ORDER
1. This miscellaneous petition has been preferred by the petitioner under Article 227 of the Constitution of India being aggrieved by the impugned orders dated 27.08.2024, 17.10.2024, 17.12.2024, 19.12.2024 passed by District Judge, Ratlam in Execution case No.18A/19 arising from a partition decree dated 01.05.1992.
2. Brief facts of the case are that a suit was filed by Raj Kishore and Mahesh Kumar (Res. No.1 &2) against the brothers and sisters of their father Nand Kishore, seeking partition of the suit property (ancestral property belonged to Durgashankar Purohit who expired on 08.10.1968) bearing No.192, 195 and Bada NO.1/181 situated at Sailana
1
Ratlam, so also agriculture land bearing survey Nos.178 522, 578, 690, 805 and 1273 of the same village. The suit was registered as RCS-18- A/1985.
3. It was pleaded by contesting defendant Mukut Behari that Nandkishore had already taken his share in lifetime of Durgashankar and migrated to Alampur, where he died. It was also pleaded that father Durgashankar and mother Pyaribai lived with Defendant No.2 Mukut Behari and also the mutation of the lands in his name was already known to the plaintiffs thus the plaintiffs have no right on the suit property. Learned trial Court allowed the suit and passed a preliminary decree directing the partition of the suit property, allotting a 1/6th share to each party and the agricultural land was directed to be partitioned by a gazetted revenue officer under the provisions of Order 20 Rule 18(1) of
CPC.
4. The decree of partition was challenged by the defendants including the present appellants before this Court and plaintiffs also filed an appeal seeking mense profits and costs. Both the appeals were dismissed by this Court confirming the judgment and decree passed by trial Court. The defendants filed a Second Appeal before the Hon'ble Supreme Court which was also dismissed by Hon'ble Supreme Court vide order dated 11.08.2022. The plaintiffs in the meanwhile filed an execution proceedings for execution of the decree, registered as Ex- 09/1992. A report was submitted by Commissioner (appointed by the
2
executing Court) in which it was reported that the two houses could not be partitioned by metes and bounds, therefore, the houses be sold and the sale proceeds be distributed amongst the parties.
5. In between one of the judgment debtors representing the LRs of Kaushalya Devi, filed an application under Order 21 Rule 35(2) read with Order 21 Rule 43 of CPC, before the executing Court praying for directions to petitioner Seems to vacate the premises which was allowed vide order 27.08.2024 directing petitioner Seema to vacate the premises and file an affidavit confirming that she had vacated the suit House. Challenging the aforesaid order petitioner Seema filed a review application under Order 47 Rule 1 read with Section 114 of CPC and the same was dismissed affirming the order dated 27.08.2024. Further Seema filed an application under Section 151 of CPC contending that since the decree has been passed without impleading LRs of Krishna D/o of Mukutbihari Purohit (respondent no.4(b)) after her death (as they were the necessary parties) the decree has been rendered unenforceable. On 17.12.2024 the executing Court dismissed the said application and ordered for attachment of the suit property under Order 21 Rule 13 of CPC so also imposed cost of Rs.1000/-. Thereafter on 19.12.2024 the executing Court passed an order in Execution case No.18-A/19 pertaining to a decree dated 01.05.1992 issued in favour of decree-holder Rajkishor and others, holding that the judgment-debtors being the legal heirs of deceased Mukut Bihari, had failed to satisfy the decree, therefore, the Court prohibited
3
the transfer, sale gift or encumbrance of the specified properties until further orders and directed the judgment-debtors to appear on 21.01.2026 to receive notice regarding the determination of sale proclamation regulations. Being aggrieved with the aforesaid order the petitioner has filed this present petition.
6. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that since the decree under execution is a partition decree with every member being entitled to an equal share of 1/6th of the suit property, therefore, no effective order could be passed without impleading the LRs of a dead member in order to execute the decree. It is further contended that petitioner Seema is residing in one of the suit houses and she is entitled for 1/6th share in the property equal to any other members, therefore, she could not be directed to vacate the house just because the house in question may fetch a higher market value and as such there is nothing mentioned in the report of the commissioner that the house cannot be sold without being vacated by the petitioner.
7. Counsel also submitted that under Order 21 Rule 35, where the decree is for delivery of possession of any immovable property, then only the judgment debtor can be asked to vacate the property, however, no such order for attachment of property can be passed in case of partition decree. The attachment of immovable property under Order 21 Rule 54 is only with a view to prevent the judgment debtor from transferring or charging the property in any way, hence no judgment debtor can be directed to vacate the possession of the house, therefore, the impugned orders cannot be sustained,
4
hence counsel prayed for quashment of the impugned orders dated 27.08.2024, 17.10.2024, 17.12.2024, 19.12.2024 passed by District Judge, Ratlam in Execution case No.18A/19.
8. On hearing the learned counsel for the petitioner, I have perused the record.
9. So far as order dated 27.08.2024 is concerned, it has been passed by learned First District Judge, Ratlam with regard to applications filed by LRs of judgment debtors Kaushalya Devi under Order 21 Rule 35 (2) and Order
21 Rule 43 of CPC. It is adjudicated by the learned execution Court that since only some house hold articles were kept in both the residential houses, the provisions of Order 21 Rule 35(2) as well as Order 21 Rule 43 of CPC could not be applied. The learned executing Court has also observed that in this case the execution was filed with regard to suit 9A/85 in the year 1992, which means that the suit is 40 years old. It is also observed by Execution Court that in this suit the decree against judgment debtor has been affirmed by Hon'ble Apex Court. Considering all aspects of the case and the observations of the Court, this Court does not find any error in the said order passed by learned execution Court.
10. Further in the same order the applications of LRs of deceased Kankamal under the provisions of Order 21 Rule 97, 98 has been decided by learned executing Court after elaborate discussions. Since the order is related to Order 21 Rule 97, of CPC, the present miscellaneous petition is not maintainable as per law, as against such orders only appeal can be entertained.
5
11. Likewise, order dated 17.10.2024, is also only with regard to objections raised by LRs of judgment Debtors No.3 and in this regard the petitioner has filed review petition under Section 114 and Order 47 Rule 1 of CPC. The learned executing Court having relying upon the law laid down by Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Kamlesh Verma vs. Mayawati and Ors., (2013) 8 SCC 320; Moran Mar Basselios Catholicos vs. Most Rev. Mar Poulose Athanasius, AIR 1954 SC 526; Akilesh Yadav vs. Vishwanath Chathurvedi, 2013 AIR SCW, 1316; S. Murali Sundaram vs. Jyotibai Kannam in Civil Appeal No.1167-1170/2023 order dated 24.02.2023 dismissed the application. Considering the adjudication of the learned execution Court, I don't find any error in the order.
12. Likewise, with regard to the order dated 17.12.2024, it is also only a way of raising objection regarding decree. The objections raised by applicants are also not looking substantial so the rejection of application is also found infallible. So far as the order dated 19.12.2024 is concerned, it is not an order rather it is a notice to the LRs of Judgment Debtors Mukut Behari, which includes the petitioners also. Actually this order has been issued to prevent the alienation and transfer of disputed property to any other party. Hence, against this order also the present petition is not maintainable.
13. In view of the aforesaid observations it is found that the order of learned executing Court passed on 27.08.2024, 17.10.2024, 17.12.2024, 19.12.2024 are not suffering from any illegality, impropriety. Actually these orders are passed in consonance of law and only with regard to an execution of a decree which has attained finality from the Hon'ble Apex
6
(PREM NARAYAN SINGH)
JUDGE
Court. The miscellaneous petition filed under Article 227 of Constitution of India being devoid of merits. Accordingly, the same is dismissed and the impugned orders are hereby affirmed.
Certified copy, as per Rules.
sumathi
7