Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Acts
  • CENTRAL EXCISE ACT
  • Rule 25 of the Rules ibid read with Section 11AC
  • provisions of Rule 8(3A)
  • provision of Rule 8(3A) of Central Excise Rules, 2002
  • Rule 8(1) and Rule 8(3) of the said Rules,
  • provisions of Rule 8(3A) of Central Excise Rules, 2002
  • Rule 8(3A) of Rules, 2002
  • sub-rule (1) and sub-rule (4) of rule 3 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004,
  • provision of Rule 8(3A)
  • Rule 8 of Central Excise Rules, 2002
  • provisions of Rule 8(3A) of the Central Excise Rules, 2002,
  • Rule 8(3A) of Central Excise Rules, 2002. 9
  • sub-rule (1),
  • Rule 8(3A) of the Rules.
  • Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944 read with Rule 25 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Acts
  • CENTRAL EXCISE ACT
  • Rule 25 of the Rules ibid read with Section 11AC
  • provisions of Rule 8(3A)
  • provision of Rule 8(3A) of Central Excise Rules, 2002
  • Rule 8(1) and Rule 8(3) of the said Rules,
  • provisions of Rule 8(3A) of Central Excise Rules, 2002
  • Rule 8(3A) of Rules, 2002
  • sub-rule (1) and sub-rule (4) of rule 3 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004,
  • provision of Rule 8(3A)
  • Rule 8 of Central Excise Rules, 2002
  • provisions of Rule 8(3A) of the Central Excise Rules, 2002,
  • Rule 8(3A) of Central Excise Rules, 2002. 9
  • sub-rule (1),
  • Rule 8(3A) of the Rules.
  • Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944 read with Rule 25 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    S Shyam Raj v. Cce Chennai-i

    CUSTOMS, EXCISE AND SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL

    CHENNAI

    REGIONAL BENCH - COURT No. III

    Excise Appeal No. 41691 of 2015

    (Arising out of Order-in-Original No. 23/2015 dated 23.04.2015 passed by Commissioner of Central Excise, No. 26/1, Mahatma Gandhi Road, Nungambakkam, Chennai - 600 034)

    M/s. SAS Autocom Engineers India Pvt. Ltd. ...Appellant

    G-77, SIDCO Industrial Estate, Kakkalur,

    Tiruvallur - 602 003.

    Versus Commissioner of GST and Central Excise ...Respondent

    Chennai I Commissionerate, No. 26/1, Mahatma Gandhi Road, Nungambakkam,

    Chennai - 600 034.

    And Excise Appeal No. 41692 of 2015

    (Arising out of Order-in-Original No. 23/2015 dated 23.04.2015 passed by Commissioner of Central Excise, No. 26/1, Mahatma Gandhi Road, Nungambakkam, Chennai - 600 034)

    Shri S. Shyam Raj ...Appellant

    Joint Managing Director, M/s. SAS Autocom Engineers India Private Ltd., G-77, SIDCO Industrial Estate,

    Kakkalur,

    Tiruvallur - 602 003.

    Versus Commissioner of GST and Central Excise ...Respondent

    Chennai I Commissionerate, No. 26/1, Mahatma Gandhi Road, Nungambakkam,

    Chennai - 600 034.

    APPEARANCE:

    For the Appellants : Ms. Pramila, Advocate For the Respondent : Mr. N. Satyanarayanan, Authorised Representative

    CORAM:

    HON'BLE MR. P. DINESHA, MEMBER (JUDICIAL) HON'BLE MR. VASA SESHAGIRI RAO, MEMBER (TECHNICAL)

    1

    2

    FINAL ORDER Nos. 41415-41416 / 2024

    DATE OF HEARING : 14.10.2024

    DATE OF DECISION: 07.11.2024

    Per Mr. VASA SESHAGIRI RAO

    Excise Appeal No. E/41691/2015 was filed by M/s. SAS Autocom Engineers India Pvt. Ltd., Tiruvallur (Appellant-A1) and Appeal No. E/41692/2015 was filed by Shri S. Shyam Raj, Joint Managing Director (Appellant-A2) which were directed against the Order-in-Original No. 23/2015 dated 23.04.2015 passed by the Commissioner of Central Excise, Chennai I Commissionerate demanding Central Excise Duty of Rs.1,72,68,455/- to be paid in cash along with interest and also imposing penalty under Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944 read with Rule 25 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002 in respect of Appellant-A1 and for imposition of penalty of Rs.10,00,000/- in respect of Appellant-A2.

    1.2 As the issue involved in the above appeals is contravention of provisions of Rule 8(3A) of the Central Excise Rules, 2002, both the appeals are being taken up together for decision and disposal by this common order.

    2.1 The above demand was consequent to an investigation conducted by the department during May 2011 wherein department alleged non-payment of excise duty within due date and belated filing of ER 1 returns during the period from October 2009 to November 2013, in as much as the removals were alleged to be non-duty paid goods in contravention of Rule 8(3A) of the Rules. A Show Cause Notice dated 01.10.2014 was issued

    3

    to the Appellant proposing to demand duty of Rs.1,80,55,015/- under Section 11A(4) of the ACT ibid along with appropriate interest under Section 11AA and to impose penalties under Rule 25 of the Rules ibid read with Section 11AC of the ACT. The impugned order observed that the utilization of CENVAT credit for clearances from January 2010 onwards was non-duty paid on the basis of statutory fiction created under Rule 8(3)A of the Rules and confirmed duty of Rs.1,72,68,455 and imposed equal penalty on the Appellant. Besides a personal Penalty was imposed on Appellant A2 who was employed as Joint Managing Director of Appellant company-A1.

    2.2 The main contentions of the appellant specified in the grounds of appeal have been summarized below: -

    i. It was submitted that proceedings are vitiated as the provision of Rule 8(3A) was declared unconstitutional and rendered invalid by the Hon'ble High Court of Gujarat in the case of M/s. Indusur Global Ltd. Vs Union of India [2014 (310) ELT 833 (Guj.)] which was followed by the Madras High Court in the case of M/s. Malladi Drugs Vs. Union of India in a batch of writ petitions in WP No. 2506/2011 and others. Further, it was submitted that there was no scope for initiation of any proceedings as the relevant provisions of Rule 8(3A) have been struck down as ultravires the main Act by the decision of the Hon'ble High Court, Gujarat in an identical case of Precision Fasters Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of central Excise, [2014-TIOL-2211-

    HC].

    4

    ii. It was averred that it was only a case of belated payment of duty and there was no violation or wilful default as the entire liability was discharged during and after the investigation As there was no malafide on the part of the appellant to evade duty, as the department was fully aware of the facts, the invocation of Section 11A was not legally sustainable and in this regard reliance was placed on the ratio of decision in the case of M/s. Uniworth Textile Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of central Excise, Raipur [2013 (288) ELT 161

    (SC)].

    iii. It was submitted that the delayed payment of duty was on account of undue financial hardships and slowdown in the business and in these circumstances invocation of extended period was not sustainable as there was no intention to evade payment of duty. Further, it was submitted that in cases of belated payments, there cannot be an allegation of wilful default or suppression as the ingredients for invoking Section 11AC were not present, as held in Commissioner of Central Excise, Bhavnagar Vs. Saurashtra Chemicals [2007 (212) ELT 7 SC].

    iv. It was submitted that the CBEC clarified vide circulars No. 766/82/2003-CX dated 15.12.2003 and Circular No. 962/05/2012 dated 28.03.2012 that credit during earlier period was available for utilization in cases of duty arrears and in this regard, reliance was placed on the following judgements:

    (a) CCC & CE, Indore Vs. Deepak Silicate (p) Ltd. [2010 (258) ELT 127 (Tri.-Del.)].

    (b) Meenakshi Associates Vs. CCE, Noida [2012-TIOL-587-CESTAT-

    DEL].

    (c) Solar Chemferts Pvt. Ltd. Vs CCE, Thane-I [2012 (276) ELT 273 (Tri.-Mumbai)].

    5

    (d) F.S.Engineers Vs. CCE, Ahmedabad II [2013 (293) ELT 61 (Tri.- Ahmd.].

    (e) Baba Viswakarma Engg. Co. Ltd. Vs. CCE, Ghaziabad [2012 (278) ELT 68 (Tri-Bang.)]

    v. It was averred that the entire issue is revenue neutral as even after cash payment, the entire amount would be available as CENVAT Credit. It was pointed out that in cases involving revenue neutrality, no demand could be made as held in: -

    (a) Allianz Steel Lrtd. Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise [2012 (286) ELT 633 (Tri.-Del.)]

    (b) Commissioner of central Excise, Jullundur Vs. Kochar Sung up Acrylic Ltd. [2010 (29) ELT 713 (Tri.-Del.)]

    vi. It was averred that being a case of wrong availment of CENVAT credit only CENVAT Credit Rules were applicable for invocation of penal provisions and not the penal provisions of Central Excise Act which are relevant only in cases of intentional / evading payment of excise duty relying the ratio of the decisions in the case of M/s Eicher Motor Ltd. [1999 (106) ELT 3 (SC)] and Dai Ichi Karkaria reported in [1999 (112) ELT 353 (SC)].

    vii. It was submitted that the confirmation of interest was incorrect in view of the judgement in the case of Shreeji Surface Coatings Pvt. Ltd. Vs Union of India [2015 (320) ELT 764 (Guj.)].

    3. The Ld. Counsel for the Appellant reiterated the grounds of appeal and submitted that the Hon'ble Tribunal in a batch of appeals involving identical issues, allowed the appeals filed by various assesses in Final Order Nos. 40847-40873/2015 dated 07.07.2015. It was also pointed out that the judgement in M/s Indsur Global Ltd. was also followed in: -

    6

    (i) Sandley Industries Ltd. Vs. UOI [2015 (326) ELT 256 (P&H)].

    (ii) Nashik Forge Pvt. Ltd. [2019 (368) ELT 20 (Bom)]

    (iii) Burgeon Pharmaceuticals Pvt. Ltd. Versus Commissioner of GST & Central Excise, Chennai [2024 (7) TMI 681]

    (iv) Andhra Cylinders Pvt. Ltd., Nalin Khara, Managing Director Vs. Commissioner of Customs, Central Excise & Service Tax, Hyderabad-I [2020 (I) TMI 189 CESTAT Hyderabad].

    and hence it was stressed that the demand was not sustainable in terms of the Hon'ble Tribunal Final Order No. 41125/2024 dated 21.08.2024.

    4. Shri N. Satyanarayanan, Ld. Authorised representative for the Department, reiterated the findings in the impugned order and submitted that there was belated payment of duty and as per provisions of Section 8(3A), CENVAT credit could not be utilized for payment of duty and hence the demand was sustainable and prayed for dismissal of the appeal filed by the Appellant.

    5. Heard both sides and carefully considered the submissions and evidences on record.

    6. The main issues that arise for consideration in these appeals are:-

    i. Whether the demand as confirmed and upheld in the impugned order dated 23.04.2015 for violation of Rule 8(3A) against the Appellant-A1 is sustainable in law or not?

    ii. Whether such demand can be raised invoking the extending period and imposition of penalty is justified?

    7

    7. The main issue involved in the present appeals is whether an assessee who failed to make full payment of duty within prescribed time limit as provided under Rule 8 of Central Excise Rules, 2002 and defaulted in payment of excise duty in terms of Rule 8(1) and Rule 8(3) of the said Rules, would be bound by the provisions of Rule 8(3A) of Central Excise Rules, 2002 and whether he would be required to pay the entire default amount from his PLA account (in cash) and he is barred from making the default amount through his CENVAT Account. In the present appeals, the appellants are alleged to have defaulted in payment of duty for the month(s) of January 2010 to November 2013. The provisions of the said rule reads as under: -

    "If the assessee defaults in payment of duty beyond thirty days from the due date, as prescribed in sub-rule (1), then notwithstanding anything contained in said sub-rule (1) and sub-rule (4) of rule 3 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, the assessee shall, pay excise duty for each consignment at the time of removal, without utilizing the CENVAT credit till the date the assessee pays the outstanding amount including interest thereon; and in the event of any failure, it shall be deemed that such goods have been cleared without payment of duty and the consequences and penalties as provided in these rules shall follow" It was the departments case that the Appellant-A1 defaulted in payment of duty and hence not eligible to utilize CENVAT Credit for payment of duty in terms of the said rule till the default in payment of duty is corrected.

    8. The issue as to whether the Assessee can utilise the CENVAT credit toward payment of duty when in default is no more res integra and many judicial authorities have held that the provision of Rule 8(3A) of Central Excise Rules, 2002 as ultravires to the Main Act. The Hon'ble Gujarat High Court in the case of M/s. Indsur Global Ltd. Vs. UOI [2014

    8

    (310) ELT 833 (Guj.)] struck down the condition in Rule 8(3A) for payment of duty "without utilizing the CENVAT credit" as unconstitutional and invalid. This judgment of the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court has been followed by other High Courts in series of cases as follows: -

    i. Shreeji Surface Coatings Pvt. Ltd. Vs Union of India [2015 (320) ELT 764 (Guj.)].

    ii. Malladi Drugs and Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India [2015

    (323) ELT 489 (Mad.)].

    iii. Sandley Industries vs. Union of India [2015 (326) ELT 256].

    iv. Nashik Forge Pvt. Ltd. [2019 (368) ELT 20 (Bom)]

    9. We find that the issue is finally settled in favour of the Assessee in view of the stand taken by various High Courts which have already held that Rule 8(3A) of Rules, 2002 is ultra vires of Article 14 of Constitution being unreasonable, irrational, arbitrary and violative. The Gujarat High Court has struck down the aforesaid Rule in Indsur Global Limited vs. Union of India[2014 (310) ELT 833 (Guj.)], Madras High Court has done so in Malladi Drugs and Pharmaceuticals Limited vs. Union of India [2015 (323) ELT 489 (Mad.)], and Punjab and Haryana High Court has also taken the same view in Sandley Industries vs. Union of India [2015 (326) ELT 256].

    10. The Hon'ble High Court of Bombay in the case of Commissioner of Central Excise & Customs, Nashik-II Vs. Nashik Forge Pvt. Ltd. [2019

    (368) ELT 20 (Bom.)] has held that Rule 8(3A) to be unconstitutional as it infringes upon the substantive right of an assessee to utilize Cenvat credit. Further, the Tribunal in the case of Indus Tropics Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Rajkot [2023 (3) TMI 950-CESTAT AHMEDABAD] has followed the decisions of various High Court to set aside the demand alleging violation of Rule 8(3A) of Central Excise Rules, 2002.

    9

    11. We find that the Department had preferred an appeal against the decision passed in Indsur Global Ltd. (supra) before the Hon'ble Supreme Court. The Ld. Counsel for the appellant has submitted before us that the appeal filed by the Department in Indsur Global Ltd. (supra) has been disposed by the Hon'ble Apex Court as per decision dated 29.07.2024. The appeal was referred to the Lok Adalat proceedings before the Hon'ble Supreme Court and settlement has been arrived at. The effect is that the stay order having merged with the order of settlement, stands vacated. The decision rendered by the Hon'ble High Courts of Gujarat and Madras in the above cases would revive and be in force as a Precedent.

    12. After appreciating the facts and following the above decisions, we are of the considered opinion that the demand raised alleging violation of Rule 8(3A) cannot sustain and requires to be set aside. Ordered accordingly.

    13. In the result, the impugned Order-in-Original No. 23/2015 dated 23.04.2015 is set aside. The appeals are allowed with consequential relief, if any, as per the law.

    (Order pronounced in open court on 07.11.2024)

    Sd/- Sd/-

    (VASA SESHAGIRI RAO) (P. DINESHA)

    MEMBER (TECHNICAL) MEMBER (JUDICIAL)

    MK

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S Shyam Raj v. Cce Chennai-i
    (Nov 7, 2024)