Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2025 DHC 2653-DB
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2025 DHC 2653-DB
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Case Summary: M/s Brijbihari Concast Pvt. Ltd. v. Directorate General of GST Intelligence & Anr. (High Court of Delhi)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, M/s Brijbihari Concast Pvt. Ltd. (through its Director Mr. Rajeev Agarwal), challenged an Order‑in‑Original no. 01/MEZU/2024 dated 28 March 2024, which affirmed a provisional attachment of the petitioner's bank account (Current Account No. 201002965063) by the Directorate General of Goods and Services Tax Intelligence (DGGI). The provisional attachment followed a search and seizure operation (Panchnama dated 13 December 2023) during which the DGGI recorded a prima facie mismatch between physical stock and the petitioner's records, leading the DGGI to form an opinion of GST evasion of Rs.15.09 crores and to provisionally attach the bank account by Form GST DRC‑22 dated 18 December 2023. The petitioner moved the High Court under Article 226 seeking relief from that attachment. At the hearing, the Court observed that more than 16 months had elapsed since the Panchnama and about one year since the impugned order, but no show cause notice had yet been issued (the Department stated an SCN was likely to be issued shortly, within a three‑year period available to it). The petition was heard afresh before the bench after an earlier order (dated 20 March 2025) could not be located by the Registry.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned Order‑in‑Original affirming provisional attachment of the petitioner's bank account (Form DRC‑22) should be set aside or modified pending adjudication of alleged GST evasion.
  2. If the attachment is to be modified, what security or minimum balance should be required in the petitioner's bank account to protect the revenue while allowing the petitioner to continue business operations.
  3. Whether any restraint should be placed on creation of third‑party interests in specified immovable property of the petitioner pending final adjudication.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The provisional attachment resulted from investigation based on an eye‑estimation (prima facie stock estimation) by DGGI officials rather than finalized adjudication.
  • No show cause notice (SCN) has been issued to date and no formal proceedings have been initiated yet.
  • The petitioner has paid substantial taxes in prior years (the impugned order itself records GST payments of Rs.116,57,07,492 and Income Tax of Rs.4,06,15,722 over the last three years), indicating compliance and the operation of a running business.
  • The attachment has caused and will continue to cause severe financial difficulty and risk to the petitioner's ongoing business; the bank account currently holds approximately Rs.2.75 crores.

Respondent's Arguments (DGGI)

  • The DGGI formed a prima facie opinion of GST evasion amounting to Rs.15.09 crores following the search and seizure and lodged provisional attachment to protect revenue interests.
  • The Department intends to issue a show cause notice shortly and retains statutory time (three years) to issue the SCN.
  • The amount alleged should be secured while cancellation or final adjudication proceeds.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded from the factual record produced during the search and seizure (Panchnama) and the impugned Order‑in‑Original. Key points of the Court's reasoning, as reflected in the record, are:

  1. The Panchnama indicates a surprise investigation and a prima facie mismatch between physical stock and the petitioner's registers; on that basis the DGGI formed an opinion of clandestine removal and evasion under Section 67 of the CGST Act (as reflected in the impugned order) and provisionally attached the petitioner's bank account by Form DRC‑22 dated 18.12.2023.
  2. Despite the impugned order and Panchnama, over 16 months have passed since the Panchnama and about one year has passed since the impugned order; however, no show cause notice has yet been issued, although the Department indicated it intends to issue one within its three‑year window.
  3. Even if the alleged evasion (Rs.15.09 crores as recorded in the impugned order) were taken at face value for present purposes, the entire amount is not immediately payable: the alleged evasion must be adjudicated in accordance with law and any final liability can only be determined after proper proceedings.
  4. Balancing the protection of revenue with the petitioner's right to continue business as a running concern, and noting the petitioner has paid substantial taxes and has ongoing business operations, the Court considered a limited security requirement appropriate rather than a complete bar on operating the account.
  5. The petitioner produced a Chartered Accountant certificate (dated 31 March 2025) detailing movable and immovable assets and showing aggregate net worth figures for three individuals associated with the company (Mr. Rajeev Agarwal, Mr. Sanjeev Agarwal and Ms. Swata Agarwal), totaling Rs.5,029.85 lacs (as taken on record by the Court).
  6. On the basis of the foregoing factual record, the Court concluded that securing 10% of the alleged amount at this stage would be sufficient to protect revenue interests while permitting the petitioner to continue its business pending adjudication.
  7. Accordingly, the Court ordered the petitioner's bank account to maintain a minimum credit balance of Rs.1.5 crores (10% of the approximate Rs.15 crore demand) and permitted operation of the account subject to that condition. The Court also directed that no third‑party interest be created in a specified residential property (No. 9, Bonjha G.T. Road, Ghaziabad) until the final Order‑in‑Original is passed in the matter.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The writ petition was disposed of subject to conditions. The Court directed that the petitioner's bank account (Current Account No. 201002965063 with IndusInd Bank, Vivek Vihar Branch) shall maintain a minimum credit balance of Rs.1.5 crores; subject to this condition being met, the petitioner is permitted to operate the bank account. Additionally, the Court restrained creation of any third‑party interest in the residential property located at No. 9, Bonjha G.T. Road, Ghaziabad, until the final Order‑in‑Original is passed. The petition and all pending applications were disposed of in these terms.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The DGGI's provisional attachment remains in place but is modified so that the petitioner may operate its bank account provided a minimum balance of Rs.1.5 crores is maintained; the specified property is protected from new third‑party interests during the adjudication period.
  • No broader precedential holding was articulated by the Court in the opinion; the order resolves the interim relief sought by the petitioner on the specific facts presented and records no new legal principle beyond the application of balancing revenue protection with permitting continued business operations pending adjudication.

    M/S BRIJBIHARI CONCAST PVT. LTD. (THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR SH. RAJEEV AGARWAL)  v. DIRECTORATE GENERAL OF GOODS AND SERVICES TAX INTELLIGENCE MEERURT ZONAL UNIT (THROUGH ITS ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR GENERAL) & ANR.

    $~82 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI Date of Decision: 15th April, 2025 + W.P.(C) 8433/2024, CM APPLs. 34828/2024 & 16421/2025

    M/S BRIJBIHARI CONCAST PVT. LTD. (THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR SH. RAJEEV AGARWAL) .....Petitioner Through: Mr. R.P. Singh, Mr. Rahul Ranjan, Mr. Anant Vijay & Mr. Nirmal Dixit,

    Advs.

    versus

    DIRECTORATE GENERAL OF GOODS AND SERVICES TAX

    INTELLIGENCE MEERURT ZONAL UNIT (THROUGH ITS

    ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR GENERAL) & ANR. .....Respondents Through: Mr. Atul Tripathi, SSC with Mr. Shubham Mishra, Adv.

    CORAM:

    JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH

    JUSTICE RAJNEESH KUMAR GUPTA

    Prathiba M. Singh, J. (Oral)

    1. This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.

    2 The present petition has been filed by the Petitioner- M/s Brijbihari Concast Pvt. Ltd through its Director Mr. Rajeev Agarwal under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, inter alia, seeking issuance of an appropriate writ assailing the Order-in-Original bearing no. 01/MEZU/2024 dated 28th March 2024 (hereinafter 'impugned order') by which the provisional attachment of the bank account bearing no. 201002965063 of the Petitioner has been affirmed.

    3. Mr. Atul Tripathi, Ld. Sr. Standing Counsel for the Respondents submits that pursuant to the order dated 27thFebruary, 2025, the records of the Respondents were produced on 20th March 2025. After perusing the records, the Court had directed the ld. Counsel for the Petitioner to seek

    1

    instructions as to the manner in which the Petitioner would secure the sum of Rs.15 crores, which is the amount due to which the bank account stands provisionally attached.

    4. Ld. Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the query of the Court on the said date i.e. 20th March 2025 was as to what are the remaining assets of the Petitioner in order to secure the demand, if any, raised in future.

    5. Ld. Counsels for the parties have in their oral submissions relied upon directions which were stated to have been issued by a Co-ordinate bench of this Court on 20thMarch, 2025. The Registry has reported that the order dated 20thMarch 2025 is not available as per the information given by the PS to the Hon'ble Judge presiding over the previous Bench. In view of the fact that the order dated 20thMarch, 2025 is not available, the matter has been heard afresh.

    6. The Petitioner is in the business of manufacturing mild steel products such as TMT bars, Billets, Miss Roll End Cutting, Mill Scale and Slage. The Petitioner is also engaged in the business of trading of goods such as Scrap, Sponge, etc. The Petitioner has a Goods and Service Tax (hereinafter, 'GST') registration bearing no. 05AACCB5197NIZA through which it is conducting its business.

    7. An investigation was conducted at the Petitioner's premises, by the Respondent - Directorate General of Goods and Services Tax Intelligence (hereinafter, 'DGGI'). In the said investigation, the allegation of the DGGI was that its officials took note of the stock of raw material which was found in heaps in the factory and the same was tallied with the various registers maintained by the Company.

    8. According to the DGGI, some of the stock was found in excess and the same was unaccounted for in the books. The DGGI was therefore of the

    2

    opinion that the same required a detailed probe and that the goods were liable for confiscation. The goods were then handed over to Mr. Sanjeev Aggarwal of the Petitioner company for safe custody.

    9. After conducting the search and seizure, the Panchnama was drawn on 13thDecember, 2023. Subsequent to the drawing of the Panchnama, a letter dated 18th December 2023 was issued in the form of 'Form GST DRC-22' by the DGGI provisionally attaching the bank account of the Petitioner. Further, it was observed in the said letter that proceedings would be liable to be initiated against the Petitioner under Section 67 of the Central Goods and Services Tax, 2017 (hereinafter, 'CGST Act').

    10. The DGGI then, passed the impugned order dated 28thMarch 2024, on the basis that there has been an evasion of GST amounting to Rs.15.09 crores. Paragraph 8 of the said order reads as under:

    "8. The basis, on which, such an opinion (provisional attachment of bank account) is formed have been duly recorded. Further.

    (1) The proceedings against M/s BCPL were initiated by way of search under Authorisation for Search which comes under Chapter XIV /Section 67 of the CGST Act, 2017?.

    (ii) M/s BCPL have evaded GST amounting to Rs. 15.09 Cr by clandestine removal of goods and the same was accepted by Shri Sanjeev Agarwal. Director of M/s BCPL in his voluntary statement dated 14.12.2023. He also showed his inability to deposit the same. Therefore. in order to protect the interest of revenue, it was necessary to provisionally attach the bank account of M/s BCPL.

    (iii) The bank account was provisionally attached by order (Form DRC ·22) dated 18.12.2023 in writing and the same was communicated to M/s BCPL.

    (iv) The manner as prescribed under Section 83 of the CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule 159(1) of the CGST

    3

    Rules, 2017 was duly followed.

    (v) M / s BCPL is a taxable person having GSTIN - 05AACCB5197N1ZA."

    11. However, the said order itself acknowledges in paragraph (E) that the stand of the Petitioner is that a substantial amount of GST has been paid by the Petitioner and Income tax has also been paid in the previous years. Paragraphs (E) and (F) of the said order is extracted below:

    "E. That M/s Brijbihari Concast Private Limited has paid huge amount towards taxes of Goods and Service Tax during the last three years without any delay and default.

    The company has paid Rs.1,16,57,07,492/- as a GST and Income Tax Rs.40615722/- during the last three years.

    F. The said company is running strictly in compliance of law and with required license and permissions. The company is providing substantial employment and various persons earn their livelihood from the business generated by the company it is stated that around 150 persons are directly and indirectly working with the companies. The applicant company is paying huge amount towards consumption of electricity."

    12. On the basis of the said order, the bank account of the Petitioner was provisionally attached by the DGGI.

    13. Ld. Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the investigation and the assessment of evasion of tax was done merely on the basis of an eye- estimation by the officials of the DGGI. Further, till date, no show cause notice has been issued against the Petitioner. Moreover, no proceedings have been initiated till date.

    14. Ld. Counsel for the Petitioner further submits that the DGGI cannot dispute that a substantial amount of more than Rs.100 crores as GST and

    4

    Rs.4.06 crores as Income tax has been paid by the Petitioner in the last three financial years. He further submits that due to the attachment of the bank account, the Petitioner is made to undergo enormous financial difficulties and the business of the Petitioner is likely to be jeopardised. The bank account of the Petitioner presently is stated to be having a balance of approximately Rs.2.75 crores.

    15. Mr. Tripathi, ld. Counsel for the Respondent on the other hand submits that the DGGI is in the process of issuing show cause notice shortly. Ld. Counsel further submits that the amount ought to be secured by the Court.

    16. Heard. A perusal of the Panchnama would show that the same was a surprise investigation which was conducted. On the basis of certain records produced by the Petitioner's officials, a prima facie estimation has been made that there is a mis-match. The amount of stock was higher than what was declared in terms of the records of the Petitioner company.

    17. It is to be noted that a period of more than 16 months has lapsed since the issuance of the Panchnama and one year has elapsed since the passing of the impugned order dated 28th March 2024. As on date, no show cause notice has been issued, though the same, as per the Department, is likely to be issued shortly. Mr. Tripathi submits that the Department has a time period of three years to issue the SCN.

    18. As per the impugned order, the alleged evasion of GST is to the amount of Rs.15.09 crores. Even if this amount is taken into consideration, it cannot be said that the entire amount would be payable immediately. The issue relating to evasion has to be adjudicated in accordance with law. Until then, the Petitioner's business cannot be prejudiced by complete attachment of bank accounts. The Petitioner is a running concern and as per the accounts which

    5

    have been placed on record, it is conducting business and paying substantial amounts of taxes.

    19. A Chartered Accountant's certificate dated 31stMarch 2025 has been placed on record giving the details of the movable and immovable assets of Mr. Rajeev Aggarwal who is the Director of the Petitioner-Company. As per the Chartered Accountant's certificate, the net worth of the moveable and immoveable assets of Mr. Rajeev Agarwal, Mr. Sanjeev Agarwal and Ms. Swata Agarwal is as under:

    Mr. Rajeev Agarwal Rs.2244.90 lacs
    Mr. Sanjeev Agarwal Rs.2264.45 lacs
    Ms. Swata Agarwal Rs.520.50 lacs
    TOTAL 5029.85 lacs

    20. The details of the assets have also been given in the said certificate. The said Chartered Accountant's certificate along with the additional documents is taken on record.

    21. Under such circumstances, it would be sufficient at this stage, if 10% of the amount can be secured by way of minimum balance in the bank account of the Petitioner.

    22. Accordingly, let the Petitioner's bank account bearing no.201002965063 maintain a minimum credit balance of Rs.1.5 crores.

    23. Subject to the said condition being fulfilled, the Petitioner is free to operate its bank account. The details of the said account are as under:

    ● Current account No. 201002965063

    ● Account Holder Name- M/s Brijbihari Concast Pvt. Ltd.

    ● Branch - IndusInd Bank Limited, Vivek Vihar Branch, Delhi

    6

    24. In addition, it is directed that in the residential property bearing no.9, Bonjha G.T. Road, Ghaziabad, no third party interest shall be created till the Final Order-in-Original is passed in the present case.

    25. Petition is disposed of in these terms. All pending applications, if any, are also disposed of.

    PRATHIBA M. SINGH

    JUDGE

    RAJNEESH KUMAR GUPTA

    JUDGE

    APRIL 15, 2025

    Rahul/ck

    7

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/S BRIJBIHARI CONCA... v. DIRECTORATE GENERAL ...
    (Apr 15, 2025)