Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

High Court of Delhi — Summary of Judgment (Oral) dated 23.08.2024

Factual and Procedural Background

These connected writ petitions (led by W.P.(C) 11620/2024 and several others listed in the judgment) were filed under Article 226 read with Section 227 of the Constitution of India. The petitioners are graduates in Bachelor of Dental Surgery (BDS) who enrolled for the MDS Batch 2020–2023 at PDM Dental College & Research Institute (referred to as respondent No. 4) in Haryana after qualifying NEET-MDS 2020 and securing counselling allotments. The petitioners completed their final MDS examinations (held in or after September 2023) and were issued provisional certificates by respondent No. 4.

On seeking recognition of their MDS degrees under Section 40 of the Dentists Act, 1948, the Dental Council of India (respondent No. 3) informed the petitioners that the degrees would not be recognised because the 2020–23 batch of respondent No. 4 was not recognised by it. The petitioners challenged the Dental Council of India’s refusal and sought issuance of writs (including mandamus for recognition of the MDS degree and compensation for loss of employment).

The Dental Council of India raised territorial jurisdiction and maintainability objections, noting relevant legal proceedings (including those relating to land, SARFAESI proceedings and internal disputes among college directors) pending in competent courts in the State of Haryana concerning respondent No. 4 college. The petitions were heard together and a common issue of territorial jurisdiction was identified for adjudication.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the writ petitions are maintainable before the High Court of Delhi, in view of the territorial jurisdiction requirements under Article 226 of the Constitution and the facts that the college awarding the MDS degrees is situated in Haryana and there are relevant legal proceedings pending in courts of Haryana?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • Petitioners relied on Regulation 23 of the Dental Council of India, Master of Dental Surgery Course Regulations, 2017, which they say mandates the grant of an MDS degree to any candidate declared successful in the examination.
  • They contended that once the MDS degree is issued by respondent No. 4, it must be recognised under Section 40 of the Dentists Act, 1948; refusal to recognise therefore contravenes that statutory framework and Regulation 23.
  • They submitted that the non-recognition of the MDS degrees awarded to the 2020–23 batch infringes fundamental rights, including the right to livelihood and the right to live with dignity under Article 21.
  • The petitioners pointed out that the college was listed as recognized for the relevant year on official websites of the State of Haryana and the Dental Council of India prior to enrolment.
  • In reply to territorial objections, petitioners argued that their grievance is against the Dental Council of India (whose Head Office is within Delhi’s territorial jurisdiction), and therefore the petitions are maintainable before this Court.

Respondent No. 3 (Dental Council of India) / Respondents' Arguments

  • Respondent No. 3 argued that respondent No. 4 college is situated in District Jhajjar, Haryana, and that several legal proceedings relevant to the college (including disputes over the land on which the college operates, SARFAESI proceedings and intra-management disputes) are pending in the competent courts of Haryana.
  • It was submitted that these facts are material to the issues of recognition and that the petitioners should approach the Hon'ble High Court of Punjab and Haryana (or other appropriate fora) instead; accordingly, the petitions should be dismissed on maintainability/territorial jurisdiction grounds.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India, (2004) 6 SCC 254 Doctrine of forum conveniens: even if a part of the cause of action arises within the territorial jurisdiction of a High Court, that fact alone may not compel the High Court to decide the matter; the Court may decline jurisdiction where forum conveniens applies. The Court extracted and relied on Kusum Ingots to emphasise that a mere presence of part of the cause of action in Delhi (i.e., the Dental Council of India’s office) is not determinative and that the doctrine of forum conveniens permits declining jurisdiction in appropriate cases.
State of Goa v. Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd., (2023) 7 SCC 791 Clarification of territorial jurisdiction under clause (2) of Article 226: to invoke writ jurisdiction where seat of Government/authority is outside territory, at least part of the cause of action must arise within the territorial jurisdiction; the Court must assess whether pleaded facts constitute a material part of the cause of action. The Court relied on the principles in State of Goa to state the tests for territorial jurisdiction — namely, that the petitioning party must disclose that integral facts constituting part of the cause of action arose within the High Court’s territorial jurisdiction and that the pleaded facts must have a nexus with the relief sought.
Chinteshwar Steel Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, 2012 SCC OnLine Del 5264 For tribunals or statutory authorities having pan-India jurisdiction, the situs of the tribunal may not be the sole determinant for identifying the jurisdictional High Court. The Court noted this authority to observe that jurisdictional questions for pan-India bodies require nuanced application; however, it did not displace the core territorial considerations in the present facts concerning the college in Haryana and related local proceedings.
Cooke v. Gill, (1873) LR 8 CP 107 Classic definition of "cause of action": "every fact which it would be necessary for the plaintiff to prove, if traversed, in order to support his right to the judgment of the court." The Court cited the definition (as adopted by Indian authorities) to explain what constitutes a "cause of action" when assessing whether a part of it arose within the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court.
Bhagat Singh Bugga; Madanlal Jalan v. Madanlal; Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. v. Jharia Talkies & Cold Storage (P) Ltd.; S.S. Jain & Co. v. Union of India; New Horizons Ltd. v. Union of India These decisions (referenced in Kusum Ingots) illustrate instances where forum conveniens or related jurisdictional principles were invoked. The Court referenced these authorities (as cited in Kusum Ingots) as supporting precedents for invoking forum conveniens in appropriate cases; they were used to buttress the territorial/fora analysis rather than as independently applied authorities in detailed analysis.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by identifying the common question of territorial jurisdiction/maintainability arising from the similar facts across the connected petitions. The petitioners relied on the location of the Dental Council of India's (DCI) Head Office within Delhi as the basis for invoking the jurisdiction of this Court. The Court examined the factual matrix: the MDS degrees were awarded by PDM Dental College & Research Institute, situated in District Jhajjar, Haryana; there were multiple pending legal proceedings in Haryana concerning the college (including SARFAESI proceedings, disputes regarding the land and intra-management disputes).

Applying settled principles from the cited precedents, the Court observed:

  • Under Kusum Ingots, even if a part of the cause of action arises within a High Court's territorial jurisdiction, that alone need not be determinative; the Court may decline jurisdiction invoking the doctrine of forum conveniens.
  • Under State of Goa, when clause (2) of Article 226 is invoked, the High Court must examine whether, on the averments treated as true, at least part of the cause of action arose within its territory; the facts pleaded must constitute an essential or integral part of the cause of action and must have a nexus with the relief sought.
  • The Court acknowledged Chinteshwar Steel for the proposition that the situs of pan-India tribunals is not always the marker for jurisdiction, but noted that the present dispute principally concerns the college in Haryana and local proceedings affecting recognition.

On applying these principles to the pleaded facts, the Court concluded that the reasons for the Dental Council of India’s non-recognition of the degrees stemmed from legal proceedings and disputes situated in Haryana relating to respondent No. 4 college. Given the local character of those disputes and their relevance to the recognition question, the Court held that Delhi was not the appropriate forum in the exercise of its discretionary writ jurisdiction and that the petitions should be dismissed on territorial jurisdiction grounds.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The connected writ petitions are DISMISSED ON GROUNDS OF TERRITORIAL JURISDICTION. Pending applications related to the petitions were also disposed of.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on parties: The petitioners' claims in the High Court of Delhi were dismissed solely for lack of territorial jurisdiction. The Court explicitly left open the petitioners' right to approach the appropriate forum of competent jurisdiction (for example, courts in Haryana) for redressal of their grievances in accordance with law.
  • No new legal principle was announced; the judgment applied and followed established authorities on forum conveniens and territorial jurisdiction under Article 226 (notably Kusum Ingots and State of Goa) to the facts at hand.
  • The Court ordered that the judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith (administrative direction).

Judge: Hon'ble Ms. Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma (Oral judgment). Date: August 23, 2024.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    DR SUPREETI CHAHAL  v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.

    W.P.(C) 11620/2024 & Connected matters Page 1 of 21

    $~57 (connected matters 57 to 60, 63, 64, 66 to 68 & 70 to 74 & 86 & 4 to 7)

    * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

    % Date of Decision: 23.08.2024

    + W.P.(C) 11620/2024

    DR SUPREETI CHAHAL .....Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Mr. Ashok Kr. Kashyap, SPC with Mr. Kabir Kr. Hazarika, GP for R-1

    Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit

    Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq

    Srivastava, Ms. Anum

    Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar

    and Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur,

    Advocates for R-2/DCI

    (58)

    + W.P.(C) 11622/2024

    DR PRITI ....Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    versus

    1

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit

    Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq

    Srivastava, Ms. Anum

    Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar

    and Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur,

    Advocates for R-2/DCI

    (59)

    + W.P.(C) 11623/2024

    PAWAN KUMAR .....Petitioner Through: Mr. Manoj Kumar Garg and Mr. Pulkit Atal, Advocates versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Ms. Nidhi Raman CGSC with Mr. Zubin Singh Advocates

    for

    R-1/UOI

    Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    Gulati, M.r Abhijit

    Chakravarty, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Tanishq

    Srivastava, Ms. Anun Hussain and Mr. Sourabh Kumar,

    Advocates for R-3

    (60)

    + W.P.(C) 11624/2024

    DR HEENA KAPOOR ........Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    2

    versus UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Mr. Piyush Gupta CGSC with Mr. Prateek Gupta, Mr. Satjeet Gill, Mrs. Kamya Chawla, Mr. Pramod Kumar, Mr. Sujeet

    Kumar Advocates and

    Mr. Karan Shankar Mani,

    Government Pleader for

    UOI/R-1

    Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit

    Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq

    Srivastava, Ms. Anum

    Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar

    and Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur,

    Advocates for R-2/DCI

    (63)

    + W.P.(C) 11630/2024

    DR. NARENDER SINGH .....Petitioner Through: Mr. Anurag Abhishek, Adv. versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Mr. Karan Shankar Mani, Government Pleader for UOI/ R-1

    Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit

    Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq

    Srivastava, Ms. Anum

    Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar

    3

    and Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur, Advocates for R-2/DCI

    (64)

    + W.P.(C) 11631/2024

    DR AMIT ARORA .....Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Mr. Jivesh Kumar Tiwari, Senior Panel counsel with Ms. Samiksha (GP) for R-1/UOI.

    (66)

    + W.P.(C) 11635/2024

    DR HARSHITA .....Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    .

    versus UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Ms. Shubhra Parashar and Mr. Virender Pratap Singh Charak Advocates for R-1/UOI

    Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit

    Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq

    Srivastava, Ms. Anum

    Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar

    and Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur,

    Advocates for R-2/DCI

    4

    (67)

    + W.P.(C) 11637/2024

    DR ARINDAM MALAKAR .....Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Mr Jivesh Tiwari SPC and Ms Samiksha Mittal GP for UOI/ R-1

    Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit

    Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq

    Srivastava, Ms. Anum

    Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar

    and Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur,

    Advocates for R-2/DCI

    (68)

    + W.P.(C) 11639/2024

    DR RIDDHIMA CHAUHAN .....Petitioner Through: Mr.Anurag Abhishek, Adv. versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit

    Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq

    Srivastava, Ms. Anum

    Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar

    and Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur,

    Advocates for R-2/DCI.

    5

    (70)

    + W.P.(C) 11641/2024

    DR PREETI CHAHAL .....Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Mr. Ashok Kr. Kashyap, SPC with Mr. Kabir Kr. Hazarika, GP for R-1

    Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit

    Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq

    Srivastava, Ms. Anum

    Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar

    and Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur,

    Advocates for R-2/DCI

    (71)

    + W.P.(C) 11643/2024

    DR. DEEPIKA MALIK .....Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Mr. Shouryendu Ray, Senior Panel Counsel for UOI/R-1

    Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit

    6

    Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq Srivastava, Ms. Anum Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar and Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur, Advocates for R-2/DCI

    (72)

    + W.P.(C) 11644/2024

    DR. MONIKA AHLAWAT .....Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Mr. Rakesh Kumar Dudeja with Mr. Deepak Chopra,

    Advocates for UOI/R-1

    Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit

    Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq

    Srivastava, Ms. Anum

    Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar

    and Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur,

    Advocates for R-2/DCI

    (73)

    + W.P.(C) 11650/2024

    DR NEHA SUNEJA .....Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    versus

    UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS .....Respondents Through: Mr. Umang Chopra and Ms.

    7

    Neha Rastogi, SPC with Ms. Tanisha verma, Mr. Karan Malhotra (GP) and Mr.Manish Kumar, Adv for UOI./R-1 Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq Srivastava, Ms. Anum Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar and Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur, Advocates for R-2/DCI

    (74)

    + W.P.(C) 11670/2024

    DR. KUNAL AMRIT .....Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Ms Neha Rastogi, SPC and Ms. Tanisha verma (GP) and

    Mr.Manish Kumar, Adv for

    UOI/ R-1

    Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit

    Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq

    Srivastava, Ms. Anum

    Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar

    and Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur,

    Advocates for R-2/DCI

    (86)

    + W.P.(C) 11709/2024

    DR GARIMA MANDERNA .....Petitioner

    8

    Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Ms. Archana Sharma and Mr. Lovekesh Aggarwal, Advocate for R-1/UOI

    Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit

    Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq

    Srivastava, Ms. Anum

    Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar

    and Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur,

    Advocates for R-2/DCI

    (4)

    + W.P.(C) 11108/2024

    DR VIKAS VASHISTH ......Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Mr. Piyush Gupta CGSC with Mr. Prateek Gupta Mr. Satjeet Gill Ms. Kamya Chawla, Mr.

    Pramod Kumar, Mr. Sujeet

    Kumar, Advocates and Mr.

    Arun Dhiman, GP for R-1/

    UOI

    Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    9

    Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq Srivastava, Ms. Anum Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar, Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur, Advocates for R-3/DCI

    (5)

    + W.P.(C) 11112/2024

    DR RIDDHI SIDHMUKH . .....Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Mr. Rahul sharma ( Sr panel Counsel) with Mr. Jitendra

    Kumar Tripathi ( GP) for UOI Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit

    Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq

    Srivastava, Ms. Anum

    Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar, Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur,

    Advocates for R-3/DCI

    (6)

    + W.P.(C) 11123/2024

    DR RAHUL DESWAL .....Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    10

    versus UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Ms. Nidhi Raman CGSC with Mr. Zubin Singh, Advocate,

    Mr. Prashant Rawat, Govt.

    Pleader and Mr. Kabir Singh, Advocate for R-1/UOI

    Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit

    Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq

    Srivastava, Ms. Anum

    Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar, Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur,

    Advocates for R-3/DCI

    (7)

    + W.P.(C) 11163/2024

    DR DEEPAK SINGH .....Petitioner Through: Mr. Nilava Bandyopadhyay, Adv.

    versus

    UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Respondents Through: Ms. Nidhi Raman CGSC with Zubin Singh, Advocate, Mr.

    Chetan Jadon, GP and Ms.

    Shivangi Rajawat, Advocate

    For R-1/UOI

    Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu

    Gulati, Mr. Aabhaas

    11

    Sukhramani, Mr. Abhijit Chakravarty, Mr. Tanishq Srivastava, Ms. Anum Hussain, Mr. Sourabh Kumar, Ms. Ramanpreet Kaur, Advocates for R-3/DCI

    CORAM:

    HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SWARANA KANTA SHARMA

    JUDGMENT

    SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J. (ORAL)

    CM APPL. 48337/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11620/2024 CM APPL. 48340/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11622/2024 CM APPL. 48341/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11623/2024 CM APPL. 48351/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11624/2024 CM APPL. 48360/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11630/2024 CM APPL. 48361/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11631/2024 CM APPL. 48368/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11635/2024 CM APPL. 48371/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11637/2024 CM APPL. 48373/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11639/2024 CM APPL. 48375/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11641/2024 CM APPL. 48377/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11643/2024 CM APPL. 48384/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11644/2024 CM APPL. 48392/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11650/2024 CM APPL. 48477/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11670/2024 CM APPL. 48677/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11709/2024 CM APPL. 45896/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11108/2024 CM APPL. 45969/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11112/2024 CM APPL. 45996/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11123/2024 CM APPL. 46172/2024 (exemption) in W.P.(C) 11163/2024

    1. Allowed, subject to all just exceptions.

    2. Applications stand disposed of.

    W.P.(C) 11620/2024, W.P.(C) 11622/2024, W.P.(C) 11623/2024, W.P.(C) 11624/2024, W.P.(C) 11630/2024, W.P.(C) 11631/2024,

    12

    W.P.(C) 11635/2024, W.P.(C) 11637/2024, W.P.(C) 11639/2024, W.P.(C) 11641/2024, W.P.(C) 11643/2024, W.P.(C) 11644/2024, W.P.(C) 11650/2024, W.P.(C) 11670/2024, W.P.(C) 11709/2024, W.P.(C) 11108/2024, W.P.(C) 11112/2024, W.P.(C) 11123/2024 and W.P.(C) 11163/2024

    3. By way of this common judgment, the above-captioned writ petitions shall be disposed of, since a common issue arises for adjudication in all these petitions on the basis of identical facts and contentions.

    4. These writ petitions, filed under Article 226 read with Section 227 of the Constitution of India, on behalf of the petitioners seek the following identical prayers:

    "i. Issue a Writ of Mandamus directing Respondent No. 3 to grant due recognition to the MDS degree of Petitioner issued by the Respondent No. 4; and

    ii. Issue appropriate order(s) directing the Respondents to pay adequate compensation to the Petitioner for the financial losses suffered beginning from June" 2023 till the date of issuance of duly recognised MDS degree by Respondent no. 3 for the loss of employment to the Petitioner; and

    iii. Issue any other appropriate writ, order or direction, as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case."

    5. Brief facts of the case, discernible from one of the petitions i.e. W.P.(C) 11620/2024, are that the petitioner, holding a recognized Bachelor"s degree in Dental Surgery from Dr. Bhimrao Ambedkar University, Agra, and registered with the Haryana State Dental Council, had appeared for the National Eligibility-Cum-Entrance Test for Masters of Dental Surgery, 2020 [„NEET-MDS 2020"]. Scoring 320 marks, the petitioner had surpassed the 50 percentile

    13

    cutoff for the General Category, allowing her to participate in the counselling process for the academic year 2020-2021. During counselling, she was allotted a seat in the MDS course in respondent no. 4 college i.e. PDM Dental College & Research Institute, PDM University, Haryana. Before accepting admission, the petitioner states that she had verified the authenticity and recognition status of the MDS course and had found the College listed as recognized for the 2020-2021 academic year on the official websites of Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 i.e. State of Haryana and Dental Council of India, respectively. After verification, the petitioner had enrolled in the MDS Batch 2020-2023 at respondent no. 4 College, after completing all requisite documentation and making fee payments. Thereafter, she had appeared in the final MDS examination in September, 2023. Following the exams, the petitioner and 23 other students had started encountering delays in the scheduling of their practical exams by the College. Concerned with the same, they had raised their grievance with the respondent no. 3 i.e. Dental Council of India. In response, respondent no. 3 had issued a show-cause notice to respondent no. 4 on 26.02.2024, requesting a response and relevant documents. Respondent no. 4 had assured that practical exams would be conducted within ten days, but the same were ultimately delayed till June, 2024. After the exams, respondent no. 4 had issued a provisional certificate to the petitioner, indicating that she had passed the final MDS examination in Oral & Maxillofacial Pathology & Oral Microbiology. However, when the petitioner had sought recognition of her MDS degree under Section 40 of the Dentist Act,

    14

    1948, the respondent no. 3 had informed her that the degree would not be recognized, as her Batch was not recognized by them. Aggrieved by this action, the petitioners have approached this Court.

    6. All the petitioners herein are similarly placed with each other, who after completing their Bachelors of Dental Surgery (BDS) course from their respective Colleges/Universities, had enrolled themselves in respondent no. 4 College, from where they had pursued their MDS course. The petitioners in all the petitions have the same grievance against the respondents herein.

    7. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners argues that as per Regulation 23 of the Dental Council of India, Master of Dental Surgery Course Regulations, 2017, any candidate who is declared successful in the examination shall be granted a Degree of Master of Dental Surgery in his respective speciality. It is stated that this provision makes it mandatory on the part of respondent no. 3 and 4 to issue a Degree of MDS to the candidate on the successful completion of the exam. Further, after issuance of MDS Degree, the same must be recognized as per Section 40 of the Dentist Act, 1948. It is therefore argued that the action of the respondent no. 3, of not recognizing the MDS degree awarded to the petitioners, is violative of Section 40 of the Dentist Act and Regulation 23 of MDS Regulations of 2017. It is further submitted that the action of non- recognition of MDS degree, awarded to the Batch of 2020-23, is also infringing the fundamental right of petitioners i.e. right to livelihood and right to live with dignity protected under the Article 21 of the Constitution of India.

    15

    8. On the other hand, learned counsel appearing on advance notice on behalf of the Dental Council of India, argues at the outset that the respondent no. 4 College, which has awarded the MDS Degree to the petitioners herein, is situated in District Jhajjar, Haryana. It is further submitted that there are several legal proceedings pending in the competent Courts of Haryana, including those related to the land on which the respondent no. 4 college is operating, proceedings under SARFAESI Act, disputes among the Directors of the college, and these are relevant facts which are to be considered before deciding the issues in question. Thus, it is submitted that it will be appropriate for the petitioners to approach the Hon"ble High Court of Punjab and Haryana, and these petitions ought to be dismissed on the grounds of maintainability.

    9. In rebuttal, learned counsel for the petitioners submit that the grievance of petitioners is against the Dental Council of India, since it has failed to fulfill its duties, and thus, these petitions are maintainable before this Court.

    10. This Court has heard arguments addressed by learned counsels appearing on behalf of all the parties and has perused the material placed on record.

    11. The common issue that arises is whether these petitions are maintainable before this Court, considering the question of territorial jurisdiction.

    12. In the present case, all the petitioners herein had appeared in the NEET-MDS 2020 Examination, and had successfully qualified the same, and pursuant thereto, they were allotted seats in the MDS

    16

    course in respondent no. 4 i.e. PDM Dental College and Research Institute, Haryana, in the 2020-2023 Batch.

    13. The grievance of the petitioners now, essentially, is that the Dental Council of India has refused to recognize the MDS Degree awarded to the petitioners by respondent no. 4 College. The ground on which the petitioner has approached this High Court is that the Head Office of the Dental Council of India i.e., respondent no. 3 is situated within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court. However, merely because the office of respondent no. 3 is situated within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court, it cannot be a ground to entertain the instant writ petition.

    14. This Court notes that in these writ petitions, the petitioners have made several averments as to how the respondent no. 4 College, situated in District Jhajjar, Haryana, after completion of final examination of the MDS Batch of 2020-23, had started delaying the practical examination, and how the same was conducted after a delay of about four months. The State of Haryana has also been impleaded as a party in these petitions, since one of the averments of the petitioners is also that the respondent no. 4 College is a recognized College/institute as per the data available on concerned websites of State of Haryana. Pertinently, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of Dental Council of India had drawn this Court"s attention towards the fact that the College/institute from which the petitioners have acquired their MDS degree, i.e. PDM Dental College and Research Institute situated in State of Haryana, is built on a land which has been mortgaged. He further informed this Court that some

    17

    proceedings under the SARFAESI Act are pending against the said College, in the competent Courts of State of Haryana, and there are other disputes also between the Directors of the college.

    15. In this background, it will be useful to refer to the judgment of Hon"ble Apex Court in case of Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India (2004) 6 SCC 254. The relevant observations which are relevant to the facts of the present case are extracted hereunder:

    "Forum conveniens

    30. We must, however, remind ourselves that even if a small part of cause of action arises within the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court, the same by itself may not be considered to be a determinative factor compelling the High Court to decide the matter on merit. In appropriate cases, the Court may refuse to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction by invoking the doctrine of forum conveniens. [See Bhagat Singh Bugga v. Dewan Jagbir Sawhney, Madanlal Jalan v. Madanlal, Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. v. Jharia Talkies & Cold Storage (P) Ltd., S.S. Jain & Co. v. Union of India and New Horizons Ltd. v. Union of India.]"

    (Emphasis supplied)

    16. Thus, as per the abovesaid judgment, in case a small part of cause of action arises within the territorial jurisdiction of a High Court, the same by itself may not be considered to be a determinative factor to compel that particular High Court to exercise its jurisdiction. Further, in appropriate cases, the Court may decline to exercise its discretion by invoking the doctrine of forum conveniens.

    17. A similar view was also taken by the Hon"ble Apex Court in the case of State of Goa v. Summit Online Trade Solutions (P) Ltd.

    (2023) 7 SCC 791, wherein it has been held as under:

    18

    "14. While dealing with an objection as to lack of territorial jurisdiction to entertain a writ petition on the ground that the cause of action has not arisen within its jurisdiction, a High Court essentially has to arrive at a conclusion on the basis of the averments made in the petition memo treating the contents as true and correct. That is the fundamental principle. Bearing this in mind, we have looked into the petition memo of WP (C) No. 38 of 2017 and searched in vain to trace how at least part of the cause of action has been pleaded by the petitioning company, to have arisen within the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court.

    15. This is a case where clause (2) of Article 226 has been invoked by the High Court to clothe it with the jurisdiction to entertain and try the writ petitions. The constitutional mandate of clause (2) is that the "cause of action", referred to therein, must at least arise in part within the territories in relation to which the High Court exercises jurisdiction

    when writ powers conferred by clause (1) are proposed to be exercised, notwithstanding that the seat of the Government or authority or the residence of the person is not within those territories.

    16. The expression "cause of action" has not been defined in the Constitution. However, the classic definition of "cause of action" given by Lord Brett in Cooke v. Gill [Cooke v. Gill, (1873) LR 8 CP 107] that "cause of action means every fact which it would be necessary for the plaintiff to prove, if traversed, in order to support his right to the judgment of the court", has been accepted by this Court in a couple of decisions. It is axiomatic that without a cause, there cannot be any action. However, in the context of a writ petition, what would constitute such "cause of action" is the material facts which are imperative for the writ petitioner to plead and prove to obtain relief as claimed.

    17. Determination of the question as to whether the facts pleaded constitute a part of the cause of action, sufficient to attract clause (2) of Article 226 of the Constitution, would necessarily involve an exercise by the High Court to ascertain that the facts, as pleaded, constitute a material, essential or integral part of the cause of action. In so determining, it is the substance of the matter that is relevant. It, therefore, follows that the party invoking the writ jurisdiction has to disclose that the integral facts pleaded in support of the cause of action do constitute a cause empowering the High Court to decide the dispute and

    19

    that, at least, a part of the cause of action to move the High Court arose within its jurisdiction. Such pleaded facts must have a nexus with the subject-matter of challenge based on which the prayer can be granted. Those facts which are not relevant or germane for grant of the prayer would not give rise to a cause of action conferring jurisdiction on the court. These are the guiding tests"

    (Emphasis Supplied)

    18. A Coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Chinteshwar Steel Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India 2012 SCC OnLine Del 5264, has held that in case of pan India Tribunals, or Tribunals/statutory authorities having jurisdiction over several States, the situs of the Tribunal would not necessarily be the marker for identifying the jurisdictional High Court.

    19. This Court also notes, based on judicial precedents, that Courts have the power under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to exercise or decline their discretion to entertain writ petitions when the petitioner has an alternative, more appropriate, and convenient High Court to approach. As mentioned above, it is reiterated that it is a settled position of law that if only a part of the cause of action arises within the territorial jurisdiction of the Court, the Court may decline to entertain the case if it is of the opinion that it is not the forum conveniens.

    20. Considering the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this Court is of the view that the reasons for which Dental Council of India has yet not recognized the Degree issued by respondent no. 3 college, situated in Haryana, is due to factum of several legal proceedings qua the said College pending in competent Courts of Haryana, and

    20

    therefore, the present petition is dismissed alongwith pending applications solely on the ground of territorial jurisdiction. The petitioners would be at liberty to approach the appropriate Court of jurisdiction for redressal of their grievance, in accordance with law.

    21. The judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith.

    SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J

    AUGUST 23, 2024/ns

    21

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    DR SUPREETI CHAHAL  v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
    (Aug 23, 2024)