Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • Section 173 of Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 482 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Section 173 Cr-P.C.
  • Section l sI(s,J CrLP.No.8550 ol 2024 269 of IPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • Section 173 of Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 482 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Section 173 Cr-P.C.
  • Section l sI(s,J CrLP.No.8550 ol 2024 269 of IPC
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Gurram Venkat Ramana v. The State of Telangana

    IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD

    TUESDAY, THE THIRD DAY OF SEPTEMBER

    TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FOUR

    PRESENT

    THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE K. SUJANA

    CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 8550 OF 2024

    Between

    Gurram Venkat Ramana, s/o Gurram Jangaiah, Aged about 52 yearc, Occ.Practicing Advocate, R/o PIot No. 52, Road no.5. Hasthinapuram East, Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, Hyderabad- 500070. N/o H. no 2-25, Kurmedu Chinthapally Mandal, Nalgonda Districl 508250. ...PETITIONER/ACCUSED NO.1

    AND

    1 The State of Telangana, Rep- by its Public Prosecutor. High Court for the State of Telangana, High Court Buildings, Hyderabad, through SHO, P S. Chinthapally ....RESPONDENT NO.1

    K. Pradeep Kumar, Police Constable 31 of Police Station Chinthapally, Nalgonda, Telangana, ...RESPONDENT NO.2 /COMPLAINANT Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P .C., praying that in the circumstances stated in the ltlemorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court may be pleased to call for the records relating to C.C.No,683 of 2020,on the file of the Junior Civil Judge -cum- Judicial First Class [\4agistrate, Devarakonda, Nalgonda District.

    l.A. NO: 2 OF 2024

    Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C., praying that in the circumstances stated in the lt/emorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay all further proceedings, including the appearance of the Petitioner/A'1 in C.C.No.683 of 202O, on the file before the Junior Civil Judge -cum- Judicial First Class [\/agistrate, Devarakonda, Nalgonda District. This Petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition and upon hearing the argumentsof Sri GOURAVULU ANIL KUMAR, Advocate for the Petitioner and the Public Prosecutor (TG) on behalf of the Respondent No.1 and None Appeared for the Respondent No,2

    2

    The Court made the following: ORDER

    1

    THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE K. SUJANA

    CRIMINAL PETITION No.855O OF 20124

    ORDER:

    . This Cnminal Petition is filed under Section 482 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (f<:,r short Cr.P.C.) to quash the proceedings against the petitioner/ accused No.1 in C.C.No.683 of 2O2O on the fiit: of the learned Junior Civil Judge-cum--Tudicial Magistrzrtc of First Class, Devaral

    2. The briel facts of the case are thal respondent No.2_ Police registered the case in Crime No. lO9 of 2O2O against the petitioner and other accused stating that as pe:- the instructionsof his superiors, he along with his staff perf _19 rules issued by the Governmen t and burnt the scare crow. After completion of investigation, he hled the charge sheet, uide C.C.No.683 ol 2O2O, before tl-re learned Junior Civil Jrrdge_ cum-Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Devarakonda,

    2

    2

    srs,J CrLP.No.9SSO oJ 2O24 Nalgonda District for the olfence punishable under Section 269 of IPC

    3. Heard Sri Gouravulu Anii Kumar, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner as well as tr. Ganesh, iearned Assistant Public Prosecutor appearing on behalf of the respondents.

    4. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the registration of the FIR is bad as the essential ingredients for the offence under Section 269 of IpC is not made out from perusal of the FIR as well as the hnal report and the proceedings have not been Iiled as per the procedure prescribed in law. He further submitted that referring to the provision of code of Criminal Procedure and the hnal report under Section 173 of Cr.P.C., learned counsel has pointed out that there is no document or investigation to substantiate that the petitioner was suffering from any communicable disease and as such, the petitioncr could not have spread the infection of any disease that may be iabelled as dangerous to life. Consequently, offcnce under Section 269 lpc is not made out. Therefore, he prayed the Court to quash the proceedings against the petitioner.

    I

    .i

    3

    sr(s,J CrI.P.No.ASS'J of 2024

    5. In support of submissions of [he learned counse I lor the petitioner, he relied upon the juclgment of the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in HLA SHWE vs. State of MaharashtraI , wherein in paragraph No.14, it is h.:ld as follows:

    "14. 'l'o attract ingredients of Sections 269 and 27O, lL'e person must cornmit any act s'hich hc kno\\ s is likely to spread irrlection of anv drsease which is dangerous to life. Il is not in dispule that the applicants had undergone Covid-19 tcst (luring their period of quarantine i.e., lrom 03.04.202O and their test report for infection of Covid 19 rvas negative. It is also not disputed that the1, \{,erc kept in isolation from 24.O3.2020 till 31,O3.2020 under the supenision of Dr. Kharaj, NMC Zonal Officcr, Momrnpura, Nagpur. 1'here is no matcrial on recorcl to prove that applicants had indulged in an-v act \tr'hich was likely to spread rnfection ot Covid - 19. Therefore, from the material produced in the charge sheet. there is no cvidence to substantrate the fulfillrnent of ingredients of Sections 269 and 27O of the Indian Penal Code."

    6. Learned counsel for the petitioner further relied upon the judgment of the Punjab ar-id Haryana High Court at Criminal Applicatron No.453 of2020 decirkrd on 2I _09 2020

    4

    srs,J CrLP.No.E55o oJ 2024 Chandigarh in Pawan Giri and others vs. State of Haryana2, wherein in paragraph Nos.1O and 14, it is held as follows

    "10.A perusal of Section 269 IPC shows that in order to attract the same, the act of an accused must be one rvhich is likety to spread infection of any disease dangerous to Iife. A perusal of the report frled by respondent under Section 173 Cr-P.C. does not indicate any prrma facie evidence collected by the Police as to $,hethcr the petitioner or the other members of the [amil,r' were suffering from any infectious disease or nould have caused spread of any infectrous diseasc. ln the absence thereof, it cannot be assumed that the petitioners were either the carriers of infection or r'r,ould have caused spread thereof. Apart there [rom, the report also does not indicate thc cxact gurdeline purportedly alleged to have been violatcd. In the absence of any such specihc guidelincs u,hich is alleged to have been violated, there is no presumption that the act of the petitioners rvas ttnla$,ful. F-urther, perusal of the notihcation dated 01.04.2020 shows that the said notification was in the nature of a prohibition imposed upon the shops selling medicines and was not against other person. Hence, the action of the petitioners in seeking procurement of essential medicines during the permissible hours of operation cannot be held to be unlau,ful. In the absence of the respondents to refer to any order, the disobedience whereof is sought to be alleged againstthe petitioners, it cannot be perceived thatthe petitioners have committed an offence under Section

    269 TPC,

    t

    cpM,r.a,s ts95 of zo2 r

    5

    SI(S,J

    CrLP-No.aSSO oJ 2O24

    14. [t has also been held by the llon'ble Supreme Court that in the rnatter of Basir ul hacl versus State of Punjab" reported as AIR 1953 SC 293, thc prosecuting agencl, cannot bc permitted to evade the application of Section 195 b-v resortrng to devices or camouflages. The test as to rvhether there is any evasion or not is u,hether the lacts disclosc primarily and essentially an offence for lvhich a complaint of the public seruant is required. The prosecuting agency thus cannot take aid of Section

    269 IPC to justify hling of the report under Section I73 Cr.P.C. especially when the essential ingredients of Section 269 IPC are not rnadc out from the final report. "

    7. Per contra, Iearned Assistant Public Prosccutor submittecl that the case is of the year 2O2O and the allegations against the petitioner, requires [rial. Therefore, he prayt:d the Court to dismiss the criminal petition.

    8. In the light of the submissions made b-v both the learned counsel and a perusal of the material available on recorrl, the main allegation against the petitioner is that he violated the Covid - 19 rules issued by the Government and burn t the scare crow, as such, respondent No.2 registered the case against the petrtioner for the offence punishable under S€ ction 269 of IPC. At this stage, it is significant to note Section 269 of IPC, which reads as follows:

    5

    srs,J CrLP-No-assO oJ 2024

    "269. Negtigent act iikel_v to spread infection of disease dangerous to Iilrj.-Whoever unlawfully or negligentl5 does anl act u'hich is, and which he knows or has reason to believe to be, likety to spread the infection of any disease dangerous to life, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term w,hich may extend to six months, or with fine, or with both."

    9. Reverting to the facts of the case on hand and a perusal of the aforementioned rulings, in order to attract Section269 of IPC, the acl of the petitioner must be one which is likely to spread infection of any disease dangerous to life. A perusal of the report filed by respondent No.2 under Section 173 Cr.P.C. does not indicate al:y pima facie evidence collected by the Police as to whether the petitioner or the other co accused and their family members were suffering from any infeclious disease or would have caused spread of any infectious disease. In the absence thereof, it cannot .be assumed that the petitioners were either the carriers of infection or would have caused spread thereof. That apart, the report also does not indicate the exact guideline purportedly alleged to have been violated. In the absence of any such specihc guidelines which is alleged to have been violated, it cannot be presumedthat the act of the petitioners was unlawful. Therefore, the allegations against the petitioner for the offence under Section

    l sI(s,J CrLP.No.8550 ol 2024 269 of IPC do not constitute, as such, the proceedings rlgainst him are liable to be quashed

    10. In the result, [he Criminurl petition is allowed and the proceedings against the petitioner in C.C.No.68 3 of 2(t2O on the file of t he learncd Junior Civil Judge_cum_Jrrdicial Magistrate ol'First Class, Devarakonda, Nalgonda Distri,:t, are hereby quashed.

    Miscellaneous applications, if any pending, shall also stand closed.

    Sd/. K. AMMAJI

    ASSISTANT REGISTRAR

    //TRUE COPY//

    SECTION OFFICER

    To,

    'l . The Court of Principal Judicial First Class Magistrate at Devarakonda.

    2. The Station House Officer, Chinthapalli Police Station, Nalgonda District

    3. Two CCs to Public Prosecutor, High Court forthe State of Telanganaat

    HyderabadIOUT] 4. One CC to SRI GOURAVULU ANIL KUIVIAR, Advocate [OPUC] 5. Two CD Copies Pcsd/DL $

    6

    HIGH COURT

    DATED:0310912024

    ORDER

    CRLP.No.8550 of 2024

    ALLOWING THE CRIMINAL PETITION

    @q'

    a,

    I

    t 1t-rE .'., r4B F ''',Ir

    o ,6.

    t4n

    (

    3)- 9^

    1q\rla

    I

    !

    9

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gurram Venkat Ramana v. The State of Telangana
    (Sep 3, 2024)