Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts

    PATEL ANISHKUMAR BHIKHABHAI v. CHAUDHARY (PATEL) URMILABEN D/O LALJIBHAI DAHABHAI W/O PATEL ANISHKUMAR BHIKHABHAI

    NEUTRAL CITATION

    C/FA/1569/2024 ORDER DATED: 14/10/2024 undefined

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

    R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 1569 of 2024

    ==========================================================

    PATEL ANISHKUMAR BHIKHABHAI

    Versus

    CHAUDHARY (PATEL) URMILABEN D/O LALJIBHAI DAHABHAI W/O

    PATEL ANISHKUMAR BHIKHABHAI

    ========================================================== Appearance:

    MR MANISH J PATEL(2131) for the Appellant(s) No. 1 ==========================================================

    CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BIREN VAISHNAV

    and

    HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MAULIK J.SHELAT

    Date : 14/10/2024

    ORAL ORDER

    (PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MAULIK J.SHELAT)

    1. Today, when the matter was called out, we have drawn the attention to learned advocate for the appellant, Mr.Manish J. Patel, about the earlier order dated 30.08.2024 passed by this Court, which reads as under:-

    "Learned advocate for the appellant is permitted to file paper book with the Registry. Stand over to 17.09.2024."

    2. Learned advocate for the Appellant, Mr. Manish Patel, has fairly stated that the appellant has not been able to prepare the paper book and requested this Court to decide the issue involved in the appeal by dispensing with paper book i.e., record and proceedings of the case.

    3. As per the request made by learned advocate for the Appellant, Mr. Patel, as this appeal is pending since April, 2024 at the stage of issuance of notice, as requested, we deem it fit to

    Page 1 of 9

    examine the issue in absence of paper book i.e., record and proceedings.

    4. The present appeal is filed by the appellant under Section 19 of the Family Court Act, 1984, against the judgment and decree dated 03.10.2023 passed by Family Court, Modasa, District Arvalli in Family Suit No.23 of 2021 under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (hereinafter referred to as "the Act"), whereby, the Family Court dismissed the petition of the Appellant herein.

    Brief Facts of the Case

    5. That the appellant - Patel Anishkumar Bhikhabhai met with respondent Chaudhari (Patel) Urmilaben D/o Laljibhai Dahabhai W/o Patel Anishkumar Bhikhabhai through Instagram and became friends and later on such friendship turns into marriage. The marriage of the parties was solemnised on 01.06.2020 at Ramapir Temple, Vijpur, Taluka Bhiloda as per Hindu rites and rituals.

    5.1 It appears that marriage was registered at Vijpur Gram Panchayat and after some time, disputes started between the couple. Respondent - wife has left her matrimonial home and started residing separately from the petitioner. It also transpires from the impugned judgment and decree that respondent - wife appears to have been selected in Police Department, whereas appellant - husband remained unemployed and has education upto 11thstandard.

    5.2 The marital knot is broken, when the appellant - husband started abusing respondent - wife by inflicting cruelty upon her. It also transpires that appellant - husband has tried to malign the image of respondent - wife in public by sharing their private intimate photographs to the brother of the respondent. There appears a criminal complaint filed by respondent - wife against the appellant under Section 498A of IPC.

    Page 2 of 9

    5.3 The appellant - husband appears to have demanded money of Rs.20,00,000/- for getting divorce or interim alimony from respondent - wife as the respondent - wife has left the house of appellant and is serving in Police Department and have no interest to live with appellant. So, the appellant - husband appears to have filed an application under Section 9 of Act for restitution of conjugal rights against respondent - wife.

    5.4 A notice came to be issued in aforesaid application, wherein respondent - wife had entered her appearance and filed her written statement and contested such application.

    5.5 The parties have produced the following set of documents in form of oral and documentary evidence in support of their case, which are as under:-

    Oral Evidence for Appellant :-

    Sr.No. Exhibit Particular
    01 22 Copy of certificate of registration of marriage
    02 20 Copy of Government of Gujarat Resolution No. Exp/2002/57Part-II/Z-1
    03 21 Letter of posting of respondent
    04 23 Closing Purshish

    Oral evidence of Respondent

    Sr.No. Exhibit Particular
    01 25 Examination-in-chief of the respondent as R.W.1
    02 28 Closing Purshish

    Page 3 of 9

    5.6 The Family Court has framed issues at Exh. 15 for its determination.

    5.7 The Family Court, after appreciating oral and documentary evidence on record and hearing the respective parties, has been pleased to reject the Family Suit no.23 of 2021 filed by the appellant - husband.

    Submission of the Appellant - Original Petitioner

    6. Mr.Patel, learned advocate for the appellant, has submitted that Family Court has not appreciated oral and documentary evidence submitted by the appellant - husband, and thereby committed serious error in rejecting petition of husband. He has further stated that it is an undisputed fact that there was a love affair between the appellant - husband and the respondent - wife and without any reasonable excuse, respondent - wife had withdrawn from the society of the appellant - husband. He has further submitted that Family Court, without appreciating the scope of Section 9 of the Act and plight of husband, who is always ready and willing to perform his matrimonial obligation suffered a blow, when his application for restitution of conjugal rights is dismissed, so he has urged this Court to allow the captioned First Appeal and to quash the impugned judgment and decree, thereby requested to allow his Suit. No other and further submissions are made by the appellant.

    Point for Determination

    7. The issue, which has cropped up in present appeal, is as to whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the Family Court has committed any error, while rejecting the Family Suit

    Page 4 of 9

    filed by the appellant - husband under Section 9 of the Act?

    Appreciation of Submissions

    8. We have heard Mr.Patel, learned advocate for the appellant - husband at length and gone through the judgment and decree passed by Family Court as stated hereinabove and in absence of the paper book provided by the appellant containing oral and documentary evidence of Family Suit, we have considered the facts, which are mentioned in impugned judgment as correctly stated having not been disputed by the appellant - husband.

    9. When we have re-examined the matter at our end, the following glaring facts, are noticed by us, whereby we are of the opinion that the present appeal does not deserve admission and requires to be dismissed in limine.

    9.1 The marriage span of the parties are too short as marriage was solemnised on 01.06.2020 and impugned Family Suit No.23 of 2021 came to be filed on 02.10.2021 by the appellant - husband under Section 9 of the Act.

    9.2 The allegation made by the respondent -wife that she was subjected to cruelty, which has resulted into filing of a complaint under Section 498A of I.P.C. against the appellant - husband, is the reason for her to leave her matrimonial home despite there was a love marriage.

    9.3 The appellant - husband is neither employed nor even in a position to maintain respondent - wife having no source of income as alleged by him, so as per the case of the respondent - wife, the appellant was asking a lump sum amount of Rs.20,00,000/- to get divorce or else pay regular interim maintenance to him, otherwise, he had threatened to share intimate photographs of the respondent - wife.

    9.4 It is the case of the respondent - wife that she is serving

    Page 5 of 9

    in the Police Department and after marriage, she came to know that appellant - husband had made a false claim that he used to work in film city and having sizable agricultural land for his livelihood.

    9.5 Even it has been observed in impugned judgment that during the course of recording of evidence, the Family Court has found that appellant is a healthy body man, having no disability but not ready to maintain his wife.

    9.6 The Family Court has firstly relied upon a decision of the Apex Court in the case of Saroj Rani Smt v. Sudarshan Kumar Chadha ., AIR 1984 SC 1562: (1984) 4 SCC 90: (1984) 2 SCALE 118 as follows:-

    "The expression, "withdrawal from the society of the other involves a mental process besides physical separation. In India it may be borne in mind that conjugal right i.e., right of the husband or the wife to the society of the other spouse is not merely creature of the statute. Such a right is inherent in the very institution of marriage itself."

    9.7 It has further placed reliance on the decision of this Court in the case of Jinnat Fatima Vajirbhai Ami Vs. Nishad Alimadbhai Polra, reported in 2022 (3) GLR 2292, which reads as under:-

    "It has to be borne in mind that the decision in a suit for the restitution of conjugal rights does not entirely depend upon the right of the husband. The Family Court should also consider whether it would make it inequitable for it to compel the wife to live with her husband. Our notions of law in that regard have to be altered in such a way as to bring them in conformity with the modern social conditions. Nothing has been shown to us in the form of any rule or otherwise which compel the Courts to always pass a decree in a suit for restitution of conjugal rights in favour of the husband. As long as there is no such rule, it would be just and reasonable for the Court to deny the said relief to the plaintiff- husband if the surrounding circumstances indicate that it would be inequitable to do so."

    9.8 Thus, after appreciating evidence on record, provisions of law and the law laid down by Apex Court and this Court, the Family Court has come to the conclusion that appellant - husband has not

    Page 6 of 9

    come with clean hand. His own conduct as noticed by Court below disentitled him to get any relief as prayed in his suit. It appears that there is no possibility to live together by the parties under one roof as there is a trust deficiency between the parties. In such circumstances, the Family Court felt that respondent - wife should not be compelled to live with husband, whereby, there is no possibility of reunion and no possibility of parties to live together under one roof.

    10. We are in complete agreement with reasons, assigned by Family Court while rejecting the prayer of the appellant - husband made in his application filed under Section 9 of the Act.

    11. We would also like to observe that Section 9 of the Act would definitely entitled the husband or a wife to apply for restitution of conjugal right, in those cases, where without any reasonable excuse, one of the partner withdrawn from the society of other. Section 9 of the Act reads as under:-

    "When either the husband or the wife has, without reasonable excuse, withdrawn from the society of the other, the aggrieved party may apply, by petition to the district court, for restitution of conjugal rights and the court, on being satisfied of the truth of the statements, made in such petition and that there is no legal ground why the application should not be granted, may decree restitution of conjugal rights accordingly".

    Explanation appended to Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act provides,

    "Where a question arise whether there has been reasonable excuse for withdrawal from the society, the burden of proving reasonable excuse shall be on the person who has withdrawn from the society."

    12. It is pertinent to note that while deciding an application under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, an enquiry has to be undertaken by Family Court, whereby it has to arrive at the definite finding that as to whether an opposite party to petition has without

    Page 7 of 9

    any reasonable excuse withdrawn from the Society of petitioner or not. Once, the Family Court comes to a definite finding that there is a reasonable excuse for opponent to have withdrawn from the Society of appellant for justifiable excuse then it cannot compel such party to live under one roof with other.

    13. The Apex Court in the case of Saroj Rani Smt v. Sudarshan Kumar Chadha . (supra) had an occasion to deal with such controversy, wherein it has succinctly held that party to the marriage cannot be compelled to live together against their wish, when there is justifiable and reasonable excuse for not residing with opposite side. It has been so held by Apex Court in Saroj Rani (supra) as under:-

    "13. Having considered the views of the learned single judge of the Andhra Pradesh High Court and that of learned single judge of Delhi High Court, we prefer to accept on this aspect namely on the validity of Section 9 of the said Act the views of the learned single judge of the Delhi High Court. It may be mentioned that conjugal rights may be viewed in its proper perspective by keeping in mind the dictionary meaning of the expression "Conjugal". Shorter Oxford English Dictio- nary, 3rd Edn. Vol. I page 371 notes the meaning of 'conjugal' as "of or pertaining to marriage or to husband and wife in their relations to each other". In the Dictionary of English Law, 1959 Edn. at page 453, Earl Jowitt defines 'conjugal rights' thus:

    "The right which husband and wife have to each other's society and marital intercourse. The suit for restitution of conjugal rights is a mat- rimonial suit, cognizable in the Divorce Court, which is brought when- ever either the husband or the wife lives separate from the other with- out any sufficient reason, in which case the court will decree restitu- tion of conjugal rights (Matrimonial Causes Act, 1950, s. 15), but will not enforce it by attachment, substituting however for attachment, if the wife be the petitioner, an order for periodical payments by the husband to the wife (s.22). Conjugal rights cannot be enforced by the act of either party, and a husband cannot seize and detain his wife by force (R.V. Jackson [1891] 1 Q.B. 671)".

    14. Even this Court in a case of Jinnat Fatima Vajirbhai Ami Vs. Nishad Alimadbhai Polra (supra) has also clarified such position of law.

    Page 8 of 9

    Conclusion

    15. Thus, the upshot of the aforesaid discussions, leading to only one conclusion that there was a just and reasonable excuse for respondent - wife not to live with appellant - husband under one roof. The appellant has miserably failed to prove a vital fact that without any reasonable excuse, the respondent - wife has withdrawn from the Society of the appellant, which is sine qua non to get decree under Section 9 of the Act.

    16. Thus, in view of the aforesaid discussion and the facts emerged from the impugned judgment and decree and position of law, we found that there is no merit in the appeal and hence, the First Appeal stands DISMISSED. No order as to costs.

    (BIREN VAISHNAV, J)

    (MAULIK J.SHELAT,J)

    MOHD MONIS

    Page 9 of 9

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    PATEL ANISHKUMAR BHI... v. CHAUDHARY (PATEL) UR...
    (Oct 14, 2024)