ORDER
The petitioner challenges the endorsement dated June 12, 2019, issued by Respondent No. 3, which denied the petitioner's request for a refund of excess stamp duty collected, amounting to Rs.34,07,173.
2. A deed of partnership under the name and style M/s. Bharat Mines & Minerals was entered into between Mr. Dinesh Kumar Singhi and M/s. BMM Ispat Limited for the purpose of trading and other allied business activities. The petitioner partnership firm was duly registered before the Registrar of Firms/Companies, and a certificate of registration was issued. Subsequently, M/s. BMM Ispat Limited decided to retire from the firm, and Mrs. Snehalatha Singhi decided to join as a partner. Consequently, a partnership-cum-retirement and reconstitution deed was executed among the partners and presented before the District Registrar, Bellary, on June 8, 2018. The Registrar demanded a payment of Rs.34,08,173 towards deficit stamp duty, stating that the properties mentioned in the schedule to the reconstitution deed fall under the definition of immovable property as per Section 2(1ga) of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act'). The petitioner
- 3 -
deposited the stamp duty and subsequently filed an application under Section 44(2) of the Act before Respondent No. 3. Respondent No. 3 rejected the application, prompting the present petition.
3. The learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the properties listed in the schedule to the reconstitution deed do not fall under the definition of immovable property as per Section 2(1ga) of the Act, thereby entitling the petitioner to a refund of the excess stamp duty. In support of this argument, reliance is placed on the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sirpur Paper Mills Ltd. vs. CCE, (1998) 1 SCC 400, and Perumal Naicker vs. T. Ramaswami Kone, 1997 SCC OnLine Mad 212.
4. In contrast, the learned Additional Government Advocate (AGA) argued that the plant and machinery mentioned in the schedule are permanently attached to the land on which the petitioner is conducting business, thus falling under the definition of immovable property as per Section 2(1ga) of the Act. Consequently, the petitioner is not entitled to a refund of the stamp duty.
5. The arguments presented by the learned counsels for both parties have been duly examined, and the materials on record have been perused.
6. In the reconstitution deed, the scheduled property of the firm was contributed by the partnership. The retiring partner relinquished all rights over the firm properties, which continued to be owned by the firm. The schedule to the reconstitution deed reads as follows:
- 4 -
SCHEDULE
| Sl. No. |
Description |
Amount |
| 1 |
Plant & Machinery Belt filter accessories – BP-RNJP etc. |
8,27,80,172/- |
| 2 |
Plant & Machinery |
2,51,03,048/- |
| 3 |
33kv power line |
51,14,869/- |
| 4 |
Railway siding weigh bridge |
6,07,670/- |
7. Whether the properties mentioned in the schedule to the reconstitution deed fall under the definition of immovable property must be considered in light of the provisions contained in Section 2(1ga) of the Act. Section 2(1ga) of the Act states that "immovable property" includes land, buildings, rights to ways, air rights, development rights (whether transferable or not), benefits arising out of land, and things attached to the earth or permanently fastened to anything attached to the earth.
8. The authorities treated the properties listed in the schedule as immovable property by referring to the aforementioned definition.
9. Article 40-B of the Act deals with the reconstitution of a firm. Clause (a) to Article 40-B states that where immovable property contributed as a share by a partner or partners remains with the firm at the time of the partner's or partners' exit upon reconstitution of the partnership firm, stamp duty of three percent on the market value of the immovable property remaining with the firm shall be paid. The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in Sirpur Paper Mills Ltd. (supra), examined whether things attached to the earth come under the definition of immovable property. It was ruled that machinery attached to the earth merely for operational efficiency is not immovable property. The Court further held
- 5 -
that plant and machinery, being fixed to the earth for better functioning, do not automatically become immovable property.
10. A similar issue was considered in Perumal Naicker (supra), where it was ruled that the attachment of an oil engine to the earth, although a fixture, is for the beneficial enjoyment of the engine itself. The attachment is necessary for the operation of the engine and lasts only as long as the engine is in use. When not in use, the engine can be detached and relocated. Such an attachment does not make the engine a part of the land or classify it as immovable property.
11. In the present case, the plant and machinery are attached to the earth solely for their beneficial enjoyment and not for the enjoyment of the immovable property. The 33 kV power line cannot be classified as immovable property since the transmission lines were installed for industrial activities, not for the beneficial use of the immovable property. Similarly, the railway siding weighbridge is used for weighing railway bogies, not for the beneficial use of immovable property. All properties listed in the schedule can be removed, shifted, and resold in the open market. If the State Government's contention that the properties mentioned in the schedule should be treated as immovable property is accepted, it would imply that the petitioner must register a sale deed before conveying these properties to a third party and pay stamp duty under Article 20, as per the provisions of Section 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act.
12. In view of the preceding analysis, the impugned endorsement issued by Respondent No. 3 is not legally sustainable, and the petitioners are entitled to a refund of the excess stamp duty collected
- 6 -
at the time of registering the reconstitution deed.. Accordingly, I pass the following:
ORDER
i. Writ petition is allowed.
ii. The impugned endorsement dated 12.06.2019 issued by respondent No.3 at Annexure-A is hereby quashed.
iii. The respondents to refund the excess stamp duty of Rs.34,07,173/- collected from the petitioner at the time of registration of reconstitution deed dated 02.04.2018 within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.
iv. Failure to pay the said amount within the prescribed time, the respondents are liable to pay interest at 9% per annum.
Sd/-
JUDGE
RKA