Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 323, 325, 341, 441, 442, 504 and 506 read with Section 34 of IPC,
  • Section 26 of the Code.
  • Sessions Court. Section 323
  • Sections 341, 323, and 504, read with Section 34 of IPC
  • Section 156(3) of Cr.P.C.
  • Sections 147, 148, 149 and 324 IPC
  • 14 14. H.P. Panchayati Raj Act
  • Sections 341, 323, 504 read with Section 34 of IPC
  • Section 209 of the Code,
  • Sections 307, 325, 323, and 341 read with Section 34 of IPC.
  • Section 156(3) of Cr.P.C. 3
  • Section 34 of the H.P. Panchayati Raj Act
  • 12 Section 323 of the Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 323, 325, 341, 441, 442, 504 and 506 read with Section 34 of IPC,
  • Section 26 of the Code.
  • Sessions Court. Section 323
  • Sections 341, 323, and 504, read with Section 34 of IPC
  • Section 156(3) of Cr.P.C.
  • Sections 147, 148, 149 and 324 IPC
  • 14 14. H.P. Panchayati Raj Act
  • Sections 341, 323, 504 read with Section 34 of IPC
  • Section 209 of the Code,
  • Sections 307, 325, 323, and 341 read with Section 34 of IPC.
  • Section 156(3) of Cr.P.C. 3
  • Section 34 of the H.P. Panchayati Raj Act
  • 12 Section 323 of the Code

    RAM LAL AND ANR v. STATE OF HP AND ORS

    H

    ig h Co ur t o f H

    .P

    .

    Neutral Citation No. ( 2024:HHC:5081 ) Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA

    Cr.MMO No. 667 of 2021

    Reserved on: 02.07.2024

    Date of Decision: 21stJuly, 2024 Ram Lal & another

    ....Petitioners

    Versus

    State of Himachal Pradesh& others ....Respondents

    Coram

    Hon'ble Mr Justice Rakesh Kainthla, Judge. Whether approved for reporting? Yes For the Petitioners : Mr. Mukul Sood, Advocate. . For the Respondents : Mr. Prashant Sen, Deputy Advocate General, for

    respondents No.1 to 3/State

    Mr. Devender K. Sharma, Advocate

    for respondents No. 4 to 7.

    Rakesh Kainthla,Judge

    The present petition has been filed for seeking a direction to conduct investigation in F.I.R. No. 0314 dated 24.11.2016 for the commission of offences punishable under Sections 323, 325, 341, 441, 442, 504 and 506 read with Section 34 of IPC, registered at Police Station Sarkaghat, District Mandi, H.P. in a time bound manner, stay the Session Trial No. 51 of 2018 till

    1

    2

    the investigation in the F.I.R. and try both the F.I.R. No. 281 of 2015 and F.I.R. No. 0314 of 2016, dated 24.11.2016 together.

    2. It is asserted that the accused started the construction of their house. A dispute arose over the land on which the construction was being raised. Petitioner No. 2 filed a civil suit before the learned Civil -Judge (Junior Divison) Court No.2 Sarkaghat, District Mandi, H.P. The Court issued an injunction order. The accused entered the land of the petitioners on 13.11.2015. Petitioner No.1 objected to their entry over the land. The accused started abusing and threatening the petitioners. Accused No.1 and 2 pelted stones upon the petitioners and their family members. They also gave beatings to the petitioners and their family members by using a spade. The daughter-in-law of petitioner No.1 Ati Devi sustained injuries in the incident. The injured were taken to the hospital at Baldwara, District Mandi, H.P. Petitioner No. 2 also made a complaint to the police, however, his complaint was not registered and an entry was made in the daily diary . The petitioners and their family members were medically examined. The police failed to register the F.I.R. Hence, the petitioners filed a complaint under Section 156(3) of Cr.P.C.

    3

    which was referred to the police with the direction to register the F.I.R. The accused got an F.I.R. No.281 of 2015, dated 13.11.2015, registered for the commission of offences punishable under Sections 307, 325, 323, and 341 read with Section 34 of IPC. The police filed the charge sheet against the petitioners and the matter is pending before the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Mandi, District Mandi, H.P. Camp at Sarkaghat, H.P. The police filed an un-traced report. The petitioners filed objections. The matter was referred for further investigation vide order dated 21.07.2018. Two cross F.I.Rs have been filed and they are to be tried together. Hence, the present petition.

    3. The petition was opposed by respondents No. 1 to 3 by filing a reply, taking preliminary objections regarding the lack of maintainability and the petitioner having not come to the Court with clean hands. The contents of the petition were denied on merits. It was asserted that the Medical Officer of Civil Hospital Baldwara, District Mandi, H.P. informed the police on 13.11.2015 at 11:00 a.m. regarding the beatings given to a patient. The police visited the hospital and found respondents 4 and 5 to be undergoing treatment. The police recorded the statements of

    4

    respondent No.4, who stated that he was undertaking the construction work of his house. The labourers were stopped by Ram Lal (petitioner No.1). This fact was disclosed to respondent No.4, who sent his son to make a complaint to the police. He (son of respondent No.4) was returning after picking up the sand. He was stopped by petitioners No. 1 and 2. Petitioner No. 1 gave him beatings with a wooden stick and stones. He sustained injuries on his head, nose, face and body. The police registered the F.I.R. and conducted the investigation. As per the medical opinion, the injuries were grievous and life-endangering. The police filed the challan against the petitioners before the Court, which was fixed for prosecution evidence on 20.4.2022. The police also received a complaint filed before the Court under Section 156(3) of Cr.P.C. F.I.R. No. 314 of 2016, dated 24.11.2016, was registered at Police Station Sarkaghat, District Mandi, H.P. The police investigated the matter and prepared a cancellation report. Petitioner No. 2 filed objections. The Trial Court ordered the reinvestigation. The police conducted reinvestigation and found that offences under Sections 341, 323, and 504, read with Section 34 of IPC were made out. The offences were triable by Gram Panchayat and the charge sheet was filed before the Gram Panchayat, Tehsil Baldwara, District Mandi,

    5

    H.P. The police conducted the investigation fairly and filed a charge sheet as per the circumstances established during the investigation. Hence, it was prayed that the present petition be dismissed.

    4. A rejoinder denying the contents of the reply and affirming those of the petition was filed.

    5. I have heard Mr. Mukul Sood, learned Counsel for the petitioners, Mr. Prashant Sen, learned Deputy Advocate General for respondents No. 1 to 3/State and Mr. Devender K. Sharma, learned Counsel for respondents No. 4 to 7.

    6. Mr Mukul Sood, learned Counsel for the petitioners submitted that two cross F.I.Rs. were registered for the same incident and both the F.I.Rs are required to be tried together. The police erred in submitting the charge sheet before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate in one case and before the Gram Panchayat Court in another case. Hence, he prayed that both FIRs be ordered to be tried together.

    7. Mr. Prashant Sen, learned Deputy Advocate General submitted that the police conducted the investigation fairly and presented the charge sheets before the Court and Panchayat, who

    6

    were competent to try the matter, therefore, he prayed that the present petition be dismissed.

    8. Mr. Devender K. Sharma, learned counsel for respondents No. 4 to 7 submitted that offences punishable under Sections 341, 323, 504 read with Section 34 of IPC are triable by the Gram Panchayat exclusively. Hence, the police had rightly filed the charge sheet before the Gram Panchayat and the matter cannot be transferred to the Court. He prayed that the present petition be dismissed.

    9. I have given considerable thought to the rival submissions at the bar and have gone through the records carefully.

    10. It was laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Nathi Lal vs. State of U.P. 1990 (sup) SCC 145, that it is a fair procedure that cross-cases should be tried by the same Judge to avoid conflicting findings in the same matter. It was observed:

    "2. We think that the fair procedure to adopt in a matter like the present where there are cross-cases is to direct that the same learned Judge must try both the cross-cases one after the other. After the recording of evidence in one case is completed, he must hear the arguments but he must reserve the judgment. Thereafter he must proceed to hear

    7

    the cross-case and after recording all the evidence he must hear the arguments but reserve the judgment in that case. The same learned Judge must thereafter dispose of the matters by two separate judgments. In deciding each of the cases, he can rely only on the evidence recorded in that particular case. The evidence recorded in the cross-case cannot be looked into. Nor can the Judge be influenced by whatever is argued in the cross-case. Each case must be decided on the basis of the evidence which has been placed on record in that particular case without being influenced in any manner by the evidence or arguments urged in the cross-case. But both the judgments must be pronounced by the same learned Judge one after the other."

    11. This petition was reiterated in State of M.P. v. Mishrilal, (2003) 9 SCC 426, wherein it was observed: -

    7. Undisputedly, accused Mishrilal lodged the report to the police vide Ext. D-8 over the same incident which happened on 5-3-1987, in which he had clearly stated that the injuries were sustained by him and his son Madhusudan at the hands of the prosecution party. It is also not disputed that on the strength of the complaint lodged by Mishrilal, the investigation was also carried out and a challan was filed, namely, Crime Case No. 52 of 1987 under Sections 147, 148, 149 and 324 IPC against the prosecution party which is pending for disposal before the learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class. In the said challan, the prosecution party is stated to be the aggressor. ………..

    8. In the instant case, it is undisputed, that the investigating officer submitted the challan on the basis of the complaint lodged by the accused Mishrilal in respect of the same incident. It would have been just, fair and proper to decide both cases together by the same court in view of the guidelines devised by this Court in Nathi Lal case [1990 Supp SCC 145: 1990 SCC (Cri) 638]. The cross-cases should be tried together by the same court irrespective of the nature

    8

    of the offence involved. The rationale behind this is to avoid conflicting judgments over the same incident because if cross-cases are allowed to be tried by two courts separately there is a likelihood of conflicting judgments. In the instant case, the investigating officer submitted the challan against both the parties. Both the complaints cannot be said to be right. Either one of them must be false. In such a situation, the legal obligation is cast upon the investigating officer to make an endeavour to find out the truth and to cull out the truth from falsehood. Unfortunately, the investigating officer has failed to discharge the obligation, resulting in a grave miscarriage of justice.

    12. It was submitted that Section 34 of the H.P. Panchayati Raj Act provides that no Court shall take cognizance of any case, which is cognizable under the Act by the Gram Panchayat for the area and an exclusive jurisdiction has been conferred upon the Gram Panchayat to try the cases mentioned in the schedule; hence, the Court is not competent to try the offences mentioned in the Panchayati Raj Act. This submission is not acceptable. The conferment of the exclusive jurisdiction does not bar the trial of the matter by the Higher Court. In Sudhir v. State of M.P., (2001) 2 SCC 688, the Hon'ble Supreme Court was concerned with the two cross-cases arising out of the same incident out of which one was triable by the Sessions Court and the other was triable by the Court of Magistrate. The Hon'ble Supreme Court held that in such

    9

    a situation, both matters should have been tried by the court of Sessions Judge to avoid conflicting findings. It was observed:

    8. It is a salutary practice when two criminal cases relate to the same incident, they are tried and disposed of by the same court by pronouncing judgments on the same day. Such two different versions of the same incident resulting in two criminal cases are compendiously called "case and counter-case" by some High Courts and "cross-cases" by some other High Courts. Way back in the nineteen hundred and twenties a Division Bench of the Madras High Court (Waller and Cornish, JJ.) made a suggestion (GoriparthiKrishtamma, In re [1929 MWN 881] that "a case and counter-case arising out of the same affair should always, if practicable, be tried by the same court; and each party would represent themselves as having been the innocent victims of the aggression of the other".

    9. Close to its heels Jackson, J., made an exhortation to the then legislature to provide a mechanism as a statutory provision for the trial of both cases by the same court (vide Krishna Pannadi v. Emperor [AIR 1930 Mad 190: 31 Cri LJ 461]). The learned Judge said thus:

    "There is no clear law as regards the procedure in counter-cases, a defect which the legislature ought to remedy. It is a generally recognized rule that such cases should be tried in quick succession by the same Judge, who should not pronounce judgment till the hearing of both cases is finished."

    10. We are unable to understand why the legislature is still trying to incorporate such a salubrious practice as a statutory requirement in the Code. The practical reasons for adopting a procedure that such cross-cases shall be tried by the same court can be summarised thus: (1) It staves off the danger of an accused being convicted before his whole case is before the court. (2) It deters conflicting

    10

    judgments being delivered upon similar facts. (3) In reality the case and the counter-case are, to all intents and purposes, different or conflicting versions of one incident.

    11. In fact, many High Courts have reiterated the need to follow the said practice as a necessary legal requirement for preventing conflicting decisions regarding one incident. This Court has given its approval to the said practice in Nathi Lal v. State of U.P. [1990 Supp SCC 145: 1990 SCC (Cri) 638] The procedure to be followed in such a situation has been succinctly delineated in the said decision and it can be extracted here: (SCC pp. 145-46, para 2)

    "2. We think that the fair procedure to adopt in a matter like the present where there are cross- cases is to direct that the same learned Judge must try both the cross-cases one after the other. After the recording of evidence in one case is completed, he must hear the arguments but he must reserve the judgment. Thereafter he must proceed to hear the cross-case and after recording all the evidence he must hear the arguments but reserve the judgment in that case. The same learned Judge must thereafter dispose of the matters by two separate judgments. In deciding each of the cases, he can rely only on the evidence recorded in that particular case. The evidence recorded in the cross-case cannot be looked into. Nor can the Judge be influenced by whatever is argued in the cross-case. Each case must be decided on the basis of the evidence which has been placed on record in that particular case without being influenced in any manner by the evidence or arguments urged in the cross-case. But both the judgments must be pronounced by the same learned Judge one after the other."

    11

    12. How to implement the said scheme in a situation where one of the two cases (relating to the same incident) is charge-sheeted or complained of, involves offences or offences exclusively triable by a Court of Session, but none of the offences involved in the other case is exclusively triable by the Sessions Court. The Magistrate before whom the former case reaches has no escape from committing the case to the Sessions Court as provided in Section 209 of the Code. Once the said case is committed to the Sessions Court, thereafter it is governed by the provisions subsumed in Chapter XVIII of the Code. Though the next case cannot be committed in accordance with Section 209 of the Code, the Magistrate has, nevertheless, the power to commit the case to the Court of Session, albeit none of the offences involved therein is exclusively triable by the Sessions Court. Section 323 is incorporated in the Code to meet similar cases. That section reads thus:

    "323. If, in any inquiry into an offence or a trial before a Magistrate, it appears to him at any stage of the proceedings before signing judgment that the case is one which ought to be tried by the Court of Session, he shall commit it to that court under the provisions hereinbefore contained and thereupon the provisions of Chapter XVIII shall apply to the commitment so made."

    13. The above section does not make an inroad into Section 209 because the former is intended to cover cases to which Section 209 does not apply. When a Magistrate has committed a case on account of his legislative compulsion by Section 209, its cross-case, having no offence exclusively triable by the Sessions Court, must appear to the Magistrate as one which ought to be tried by the same Court of Session. We have already adverted to the sturdy reasons why it should be so. Hence the Magistrate can exercise the special power conferred on him by virtue of

    12

    Section 323 of the Code when he commits the cross-case also to the Court of Session. Commitment under Sections 209 and 323 might be through two different channels, but once they are committed their subsequent flow could only be through the stream channelised by the provisions contained in Chapter XVIII.

    14. Now we have to deal with the powers of the Sessions Court in the light of Section 228 of the Code which says that when the Sessions Court, after hearing under Section 227, is of the opinion that none of the offences presumed to have been committed by an accused is triable by a Court of Session he is to transfer the case for trial to the Chief Judicial Magistrate.

    15. In this context, we may point out that a Sessions Judge has the power to try any offence under the Penal Code, 1860. It is not necessary for the Sessions Court that the offence should be one exclusively triable by a Court of Session. This power of the Sessions Court can be discerned from a reading of Section 26 of the Code. When it is realised that the Sessions Judge has the power to try any offence under the Penal Code, 1860 and when a case involving an offence not exclusively triable by such court is committed to the Court of Session, the Sessions Judge has to exercise discretion regarding the case which he has to continue for trial in his court and the case which he has to transfer to the Chief Judicial Magistrate. For this purpose, we have to read and understand the scope of Section 228(1) in light of the above legal position. The sub-section is extracted below:

    "228. (1) If, after such consideration and hearing as aforesaid, the Judge is of the opinion that there is ground for presuming that the accused has committed an offence which —

    (a) is not exclusively triable by the Court of Session, he may frame a charge against the

    13

    accused and, by order, transfer the case for trial to the Chief Judicial Magistrate, and thereupon the Chief Judicial Magistrate shall try the offence in accordance with the procedure for the trial of warrant cases instituted on a police report;

    (b) is exclusively triable by the court, he shall frame in writing a charge against the accused."

    (emphasis supplied)

    16. The employment of the word "may" at one place and the word "shall" at another place in the same sub-section unmistakably indicates that when the offence is not triable exclusively by the Sessions Court it is not mandatory that he should order transfer of the case to the Chief Judicial Magistrate after framing a charge. In situations where it is advisable for him to try such an offence in his court, there is no legal obligation to transfer the case to the Chief Judicial Magistrate. One of the instances for not making the transfer is when a case and a counter-case have been committed to the Sessions Court and one of those cases involves an offence exclusively triable by the Sessions Court and the other does not involve any such offence.

    17. In the present case, the Sessions Judge ought not to have transferred the second case to the Chief Judicial Magistrate as he did, but he himself should have tried it in the manner indicated in Nathi Lal [1990 Supp SCC 145: 1990 SCC (Cri) 638]. To facilitate such a procedure to be adopted we have to set aside the order passed by the Sessions Judge in the second case. We do so.

    13. Therefore, it is permissible to try the cases by the Higher Court even if the exclusive jurisdiction has been conferred upon a different Court when two FIRs arise out of the same incident.

    14

    14. H.P. Panchayati Raj Act also provides that the Gram Panchayat can send the case to the Judicial Magistrate in certain eventualities under Sections 30 and 37 of the Act and the exclusion of the jurisdiction of the other Courts is not absolute.

    15. It was laid down by this Court in Shyam Lal vs. State of H.P. 2014(1) Him. L.R. 645 that the cross-case is required to be decided by the same Judge and if one case has been filed before the Gram Panchayat, the same is required to be transferred to the Court where the cross-case is pending.

    16. This Court has transferred the matter from the Gram Panchayat to the Court of learned Magistrate in case titled Roshan Lal vs. State of H.P. in Cr.MMO No. 543 of 2019 decided on 01.11.2019. Thus, the conferment of the exclusive jurisdiction upon the Gram Panchayat under Section 34 of the H.P. Panchayati Raj Act does not impede the trial of the cross-cases by the same Court.

    17. The petitioner has prayed to direct the investigation of the F.I.R. No. 0314 dated 24.11.2016, in time time-bound manner and stay the proceedings in a sessions trial till the completion of the investigation. Since the police had already filed the charge

    15

    sheet before the Gram Panchayat, therefore, these prayers have become infructuous.

    18. In view of the above, the present petition is allowed. The challan filed before the Gram Panchayat Court, Tehsil Baldwara, District Mandi, arising out of F.I.R. No. 0314 of 2016, dated 24.11. 2016, is ordered to be transferred to the Court of learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Court No.1 Sarkaghat, District Mandi, H.P. who shall proceed further in the matter as per the law and if deemed necessary, commit the trial to the Court of learned Sessions Judge where the cross-case is pending.

    19. The parties through their respective counsel are directed to appear before the Court learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate Court No.1, Sarkaghat, District Mandi, H.P. on

    30.07.2024.

    20 A copy of this order be sent to Gram Panchayat Court Tehsil Baldwara, District Mandi, H.P. and learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate Court No. 1, Sarkaghat, District Mandi for information and compliance.

    16

    21. The observation made hereinabove shall remain confined to the disposal of the petition and will have no bearing, whatsoever, on the merits of the case.

    22. The present petition stands disposed of along with the miscellaneous application(s), if any.

    (Rakesh Kainthla)

    Judge

    12thJuly,2023

    (Ravinder)

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    RAM LAL AND ANR v. STATE OF HP AND ORS
    (Jul 12, 2024)