ORAL JUDGMENT
1. Heard Mr.Krunal Pandya, learned advocate appearing for the petitioners and Ms.Pooja Ashar, learned A.G.P. appearing for the respondents.
2. By way of the present petition, the petitioners, invoking Article 226 of the Constitution of India, have prayed for the following reliefs:-
Page 1 of 19
"(A) This Honourable Court may be pleased to admit and allow this petition.
(B) This Honourable Court may be pleased to issue a writ of mandamus or any appropriate writ, commanding or directing the respondent authorities to grant the Driver grade pay Rs.4000-6000 for 5thpay scale, and Rs.5200-20200, for 6thpays scale to the petitioners
(C) This Honourable Court may be pleased direct respondent to absorb in the post of Driver and considered at par with other class-IV promoted employees.
(D) This Honourable Court may be pleased to issue a writ of mandamus or any appropriate writ, commanding or directing the respondent authorities to grant promotion on the post of Driver since 1985 and pay financial benefits.
(E) This Honourable Court may be pleased to issue a writ of mandamus or any appropriate writ, and during the pending the petition the passed the order or direction, to the respondent authorities to examine the case of the petitioner within stipulated period.
(F) Be pleased to pass such other and further relief in favour of the petitioner that is just, fit and expedient in the facts and circumstances of the case;"
3. Briefly stated, the petitioner nos.2 to 12 came to be appointed as regular cleaner in the forest department and are rendering services as driver, having valid driving license since long and,
Page 2 of 19
therefore, the petitioners are eligible to be selected as driver. The particulars of the petitioners are duly produced at Annexure-A at page 17. The petitioners made detailed representations to the respondent - authority on 18.07.2015 and 09.12.2013, which are duly produced at Annexure-B collectively. It is the case of the petitioners that they were required to be considered as per the circular dated 30.01.1981 and during that period, many persons were absorbed in the post of driver. By communication dated 18.10.2007, the petitioner - association was informed as under:-
"In reference to the representation made by you through your application, you - all the petitioners have been personally heard at 16:00 hrs. on 17/10/2007. The Recruitment Rules of the Drivers have been published vide Government Notification no.: GHK-132-76-RCT- 1376/67457-P, Dtd.15/07/1976 of the Agriculture, Forest and Co-operation Department, Secretariat, Gandhinagar. Wherein there is no provision in the Recruitment Rules of the Drivers to give promotion from Cleaner to Driver. Hence, your prayer could not be accepted in the present circumstances."
4. It is the case of the petitioners that between the years 1981 and 2005, though the petitioners worked on the post of cleaner, no steps were taken by the respondent - State to absorb the petitioners in the post of driver. The respondent - authority failed in considering the petitioners' representation for promotion to the post
Page 3 of 19
of driver from the post of cleaner. The petitioners herein are neither granted higher grade pay of Rs.4000-6000 as per the 5thpay commission nor granted grade pay of Rs.5200-20200 as per the 6th pay commission, which means that they are not promoted and if they are not promoted, then in the same cadre, they get the pay scale of driver but, the petitioners are deprived of the same also. It is the case of the petitioners that the respondent - State has not acted in accordance with the circular dated 30.01.1981 and even the notification dated 15.07.1976, which itself is clear in favour of the petitioners. It is the case of the petitioners that though the petitioners passed 4thstandard, they are required to be considered for promotion, moreover, the respondent failed to consider the Gujarat Civil Services Classification and Recruitment General Rules, 1967. The General Administration Department of the respondent - State issued notification on 26.02.2009, which are the recruitment rules for appointment to the post of driver and further qualification, which is required for promotion to the post of driver, is passing 10 th standard. It is the case of the petitioners that the petitioners herein were required to be promoted from Class - IV to Class - III as drivers having rendered the services with the respondent for the period between 1981 to 2005 i.e. 24 years.
5. Mr.Krunal Pandya, learned advocate for the petitioners,
Page 4 of 19
relying on the facts, as referred above, submitted that the petitioners herein are deprived of the benefits of the government circular dated 30.01.1981. It is submitted that the petitioners came to be appointed as cleaner in the forest department and were rendering the services as driver in the office of the respondent - authorities and have rendered their services as driver sincerely. It is submitted that after five years' of service as driver, if the petitioners are having license as driver then, they are eligible to be promoted as driver though, since past 20 to 30 years, they have rendered services as driver but, the office of the respondent has not given the grade of driver i.e. Rs.4000-6000 to the present petitioners as per the 5thpay commission and Rs.5200-20200 as per the 6thpay commission. Placing reliance on the aforesaid, it is submitted that the prayers, as prayed for, in the present petition be granted.
5.1. Reliance is placed on the order dated 30.06.2016 passed by this Court in Special Civil Application No.9009 of 2015 wherein, this Court held that considering the terms of reference as to whether, the employees working in feeder cadre of the clerk with the educational qualification of not less than SSC pass, should be considered for appointment on the post of clerk or not, that too against the quota reserved for the departmental candidates. The said order was held in favour of the workmen. It is submitted that
Page 5 of 19
the petitioners herein are identically placed and seek parity in light of the said order dated 30.06.2016. It is submitted that the said order was the subject matter of challenge by way of Letters Patent Appeal No.390 of 2017, which was confirmed by the Division Bench of this Court. It is submitted that the said order was also the subject matter of challenge before the Hon'ble Apex Court wherein, the order passed in Special Civil Application No.9009 of 2015 was not disturbed. However, it was clarified by the Hon'ble Apex Court by order dated 09.04.2018 that the said order was confined to 36 employees in question in the facts of the said case.
5.2. Placing reliance on the aforesaid, it is submitted that the present petitioners were required to be promoted from the post of cleaner - Class-IV to the post of driver - Class-III.
6. Ms.Pooja Ashar, learned A.G.P. relied on the affidavit-in-reply filed by the respondent - State and submitted that out of 11 petitioners, 4 have been given the benefits of stock promotional posts i.e. of driver, having requisite qualification as per the government resolution dated 26.02.2009, which is duly produced at page 82. It is submitted that those petitioners having qualified for the post of driver, are extended the benefits. It is submitted that as per the government resolution dated 02.03.2009, there is a further requirement of passing CCC examination for which, all the
Page 6 of 19
petitioners are exempted. Reliance is placed on the said government resolution dated 02.03.2009, which is duly produced at page 86. It is submitted that in view of the aforesaid, the remaining petitioners are not promoted as Class - III. It is also submitted that the petitioners are granted the benefit of the second higher pay scale in absence of promotional avenue. To substantiate the aforesaid contentions, reliance is placed on the chart, which is produced on record at Annexure-R3.
6.1. Upon instructions, it is stated that the petitioners, those who are not promoted, are extended the benefit of the second higher pay scale. Placing reliance on the aforesaid submissions, it is submitted that the prayers, as prayed for, are such that the same may not be granted, the petitioners herein having not qualified to the promotional post.
7. Having heard the learned advocates appearing for the respective parties, it emerges that the petitioners herein came to be appointed as regular cleaners in the forest department of the respondent - State and worked between 1981 to 2005. This Court has perused the chart, which is placed on record at pages 17 to 19. On perusal of the same, it emerges that all the petitioners have superannuated upon attaining the age of retirement. It is not in dispute that the petitioners herein, during the course of their
Page 7 of 19
employment, are granted the benefits of 1stand 2ndhigher pay scales in accordance with the government resolutions issued from time to time. It emerges that the petitioners herein are seeking the benefit of the notification dated 15.07.1976, which is duly produced at page 66, regarding Driver (Forest Department) Recruitment Rules, 1976. Upon perusal of the same, it emerges that said rules are for direct recruitment. The respondent - State also issued a circular dated 30.01.1981 for Class-IV employees, having complied with the conditions of a driver at pg 71. The said circular provides that all the Class-IV employees, if they comply with the requirement, they would be promoted as drivers. The petitioners herein are seeking the benefit of the said circular dated 30.01.1981 and according to the petitioners, they are qualified under the said government resolution.
8. Upon perusal of the details, which are provided, it emerges that all the petitioners have retired and are seeking the benefit of the said circular retrospectively. The present petition is also filed by the petitioners after having retired and having received the benefit of the second higher pay scale. In the meantime, when the petitioners were in service, the respondent - State issued notification dated 26.02.2009 wherein, the petitioners were required to comply with condition no.3 of the said circular. It also required the petitioners to pass the CCC examination. However, the same is
Page 8 of 19
exempted by government resolution dated 02.03.2009 and out of 11 petitioners, 4 petitioners are granted the benefit of the government resolution dated 26.02.2009.
9. Considering the aforesaid aspects, in the opinion of this Court, the petitioners are seeking benefit of promotion upon retirement retrospectively, which is such that, the petitioners would not be eligible for the same. Further, upon perusal of the chart, which is produced at page 88, it emerges that the petitioners were not promoted as per the government resolution dated 26.02.2009, having not been qualified and having not passed 10thstandard examination.
10. It is apposite to deal with the judgment relied upon by Mr.Pandya, learned advocate for the petitioners wherein, in the facts of the said case, the petitioners had approached the Court upon the award passed by the learned Labour Court wherein, it was held that the petitioners therein were entitled to the said benefit, taking into consideration the award passed by the learned tribunal and the same was affirmed by the Division Bench of this Court and the Hon'ble Apex Court in the facts of the said case.
11. In the facts of the present case, no such dispute was ever raised by the petitioners before the learned tribunal. The petitioners
Page 9 of 19
herein were appointed as regular employees in Class-IV and at the time of superannuation, the petitioners were granted the benefits of the government resolutions prevailing at the relevant point of time by granting 1stand 2ndhigher pay scale. The petitioners have superannuated as back as in the year 2016 to 2019.
12. In view of the aforesaid, it is apposite to refer to the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of West Bengal and others vs. Dr.Amal Satpathi and others reported in 2024 INSC 906. Paragraphs 11, 15, 19 and 21 of the said judgment read as under:-
11. In support of these contentions, learned counsel for the appellants relied upon the case of Union of India v. N.C. Murali, to contend that without a specific rule entitling employees to promotion from the date of vacancy, the right to promotion arises only when it is actually effected. He also relied upon Sunaina Sharma v. State of Jammu & Kashmir, wherein this Court held that promotion cannot be retrospectively granted from a date before the employee was in the cadre, as it would violate Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. He thus implored the Court to set aside the impugned judgment and accept the appeal.
15. Discussion and Conclusion: - 15. The primary question that arises for our consideration in the present appeal is whether respondent No.1, who was recommended for the promotion before his
Page 10 of 19
retirement but did not receive actual promotion to the higher post due to administrative delays, is entitled to notional financial benefits of the promotional post after his retirement?
19. It is a well settled principle that promotion becomes effective from the date it is granted, rather than from the date a vacancy arises or the post is created. While the Courts have recognized the right to be considered for promotion as not only a statutory right but also a fundamental right, there is no fundamental right to the promotion itself. In this regard, we may gainfully refer to a recent decision of this Court in the case of Bihar State Electricity Board and Others v. Dharamdeo Das9 , wherein it was observed as follows:
"18. It is no longer res integra that a promotion is effective from the date it is granted and not from the date when a vacancy occurs on the subject post or when the post itself is created. No doubt, a right to be considered for promotion has been treated by courts not just as a statutory right but as a fundamental right, at the same time, there is no fundamental right to promotion itself. In this context, we may profitably cite a recent decision in Ajay Kumar Shukla v. Arvind Rai10 where, citing earlier precedents in Director, Lift Irrigation Corporation Ltd. v. Pravat Kiran Mohanty 11and Ajit Singh v. State of Punjab12, a three-Judge Bench observed thus:
41. This Court, time and again, has laid
Page 11 of 19
emphasis on right to be considered for promotion to be a fundamental right, as was held by K. Ramaswamy, J., in Director, Lift Irrigation Corpn. Ltd. v. Pravat Kiran Mohanty in para 4 of the report which is reproduced below:
'4……. There is no fundamental right to promotion, but an employee has only right to be considered for promotion, when it arises, in accordance with relevant rules. From this perspective in our view the conclusion of the High Court that the gradation list prepared by the corporation is in violation of the right of respondent-writ petitioner to equality enshrined under Article 14 read with Article 16 of the Constitution, and the respondent- writ petitioner was unjustly denied of the same is obviously unjustified.'
42. A Constitution Bench in Ajit Singh v. State of Punjab, laying emphasis on Article 14 and Article 16(1) of the Constitution of India held that if a person who satisfies the eligibility and the criteria for promotion but still is not considered for promotion, then there will be clear violation of his/her's fundamental right. Jagannadha Rao, J. speaking for himself and Anand, C.J., Venkataswami, Pattanaik, Kurdukar, JJ., observed the same as follows in paras 22 and 27:
Articles 14 and 16(1) : is right to be considered for promotion a fundamental right
Page 12 of 19
22. Article 14 and Article 16(1) are closely connected. They deal with individual rights of the person. Article 14 demands that the 'State shall not deny to any person equality before the law or the equal protection of the laws'. Article 16(1) issues a positive command that:
'there shall be equality of opportunity for all citizens in matters relating to employment or appointment to any office under the State'. It has been held repeatedly by this Court that clause (1) of Article 16 is a facet of Article 14 and that it takes its roots from Article 14. The said clause particularises the generality in Article 14 and identifies, in a constitutional sense "equality of opportunity" in matters of employment and appointment to any office under the State. The word "employment"
being wider, there is no dispute that it takes within its fold, the aspect of promotions to posts above the stage of initial level of recruitment. Article 16 (1) provides to every employee otherwise eligible for promotion or who comes within the zone of consideration, a fundamental right to be "considered" for promotion. Equal opportunity here means the right to be "considered" for promotion. If a person satisfies the eligibility and zone criteria but is not considered for promotion, then there will be a clear infraction of his fundamental right to be "considered" for
Page 13 of 19
promotion, which is his personal right.
"Promotion" based on equal opportunity and seniority attached to such promotion are facets of fundamental right under Article
16(1).
* * *
27. In our opinion, the above view expressed in Ashok Kumar Gupta v. State . of U.P.13, and followed in Jagdish Lal v. The State . of Haryana14, and other cases, if it is intended to lay down that the rightguaranteed to employees for being
"considered" for promotion according to relevant rules of recruitment by promotion (i.e. whether on the basis of seniority or merit) is only a statutory right and not a fundamental right, we cannot accept the proposition. We have already stated earlier that the right to equal opportunity in the matter of promotion in the sense of a right to be "considered" for promotion is indeed a fundamental right guaranteed under Article 16(1) and this has never been doubted in any other case before Ashok Kumar Gupta v. State . of U.P.], right from 1950.'
"20. In State of Bihar v. Akhouri Sachindra Nath15, it was held that retrospective seniority cannot be given to an employee from a date when he was not even borne in the cadre, nor can seniority be given with
Page 14 of 19
retrospective effect as that might adversely affect others. The same view was reiterated in Keshav Chandra Joshi v. Union of India16, where it was held that when a quota is provided for, then the seniority of the employee would be reckoned from the date when the vacancy arises in the quota and not from any anterior date of promotion or subsequent date of confirmation. The said view was restated in Uttaranchal Forest Rangers' Assn. (Direct Recruit) v. State of U.P17, in the following words:
'37. We are also of the view that no retrospective promotion or seniority can be granted from a date when an employee has not even been borne in the cadre so as to adversely affect the direct recruits appointed validly in the meantime, as decided by this Court in Keshav Chandra Joshi v. Union of India held that when promotion is outside the quota, seniority would be reckoned from the date of the vacancy within the quota rendering the previous service fortuitous. The previous promotion would be regular only from the date of the vacancy within the quota and seniority shall be counted from that date and not from the date of his earlier promotion or subsequent confirmation. In order to do justice to the promotes, it would not be proper to do injustice to the direct recruits……
38. This Court has consistently held that no retrospective promotion can be granted nor
Page 15 of 19
can any seniority be given on retrospective basis from a date when an employee has not even been borne in the cadre particularly when this would adversely affect the direct recruits who have been appointed validity in the meantime." (emphasis supplied)
21. While we recognize respondent No.1's right to be considered for promotion, which is a fundamental right under Articles 14 and 16(1) of the Constitution of India, he does not hold an absolute right to the promotion itself. The legal precedents discussed above establish that promotion only becomes effective upon the assumption of duties on the promotional post and not on the date of occurrence of the vacancy or the date of recommendation. Considering that respondent No. 1 superannuated before his promotion was effectuated, he is not entitled to retrospective financial benefits associated to the promotional post of Chief Scientific Officer, as he did not serve in that capacity."
13. It is also apposite to refer to the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Sunaina Sharma and others vs. State of Jammu and Kashmir and others, reported in (2018)11 SCC 413. Paragraphs 11, 15 and 16 of the said judgment read as under:-
11. At this stage, it would be pertinent to mention that it is a settled principle of law that normally no person can be promoted with retrospective effect from a date when he was not borne in the cadre. Seniority has to be reckoned only from the date the person entered into that service. In this behalf
Page 16 of 19
reference may be made to the judgment of this Court in State of Bihar v. Akhouri Sachindra Nath [State of Bihar v. Akhouri Sachindra Nath, 1991 Supp (1) SCC 334 : 1991 SCC (L&S) 1070] where this Court held as follows : (SCC p. 342, para 12)
"12. … It is well settled that no person can be promoted with retrospective effect from a date when he was not borne in the cadre so as to adversely affect others. It is well settled by several decisions of this Court that amongst members of the same grade seniority is reckoned from the date of their initial entry into the service."
Thereafter, in Kaushal Kishore Singh v. Director of Education [Kaushal Kishore Singh v. Director of Education, (2002) 9 SCC 634 : 2002 SCC (L&S) 1090] this Court held as follows : (SCC p. 635, para
5)
"5. The claim of seniority of the employee is always determined in any particular grade or cadre and it is not the law that seniority in one grade or cadre would be dependent on the seniority in another grade or cadre."
15. From the judgments referred to hereinabove it is apparent that the normal rule is that a person is entitled to seniority only from the date when the said person actually joins the post. True it is, that there are exceptions and sometimes "in service"
Page 17 of 19
candidates can be granted promotion from a date anterior to their being regularly promoted/appointed. However, this can be done only if the rules enable retrospective appointment and on fulfilling the other requirement of the Rules.
16. As far as the present case is concerned, Rule 23 of the Civil Services Rules has been extracted hereinabove. It, no doubt, postulates the appointment of a probationer to the service on a date anterior to his regular appointment. However, this is subject to two conditions. The first is that the vacancy in his category should have existed and no appointment can be made from a date prior to the date of existence of vacancy. The second condition is that the person must have been continuously on duty as member of service from the said date. As far as the first condition is concerned there is no doubt that the promotees have been appointed from the date when the vacancies existed in their promotional quota. It is the second aspect of the matter which needs to be analysed in detail."
14. In opinion of this Court, the petitioners herein have superannuated as back as in the years 2016 to 2019 and view thereof, the question of granting promotions retrospectively, does not arise.
Page 18 of 19
15. For the foregoing reasons, the prayers, as prayed for, in the present petition are such that, this Court is not inclined to exercise extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
16. Accordingly, the present petition is dismissed. Rule is discharged.
(VAIBHAVI D. NANAVATI,J)
Hitesh
Page 19 of 19