(1)
Court No. - 30 Case :- MATTERS UNDER ARTICLE 227 No. - 2139 of
2015
Petitioner :- Heera Lal
Respondent :- State Of U.P. & Another
Counsel for Petitioner :- Ray Sahab Yadav,Surendra Kumar Yadav
Counsel for Respondent :- C.S.C.,Rama Nand Gupta
Hon'ble Suneet Kumar,J.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri S.K. Chaturvedi, learned counsel for the respondents. The defendant/petitioner is assailing the order dated 25.08.2010 passed by the Additional District Judge, Court No. 2, Jhansi in Misc. Civil Appeal No. 59 of 2013, Heera Lal Versus Praveen Rai and order dated 31.05.2013 passed by the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Jhansi in Misc. Suit No. 05 of 2013 arising from Original Suit No. 178 of 2009, Heera Lal Versus Praveen Rai rejecting the petitioner's application under Order IX Rule
13.
The facts in brief is that the second respondent Praveen Rai instituted a suit being Original Suit No. 178 of 2007 against the petitioner for specific performance which was allowed exparte on 08.07.2008. The petitioner made an application under Order IX Rule 13 of Code of Civil Procedure (C.P.C.) on 28.01.2009 which was allowed on 09.02.2012. Aggrieved, the respondent no. 2 preferred an appeal being Misc. Civil Appeal No. 30 of 2012, Praveen Rai Versus Heera Lal which was allowed on 23.11.2012 for the reason that the application filed under Order IX Rule Rule 13 was time Neutral Citation No. - 2015:AHC:74771
(2)
barred and was filed without delay condonation application. On remand the trial court on 31.05.2013 rejected the application of the petitioner under Order IX Rule 13 on merits, as well as, for the reason that no application for delay condonation application was filed. Aggrieved, the petitioner preferred an appeal being Misc. Civil Appeal No. 59 of 2011 which was dismissed on
11.07.2013.
It is not being disputed by learned counsel for the petitioner that delay condonation application, admittedly, was not filed along with the application, apart from that he would not dispute that summons was not served upon the petitioner.
Submission of learned counsel for the petitioner is that the petitioner may be given an opportunity to contest the case on merit.
The language of the rule Order IX Rule 13 is plain, express and unambiguous and the grounds mentioned therein are exhaustive.
As provided in Rule 6, the suit may proceed ex parte against the defendant only when it is proved by the plaintiff to the satisfaction of the court that the defendant did not appear even though the summons was duly served. In that case, an ex parte decree may be passed against him. Therefore, if the defendant satisfies the court that the summons was not duly served upon him, the court must set aside the ex parte decree passed against him.
The expression "sufficient cause" has not been
(3)
defined anywhere in the Code. It is a question to be determined in the facts and circumstances of each case. The words "sufficient cause" must be liberally construed to enable the court to exercise powers ex debito justitaie. A party should not be deprived of hearing unless there has been something equivalent to misconduct or gross negligence on his part. Necessary materials should be placed on record to show that the applicant was diligent and vigilant. Improper advice of advocate may be a good ground to set aside ex parte decree but it cannot be accepted as a sufficient cause in all cases. Conversely, if "sufficient cause" is not shown, ex parte decree cannot be set aside. "The right and this duty is a sine qua non of judicial procedure. An order setting aside ex parte decree is judicial, it must be supported by reasons. (Refer: Mahesh Yadav vs. Rajeshwar Singh1)
If there are delaying tactics and non-cooperation on the part of the party, he cannot seek indulgence of the court. The test to be applied is whether the party honestly intended to remain present at the hearing of the suit and did his best to do so.
In Arjun Singh vs. Mohindra Kumar2 Supreme Court observed that every good cause is a sufficient cause and must offer an explanation for non- appearance. The only difference between a "good cause"
and "sufficient cause" is that the requirement of a good cause is complied with on a lesser degree of proof than
(4)
that of a "sufficient cause".
When an application for setting aside ex parte decree is made by the defendant, the court should consider whether the defendant was prevented by
"sufficient cause" from appearing before the court when the suit was called out for hearing. "Sufficient cause" is a question of fact.
The following causes have been held to be sufficient for the absence of the defendant;
1. bona fide mistake as to the date of hearing;
2. Late arrival of a train;
3. sickness of the counsel;
4. fraud of the opposite party;
5. mistake of pleader in noting wrong date in diary;
6. negligence of next friend or guardian in case of minor plaintiff or defendant;
7. death of relative of a party;
8. imprisonment of party;
9. strike of advocates; 10.no instructions pursis by a lawyer, etc. The following causes, on the other hand, have been held not to be sufficient for absence of the defendant for setting aside an ex parte decree;
1. dilatory tactics;
2. bald statement of noting wrong date in diary;
3. negligence of party;
4. counsel busy in other court;
5. suit of high valuation;
6. absence of defendant after prayer for adjournment is refused;
7. hardship of defendant;
8. absence to get undue advantage;
9. mere thinking that the case will not be called out; not taking part in proceedings, etc.
The Supreme Court in Parimal vs. Veena3was considering the scope and ambit of an application under
(5)
Order 9 Rule 13. In the facts of that case, the trial court recorded that the notice of the petition was served upon the applicant who refused to accept the notice, subsequently, when served the applicant again refused to accept the notice thereafter, the notice was published in a daily and was sent to the applicant at her address. In these circumstances, the application under Order
9 Rule 13 filed by the applicant on the plea that she was not residing at the said residence but was residing with her brother. The trial court rejected the application. The Supreme Court held that the presumption of publications stood rebutted by a bald statement made by the applicant that she was living at a different address with her brother. The Apex Court reversed the order passed by the High Court, as the application was not considered in the right perspective regarding substituted service. The Court observed as follows:
"However, in case the matter does not fall within the four corners of Order 9 Rule 13 CPC, the Court has no jurisdiction to set aside an ex parte decree. The manner in which the language of the second proviso to Order 9 Rule 13 CPC has been couched by the legislature makes it obligatory on the appellate Court not to interfere with an ex parte decree unless it meets the statutory requirement."
Material date for deciding "sufficient cause" for non-appearance by the defendant is the date on which ex parte decree was passed and not his previous negligence or past defaults. In G.P. Srivastava v. R.K. Raizada4, the Supreme Court observed:
"The 'sufficient cause' for non-appearance refers to the date on which the absence was made a ground for proceeding ex parte and cannot be stretched to rely
(6)
upon other circumstance anterior in time. If sufficient cause' is made out for non-appearance of the defendant on the date fixed for hearing when ex parte proceedings initiated against him, he cannot be penalized for his previous negligence which had been overlooked and thereby condoned earlier." Since the Code makes specific provision for setting aside ex parte decree, no inherent power can be exercised to set aside such decree.
As Rankin, L.J. stated, "I entirely dissent from the view that, if no case is made out under that rule (Rule 13), it is open to the learned Judge to enlarge the rule by talking about Section 151." (Refer: Manohar Lal vs. Seth Hira Lal5, K.B. Dutt vs. Shamsuddin Shah6).
Defendant against an ex-parte decree has two options (1) to file a regular appeal (2) to file an appeal for setting aside the order in terms of Order 9 Rule 13. Both the proceedings are available simultaneously. In Bhanu Kumar Jain v. Archana Kumar & Anr7, the Supreme Court held as follows:
"26. When an ex parte decree is passed, the defendant (apart from filing a review petition and a suit for setting aside the ex parte decree on the ground of fraud) has two clear options, one, to file an appeal and another to file an application for setting aside the order in terms of Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code. He can take recourse to both the proceedings simultaneously but in the event the appeal is dismissed as a result whereof the ex parte decree passed by the trial court merges with the order passed by the appellate court, having regard 9 to Explanation appended to
(7)
Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code a petition under Order 9 Rule 13 would not be maintainable. However, Explanation I appended to the said provision does not suggest that the converse is also true."
Applying the law in the facts and circumstances of the case, the application under Order 9 Rule 13 would reflect that the petitioner alleged that he could not appear on the date of hearing as the summons was not served upon the petitioner, at no point of time, he had refused to accept the summon. Further, the application dated 28.01.2009 was moved when the petitioner came to know of the ex parte decree in 2009. The courts below have noted that the summons was duly sent to the address of the petitioner. The petitioner upon reading the summons not only refused to accept it but the petitioner and his son made an attempt to captivate the person who had gone to serve the summon, consequently, the summons was pasted at the door of the petitioner in the presence of two witnesses. The petitioner in his application has not objected regarding the notice being pasted in the presence of two witnesses neither the signature of the witnesses has been disputed nor they were summoned to verify the truth. The courts further noted that in the execution proceeding being Execution Case No. 29 of 2008 notices were served upon the petitioner on 04.11.2008, which has not been disputed by the petitioner, whereas, in the application for recall of the judgment and decree it has been stated that the petitioner had no knowledge of the exparte proceedings, until 2009, whereas, admittedly, petitioner
(8)
had received the summons in the execution case arising from the same judgment and decree on 04.11.2008, the application for recall was filed on 28.01.2009. That apart despite remand of the case by the appellate court, petitioner did not file any application for condonation of the delay. The Appellate court having noted in its order that the application being time barred was not accompanied by a delay condonation application. In such circumstances, the application under Order 9 rule 13 was rightly rejected.
Having due regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, I am not inclined to interfere with the impugned order.
The writ petition is, accordingly, dismissed. No order as to costs.
Order Date :- 12.5.2015 kkm