ORDER
The present petition has been filed challenging the order dated 24/07/2024 passed by the trial Court whereby allowing the application submitted by present respondent No.3 under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC.
2. The facts in brief for the purpose of disposal of present petition are that the suit has been filed by the plaintiffs who are husband and wife against the present petitioner who is brother of plaintiff No.1. Thus, the plaintiff No.1 and defendant No.1 are real brothers. It has been asserted in the plaint that they are the sons of Ganpad Singh. It has further contended in the plaint that in the year 2008 their father Ganpad Singh had carried out partition of the properties among the plaintiff No.1 and defendant No.1 as well as their another brother. It is contended that the defendant No.1 is not respecting the said mutual partition carried out by their father Ganpad Singh and is trying to encroach on the land which has come to the share of plaintiff No.1 and thus declaration has been sought that in respect of some land on which the defendant No.1 is alleged to be carrying out encroachment. The defendant
1
No.1/present petitioner filed written statement and in the written statement he admitted to the fact that their father Ganpad Singh had carried out partition of the property among the plaintiff No.1, defendant No.1 as well as their another brother. However, it was denied that the defendant No.1 is not respecting the partition but submitted that in fact he is raising construction only on the portion which has fallen to his share.
3. Their father Ganpad Singh, who is alleged to have partition the property amongst his son in the year 2008 filed application under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC for impleading himself as defendant in his suit on the assertion that he is the actual owner of the property being father of defendant No.1 as well as plaintiff No.1 and his sons are in occupation of different portions of the property as per the general consent among the family members but infact he still holds title over the entire property thus, he may be heard in the suit to place necessary facts which are relevant for adjudication of the dispute.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner i.e. defendant No.1 had relied on the judgment of Division Bench of this Court in the case of Sunil Vs. Satya Narayan Dubey reported in AIR 1985 MP 199 to contend that the judgment that would be passed in the suit would be a judgment in persona and not judgment in rem and their father would not be bound by the judgment and there is no necessity for the Court to have allowed impleadment of Ganpad Singh as party defendant in the suit.
5. The trial Court has taken note of the provisions of Order 1 Rule 10 CPC as also Order 1 Rule 3 CPC which states that all persons may be joined in one suit as defendants where if separate suits were brought against such
2
persons in a common question of law or facts would arise.
6. From the facts as obtaining in the present case it is clear that the plaintiff as well as original defendant No.1 have a common ground that their father Ganpad Singh has partitioned the property amongst his sons including the plaintiff No.1 and defendant No.1. Thus, they do not dispute the title of their father to the property. Now their father has sought to enter the arena stating that he still holds the title of the entire property and the sons are occupying their respective portions as per his consent. Thus, he may be allowed to be impleaded as defendant
7. From the aforesaid facts of the case it is clear that the dispute is of partition of property by Ganpad Singh and now Ganpad Singh contends that he still holding the title of the property. Thus, in terms of Order 1 Rule 3 CPC even if Ganpad Singh bring some separate suit the common question would arise relating to partition between the family members and the ancillary question would arise about the share of each member of family in such partition. Order 1 Rule 3 CPC reads as under:
3. Who may be joined as defendants.- All persons may be joined in one suit as defendants where-
(a) any right to relief in respect of, or arising out of, the same act or transaction or series of acts or transactions is alleged to exist against such persons, whether jointly, severally or in the alternative; and
(b) if separate suits were brought against such persons, any common question of law or fact would arise.
8. As per Order 1 Rule 10 (2) of CPC, the court is having power to join the name of any person as the plaintiff or defendant whose presence before the Court is necessary in order to enable the court to properly, effectively and completely adjudicate upon all the matters and settle all the question
3
(VIVEK JAIN)
JUDGE
involved in the suit. As per judgment of Apex Court in the case of Vidur Impex & Traders Private Ltd. and others Vs. Tosh Apartments Private Limited and others reported in 2012 (8) SCC 384 wherein it has been held in para 41 that a necessary party is a person who ought to be joined as party to the suit and in whose absence an effective decree cannot be passed by the court. It is further held that a proper party is a person whose presence would enable the court to completely, effectively and properly adjudicate upon all matters and issues, though he may not be a person in whose favour of or against whom a decree is to be passed.
9. Not only on the anvil of Order 1 of Rule 3 CPC but also on the anvil of Order 1 Rule 10 CPC, the applicant of the application under Order 1 Rule
10 CPC namely Ganpad Singh seems to be a proper party whose presence would enable the Court to completely, effectively and properly adjudicate upon all matters and issues even if he was not be a person in whose favour or against a decree is to be passed.
10. Consequently, no error is found in the order Annex.P/1 passed by the trial Court, the petition stands dismissed.
RS
4