ORDER
Heard Sri A. Sudershan Reddy, the learned Senior designate counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioner, the learned Deputy Solicitor General of India appearing on behalf of respondent No.1 and Smt. Anjali Agarwal appearing on behalf of respondent Nos.2 and 3.
2. The petitloner aDproached the Court seelinq D!'aver as under:
".........to pass an order, direction or Writ particularly one in the nature of WRIT OF MANDAMUS declaring the action of the Respondent Nos 1 to 3 in depriving and denying the Petitioner's Constitutional rights by withholding the amounts due and payable to the Petitioner inspite of approval of Chief Engineer/Competent Authority i.€., respondent No.2 and also as recommended by pre- arbitration committee in relation to claims 2 and 4 in respect of completed works under agreement
No.46ICAO/C/SC/2010, dated 15-09-2010 as arbitrary, illegal and u nconstitutio na I and consequently direct the Respondents to release the Petitioner's amounts forthwith and pass such other order or orders......."
CORD:
*l
t
3 PERUSED THE RE
4
A)
The aD
roval dated 30.o3.2
11 c,f
the C hief Eno inee r /Com
etent Auth orl 1.e
es
,:)nde
nt p
No.2, in favour of thePetitioner. reads as u nder:
Approval of Chief Admn. Officel,( on/SC is hereby communicated for the variation to a net ; ncl grcss value of Rs.12 44,85,096.85Ps. Variation stat,nrent is sent herewith, in duplicate, alongwith r-.:e analysis for verif ic ation and early return.
Ihe subject work was awarded to trl/s.
Co. Ba rgalore at an agreement value of t s. g Ps.
)y.CEIC/GTL has submitted First I'i -iation vide letter dated 1B-03-20 11(P- 178)
)y. CElC has mentioned in the l:)tter that during execu'.ion it is necessitated to operate < ne: additional NS item cxtra over item No.1 & 2 of Schelriule-A for cutting rock ilnd scooping out the debris outs ije the area to enable to complete the box pushing. Accordingly the variation statement is submitted duly prr oosinq additional NS iten for extra over for box pushing hr -d rock strata for a qualtity ot 2.875 Sqm per RM with a ra.e of 11s.14,325/- amourting to Rs.4,11,84,375l- which r,,rr rks out to gross excess of 49.12o/o over the agreement verl te. As per the details of rate for additional \l; tem submitted by Dy.CEl.C,
Rate f >r R M-Rs.6,73,000(Agt.No. 1 1/Dy.( :E/CNIMAS/2009, dared 16.04.2009)
Box si;:e 5.50 x 3.66m=20.13 Sqm per RI\
Rate frrr Sq m per R M=6,73,000/20.13-.. j,432.69 Rate for Sq.m per R M for item No.1 & 2
Of Schedule-A of the same Agt. ==
Differe nce in Rate
125 Sq,m per R M However, CAO/C has approved th s proposal for a quanti :y 3840 Sqm pr RM with a rate of R:;t0,62:4/- vide N- B, Therefore the details for additional I\l: item will be as below:
S.K.Swamy &
36,88,936.85
9,t07 .
73
4,324.9
5or Say Rs.14,
5
sl No Description ofitem
Qtv RateUnit Amount in Rs Remarks
1 Extra over item No.1&2 of Schedule- A for cutting rock by
approved
methods
suchas
chemical d isintegratio n of rock by any other
a pproved
method and l scoopinq out the debris out side the area with all contractors materials, la bou r,
tools,pla nt and
machinery all lead lift and lift ect., completeas directed by the
Eng ineer- in- Charqe
3840 10,624.00 Sq.m.per R. tvl
4,O7,96,160.00
While executingof thrustbed, the front face ofbox
pushing encou ntered with full of rock which cannotbe
removed by ordinary blasting under the tra ffic Financial implications :
Original Agt.Value Rs.8,36,88,936.85 Value of one addl.N.S.item Rs.4,07,96,160.00 Net & Gross value Rs.12,44,85,096.85 Net & Gross excess and
percentage Rs.4,07,96,160.00 (i.e.48.75olo) Negotiations required for
one addl NS item Rs.4,07,96,160.00 Dy.CElC has certified that there is no vitiation due to variation/ since no savings occurred vide letter date 18.03.2011 (F-178).
6
Administrative approval of CE/C i required to the First variation in terms of item no.9 of pa-t A of SOp 2009, toprc cess further with Finance for con<:L rr3nce. Since the overa I excess is exceeded beyond 25o, lf agt.value, it shall be brought to the notice of C,At)/C in terms of CAO/()'s circular No.20109, dated 07.12.0:)
B)
The reco mmendati
ons of the P re-Arbitration Committee dated O9.O1.2O14 an relation tC. C aims 2 a
d4 in resDect of comol
d work u ler ao ree
ent No.4
/cAo/cts c/ 2010.
dated 5.09 Details leading to Recommendation l; Earth work excavation
- from grou td level to bed/top level of the thrust b ild earthwork (i.e.) excluding earthwork t,rr thrust bed done
a. Earth work in All Soils (AS) 815.:r;,2 M3 ;< 1O1 x
(-1tr) = Rs.74,153.67
b. RNRB 562.490 m3 x144 x (-1O) = t 5. 72$98.7O
c. Hard Rock =5513.193 M3 x 187 x(-11) =Rs 9,27,870.38 Total (a+b+cr= Rs.7),74,922.75
The Quantity of earthwork has been certiti :,d by A (EN/GTL vide letter dt 26.L2.L3 is as p :r the site records and measurement bor <. Rate; adopted are with -10o/o taken frc n Schedule B of this agreement.
Pending settlement and payment of a rate for Additional item of work i. r:. specialized technique Box pushing in Hard Rock by etc. Quantity 3,840 x Rs.LO,624,07 per Sqm/RM
-lO1Q. read as
u nder
Amount
recommended
in Rs.
Arnount claimed
R:;.26,48,43O/-
Arnount
recom mended
Rs,.
7Ct.74.922.75/ -
Amount claimed
Rs.4,O7,96,429
Amou nt
rer:ommended
Claim
No.
2
4
Rs. 4
o7 96
160
7
The Claimant has claimed a sum of Rs.4,O7,96,429l- for this item. The main contention of the Claimant is that there exists no scooping activity, no specialized methodology of working like chemical disintegration like chiseling/chipping, etc., for working under hard rock conditions, as well as the rates quoted by the Contractor does not cater to these type of working. The Pre Arbitratlon Committee, spent the maximum time on this claim. Based on all the records placed before the Pre Arbitration Committee, both by the Contractor and AXEN/GTL (Department), and as per the conditions of agreement/site this claim is justified. The amount claimed is based on approved variation by the Chief Engineer and Chief Admlnlstrative Officer. The rate for additional NS item with Rs. LO,624.O7 per Sq M/RM for box pushing in hard rock strata has been worked out after detailed analysis and has administrative approval of CAO DI.16.03.11 and has been accepted by the agency who previously demanded Rs.41,034 per Sq M/RM. The actual quantity of work done using additional NS has been worked out by the AXEN(who was in charge durlng the execution of this work) vide letter dt.26.12.13.
3840 Sq M/RM x L0,624= Rs.4,07,96,160.
c) The I eoAI oolnlo n
dated 27.OL.20L4. No.W.Con.29 I A1267
/LAW lLO.4, reads as rrnrjer:
Tt e recommendations of thr: pr€-arbitration Comrrittee dated 09.01.2014 have been ,:xamined. Out of the 1( claims submitted to the Pre-arbit:r rtion Committee, the C )mmittee made recommendation:; irr respect of 7 claims of the 7 recom mendations, the Committee recom nended nil amount with respect trt cl,aims 1,5,7 and 9, whi e recommended accruals to be arr vr:d and paid by respordent with reference to claim n9.1 r, ie payment of final bill, PVC, SD & PG. So far as clair rs No.2 & 4 are concerned, Rs.tO,74,922/- recommenclr J ins,tead of a claim rf 726,48,430/- towards claim no . i,e., earth work excav; tion-from ground level to bed/top lr vr:l ol' thrust bed and R:r.4,07,96,t6O/- towards claim no.,i .er payment of a rate fcr additional item of work.
Iin the instant ase, there was nt)
dispute as to the ooera
tion of th e additinn
al workq
u
n
laims 2 & 4, and the same has oot completed b'f-!lr3_aggn_Sy. Sectio
n 70 ol the Contract
Act, 1872 st!p_u.la!cs_!ha! where a
D erson lawfullv d oes anvthi rc I for another person for a sum, and such other pe_! sc)n ento vs the benefit
thereof, the latter
is bor rnrd
to make com en
e former in
t of. After due i:
neootiat
ions, the Chief Enqineer fixed th e rate for the additional NS items which is bind n(
both the parties in
terms of C1.39 of GCC. The
! aimant cannot demand m ore than what has been fix: :d_by the Chief Engtneer. So far
=as
claim n _ is_-_qqn-eeInell
8
9
Committee recommended, the rate as per Schedule- R nf tha ,rrroarnant Tha rarnmmend:tinnc nf the Pre-arbitration Committee are based on the approved variations in terms of C1.39 and 43 of GCC and aqreement. Since the Pre-arbitration Committee recommended what has alreadv been accepted in terms of GCC towards claim4
under terms of aqreement at scheduled rates towards claim no.2. and as accrued towards claim no. 10. it is ooined that there are no leqal qrounds to interfere with the same.
D) Para Nos.17 and 18 of the counter affidavit filed on behalf of ResDondent Nos.1 to 3, read as follows :
17. In reply to para 17 of the affidavit, it has been stated that the present writ is being limited to the recommended claims of 2 and 4 in the orders passed by thepre arbitration committee dated 09.01.2014. But in this regard it is to inform that as per sub-clause no.1.2 of Special Conditions of the agreement, the agency should seek reference to arbitration to settle the disputes ONLY ONCE, subject to the condition mentioned below. The condition of the agreement is reproduced hereunder for immediate reference;
"The provisions of clause 63 and 64 of the General Conditions of contract will be applicable only for settlement of cla ims/disputes, for values less than or equal to 20o/o of
10
the o -iginal value (excluding the cost 01= .naterials supplied free ry Railways) of the contract or 2i)o,6 of the actual value of the work done (excluding the,a ue of the work rejected) under the contract, whichev rr is less. When cla im:;/d isputes are of value more than .2 ,oh of the value of the original contract or 2Oo/o of the valu<: )f the actual work done under the contract, whichever is le ;s, the contractor will r ot be entitled to seek such (lii;putes;/claims for reference to arbitration and the provisior, crf clause 63 and 64 o'' the General Conditions of cont -act will not be applicable for referring the disputes to t _. settrled through a rbitr,:tion. As su ch it is furt her to -inl 'orm that the men
value of the work ts Rs,8
J6.88,935.8s and
the
value of
actua! w r>rk done is Rs.9,l2 .o5.536.34
and val
eof _. actual claims subm itted
bv the aqencv
for cla im N
2&4 i
7.39.1
9/- and the o resent cl armt rs mo
e than 20o/o of ao
reement value.
18.
In reolv to o ara 18 of t e affi rtavit, as stated ea rlie r
the re commendations
of the Pre-arbi
tration committee a
itself null and
void rrrd the claims made
bv the Peti tioner come
under
tl te
urvlew
of EXCCpted Matters as per s lr:rct conditions and sDE
ifications no
.3.O & 9 .Or d w
ith its sub cla uses nd as such the same is b I/Ond Arbitrable tssue
or domain of Civil Courts. m
Rs.4.:l
11
4, The case of the Detitioner, in brief, as per the averments made bv the oetitioner in
t he affidavit filed bv the petitioner in support of the present writ petition, is as u nder:
i) It is the specific case of the Petitioner that the Petitioner is a reputed civil contractor in the field of clvil works for decades and in response to tender published by the 1't Respondent for execution of civil work (deposit work), the Petitioner submitted his tender and the Petitioner became a successful bidder and the contract was awarded by the 2nd Respondent to the Petitioner vide letter dated 04.06.2010 and consequently Petitioner and Respondent entered into an Agreement dated 15.09.2010 bearing No.46/CAO/C/SC|2O|O. It is further the case of the Petitioner that the Petitioner did additional/extra item of work which is not contemplated in the tender and the Petltioner had to do box pushing in rocky area. Petitioner vide letter dated 74.12.20L0 and 15.12.2010 requested for payment in accordance to special conditions of contract No.9.0 and its sub- clauses. In pursuance to the correspondence between the Petitioner and Respondents for settlement of the payments for the extra work executed by the Petitioner i n the oroiect in he 2"d ResDondent had intimatouestion, t d constitution
72
of a Pre-Arbitration Committee to the pS titiel r thro
qhe letter date L7.1 o1 ii)
Itisf rth he
eof EP to n,lr
hat the Pre-t Arbit ration Com
mit tee had qrven
its re rc< llnrloclldallgns th rouqh ir
detaile d orde r dat ed 09
.Dl.2 4 nd rec omme
ded in
favou
of th e Petit
onel v dlI-resaId_to the claims 2 and 4. In so far as claim NJ,.2 is
ernedconc the Peti t ioner' clai mha db :du n
_r€ ced f om Rs.26
,48.4 3O,/- to Rs.1O,74,922.75 and iD sr)fa ras claim No.4 ts
concerned
the Co mmitte ha 5 acceoted and recom men@ cleimed_by_lhe Petitio ner
l.e., ns.+,O2,gO !)nU!LrttCC__n!i!-dC acl ar reco menda
ion with reoard o the 4'th clai
or an amount of Rs
4,O7.96 ,L60 / -
and th Peti
on er ma dea ti demand vide letter dated O4.11.2O14 fot: the release of the said amounts as oer the recommenda!ior
ls
f the Pre- Arbitratio n
Committee dated 09.01
.2014.
iii) It is frrrther the case of the petitioner r.l at the petitioner secured the legal opinion given by the Law Offir:r unler the RTI Act, dated 0t.08.2014 wherein it has been clea ty ob:;erved that in view of th,: fact that the petitioner executed 2 arlditronal works
with the approval of the concerned C.E., and the rates and variations have been accepted and approved by the C.E. and C.A.O., in conformity with the provisions of GCC the Petitioner had to be paid for the additional works executed
iv) It is further the case of the Petitioner that the Competent Authority had approved for the variation to a net and gross value of Rs.I2,44,85,096.85 paisa and the said details are evidenced in the material documents dated 2l.O3.2oll and 30.03.2011 filed by the petitioner in support of the present writ petition.
v) In spite of repeated requests made by the Petitioner the Respondents No.1 to 3 deprived and denied the Petitioner's constitutional rights by withholding the amounts due and payable to the Petitioner, in spite of the approval of the Chief Engineer/Competent Authority Respondent No.2 dated 30.03.2011 vide Proceedings No.W.Con.14B/A/CfL/Box push/3936, for which the Petitioner addressed representation dated 04.I1.2014 to the General Manager, South Central Railway, Rail Niyalam, Secunderabad, and requested for arrangement and payment towards/additiona I item of work done relating to box pushing in hard rock and thereafter no action has e
13
14
been initiat.-'d. Aggrieved by the same, the prr se,nt,,A/rit petition has been fil:d by the petitioner.
5. Para No s.7& of the reolv
ffid3 uit filed bv the Petition er, ead a
nder :
In re tly to para 7, I submit that t:l : GAD (General arran(lement drawings) relating to tht-. sr.rbject contract work does not reflect the actuat site c:onditions, and preserce of hard rock beneath the Carth. It is also pertin,lnt to mention that sometime:; t1e actual site condit ons would change from GAD ancl in such circun stances the work shall be treated,rs adrlitional/new work irnd a separate rate has to be arrivld at and shall be paid, ,rs per C|.9.1 & 9.2 of Special Cond t ons of Contract. a)I sub
it that the claim in
the ,vrit oe tition is re
latino to
additional/new ite
sw h jclr__qreppCd__Up durinq the cours e of execut
on of_ rvrlrk orro r n allv mentioned in
the sched
ules of the Aqreemen t dt.
120
O, and t
e same ere _..1:rrlruoht to the notic
of the Reso ondents.
which '/VClfe
admitted, enouir ed, ascertai ned the r ates from othCr_fCS!enS. neo ot i ated, aoorov ed bv the mDel errt authorities (Chief En rneer and Chi ef Adminisl:rative O
lcer, whose aooroval/orders is fin
I and trrndinq on both a rties h A en
er
-l cflLe_Sreela! Condi tions of Con tract annexed to th SA
qreem
ent dt. 1 5 / 10 / 20 10 ), and a variation statetr tertlC!e!!!g_!e the a ddition allnew items
of work. - whtqh__arc_lhc
15
claims in the oresent writ Detition wasdrafted and m n rnv ln he said variation state
was aoreed / acceoted I aooroved bv both the Darties i.e., the Petitioner and t he Resoondent-
b) I submit that it is the discretion of the Respondents whether to entrust the additional/new work to the petitioner or to any third party contractor as per C1.9.1 of the Special Conditions oF Contract. The claims in the writ petition are for additional/new items of work, which were notified to the Respondents, during the progress of the original agreement works, and that had it beennot additional/new items of work, the Respondents ought to have taken steps at that point oF time itself, but the Respondents did not do so, they also satisfied that they are additional/new items oF works, and rates are to be arrived at, and accordingly they have ascertained the samefrom Southern Railways, Chennai, for such work (Box pushing in hard rock with specialised skill/experience) as the South Central Railways had not dealt with similar work in similar site conditions. Unless the additional/new items of work in the writ petition are entrusted, the Petitioner cannot proceed to execute the original items of works of the original agreement dt.Ls/LO/2010, therefore the Respondents entrusted the works claimed in the writ petition.
c) I submit that it is incorrect to state on the part of the Respondents that the claim of the Petitioner is malafide,
16
claiming extra money and is not tenable and the same is denie,l.
8. fn reolv to para 8, the schedule -grf ks ca rried bvt he Petiti
ner ts n o t in all kind
f soil, it is inso hard rock,
therefore
itisana dditiolral
ewt
f work,
which was aDDrove
d/entrr rs!ed---Ey__lhe , ll'he additional lne items
of works v, e re exolicitlv neqotiated and entrusted to the peti:io ,ne r,
and now th e R.esDon dents ca nnot turn arou n rl
End-say-lhat thev are
of aoree a ble for o avmen
here is no com
etent
authoritv to the Peti ronel t. T
delav on he oart o f the Pet itioner ce-nl_reeto!:_lhC dela v occur
donth oa rt of
the llesoond
ents in ta kino dec
lslons. asc
the ri rtc)s.
entrustino erta i n ino decision s and a
D
rovals
from the
work to
the Pet
itioner. avrng l:aken all the J.1o competent
tnautho rl
the R
onden
esto)er
om sa reeable for thr r:laims of the Petitioner. Such a denial
is contrarv to the i
terna I correspondence of the Respondents_.dt ',.L3t06
/2OLL (Ann exure-18) o
tained und er RTI.
5. DIS sSION AND
oNcLUSION:
A. A bare perusal of material on record < e,arly indicates that the c;laim of the Petitioner is ap:rn)ved by the competent authority vide notings and final atrproval dated 30.03.2011 which the petitioner had obtain,ed under the that thev
are not ao r
77
RTI Act and the same had been filed by the petitioner as material document in support of the affidavit filed by the Petitioner in the present writ petition.
B. A bare perusal of the report of the Pre-Arbitration Committee dated 09.01.2014 (referred to and extracted above) very clearly indicates that the Pre-Arbitration Committeemade specific observations in favour of the Petitioner and recommended for payment with regard to claims 2 and 4, though the claim of No.2 of the Petitioner had been reducedfrom Rs.26,48,43O/-, the Committee however, accepted and recommended for payment of full claim with regard to the 4th claim of the Petitioner for an amount of Rs.4,07,96,160/-. It is relevant to note here that i
is the 2nd Resoondent who had in fact intimated con stitution of the said Pre- Arbitration Committee to the P etitioner throuqh his letter d 17.10.2013 and there avrn
initiated and qreed for Pre-Arbitration ca
not turn back and state in t e counter affidavit at
D ar a
os. L7 and 18 th at th recom menda
ns of the Pre-Art o
bitration Comm
ittee itself a ren u
ll and void.
C, A bare perusal of the record also ind cates that it is an admitted fact as borne on record tha.. the petitioner completed the work and the same is evidr:nced from the letter dated 17.01.2013 of Deputy Chief Er.gineer (Const) SC Railway. A bare perusat of the correspondence dated 30.03.201, secured by the petitioner undr:r the RTI Act, clearly inclicates that there is an ap i:roval of the competent authority for the amounts payatrle for the extra work done by the Petitioner with regard to claims 2 and 4. A bare perusa! of legal opinion dated 27.,:r1.2O14 clearly indicates a n observation in favour of thr: prrtitioner that since the Pre-Arbitration Commiftee recor.trnended what has already been accepted in terms of GC( towards claim No.4 under terms of agreement at sr:hr:duled rates towards claim No.2, the Respondents r:trn not interfere with the same since there are no leg,rl grounds to interfere.
D. This Court opines that the pleas put-forth by the Iearned counsel appearing on behalf of Rer;prrndents No.1 to 3 that the present writ petition is not rraintainable, is not tenable in view of the facts being ar: nritted by the
18
19
Respondent Authority as borne on record which is evident on perusal of the following documents :
i) L etter dated L7.O1.2OL3 of the Deoutv Chief Enoineer (Const )
SC Railwa which is a work comoletion certificate, certifvina that t
e Petitioner had comoleted the work in all aspects.
ii) Letter dated 3O.O3.2011
secured bv the ner under the RTI A n same indicates that the 1't R esDondent acceoted the value of the extra work throuo h a corresoondence dated 30.o3.2011.
The 2nd Res on n h
ti of Pre-Arbitration Committee to the Petitioner throuoh letter dated 17.10.2013.
iv) The re
ommendations of the Pre-Arbitration Com mittee dated O9.O1.2O1
4 in favour of the P etationer.
v) The
Leqal Ooinion
dated 27.OL.ZOL4
and os.o8.2OL4. with obs ervati ons in favour of the P etitioner. rri \
The
val d d ?nn
3.2 n 11
aJ
th com
nt a utho rltv in favour of the Pe titioner. answ
the
lea he Res
ondf o.1 t e marn
r
ilit
n
tition hioft ent wri
20
urt o tn
hat th r
nt writ e
s maintainable iudqments referred
to and extracted below.
7. The D
ivision Benc
h of the Ao
x Cou r, 11 a iudoment date d 20.04.2 re o
202t )c
77L in M/s. Radha
rishnan Indu rres
Vs. Sta
of Hinrar :hal Pradesh, referred to Whirloool Cor oration Vs. Ret
listrar of Trade Marks (re
orted in (1998)
8 SCC 1) and
Itrrther the said view had been
reiterated bv a Full Benc h of the ADex Court
3 Judoes) in
a iudoment r eDorted it (2O2L ) scc Online SC paqe 8O1 in Maoadh
Suqar and Errerqv Limited Vs. State f Bihar and Others d ated 24.O9
.:lo 2L
in the said iudoment it is
observed as under :
28. The principles of law which emerge are that:
(i) Ibe oower under Arti !rc
Constitution to tssue
ts can be exercised r. ot onlv for the enforcement o f fundamental r, d
but for anv bi9 other DurD e as well;
(ii) The High Court has the discretion n t to entertain a writ petition. One of the restrictiorl' ,olaced on the pawer of the High Court is where an e 'fe'ctiv,e alternate renedy is available to the aggrieved L )rson:
in the liqht of the observations of the ABi'xl9u_I!_jL!hC
2t
(iii) Exceptions to the rule of alternate remedv arise where (a) the writ oetition has been filed for the enforcement of a fundamentalri'oht Drotected bv Part lff of the Constitution; (b) there has been a violation of the principles of natural justice; (c) the order or proceedings are wholly without jurisdiction; or
(d) the vires of a legislation is challenged;
(iv) An alternate remedy by itself does not divest the High Court of its powers under Article 226 of the Constitution in an appropriate case though ordinarily, a writ petition should not be entertained when an efficacious alternate remedy is provided by law;
(v) When a right is created by a statute, which itself prescribes the remedy or procedure for enforcing the right or liability, resoft must be had to that particular statutory remedy before invoking the discretionary remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution. This rule of exhaustion of statutory remedies is a rule of policy, convenience and discretion; and
(vii) In cases where there are disputed questions of fact, the High Court may decide to decline jurisdiction in a writ petition. Ho wever. if the ll itt
hc is ob
1 ectivel of the
, lt
tha l- tha nature of t e cgotroversv reguires
the exercise n
readilv be interfered with."
avi wou
21
))
rhjEj:ourt opines that t te-ple_Se_n!_lase and the
rial on
rd cle rl
di,:ates tha t the oresent case falls under Clause (i). iii (a).i.nd_lyI-L L The Divisi
n Bench
of ADex C ou rt i1r l:he
iudoment dated O2.O3.2023 re Dorted in 2023 SCC Orrline SC 214 in o
Hornbill Co nsu !ta nt Vs. State of Pu niab &
(tthErs-a!_Pala_g bserved as u nder :
Para B : It is, no doubt, correct tfta : in contractual matters, the High Courts do not Iike to ex,,rcise jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of Ir Jia, even though this p,vr,1rsr- is plenary in nature and n r limited by any provision of the Constitution of India; a: norntally, when disputed questions of fact arise, adjudicati:rn in i: civil court is more appropriate, just and fair. Nevel.threless, this is not an absolute rule: mor esorn :ts es when the ord ers oassed bv
the oover
ment iruthoriti
es are rv. un lr or unreason ble and ,vtrere the facts are not in
disoute and are
easilv as<
ertaineE!-e.__! lc are, in vi ew of the laose of time, incliI.EC llow th apoeal in order to prevent anv fu1:hr lr rou
nds of litio ation between the Da
ies wherr
fac
son rthe record are crvstal clear and
do not rer 1u ire a detailed revl ew. The asDe ct of arbitrarv and :rrr
cco uct on the oart of the resoondents has !,ee and elucidated eartier"
!n dd ressed
22
9. The Division ADex Court in the iudoment dated I7.O2.2O2L reoorted in 2021 (2) ALT(SC) 149 in Civil Aooeal No.317 of 2O2L in Unitech Ltd.. & Others Vs. Telanqana State Industrial Infrastructure Corooration (TSIIC) & Others. at oara Nos. 32 and 33 observed as under
32. Much of the ground which was sought to be canvassed in the course of the pleadings is now subsumed in the submissions which have been urged before this Court on behalf of the State of Telangana and TSIIC. As we have noted earlier, during the course of the hearing, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the State of Telangana and TSIIC informed the Court thatthe entitlement of Unitech to seek a refund is not questioned nor is the availability of the land for carrying out the project being placed in issue. Learned Senior Counsel also did not agitate the ground that a remedy for the recovery of moneys arising out a contractual matter cannot be availed of under Article 226 of the Constitution. However, to clear the ground, it is necessarv to postulate that recourse to the iurisdictio
n under Article 226 of the Constitution is not excluded altoqether in a ntractualm
tter.A
ublic law remed ts V il leo ofor enforci no
al ri hts subiect to well-settled Darameters
33. A two judge Bench of this Court in ABL International Ltd. v. Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India IABL
23
24
Internationall analyzed a tong line of 1 recedent of this Court to conclude that writs under Articlt: 226 are maintirinable for asserting contractual r lhts against the state, or its instru menta lities, as defined u.rder Article 12 of the Indian Constitution. Speaking 1:l rougl- Justice N Santos;h Hegde, the Court held:
"27. ...the following legal principle:; )nterqe as to the rnaintainability of a writ petition:
,a) In an appropriate case, a writ p:rtition as against rr State or an instrumentality of a Sjl ;t,: arising out of it contractual obligation is maintaina:rler. rb) Merely because some disputecl tuestlons of fact ;rrise for consideration, same cannc. be er ground to |efuse to entertain a writ petition r all cases as a rnatter of rule.
(c) A writ petition involving a cons;(rquentiaI relief of rnonetary claim is also maintainablt: '
This e(position has been followed by fl-i, Oourt, and has been adopted by three judge Bench decis tns or this Court in Stale of UP v. Sudhir Kumar and po1:atrao Vynkatrao Patil /. State of Maharashtra. The er:isicrn in ABL Intern.ltional, cautions that the plenary po\v€rr under Article 226 rlust be used with circumspect on when other remed es have been provided by the cc,ttract. But as a staten ent of principle, the jurisdiction un er- Article 226 is not exr:luded in contractual matters.
Article 23.1 of the Development Agreeme rt in the present case rnandates the parties to resolve .:heir disputes throug I an arbitration. However, the tr=sence of an arbitrar:ion clause within a contract b,rtlveen a state instrunrentality and a private party has lot a(:ted as an absoluie bar to availing remedies under F.ti:le 226. If the
25
state instrumentality violates its constitutional mandate under Article 14 to act fairly and reasonably, rellef under the plenary powers of the Afticle 226 of the Constitution would lie. This principle was recognized in ABL International:
"28. However, while entertaining an objection asto the maintainability of a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the court should bear in mind the fact that the power to issue prerogative writs under Article 226 of the Constitution is plenary in nature and is not limited by any other provisions oF the Constitution. TheHigh Court having regard to the facts of the case, has a discretion to entertain or not to entertain a writ petition. The Court has imposed upon itself certain restrictions in the exercise of this power. (See Whirlpool Corpn. v. Registrar of Trade Marks [(1998) B SCC 1l .) And this plenary right of the High Court to issue a prerogative writ will not normally be exercised by the Court to the exclusion of other available remedies unless such action of the State or its instrumentality is arbitrary and unreasonableso as to violate the constitutional mandate of Article 14 or for other valid and legitimate reasons, for which the Court thinks it necessary to exercise the said jurisdiction." (emphasis supplied).
Therefore, while exercising its jurisdiction under Article 226, lhe Court is entitled to enquire into whether the action of the State or its instrumentalities is arbitrary or unfair and in consequence, in violation of Article 14. The jurisdiction under Article 226 is a valuable constitutional safeguard against an arbitrary exercise of state power or a misuse of authority. In determining as to whether the jurisdiction should be exercised in a contractual dispute, the Court must, undoubtedly eschew, disputed questions of fact which would depend upon an evidentiary
26
deterrnination requiring a trial. But eq] ralllv
itisw ell- settled that the iurisdiction under AItic !e
226 cannot be ouste d onlv on the basis
that
he :lis;o
te Dertatns to thec ontract ual are na. Th
is is
For the sim e reason
that t e Sta te and
its instn m
taliti are xemDt
from
the dut vto ac fa irlv merelv because in their business dealinqs ill: rv hav eentered into the realm of contract. Similarlv., t:he presence of an ar ra cla
st th u lis;d i ction u
der oe Arti 22
all es u h
s':ill eeds be froecr
se
tow t tlctr recours eto a oub lic law rem edv can IUstifia
vl
le nvoked. The jurisdirtion under Article 226 was righUr irvoked by the Single Judge and the Division Bench of Ur , Andhra pradesh in this case, when the foundational repr,sentation of the contra:t has failed. TSIIC, a state instrunrentality, has not just reneged on its contractual obligation, b,lt hoarded the refund of the principal and interest on 1re consideration that was paid by Unitech over a decader :go. ,tt does not dispute the entitlement of Unitech to t re refund of its p rin cip al.
10. The Apex Court in the judgement da.:erl 14.0g.2O1S reported in (2O15) 9 SCC 433 in State of tr erala & Others Vs. M.K. Jose at Para Nos. 16 and 17 observr:dl as follows :
16. Hitving referred to the aforesaid Je:cisions, it is obligat,rry on our part to refer to two otf tr authorities of this Court where it has been opined t.ra: under what circum:;tances a disputed question of fa;t can be gone
27
into. In Gunwant Kaur v. Municipal Committee, Bhatinda,it has been held thus:-
"14. The High Court observed that they will not determine disputed question of fact in a writ petition. But what facts were in dispute and what were admitted could only be determined after an affidavit- in-reply was filed by the State. The High Court, however, proceeded to dismiss the petition in limine. The High Court is not deprived of its jurisdiction to entertain a petition under Article 226 merely because in considering the petitioner's right to relief questions of fact may fall to be determined. In a petition under Article 226 the High Court has jurisdiction to try issues both of fact and law. Exercise ofthe jurisdiction is, it is true, discretionary, but the discretion must be exercised on sound judicial principles. When the petition raises questions of fact of a complex nature, which may for their determination require oral evidence to be taken, and on that account the High Court is of the view that the dispute may not appropriately be tried in awrit petition, the High Court may decline to try a petition. Rejection of a petition in limine will normally be justified, where the High Court is of the view that the petition is frivolous or because of the nature of the claim made dispute sought to be agitated, or that the petition against the party against whom relief is claimed is not maintainable or that the dispute raised thereby is such that it would be inappropriate to try it in the writ jurisdiction, or for analogous reasons.
15. From the averments made in the petition filed by the appellants it is clear that in proof of a large number of allegations the appellants relied upon documentary evidence and the only matter in respect of which conflict of facts may possibly arise related to the due publication of the notification under Section 4 by the Collector.
16. In the present case, in our judgment, the High Court was not justified in dismissing the
28
petition on the ground that it will not determine clisputed question of fact. The .lirlh Court has jurisdiction to determine questions of fact. even if they are in dispute and the :rrrssent, in our judgment, is a case ln
which in :h
terests of both th
oarties the H
iqh Cour'
t should have entertai ned the Detit ion and
d for n affidavit-
in-reolv from
the res po,ndents, and should
ave oroceed
to tr the etition in stead
of releoatino
the aDpc{ler!slq___a Separate suit." IEmphasis addeq-l
L7.
n ABL International Ltd. v.
xDort Cr,3clit Gu ra ntee Coron.
of India Ltd., a two-Judqe Bench afler referrr n to varro
s iuclqments
as well as
e Dronotrnce ment in Gunw n
ur (suor a) and Centurv S Dq. And Mfo. C o. Ltd.
v. Ulhasnaqar Municioal Co uncil, has held tt u!;:-
"19. Tlrerefore, it is clear from the abovr: enunciation ot law that merely because one of the partier; t,r the litigation raises ,r dispute in regard to the facts of thr: r:ase, the court enterta ining such petition under Artie L_225 ot the Constitution is not always bound to relege:e th€: parties to a suit. In the above case of Gunwant Kau tlris ,3ourt even went t() the extent of holding that in a rarr t petition, if the facts require, even oral evidence can :e taken. This rl show h
a ro rl
case, the writ as the iurisdiction to e ntertain a writ etition no diso uted ouestions
of fac t anrl there is no a bsol ute
bar for ente rtaininq a writ r lel:ition even if the same arises
out of a contracl uaI
oblioation and/o,r involves some
disputed ouesti(inr;. of fact.
27. Frc m the above discussion of ours, tl^ : Following legal principrs5 emerge as to the maintaina:ril ty of a writ petitior :
(a) in an appropriate case, a writ petiri :rn as against a Stater>r an instrumentality of a State , r-isinq out of a contra( tual obligation is maintainable.
29
(b) Merely because some disputed questions of fact arise for consideration, same cannot be a ground to refuse to entertain a writ petition in all cases as a matter of rule.
(c) A writ petition involving a consequential relief of monetary claim is also maintainable.
While laying down the principle, the Court sounded a word of caution as u nder:-
28. "However, while enteftaining an objection as to the maintainability of a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the court should bear in mind the fact that the power to issue prerogative writs under Article 226 of the Constitution is plenary in nature and is not limited by any other provisions of the Constitution.The High Court having regard to the facts of the case, has a discretion to entertain or not to entertain a writ petition. The Court has imposed upon itself certain restrictions in the exercise of this power. ( See Whirlpool Corpn.v Req istrar of Trade Marks
[11].) And this olenarv riqht of the Hiqh Court to issue a Dreroqative writ will not normally be exercised bv the Court to the exclusion of other available remedies unless such action of the State or its instrumentalitv is arbitrarv and unreasonable so as to violate the constitutional mandate of Article L4 or for other valid and leoitimate reasons. for
hich the Court thinks it necessary to exercise the said iurisdiction",
11. Takinq into consideratio
the entire material on record. referred to at sub oara D of oar a No.3 of the present iudqment, this Court oDines that the oleas out- forth bv
the Resoondent Nos,1 to 3 in the c
unter affidavit are untenable
and hence reiected. This Co rt opines that ts relied upon bv the lethe iudoemen
rned counsel
30
AD
ea rinq on
ehal
of s on n
os,z lnd
3. do cts o
the rese nt case. L2. kin rn
on
era n not
i) Section 7O of the Contract Act, 1g72 vvhich clearly stipulates that where a person lawfully dor:s anything for another person for a sum, and such other prtrson enjoys the benefit thereof, the latter is bo| nd to make compensation to the former in respect there of,
ii) The aforesaid facts and circumstances r>f the case,
iii) Duly cclnsidering the entire materiat o,r record which is clearly in favour of the petitioner as discur;sed at para-D of the present judgment i.e:-
tter dated L7 .01.201 3 of the D,e
utv C
ief Enqine, er Const. ) sc Railwav whic [r i a work completion certificate, certifvino that_ thelslitigner ole ted the wi) in al! as
ects.
b) Letter
dated 3 o.o 3.2011 secr r rr:d bv the Petitioner under the RTI Act and a b
:rr(l DErus al of the same i
dicates
that th e 1"t Re DOn rlernt acce d the v alue of the extra
work tecorrespdeno 3.2 1 th rouqha
31
c) The 2nd Resoondent had intimated constitution of Pre-Arbitration Committee to the Petitioner throuoh letter d ted 17.1O.2O13.
d) The recommendations of the
Pre-Arbitration 9.OL.20L4inth Petitio ner.
e) The Leoal Ooinion dated 27-O1,.2()14 and 05.08.2014, with observations in favour of the Petitioner,
f) The aDDrovaldad 3O.O3.2O11 of the comDetent authoritvinfavour of the Petitioner.
iv) The view and the observations of the Apex Courtin following judgments (referred to and extracted above),
a) Unitech Ltd., & Others Vs. Telangana State Industrial Infrastructure Corporation (TSIIC) & Others, reported in 2021 (2) ALT (SC) 149 in Civil Appeal No.317 of 2O2L, dated 17.02.2O2L.
b) State of Kerala & Others Vs. M.K. Jose reported in (2015) 9 SCC 433, dated 14.O8.2015.
c) M/s. Radhakrishnan Industries Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh reported in (2021) 6 s,CC 77L, dated 2O.O4.2O2L,
32
d) l'lgrnbill Consultant Vs. State of Etrn & Others re
2023 SCC Onlin L4
dated o2.o3,2023
v) The a\rerments made in the counter a Ffidavit filed on behalf of the Respondent Nos.1 to 3,
vi) Duly considering the submissions nrade by a!! the learned counsel on record,
The Writ Petition is allowed and tl'rer Respondent Nos.1 to 3 are directed to consider the relrresentation of the Petitioner dated O4.LL.2O[4 for I elease of the Petitioner's amounts due and payable to tl're Petitioner as recommended by the Pre-Arbitration Con mittee vide its recommenrlations dated O9.O1.2014 in relal:ion to Claims 2 and 4 in nespect of completed work un Jr:r agreement No.46lCAO/ClSCl2OlO, dated 15.O9.2O1O as; approved by the competent authority i.e., the 2"d Reslro ndent herein vide approval dated 30.03.2011 within a period of four
(04) weeks from the date of receipt of I re: copy of the order in accordance to law, in conformity with principles of natural justice by providing a reasonabl.: c,pportunity of personal hearing to the petitioner and drrl / communicate the decision on petitioner's represe 'rtittion, dated
O4,L1.2O24 to the petitioner. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
Miscellaneous petitio
Petition, shall stand closed.
i One fair copy to the
o
1. The Chief Admi Central Railwa
500 071, A.P.
2. The Chief Engi
4
o
7
8
9.
rNDrA (OPUC)
10. Two CD Copies
SA
GJP
if any, pending in this Writ NS, l
T
I
i i
I
I
I
I
I
3. The Deputy Chi6f Engineer, Constructlon, South Central Railway, Guntakal - 515 801. Andhrd Pradesh.
SD/. V. HARI PRASAD
ASSISTANT REGIST R
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
ON'BLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA (For His Lordship's Kind Perusal) istrative Officer, (Construction), Union of lndia, Southern South Central Railway, Rail Nirman Bhavan, Secunderabad - eer, Construction - l, South Central Railway, Rail Nirman Bhavan, Secun derabad-500 071 .A.P
and Company
h Court
l
33
HIGH COURT
I DATED:03/06/ 024
ORDER
iWP.No.35956
t 2015
, ALLOWING T E W.P
WITHOUT CO TS
$ 16
1 4 ArrE 2[24
6 (
1r : S lrl \)
'+
o
o zlpr, ,+
a '''Alanw'-,--,' J.-/.
o
IJ,
! r r(
)
(
I
\-c)
J
34