Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is Manish Kumar, a Class IV employee (Peon), who has been working as a daily-wager in the service of Magadh University since his appointment in January 2009. The petitioner seeks, inter alia, an order regularizing his service and consequential reliefs because he alleges uninterrupted service since 2009, that many persons appointed around the same time were regularized in 2018, and that no complaints exist against him. The petitioner filed a detailed representation before the Vice-Chancellor of Magadh University for regularization on 25.02.2025; no action had been taken on that representation before the hearing.

The writ petition (Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.4893 of 2025) came up for oral hearing before Hon'ble Mr. Justice Purnendu Singh on 25.03.2025. Counsel for the petitioner and for the university and State were present. The court disposed of the writ petition by directing the Vice-Chancellor to verify whether the petitioner was engaged/appointed against a sanctioned vacant post and to consider the petitioner's representation in light of recent Supreme Court authority cited in the judgment. The court ordered no costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner, who has been working as a daily-wager Peon since January 2009 and performing perennial duties, is entitled to regularization of his service.
  2. Whether the Vice-Chancellor should verify if the petitioner was engaged/appointed on a sanctioned vacant post and, if so, take steps to consider the petitioner's representation in light of recent Supreme Court rulings regarding regularization of long-term temporary/irregular employees.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jaggo v. Union of India & Ors. [SLP (C) No. 5580 of 2024] Relied upon by the High Court; it contains observations (reproduced in the judgment) about not penalizing long-serving employees and the need for fair and humane resolutions where service has been prolonged and duties are perennial. The Jaggo judgment relied on the Vinod Kumar decision and reproduced key paragraphs (20–27) addressing misuse of temporary labels and the need for regularization in appropriate cases. The court directed the Vice-Chancellor to consider the petitioner's representation in light of the law laid down in Jaggo.
Vinod Kumar and Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors., (2024) 1 S.C.R. 1230 Held that procedural formalities cannot be used to deny regularization of service to an employee whose appointment was termed "temporary" but who performed the same duties as a regular employee over a considerable period; distinguished between "irregular" and "illegal" appointments; emphasized fairness where continuous, long-term service exists. The court reproduced and relied on the observations from Vinod Kumar (via Jaggo) as a guiding principle and instructed the university to consider the representation in light of those principles.
Shripal & Anr. v. Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad (Civil Appeal Nos. 8158-8179 of 2024) Reiterated that Uma Devi distinguishes between "illegal" and "irregular" appointments; Uma Devi cannot be used as a shield to justify exploitative engagements persisting for years without legitimate recruitment; courts may draw adverse inference if employer fails to furnish records; long continuous service disfavors perpetual daily-wage engagement. The court cited Shripal and directed that the petitioner's representation be considered in the context of the principles reiterated in Shripal.
Union of India rep. by Government of Puducherry & Anr. v. K. Velajagan & Ors. [SLP(c) No. 2868 of 2018] Contains observations (quoted in the opinion) indicating that employees should not suffer because of internal disputes and that Uma Devi cannot be used to justify long-standing exploitative engagements; the decision was cited for the proposition that such shields are impermissible. The court referred to this authority for the proposition that Uma Devi cannot be used as a shield and required consideration of the representation in light of that view.
State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi (commonly cited as "Uma Devi") Referenced in the judgment as a precedent distinguishing "illegal" appointments from "irregular" ones; the cited subsequent authorities stress that Uma Devi was not intended to penalize long-serving employees whose appointments are irregular rather than illegal. The court used the distinction drawn in Uma Devi (as explained by later Supreme Court decisions) as part of the legal framework for directing reconsideration of the petitioner's representation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court heard counsel and noted the petitioner's representation dated 25.02.2025 which had not been acted upon. Given the relief sought (regularization and consequential reliefs) and the petitioner's pleaded continuous service since January 2009, the court considered recent Supreme Court authorities addressing regularization of long-serving temporary/contractual employees.

The court reproduced relevant observations from Jaggo (which in turn relied on Vinod Kumar) emphasizing:

  • Uma Devi should not be used to penalize employees who have rendered long years of continuous service performing necessary, perennial functions.
  • Procedural formalities cannot be used to perpetually deny substantive rights that have accrued through continuous service; where appointments are "irregular" rather than "illegal", fairness may require regularization.
  • The pervasive misuse of temporary employment labels and other exploitative practices was highlighted, including lack of job security, denial of benefits, and the use of outsourcing as a shield against regular employment.
  • International and policy considerations (reference in the reproduced text to ILO principles) were mentioned in the reproduced paragraphs as supporting fair employment practices in public institutions.

The court also relied on the rulings in Shripal and a decision involving Puducherry v. K. Velajagan to reiterate that Uma Devi cannot be invoked to justify exploitative, indefinite temporary engagements where the employer has not undertaken legitimate recruitment and where long continuous service exists.

On this basis, rather than deciding the merits of regularization on the record before it, the court directed an administrative step: the Vice-Chancellor of Magadh University was to verify whether the petitioner was engaged/appointed against a sanctioned vacant post and, thereafter, take necessary steps to consider the petitioner's representation in the light of the cited Supreme Court authorities.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is disposed of with a direction to the Vice-Chancellor of Magadh University to verify whether the petitioner was engaged/appointed on a sanctioned vacant post and to take necessary steps to consider the petitioner's representation in light of the recent Supreme Court judgments cited in the opinion. There shall be no order as to costs.

Implications: The direct effect of the decision is an administrative direction to Magadh University's Vice-Chancellor to verify the factual question of whether the petitioner was appointed against a sanctioned vacancy and to reconsider the petitioner's representation applying the principles from the Supreme Court authorities (Jaggo, Vinod Kumar, Shripal, Puducherry v. K. Velajagan and the distinctions drawn from Uma Devi). The opinion does not state or purport to create any new precedent; it applies existing Supreme Court decisions to the petitioner's circumstances and instructs the university to act accordingly.


Source: Oral Judgment dated 25-03-2025, High Court of Judicature at Patna, Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.4893 of 2025 (Manish Kumar v. State of Bihar & Ors.). The summary is limited to and based exclusively on the information contained in that opinion.

    Manish Kumar v. The State of Bihar

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA

    Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.4893 of 2025

    ====================================================== Manish Kumar S/o- Arjun Yadav, Resident of Village- Baheri, Kachauri, Gaya, P.S.- Sherghati, District- Gaya.

    ... ... Petitioner/s

    Versus

    1. The State of Bihar through the Additional Chief Secretary, Department of Education, Government of Bihar, New Secretariat, Patna.

    2. The Additional Chief Secretary, Department of Education, Government of Bihar, New Secretariat, Patna.

    3. The Director, Higher Education, Department of Education, Government of Bihar, New Secretariat, Patna.

    4. The Magadh University, Magadh University, Bodh Gaya.

    5. The Vice Chancellor, Magadh University, Bodh Gaya.

    6. The Registrar, Magadh University, Bodh Gaya.

    7. The Finance Officer, Magadh University, Bodh Gaya. ... ... Respondent/s

    ======================================================

    Appearance :

    For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Ritesh Kumar, Advocate For the MU : Mr.Siddhartha Prasad, Advocate For the Respondent/s : Mr.Sheo Shankar Prasad, Advocate ======================================================

    CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PURNENDU SINGH

    ORAL JUDGMENT

    Date : 25-03-2025

    Heard Mr. Ritesh Kumar, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner; Mr. Siddhartha Prasad, learned counsel for the Magadh University and Mr. Sheo Shankar Prasad, learned counsel for SC 8 for the State.

    2. The petitioner in paragraph no. 1 of the present writ petition has sought inter alia following relief(s), which is reproduced hereinafter:

    "(I) For commanding the Respondents to Regularize the services of the petitioner on his post i.e. Class IV post of Peon, since the petitioner is uninterruptedly working in the services of the Magadh University from the date of his appointment i.e. January, 2009 and is being paid the wages as Daily Wager, and person appointed in 2009 like the petitioner, have been regularized and he is performing the

    1

    2/7

    duties which are perennial in nature and is indispensable.

    (II) For commanding the respondents to grant consequential reliefs to the petitioner after his regularization, since the petitioner is working as Daily Wager in the services of Magadh University for 16 long years and no complaint whatsoever has been made against the petitioner from any authority, till date and persons appointed on daily wages in 2009 i.e. almost from the same time when the petitioner started discharging his duties, have already been regularized in the services of the University in 2018, but the petitioner has been left out for the reasons best known to the respondent authorities.

    (III) For grant of any other relief/reliefs to which the petitioner may be found entitled for."

    3. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner submitted that the petitioner has filed detailed representation before the Vice-Chancellor of the Magadh University for regularization of his service on 25.02.2025, however, no action has been taken till date on the said representation.

    4. Considering the relief sought for in the present writ petition, as well as, submission made on behalf of the petitioner, I find it proper to direct the Vice-Chancellor of the Magadh University to verify, as to whether, the petitioner was engaged/appointed on the sanctioned vacant post and, thereafter, take necessary steps and consider the representation of the petitioner in light of the recent law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Jaggo Vs. Union of India & Ors. [SLP (C) No. 5580 of 2024], wherein the Apex Court relying on

    3/7

    its judgment passed in Vinod Kumar and Ors. Etc. Vs. Union of India & Ors., reported in (2024) 1 S.C.R. 1230 has made following observations in Paragraph Nos. 20, 21, 22, 23, 25 and 27, which are reproduced hereinafter:

    "20. It is well established that the decision in Uma Devi (supra) does not intend to penalize employees who have rendered long years of service fulfilling ongoing and necessary functions of the State or its instrumentalities. The said judgment sought to prevent backdoor entries and illegal appointments that circumvent constitutional requirements. However, where appointments were not illegal but possibly

    "irregular," and where employees had served continuously against the backdrop of sanctioned functions for a considerable period, the need for a fair and humane resolution becomes paramount. Prolonged, continuous, and unblemished service performing tasks inherently required on a regular basis can, over the time, transform what was initially ad-hoc or temporary into a scenario demanding fair regularization. In a recent judgement of this Court in Vinod Kumar and Ors. Etc. Vs. Union of India & Ors.[2024] 1 S.C.R. 1230, it was held that held that procedural formalities cannot be used to deny regularization of service to an employee whose appointment was termed "temporary" but has performed the same duties as performed by the regular employee over a considerable period in the capacity of the regular employee. The relevant paras of this judgment have been reproduced below:

    "6. The application of the judgment in Uma Devi (supra) by the High Court does not fit squarely with the facts at hand, given the specific circumstances under which the appellants were employed and have continued their service. The reliance on procedural formalities at the outset cannot be used to perpetually deny substantive rights that have accrued over a considerable period through continuous service. Their promotion was based on a specific notification for vacancies and a subsequent circular, followed by a selection process involving written tests and interviews, which distinguishes their case from the appointments through back door entry as discussed in the case of Uma Devi (supra).

    7. The judgement in the case Uma Devi (supra) also distinguished between "irregular" and "illegal" appointments underscoring the importance of considering certain appointments even if were not made strictly in accordance with the prescribed Rules and Procedure, cannot be said to have been made illegally if they had followed the procedures of regular

    4/7

    appointments such as conduct of written examinations or interviews as in the present case…"

    21. The High Court placed undue emphasis on the initial label of the appellants' engagements and the outsourcing decision taken after their dismissal. Courts must look beyond the surface labels and consider the realities of employment:

    continuous, long-term service, indispensable duties, and absence of any mala fide or illegalities in their appointments. In that light, refusing regularization simply because their original terms did not explicitly state so, or because an outsourcing policy was belatedly introduced, would be contrary to principles of fairness and equity.

    22. The pervasive misuse of temporary employment contracts, as exemplified in this case, reflects a broader systemic issue that adversely affects workers' rights and job security. In the private sector, the rise of the gig economy has led to an increase in precarious employment arrangements, often characterized by lack of benefits, job security, and fair treatment. Such practices have been criticized for exploiting workers and undermining labour standards. Government institutions, entrusted with upholding the principles of fairness and justice, bear an even greater responsibility to avoid such exploitative employment practices. When public sector entities engage in misuse of temporary contracts, it not only mirrors the detrimental trends observed in the gig economy but also sets a concerning precedent that can erode public trust in governmental operations.

    23. The International Labour Organization (ILO), of which India is a founding member, has consistently advocated for employment stability and the fair treatment of workers. The ILO's Multinational Enterprises Declaration encourages companies to provide stable employment and to observe obligations concerning employment stability and social security. It emphasizes that enterprises should assume a leading role in promoting employment security, particularly in contexts where job discontinuation could exacerbate long-term unemployment.

    25. It is a disconcerting reality that temporary employees, particularly in government institutions, often face multifaceted forms of exploitation. While the foundational purpose of temporary contracts may have been to address short-term or seasonal needs, they have increasingly become a mechanism to evade long-term obligations owed to employees. These practices manifest in several ways:

    • Misuse of "Temporary" Labels: Employees engaged for work that is essential, recurring, and integral to the functioning of an institution are often labeled as "temporary" or "contractual, even when their roles mirror those of regular

    5/7

    employees. Such misclassification deprives workers of the dignity, security, and benefits that regular employees are entitled to, despite performing identical tasks.

    • Arbitrary Termination: Temporary employees are frequently dismissed without cause or notice, as seen in the present case. This practice undermines the principles of natural justice and subjects workers to a state of constant insecurity, regardless of the quality or duration of their service.

    • Lack of Career Progression: Temporary employees often find themselves excluded from opportunities for skill development, promotions, or incremental pay raises. They remain stagnant in their roles, creating a systemic disparity between them and their regular counterparts, despite their contributions being equally significant.

    • Using Outsourcing as a Shield: Institutions increasingly resort to outsourcing roles performed by temporary employees, effectively replacing one set of exploited workers with another. This practice not only perpetuates exploitation but also demonstrates a deliberate effort to bypass the obligation to offer regular employment.

    • Denial of Basic Rights and Benefits: Temporary employees are often denied fundamental benefits such as pension, provident fund, health insurance, and paid leave, even when their tenure spans decades. This lack of social security subjects them and their families to undue hardship, especially in cases of illness, retirement, or unforeseen circumstances.

    27. In light of these considerations, in our opinion, it is imperative for government departments to lead by example in providing fair and stable employment. Engaging workers on a temporary basis for extended periods, especially when their roles are integral to the organization's functioning, not only contravenes international labour standards but also exposes the organization to legal challenges and undermines employee morale. By ensuring fair employment practices, government institutions can reduce the burden of unnecessary litigation, promote job security, and uphold the principles of justice and fairness that they are meant to embody. This approach aligns with international standards and sets a positive precedent for the private sector to follow, thereby contributing to the overall betterment of labour practices in the country."

    5. Further the Hon'ble Supreme Court has recently reiterated the same in the case of Shripal & Anr. vs. Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad (Civil Appeal Nos. 8158-8179 of 2024),

    6/7

    wherein, in paragraphs no. 14 and 15, the Apex Court has held as follows:

    "14. The Respondent Employer places reliance on Umadevi (supra) to contend that daily-wage or temporary employees cannot claim permanent absorption in the absence of statutory rules providing such absorption. However, as frequently reiterated, Uma Devi itself distinguishes between appointments that are "illegal" and those that are "irregular," the latter being eligible for regularization if they meet certain conditions. More importantly,Uma Devi cannot serve as a shield to justify exploitative engagements persisting for years without the Employer undertaking legitimate recruitment. Given the record which shows no true contractor-based arrangement and a consistent need for permanent horticultural staff the alleged asserted ban on fresh recruitment, though real, cannot justify indefinite daily-wage status or continued unfair practices.

    15. It is manifest that the Appellant Workmen continuously rendered their services over several years, sometimes spanning more than a decade. Even if certain muster rolls were not produced in full, the Employer's failure to furnish such records —despite directions to do so—allows an adverse inference under well-established labour jurisprudence. Indian labour law strongly disfavors perpetual daily-wage or contractual engagements in circumstances where the work is permanent in nature. Morally and legally, workers who fulfil ongoing municipal requirements year after year cannot be dismissed summarily as dispensable, particularly in the absence of a genuine contractor agreement. At this juncture, it would be appropriate to recall the broader critique of indefinite"temporary" employment practices as done by a recent judgement of this court in Jaggo v. Union of India."

    6. Further the Apex Court has recently reiterated the same in the case of Union of India Rep by Government of Puducherry & Anr. Vs. K Velajagan & Ors. [Petition for Special Leave to Appeal (c) No.2868 of 2018], wherein, in paragraph no.9 has observed as follows:

    "Be that as it may, neither the said 15 incumbent lecturers nor the respondents should suffer because of the internal squabble between the petitioners and the UPSC. The decision in State of Karnataka V.

    7/7

    Uma Devi (3), as held in a recent decision of this Court in Shripal V. Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad, cannot be used as a shield to justify exploitative engagements persisting for years without the employer undertaking legitimate recruitment process to deny relief of regularization."

    7. With the above observation/direction, the present writ petition stands disposed of.

    8. There shall be no order as to cost.

    (Purnendu Singh, J)

    chn/-

    AFR/NAFR
    CAV DATE NA
    Uploading Date 25.03.2025
    Transmission Date NA

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Manish Kumar v. The State of Bihar
    (Mar 25, 2025)