ORDERS
28. The considerations that weigh with the appellate Court for setting aside the bail order on an application being moved by the aggrieved party include any supervening circumstances that may have occurred after granting relief to the accused, the conduct of the accused while on bail, any attempt on the part of the accused to procrastinate,
- 12 -
resulting in delaying the trial, any instance of threats being extended to the witnesses while on bail, any attempt on the part of the accused to tamper with the evidence in any manner. We may add that this list is only illustrative and not exhaustive. However, the court must be cautious that at the stage of granting bail, only a prima facie case needs to be examined and detailed reasons relating to the merits of the case that may cause prejudice to the accused, ought to be avoided. Suffice it is to state that the bail order should reveal the factors that have been considered by the Court for granting relief to the accused."
12. In the case of PURAN VS RAMBILAS & ANOTHER - (2001)6 SCC 338, in paragraph 11, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed as under:
"11. Further, it is to be kept in mind that the concept of setting aside the unjustified illegal or perverse order is totally different from the concept of cancelling the bail on the ground that the accused has misconducted himself or because of some new facts requiring such cancellation. This position is made clear by this Court in Gurcharan Singh v. State (Delhi Admn.). In that case the Court observed as under: (SCC p. 124, para 16)
- 13 -
"If, however, a Court of Session had admitted an accused person to bail, the State has two options. It may move the Sessions Judge if certain new circumstances have arisen which were not earlier known to the State and necessarily, therefore, to that court. The State may as well approach the High Court being the superior court under Section 439(2) to commit the accused to custody. When, however, the State is aggrieved by the order of the Sessions Judge granting bail and there are no new circumstances that have cropped up except those already existing, it is futile for the State to move the Sessions Judge again and it is competent in law to move the High Court for cancellation of the bail. This position follows from the subordinate position of the Court of Session vis-à- vis the High Court."
13. In the case of DEEPAK YADAV VS STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH & ANOTHER - (2022)8 SCC 559, in paragraph 33, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed as under:
- 14 -
"33. It is no doubt true that cancellation of bail cannot be limited to the occurrence of supervening circumstances. This Court certainly has the inherent powers and discretion to cancel the bail of an accused even in the absence of supervening circumstances. Following are the illustrative circumstances where the bail can be cancelled:
33.1. Where the court granting bail takes into account irrelevant material of substantial nature and not trivial nature while ignoring relevant material on record.
33.2. Where the court granting bail overlooks the influential position of the accused in comparison to the victim of abuse or the witnesses especially when there is prima facie misuse of position and power over the victim.
33.3. Where the past criminal record and conduct of the accused is completely ignored while granting bail.
33.4. Where bail has been granted on untenable grounds.
33.5. Where serious discrepancies are found in the order granting bail thereby causing prejudice to justice.
- 15 -
33.6. Where the grant of bail was not appropriate in the first place given the very serious nature of the charges against the accused which disentitles him for bail and thus cannot be justified.
33.7. When the order granting bail is apparently whimsical, capricious and perverse in the facts of the given case."
14. In the case of KANWAR SINGH MEENA VS STATE OF RAJASTHAN & ANOTHER - (2012)12 SCC 180, in paragraph 10, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed as under:
"10. Thus, Section 439 of the Code confers very wide powers on the High Court and the Court of Session regarding bail. But, while granting bail, the High Court and the Sessions Court are guided by the same considerations as other courts. That is to say, the gravity of the crime, the character of the evidence, position and status of the accused with reference to the victim and witnesses, the likelihood of the accused fleeing from justice and repeating the offence, the possibility of his tampering with the witnesses and obstructing the course of justice and such other grounds are required to be taken into consideration. Each criminal case presents its own peculiar factual
- 16 -
scenario and, therefore, certain grounds peculiar to a particular case may have to be taken into account by the court. The court has to only opine as to whether there is prima facie case against the accused. The court must not undertake meticulous examination of the evidence collected by the police and comment on the same. Such assessment of evidence and premature comments are likely to deprive the accused of a fair trial. While cancelling the bail under Section 439(2) of the Code, the primary considerations which weigh with the court are whether the accused is likely to tamper with the evidence or interfere or attempt to interfere with the due course of justice or evade the due course of justice. But, that is not all. The High Court or the Sessions Court can cancel the bail even in cases where the order granting bail suffers from serious infirmities resulting in miscarriage of justice. If the court granting bail ignores relevant materials indicating prima facie involvement of the accused or takes into account irrelevant material, which has no relevance to the question of grant of bail to the accused, the High Court or the Sessions Court would be justified in cancelling the bail. Such orders are against the well-recognised principles underlying the power to grant bail. Such orders are legally infirm and vulnerable leading to miscarriage of justice and absence of supervening
- 17 -
circumstances such as the propensity of the accused to tamper with the evidence, to flee from justice, etc. would not deter the court from cancelling the bail. The High Court or the Sessions Court is bound to cancel such bail orders particularly when they are passed releasing the accused involved in heinous crimes because they ultimately result in weakening the prosecution case and have adverse impact on the society. Needless to say that though the powers of this Court are much wider, this Court is equally guided by the above principles in the matter of grant or cancellation of bail."
15. In the case of BHURI BAI VS STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH - 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1779, in paragraphs 19 & 20, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed as under:
"19. It remains trite that normally, very cogent and overwhelming circumstances or grounds are required to cancel the bail already granted. Ordinarily, unless a strong case based on any supervening event is made out, an order granting bail is not to be lightly interfered with under Section 439(2) CrPC.
20. It had not been the case of the prosecution that the appellant had misused the liberty or had comported herself in any manner in
- 18 -
violation of the conditions imposed on her. We are impelled to observe that power of cancellation of bail should be exercised with extreme care and circumspection; and such cancellation cannot be ordered merely for any perceived indiscipline on the part of the accused before granting bail. In other words, the powers of cancellation of bail cannot be approached as if of disciplinary proceedings against the accused and in fact, in a case where bail has already been granted, its upsetting under Section 439(2) CrPC is envisaged only in such cases where the liberty of the accused is going to be counteracting the requirements of a proper trial of the criminal case. In the matter of the present nature, in our view, over-expansion of the issue was not required only for one reason that a particular factor was not stated by the Trial Court in its order granting bail."
16. In the case on hand, the respondent is arrayed as accused on three counts, (i) on suspicion; (ii) on the basis of the confession statement of other accused; (iii) on the basis of circumstantial evidence. Undisputedly, respondent was not present at the spot of crime and there is no direct evidence to connect him to the crime. Respondent has no criminal antecedents. He is a qualified person and owner of a software
- 19 -
company. Though State has expressed that he is likely to tamper with the prosecution witnesses, the State has not produced any material before this Court to show that after the respondent was enlarged on bail in the month of November 2023, he has made any attempt to tamper with the prosecution witnesses. It is also relevant to take note of the fact that though bail was granted to the respondent by the Trial Court on 03.11.2023, this petition seeking cancellation of bail was belatedly filed by the State on 19.07.2024 on the ground that the Trial Court was not justified in granting bail to the respondent on the merits of the case, and not on the ground of violation of any of the bail conditions.
17. It is also not the case of the prosecution that the respondent has violated any one of the bail conditions till date. The State has sought cancellation of bail mainly on the ground that the Trial Court has failed to appreciate the statements of CW-55 & CW-74. The statement of those witnesses have been perused and considered by this Court. Merely for the reason that a particular factor has not been considered by the Trial Court while granting bail to an accused, the same cannot be a ground to cancel the bail, if it is otherwise found that the order
- 20 -
granting bail to the said accused is justifiable and the accused who has been released on bail has not violated the bail conditions. The relevant factors which are required to be taken into consideration for the purpose of cancellation of bail has to be considered cumulatively and merely for the reason that one of the several factors has not been considered, in normal circumstances, the bail granted to an accused cannot be cancelled. Cancellation of bail would amount to interfering with the right to liberty guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India, and therefore, unless it is found on the facts and circumstances of the case which includes, the antecedents of the accused, gravity of the crime, gravity of accusation, role of the accused in the crime, danger of accused fleeing or influencing witnesses, or that the court was not at all justified in enlarging the accused on bail, the order of bail cannot be cancelled.
18. In the case on hand, though the Trial Court has not passed a well reasoned order while enlarging the respondent on bail, it cannot be said that the Trial Court was completely unjustified in granting bail to the respondent or that the order granting bail to the respondent, has resulted in total
- 21 -
miscarriage of justice. Under the circumstances, I am of the opinion that the order impugned granting regular bail to the respondent, does not call for interference. Accordingly, the petition is dismissed.
Considering the fact that accused Nos. 1 to 3 are in custody from 12.07.2023 onwards, trial court is requested to expedite the trial and make endeavors to dispose of the case at the earliest.
Sd/-
(S VISHWAJITH SHETTY)
JUDGE
KK