Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a motor accident compensation claim filed by the appellant, Jayanandan, who was injured in a collision on 15.02.2005 when an autorickshaw allegedly driven rashly and negligently hit his motorcycle. The appellant sustained serious injuries, including loss of right eyesight and fractures to facial bones. He claimed compensation of ₹14,58,000/- before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Thrissur, which awarded ₹8,70,000/- with interest. Dissatisfied with the quantum of compensation, the appellant filed this appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the compensation awarded by the tribunal for permanent or continuing disability adequately reflects the appellant’s functional disability and future prospects.
  2. Whether the amounts awarded for pain and suffering and loss of amenities and conveniences should be enhanced.
  3. Whether the notional income fixed by the tribunal for loss of earnings is appropriate.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The tribunal erred in considering only the permanent disability assessed by the Medical Board and ignored the appellant’s functional disability, warranting enhancement of compensation for continuing disability.
  • The appellant claimed higher amounts for pain and suffering and loss of amenities and conveniences, arguing these were understated by the tribunal.
  • The appellant accepted the tribunal’s calculation of notional income and loss of earnings.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The insurance company contended that the Medical Board assessed the whole body permanent disability at 48.9%, which the tribunal correctly adopted as 49%, thus no enhancement for disability compensation was justified.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance [(2011) 13 SCC 236] Fixing notional income for loss of earnings in motor accident claims. The court upheld the tribunal’s fixation of notional income at ₹5,000/- based on this precedent and declined to interfere.
Pappu Deo Yadav v. Naresh Kumar and others [CDJ 2020 SC 727] Calculation of future prospects and enhancement of compensation for disability. The court applied this precedent to increase the permanent disability percentage to 65% and calculate future prospects at 40%, resulting in enhanced compensation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court carefully examined the Special Medical Board Report (Ext.X1), which assessed the appellant’s whole body permanent disability at 48.9%. It noted the appellant’s occupation as a diamond cutter and the serious nature of injuries including loss of right eyesight and multiple facial fractures. The tribunal had equated functional disability with permanent disability at 49%, which the court found unreasonable given the appellant’s inability to continue his avocation.

The court reasoned that the tribunal should have considered both functional and permanent disability and recalculated the disability percentage at 65%. Following the precedent in Pappu Deo Yadav, future prospects were calculated at 40%. The resulting compensation under this head was recalculated accordingly.

The court accepted the tribunal’s calculation of notional income and loss of earnings based on Ramachandrappa. It also found that the amounts awarded for pain and suffering and loss of amenities and conveniences were understated and allowed a moderate enhancement.

The court tabulated the modified compensation amounts, showing an increase in total compensation from ₹8,70,000/- to ₹10,57,500/-.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed in part. The appellant is awarded an additional compensation of ₹1,87,500/- over the tribunal’s award, with interest at 8% per annum from the date of petition till realization and proportionate costs. The respondent insurer is directed to deposit this amount within two months of receipt of certified copy of the judgment. The appellant must furnish relevant identification and bank details to facilitate payment.

The enhanced compensation will not carry interest for the 173-day delay in filing the appeal. No new legal precedent is established; the decision modifies compensation based on the facts and application of existing precedents.

    JAYANANDAN v. VARKEY

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

    PRESENT

    THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN

    WEDNESDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF JUNE 2024 / 29TH JYAISHTA, 1946

    MACA NO. 93 OF 2019

    [AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 21.07.2017 IN OP(MV) NO.1009 OF

    2007 OF MOTOR ACCIDENTS CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, THRISSUR]

    APPELLANT//PETITIONER:

    JAYANANDAN,

    AGED 50 YEARS

    S/O.SANKARANKUTTY, CHITTAZHIKKARA HOUSE,

    P.O.PUTHIRUTHI, VIA. WADAKKANCHERY, THRISSUR

    DISTRICT.

    BY ADV P.V.CHANDRA MOHAN

    RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:

    1 VARKEY

    S/O.VARUNNY, PUTHUR HOUSE, MANGAD, KOTTAPURAM

    P.O., ERUMAPETTY, THRISSUR DISTRICT.

    2 JOSHI

    S/O.VARKEY, PUTHUR HOUSE, MANGAD, KOTTAPURAM P.O.,

    ERUMAPETTY, THRISSUR DISTRICT.

    3 THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO.LTD.

    ANUGRAHA BUILDING, WADAKKANCHERY ROAD, KUNNAMKULAM

    - 680503 REP.BY BRANCH MANAGER.

    BY ADVS.

    SRI.T.C.SURESH MENON FPR R2

    SRI.P.MURALEEDHARAN FOR R3

    SRI.P.S.APPU

    SRI.A.R.NIMOD

    THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING COME UP

    FOR ADMISSION ON 19.06.2024, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY

    DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

    1

    :-2-:

    JUDGMENT

    This appeal has been filed by the claimant in OP(MV) No.1009 of 2007 on the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal,Thrissur. The respondents herein are the respondents before the tribunal.

    2. According to the appellant, on 15.02.2005 at 7:30 pm, while he was riding a motorcycle bearing Regn.No.KL-08-J-8556 through Kunnamkulam-Wadakkanchery public road towards east at Muttikkal, an autorickshaw bearing Regn.No.KL-08-C-6685 came from the opposite direction in a rash and negligent manner, and hit on his motorcycle and the appellant fell down on the road and sustained injuries. The appellant approached the tribunal claiming a total compensation of ₹14,58,000/-.

    3. The third respondent-insurer filed a written statement, admitting the insurance policy, but disputing the quantum of compensation claimed. Before the tribunal, no oral evidence was adduced on either side. Exts.A1 to A15 to were marked on the side of the appellant and Ext.X1 Medical Board report is marked as the court exhibit. The tribunal, after analysing the pleadings and materials on record, awarded a sum of ₹8,70,000/- as compensation under different heads with interest @8% per annum from the date of petition till realization, against the third

    :-3-:

    respondent being the insurer. Dissatisfied with the quantum of compensation awarded by the tribunal, the claimant has come up in appeal.

    4. Heard the learned counsel for the appellant and the learned Standing Counsel for the third respondent-insurer.

    5. The learned counsel for the appellant claims enhancement mainly under the following heads:-

    5.1 Notional Income/Loss of Earnings- The tribunal awarded an amount of ₹60,000/- under the head 'loss of earning', by calculating the notional income at ₹5000/-. The accident was in 2005. The tribunal had rightly fixed the notional income following the judgment in

    Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance [(2011) 13 SCC 236]. I do not find any reason to interfere with the notional income fixed by the tribunal.

    5.2 Permanent or continuing disability - Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the tribunal, while awarding compensation under the said head, had considered only the permanent disability assessed by the medical board. Ext.X1 Special Medical Board Report issued in

    :-4-:

    respect of the claimant - Mr.Jayanandan by the Special Medical Board at the Government Medical College, Thrissur shows that the total whole body permanent disability of the appellant was assessed at 48.9%. The tribunal, after elaborate consideration of the issue, assessed the permanent disability at 49%. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that while awarding the compensation, the tribunal ignored the aspect of functional disability.

    The learned Standing Counsel for the insurance company submits that the Medical Board assessed the whole body permanent disability only at 48.9% and the tribunal, while awarding compensation, has taken the entire disability assessed by the Medical Board. Hence, according to the Standing Counsel, the appellant is not entitled for any enhancement of compensation awarded under the said head.

    On a perusal of Ext.X1, it is seen that the Special Medical Board Report is issued by the Special Medical Board, consisting of four doctors at the Government Medical College , Thrissur. It is not disputed that the appellant was working in the Diamond Cutting establishment as a diamond cutter. Ext.A12 certificate issued by the employer of the appellant shows that in the year 2005 also, he was working in the

    :-5-:

    diamond cutting establishment as a diamond cutter and polishing worker. On account of the accident, the petitioner sustained serious injuries. Learned counsel further submits that due to the injury, he lost his right eyesight and had sustained fracture of anterior and lateral wall of (R) maxillary sinus and (R) zygomatic arch, (R) lateral wall of (R) orbit and periocular air pockets, haemosinus and (R) fronto temporal scalp contusion. Due to the injury, the appellant is not in a position to carry on the avocation which he was doing during the time of the accident.

    On a perusal of the award passed by the tribunal, the tribunal considered the functional disability same as permanent disability and assessed the percentage of disability as 49%, which appears to be unreasonable. The percentage of disability being 49%, the tribunal ought to have also considered the functional disability of the appellant due to the accident or injury. The appellant was only aged 39 years and he may not be able to continue the same avocation after loss of right eyesight. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, I feel that it would be just and reasonable that after considering the functional disability and as well as permanent disability as per Ext.X1, permanent

    :-6-:

    disability or continuing disability is to be recalculated as 65%. Following the decision in Pappu Deo Yadav v. Naresh Kumar and others [CDJ 2020 SC 727], the future prospects should also to be calculated at 40%. Accordingly, the total compensation for permanent or continuing disability is to be recalculated as ₹7000 (5000+2000) x 12 x 15 x 65/100 = ₹8,19,000. Thus, the additional compensation payable under the said head is ₹1,57,500/-.

    5.3 Pain and suffering - The appellant claimed an amount of ₹50,000/- under the said head. But, the tribunal has awarded an amount of ₹40,000/- considering the injuries. It is a fact that most of the injuries sustained by the appellant were to the face and head. He also lost his right eyesight. Considering the injuries sustained and the pain and suffering undergone by the claimant, I feel that an additional amount of ₹10,000/- can be given over and above ₹40,000/- granted by the tribunal.

    5.4 Loss of amenities and conveniences - The appellant had claimed for an amount of ₹2,00,000/-, but the tribunal awarded an amount of ₹30,000/-. The tribunal, on consideration of the issue, had come to the conclusion that the appellant could not work for almost one

    :-7-:

    year due to the injuries sustained in the accident. Considering the age and inconvenience faced by the claimant, I am of the opinion that an additional amount of ₹20,000/- more can be granted under the above head. Accordingly, the total amount awarded under the head is ₹50,000/-.

    6. Thus, the impugned award of the tribunal is modified as follows:-

    Sl.No. Head of claim Amount claimed Amount awarded by the tribunal modified in appeal total compensation
    1 Loss of earning 1,00,000 60,000 Not modified 60,000
    2 Medical and Miscellaneou s expenses 60,000 34,000 Not modified 34,000
    3 Personal attendants 10,000 5000 Not modified 5000
    4 Transportatio n expenses 10,000 6000 Not modified 6000
    5 Extra nourishment 2500 2500 Not modified 2500
    6 Damage to clothing etc. 500 1000 Not modified 1000
    7 Pain and suffering 50,000 40,000 10,000 50,000

    :-8-:

    8 Compensati on for permanent or continuing disability (Compensati on for loss of earning in future) 3,50,000 6,61,500 1,57,500 8,19,000
    9 Compensatio n for disfigurement 50,000 30,000 Not modified 30,000
    10 Shortened expectancy of life 25,000 - - -
    11 Loss/reductio n in earning capacity 6,00,000 - - -
    12 Loss of amenities and convenience s etc. 2,00,000 30,000 20,000 50,000
    13 Total 14,58,000 8,70,000 1,87,500 10,57,500

    Accordingly, the appeal is allowed in part and the

    appellant/claimant is awarded an additional compensation of

    ₹1,87,500/- (Rupees One Lakh Eighty Seven Thousand Five Hundred only) over and above the compensation awarded by the tribunal with

    :-9-:

    interest @ 8% per annum from the date of petition till realization and proportionate costs. The respondent insurer shall deposit the said amount together with interest and costs within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment. The claimant shall furnish copies of the PAN Card, AADHAAR Card and bank details before the respondent insurer within a period of one month so as to enable the insurance company to make the deposit as ordered above. In case of failure to furnish details as above, it shall be open for the insurance company to deposit the said amount before the tribunal. Upon such deposit being made, the entire amount shall be disbursed to the appellant at the earliest in accordance with law. However, it is made clear that the enhanced compensation will not carry interest for the period of delay of 173 days in filing the appeal.

    Sd/-

    SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN

    JUDGE

    MBS/

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    JAYANANDAN v. VARKEY
    (Jun 19, 2024)