the criminal proceedings.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the revisional application and quashed the FIR No. 753 of 2023 and Charge Sheet No. 499 of 2024 under Sections 406 and 420 of the IPC. The petitioners were discharged from the case.

The direct effect of this decision is the termination of the criminal proceedings against the petitioners in this matter. The Court did not set any new precedent but reaffirmed established legal principles distinguishing civil disputes from criminal offences of cheating and criminal breach of trust, and cautioned against misuse of criminal law for civil recovery.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    PHUCHUNG TSHERING BHUTIA @ PHUCHUNG BHUTIA AND ANR. v. THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ANR.

    IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA

    CIRCUIT BENCH AT JALPAIGURI

    (Criminal Revisional Jurisdiction)

    APPELLATE SIDE

    Present:

    The Hon'ble Justice Krishna Rao CRR No. 223 of 2025

    Phuchung Tshering Bhutia @ Puchung Bhutia & Anr. Versus

    State of West Bengal & Anr.

    Mr. Jagriti Mishra

    Ms. A. Bhattacharjee

    Ms. M. Das

    .....For the Petitioners.

    Mr. Aditi Shankar Chakraborty, Ld. APP. Mr. Abhijit Sarkar

    …..For the State.

    Hearing Concluded On : 16.05.2024

    Judgment on : 20.05.2025

    Krishna Rao, J.:

    1. The petitioners have filed the present revisional application under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 praying

    1

    2

    for quashing of the First Information Report of Malbazar Police Station Case No. 753 of 2023 dated 15thSeptember, 2023, Charge Sheet No. 499 of 2024 dated 31stAugust, 2024 under Section 406/420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, corresponding to G.R. Case No. 4930 of 2023 pending before the Learned Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Jalpaiguri.

    2. One, Shri Ranjit Singh had filed a complaint before the Officer-in- Charge, Malbazar Police Station on 15thSeptember, 2023 against the petitioner no. 1 being the owner of Arjun Enterprise and the petitioner no. 2, namely, Vinay Shresta being the Manager of Arjun Enterprise alleging that as per request of the petitioners, the complainant has started providing River Bed Materials (RBM) with his truck from 19th January, 2019 till 26thJanuary, 2020. He supplied about 320 trucks of River Bed Materials to the petitioners on different locations for a total sum of Rs. 1,38,872/-. When the complainant demanded the amounts due to the complainant, the petitioners failed to pay the said amount and thus the petitioners have cheated the complainant and misappropriated the amount of the complainant.

    3. On receipt of the said complaint, the police of P.S. Malbazar registered an FIR No. 753 of 2023 dated 15thSeptember, 2023 under Section 406/420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The police has investigated the matter and on completion of investigation submitted charge sheet against the petitioners being Charge Sheet No. 499 of 2024 dated 31st August, 2024 under Section 406/ 420 of the IPC.

    3

    4. Learned Advocate representing the petitioners submits that the entire dispute relating to an alleged unpaid commercial invoices and no ingredient of criminal breach of trust or cheating is made out. He submits that there is no entrustment with the property of the complainant to the petitioners and the petitioners have not misappropriated or converted any property of the complainant of their own use.

    5. He further submits that the petitioners have not deceived the complainant fraudulently or dishonestly or induces the complainant to deliver any property to the complainant. He submits that breach of trust and cheating is not applicable in the facts of the present case.

    6. He submits that as per the complaint, the complainant has last supplied materials to the petitioners on 26thJanuary, 2020 and complaint was filed on 15thSeptember, 2023 that is after the period of three (3) years seven (7) months knowing that if the complaint files a suit for recovery of money, the same would be barred by limitation.

    7. He submits that the civil dispute has been given the colour of a criminal case. He submits that the Hon'ble Supreme Court and the different High Courts have consistently held that the criminal justice system should not be misused as a tool for recovery of money.

    8. Learned Counsel for the petitioners relied upon the judgment in the case of Delhi Race Club (1940) Ltd. & Ors. Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Another reported in 2024 INSC 626 and submitted

    4

    that there is a distinction between the offence of cheating and criminal breach of trust. Both offences are independent and distinct. The two offences cannot co-exist simultaneously in the same set of fact.

    9. Learned Counsel for the State submits that the on receipt of complaint, the police has registered a case and during investigation, sufficient materials have been collected to prove that the petitioners have committed an offence under Section 406/420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.

    10. Learned Counsel for the State submits that in the complaint, it is specifically alleged that as per request of the petitioners, the complainant has supplied River Bed Materials through his truck but the petitioners failed to pay the amount against the materials supplied to the petitioners, thus prima facie case is made out against the petitioners for the offence under Section 406/420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.

    11. Learned Counsel for the State submits that during investigation, the Investigating Officer has seized 31 pieces of loading slip of vehicle No. WB 73-D-8761 issued by the petitioner's firm which established that the complainant has supplied materials to the petitioners.

    12. Learned Counsel for the State submits that during investigation, sufficient materials have been collected against the petitioners to prove the case against the petitioners and thus the police has submitted

    5

    charge sheet against the petitioners for the offence under Section 406/420 of the IPC.

    13. Learned Counsel for the State submits that the judgment relied by the petitioners is distinguishable from the facts and circumstances of the present case.

    14. Complaint filed by the complainant before the Officer-in-Charge, Malbazar Police station dated 15thSeptember, 2023 reads as follows:

    "To The officer-in-Charge PS: Mal DATE: 15-09-23 PO: Mal

    Complainant: Ranjit Singh, S/o: Hari Shankar Singh, Permanent Resident of Hospital Para Kranti, PO-Kranti, P.S.-Mal, Dist: Jalpaiguri. Sub: FIR against 1. Phuchung Bhutiya Owner of Arjun Enterprise, 2. Vinay Shresta, Manager of Arjun Enterprise, VII- Turibari, Jalpaiguri, u/s,

    403,405,406,415,417,418,420 and 120, of Indian Penal Code along with other Sections. Respected Sir,

    This is for your kind information with a request to take immediate strict and immediate stringent steps against the above accused person. I the below signed would like to draw your kind attention towards the fact that the above two persons had conducted to provide R.B.M. to their company i.e. Arjun Enterprise having their office at Turibari Oodlabari, and as they said I started providing them R.B.M. with my truck from the date of 19/11/2019 and since then one by one almost

    6

    constantly I started giving them R.B.M. his place as per their company's demand, thus one by one I gave them about 45 days 320 trips, (loaded with R.B.M.) with my truck up to date of 26/01/2020, but the situation started changing from when I started asking them my dues. My rightful dues amount to Rs. 1,38,872.00 I have not received it till date, its been so long since I asked for my legitimate dues, I am almost tired, both the owner and the manager were turning me around day after day with false promises, without showing me any intention for clearing my dues. Now I have understand that they have completely cheated me, they made a deal with me, and I had supplied R.B.M. to them, but they did not gave me the money till today, they and their company had cheated me, Misappropriated me with an malafide intention, embezzled my money and not paying me back what which I should have.

    It is therefore prayed before Honorable authority by considering the above circumstance to have stringent action against the aforesaid No-1&2 under above mentioned section and other relevant section of Indian Penal Code, and initiate investigation.

    Ranjit Singh

    Thanking you, Yours faithfully."

    15. As per complaint, the complainant has supplied River Bed Materials to the petitioners from 19thNovember, 2019 to 26thJanuary, 2020 for a total sum of Rs. 1,38,872/- but the petitioners failed to make payment to the complainant.

    16. "Criminal Breach of Trust" is defined under Section 405 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and punishment thereto is provided under Section 406 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 which reads as follows:

    7

    "405. Criminal breach of trust.— Whoever, being in any manner entrusted with property, or with any dominion over property, dishonestly misappropriates or converts to his own use that property, or dishonestly uses or disposes of that property in violation of any direction of law prescribing the mode in which such trust is to be discharged, or of any legal contract, express or implied, which he has made touching the discharge of such trust, or wilfully suffers any other person so to do, commits "criminal breach of trust".

    Explanation 1.— A person, being an employer of an establishment whether exempted under section 17 of the Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 (19 of 1952), or not who deducts the employee's contribution from the wages payable to the employee for credit to a Provident Fund or Family Pension Fund established by any law for the time being in force, shall be deemed to have been entrusted with the amount of the contribution so deducted by him and if he makes default in the payment of such contribution to the said Fund in violation of the said law, shall be deemed to have dishonestly used the amount of the said contribution in violation of a direction of law as aforesaid.

    Explanation 2.— A person, being an employer, who deducts the employees' contribution from the wages payable to the employee for credit to the Employees' State Insurance Fund held and administered by the Employees' State Insurance Corporation established under the Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948 (34 of 1948), shall be deemed to have been entrusted with the amount of the contribution so deducted by him and if he makes default in the payment of such contribution to the said Fund in violation of the said Act, shall be deemed to have dishonestly used the amount of the said contribution in violation of a direction of law as aforesaid.

    406. Punishment for criminal breach of trust.—Whoever commits criminal breach of trust shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to three years, or with fine, or with both.

    8

    CLASSIFICATION OF OFFENCE

    Punishment- Imprisonment for 3 years and fine, or both-Cognizable-Non-bailable-Triable by Magistrate of the first class-compoundable by the owner of the property in respect of which breach of trust has been committed, with the permission of the court."

    17. In order to constitute a criminal breach of trust, the following ingredients are necessary:

    i. There must be entrustment with person for property or domain over the property,

    ii. The person entrusted:-

    a. Dishonestly misappropriated or converted property to his own use, or

    b. Dishonestly used or disposed of the property or willfully suffers any other person so to do in violation of:

    iii. Any direction of law prescribing the method in which the trust is discharge or

    iv. Legal contract touching the discharge of trust.

    18. Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 reads as follows:

    "420. Cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery of property.—Whoever cheats and thereby dishonestly induces the person deceived to deliver any property to any person, or to make, alter or destroy the whole or any part of a valuable security, or anything which is signed or sealed, and which is capable of being converted into a valuable security, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, and shall also be liable to fine.

    CLASSIFICATION OF OFFENCE

    Punishment- Imprisonment for 7 years and fine- Cognizable-Non-bailable-Triable by Magistrate

    9

    of the first class- compoundable by the person cheated with the permission of the court."

    19. In order to constitute an offence under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, the essential ingredients are as follows:

    i. Deception of any person, either by making a false or misleading representation or by other action or by omission:

    ii. Fraudulently or dishonestly inducing any person to deliver any property, or

    iii. The consent that any person shall retain any property and finally intentionally inducing that person to do or omit to do anything which would not do or omit.

    20. In the case of Delhi Race Club (1940) Ltd. & Ors. (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that:

    "26. Further, in both the aforesaid sections, mens rea i.e. intention to defraud or the dishonest intention must be present, and in the case of cheating it must be there from the very beginning or inception.

    27. In our view, the plain reading of the complaint fails to spell out any of the aforesaid ingredients noted above. We may only say, with a view to clear a serious misconception of law in the mind of the police as well as the courts below, that if it is a case of the complainant that offence of criminal breach of trust as defined under Section 405 of IPC, punishable under Section 406 of IPC, is committed by the accused, then in the same breath it cannot be said that the accused has also committed the offence of cheating as defined and explained in Section 415 of the IPC, punishable under Section 420 of the IPC.

    28. Every act of breach of trust may not result in a penal offence of criminal breach of trust unless there is evidence of manipulating act of fraudulent misappropriation. An act of breach of trust involves a civil wrong in respect of which the person may

    10

    seek his remedy for damages in civil courts but, any breach of trust with a mens rea, gives rise to a criminal prosecution as well. It has been held in Hari Prasad Chamaria v. Bishun Kumar Surekha & Ors., reported in (1973) 2 SCC 823 as under:

    "4. We have heard Mr. Maheshwari on behalf of the appellant and are of the opinion that no case has been made out against the respondents under Section 420 Penal Code, 1860. For the purpose of the present appeal, we would assume that the various allegations of fact which have been made in the complaint by the appellant are correct. Even after making that allowance, we find that the complaint does not disclose the commission of any offence on the part of the respondents under Section 420 Penal Code, 1860. There is nothing in the complaint to show that the respondents had dishonest or fraudulent intention at the time the appellant parted with Rs. 35.000/- There is also nothing to indicate that the respondents induced the appellant to pay them Rs. 35,000/- by deceiving him. It is further not the case of the appellant that a representation was made, the respondents knew the same to be false. The fact that the respondents subsequently did not abide by their commitment that they would show the appellant to be the proprietor of Drang Transport Corporation and would also render accounts to him in the month of December might create civil liability on the respondents for the offence of cheating."

    29. To put it in other words, the case of cheating and dishonest intention starts with the very inception of the transaction. But in the case of criminal breach of trust, a person who comes into possession of the movable property and receives it legally, but illegally retains it or converts it to his own use against the terms of the contract, then the question is, in a case like this, whether the retention is with dishonest intention or not, whether the retention involves criminal breach of trust or only a civil liability would depend upon the facts of each case.

    11

    30. The distinction between mere breach of contract and the offence of criminal breach of trust and cheating is a fine one. In case of cheating, the intention of the accused at the time of inducement should be looked into which may be judged by a subsequent conduct, but for this, the subsequent conduct is not the sole test. Mere breach of contract cannot give rise to a criminal prosecution for cheating unless fraudulent or dishonest intention is shown right from the beginning of the transaction i.e. the time when the offence is said to have been committed. Therefore, it is this intention, which is the gist of the offence. Whereas, for the criminal breach of trust, the property must have been entrusted to the accused or he must have dominion over it. The property in respect of which the offence of breach of trust has been committed must be either the property of some person other than the accused or the beneficial interest in or ownership' of it must be of some other person. The accused must hold that property on trust of such other person. Although the offence, i.e. the offence of breach of trust and cheating involve dishonest intention, yet they are mutually exclusive and different in basic concept. There is a distinction between criminal breach of trust and cheating. For cheating, criminal intention is necessary at the time of making a false or misleading representation i.e., since inception. In criminal breach of trust, mere proof of entrustment is sufficient. Thus, in case of criminal breach of trust, the offender is lawfully entrusted with the property, and he dishonestly misappropriated the same. Whereas, in case of cheating, the offender fraudulently or dishonestly induces a person by deceiving him to deliver any property. In such a situation, both the offences cannot co-exist simultaneously."

    21. In the present case, the allegation that the complainant has supplied River Bed Materials but the petitioners failed to pay the amount of the materials supplied. In the case of sale of goods, the property passes to the purchaser from the seller when the goods are delivered. Once the property in the goods passes to the purchaser, it cannot be said that

    12

    the purchaser was entrusted with the property of the seller. Without entrustment of property, there cannot be any criminal breach of trust. Thus, prosecution of cases on charge of criminal breach of trust, for failure to pay the consideration amount in the case of sale and goods is flawed to the core. There can be civil remedy for the non-payment of the consideration amount, but no criminal case will be maintainable for it.

    22. Considering the above, this Court finds that this is the fit case to invoke the provisions of Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. Accordingly, First Information Report of Malbazar Police Station Case No. 753 of 2023 dated 15thSeptember, 2023, Charge Sheet No. 499 of 2024 date 31stAugust, 2024 under Section 406/420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, corresponding to G.R. Case No. 4930 of 2023 pending before the Learned Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Jalpaiguri are set aside and quashed. The petitioners are discharged from the case.

    23. C.R.R. No. 223 of 2025 is allowed. Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of a server copy of the Judgment placed on the official website of the Court. Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this Judgment, if applied for, be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.

    (Krishna Rao, J.)

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    PHUCHUNG TSHERING BHUTIA @ PHUCHUNG BHUTIA AND ANR. v. THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ANR.
    (May 20, 2025)