Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • SECTION 54 TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • 8 of 9 sub-rule (4).
  • Rule 10 of Order 1 of CPC
  • sub-rule (3),
  • Order 23 Rule 1(5)
  • provisions contained in Rules 1 to 14 of Order 32
  • Order 23 Rule (1)(A) of CPC,
  • Order 23 Rule 1(4) of CPC
  • Order 23 Rule 1(1) of CPC
  • sub-rule (1)
  • Order 23 Rule 1 (4)(b) and Order 23 Rule (1)(5) of CPC,
  • Order XXIII Rule 1
  • Order 23 Rule 1(3) of CPC. As far as Order 23 Rule 1(4)
  • rule 10 of Order
  • Order 23 Rule 1 and Order 23 (1A) of CPC
  • Order 23 Rule 1 of CPC,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • SECTION 54 TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • 8 of 9 sub-rule (4).
  • Rule 10 of Order 1 of CPC
  • sub-rule (3),
  • Order 23 Rule 1(5)
  • provisions contained in Rules 1 to 14 of Order 32
  • Order 23 Rule (1)(A) of CPC,
  • Order 23 Rule 1(4) of CPC
  • Order 23 Rule 1(1) of CPC
  • sub-rule (1)
  • Order 23 Rule 1 (4)(b) and Order 23 Rule (1)(5) of CPC,
  • Order XXIII Rule 1
  • Order 23 Rule 1(3) of CPC. As far as Order 23 Rule 1(4)
  • rule 10 of Order
  • Order 23 Rule 1 and Order 23 (1A) of CPC
  • Order 23 Rule 1 of CPC,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, defendant no.5 in Special Civil Suit No.409 of 2010 filed in the Court at Surat, challenges the order dated 21.10.2015 passed by the Senior Civil Judge, Surat, which permitted the plaintiff to withdraw the suit unconditionally. The suit was originally filed by respondent no.7 (plaintiff) for execution of a document in relation to property owned by defendant no.1. The plaintiff had also sought to restrain defendants from alienating the property. The petitioner had filed an application challenging the suit on the ground of limitation and referred to an earlier suit filed in 1994 concerning the same property. The Trial Court rejected the petitioner’s application without notice to him, and subsequently, the plaintiff filed an application declaring a settlement outside court and sought to withdraw the suit, which was allowed by the Trial Court. The petitioner then filed the present petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India seeking to quash the order permitting withdrawal and to direct the trial court to decide the suit on merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Trial Court erred in permitting the plaintiff to withdraw the suit unconditionally without issuing notice to the defendants, particularly defendant no.5.
  2. Whether the petitioner’s right to claim costs or to oppose the withdrawal was prejudiced by the order allowing unconditional withdrawal without notice.
  3. Whether defendant no.5, holding only a power of attorney and rights under an agreement to sell, has sufficient proprietary interest to object to the plaintiff’s unconditional withdrawal of the suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The Trial Court violated procedural requirements under Order 23 Rule 1(4)(b) and Rule 1(5) of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) by permitting unconditional withdrawal without notice to defendants.
  • Unconditional withdrawal without notice adversely affects the petitioner’s rights, including the right to claim costs.
  • Under Order 23 Rule 1(A) CPC, defendants have a right to apply for transposition as plaintiffs when a suit is withdrawn, and the Court must consider if the applicant has a substantial question to be decided.
  • The petitioner had a pending application (Exh.22) challenging the suit on limitation grounds, which was not decided before withdrawal.
  • Defendant no.5, though a power of attorney holder, claims that defendants no.1, 3, and 4 colluded with the plaintiff to wipe out his rights in the property, thus opposing unconditional withdrawal.
  • Relied on precedents including B.Battabhirmayva v. Gopalakrishnayya, Jagdish Chander Dhawan v. Karam Chand Mehtra, and Suresh Chandra Chaudhary v. Ranjana Devi to support the need for notice before withdrawal.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The plaintiff has an absolute right as dominus litis to withdraw the suit unconditionally and this right cannot be questioned by defendants.
  • The petitioner/defendant no.5 had not filed a written statement before the suit was permitted to be withdrawn.
  • The petitioner cannot claim costs as he did not actively defend the suit.
  • The application Exh.22 relied upon by the petitioner was decided prior to the withdrawal of the suit, contrary to the petitioner’s claim.
  • Relied on the judgment of this Court in Manoramya Resorts and Hotels Pvt. Ltd. v. Tinaben Behram Mehta to assert the plaintiff’s absolute right to withdraw the suit.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
B.Battabhirmayva v. Gopalakrishnayya [1983 (0) Supreme (AP) 177] Requirement of notice to defendants before permitting unconditional withdrawal of suit. Referenced by petitioner to support argument that withdrawal without notice is improper.
Jagdish Chander Dhawan v. Karam Chand Mehtra [1967 (0) Supreme (Del) 172] Procedural safeguards in suit withdrawal under CPC. Relied upon by petitioner for procedural compliance before withdrawal.
Suresh Chandra Chaudhary v. Ranjana Devi [1988 (0) Supreme (Pat) 338] Notice and rights of defendants in suit withdrawal. Used by petitioner to contend for notice and protection of defendant rights.
Manoramya Resorts and Hotels Pvt. Ltd. v. Tinaben Behram Mehta [2020 (1) AIJ (DG) 133] Absolute right of plaintiff to withdraw suit unconditionally. Applied by Court to uphold plaintiff’s right to withdraw suit without objection from defendants.
Anil Kumar Singh v. Vijay Pal Singh [2017 (13) Scale 756] Liberty of plaintiff to withdraw suit and limited rights of defendant to object except for costs. Followed by Court to confirm that plaintiff’s right to withdraw is absolute and defendants cannot object except to seek costs.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the provisions of Order 23 Rule 1 and Rule 1A of the CPC concerning withdrawal of suits. It noted that the plaintiff has the right to abandon or withdraw a suit at any time after institution, subject to safeguards only when the plaintiff is a minor or similarly protected person. The Court emphasized that the provisions do not require notice to defendants before permitting unconditional withdrawal, although defendants may claim costs under sub-rule (4).

The Court further analyzed the petitioner’s status as defendant no.5, who holds only a power of attorney and rights under an agreement to sell, which does not confer proprietary interest superior to defendants no.1, 3, and 4, the actual owners. Since these owners did not object to withdrawal, the petitioner’s objection was considered untenable. The Court referred to binding precedent, including the Apex Court’s ruling in Anil Kumar Singh v. Vijay Pal Singh, which affirms the plaintiff’s absolute right to withdraw a suit and limits defendants’ rights to object except for costs.

The petitioner did not seek costs in the present petition. The Court found no merit in the contention that notice was mandatory before withdrawal. The Court thus upheld the impugned order allowing unconditional withdrawal.

Holding and Implications

The Court DISMISSED the petition challenging the order permitting the plaintiff to withdraw the suit unconditionally and disposed of the related civil application.

The direct effect of this decision is to confirm the absolute right of a plaintiff to withdraw a suit unconditionally without notice to defendants, except that defendants may seek costs if they so choose. No broader precedent altering the established law was set. The petitioner, lacking superior proprietary interest and having not sought costs, could not challenge the withdrawal successfully.

    RAMESHBHAI CHHELSHANKERBHAI OZA v. HEIRS AND LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES OF DECEASED

    C/SCA/15871/2016 ORDER DATED: 17/09/2024

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

    R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 15871 of 2016 With

    CIVIL APPLICATION (FOR BRINGING HEIRS) NO. 1 of 2024 In R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 15871 of 2016

    ==========================================================

    RAMESHBHAI CHHELSHANKERBHAI OZA

    Versus

    HEIRS AND LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES OF DECEASED & ORS. ========================================================== Appearance:

    MR RAJESH K SAVJANI(2225) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1 MR DHAVAL D VYAS(3225) for the Respondent(s) No. 7 MR DIPAN DESAI(2481) for the Respondent(s) No. 6 MR. BHAUMIK DHOLARIYA(7009) for the Respondent(s) No. 1.1,1.2,3,4 NOTICE SERVED BY DS for the Respondent(s) No. 2 SERVED BY AFFIX(N) for the Respondent(s) No. 5 ==========================================================

    CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE J. C. DOSHI

    Date : 17/09/2024

    ORAL ORDER

    1. Instant petition is filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India with following reliefs :-

    "A) Hon'ble Court be pleased to issue a writ of Certiorari or any other appropriate writ order or direction in the nature of Certiorari quashing and setting aside order dated 21.10.2015 passed by Court No.19 Senior Civil Judge Surat, below exh.48 in Special Civil Suit No.409 of 2010 and be further pleased to direct the trial Court to adjudicate and decide Special Civil Suit No.409 of 2010 on its own merit.

    (B) Pending hearing and final disposal of this petition Hon'ble Court be pleased to stay the execution, implementation, operation and enforcement of order dated 21.10.2015 passed below exh.48 by Court No.19 Senior Civil Judge, Surat in Special Civil Suit No.409 of 2010.

    Page 1 of 9

    (C) Pending hearing and final disposal of this petition be pleased to restrain respondent no. 1 to 7 herein from dealing with suit property of Special Civil Suit No. 409 of 2010 pending before 18th Court of Additional Senior Civil Judge Surat in any manner.

    (D) Pending hearing and final disposal of this petition be pleased to direct the respondent no. 1 to 7 to maintain status quo in relation to suit property of Special Civil Suit No. 409 of 2010.

    (E) Be pleased to grant any other and further relief as think just and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case and in the interest of justice."

    2. Facts of the case are as under :-

    2.1. The petitioner herein is defendant no.5. Respondent no.7 - plaintiff filed SCS No.409 of 2010 for execution of document in favour of the plaintiff on the basis of agreement alleged to have been executed in favour of one Maya Corporation in relation to property owned by defendant no.1 in the Court at Surat. Along with suit, application Exh. 5 was also made praying for restraining the defendants from alienating the subject land. The petitioner submitted application Exh.22 disclosing that prayer in relation to rejection of suit as the same is barred by period of limitation. The petitioner pointed out in the said application that earlier suit SCS No.20 of 1994 was filed in relation to subject land. The petitioner submitted this application to dismiss the suit. Thereafter, after 4 years, learned Trial Court without issuing notice to the petitioner or his advocate rejected the application observing that application is filed to delay the proceedings. At the time of applying for certified copy of the

    Page 2 of 9

    order, the petitioner came to know that by order dated 09.12.2010 below Exh.24, application filed by defendant no.2 and 7, Trial Court while rejecting the application for adjournment has closed right of the petitioner of filing written statement. The plaintiff thereafter submitted application Exh.48 declaring that settlement in relation to suit property is arrived outside Court, therefore, the plaintiff may be permitted to withdraw SCS No.409 of 2010. Learned Trial Court allowed the said application vide order dated 21.10.2015. Hence, present petition.

    3. Heard learned advocate Mr.Savjani for the petitioner and learned advocates appearing for other side.

    4. In essence, the petitioner who is defendant no.5 in the suit, challenges withdrawal purshish at Exh.48 and consequent order below it permitting the original plaintiff to withdraw the suit unconditionally. Learned advocate Mr.Savjani for the petitioner challenges the impugned order on two grounds, firstly he would submit that in view of Order 23 Rule 1 (4)(b) and Order 23 Rule (1)(5) of CPC, without issuing notice to the defendants, the Court cannot permit the plaintiff to withdraw the suit unconditional. It is further submitted that if plaintiff is permitted to withdraw the suit unconditional without issuing notice to the defendant, it would adversely affect the right of the petitioner involved in the suit. He would further submit that since before permitting plaintiff to withdraw suit unconditionally, notice is not issued to the defendant, his right to claim for cost is also prejudiced.

    4.1. Referring to Order 23 Rule (1)(A) of CPC, learned advocate

    Page 3 of 9

    for the petitioner submits that when suit is withdrawn or abandoned by the plaintiff under Order 23 Rule 1 of CPC, the defendant can apply for transposition as plaintiff under Rule 10 of Order 1 of CPC and the Court shall in considering such application, has due regard to the question whether the applicant has substantial question to be decided as against any of other defendants. It is submitted that in view of above stated provisions, learned Trial Court has committed serious error in not issuing notice to the defendants while permitting the plaintiff to withdraw the suit unconditional. It is submitted that during pendency of the suit, defendant no.5 has filed application Exh.22 for staying of the suit and it was pending for decision for years and was kept pending till suit is withdrawn unconditional.

    4.2. Making above submissions, learned advocate Mr.Savjani submit to allow this petition and to interfere with the impugned order.

    4.3. To buttress his contentions, more particularly contention that defendant should be issued notice prior to permitting the plaintiff to withdraw the suit unconditional, learned advocate for the petitioner has relied on following judgments :-

    (i) B.Battabhirmayva v/s. Gopalakrishnayya [1983 (0) Supreme (AP) 177]

    (ii) Jagdish Chander Dhawan v/s. Karam Chand Mehtra [1967 (0) Supreme (Del) 172].

    (iii) Suresh Chandra Chaudhary v/s. Ranjana Devi [1988

    (0) Supreme (Pat) 338].

    Page 4 of 9

    5. On the other hand, learned Senior Counsel Mr.Dhaval Vyas for the respondent no.7 / plaintiff referring to judgment of this Court in the case of Manoramya Resorts and Hotels Pvt. Ltd. v/s. Tinaben Behram Mehta [2020 (1) AIJ (DG) 133] would submit that plaintiff has right to withdraw the suit unconditional as plaintiff is dominus litus and it is absolute right and same cannot be questioned by defendants. It is further submitted that defendant who is questioning unconditional withdrawal of the suit has not filed written statement till learned Trial Court permitted the plaintiff to withdraw the suit unconditional. It is submitted that the defendant who is petitioner before this Court has no right to even ask for cost as he has not entered into defence till date, the suit is permitted to be withdrawn unconditional. It is further submitted that application Exh.22 which is relied by the petitioner is decided much prior to withdrawal of the suit preciously on 14.08.2015, whereas, the suit is withdrawn unconditional on 21.10.2015. It is submitted that it is incorrect to say that application Exh.22 remained undecided till suit is permitted to withdrawn unconditional.

    5.1. Upon above submissions, learned Senior Counsel Mr.Vyas while supporting impugned order, submits to dismiss the petition.

    6. Having heard learned advocates for both the sides, let refer Order 23 Rule 1 and Order 23 (1A) of CPC :-

    "1. Withdrawal of suit or abandonment of part of claim.—

    (1) At any time after the institution of a suit, the plaintiff may as against all or any of the defendants abandon his suit or abandon a part of his claim:

    Page 5 of 9

    Provided that where the plaintiff is a minor or other person to whom the provisions contained in rules 1 to 14 of Order XXXII extend, neither the suit nor any part of the claim shall be abandoned without the leave of the Court.

    (2) An application for leave under the proviso to sub-rule

    (1) shall be accompanied by an affidavit of the next friend and also, if the minor or such other person is represented by a pleader, by a certificate of the pleader to the effect that the abandonment proposed is, in his opinion, for the benefit of the minor or such other person.

    (3) Where the Court is satisfied,—

    (a) that a suit must fail by reason of some formal defect, or

    (b) that there are sufficient grounds for allowing the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit for the subject matter of suit or part of a claim, It may, on such terms as it thinks fit grant the plaintiff permission to withdraw from such suit or such part of the claim with liberty to institute a fresh suit in respect of the subject-matter of such suit or such part of the claim.

    (4) Where the plaintiff—

    (a) abandons any suit or part of claim under sub-rule (1), or

    (b) withdraws from a suit or part of a claim without the permission referred to in sub-rule (3), he shall be liable for such costs as the Court may award and shall be precluded from instituting any fresh suit in respect of such subject- matter or such part of the claim.

    (5) Nothing in this rule shall be deemed to authorise the Court to permit one of several plaintiffs to abandon a suit or part of a claim under sub-rule (1), or to withdraw, under sub-rule (3), any suit or part of a claim, without the consent of the other plaintiff.

    1A.When transposition of defendants as plaintiffs may be permitted.—Where a suit is withdrawn or abandoned by a plaintiff under rule 1, and a defendant applies to be transposed as a plaintiff under rule 10 of Order I the Court shall, in considering such application, have due regard to the question whether the applicant has a substantial question to be decided as against any of the other defendants."

    Page 6 of 9

    7. Plain reading of Order 23 Rule 1(1) of CPC indicates that after the institution of suit, the plaintiff may abandon suit against all the defendants or any of the defendants or part thereof of his claim. Embargo on unconditional withdrawal is that if the suit is filed by the minor or person to whom the provisions contained in Rules 1 to 14 of Order 32 extend, suit cannot be permitted to withdrawn unconditional without leave of the Court. When suit is withdrawn with a view to file fresh suit, procedure is laid down in Order 23 Rule 1(3) of CPC. As far as Order 23 Rule 1(4) is concerned, it permits defendant to raise issue of cost. Order 23 Rule 1(5) applies to case where amongst several plaintiffs, one plaintiff wants withdraw or abandon the suit.

    8. Learned advocate Mr.Savjani for the petitioner relied upon Order 23 Rule 1(4) of CPC to submit that in case plaintiff withdraws the suit unconditional, notice is required to be issued to the defendants. To be noted that defendant no.5 is power of attorney holder of defendant nos.1,3 and 4. Defendant no.5 is joined as party in the suit on the ground that defendant no.1,3 and 4 have executed agreement to sell in his favour with declaration. Thus, it can be noticed that defendant no.5 has no individual proprietary interest in the suit. Section 54 of Transfer of Property Act speaks that agreement to sell does not create any right, title or interest in the property. Thus, defendant no.5 has no title, right or interest in the suit better than defendant no.1,3 and 4 who are owners of the property. It also noticeable that defendant no.1,3 and 4 have no objection in withdrawal of the suit. To be further noticed that defendant nos.1,3 and 4 have not

    Page 7 of 9

    questioned withdrawal of the suit conditionally or unconditionally. Based on agreement to sell, defendant no.5 has no better right to contest suit proceedings. At the most defendant no.5 steps in the shoes of title holder i.e defendant nos.1,3 and 4. Learned advocate Mr.Savjani submits that defendant no.1,3 and 4 have colluded with plaintiff to wipe out defendant no.5's right in disputed property. Hence, conditional withdrawal is seriously objected. Submission by learned advocate Mr.Savjani failed to afloat. Defendant no.5 who rides on agreement to sell qua disputed property may have right to get registered sale deed but it is only against defendant nos.1,3 and

    4. It is altogether different cause of action. Upon such reason, defendant no.5 cannot object plaintiff from withdrawing his suit that too unconditionally. In above circumstances, defendant no.5 cannot stand taller than defendant nos.1,3 and 4.

    9. Apt to note that this Court in the case of Manoramya Resorts and Hotels Pvt. Ltd. (supra), more particularly in para

    13.6 and 13.7 held that it is absolute right of the plaintiff to withdraw the suit unconditional.

    10. In case of Anil Kumar Singh v/s. Vijay Pal Singh [2017 (13) Scale 756], the Hon'ble Apex Court addressed this issue. Para 24 is relevant which reads as under :-

    "24) In our considered opinion, when the plaintiff files an application under Order XXIII Rule 1 and prays for permission to withdraw the suit, whether in full or part, he is always at liberty to do so and in such case, the defendant has no right to raise any objection to such prayer being made by the plaintiff except to ask for payment of the cost to him by the plaintiff as provided in

    Page 8 of 9

    sub-rule (4). "

    11. It is said by Hon'ble Apex Court that plaintiff would be always at liberty to withdraw the suit and defendant has no right to raise any objection to such prayer made by the plaintiff except to ask for payment of cost to him by the plaintiff as provided in sub-rule 4.

    12. In view of above, the plaintiff has right to withdraw the suit at any time. Noticeably the petitioner / defendant has not asked to pay cost even in the present petition.

    13. In view of above, the petition is dismissed. The Civil Application also stands disposed of.

    (J. C. DOSHI,J)

    SATISH

    Page 9 of 9

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    RAMESHBHAI CHHELSHANKERBHAI OZA v. HEIRS AND LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES OF DECEASED
    (Sep 17, 2024)