Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • short. Rule 12 of the Rules of Legal Education, 2008
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • short. Rule 12 of the Rules of Legal Education, 2008
Smart Summary

Summary of Judgment — WA No.74/2024 (High Court of Meghalaya)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant was a 5th semester student of Shillong Law College affiliated to North Eastern Hill University (NEHU) pursuing the LLB course. He was not allowed by the college to sit the 5th semester end-semester examination held in December 2024 on the ground that his attendance was below the minimum requirement prescribed by Rule 12 of the Rules of Legal Education, 2008. The appellant's recorded attendance before the examination was 60%. He claimed that his attendance fell short due to a gallbladder ailment and surgery in November 2024 and sought permission to appear in the examination.

A single judge dismissed the appellant's writ petition, feeling bound by Rule 12. The appellant filed the present appeal. By an interim order dated 5 December 2024 the High Court allowed the appellant to sit the examination without prejudice to the parties' rights and contentions. The appellant appeared in the examination; the result was pending at the time of this judgment. The appeal was heard on the filing of paper-books and decided on 6 May 2025.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a student who falls below the 70% attendance threshold prescribed by Rule 12 due to illness (here, a gallbladder ailment and surgery) can be permitted to appear in the end-semester examination.
  2. Whether Rule 12 must be interpreted strictly in all cases or whether it permits a reasonable/liberal construction in extraordinary circumstances (illness, acts of God, bereavement, etc.), including the scope of the discretion conferred on the Dean, Principal, Vice‑Chancellor or Director to allow a student with at least 65% attendance to take the test for exceptional reasons.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant's attendance fell short because, from about August 2024, he suffered from a gallbladder ailment which in August and again in October 2024 caused intense pain and reduced attendance; he underwent surgery in November 2024.
  • He was a diligent and meritorious student with high attendance in several subjects (100% in some papers, 85.71% in another), and his overall performance indicated sufficient interest and knowledge of the subjects; therefore he should be allowed to write the examination despite the shortfall caused by illness.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The college/University relied on Rule 12 of the Rules of Legal Education, 2008, which requires a minimum of 70% attendance to be eligible for the end semester test; because the appellant's attendance was only 60%, he was ineligible to take the examination.
  • The single judge hearing the writ petition considered himself bound by the rule and dismissed the petition on that basis.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reproduced Rule 12 in full and then examined the undisputed factual matrix: the appellant's attendance history across five papers (ranging between 50% and 100% across subjects), episodes of aggravated illness in August and October 2024 and surgery in November 2024, and an overall attendance of 60% prior to the 5th semester examination.

The court reasoned that Rule 12 must be interpreted reasonably. It distinguished between two categories of absence: (a) absence resulting from deliberate or negligent non-attendance in normal circumstances, where the rule should operate strictly, and (b) absence caused by extraordinary circumstances — such as illness, bereavement, natural disaster, riot, political upheaval or other acts of God — where strict application of the rule would be inappropriate. In the latter category, the rule ought either not to apply or to be liberally construed, taking into account the student's overall performance, conduct and demonstrated interest in the subjects.

The court observed that the administrators of the college (Dean/Principal) have a limited statutory discretion under Rule 12 to allow a student with at least 65% attendance to appear in the test for exceptional reasons; more generally, administrators must examine each case on its own merits.

Applying these principles to the facts, the court found that the appellant's shortfall in attendance was caused by illness and that, but for the gallbladder ailment, he would have maintained regular attendance. The court therefore concluded that the case fell within the category of extraordinary circumstances where the rule should not be applied rigidly.

On that basis the court reaffirmed the reasoning given in its interim order dated 5 December 2024 and directed that the appellant's attendance be treated as regular and that he be assessed in the 5th semester examination in the regular course.

Holding and Implications

CORE RULING: The appeal is ALLOWED; the impugned judgment and order of the single judge is set aside; the appellant's attendance is to be treated as regular and he shall be assessed in the 5th semester examination in the regular course.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The appellant may be assessed as a regular candidate in the 5th semester examination; the single judge's dismissal of the writ petition has been overturned.
  • Legal/practical guidance: The court clarified that Rule 12 is to be interpreted reasonably and should not be applied rigidly in cases of extraordinary circumstances (illness, bereavement, natural disasters, riots, political upheavals, acts of God). Administrators are required to consider each case on its own merits and may permit a student to appear in an examination where the student's overall performance, conduct and circumstances justify such relief.

    BAMANGNABAM v. NORTH EASTERN HILL UNIVERSITY AND 3 ORS.

    Page 1 of 6 Serial No.03 Daily List

    HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA

    AT SHILLONG

    WA No.74/2024

    Date of Order : 06.05.2025 Shri Bamang Nabam ….. Appellant Vs.

    1. North Eastern Hill University (in short NEHU) represented by the Registrar of NEHU, Umshing Mawkynroh, Shillong-793002.

    2. The Controller of Examination NEHU, Umshing Mawkynroh, Shillong-

    793002.

    3. The Vice Chancellor, NEHU Umshing Mawkynroh, Shillong-793002.

    4. The Principal, Shillong Law College, Dhankheti, Shillong, East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya. ….. Respondents

    Coram:

    Hon'ble Mr. Justice I.P. Mukerji, Chief Justice Hon'ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge Appearance:

    For the Appellant : Mr. P. Yobin, Adv with Ms. I. Laloo, Adv

    Mr. A. Dkhar, Adv

    For the Respondent : Mr. S. Sen, Adv with Ms. E. Blah, Adv for R/1-3

    Mr. S. Chakrawarty, Sr.Adv with Mr. E. Laloo, Adv for R/4

    F

    1

    i) Whether approved for Yes reporting in Law journals etc.:

    ii) Whether approved for publication Yes in press:

    Note: For proper public information and transparency, any media reporting this judgment is directed to mention the composition of the bench by name of judges, while reporting this judgment/order.

    JUDGEMENT: (per the Hon'ble, the Chief Justice) (ORAL) The appellant was a 5thsemester student of Shillong Law College under North Eastern Hill University (NEHU), pursuing its LLB course. He was not allowed to write the 5thsemester examination which was held some time in December, 2024. The reason why the college did not allow him to do so was that his attendance was short. Rule 12 of the Rules of Legal Education, 2008 was made applicable. Its states that if a student does not have minimum 70 per cent attendance in each subject, he would be ineligible to take the examination. The Dean of the University or the Principal of the Centre of Legal Education had a limited power of allowing students with at least 65 per cent attendance to appear for the examination provided the reasons for such exercise of power were exceptional.

    In this case, the attendance of the appellant-student was 60 per cent.

    2

    He pleaded that his attendance fell short due to gallbladder ailment followed by surgery that he underwent in November, 2024 and that he should be allowed to write the examination.

    Learned single judge hearing the writ petition felt himself bound by the said rule and dismissed the writ petition.

    The appeal was preferred before us.

    By our interim order dated 5thDecember, 2024, we allowed the appellant to sit for the examination without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the parties in the appeal.

    We are told that he appeared in the examination, the result of which is awaited.

    In the meantime, the appeal became ready for hearing on filing of paper-books. We have heard out the appeal today.

    First let us set out Rule 12. It is as follows:

    "12. End Semester Test. No students of any of the degree program shall be allowed to take the end semester test in a subject if the student concerned has not attended minimum of 70% of the classes held in the subject concerned as also the moot court room exercises, tutorials and practical training conducted in the subject taken together. Provided that if a student for any exceptional reasons fail to attend 70% of the classes held in any subject, the Dean of the University or the Principal of the Centre of Legal Education, as the case may be, may allow the student to take the test if the student concerned

    3

    attended at least 65% of the classes held in the subject concerned and attended 70% of classes in all the subjects taken together. The similar power shall rest the Vice Chancellor or Director of a National Law University, or his authorized representative in the absence of the Dean of Law."

    The facts which the appellant/writ petitioner present before us and not contradicted by the respondents are these: He is a very diligent and meritorious student.

    From or about August, 2024, he developed an ailment relating to his gallbladder. Often, he used to be in intense pain as a result of which, his attendance dipped sharply in August, 2024. However, he was in better state of health in September, 2024. His attendance was 100 per cent in evidence, Civil Procedure code, labour law and drafting, pleadings and conveyancing and

    85.71 per cent in human rights, the average of which was 97 per cent. Once again in October, 2024 his illness aggravated and there was a drop in attendance although not so much as it was in August, 2024. The attendance range was between 50 per cent and 85.71 per cent in the five papers. This continued in November, 2024 when he had to undergo a surgery. Before the 5thsemester examination, it was only 60 per cent. We had advanced the following reasons in our interim order dated 5th December, 2024 allowing the appellant/writ petitioner to sit for the examination:

    4

    "Prima facie we are of the view that this rule is to be interpreted reasonably. When it is possible for the student to attend classes and he deliberately or negligently does not do so, the rule would apply. In case of impossibility created by illness, act of God etc., this rule is either not to be applied or to be liberally construed, so that taking into account the overall performance of the student and his conduct, his case for being allowed to write the examination is compassionately considered.

    Prima facie there is nothing to suggest anything against the merit of the student.

    As an interim order, we direct the respondents to allow the appellant to sit for the examination commencing tomorrow, subject to the result of the appeal. All formalities like permission from the College or issuance of admit card by the University shall be done in course of the day on the basis of the written communication on the basis of this order by the learned Advocate-on-record for the appellant, counter signed by an officer attached to this Court, in case the server copy of the order is not available.

    We expedite the hearing of the appeal dispensing with all formalities. Advocate-on-record for the appellant will file informal paper-books in this Court by 3rdFebruary, 2025. Copies of the paper-books should be served on the respondent at least seven days before the date of hearing of the appeal.

    List the appeal for hearing on 19thFebruary, 2025."

    We affirm those reasons. We reiterate that the above rule could only cover a situation where in normal circumstances a student is absent and his attendance falls below 70 per cent. But this rule certainly does not cover extraordinary circumstances like illness or bereavement in a student's family, natural disaster, riot strife, political upheavals, other acts of God and so on which prevent a student or students from attending classes.

    5

    In such a case, this rule would not apply. The administrators of the college are to consider each case on its own merit. If they find that with the existing attendance the student has shown sufficient interest in and has adequate knowledge of the subjects in the semester and is otherwise diligent and of good conduct, he should be allowed to write the examination. In this case, the record shows that had the student not been inflicted with gallbladder ailment, he would have maintained regular attendance and fulfils the above qualifying criteria.

    In that view of the matter, we direct that the attendance of the appellant/writ petitioner be treated as regular and that he be assessed in the 5th semester examination in regular course.

    This appeal is accordingly allowed. The impugned judgment and order is set aside.

    (W. Diengdoh) (I.P. Mukerji) Judge Chief Justice

    Meghalaya

    06.05.2025

    "Lam DR-PS"

    6

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    BAMANGNABAM v. NORTH EASTERN HILL UNIVERSITY AND 3 ORS.
    (May 6, 2025)