Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges

    VIBEESH v. SEBASTIAN MATHEW

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

    PRESENT

    THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN

    THURSDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF JULY 2024 / 13TH ASHADHA, 1946

    MACA NO. 765 OF 2019

    AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 03.03.2018 IN OPMV NO.794 OF 2010 OF MOTOR

    ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, THRISSUR

    APPELLANT/PETITIONER:

    VIBEESH

    AGED 33 YEARS

    S/O.VIJAYAN, KALIYANKARA HOUSE, P.O.PULLAZHI,

    THRISSUR DISTRICT.

    BY ADV P.V.CHANDRA MOHAN

    RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:

    1 SEBASTIAN MATHEW

    S/O.MATHEW, MOOLASSERY HOUSE, KANNUMMA P.O., KAVALAM, KUTTANADU, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT - 688 506.

    2 BIJU

    S/O.KURIAN, VALIPLAKKAL HOUSE, POOVANCHIRA, CHUVANNAMANNU, THRISSUR DISTRICT - 688 506.

    3 THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO.LTD.

    BRANCH OFFICE, THRISSUR - 680 001.

    BY ADV SRI.N.S.MOHAMMED USMAN

    THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD

    ON 04.07.2024, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

    1

    2

    JUDGMENT

    Dated this the 4th day of July, 2024

    This appeal has been filed by the claimant in OP(MV) No.794 of 2010 on the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Thrissur. The respondents herein are the respondents before the Tribunal.

    2. According to the appellant, on 15.04.2007 at about 4.30 p.m., while the appellant was riding a motorcycle bearing registration No.KL-8/AF 5672 through Pullazhi Power House road, a van bearing registration No.KL-8J-9036 hit on the motorcycle in which the appellant was riding and caused serious injuries to the appellant. The appellant approached the Tribunal claiming a total compensation of ₹28,86,000/-.

    3. The respondent-insurer filed a written statement, admitting the insurance policy, but disputing the quantum of compensation claimed. Before the Tribunal, no oral evidence was adduced by the respondent-insurer. Exts.A1 to A20 documents were marked on the side of the appellant. Ext.B1 document was marked on the side of the respondent. The Tribunal, after analysing the pleadings and materials on record, awarded a sum of ₹11,27,380/- as compensation under different heads with

    3

    interest @ 8% per annum from the date of petition, till realization, against the respondent being the insurer. Dissatisfied with the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal, the claimant has come up in appeal.

    4. Heard the learned counsel for the appellant and the learned Standing Counsel for the respondent.

    5. The learned counsel for the appellant claims enhancement mainly under the following head:-

    I. Notional income

    The main head under which the appellant claims for enhancement is the notional income arrived at by the Tribunal. Though the appellant was working as a painter at the time of accident, had claimed only an amount of ₹4,500/- towards notional income and the Tribunal had granted the same, while passing the award. It is an admitted fact that the accident occurred in the year 2007. Therefore, the notional income arrived at by the Tribunal is just and reasonable. Hence, I am not inclined to interfere with the notional income fixed by the Tribunal.

    II. Future prospects

    The learned Counsel for the appellant submits that no

    4

    compensation was granted by the Tribunal under the head of future prospects. It is true that the appellant had sustained serious injuries, which affects his future as well his ability to be involved in any avocation. Considering the nature of injuries sustained by the appellant, I feel that 25% future prospects can be added to the notional income arrived at by the Tribunal to award compensation.

    III. Loss of earning in future due to disability (Compensation for permanent or continuing disability )

    Ext.A12 disability certificate was mistakenly shown as Ext.A13 in the award. The learned Counsel for the appellant submits that as per Ext.A12 disability certificate, issued by the Professor of Neurosurgery of Medical College, Thrissur, assessed the permanent whole body disability of the appellant to be 50.39%. However, the learned Counsel for the appellant submits that the functional disability has been added to the permanent disability, while granting the award. The Tribunal had taken the permanent disability at 50.39%, taking into consideration, Ext.A12 disability certificate.

    The permanent neurological disability of the appellant is assessed as follows:-

    5

    1. Permanent disability due to recurrent epileptic attacks and lifelong risk of post traumatic epilepsy and the need to continue antiepileptic medicines to prevent seizures amounts to 25% disability of the whole body.

    2. Permanent disability due to traumatic brain injury resulting in cognitive dysfunction with a lowered MMSE score and recurrent headache, impaired memory and giddiness affecting his ability to work with definite impairment to adaptation in social, domestic and occupational conduct with extended persistent symptoms requiring enforcement of continued adjustments and the psychological trauma due to the sexual dysfunction amount to 25% disability of whole body.

    3. Permanent disability due to cosmetically deforming depressed bony scar on the forehead and adjacent scalp amounts to 2% disability of whole body. The appellant is also entitled to get 25% future prospects added to his notional income for the purpose of calculation of compensation for permanent disability. Taking into consideration the gravity of the injuries sustained by the appellant, I am inclined to grant the percentage of disability at 70.39% (50.39 + 20.00%). Accordingly, the compensation under the said head is re- calculated, totalling to an amount of ₹8,07,725/- (4,500 x 25% =

    6

    5,625 x 12 x 17 x 70.39 / 100). Thus, there will be an additional enhancement of ₹3,45,145/- (Rupees Three Lakh Forty Five Thousand One Hundred and Forty Five Only) under the said head.

    IV. Compensation for loss of marriage prospects

    Though an amount of ₹2,50,000/- was claimed by the appellant towards the head of compensation for loss of marriage prospects, the Tribunal had granted only an amount of ₹50,000/-. However, I feel that an additional enhancement of ₹50,000/-

    (Rupees Fifty Thousand Only) can be granted under the said head. Accordingly, the total enhancement under the said head will be ₹1,00,000/-.

    V. Pain and suffering

    The next head under which the learned Counsel for the appellant seeks enhancement is the pain and suffering. Though an amount of ₹1,00,000/- was claimed by the appellant under the said head, the Tribunal had granted only an amount of ₹50,000/-. Considering the nature of injuries as well as the age of the appellant, an additional enhancement of ₹20,000/- (Rupees Twenty Thousand Only) can be granted towards the said head. Accordingly, there is a total enhancement of ₹70,000/- under the

    7

    said head.

    VI. Loss of amenities and enjoyment of life.

    Though the appellant claimed an amount of ₹1,50,000/- towards the head under the loss of amenities and enjoyment of life, the Tribunal had granted only ₹50,000/-. Considering the age of the appellant as well as the injuries sustained by the appellant, I am inclined to grant an additional enhancement of ₹20,000/-

    (Rupees Twenty Thousand Only) under the said head. Thus, the impugned award of the Tribunal is modified as follows;

    Sl. No. Head of Claim Amount claimed (in Rs.) Amount awarded by the tribunal (in Rs.) Amount modified in appeal (in Rs.) Total compensati on
    Notional income 4,500 4,500 - 4,500
    1 Loss of earnings 1,00,000 45,000 (not modified) 45,000
    2 Transport 10,000 10,000 (not modified) 10,000
    3 Extra nourishment 10,000 10,000 (not modified) 10,000
    4 Bystander/ personal attendance 35,000 16,200 (not modified) 16,200
    5 Damage to 1,000 1,000 (not

    8

    clothing and articles modified) 1,000
    6 Medical expenses 1,75,000 3,82,600 (not modified) 3,82,600
    7 Future treatment expenses 20,000 20,000 (not modified) 20,000
    8 Pain and sufferings 1,00,000 50,000 20,000 70,000
    9 Loss of earning in future due to disability (Compensation for Permanent or continuing disability) 20,00,000 4,62,580 3,45,145 8,07,725
    10 Compensation for disfigurement 15,000 10,000 (not modified) 10,000
    11 Loss of amenities and enjoyment of life 1,50,000 50,000 20,000 70,000
    12 Compensation for shortened expectancy of life 20,000 20,000 (not modified) 20,000
    13 Compensation for loss of marriage prospects 2,50,000 50,000 50,000 1,00,000
    Total 28,86,000 11,27,380 4,35,145 15,62,525

    Accordingly, the appeal is allowed in part and the

    appellant/claimant is awarded an additional compensation of

    ₹4,35,145/- (Rupees Four Lakh Thirty Five Thousand One

    Hundred and Forty Five Only) over and above the

    compensation awarded by the tribunal with interest @ 8% per

    annum from the date of petition till realization and

    9

    proportionate costs. The respondent insurer shall deposit the said amount together with interest and costs within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment. The claimant shall furnish copies of the PAN Card, AADHAAR Card and bank details before the respondent insurer within a period of one month so as to enable the insurance company to make the deposit as ordered above. In case of failure to furnish details as above, it shall be open for the insurance company to deposit the said amount before the Tribunal. Upon such deposit being made, the entire amount shall be disbursed to the appellant at the earliest in accordance with law. However, it is made clear that the enhanced compensation will not carry interest for the period of delay of 93 days in filing the appeal.

    Sd/-

    SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN

    JUDGE

    RK

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    VIBEESH v. SEBASTIAN MATHEW
    (Jul 4, 2024)