ORDER (Per Ravi Nath Tilhari, J) :
Heard, Ms.Nalluri Sahithi Aparna, learned counsel representing Ms.Sodum Anvesha, learned counsel for the appellant and Sri.Bandi Srihari, learned counsel for the respondent.
2. This appeal is filed by the defendant aggrieved by the order dated 30.04.2024,in OS.No.119 of 2021 on the file of XIII Additional District Court, Vijayawada, in I.A.No.244 of 2022. By the said order, attachment before Judgment of the petition schedule property filed by the plaintiff/respondent was allowed.
3. The plaintiff/respondent filed O.S.No.119 of 2021 for recovery of the amount of Rs.63,64,000/- with future interest and principal amount of Rs.37,00,000/-. The defendant borrowed Rs.37,00,000/- on 27.09.2018 for the development of her property with an undertaking to pay interest at the rate of 24% per annum. The defendant even after demand, did not makethe payment. She issued 2 cheques for different amounts which were dishonoured as "funds insufficient". After issuing legal notice, and
3
when the notice was not complied with, C.C.No.198 of 2021 on the file of II Additional Metropolitan Magistrate Court, Vijayawada was filed. The present suit was also filed for recovery of the said amount. The defendant/petitioner filed counter and denied the contention of the plaintiff and also filed I.A.No.244 of 2022 for attachment. On 08.07.2022 an order of conditional attachment was passed with a direction to the defendant to furnish the security to a tune of Rs.63,64,000/- within 72 hours. The conditional attachment order was not complied. The defendant filed the objections to the application inter-alia denying the averments of the petition. It was also submitted that the plaint schedule property did not belong to the defendant but to her brother. The learned Court by the impugned order allowed the said interlocutory application and issued an attachment before the Judgment over the plaint schedule property for the undivided share of the defendant in the property bearingD.No.31-11-978 in Ward NO.6, Opposite to Yalamanchili Surendra Kumar Hospital of Arundalpet, Guntur, District. Challenging the said order, present appeal is filed.
4. The learned counsel for the appellant submits that the order of attachment cannot be sustained for the reason that the
4
property does not belong to the appellant and secondly, the order does not comply with the requirement of Order 38 Rule 5 and 6 of CPC. Her submission is that there is no finding recorded by the court that the defendant was about to dispose of the whole or part of the property or about to remove the property from the local limits of the Jurisdiction of the Court. She further submits that there is also no finding recorded that the defendant intends to obstruct or delay the execution of the decree that may be passed in the suit of the defendant. Her submission is that in the absence of any such finding recorded based on the material on record, the order for attachment cannot be passed. She has placed reliance on the decision of High Court of Delhi in Hari Shankar Vs. ShrimatiBhoori Devi1and the High Court of Andhra Pradesh in Surender Singh Bajaj Vs. M/s.Kitty Steels Ltd and Anr2.
5. The learned counsel for the respondent submits that the conditional order of attachment was passed way back on 08.07.2022 but the same was not complied with. Consequently, as the security was not furnished, a conditional order has been confirmed under Rule 6, in which there is no illegality. With
1
2
respect to the defendant being the owner of the plaint schedule property, his submission is that the property stands in the name of the appellant"s brother viz., Gollapudi Krishna Rao, and other family members. Therefore, the appellant being a family member, is also the owner and therefore, the Court is right in presuming that she is the owner. He has placed reliance on the decision of this Court in Deepika Constructions, Engineers and Civil Contractors Vs Garikipati Radha Krishnaiah3.
6. We have considered the aforesaid submissions and perused the material on record.
7. The point for our consideration and determination is as follows:
Whether the order dated 30.04.2024 under challenge is legal and justified or it requires interference in the exercise of the appellate jurisdiction?
Point:
8. Before proceeding further, we reproduce the provisions of Order 38 Rule 5 and 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) as under:
2006 LawSuit(AP) 358
3
5. Where defendant may be called upon to furnish security for production of property
(1) Where, at any stage of a suit, the Court is satisfied, by affidavit or otherwise, that the defendant, with intent to obstruct or delay the execution of any decree that may be passed against him,-
(a) is about to dispose of the whole or any part of his property, or
(b) is about to remove the whole or any part of his property from the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court,
the Court may direct the defendant, within a time to be fixed by it, either to furnish security, in such sum as may be specified in the Order, to produce and place at the disposal of the Court, when required, the said property or the value of the same, or such portion thereof as may be sufficient to satisfy the decree, or to appear and show cause why he should not furnish security.
(2) The plaintiff shall, unless the court otherwise directs, specify the property required to be attached and the estimated value thereof.
(3) The Court may also in the Order direct the conditional attachment of the whole or any portion of the property so specified.
7
1[(4) If an Order of attachment is made without complying with the provisions of sub-rule (1) of this rule such attachment shall be void.]
6. Attachment where cause not shown or security not furnished
(1) Where the defendant fails to show cause why he should not furnish security, or fails to furnish the security required, within the time fixed by the Court, the Court may Order that the property specified, or such portion thereof as appears sufficient to satisfy any decree which may be passed in the suit, be attached.
(2) Where the defendant shows such cause of furnishes the required security, and the property specified or any portion of it has been attached, the Court shall Order the attachment to be withdrawn, or make such other Order as it thinks fit."
9. A bare reading of Rule 5 shows that where at any stage of the suit, if the Court is satisfied by affidavit or otherwise that the defendant intends to obstruct or delay the execution of decree that may be passed against him and is about to dispose of the whole or any part of the property or is about to remove the whole or any part of the property from the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court, the court may direct the defendant either to furnish security in such as specified in the order to produce and place at
8
the disposal of the Court when required the said property or the value of the same or such portion thereof as may be sufficient to satisfy the decree or to appear and show cause. It is evident that for the exercise of the power under Rule 5 of CPC, the condition precedent is that the court must satisfy with respect to the existence of the condition under clause (a) or (b) or both and such act must be with intention to obstruct or delay the execution of the decree to be passed in the suit. In the absence of any such finding, the Court will not get any jurisdiction to pass the order.
10. In Surender Singh Bajaj (supra) only the allegation were made by the plaintiff in the affidavit filed in support of the application for attachment and no material was placed. It was therefore, observed that the question to be considered was whether those allegations of the plaintiff could constitute necessary conditions, precedent under Order 38 Rule 5 of CPC. It was observed and held that the circumstances stated by the plaintiff in the affidavit even if true, in itself were not sufficient to pass order under Order 38 Rule 5 of CPC, unless it was also pleaded that the defendant intended to delay the execution of the decree, that must be passed by the Court against him. But, that condition was totally absent.
9
11. It is apt to refer relevant paras of 9 and 25 as under:
"9. It is clear from the aforesaid decision that the Court has to find prima facie case. The petitioner who is seeking attachment has to satisfy by affidavit or otherwise that the person whose debt is due to him is making attempts to leave the jurisdiction of the Court or take away the amount with an intention to defeat and delay the execution of the decree. The affidavit furnished by the petitioner did not make specific mention that he was disposing of the whole or any part of the property or removing the whole or any part of his property from the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court with an intention to obstruct or delay the execution of the decree. Obviously, in this case, he was not disposing of any property. The Court cannot act on mere mentioning about the removing the whole or any part of his property from the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court. Moreover, the amount is lying with the Court and the Court has not yet passed an order permitting him to withdraw the same. I state that in view of the principles laid down by the aforesaid decision of a Division Bench of this Court, it cannot be said that the decision in J. Balakrishna v. United Bank Of India & Anr., (supra) places correct law as it has not considered Order 38, Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure and Section 60 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Now it is to be seen whether the amount in the hands of the third party cannot be attached unless
10
a decree is passed in the suit. I am of considered opinion that money in the hand of third party can be attached before judgment in view of the principles laid down under Order 38, Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure and I have no hesitation to state that it does lay the correct law."
"25. Since we hold that the application filed by the plaintiffs under Order 38, Rule 5 CPC in this case is maintainable, the next question to be considered is whether in allowing the application, the Court below acted legally or not? It is well settled that an order under Order 38, Rule 5 CPC should not be passed merely for the sake of asking or merely because of the fact that the garnishee has huge sum of money payable to the defendant. The law in this regard were discussed by this Court in Sripathi Panditarajula Venkanna Babu v. Varalakhsmi Finance Corporation, Rajahmundry, 1996 (4) ALD 453 (DB), wherein the steps necessary to be taken before an order is passed were clearly discussed and laid down. Further a Division Bench of this Court in Chairman and Managing Director, R.P.N. Nigam Limited, New Delhi
v. Rambachane Singh, , dealing with necessary conditions for ordering an application filed under Order 38, Rule 5, CPC was pleased to hold:
".......Such an order is not to be passed in a routine manner merely for the asking for it but that the Court has to be satisfied on tangible materials placed before
11
it that there are attempt at alienation and that the steps are taken so as to delay or obstruct the judgment that may be ultimately passed against the defendant. Before passing an order, the defendant is first of all to be called upon to furnish security in the shape of specific sum to produce and place at the disposal of the Court when required, the property specified by the plaintiff in his petition or such portion of it as may be sufficient to satisfy the decree or call upon him to show-cause as to why he shall not furnish security. But such an order can be passed only after the primary satisfaction of the obstructive conduct of the defendant. The ultimate attachment order can be passed only if the defendant either fails to show-cause why the security shall not be furnished or fails to fgmish the security as required........"
"The only allegation made by the plaintiffs in the affidavit filed in support of the application is that the defendant No. 2 is "now trying to leave beyond the jurisdiction of the Court" and that "he is attempting to withdraw the money deposited with the defendant No. 2 and if the attachment before judgment is not granted it would be very difficult for the plaintiffs to recover their dues from the defendant No. 1." That is the only allegation in the affidavit. Therefore, the question to be considered is whether the above allegation of the plaintiffs could constitute necessary conditions precedent to order an application under Order 38,
12
Rule 5, CPC. The above circumstance stated by the plaintiffs in the affidavit, even if true, in itself, in my considered opinion is not sufficient to pass an order under Order 38, Rule 5 CPC unless it is also pleaded that by the impugned conduct of the defendant No. 1, he was intending to delay the execution of the decree that may be passed by the Court against him. The satisfaction of the Court that the defendant with an intention to obstruct or delay the execution of the decree that may be passed by it, is about to dispose of the whole or any part of his property, or is about to remove the whole or any part of his property from the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court, is sine qua non for exercising the power under Order 38, Rule 5. This condition is totally absent in the instant case. In the impugned order, nowhere the Court below has recorded such satisfaction. In that view of the matter, the Court below ought not to have ordered the application filed by the plaintiffs under Order 38, Rule
5 CPC,"
12. In Harishankar (supra), the Delhi High Court observed that the Court has to be satisfied on two points viz., (1) that the defendant is about to dispose of whole or part of his property and
(2) that the disposal is with the intention of obstructing or delaying the execution of any decree that may be passed against him. It was observed that there has to be definite evidence of
13
these points and not merely vague allegations. An order of the Court without proper investigation of the allegations constitutes a grave dereliction of duty.
13. In Harishankar (supra), it was further observed by the Delhi High Court that before exercising jurisdiction under Rule 5, the Court should satisfy itself of the practical certainty of the plaintiff"s success and of the existence of a grave danger and of a real fear that a dishonest defendant, undoubtedly liable, is making away with the probable fruits of the Judgment and for this purpose it is not sufficient to merely allege that defendant is likely to dispose of the property.
14. Para 6 of the Harishankar (supra) is as follows:
"6. It goes without saying that the jurisdiction of courts in attaching property before judgment is of an extraordinary nature and has to be exercised sparingly and strictly in accordance with the procedure prescribed by the Code The court has to be satisfied on two points namely, (1) that the defendant is about to dispose of the whole or part of his property (emphasis added) and (2) that the disposal is with the intention of obstructing or delaying the execution of any decree that may be passed against him. There has to be definite evidence on these points and not merely vague allegations. An order of the court without proper investigation of the
14
allegations constitute a grave dereliction of duty. The fact that the defendant is in uncertain circumstances and is in acute financial and embarrassment is a relevant circumstance but is not by itself sufficient. Again the fact that the plaintiff may have cope just claim against the defendant will net entitled him in law to have ah order of attachment before judgment. At the same time before exercising jurisdiction under rule 5, the Court should satisfy itself of the practical certainty of the plaintiff's success and of the existence of a grave danger and of a real fear that a dishonest defendant, undoubtedly liable, is making away with the probable fruits of the judgment and for this purpose it is not sufficient to merely allege that defendant is likely to dispose of the property. For a defendant like the present petitioner who is carrying on jewellery business, the disposal of the assets of such business is likely in the day to day conduct of the business and a mere averment in the affidavit that the defendant is disposing of the assets does not show that the disposal of the assets is With a view to obstructing or delaying the execution of any decree that may be passed against him. It is clear from the provisions of sub- rule (2) that the provisions of sub-rule (2) are mandatory I find from the application that no particulars of the property sought to be attached, either by description or value, have been given and merely a description of the
"jewellery of the shop" is not" is not sufficient compliance for the purpose of sub-rule (2) of Rule 5 of Order 38. The result of improper description is not difficult to foresee. In
15
case of failure to furnish security, a warrant of attachment has to be issued which for necessity has to specify the particular property sought to be attached. Jf the application is vague, the warrant of attachment will not be executed Again, the particulars of the property and specific value thereof in a case like jewellery are very necessary because the plaintiff has to find out which of the items is of proper value for his purposes. In the circumstances, it is imperative for the plaintiff to give proper particulars of the property sought to be attached. In Hari Bakhsh v. Babu Lal , Bhide J. observed as follows:
"The rule requires the applicant to specify the property to be attached and the estimated value thereof" and serurity can only be taken for producing and placing at the disposal of the court such property or the value of the same or such portion thereof as may be sufficient to satisfy the decree. In the present instance, the applicant has not specified any property and has applied generally for security being taken for satisfaction of any decree that may be passed against the respondent. No such application seems to me to fall within the scope of O 18, R. 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure."
15. It clearly follows from the judgment cited that prerequisites to pass order of attachment under Rule 5 and 6 must be satisfied. Such satisfaction must also be recorded in the order. In the present case, we find that no such satisfaction is recorded neither
16
in the Order under Rule 5 nor in the Order under Rule 6, confirming the order of conditional attachment.
16. The pre-conditions under Rule 5 are to be satisfied mandatorily for passing order under Rule 5 and on cause being shown by filing reply in the light of the cause shown or objections filed, on consideration of the case of both the sides and the material on record the Court has to record satisfaction of existence of the preconditions for an order of attachment before Judgment.
17. The learned counsel for the respondent placed reliance on
Deepika Constructions, Engineers and Civil Contractors
(supra), to contend that the conditional order of attachment could be without notice to the defendant and the defendant could file an application under Order 38 Rule 6(2) of CPC for withdrawal of that attachment. As the defendant failed to furnish security, so the attachment vide impugned order came to be affected.
18. There is no dispute on the proposition of law that the order of conditional attachment under Rule 5 can be passed without notice to the defendant and while passing the order notice is to be issued. It is, after notice, if the defendant files objection to show cause under Rule 6, then the final order of attachment is to be
17
passed, if the security is not furnished and the cause shown is also not satisfactory.
19. In Deepika Constructions, Engineers and Civil Contractors (supra), also a co-ordinate bench of this Court clearly reiterated the position of law on the pre-conditions to be satisfied before passing an order of attachment before it. Relevant part of the para 8 reads as under:
"........In Sripathi Panditarajula Venkanna Babu's case (1st cited) it has been held that the Court before ordering attachment should be satisfied by cogent evidence that the defendant was about to alienate his properties and also that the said alienation is attempted to delay ordefeat the decree. Para 7 of the judgment passed therein needs to be noted and it is thus:
An order of attachment before Judgment affects the right of the owner of the property to deal with the same even before any verdict is available against him as regards the claim of the plaintiff. Such an order is not to be passed merely for the asking or in the routine manner. There must be cogent, prima facie, materials to lead the Court to the conclusion that there has been attempts by the defendant to dispose of the property with a view to defeat the decree. Mere satisfaction that there has been an attempt to dispose of the property is in itself not sufficient and there must be further conclusion, again prima facie, that the attempt to
18
alienate is to delay or defeat the decree. For reaching such satisfaction, there has to be before the Court some tangible material than the mere statement without giving any particulars and without disclosing the source of the information of attempted alienation.........................." then and further as under:
".......In Chairman and Managing Director, Rastriya Pariyojna Nirman Nigam Limited (2nd cited) it has been held that an Order under Order 38 Rule 5 can be passed only after primary satisfaction of obstructive conduct of defendant-appellant and that mere allegation of likelihood of appellant leaving jurisdiction of Court after recovering money from garnishee in itself without reaching primary satisfaction is not sufficient to pass order of attachment before judgment.
In Surender Singh Bajaj's case (3rd cited) it has been held that the satisfaction of the Court that the defendant with an intention to obstruct or delay the execution of the decree that may be passed by it, is about to dispose of the whole or any part of his property, or is about to remove the whole or any part of his property from the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court, issine qua non for exercising the power under Order 38, Rule 5.
In Avinash Constructions case, (4th cited) it has been held that before passing an order under Order 38 Rule 5 CPC, it is incumbent upon the Court to satisfy itself of the existence of the conditions laid down in the said Order. The
19
conditions precedent for passing an order under Order 38 Rule 5 CPC are:
(1) Satisfaction of the court whether the defendant is about to dispose of the whole or any part of his property; or
(2) The defendant is about to remove the whole or any part of his property from local limits of the jurisdiction of the court;
(3) The defendant should be asked, within a time to be fixed by it, to furnish security, or;
(4) To show cause why such a security should not be furnished.
If these conditions are violated, the order becomes void in terms of Sub-rule (4) of Rule 5 of Order 38 CPC. In Guntupalli Ramalingeswara Rao's case (5th cited) it has been held that the Court should record satisfaction before ordering conditional attachment. Order passed without recording satisfaction is liable to be set aside."
20. A perusal of the conditional order under Rule 5 annexed also does not show that any such satisfaction was recorded by the learned Court. The Court recorded only this much that from the perusal of the material on record, prima-facie it appears that the claim of the plaintiff was bonafide and in view thereof, the Court considered it just and proper to accede the request of the plaintiff and that no prejudice would be caused to the
20
defendant/petitioner. We are of the view that simply because the prima-facie case is madeout, the order cannot be passed for attachment unless pre-conditions under Rule 5 are satisfied. Even in the order under challenge, dated 30.04.2024, after the petitioner filed objections/counter, showing cause pursuant to the notice issued under Rule 5, there is no such satisfaction recorded. In paragraph 5 of the impugned order, the point for determination was framed and in consideration of such point, we find that from para 6 to 8, only the contentions of the learned counsel for the plaintiff and the defendants were recorded. It is in part of para 8, at page 12 of the memo of the appeal, internal page 6 of the Judgment, that there it is observed, which we record, as under:
"in those circumstances, the Court can consider the claim of the petitioner to show that the respondent/defendant intends to alienate the property and also defraud the claim of the petitioner".
21. Therefore, we are of the view that the satisfaction has not been recorded legally on the existence of the conditions precedent for passing the order of attachment.
22. We are of the view that after making such observation the Court ought to have proceeded to consider if the conditions under
21
clause (a) or/and (b) were satisfied so as to obstruct or delay the execution of any decree that may be passed in the suit, but instead of considering and recording the satisfaction on such points, it jumped to the conclusion that the claim of the plaintiff deserved to be allowed as prayed.
23. The Court also presumed that the appellant/defendant is also one of the owner of the plaint schedule property, which is reflected from the following observation made out:
"On the other hand, even the documents filed by the respondent clearly show that the petition schedule property stands in the name of the Gollapudi Krishna Rao and other family members. Therefore, it is deemed that the respondent/defendant is also one of the owner of the plaint schedule property".
24. It was a specific case of the appellant in her objections that she is not the owner but the Court has deemed that she is also one of the owner of the plaint schedule property. How such „deemed" was drawn and from what document is not clear in the order. How the petitioner being the sister of Gollapudi Krishna Rao could be covered under „and other family members", is also not clarified in the order.
22
25. Thus considered, we are of the view that the order under challenge is legally unsustainable and deserves to be interfered.
26. Accordingly, we set aside the order under challenge and remit the matter to the Court of XIII Additional District Judge Court, Vijayawada, to pass a fresh order in I.A.No.244 of 2022 in accordance with law by giving due opportunity to both the parties, within two (2) months from the date copy of this order is placed before the learned Court.
27. The appeal is partly allowed in the aforesaid terms. There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending consideration if any in this case shall stand closed.
____________________
RAVI NATH TILHARI, J
23
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
&
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
C.M.ANo.558 of 2024
26.12.2024
RSD
LR copy to be marked
24