Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • Clause 23 of General Conditions of the Contract, Volume-I
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • Clause 23 of General Conditions of the Contract, Volume-I
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    AUGH SIGN., M/S.MEIL-SEW-MAYTAS-BHEL CONSTRUCTION, HYDERABAD v. PRL SECY, IRRIGATION AND CAD(PW) DEPT, HYDERABAD AND 4 OTHERS

    [ 3183 ]

    HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA

    AT HYDERABAD

    (Specia! Original Jurisdiction)

    MONDAY, THE FOURTH DAY OF DECEMBER

    TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW THREE

    PRESENT

    THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE B.VIJAYSEN REDDY

    WRIT PETITION NO: 39831 OF 2014

    Between:

    AND

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    M/S.MElL-SEW-MAYTAS-BHEL Consortium: S-2, Technocrat lndustrial Estate, Balanagar, Hyderabad Rep. by its Authorised Signatory Mr. B. Srinivasa Reddy

    ...PETITIONER

    The State of Telangana, represented by its Principal Secretary, lrrigation and CAD (PW) Department, Secretariat Building, Hyderabad.

    The Chief Engineer, Dr. Ambedkar Pranahita Chevella Sujala Sravanti, I and CAD, Jalasoudha, Erramanzil, Hyderabad-500082.

    The Superintending Engineer, I and CAD Sripada Yellampally Project Cirlce, Mancherial, Adilabad Dist. Telangana State

    The Executive Engineer, I and CAD, Gauging Division, LMD Colony, Karim Nagar, District, Telangana State.

    The Pay & Account Officer, Works and Projects, LMD Colony, Karimnagar District, Telangana State.

    ...RESPONDENTS

    Petition under Article 226 of lhr- Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pbased to issue a Writ, Order or direction and more particularly one in the nature of Writ of "Mandamus", declaring the impugned mefiro no. 3036/M and M1 -T- lVl2O14, datd 24.04.2014 issued by the 1sr respondent herein and the memo No. CE/DT.BRAPCSS/DEE-2IAEE-512014, dated 11-06-201.4 issued by 2nd respondent herein as null and void and in violation of Article 14 and 19(ixg) of the Constitution of lndia and contrary to clause 49.4 ot the terms of the conditions of

    1

    the agreement and consequenfly direct the respondents 3 to 5 not to collect the interest on the mobilization advance during the extended period l.A. NO: 1OF 2014(wPMP. NO:499 s3 0F 2014)

    Petition under section 151 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased tc direct the respondents 3 to'5 not to collect the interest on the mobilization advance as per clause 49.4 of the terms of the conditions of the agreement from the petitioners company pending disposal of the above writ petition Counsel for the Petitioner: SRt AVULA KRISHNAVEN.I

    Counsel for the Respondent No.1 to 4: Gp FOR lRRl AND COMM AREA DEV Counsel for the Respondent No.S: Gp FOR FINANCE & PLANNING

    The Court made the foltowing: ORDER

    2

    HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE B. VIJAYSEN REDDY

    WRIT PETITION No.39831 OF 2014

    ORDER:

    l.l. It is stated that the petitioner viz., M/s. MEIL-SEW- MAYTAS-BHEL Consortium is a joint venture promoted by its constituent partners. They are engaged in execution of infrastructure and civil contract works pursuant to the tender notifications issued by the then Government of Andhra Pradesh. The petitioner has been awarded work of Package-S for "Detailed Investigation, Design and Execution of Lift Irrigation Scheme for drawl and lifting of 114.24 TMC of water from Ragampet Village near Kakatiya Canal, Choppadandi Mandal, Karimnagar District to Motevagu Reservoir and carrying by a gravity canal to existing Flood Flow Canal to feed Mid Manair Reservoir with the Components such as Lined Gravity Canal, CM & CD Works, Lift, Pressure mains and Lined Tunnels with all associated Civil, Hydro Mechanical and Electro-Mechanical Works."

    1.2. Pursuant thereto, the petitioner entered into Agreement No.3/EPC/2008-2009 dated 17.11.2008. The said agreement was executed by respondent No.3 - the Superintending Engineer, I&CAD Sripada Yellampally Project Circle, Mancherial, Adilabad District,

    3

    2

    Telangana. The contract was awarded to the petitioner for an amount of Rs.3271,09,46,100/- (Rupees three thousand two hundred and two seventy one crores nine lakhs forty six thousand and one hundred only). The work allotted to the petitioner was to be executed within forty-eight (48) months from the date of agreement.

    1.3. It is stated that as per Clause 49.1 of the agreement,the petitioner is entitled to receive l0% of the contract amount as mobilization advance. Clause 49. I of the agreement reads as under:

    "49 .l The contractors for works exceeding more than Rs.L00 Crore of estimated contract value are permitted to avail the facility of mobilization advance in two installments equivalent to 10% of the contract amount (5% for labour rnobilization and 5%:o for machinery and equipment). The mobilization advance of 5olo towards Labour mobilization will be paid in two installments(1% after concluding agreement and. 4%o at the time of commencement of work i.e. after completion of investigation, suwey and designs) vide - Govemrnent Memo No.26 I 3 5/ reforms/06, Dt. 16.9.2006 Payment ol the loan will be done under separate certification by the Executive Engineer after (i) Execution of the form of contract by the parties there to (ii) Provisions by the contractor of the further security in accordance with relevant condition and (iii) provision by the contractor of a

    3

    Bank Guarantee fiom scheduled Bank acceptable to the Executive Engineer for an amount equal to l0%o of a contract amount as indicated in the letter of acceptance towards the installment of the advance mobilization loan, such bank guarantee to remain effective until the said advance loan has been completely repaid by the contractor out of the current earnings under the contract and certified accordingly by the Executive Engineer. The .Advance mobilization loan' will be paid in 30 days after fulfilling the above - i, ii, and iii items. Advance mobilization loan will be paid only in case of contracts with estirnated conrract value exceeding Rs.l00 lakhs."

    1.4. It is submitted that the petitioner received mobilization advance amount in accordance with the provisions of the agreement and it was being recovered against the works executed and bills received by the petitioner. It is the case of the petitioner that as per Clause 49.4 of theagreement, the petitioner is not Iiable to pay interest on the mobilization advances received from the respondent during the period of extension due to paucity of funds, land acquisition, forest land involvement etc., which are beyond control of the contractor.

    1.5.

    It appears, pursuant to a clarification sought by respondent No.2 from respondent No.l regarding levy of interest on mobilization ii

    ir

    rl

    1

    I

    ii

    I

    I

    I

    I

    I

    I

    i advance taken during the extension period of agreement, respondent

    4

    No.l issued Memo No.3036/M&MI-T-IV-2014 dated 24.04.2014 stating that "there cannot be interest free mobilization advanceand directed to take action accordingly".

    1.6. It is submitted that after receiving clarification from respondent No. l, respondent No.2 issued Memo No.CElDr. B RAPC S S/DEE-2I AEE- 5 I 20 | 4 dated 1 | .06.20 I 4 directing all the Superintending Engineers to take necessary action as per the clarification given by the Government vide Memo dated 24.04.2014. Thereafter, the petitioner addressed the letter dated 12.08.2014 to respondent No. I requesting not to charge any interest on mobilization advance in all Dr.B.R. Ambedkar Pranahita Sujala Sravanthi Projects for the extended agreement period, but no action has been taken so far.

    2.1. Mr. S. Ravi, leamed senior counsel, appearing for Ms. Avula Krishnaveni, learned counsel for the petitioner, submitted that the Govemment vide Memo No.75l4lMajor Irrigation VIII(I)/2010 dated 30.06.2011 taken a decision and revised the target year of completion of project to 2018-19 due to problems like paucity of funds, land acquisition, forest land involvement etc. The revised milestones were fixed and period for completion of contract was

    5

    extended from 2012-13 to 20lg-lg and reasons for the deray are not attributable to the contractor - petitioner.

    2.2. It is submitted by the leamed senior counsel appearing for the petitioner that the party to the contract cannot unilateralry alter terms of the agreement. Respondent Nos.3 to 5 by relfng on the Memo No.30364{&Ml-T-M2Ol4, dated 24.04.2014, issued by respondent No. I and the Memo No.CE/DT.BRAPCSS/DEE_2/AEE_ 5/2014 dated 11.06.2014 issued by respondent No.2, are taking steps to collect interest on the mobirization advances received by the petitioner contrary to Clause 49.4 of the agreement. Respondent Nos.3 to 5 have no authority to collect interest on mobilization advances during the extended period of agreement as the delay is not attributable to the petitioner.

    2.3. It is case of the respondents that as per Clause 49.1 of Volume - I of the agreement and guidelines of the agreement vide Memo No.260 I 0(M&MI-T -IV)/2O| t, dated 27.0 t.20 12, following advances were released to the petitioner:

    "l* instalment of Rs.32,71,00,000/- on l6-01-2009 2nd instalment of Rs.32,71,09 ,461/- on3l-Ol-ZOl2

    6

    3'd instalment of Rs.3 2,7 1,09,46 | I - on 28-08-20 12 4'h instalment of Rs.32,71,00,000/- on l9-08-2013 5'h instalment of Rs.32,7 1,09 ,4601- on 28-08-2013"

    2.4. Installment Nos.4 and 5 referred to above were paid tothe petitioner during the extended period ofcontract agreement.

    2.5. It is contended that the Government vide Memo No.7514lMaj.In.VII(l)/2010, dated 30-06-201 l, has approved the revised completion programme and permitted the Chief Engineer, DT.BRAPCSS, Hyderabad to revise the milestones of all the packages strictly in accordance with the Project Evaluationand Review Technique (PERT) Chart submitted for the entire project completion period in the next eight years. The decision was taken during the review meeting held on 19.12.2009 and in accordance with the DPR submitted, the Chief Engineer, DT.BRAPCSS, Hyderabad has submitted revised milestones for completion of DT.BRAPCSS Project in the next eight (8) years and requested for approval ofthe agreement. Accordingly, the Chief Engineer, DT.BRAPCSS, Hyderabad vide Memo No.CEIDr.B.R.A.PCSS/DEE- I /AEE-3 120 12 dated 07 . 12.2012 approved the revised milestones programme and the agreement was

    7

    extended up to 30.06.2019. No forest is involved in Package - 8 as stated by the petitioner.

    2.6. It is stated by the respondents that based on the representation made by the contractors to the higher authorities seeking clarification whether to levy interest on mobilization advance in the extended period, pending clarification no interest was levied. The Chief Engineer, DT.BRAPCSS, Hyderabad, addressed the Govemment vide Lr.No.CEIDT.BRAPCSS/DEE-l/AEE -5lPkg.2l20l4 dated 06.02.2014 to communicate clarification on whether the levy of interest on mobilization advance taken during extension may be waived or not. Along with the letter details of all the 28 packages was sent to the Covemment. In reply, the Govemment informed vide Memo No.303644&MI-T-M2014, dated 24.M.2014, rhar there cannot be interest free mobilization advance, as such, action should be taken accordingly.

    2.7. lt is submitted that the petitioner has given consent vide Reference No.MEIL-SEW-MAYTAS-BHEL Consortium letter dated 09.09.2011 for the revised milestone prograrnme approved by the Chief Engineer, DT.BRAPCSS, Hyderabad. The PAO, LMD Colony,

    8

    Karimnagar vide Letter No.PAO/K/W-liGauging Dn/2014-l5l19 dated 20.10.2014, requested to recover interest on mobilization advance. It is submitted that recovery of interest on mobilization advance taken during the extended period is not made till date pending clarification from the higher authorities and the same was intimated to the PAO, LMD Colony, Karimnagar.

    2.8. In view of the aforesaid clarification givenby the Government, respondent No.4 seeks permission of this Court to levy interest on mobilization advance taken by the petitioner during the extended period of agreement.

    2.9. Respondent No.4 has filed additional counter affidavit inter alia stating that the impugned memos are internal correspondence between the respondents officials, as such, there is no cause of action for the petitioner to file the present writ petition. The disputes pertain to contractual obligations between the petitioner and the respondents and writ remedy is not a proper one. As per Clause 23 of General Conditions of the Contract, Volume-I of the agreement, boththe parties have to approach the competent civil Forum for enforcement of

    I

    their rights in case value of the agreement is more than Rs.50,000/-.

    9

    3. Heard Mr. S. Ravi, leamed senior counsel, appearing for Ms. Avula Krishnaveni, learned counsel for the petitioner, and learned Government Pleader for Irrigation and Command Area Developrnent for the respondents, and perused the materiai on record. 4.The interim order dated 26.12.2014 passed by this Court is as under:

    "As per Clause- 49.4 of the agreement betweenthe parties, il completion of work is delayedby circumstances beyond the control of the contractor for which an extension has been granted by the Executive Engineer/ Superintending Engineer, the interest charges on advances shall be waived lor the period of extension. The respondents are allegedly seeking to recover interest based on Metno No.3036/lv{ & |v{I-T-lVl2Ol4, dated 24-04-2014, of respondent No.l, as reiterated by memo No.CE/DT.B.R.A.PCSSIDEE-2IAEE-512014, dated I 1.06.2014, of respondent No.2.

    Prima facie, these memos are contrary to the specific agreement condition. Therefore, the respondents are

    -

    restrained from recovering interest on the mobilization advance from the petitioner during the extended period ofcontract, pending further orders."

    10

    5. Clause 49.4 of the agreement reads as under:

    "The above advance shall bear borrowing rate of Interest as approved by the Govemment of A.P. fron-r tirne to time. The interest on the amounts paid as advance is chargeable from the date the arnount'is paid. Horvever if completion is delayed by circurnstances beyond control of the contractor for which an extension has been granted by the Executive Engineer / Superintending Engineer the interest charges on such advances shall be waived for the period of extension."

    6.As per Clause 49.4 of the agreement, it is clear that if completion of the project is delayed by the circumstances which are beyond control of the contractor for which an extension of time has been granted, the interest on mobilization advance shall be waived for the extension period of time. It is specific case of the petitioner that revised milestones were fixed and time for cornpletion of the contract has been extended from 2012-13 to 2018-19 due to problems like paucity of funds, land acquisition and forest land involvement etc. In paragraph No.5 of the counter affidavit filed by respondent No.4, it is stated that no forest land is involved in Package - 8 as contended by the petitioner. However, delay due to land acquisition or paucity of funds as contended by the petitioner is not denied by the respondents.

    u Neither in the counter affidavit, additional counter aflidavit nor in the oral submissions, the respondents were abre to point out as to why time for completion ofproject has been extended. It is not the case ofthe respondents that the petitioner is in any way responsible for the deray in completion of the project or that revised milestones have been fixed on the request of the petitioner.

    7. It is pertinent to point out that as admitted by the respondents in paragraph No.5 of their counter affidavit, the milestones have been revised for all the packages of DT.BRApSSp and such decision was taken during the review meeting held on lg.lz.Z00g which was approved by the Government.

    8. The Memo No.75l4lMaj.In.VIII(L)/ 2Ot0 dated 30.06.2011 of Secretary to Government, Irrigation & CAD (p.W. MAJ.IRR. VIID Department, Government of Andhra pradesh, and Letter No. cE/Dr.B. R. A.pcs S/DEE- UAEE-s/pkg .2/ 20 r 4 dated 06.02.20 r 4, would make it-further crear that the milestones have been extended due to problems like paucity of funds, land acquisition, forest land involvement etc. The rerevant portion of the letter dated 06.02.2014 reads as under:

    13

    t2

    "The entire works of Dr.B.R. Ambedkar Pranahitha- Chevella Sujala Sravanthi is divided into 28 Packages. Agreements are concluded for all 28 Packages under EPC contract system during 2008-09 & 2009-10 with an agreelnent period of 30/48 rnonths to complete the project by 2012-13. Govemment vide ref 2d cited have revised the target year of cornpletion of the project to 2018-19 due to problems like paucity of funds, land acquisition, florest land involvement etc,."

    Thus, action of the respondents is in contravention of Clause 49.4 of the agreement.

    9. It is contended by the leamed Govemment Pleader for Irrigation that so far interest was not levied for the mobilization advances received by the petitioner during the extended period of contract and the impugned memos are intemal correspondence; and on a mere apprehension, the writ petition has been filed by the petitioner though there is no cause of action. However, it is clearly stated in paragraph No.ll of the counter affidavit that the respondents are seeking to levy interest on mobilization advance during the extended period of agreement, and therefore, it can be presumed that the respondents have decided to levy interest on the petitioner towards mobilization advance received by it. Hence, it cannot be said that no

    14

    I

    l3 cause of action is subsisting for the petitioner to hle this writ paition. The petitioner has to avail civil law remody as the subject matter involves contractual obligations and not amenable to writ jurisdiction.

    10. As noted above, it is very clear that interest cannot be levied on the mobilization advances during the extended period of agreement. Further, there are no disputed questions of facts involved in this case or there is any need for interpretation of terms of contract. It is settled law that this court exercising writ jurisdiction under Article 226 ofthe Constitution of Indiacan be invoked even in contractual matters' 11.1.The leamed senior counsel appearing for the petitioner relied on the decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in ABL International Limited v. Export credit Guarantee Corporation of India Limitedr and Century Spinning and Manufacturing Company Limited v. The Ulhasnagar Municipal Council2'

    11.2. In ABL International Limited's case (Supra 2), the Hon'ble Supreme Court hetd as under:

    ' lzooa; I scc ssl21t9zoy t scc saz

    15

    t4

    "8. As could be seen frorn the arguments addressed in this appeal and as also from the divergent views of the two courts below one of the questions that falls for our consideration is whether a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is rnaintainable to enforce a contractual obligation of the State or its instrurnentality, byan aggrieved party.

    9. In our opinion this question is more res integra and is settled by a large number of judicial pronouncements of this Court.

    29. From the above discussion of ours, following legal principles emerge as to the maintainability of a writ petition :-

    (a) In an appropriate case, a writ petition as against a State or an instrumentality of a State arising out of a contractual obligation is maintainable.

    (b) Merely because some disputed questions of facts arise for consideration, same cannot be a ground to refuse to entertain a writ petition in all cases as a matter of rule.

    (c) A writ petition involving a consequential relief of monetary claim is also maintainable.

    16

    t5

    38. What is disputed is the obligation of the first respondent to cover the risk of non-payment of consideration by cash in US currency on the ground that the risk covered by the first respondgnt is a risk arising out of non-supply ofgoods by the barter method only.

    39. In our opinion, this limited area of dispute can be settled by looking into the terms of the contract of insurance as well as the export contract, and the same does not require consideration of any oral evidence or any other documentary evidence other than what is already on record. The claim of the contesting parties will stand or fall on the terms of the contracts, interpretation of which, as stated above, does not require any external aid."

    11.3. In Century Spinning and Manufacturing Company Limited' case (Supra 3), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under:

    "15. Mr. Gokhale appearing on behalf of the Municipality urged that the petition filed by the Company apparently raised questions of fact which in the view of the High Court could not appropriately be tried in the exercise of the extra-ordinary jurisdiction under Article.226. But the High Court has not,said sg, ard on a review of the averments made in the petition this argument cannot be sustained. Merely because a question of fact is raised, the High Court will not be justified in requiring the party to se€k relief by the

    17

    l6 somewhat lengthy, dilatory and expensive process bya civil suit against a public body. The questions of fact raised by the petitioner in this case are elementary."

    12. The Memo Nos.3036M&M1-T-lVl20l4 dated 24.04.2014 dnd CE/DT.BRAPCSS/DEE-2IAEE-5/2014 dated 11.06.2014 are vague. In the opinion of this Court, such general memos could not have been issued without examining whether the delay in completion of the contract is attributable to the contractor or not. There is no reference to Clause 49.4 of the agreement in the impugned memos and it is apparent that the earlier memos dated 30.06.2011 and 06.02.2014 by which revised targets have been fixed for completion ofproject for all 28 packages, have not been taken into consideration.

    13. For the aforesaid reasons, the writ petition is allowed. Memo No.3036/M&Ml-T-lYl20l4 dated 24.04.2014 and Memo No.CE/DT.BRAPCSS/DEE-2IAEE-5/2014 dated I 1.06.2014 are set aside to the extent of the petitioner herein. The respondents are directed not to levy interest on mobilization advance of Rs.32,71,00,000/- paid on 19.08.2013 and Rs.32,71,09,4601- paid on 28.08.2013, as Installment Nos.4 and 5 respectively, to the petitioner during extension period ofcontract. No order as to costs.

    18

    t7 As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous applications, if any, pending in the writ petition stand closed.

    That Rule Nisi has been made absolute as above. Witness THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE ALOK ARADHE, pn this Monday, ' the Fourth Day of December Two Thousand and Twenty Three. SD/-N. SRIHARI

    ASSISTANT REGIST R

    //TRUE COPY//

    SECTION OFFICER

    To,

    1. The Principal Secretary, lrrigation and CAD (PW) Department, Secretariat Building, The State of Telangana, Hyderabad.

    2. The Chlef Engineer, Dr. Ambedkar Pranahita Chevella Sujala Sravanti, I and CAD, Jalasoudha, Erramanzil, Hyderabad-500082.

    3. The Superintending Engineer,I and CAD Sripada Yellampally Project Cirlce, Mancherial, Adilabad Dist. Telangana State

    4. The Execuiive Engineer,I and CAD, Gauging Divibion, LMD Colony, Karim Nagar, District, Telangana State.

    5. The Pay & Account Officer, Works and Projects, LMD Colony, Karimnagar District, Telangana State.

    6. One CC to M/s. Avula Krishnaveni, Advocate [OPUC]

    7. Two CCs to GP for Finance and Plahning, HQh Court for the State of Telangana, at Hvderabad [OUT]

    8. Two CCs to Gefor lrrigatibn arid Common Area Development, High Court for the State of Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUT]

    9. Two CD Copies TJ GJP ts t

    19

    t r,

    HIGH COURT

    DATED:0411212023

    ORDER

    WP.No.39831 of 2014

    ALLOWINGTHE WRIT PETITION

    WITHOUT COSTS.

    1tl

    F, STAr 6 A q

    /J

    ()

    2?. APH 202f iu -|. j

    ,l

    tt {)ESP

    cg**

    ,.\o

    $

    i

    20

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    AUGH SIGN., M/S.MEIL... v. PRL SECY, IRRIGATION...
    (Dec 4, 2023)