Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2025 PHHC 578
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2025 PHHC 578
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This common order disposes of CWP-18889-2016 and CWP-5646-2024 (O&M) by consent. The petitioner, Ram Pal Singh, seeks setting aside of order dated 27.01.2016 (Annexure P-12) by which he was declared junior to respondent No.4 and his claim for promotion to the post of Senior Scientific Assistant (Serology) was rejected. The petitioner joined as Scientific Assistant (Serology) at the Director, Forensic Science Laboratory, Madhuban on 01.07.2013. He holds an M.Sc. in Medical Lab Technology (MLT). The respondents treated M.Sc. (MLT) as equivalent for initial appointment but, by the impugned order, declined to treat it as equivalent for promotion; Kurukshetra University communicated that M.Sc. (MLT) is not equivalent to M.Sc. in Biochemistry/Zoology/Microbiology/Human Biology/Forensic Science/Anthropology (Physical).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order dated 27.01.2016 declaring the petitioner junior to respondent No.4 and rejecting his claim for promotion should be set aside.
  2. Whether M.Sc. (Medical Lab Technology) should be treated as equivalent to the M.Sc. degrees prescribed for eligibility to the promotional post of Senior Scientific Assistant (Serology).

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court compared the qualifications prescribed for Scientific Assistant (Serology) (Haryana Forensic Science (Group C Scientific Staff) Service Rules, 1979) and Senior Scientific Assistant (Serology) (Haryana Forensic Science (Group C Scientific Staff) Service Rules, 1995). It observed that the prescribed qualifications for both posts recognize M.Sc. degrees in Biochemistry, Zoology, Microbiology, Anthropology (and related branches) or their equivalents. The court noted that the respondent had previously treated the petitioner's M.Sc. (MLT) as equivalent for appointment to Scientific Assistant (Serology). On being confronted, the respondent's counsel could not point out any difference between the qualifications for the two posts with respect to persons holding M.Sc. degrees. The court concluded there was no reason to deny equivalence of M.Sc. (MLT) for the promotional post when it had been treated as equivalent for appointment, and therefore the petitioner's claim for promotion and related benefits required reconsideration.

Holding and Implications

ALLOWED

Direct effect: The petitions are allowed and respondent No.2 is directed to reconsider the petitioner's claim for the promotional post of Senior Scientific Assistant (Serology) and other benefits.

No broader implications or new precedent were stated in the opinion; the decision effects reconsideration and relief to the petitioner only.

    RAM PAL SINGH v. STATE OF HARYANA & ORS.

    CWP-18889-2016 & CWP-5646-2024 (O&M) -1-

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

    AT CHANDIGARH

    204 (2 cases) CWP-18889-2016 Date of Decision: 07.01.2025 Ram Pal Singh …Petitioner Versus

    State of Haryana and others …Respondents And

    CWP-5646-2024 (O&M)

    Ram Pal Singh …Petitioner

    Versus

    State of Haryana and others …Respondents

    CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JAGMOHAN BANSAL

    Present: - Mr. Shivam Malik, Advocate for the petitioner Mr. Praveen Chander Goyal,

    Additional Advocate General, Haryana

    Mr. A.S. Virk, Advocate

    for respondent No.5-Kurukshetra University Mr. Manish Verma, Advocate

    for Mr. J.S. Lalli, Advocate

    for respondent Nos.6-I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University ***

    JAGMOHAN BANSAL, J. (Oral)

    1. As common issues are involved in the captioned petitions, with the consent of all parties, the same are hereby disposed of by this common order. For the sake of brevity and convenience, facts are borrowed from CWP-18889-2016.

    2. The petitioner through instant petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is seeking setting aside of order dated 27.01.2016 (Annexure P-12) vide which he has been declared junior to respondent No.4

    1

    and his claim for promotion to the promotional post of Senior Scientific Assistant (Serology) has been rejected.

    3. The petitioner joined office of Director, Forensic Science Laboratory, Madhuban as Scientific Assistant (Serology) on 01.07.2013. The qualification prescribed for the said post as per the Haryana Forensic Science (Group C Scientific Staff) Service Rules, 1979 was as below : -

    "M.Sc. in Biochemistry, Zoology, Microbiology, Anthropology (Physical) or equivalent.

    OR

    (i) B.Sc. 2nd Division in Zoology, Botany and Chemistry Group or B.Sc. (Hons) in Biochemistry or Zoology or Microbiology or Anthropology (Physical).

    (ii) Two Years experience in a scientific laboratory."

    4. The petitioner was not considered for the promotional post of Senior Scientific Assistant (Serology) on the ground that he was not holding degree of M.Sc. in any of the branches as prescribed in the Rules. He is holding degree of M.Sc. [Medical Lab Technology ('MLT')] which as per communication from Kurukshetra University is not equivalent to M.Sc. in Biochemistry/Zoology/Microbiology/Human Biology/Forensic Science, Anthropology (physical). The respondent has passed order dated 27.01.2016 whereby petitioner has been considered junior to Smt. Saroj Bala. The petitioner is further claiming that Smt. Saroj Bala has wrongly been considered senior to him.

    5. The qualification prescribed for the post of Senior Scientific Assistant (Serology) under the Haryana Forensic Science (Group C Scientific Staff) Service Rules, 1995 is as below:-

    "(i) B.Sc. at least 2nd Division in Medical Group.

    2

    (ii) Four Years experience as Scientific Assistant.

    OR

    (i) M.Sc. at least 2nd Division in any one of the subjects i.e. Biochemistry, Zoology, Microbiology, Human Biology, Forensic Science, Anthropology (Physical) or its equivalent degree.

    (ii) One Year experience as Scientific Assistant."

    6. From the conjoint reading of qualification prescribed for the post of Scientific Assistant (Serology) and Senior Scientific Assistant (Serology), it is evident that a person holding degree of M.Sc. in Biochemistry/Geology/Microbiology/Anthropology or equivalent is eligible for the post of Scientific Assistant (Serology) as well as Senior Scientific Assistant (Serology). The petitioner at the time of appointment as Scientific Assistant (Serology) was possessing degree of M.Sc. (MLT). The respondent considered said degree equivalent to M.Sc. in Biochemistry/Zoology/Microbiology/Anthropology and appointed him on the post of Scientific Assistant (Serology).

    7. On being confronted with the qualifications prescribed for the post of Scientific Assistant (Serology) and Senior Scientific Assistant (Serology), learned counsel for the respondent could not point out any difference between qualifications prescribed for both the posts especially with respect to persons possessing degree of M.Sc.

    8. From the perusal of qualifications prescribed for Scientific Assistant (Serology) and Senior Scientific Assistant (Serology), it is evident that any person holding degree in

    Biochemistry/Zoology/Microbiology/Anthropology is entitled for the post of Scientific Assistant (Serology) as well as Senior Scientific Assistant (Serology). It is further apt to mention here that while prescribing

    3

    qualification for the post of Senior Scientific Assistant (Serology), the respondent has approved M.Sc. in Human Biology and M.Sc. in Forensic Science apart from other branches of M.Sc.

    9. The petitioner concededly is having degree of M.Sc. in MLT. The said degree was considered equivalent to other branches of M.Sc. while making appointment as Scientific Assistant (Serology). There was no reason to hold on the part of respondent that M.Sc. in MLT is not equivalent to M.Sc. in Biochemistry/Zoology/Microbiology/Anthropology for promotional post.

    10. In the wake of above discussion and findings, this Court is of the considered opinion that present petitions deserve to be allowed and accordingly allowed. The respondent No.2 is hereby directed to reconsider claim of petitioner for the promotional post as well as other benefits.

    (JAGMOHAN BANSAL)

    JUDGE

    07.01.2025

    Mohit Kumar Whether speaking/reasoned Yes Whether reportable Yes

    4

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    RAM PAL SINGH v. STATE OF HARYANA & ORS.
    (Jan 7, 2025)