आदेश / O R D E R P ER PRABHASH SHANKAR [A.M.] :-
Thepresent appeal emanating from the appellate order dated 12.03.2020is filed by the assesseeagainst the order passed by the Learned Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals)49,Mumbai[hereinafter referred to as "CIT(A)"] pertaining to assessmentorder u/s. 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 [hereinafter referred to as "Act"] dated21.12.2017- passed by the Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle 7(2), Mumbaifor the Assessment Year [A.Y.] 2015-16.
1
2. It may be stated here that in this case,vide order in ITA No.1645/Mum/2023 dated 22.08.2023,the appeal was earlier decided dismissing the appeal of the assessee ex parte.However,subsequently on an application by the assessee,the order was recalled vide M.A.No.645/Mum/2023.Accordingly,the original appeal on restoration has been fixed and after according due opportunity of hearing to both the parties is being decided here.
3. The main grounds of appeal are as under:-
1. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law the Ld. CIT(A) erred in confirming the AO's action of disallowing the business loss of Rs 26,88,98,500/-on contract settlement by holding the same as not genuine.
2. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law the Ld. CIT(A) erred in confirming the AO's action of holding the business loss of Rs. 26,88,98,500/- as speculative loss and thereby, not allowing the set-off against the non-speculative business income.
4. Brief facts of the case are that theassessee filed its return of income on 29.09.2015 declaring total loss of Rs. 25,50,57,463/-.During the year under consideration, the assessee derivedincome from commodity trading.It was observed that the assessee had claimed loss of Rs. 26,88,98,500/- on account of loss on commodity trading. The Assessing Officer while adjudicated on the issue of loss observed and decided as below:
" During the course of assessment proceedings, it was observed that the assessee had claimed loss of Rs. 26,88,98,500/- on account of loss on shares/commodity and this includes Rs. 60,000/- on account of expenses related to the loss on the commodity. The details in this regard were called for and it was submitted that the company has made
2
six different purchase contracts of commodity 'coriander' with another companies i.e. M/s Arabesque Mercantile Pvt. Ltd. (AMPL) and M/s Betul Oil Ltd. (BOL) on various dates during FY 2014-15. It was further submitted that the company has debited Rs. 26,88,38,500/- towards the price difference of the coriander commodity on account of settlement of contract and price difference. In this physical movement of the commodity did not happen and it was a non-delivery based transaction. It was also observed that this transaction also not being carried out at any recognized Commodity Stock Exchange. The overall nature of the transaction appeared to be non- genuine. In view of these facts, the assessee was requested by the AO to show cause as to why the loss of Rs. 26,88,98,500/- should not be disallowed and added back to total income on account of being bogus and non-genuine.
In response to this the VMEPL filed its submission which is reproduced as under:-
"With reference to your notice dated 11/12/2017, we would like tosubmit that during the course of hearing, we explained the facts of the case and also explained why the claimed loss of Rs. 26,88,98,500/-on account of trade settlement is genuine and should be allowed as a business loss.
The summary of the said submissions are as follows:
We are in to the business of agro commodities. During the course of business we do various contract for procurement as well as supply. We also do contracts to guard against loss through future price fluctuations in respect of other contracts for delivery of goods. We further submit that above contracts may be in 'oral or written'.
We also submit that we had engaged/entered into contracts for sale of coriander with buyer. We further submit that due to price difference, buyer has issued debit notes for Rs. 26,88,98,500/- and Rs. 60,000 for other expenses for non- delivery of goods as per the contract which was shown as "loss from contract settlement" in our profit & loss account.
We submit that the department has proceeded mainly on the premise that the overall nature of transaction appear to be non-genuine as noevidence provided by us to prove that the transaction is genuine and the price difference arising on settlement of contract is on nature of 'speculation transaction' and therefore, the loss arising out of such purchase and sale transactions are only be set off against the speculation profit. We submit that this objection raised by the department is erroneous in as much as, the same is without proper understanding of the manner in which commodity business are transacted between a Buyer and Seller in the trade.
We submit that during the year 2014-15, we have entered into six contracts with M/s Arabseque Mercantile Pvt Ltd. (i.e. the buyer) & M/s Betul Oil Limited (i.e. the buyer) for sale of commodity "Coriander". In terms of the said contract, the title to the contracted goods is transferred to buyer by us at a price (generally the prevailing market price) agreed between the parties, however, the physical
3
delivery of the goods shall be given to the buyer at any time before the contract expires (known as the delivery period) which could be one month, two months etc., from the date of entering into the contract. Further, 100% of the contract price is required to be paid by the buyer to us within 3 working days from the date of Invoice and Lorry Receipt/handover of Warehouse Receipt endorsed. It may be noted that the price of the underlying commodity i.e. the Coriander keeps fluctuating due to market influence of demand and supply and, naturally the market price prevailing agreed upon by the parties on the date of entering into contract would either increase or decrease several times before the expiry of the delivery period. Many a times on the date of taking delivery of the goods, the purchaser offers to resell the same to seller at the spot price prevailing that day. In case we agree then the seller does not supply the goods and buyer/we prepare a Debit/Credit note to account for the price difference between the contracted price and the prevailing market price, the loss/ income is being integral part of our business.
We submit that in the present case the buyer had entered into contract with us for buy of Coriander. However, since, there has been increase in the price of the contracted goods during the delivery period; we have not given physical delivery of the goods. But we have buy back the same and the price difference arising due to such transaction is paid by us. We submit that buyer issue debit note to us for the price difference payable to buyer on account of the said transaction. The contracts entered by us with the buyer, the Debit Note issued by buyer to us, Ledger Confirmation from buyer, Income Tax return, Profit and Loss, Balance Sheet, List of Directors and Shareholder of buyer are already furnished by us to your good office. However, sample copies of the same are again enclosed to this reply.
These documents prove that transactions are genuine. In our case, the transaction entered by us with the buyer is a genuine business transaction and all the necessary ingredients for nature of speculation transaction are non- existent.
We also submit the buyer has not recoded said income in their books as "profit from contract settlement" and the said income has already been offered for taxation by the buyer in its computation of income.
We submit that during the year 2014-15, we have loss of Rs. 26,88,98,500/-on such trading in goods with the buyer and the said loss is recorded by us in our books as "Loss from contract settlement" under Purchase Accounts. As explained above, the said loss is nothing but the price difference/profit/Loss earned between the sale andpurchase transaction entered by us with the buyer. In other words, it is the loss by us selling the goods at a higher price and thereafter buying the same back at a lower price.
In view of the above submissions, we submit that the contract entered by us with the Buyer is an activity of trading in goods and not a speculative transaction,
4
We humbly pray before your good self to kindly drop the subject point in the interest of justice and equity."
6.1 The details of the contracts undertaken by the VMEPL for sale of coriander commodity (Badami Whole Dhaniya) are as under:-
| Contract No. |
Part y |
Date |
Rate(Rs .)/MT |
Qty MT |
Contra ct Period (Days) |
Amount(Rs.) |
| BOL/Agri/Vision/ 03/32 |
BOL |
30.05.2014 |
91,650/- |
1500 |
60 |
13,74,75,000/- |
| BOL/Agri/Vision/ 03/30 |
BOL |
29.05.2014 |
90,450/ - |
2000 |
60 |
18,09,00,000/- |
| AMPL/Agri/Visio n/03/29 |
AMP L |
27.05.2014 |
90,100/ - |
1500 |
60 |
13,51,50,000/- |
| AMPL/Agri/Visio n/03/23 |
AMP L |
23.05.2014 |
88,650/ - |
2500 |
60 |
22,16,25,000/- |
| BOL/Agri/Vision/ 03/22 |
BOL |
23.05.2014 |
88,900/ - |
2500 |
60 |
22,22,50,000/- |
| BOL/Vision/BOL/ 03/21 |
BOL |
22.05.2014 |
88,700/ - |
2300 |
60 |
20,40,10,000/- |
| TOTAL |
|
|
|
|
|
110,14,10,000/- |
From a perusal of the details of the contracts, it is manifest that the numbers given to the
contract has no rationale at all as VMEPL has executed multiple contracts during FY 2014-15. The
numbers given to the contracts are illogical and not in sequence. It appears that the STPL has
undergone 20 such contracts earlier but nothing was on record to show the earlier numbered
contracts. Copy of one of the contracts is also enclosed along with the assessment order as
Annexure I.
The above said contracts were made only between VMEPL and AMPL and there was no
broker involved in whole of the process. Another contact was made only between VMEPL and
Betul Oil Ltd. (BOL) and there was no broker involved in whole of the process
The VMEPL is unable to explain and produce such earlier contracts bearing numbers
before the numbers given to the above mentioned contracts.
The contracts were made on the letter head of the AMPL and BOL and signatures of only
seller and buyer are seen on second page of the contracts.
This buyer party AMPL is well known to the VMEPL asseen from the balance sheet of the
VMEPL and AMPL.
There are transactions of unsecured loan between VMEPL, AMPL.
The shareholders of VMEPL and BOL are from same family.
5
The VMEPL has made contract of coriander sale approximately of Rs. 110 Crores but inexplicably there was no advance of a single rupee given by AMPL or BOL to VMEPL at the time of the contract.
After lapse of 60 days AMPL has raised debit notes with respect to each of the abovementioned six contracts. The details are as under:-
| Contract No. |
Date |
Contract Rate(Rs.) /MT |
Market Price (Rs./MT) |
Quantit y MT |
Price Difference |
Amount (Rs.) |
| BOL/Agri/Vision/03 /32 |
29.07.2014 |
91,650/- |
1,11,400 |
1500 |
19,750 |
2,96,40,000/- |
| BOL/Agri/Vision/03 /30 |
21.07.2014 |
90,450/- |
1,11,400 |
2000 |
20,950 |
4,19,00,000/- |
| AMPL/Agri/Vision/0 3/29 |
28.07.2014 |
90,100/- |
1,11,400 |
1500 |
21,300 |
3,19,63,500/- |
| AMPL/Agri/Vision/0 3/23 |
28.07.2014 |
88,650/- |
1,11,400 |
2500 |
22,750 |
5,68,75,000/- |
| BOL/Agri/Vision/03 /22 |
22.07.2014 |
88,900/- |
1,11,400 |
2500 |
22,500 |
5,62,50,000/- |
| BOL/Vision/BOL/03 /21 |
21.07.2014 |
88,700/- |
1,11,400 |
2300 |
22,700 |
5,22,10,000/- |
| TOTAL |
|
|
|
|
|
26,88,38,500 |
All the above said contracts were settled and the loss of Rs. 26,88,38,500/- was claimed
by the assessee in profit and loss account.
Copy of one of the debit notes is also enclosed along with the assessment order as
Annexure - II. These debit notes were printed on the letter head of AMPL and BOL without any
identification numbers on them. After the minute observations of the debit notes and contact
notes, it is seen that even the reference contract numbers mentioned in debit notes are also
different. The same can be seen after comparing the above two tables.
There was no broker involved at any of the stage till the settlement of contract.
Even after the settlement of contract, no actual payment was made from AMPL to
VMEPL, not only this; payment was never paid from VMEPL or AMPL.
The ledger of AMPL in the books of VMEPL was called for and the same is as under:-
| Date |
Particulars |
Vch. Type |
Debit |
Credit |
| 23/04/2014 |
Sales Coriander |
Sales Coriander |
145987897 |
|
| 25/04/2014 |
Sales Coriander |
Sales Coriander |
76940218 |
|
| 24/06/2014 |
Purchase Coriander |
Purchase Coriander |
|
7300000 |
| 28/06/2014 |
Purchase Coriander |
Purchase Coriander |
|
79800000 |
6
| 07/07/2014 |
Purchase Coriander |
Purchase Coriander |
|
101295709 |
| 10/07/2014 |
Purchase Coriander |
Purchase Coriander |
|
44693000 |
| 25/08/2014 |
Purchase Coriander |
Purchase Coriander |
|
22950000 |
| 18/09/2014 |
Purchase Coriander |
Purchase Coriander |
|
154224000 |
| 31/3/2015 |
Vision Millenium Exports Pvt. Ltd. Mumbai |
Journal |
28,60,594 |
|
| 31/3/2015 |
-do- |
Journal |
3,02,50,000 |
|
| 31/3/2015 |
-do- |
Journal |
15,42,24,000 |
|
|
|
|
410262709 |
410262709 |
It is observed that this transaction of contract settlement was adjusted against the sale of
coriander made from VMEPL to AMPL during the same FY and the journal entry was passed on
the last day of FY.
The whole of the transaction is bogus and manipulated to take the fictitious loss on account of
contract settlement which was ultimately adjusted against the huge profit on sale of shares.
The VMEPL has net profit on sale of shares amounting to Rs. 25,57,37,883/- during the year and
the sale and purchase of shares on stock exchange is the business activity of the VMEPL. The
amount payable by AMPL to VMEPL on account of loss on contract settlement was adjusted
against the sale bills of coriander sale from VMEPL to AMPL and BOL.
The contract settlement transaction was neither carried out at any of the recognized
'Commodity Stock Exchange' nor there any broker involved. Hence, no third party verification
can be done to cross check the veracity of the claim.
The documents purporting to be an agreement is not stamped nor registered with any
government authorities and, hence, those rights and obligations are not enforceable in court of
law - which is highly improbable looking at the quantum of the transaction.
It is apparent that transaction has been created as an afterthought and a device to
illegitimately reduce the tax liability. Since it is afterthought, the similarity of rate of coriander in
contract note to the rate reflected on NCDEX platform is of no consequence.
This is not an independent transaction between the strangers but between two persons
commercially well acquainted with one another. This increases the scope of manipulation.
7
It is significant to note that the counter party i.e. AMPL, has profit from the contract settlement but the said profit was set off against its loss of business. Ultimately, therefore, neither of the parties have paid any tax on this transaction. The contract settlement by SCCPL and loss from the said transaction cannot be viewed in isolation. Enquiries and verification reveal without an iota of doubt that the group entities have manipulated the profits and loss in their constituent companies in such a way that there should not be any tax on any of the profit.
This itself makes it clear that the goods were never delivered nor there was any movement of a single rupee for the transaction. The SCCPL also mentions that they had bought back the commodity, this is like doing business with own which is not permissible by law. The essentials of a valid contract as emanates from the Indian Contracts Act, 1872 and various judicial pronouncements are as under:-
1. Offer and acceptance:
In a contract there must be at least two parties one of them making the offer and the other accepting it. There must thus be an offer by one party and its acceptance by the other. The offer when accepted becomes agreement.
2. Legal relationship:
Parties to a contract must intend to constitute legal relationship. It arises when the parties know that if any one of them fails to fulfill his part of the promise, he would be liable for the failure of the contract.
If there is no intention to create legal relationship, there is no contract between parties. Agreements of a social or domestic nature which do not contemplate a legal relationship are not contracts.
3. Consensus-ad-idem:
The parties to an agreement must have the mutual consent i.e. they must agree upon the same thing and in the same sense. This means that there must be consensus ad idem (i.e. meeting of minds).
4. Competency of parties:
The parties to an agreement must be competent to contract. In other words, they must be capable of entering into a contract.
According to Sec 11 of the Act, "Every person is competent to contract who is of the age of majority according to the law to which he is subject to and who is of sound mind and is not disqualified from contracting by any law to which he is subject."
5. Free consent:
Another essential of a valid contract is the consent of parties, which should be free. Under Sec. 13, "Two or more parties are said to consent, when they agree upon the same thing in the same sense." Under Sec. 14, the consent is said to be free, when it is not induced by any
8
of the following:- (i) coercion, (i) misrepresentation, () fraud, (iv) undue influence, or (v) mistake.
6. Lawful consideration:
Consideration is known as 'something in return'. It is also essential for the validity of a contract. A promise to do something or to give something without anything in return would not be enforceable at law and, therefore, would not be valid. Consideration need not be in cash or in kind. A contract without consideration is a wagering contract' or "betting'. Besides, the consideration must also be lawful.
7. Lawful objects:
According to Sec. 10, an agreement may become a valid-contract only, if it is for a lawful consideration and lawful object. According to Sec. 23, the following considerations and objects are not lawful:-
(i) If it is forbidden by law;
(ii) If it is against the provisions of any other law;
(ii) If it is fraudulent;
(iv) If it damages somebody's person or property; or
(v) If it is in the opinion of court, immoral or against the public policy. Thus, any agreement, if it is illegal, immoral, or against the public policy, cannot become a valid contract.
8. Agreement not expressly declared void:
An agreement to become a contract should not be an agreement which has been expressly declared void by any law in the country, as it would not be enforceable at law.
9. Certainty and possibility of performance:
Agreements to form valid contracts must be certain, possible and they should not be uncertain, vague or impossible. An agreement to do something impossible is void under Sec. 56.
10. Legal formalities:
The agreement may be oral or in writing. When the agreement is in writing it must comply with all legal formalities as to attestation, registration. If the agreement does not comply with the necessary legal formalities, it cannot be enforced by law. In view of the above facts, the following conclusions can easily be made.
i. The settlement transaction have not happened on any of the official platform, i.e. on a recognized
CommodityStockExchange/Broker/Association.
ii. This transaction was non delivery based.
9
iii. No broker was involved at any of the stage of the transaction.
iv. The two parties were commercially well acquainted with each other.
v. No advance whatsoever or any type of payment at the time of contract was given.
vi. No payment was ever made at the conclusion of the contract and thereafter.
vii. The counter party has also not paid any tax on the profit from this contract settlement.
viii. The contracts entered by STPL and AMPL are itself void.
ix. The STPL had huge profit from sale of shares and these bogus transactions were manipulated and entered purely to evade the taxes by neutralising them. In this way, the complete 'cycle' of modus operandi is established.
In view of the above facts and circumstances, it is proved beyond doubt that the contracts entered by VMEPL are void and purely non- genuine and bogus and hence the loss of Rs. 26,88,38,500/- on account of loss from coriander contract settlement is also non-genuine and not allowable to VMEPL.
7. Even if the above mentioned transaction of contract settlement loss is considered as genuine strictly for the sake of academic discussion, yet the explanation offered by the assessee is not tenable. The assessee has entered into a transaction which is non delivery based and not even carried out at any of the recognized stock exchange and no Securities Transaction Tax (STT) or Commodity Transaction Tax was paid. Accordingly, the said transaction is to be characterised as 'speculative transaction within the meaning of 43(5) of the Act. The assessee was show caused as to why the loss claimed by it should not be disallowed as business loss as the same was a loss from speculation business. The reply of the assessee is already reproduced in earlier para and the same is found to be devoid of any merit.Section 43(5) of the Act reads as under:-
43(5) speculative transaction" means a transaction in which a contract for the purchase or sale of any commodity, including stocks and shares, is periodically or ultimately settled otherwise than by the actual delivery or transfer of the commodity or scrips:
Provided that for the purposes of this clause-
(a) a contract in respect of raw materials or merchandise entered into by a person in the course of his manufacturing or merchanting business to guard against loss through future price fluctuations in respect of his contracts for actual delivery of goods manufactured by him or merchandise sold by him; or
(b) a contract in respect of stocks and shares entered into by a dealer or investor therein to guard against loss in his holdings of stocks and shares through price fluctuations; or
(c) a contract entered into by a member of a forward market or a stock exchange in
10
the course of any transaction in the nature of jobbing or arbitrage to guard against loss which may arise in the ordinary course of his business as such member;
(d) an eligible transaction in respect of trading in derivatives referred to in clause 35 (ac) of section 2 36 of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956 (42 of 1956) carried out in a recognized stock exchange,
(e) an eligible transaction in respect of trading in commodity derivatives carried out in a recognized association (which is chargeable to commodities transaction tax under chapter VII of the Finance Act, 2013 (17 of 2013)
shall not be deemed to be a speculative transaction."
In view of the aforesaid it is clear that the transaction under consideration is a speculative transaction. Accordingly, the loss arising from such speculative transaction is a speculative loss.
None of the exceptions enumerated from subsection (a) to (e) of section 43(5) of the Act is applicable in the case of VMEPL. This is demonstrated as under:-
(a) a contract in respect of raw materials or merchandise entered into by a person in the course of his manufacturing or merchanting business to guard against loss through future price fluctuations in respect of his contracts for actual delivery of goods manufactured by him or merchandise sold by him; or
The VMEPL has not engaged in any of the manufacturing or merchanting business and there was no actual delivery of goods manufactured or merchandise by VMEPL. There was no raw material possessed with VMEPL.
(b) a contract in respect of stocks and shares entered into by a dealer or investor therein to guard against loss in his holdings of stocks and shares through price fluctuations; or
The VMEPL was not having the stock of 12300 MT at the time of entering into contract of sale with AMPL.
Also, there is nothing on the record which shows that the VMEPL entered into the contract to guard against loss in his holdings and there was no 'holding' itself in actual.
(c) a contract entered into by a member of a forward market or a stock exchange in the course of any transaction in the nature of jobbing or arbitrage to guard against loss which may arise in the ordinary course of his business as such member; The VMEPL is neither a member of a forward market nor of a Stock Exchange. The above mentioned transaction is neither in the nature of jobbing nor an arbitrage and never as a guard against loss which may arise in the ordinary course of its business.
(d) an eligible transaction in respect of trading in derivatives referred to in clause 35 (ac)] of section 2 36 of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956 (42 of 1956) carried out in a recognized stock exchange;
11
The contract settlement transaction was not an eligible transaction as it has not been carried out in a recognized stock exchange.
(e) an eligible transaction in respect of trading in commodity derivatives carried out in a recognized association (which is chargeable to commodities transaction tax under chapter VII of the Finance Act, 2013(17 of 2013)
The contract settlement transaction was not an eligible transaction as it has not been carried out in a recognized stock exchange and not even carried out in a recognized association as there is no third party involved at any of the stage of the transaction. In light of the discussion as made as foregoing, the loss of Rs. 26,88,38,500/- claimed by VMEPL on account of loss shares/commodities in its profit and loss account within the ambit of loss from speculation business within the meaning of section 43(5) of the Act.
5.1 As per section 73(1) of the Act:-
"any loss, computed in respect of a speculation business carried on by the assessee, shall not be set off except against profits and gains, if any, of another speculation business.
Accordingly, the loss of Rs. 26,88,98,500/- is a loss in speculation business and can only be set off against the profit in speculation business.
In view of the above facts, Rs. 26,88,98,500/- is treated firstly as a sham and a non- genuine loss and, added back to the total income of the assessee. Without prejudice to the above and in the alternate, the aforesaid loss is also liable to be treated as a speculative loss within the meaning of section 43(5) of the Act."
5. It may be stated here that the ld.CIT(A) while deciding the appeal,has taken note of the contents of the assessment order on pages 3 to 12 and has also duly considered the submissions of the aseesseein the appellate order.Apart from endorsing the findings of the AO,theld.CIT(A) has highlighted following features of the case in support of his findings that the whole transaction was not genuine:
12
1. Numbers given in contract note illogical and not in sequence.Assessee failed to produce earlier contracts bearing numbers before the number given to aforesaid contract.
2. Contract settlement transaction neither carried out at any of the recognized Commodity Stock Exchange nor any broker was involved in the transactions
3. Documents purporting to be contracts were not stamped nor registered with government agency,thus not enforceable in any court of law.
4. Transactions with known parties with existing business relations supporting the probability of manipulation and adjustment in mutual beneficial in the matters of tax evasion.
5. Absence of any monetary transaction during the whole process as no advance given neither any payment made for settlement of the contract value.The transaction completed at the fag end of the financial year through journal entries.
6. Assesee in the business of shares with substantial profit during the year and the impugned transactions only to reduce the tax liability.
7. Trading in coriander is not its regular business.Asessee failed to show any previous transaction of forward contract in coriander.
8. Claim that assessee failed to deliver goods for the reasons that process had raised sharply.But could not explain why it failed to deliver the goods even partially when the prices were increasing.
9. Also an another group concern i.e Shreyans Credit and Capital Ltd:SCCPL) had also entered into transactions with ArbesqueMerchantileP.Ltd one of the parties with whom the assessee also entered into contract with which was also premeditatae(para 6.3.14)
5.1 The ld.CIT(A) has also placed reliance on various judicial decisions of High Courts and Apex court in support of his conclusion that the wholeexercise undertaken was simply smokescreen to carry out bogus loss transactions in the garb of sale of commodity which was not real and the assessee failed to dispel all the queries of the AO to prove otherwise.
13
5.2In so far as the alternative plea of the assessee that the loss arising due to settlement of contract was wrongly treated as loss from speculation business u/s 43(5) by the AO is concerned,in paras 7.1 to 7.3,the contents of the assessment order as also the submissions made by the assessee have been reproduced and in the concluding para 7.3,the ld.CIT(A) observed that loss already being treated as non genuine the ground was academic and did not call for adjudication.However,he endorsed the findings of the AO that the transactions were liable to be treated as Speculation loss u/s 43(5) of the Act.
6. In the course of hearing before us,the ld.AR of the assessee has reiterated the same arguments as made before the authorities below.It was submitted that the impugned transactions were genuine and the loss arose on account of sharp increase in the prices of coriander.It is claimed that the assessee deals in agro commodities and to guard against loss due to future price fluctuations contracts are entered into.The contracts could be oral or in writing. It is also argued that the buyers have duly disclosed the profit in their respective returns of income and offered for taxation.It is argued that there is no bar that commodity transactions need to be done on platform of recognized commodity exchange only.In support of the genuineness of the contracts the assessee submitted contract notes,debit notes,ledger confirmations etc.It is pleaded that the action of the AO is based on
14
presumptions only.Per contra,theld.CIT(DR) supported findings and orders of the lower authortities.
7. On careful consideration of all the relevant facts of the case,the findings and the observations of the ld.AO as well as ld.CIT(A) and also the rival submissions,we find that the assessee has miserably failed to controvert their findings in any manner apart from harping on the same contentions mad before the revenue authorities.On the other hand,we find no infirmity in the assessment order also on the appellate order.From the detailed discussions emanating from the order, it is evident that the assessee in an orchestrated manner andin a bid to reduce its tax liability for share transactions indulged in this whole exercise of the claiming a non- existent loss from alleged transactions in commodity derivatives.The assessee has failed to rebut the findings and observations of the AO and CIT(A).Thegenuineness of the transactions has not been proved by the assessee in any manner.
7.1 From the facts narrated in the preceedingparas,it is quite apparent that the transactions resulting in such a huge loss are not transparent,entered into with known parties in a collusive manner with win- win situation for all of them.While the assessee has set off huge income from share transactions, other two parties have set off substantial business losses and disclosed negligible income in their respective returns of income
15
for the relevant yearfrom the profit claimed to have earned from the impugned transactions.The transactions were admittedly not done on any recognized commodity exchange platform through SEBI registered broker and therefore, not carried out electronically on screen based systems through member or an intermediary, screen-based registered under the bye- laws, bye rules and regulations of the recognized association for trading in commodity derivative in accordance with the provisions of the Forward Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1952 and the rules, regulations or bye laws made or directions issued under that Act on a recognized association and which is supported by a time stamped contract note issued by such member or intermediary to identity number allotted under the Act, every client indicating in the contract note, the unique client identity rules, regulations or bye-laws,unique trade number and permanent account number allotted under this Act.In the present case,the self-serving contract notes were manually made to suit the convenience of the respective purposes.
7.2 An inference about the genuineness of apparent Commodity Trade Loss transactions has to be drawn on the basis of the circumstances available on the record and having regard to the conduct of the assessee in making payment as well as other material on the record, an inference could reasonably be drawn that the Commodity Trade Loss transactions are non- genuine. It is held that after considering the surrounding circumstances and
16
applying the test of human probabilities it is rightly concluded that the appellant's Commodity Trade Loss transactions is not genuine. It cannot be said that the explanation offered by the appellant in respect of the said payment has been rejected unreasonably.
7.3 As observed by the co-ordinate Bench in the case of ITA 3607/Mum/2011 Assessment Year 2006-07 M/s. Sanika Agri Impex Pvt. Ltd,the primary-onus is on the assessee company to bring on record cogent material to substantiate that these transactions are genuine transactions and were actually entered into by the assessee company and are not merely accommodation entries, by bringing on record cogent evidences / documents such as sauda books, records maintained by various government and other statutory /authorities authorities which are regulating transactions in agricultural produce under various legislations and rules regulating the trade in agricultural commodities such as APMC, Forward Contract(Regulation) Act,1952, State Agricultural Boards, Agricultural Mandi's etc. and proof of payment of any fee,taxes etc to these bodies/authorities as mandated under law to substantiate that these transactions were genuinely entered into by the assessee at that point of time and the losses , if incurred were genuine losses . Further , the primary onus is on the assessee company to bring on record cogent material to substantiate that these transactions are hedging transactions to safeguard
17
against future losses in contracts based on actual delivery entered into by the assessee company on these commodities by bringing on record concrete materials by way of contracts in the agricultural commodities which the assessee company has to execute on actual delivery basis against which these hedging transactions were entered into to guard against losses to be covered by proviso (a) to Section 43(5) of the Act to be taken out of purview of being classified as speculative transaction.The assessee in the present case has not brought on record any such cogent evidence to buttress its claim of loss.
7.4 It may be stated here that the coordinate bench in the case of ITA No.1644/Mum/2020 M/S. Shreya Credit & Capital P. Ltd. vs Dcit, Central Circle7(2), Mumbai dated 31 March, 2023on almost identical facts and circumstances,upheld the decision of the authorities below and appeal of the assessee was dismissed.
7.5 The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of JuggilalKamlapat v. CIT [1969] 73 ITR 702 has held that the income-tax authorities are entitled to pierce the veil of corporate entity and look at the reality of the transaction and that in exceptional cases the Court can lift the veil of corporate entity and to pay regard to the economic realities behind the legal façade. Similarly, the Assessing Officer has power to disregard the corporate entity if it is used for tax evasion or to circumvent tax obligation or to perpetuate fraud.The Hon'ble Delhi High Court in PNB Finance Ltd. v. Shri Shital
18
Prasad Jain [1983] 54 Comp. Cas. 66 has held that the doctrine of piercing the corporate veil wherever necessary might be invoked by the Court in the interest of justice to prevent the corporate entity from being used as an instrument of fraud and the fundamental principle of corporate personality itself might be disregarded having regard to the exigencies of the situation and for the ends of justice. If the economic realities of a transaction between the appellant and others are arranged and the exigency of the circumstances surrounding it reveal that the transaction has been entered only to defraud the revenue causing injustice to it, the authorities should look behind the real purpose of the transaction and deal with the consequence of the transaction in a manner with which it should have been dealt with otherwise.
8. On careful appreciation of the facts surrounding the above transactions, we conclude that they were areneither hedging transaction nor speculative in terms of the section 43(5) of the Act. The circumstantial evidences brought on record by the AO on touchstone of preponderance of probabilities is sufficient to establish that these transactions are non- genuine.We are of the opinion that the assessee has failed to discharge the onus cast upon him by the statute. Besides, finding of fact given by the Revenue Authorities remained un-controverted that loss shown by the assessee pertained to these forward transactions against which no actual
19
delivery was made was not genuine. The alleged loss claimed by the assessee in these transactions in commodities were accounted for by way of journal entries only. We find that the commodities transactions were not carried out by the assessee throughout the year, thus this artificial loss generated therefrom was prompted with an intent to 'set off' the same against the profit earned by the assessee in share transactions.Accordingly, the orders of authorities below are upheld.
9. In the result, the appeal of the assessee is dismissed. Order pronounced in the open court on 10/02/2025. Sd/- Sd/-
SANDEEP GOSAIN PRABHASH SHANKAR
(ाियकसद /JUDICIAL MEMBER) (लेखाकारसद/ACCOUNTANT MEMBER) Place: मबंु ई/Mumbai
दनांक /Date 10.02.2025
Lubhna Shaikh / Steno
आदेेश की ितिलिप अ ेेिषत/Copy of the Order forwarded to :
1. अपीलाथ / The Appellant
2.
थ / The Respondent.
3. आयकर आयु / CIT
4. िवभागीय ितिनिध, आयकर अपीलीय अिधकरण DR, ITAT, Mumbai
5. गाड फाईल / Guard file.
20
स ािपत ित //True Copy//
आदेशानुसार/ BY ORDER, उप/सहायक पंजीकार (Dy./Asstt. Registrar) आयकर अपीलीय अिधकरण/ ITAT, Bench, Mumbai.
21