ORDER
The complaint has been filed by the complainant against the Opposite Part ies (hereinafter referred to as the OPs) under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. It is averred that the complainant online purchased laptop model Acer Nitro V Gaming Laptop 13th Generation Intel Core i5 -13420 with RTX 4050 Graphics 6GB VRAM ,144Hz Display (16GB DDR5 /512GB SSD /Windows 11 Home/ Wi-Fi 6 )15.6 "(39.6 cms) FHD ANV 15-51 for amounting to Rs.72,990/- on dated 7.10.2023. The laptop was delivered to the complainant on 10 .10.2023. However, when the complainant opened the laptop, he found that the OPs have sent the old laptop of Acer Company and said laptop seemed to be very old. On 10.10.2023, the complainant lodged a complaint with OP No.2. The concerned customer care official of OP No. 2 disclosed that they have to conduct an investigation regarding delivery of different order and product. Accordingly, the complainant fulfilled all the formalities of OP No. 2 for investigation, including sending them pictures of said old laptop. OP No.2, after receiving all the documents, assured the complainant that the investigation shall take three calendar days to complete and further directed to contact them on 14 .10.2023 for update. Thereafter they will initiate the return and refund process of order. On 13.10.2023, the complainant received a n email sent by OP No. 2 which disclosed that the OPs have accepted the return request of the complainant and assured that
3
once they receive the item, they will iss ue the refund. Accordingly, on 15.10.2023, the OPs picked the said product from the complainant but they did not refund the amount and on inquiry it came to the notice of the complainant that OPs with malafide intention to cheat the complainant willfully updated the status of the return not received and that the return is likely lost in transit but from the return shipment status it clearly reveals that the OPs have received the said item. It is further averred that on 29.10. 2023 the OPs sent an e-mail to the complainant in which they alleged that they can't issue refund for this order until they received the correct item. This act and conduct of the OPs amount to unfair trade practice and deficiency in service. Consequently prayer has been made for issuance of directions to the OPs to refund amount of Rs.72,990/- along with interest @12% per annum with effect from 7.10.2023; to pay a sum of Rs.50,000/- as compensation on account of unfair trade practice, negligence in service, harassment, torture and Rs.25,000 as litigation cost.
2. Despite service through a registered post, OP No. 1 failed to put in appearance and as a result, there of, it was proceeded against ex-parte vide order dated 07.05.2024
3. Upon notice, OP No.2 appeared and filed written statement by pleading in the preliminary objections that the complainant has approached this Commission with unclean
4
hands and is guilty of suppressing material facts. The OP owns and operates an online web portal and is engaged in business of online market place, providing platform/technology and or other mechanism/services to facilitate transactions, electronic commerce, mobile commerce, by and between respective buyers and sellers and enables dealing in various categories of g oods. The portal is a marketplace, wherein third party vendors/sellers who wish to use the platform, register themselves as vendors/sellers and list their products and offer the said products for sale. There are several third party vendors/sellers who list variety of products on the said portal, including but not limited to books, electronic gadgets, apparels for men, women and kids, home and kitchen appliances, perfumes and related products. Being an intermediary, the OP is protected under Section 79 of the Information Technology Act. There is no dispute contemplated under the Consumer Protection Act. The complainant had made the allegation of non delivery of the product as per specifications, but failed to bring on record that what kind of product was ordered by him with what kind of specifications. Denying other averments of the complaint on merit, OP No.2 has prayed for dismissal of the complaint.
4. In support of his case, the complainant placed on record affidavit Ex.CW-1/1 and documents Ex C-1 to Ex C-10.
5
5. On the other hand, counsel for the OP No 2 placed on record affidavit Ex.OP-2/A of Richa Bakshi and documents Ex.OP-2/1 to Ex.OP-2/7.
6. We have heard authorized representative of the complainant and ld. counsel for OP No.2 and perused the record.
7. It is undisputed that the complainant purchased an Acer Nitro V Gaming Laptop for Rs.72,990 /- on 7.10.2023 vide Ex.C-5. The laptop was delivered to the complainant on 10.10.2023. However, upon inspection, it was found that the complainant received an older and different model of the laptop, contrary to the product ordered. The complainant immediately lodged a complaint with OP No. 2 and cooperated fully with their investigation by providing necessary documentation and photographs of the incorrect laptop. The OPs, after reviewing the complainant 's evidence, accepted the return request on 13.10.2023, and the incorrect laptop was collected from the complainant on 15.10.2023. It is evident from t he tracking information (Ex.C-9) that the item was indeed returned and received by the OPs, contrary to their claim that the item was lost in transit. Despite acknowledging the receipt of the returned item, the OPs wrongfully updated the status of the return as "not received" and, in bad faith, communicated to the complainant on 29.10.2023 that refund could not be processed until the "correct
6
item" was returned (Ex.C-10). This contradicts the earlier acceptance of the returned product and constitutes an unfair trade practice. OP No.1 has been proceeded against ex-parte as per order dated 07.05.2024. Hence, the allegations and claims made by the complainant against OP 1 stand unchallenged. OP No. 2 has contended that it merely operates as an intermediary under Section 79 of the Information Techno logy Act, providing an online platform for third -party sellers. While the Commission recognizes the intermediary protection under the Information Technology Act, but this protection does not absolve OP No. 2 from ensuring that consumers are not subjected t o unfair trade practices or deficient services. OP No. 2 has a responsibility to facilitate smooth transaction and resolve any disputes that ar ose during or after transaction. The complainant, having acted in good faith, the conduct of the OPs in failing to provide the correct product, denying a rightful refund, and updating the return status incorrectly reflects a deliberate attempt to evade their legal responsibility, further constituting unfair trade practice as per the Act. Based on the foregoing, the complainant has made a valid case of deficiency in service, unfair trade practice, and negligence on the part of the OPs.
8. Consequently, keeping in view the entire facts and circumstances of this case, we partly allow the complaint and direct the OPs to refund to the complainant amount of
7
Rs.72,990/- to the complainant, along with interest @ 9% per annum w.e.f. 07.10.2023 i.e. the date of purchase within a period of 30 days from the date of receipt of free certified copy of this order, failing which the above said amount will carry interest @ 12% per annum. The OPs are also directed to pay to the complainant Rs.20,000/- as compensation for mental agony and harassment and as well as litigation expenses. Both the OPs are jointly and severally held liable to comply with this order.
9. The instant complaint could not be disposed of within stipulated period for want of quorum and due to heavy institution.
Certified copies of this order be sent to the parties free of costs. File be indexed and consigned to record room. Pronounced
July 23, 2024
(S.K. Aggarwal)
President
(Ms. Paramjeet Kaur)
Member