Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 12 of Page 3 of 5 the Rules of Legal Education, 2008,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 12 of Page 3 of 5 the Rules of Legal Education, 2008,
Smart Summary

Executive Summary of the Judgment and Order (Oral)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Shri Bamang Nabam, a 5th semester student of Shillong Law College, filed WP(C) No. 441 of 2024 under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking relief to condone a shortfall in attendance so he could sit for the 5th semester end semester examinations. The petition asserts that the petitioner underwent an operation in November 2024 and produced a medical certificate and related documents in support of the medical reasons for the attendance shortfall. The College declared the petitioner ineligible to take the end semester examinations due to insufficient attendance. The writ petition was heard on 03.12.2024 before Hon'ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner’s shortfall in attendance can be condoned to enable him to sit for the 5th semester End Semester Test in light of the medical reasons presented.
  2. How Rule 12 of the Rules of Legal Education, 2008 (the provision governing eligibility for End Semester Test and its proviso allowing condonation) applies to the petitioner’s attendance percentages.
  3. Whether the affiliated university respondents (NEHU — respondents Nos. 1, 2 & 3) have jurisdiction or power to condone the shortfall in attendance, or whether that power rests with the College Principal/Dean under the Rules.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner’s shortfall in attendance was due to legitimate medical reasons, including an operation in November 2024.
  • Medical certificates and related documentation were annexed to the writ petition to substantiate the medical condition.
  • The petitioner is an otherwise exceptional student with no backlog ("without any back paper till date"), and therefore seeks consideration to be permitted to sit for the examinations.

Respondent No. 4 (Principal, Shillong Law College) — Arguments

  • While acknowledging the genuineness of the petitioner’s case, the College is bound by Rule 12 of the Rules of Legal Education, 2008.
  • The proviso to Rule 12 permits condonation only where a student has at least 65% attendance in a particular subject and 70% attendance overall; the petitioner had only 60% overall attendance and therefore cannot be held eligible under that Rule.

Respondents Nos. 1–3 (NEHU) — Arguments

  • As the College is an affiliated institution, the question of condonation or any consideration of shortfall in attendance lies within the College’s purview; respondents Nos. 1, 2 & 3 (NEHU) assert they have no jurisdiction or power to condone the shortfall.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reproduced and examined Rule 12 of the Rules of Legal Education, 2008, which governs eligibility to take the End Semester Test. The Rule provides that no student shall be allowed to take the end semester test unless the student has attended at least 70% of classes in the subject and overall; the proviso permits, for exceptional reasons, the Dean or Principal to allow a student to take the test if the student attended at least 65% of classes in the particular subject and 70% of classes overall.

Applying this provision, the court noted the undisputed factual position that the petitioner had only 60% attendance overall. Because the proviso requires at least 65% attendance in the subject concerned and 70% overall, the petitioner’s attendance did not meet the threshold set by Rule 12. The court therefore concluded that the Rule rendered the petitioner ineligible to sit for the End Semester Exams.

The court acknowledged the petitioner’s predicament and the genuineness of the medical cause but held that due to the explicit mandate of Rule 12 (the “mandate of law”), it could not grant the relief sought in the writ petition.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED. The writ petition is closed and accordingly disposed; the prayer to condone the shortfall in attendance and permit the petitioner to sit for the 5th semester End Semester Examinations was refused.

Direct consequences: The petitioner remains ineligible to take the 5th semester End Semester Exams under the applicable Rule (Rule 12, Rules of Legal Education, 2008) because his attendance figure (60%) falls below the thresholds (65% in the subject and 70% overall) required for condonation. The opinion does not purport to establish or announce any new legal precedent beyond the application of the quoted Rule.

Case details: WP(C) No. 441 of 2024 — Decision dated 03.12.2024 — High Court of Meghalaya (Hon'ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew).

    BAMANG NABAM v. NORTH EASTERN HILL UNIVERSITY AND 3 ORS.

    Serial No. 01 Supplementary List

    HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA

    AT SHILLONG

    WP(C) No. 441 of 2024 Date of Decision: 03.12.2024 Shri Bamang Nabam … Petitioner(s) Versus

    1. North Eastern Hills University (NEHU) Represented by the Registrar of NEHU Umshing Mawkynroh, Shillong-793002.

    2. The Controller of Examination, NEHU Umshing Mawkynroh, Shillong-793002.

    3. The Vice Chancellor, NEHU Umshing Mawkynroh, Shillong-793002.

    4. The Principal, Shillong Law College, Dhankheti, Shillong East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya. … Respondent(s) Coram:

    Hon'ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge Appearance:

    For the Petitioner(s) : Mr. P. Yobin, Adv. with Ms. B. Ramsiej, Adv.

    For the Respondent(s) : Mr. S. Sen, Adv. (For R 1-3) Mr. S. Chakrawarty, Sr. Adv. with

    Mr. E. Laloo, Adv. (For R 4)

    Page 1 of 5

    ________________________________________________________

    i) Whether approved for reporting in Yes/No Law journals etc.:

    ii) Whether approved for publication in press: Yes/No

    JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)

    1. The petitioner who is stated to be a Student in the 5 th Semester of Shillong Law College is before this Court seeking interference by invoking powers under Article 226 of the Constitution, to condone the shortfall in attendance for which he has been held ineligible by the College to take the End Semester Exams (5 thsemester Exams).

    2. Mr. P. Yobin, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the failure of the petitioner/student to meet the required attendance was because of legitimate reasons i.e. medical conditions, for which he had undergone an operation in November, 2024, and a medical certificate and the other details to this effect have been annexed to the writ petition. He further submits that the reasons being genuine, the petitioner who is an exceptional student without any back paper till date, be given some consideration and prays for directions

    Page 2 of 5

    from this Court to enable the petitioner to sit for the 5 thSemester Examinations.

    3. Mr. S. Chakrawarty, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. E. Laloo, learned counsel, who has entered appearance on behalf of the respondent No. 4, i.e. the Principal, Shillong Law College has submitted that though the case of the petitioner may be genuine, however, the College is bound by the Rules of Legal Education, 2008, wherein with regard to the End Semester Test, the proviso for condonation is only to the extent of 65% for a particular subject, and 70% for overall attendance. He further submits that the petitioner having attended only 60% of all the classes, therefore as per the Rule, cannot be held to be eligible to take the Examinations.

    4. Mr. S. Sen, learned counsel appearing for the respondents Nos. 1, 2 & 3, (NEHU) has submitted that the College being an affiliated College, the matter for condonation or any consideration thereof, is strictly within its purview, and the respondents Nos. 1, 2 & 3 have no jurisdiction or power to condone the shortfall in attendance.

    5. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the materials on record. The provision regarding redressal for shortfall in attendance for taking the End Semester Test, is contained in Rule 12 of

    Page 3 of 5

    the Rules of Legal Education, 2008, which for the sake of convenience is reproduced hereinbelow:-

    "12. End Semester Test. No student of any of the degree program shall be allowed to take the end semester test in a subject if the student concerned has not attended minimum of 70% of the classes held in the subject concerned as also the moot court room exercises, tutorials and practical training conducted in the subject taken together.

    Provided that if a student for any exceptional reasons fail to attend 70% of the classes held in any subject, the Dean of the University or the Principal of the Centre of Legal Education, as the case may be, may allow the student to take the test if the student concerned attended at least 65% of the classes held in the subject concerned and attended 70% of classes in all the subjects taken together. The similar power shall rest the Vice Chancellor or Director of a National Law University, or his authorized representative in the absence of the Dean of Law."

    6. A perusal of the same would show that for a student who fails to attend 70% of the classes held in any subject, the Dean or the Principal may allow the student to take the Test, if the student concerned attended at least 65% of the classes held in the subject concerned, and attended 70% of classes on all subjects taken together. The undisputed fact in the instant case, being that the student has only

    Page 4 of 5

    obtained 60% attendance, the operation of the said Rule has therefore rendered him ineligible to sit for the End Semester Exams.

    7. Though this Court understands the predicament that the student is facing, however, due to the mandate of law, no relief can be forthcoming by way of the instant petition.

    8. For the above stated reasons, the prayer cannot be allowed, and the writ petition is closed and accordingly disposed.

    JUDGE

    Meghalaya

    03.12.2024

    "V. Lyndem-PS"

    Page 5 of 5

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    BAMANG NABAM v. NORTH EASTERN HILL UNIVERSITY AND 3 ORS.
    (Dec 3, 2024)