Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • SECTION 2 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT
  • LEGAL METROLOGY ACT
  • CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT
  • provisions of the Legal Metrology Act and Rules,
  • Rule 6 (2) of PCR. d) Rule 9(1) - Legibility and Prominence: Rule 9(1)
  • Rule 6 r/w Rule 7(5)
  • provisions of the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules, 1945,
  • Commodities) Rules, 2011. Rule 18(1) of the Packaged Commodities Rules
  • II, Rule 7(5) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011.
  • Section 35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.
  • Rule 7 (5) - Exemptions from Rules: Rule 7 (5)
  • Sec 39(1)(k) of the 14 Consumer Protection Act,2019
  • provisions of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, and the Legal Metrology Act, 2009.
  • Cosmetic Rules, 1945, Table II
  • Rule 7(2) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011.
  • Rule 7(2) of the Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011,
  • Act 2009, specifically Section 52,
  • b) Rule 7 (2)
  • Rule 7(5) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011,
  • Cosmetic Rules 1945 originates from Sections 6(2), 12, and 33 of the Drugs and Cosmetic Act 1940. It's noteworthy that Section 2 of the Drugs and Cosmetic Act 1940
  • Rule 6(2) of the said Rules
  • CP Act.' ((2007) 4 SCC 579 (1996) 6 SCC 385 (2000) 5 SCC 294 (2011) 10 SCC 316) , CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3581-3590 OF 2020 @ CIVIL APPEAL DIARY NO.9796/2019 M/s
  • Rule 7(5) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, Table II
  • Rule 6 (2) - Consumer Care Details: 8 Rule 6 (2)
  • Rule 7(2) of the Legal Metrology Rules,
  • II, Rule 23(1),
  • 148(1)(b) of the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules, 1945).
  • Development) Act 2016.
  • Rule 7(5) of PCR. 9 Relevant Sections of Legal Metrology Act 2009:
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • SECTION 2 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT
  • LEGAL METROLOGY ACT
  • CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT
  • provisions of the Legal Metrology Act and Rules,
  • Rule 6 (2) of PCR. d) Rule 9(1) - Legibility and Prominence: Rule 9(1)
  • Rule 6 r/w Rule 7(5)
  • provisions of the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules, 1945,
  • Commodities) Rules, 2011. Rule 18(1) of the Packaged Commodities Rules
  • II, Rule 7(5) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011.
  • Section 35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.
  • Rule 7 (5) - Exemptions from Rules: Rule 7 (5)
  • Sec 39(1)(k) of the 14 Consumer Protection Act,2019
  • provisions of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, and the Legal Metrology Act, 2009.
  • Cosmetic Rules, 1945, Table II
  • Rule 7(2) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011.
  • Rule 7(2) of the Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011,
  • Act 2009, specifically Section 52,
  • b) Rule 7 (2)
  • Rule 7(5) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011,
  • Cosmetic Rules 1945 originates from Sections 6(2), 12, and 33 of the Drugs and Cosmetic Act 1940. It's noteworthy that Section 2 of the Drugs and Cosmetic Act 1940
  • Rule 6(2) of the said Rules
  • CP Act.' ((2007) 4 SCC 579 (1996) 6 SCC 385 (2000) 5 SCC 294 (2011) 10 SCC 316) , CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3581-3590 OF 2020 @ CIVIL APPEAL DIARY NO.9796/2019 M/s
  • Rule 7(5) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, Table II
  • Rule 6 (2) - Consumer Care Details: 8 Rule 6 (2)
  • Rule 7(2) of the Legal Metrology Rules,
  • II, Rule 23(1),
  • 148(1)(b) of the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules, 1945).
  • Development) Act 2016.
  • Rule 7(5) of PCR. 9 Relevant Sections of Legal Metrology Act 2009:
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The complainant, Venugopala Pillai P.V, filed a complaint under Section 35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, concerning the purchase of two cosmetic products (Baby Lotion and Baby Top-to-toe) from M/s Reliance Retail Ltd's store in Cochin on September 7, 2021. The complaint alleged that the product packaging did not comply with the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, specifically that certain printed declarations on the products were illegible without magnification and lacked required consumer care details. Notices were issued to the opposite parties, including the manufacturer (M/s Johnson & Johnson Pvt Ltd), the retailer (M/s Reliance Retail Ltd), and the Legal Metrology Department, but responses were either absent or unsatisfactory. The complainant claimed these issues amounted to unfair trade practices and sought compensation, litigation expenses, and withdrawal of the products from the market.

The opposite parties submitted their versions denying the allegations. The first opposite party contended the complaint was an abuse of process and that the products complied with the Legal Metrology Rules. The second opposite party denied liability, questioned the complainant's status as a consumer, and sought removal from the case. The third opposite party, the Legal Metrology authority, submitted certificates and reports claiming compliance with the rules but was criticized for inadequate enforcement and misleading reports. The Commission appointed an independent expert to measure the lettering on the products, who reported difficulties in legibility and recommended minimum font sizes and spacing for clarity.

After considering the evidence, expert reports, parties’ submissions, and relevant laws, the Commission proceeded to adjudicate the complaint.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the complaint is maintainable under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.
  2. Whether there is any deficiency in service or unfair trade practice by the opposite parties concerning the product packaging and declarations.
  3. If such deficiency or unfair trade practice exists, whether the complainant is entitled to relief.
  4. The question of costs of the proceedings.
  5. Any other necessary reliefs.

Arguments of the Parties

Complainant's Arguments

  • The product packaging violated the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, as certain declarations were illegible without magnification.
  • Consumer care details such as the contact person or office were missing or not prominently displayed as required by Rule 6(2) of the Rules.
  • The complainant challenged the validity of the Legal Metrology Department’s certificates and reports, citing non-compliance with size and legibility requirements.
  • Alleged that the first opposite party’s manufacturing practices amounted to unfair trade practice and sought withdrawal of products from the market.
  • Requested compensation for mental agony, financial loss, and costs of litigation.
  • Emphasized that the Legal Metrology Act has overriding effect over other statutes, including the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules, 1945.

First Opposite Party's Arguments

  • The complaint did not pertain to any deficiency or unfair trade practice on their part and was an abuse of legal process.
  • Asserted compliance with the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, including size and legibility of letters and numerals on packaging.
  • Argued that smaller packages necessarily have smaller fonts due to space constraints but remain legible as per the Rules.
  • Claimed that the complaint should have been filed with legal metrology authorities and that the Assistant Controller had already found the products compliant.
  • Denied any unfair trade practice and requested dismissal of the complaint with costs.

Second Opposite Party's Arguments

  • Contended that the complainant was not a consumer under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, and thus the dispute was not maintainable as a consumer dispute.
  • Denied liability for the product quality or the alleged deficiencies.
  • Asserted improper party joinder and requested removal of their name from the case.
  • Maintained that the product packaging complied with the Legal Metrology Rules and that the complaint was baseless, frivolous, and vexatious.
  • Urged dismissal of the complaint against them with compensatory costs.

Third Opposite Party's Arguments (Legal Metrology Department)

  • Submitted certificates and reports asserting compliance of the product packaging with the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011.
  • Relied on Rule 7(5) and Table II of the Rules to contend that the size of letters and numerals on the product package met prescribed standards.
  • Denied any violation of the Legal Metrology Rules.
  • Criticized by the Commission for failure to take appropriate action on the complaint and for submitting misleading reports.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Imperia Structures Ltd. v Anil Patni, (2020) 10 SCC 783 Remedies under the Consumer Protection Act are additional to remedies under other statutes and availability of alternate remedy is not a bar to entertaining a complaint under the CP Act. The Commission relied on this precedent to hold that the complainant could pursue remedies under the Consumer Protection Act concurrently with legal metrology remedies, affirming the supplementary nature of consumer protection remedies.
Hindustan Coca-Cola Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v. National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission & Ors. Non-compliance with legal provisions related to consumer protection and packaging requirements amounts to deficiency in service and unfair trade practice. The Commission referred to this case to support the finding that violations of Legal Metrology Rules constituted deficiency in service and unfair trade practice under the Consumer Protection Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Commission first confirmed the complainant’s status as a consumer under Section 2(7) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, based on the bill of purchase. It then examined the core allegations concerning non-compliance with the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, focusing on the legibility and prominence of consumer care details on the product packaging.

The expert report demonstrated that certain letters were below the 1mm minimum height required by Rule 7(2) and that the printed information was difficult to read due to character and line spacing. The complainant’s argument that Rule 7(5) does not exempt consumer care details from size requirements was accepted, contrary to the third opposite party’s position. The absence of contact information for consumer complaints was noted as a violation of Rule 6(2).

The Commission criticized the third opposite party for inadequate enforcement, misleading reports, and failure to protect consumer rights, emphasizing the need for specialized training for Legal Metrology officers.

Legally, the Commission applied the overriding effect of the Legal Metrology Act, 2009, which supersedes inconsistent provisions of other laws such as the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules, 1945. It also relied on the Supreme Court precedent from Imperia Structures Ltd. v Anil Patni to affirm that consumer remedies under the Consumer Protection Act are supplementary and can be invoked alongside other statutory remedies.

Considering the evidence and legal provisions, the Commission concluded that the opposite parties committed deficiency in service and unfair trade practice by failing to comply with mandatory packaging and labeling standards, thereby harming consumer interests.

Holding and Implications

The complaint is partly allowed.

The Commission directed the first opposite party to rectify the packaging defects within 45 days and to discontinue the unfair trade practice of manufacturing non-compliant prepackaged commodities. The first opposite party was ordered to deposit ₹25,000 into the Legal Aid Fund as reparation for harm to unidentified consumers.

The first and second opposite parties were jointly and severally ordered to pay ₹10,000 to the complainant as compensation for deficiency in service and mental agony, and ₹25,000 towards the costs of the proceedings. Interest at 9% per annum will accrue on the compensation and cost amounts from the date of filing the complaint if not paid within the stipulated time.

The Controller of Legal Metrology, Kerala, was directed to ensure that the third opposite party’s officers receive comprehensive training on the Legal Metrology Act and Rules, particularly the Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011, to improve enforcement and consumer protection.

No new precedent was set beyond affirming the supplementary nature of consumer protection remedies and enforcement of packaging standards. The decision directly affects the parties by mandating compliance, compensation, and administrative reforms.

    VENUGOPALA PILLAI P.V v. APARNA KAMATH

    BEFORE THE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL FORUM

    ERNAKULAM

    Complaint Case No. CC/21/436 ( Date of Filing : 17 Nov 2021 )

    1. VENUGOPALA PILLAI P.V

    67, SUBASH NAGAR, EDAPPALY, COCHIN ...........Complainant(s) Versus

    1. APARNA KAMATH

    BEHIND MAJAS DEPOT , JOGESHWARI , MUMBAI ............Opp.Party(s)

    BEFORE:

    HON'BLE MR. D.B BINU PRESIDENT HON'BLE MRS. SREEVIDHIA T.N MEMBER

    PRESENT:

    Dated : 22 May 2024 Final Order / Judgement

    DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION ERNAKULAM

    Dated this the 22ndday of May 2024. Filed on: 17.11.2021

    PRESENT

    Shri.D.B.Binu President Shri.V.Ramachandran Member Smt.Sreevidhia.T.N Member

    C C NO. 436/2021

    COMPLAINANT

    Venugopala Pillai P V, S/o. Venketeswaran Pillai.Treasurer, Acpm, 67, Subash Nagar, Edappally, Cochin-682024,

    VS

    OPPOSITE PARTIES

    1

    Aparna Kamath, Manager Regulatory Affairs,M/s. Johnson & Johnson Pvt Ltd, Corporate Office, Arena Space, Off JVLR, Behind Majas Depot, Jogeshwari (E), Mumbai-400060. India

    1.

    (Op1 rep. by Adv.Abraham Joseph Markos, Chandapillai Abgaham P.G.Z. M/s.Joseph & Kurian, Providence Road, Kochi-)

    Manager, M/s. Reliance Retails Ltd (Reliance Fresh), Opposite St. Antony's Church, Thannikkal, Keerthinagar, Elamakkara, Cochin -682026.

    2.

    (op.2 rep. by Adv.M.Premchand, 3-D, RDS Retrest, Chittoor Road, Kacherippady, Ernakulam-18)

    3) Assistant Controller, Legal Metrology,Legal Metrology Bhavan, Kakkanad, Ernakulam- 682030.

    F I N A L O R D E R

    D.B. Binu, President. A brief statement of facts of this complaint is as stated below:1. The complaint was filed under Section 35 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. The brief facts, as averred in the complaint, are that on September 07, 2021, the complainant made a purchase of one 100ml bottle of Baby Lotion and one 100ml bottle of Baby Top-to-toe from M/s. Reliance Retail Ltd's Elmakkara, Cochin store for Rs.171/-, as documented in Tax Invoice No. IR 5010721522207. The complainant observed that certain declarations printed on the back of these products did not adhere to the standards outlined in the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011. Some of the printed letters were illegible and could only be discerned with a microscopic lens. Consequently, notices were dispatched to all relevant parties, including M/s Reliance Retail and the Legal Metrology Department, yet no substantial response was received, except for acknowledgement. M/s. Johnson & Johnson Pvt Ltd, in response to the complaint, that there is no violation of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011. The complainant asserts that these issues constituted the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011 due to the negligence of all those concerned. The complainant requested the withdrawal of the products from the market it constitutes

    "Unfair Trade Practice" and sought appropriate relief from the commission. Extensive documentation including communication and evidence of purchase supported the complainant's case. The complainant's plea highlighted delays and omissions in responses from the concerned parties, asserting that their claims for compensation, including Rs.10,171/-. The complainant's demand for compensation, litigation expenses, and the removal of products from the market to prevent further unfair trade practice.

    2

    2) Notice

    The Commission issued notices to the opposite parties, and in response, the opposite parties provided their respective versions.

    THE VERSION OF THE 1st OPPOSITE PARTY3. The complaint doesn't pertain to alleged service deficiencies or unfair practices on the part of the opposite party. The opposite party views the complaint as an abuse of the legal process and requests its dismissal with costs. The opposite party mentioned a communication from the complainant regarding alleged non-conformance to Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011 for certain products purchased from one of the opposite party's outlets. The opposite party alleges that the complaint should have been lodged with the appropriate legal metrology authorities as per the Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011. They claim the complainant didn't provide evidence of filing a complaint or a response from the legal metrology department. They mention that the Assistant Controller, Legal Metrology, had already assessed the complaint and found the products compliant with the Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011.

    The opposite party emphasizes that the product labels meet the requirements specified in the Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011, including the size of letters and numerals. They point out that smaller packages have smaller fonts due to space constraints and that the product labels are legible as required by the Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011.

    The opposite party disputes the complainant's claim that the size of letters and numerals must be "easily readable to the consumer," arguing that such a requirement isn't mentioned in the Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011. They reject the assertion of unfair trade practices, noting that the alleged non-compliance doesn't fit the definition of unfair trade practices under the Consumer Protection Act.

    The opposite party alleges that the complaint seems aimed at tarnishing their reputation rather than addressing valid concerns. They label the complaint as false, frivolous, and speculative, and request its dismissal with costs, as has been done by the legal metrology authorities after due consideration of the complaint.

    THE VERSION OF THE SECOND OPPOSITE PARTY4.

    The complainant has presented misleading statements and omitted important facts while approaching this Commission. Their intentions seem dubious and intended for unfair gain. In our view, the complainant does not fall under the legal definition of a "consumer" as outlined in the Consumer Protection Act. Therefore, the alleged dispute cannot be classified as a

    "Consumer Dispute". Furthermore, the complaint is legally and factually unsound, filed without credibility, and seems to have been brought forward solely to harass the opposite party. The opposite party is not accountable for the product's quality and bears no liability for the mentioned allegations or the dispute between the complainant and the first opposite party. Hence, this complaint is flawed due to the improper joining of parties, and as a result, the opposite party's name should be removed from the list of parties involved.

    3

    In accordance with Rule 7(2) of the Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011, the height of any numeral and letter in the required declaration should follow the specifications in Table I. The product package labels adhere to the mandates of these Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011, confirming that the minimum height of letters and numerals on the product package is 1mm on the relevant Principal Display Panel, aligning with Legal Metrology Rules. Therefore, the existing declaration on the package fully conforms to Rule 7(2) and the requirements of Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011.

    Referring to Chapter II, Rule 23(1), a "deceptive package" is one deliberately designed to mislead consumers about the quantity of the commodity within. However, this definition pertains to quantity, and the complaint concerns product packaging (labels), which is not deceptive since it adheres to the declared net quantity/volume.

    The cause of action stated against the opposite party is baseless, frivolous, and vexatious, and the opposite party refutes it. There is no valid cause of action against the opposite party, and the complainant is not entitled to any relief from the opposite party. In the interest of justice, the opposite party urges this Commission to dismiss the complaint against the opposite party, awarding compensatory costs.

    THE VERSION OF THE THIRD OPPOSITE PARTY5.

    All the necessary declarations mandated by the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011 were indeed provided on the specified package. According to Rule 7(5) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, Table II is specifically relevant for determining the size of numbers and letters used for indicating net weight, retail sale price, expiry date, best before date (where applicable), and consumer care details. Notably, for the package in question, which falls under the scope of the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules, 1945, Table II is inapplicable to declarations beyond those mentioned (as per 148(1)(b) of the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules, 1945).

    The dimensions of letters and numerals in the declarations required for the packages conform to the criteria laid out in Table II, Rule 7(5) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011. There has been no breach of the provisions outlined in the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules-2011.

    6) . Evidence

    The complainant had produced a proof affidavit along with four documents, marked as Exhibits A-1 to A-4. Additionally, the complainant presented two bottles of Baby Lotion and Baby Top-to-toe, manufactured by Johnson & Johnson, marked as Material Object No. 1

    (M.O-1). The report from the expert commissioner is also marked as Exhibit C-1. Ext.A1: True Copy of the emails and registered letters dated September 23, 2021.•

    Ext.A2: Response received from O.P. 1 on October 9, 2021.•

    Ext.A3: photographs of products.•

    Ext.A4: copy of the bill dated September 07, 2021.• The third opposite party (The Assistant Controller of Legal Metrology from Legal Metrology

    4

    Bhavan, Kakkanad, Ernakulam), submitted Certificates of Measurement to the commission.

    7) The main points to be analysed in this case are as follows:

    i) Whether the complaint is maintainable or not?

    ii) Whether there is any deficiency in service or unfair trade practice from the side of the opposite parties to the complainant?

    iii) If so, whether the complainant is entitled to get any relief from the side of the opposite parties?

    iv) Costs of the proceedings if any?

    v) Any other reliefs necessary?

    8) The issues mentioned above are considered together and are answered as follows:

    As per Section 2(7) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, a consumer is a person who buys any goods or hires or avails of any services for a consideration that has been paid or promised or partly paid and partly promised, or under any system of deferred payment. The complainant had produced a Copy of the Bill issued by the second opposite party

    (Exhibit A-4). This document shows the payment made by the complainant to the second opposite party. Hence, the complainant is a consumer as defined under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, (Point No. i) goes against the opposite parties. In the present case, the complainant has raised allegations concerning deficiencies in service and unfair trade practices on the part of the opposite parties. Central to this dispute are the alleged breaches of Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011, raising the critical question of whether the complainant is entitled to redress and relief.

    The third opposite party produced the Measurement Certificate before the commission. The Measurement Certificate is reproduced below:

    "Measured height and width of Numerals and Letters

    It is submitted that all the required declarations under Rule 6 r/w Rule 7(5) of the Legal Metrology Packaged Commodities Rules - 2011 are in sufficient height and width. The height of the above-mentioned declarations are more than 1 mm and the width of the same are more than 0.33 mm.

    All what is stated above are true and correct.

    5

    Dated this the 8th day of December, 2023 Submitted,

    SAJU M.S,

    Assistant Controller (I/c/) Legal Metrology Ernakulum."

    The complainant initiated two Interlocutory Applications (I.A. Nos. 1135 of 2023 and 49 of 2024) before the Commission, seeking an examination of M.O. produced by the complainant. Specifically, the applications request that two bottles (M.O-1), submitted to the Commission on April 22, 2022, be forwarded to a reputable testing organization for detailed analysis. This analysis involves measuring the dimensions of the numerals and letters on the bottles and providing official calibration and certification. The complainant stated that the 'Customer Care' email address printed on the bottles is not easily legible, necessitating the use of a magnifying glass or microscope for reading. Additionally, it is pointed out that the packaging lacks clear information regarding a contact person or office for consumer complaints. The necessity for an expert evaluation is underscored by concerns regarding the authenticity of a Calibration Certificate provided by Legal Metrology, identified as the third opposite party. Doubts about the certificate's reliability stem from its compliance with the specifications outlined in the Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011. The certificate presented by Legal Metrology to the Commission on December 8, 2023, is contested due to their involvement as an opposite party in the case. Hence the Commission had heard both parties on IA. Accordingly, the Commission allowed the I.A. and directed the Head of the Department of Mechanical Engineering at Government Model Engineering College, Thrikkakara, Kochi 682021, to undertake the measurement of the lettering and numerals concerning consumer care details on the provided bottles. This includes assessing the clarity and visibility of the printed information for consumer readability, with specific reference areas on the bottles highlighted in green ink. Following the expert's submission of their findings in a sealed report to the Commission, a call for objections to the expert's report was posted on February 9, 2024. After receiving no objections from either party by February 20, 2024, the Commission has scheduled the case for a final hearing.

    Below is the expert commissioner's report (Exhibit C-1) reproduced for reference:

    TEST REPORT

    Details of products tested:

    Description: 1 . Baby Lotion 2. Baby top-to-toe Make: Johnson and Johnson

    6

    Date of Testing 30 Jan 2024 Details of Instruments used for the test

    Scale and Tape Calibration Unit

    Room Temperature: 20oC ± 2oC

    Relative humidity: 40% to 60%

    TEST RESULTS

    Measurement of Letter size printed on the bottle(m.m) SL No.

    DUC

    Identification Length Width Thickness Consumer Carea.

    Upper case C 1.756 1.042 0.484

    Lower Case o 1.395 0.871 0.357 Toll-Freeb.

    Upper case T 1.713 1.026 0.65

    Lower Case o 1.230 0.903 0.302 Write toc.

    Upper case W 1.088 0.913 0.291

    Lower Case o 0.828 0.548 0.225

    1800d. Number 1 1.719 0.510 0.212

    7

    Number 8 1.684 0.926 0.334

    OBSERVATIONS

    Easy reading of the printed letters/words on the bottles labels appear to be difficult in the current format, especially owing to character and line spacing.

    RECOMMENDATIONS

    The minimum recommended font sizes and the corresponding character and line spacing are

    Basis: Labelling should have a lowercase 'x' at least 1.2 mm tall, and all text must be scaled to that minimum

    Example fonts and their minimum font sizes: Times New Roman:7.5 points, Arial :6.5 points, Calibri: 7.5 points.

    Line and character spacing: A line spacing of 120% to 150% of the font size and a minimum character spacing of around 0.1 to 0.2 times the font size is recommended

    Font size: 1 point = 0.35mm Date of Issue :07.02.2024

    Dr.Rajesh VG Head- Dept. of Mech. Engg. Model Engg. College Thrikkakara, Kochi-21

    The complainant submitted that the sole relaxation Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules 2011 (referred to as PCR):

    PCR offers for cosmetic product packages are found in the proviso to Rule 6(1)(d), which stipulates that declarations about the month and year of manufacturing or packing should align with the provisions of the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules 1945. This exemption is exclusively related to the date-related declaration and doesn't extend to the size requirements for consumer care details, as stipulated by Rule 7(5) of PCR. The complainant further submitted the relevant provisions related to the PCR.

    a) Rule 6 (2) - Consumer Care Details:

    8

    Rule 6 (2) mandates that every package should include consumer care details, comprising the name, address, telephone number, and e-mail address of the person or office to contact in case of consumer complaints. These details are required to be legible and prominent on the package. In this context, it's noted that the e-mail address labelled "Customer Care" is not easily readable without the aid of a magnifying glass or microscopic lens. Moreover, the necessary information regarding the contact person or office in charge of handling consumer complaints is absent from these packages.

    b) Rule 7 (2) - Size of Numerals and Letters:

    As per Rule 7 (2), the dimensions of numerals and letters in the required declarations should adhere to the specifications laid out in Table 1.

    c) Rule 7 (5) - Exemptions from Rules:

    Rule 7 (5) specifies that except for details such as net weight, retail sale price, expiry date, best before date (as applicable), and consumer care details, the provisions outlined in sub-rules (1) to

    (4) are inapplicable to packages that require information in accordance with other laws. However, it's emphasized that Rule 7 (5) doesn't exempt the size requirements for consumer care details mentioned in Rule 6 (2) of PCR.

    d) Rule 9(1) - Legibility and Prominence:

    Rule 9(1) establishes that every declaration on a package, as mandated by these rules, must be both legible and prominent.

    Based on these regulations, a clear violation of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules 2011 is evident. Consequently, trading such products would qualify as an "Unfair Trade Practice," warranting the withdrawal of these items from the market.

    Challenging the Assistant Controller's Statement of Facts (Dated 03/01/22)

    The complainant contests the Assistant Controller's statement, dated 03/01/22, on legal grounds. It's contended that Rule 7(5) of PCR doesn't provide any exemption regarding the size of numerals and letters pertaining to consumer care details, a requirement under Rule 6(2) of PCR. The email address's illegibility and non-compliance with the size criteria of Rule 7(2) are stressed. Furthermore, the absence of the name and address of the designated contact person or office for consumer complaints is pointed out.

    Relaxation for Cosmetic Product Packages:

    The complainant states that the sole relaxation PCR offers for cosmetic product packages is found in the proviso to Rule 6(1)(d), which stipulates that declarations about the month and year of manufacturing or packing should align with the provisions of the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules 1945. This exemption is exclusively related to the date-related declaration and doesn't extend to the size requirements for consumer care details, as stipulated by Rule 7(5) of PCR.

    9

    Relevant Sections of Legal Metrology Act 2009:

    Reference is made to the Legal Metrology Act 2009, specifically Section 52, granting the Government of India authority to establish rules concerning standard quantities, declaration formats, and particulars as per Section 18(1). This act's provisions hold precedence over inconsistent provisions of other enactments or instruments.

    The Exhibit: C1 report submitted by the expert indicates that certain lowercase letters in the consumer care details printed on the packages are only 0.828mm in height, which is below the 1mm minimum required by Table I under Rule 7(2) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011. Furthermore, a cursory examination of these declarations demonstrates their illegibility, a fact corroborated by the Expert's Exhibit: C1 report. It is a well-known fact that characters, regardless of their specified height and width, can be printed legibly or illegibly. Even the smallest characters can be rendered legible, as evidenced by the clarity of both small and large print in prominent newspapers, journals, and periodicals. The legibility of a character depends on the clarity of its printing, not merely its size. Accordingly, the Packaged Commodities Rules mandate under Rule 9(1)(a) that every declaration be legible and prominent, reflecting the explicit intent of the law. The third party (3rd OP) has failed to adequately understand the provisions of the Legal Metrology Act, 2009, as well as the Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011. This party also overlooked the implications of Rule 7(5), which does not exempt consumer care details from compliance requirements. Furthermore, the 3rd OP failed to notice that the name and address of the contact person or office for consumer complaints were not included in the consumer care details, a violation of Rule 6(2).

    The 3rdOpposite Party, responsible for protecting consumer rights, has failed miserably in their duties as public servants. No action was taken on the complaint filed by the consumer. Sri. Muhamad Ismail K.M, Technical Assistant (in charge), Legal Metrology (CL), Ernakulam, appeared before the commission and presented a version and Certificate of Measurement that were misleading. The commission directed the 3rd Opposite Party to submit a detailed measurement report, which was signed and filed by Sri. Saju M.S, Assistant Controller (in charge), Legal Metrology, Ernakulam, but these reports were also misleading. The actions of the aforementioned public servants undermine the purpose of consumer protection laws and force the complainant into unnecessary litigation.

    The commission hereby notes its displeasure and dissatisfaction with the conduct of the officers of the 3rd Opposite Party incumbents, namely Sri. Muhamad Ismail K.M, Technical Assistant (in charge), Legal Metrology (CL), Ernakulam, and Sri. Saju M.S, Assistant Controller (in charge), Legal Metrology, Ernakulam.

    Despite these violations, the 3rd OP erroneously exonerated the first and second parties (1st and 2nd OPs). The laws governing Legal Metrology are designed to shield consumers from deceptive practices related to weights, measures, and pre-packaged goods. A Legal Metrology Officer must be well-versed in these laws to enforce them effectively. The shortcomings of the 3rd OP suggest a significant need for intensive training on the Legal Metrology Act, 2009 and its associated rules, particularly the Packaged Commodities Rules, 2011. It is essential that such

    10

    training be conducted.

    Overriding Effect of the Legal Metrology Act:

    The complainant underscores the overriding effect of the Legal Metrology Act, as stipulated in Section 3 of the Act. This clause asserts that the Act's provisions hold sway regardless of inconsistencies with other laws or enactments. Consequently, the Legal Metrology Act supersedes the provisions of the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules 1945. The legal authority of the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules 1945 originates from Sections 6(2), 12, and 33 of the Drugs and Cosmetic Act 1940. It's noteworthy that Section 2 of the Drugs and Cosmetic Act 1940 unambiguously establishes the complementary nature of its provisions, without derogation from other laws.

    In light of these arguments, the complainant calls for appropriate actions to be taken against the opposite parties.

    The learned counsel for the first opposite party submitted that the product labels adhere to the stipulated criteria outlined in the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, encompassing factors like the size of letters and numerals. They highlight that smaller packages necessarily employ smaller fonts due to spatial limitations while underlining that the product labels remain legible, a stipulation mandated by the rules

    One of the main contentions put forward by the learned counsel for the first opposite party is that it revolves around the regulatory framework of the Legal Metrology Act and its accompanying Rules. This framework outlines a specific procedure for addressing complaints related to violations of declaration requirements on retail packages. Key authorities, including the Controller of Legal Metrology, Assistant Controller of Legal Metrology, and Inspector of Legal Metrology, are involved in this process within their respective jurisdictions.Top of Form

    In Imperia Structures Ltd. v Anil Patni on 2 November, 2020, (2020) 10 SCC 783),

    the Honourable Supreme Court held that the remedies available under the Act of 1986 are in addition to the remedies available under other statutes, including special statutes like the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016. The Honourable Supreme Court reiterated the settled position of law in the following terms:

    "21. It has consistently been held by this Court that the remedies available under the provisions of the CP Act are additional remedies over and above the other remedies including those made available under any special statutes; and that the availability of an alternate remedy is no bar in entertaining a complaint under the CP Act.'

    ((2007) 4 SCC 579 (1996) 6 SCC 385 (2000) 5 SCC 294 (2011) 10 SCC 316) , CIVIL

    APPEAL NO. 3581-3590 OF 2020 @ CIVIL APPEAL DIARY NO.9796/2019 M/s Imperia Structures Ltd. vs. Anil Patni.)."

    The learned counsel for the second opposite party contends that the complainant has presented misleading statements and omitted crucial facts in their approach to this Commission,

    11

    indicating questionable motives aimed at unjust gains. According to their assessment, the complainant does not fulfil the legal criteria defining a "consumer" within the Consumer Protection Act, thus rendering the alleged dispute ineligible as a "Consumer Dispute." They assert that the complaint is legally and factually flawed, devoid of credibility, and seemingly brought forward with harassing intent.

    The second opposite party disclaims accountability for the product's quality and denies any liability for the mentioned allegations or the dispute between the complainant and the first opposite party. As a consequence of improper party alignment, they assert that their name should be excluded from the list of involved parties.

    Citing Rule 7(2) of the Legal Metrology Rules, they emphasize that the height of numerals and letters on the required declaration adheres to the specifications outlined in Table I. The product packaging labels, they affirm, conform to these mandates, with the minimum letter and numeral height of 1mm on the relevant Principal Display Panel, aligning with Legal Metrology Rules. Referring to Chapter II, Rule 23(1), they clarify that the term "deceptive package" pertains to quantity manipulation, whereas the complaint addresses product packaging (labels) compliant with the declared net quantity/volume, thereby not deceptive.

    They dismiss the cause of action against them as baseless, frivolous, and vexatious, refuting its validity. The second opposite party contends that there is no legitimate cause of action against them, and they argue against the complainant's entitlement to relief. Urging the Commission in the interest of justice, they request the dismissal of the complaint against them, along with compensatory costs.

    In summary, the second opposite party's stance challenges the complainant's assertions, questioning their motives and credibility. They refute liability, assert compliance with Legal Metrology Rules, and request the dismissal of the complaint against them. The third opposite party asserts that the opposite party has indeed provided the necessary declarations as mandated by the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011 on the specific package. They point out that Rule 7(5) of these rules refers to Table II, which is particularly applicable for determining the size of numbers and letters used for indicating net weight, retail sale price, expiry date, best before date (where applicable), and consumer care details. However, they highlight that in the case of the package in question, which falls under the jurisdiction of the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules, 1945, Table II is not relevant for declarations beyond those specifically mentioned (as per 148(1)(b) of the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules, 1945).

    They emphasize that the dimensions of letters and numerals in the required declarations for the packages align with the criteria stated in Table II, Rule 7(5) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011. They firmly state that there has been no violation of the provisions outlined in the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011.

    After careful consideration of the presented arguments, relevant legal precedents, and the provisions of the CP Act and Legal Metrology Act, this Commission is inclined to support the view that the remedies available under the CP Act are indeed additional remedies that can

    12

    be pursued concurrently with other remedies, including those under special statutes. The Consumer Protection Act, enacted with the primary objective of safeguarding consumer interests, explicitly provides remedies to consumers for various unfair trade practices and deficiencies in services. The Act does not intend to restrict the avenues available to consumers seeking redressal. This is evident from the wording of the Act itself and has been reinforced by judicial pronouncements.

    The case of Imperia Structures Ltd. v Anil Patni (2 November 2020) 10 SCC 783, as cited by the Honorable Supreme Court of India, stands as a notable precedent in this regard. The Honorable Supreme Court has consistently held that the remedies available under the provisions of the CP Act are supplementary and complementary to other remedies, even under special statutes. The fact that an alternate remedy exists does not constitute a barrier to entertaining a complaint under the CP Act. The Hon'ble Supreme Court's consistent position, as expressed in various judgments, reflects a clear intent to provide consumers with an array of options to seek justice without undue constraints.

    Considering the present case and the principles elucidated by the Honourable Supreme Court, it is incumbent upon this Commission to hold that the remedies available under the CP Act can be availed by the Complainant in parallel with other available remedies. The provisions of the Legal Metrology Act and Rules, which establish distinct machinery for addressing complaints, do not preclude the Complainant from seeking remedies under the CP Act, especially when the essence of the remedies provided under the two statutes serves different purposes. In conclusion, the remedies available under the provisions of the CP Act are additional remedies over and above those available under other statutes, including special statutes. The availability of an alternate remedy does not act as a bar to entertaining a complaint under the CP Act. This Commission affirms the position established by the Honourable Supreme Court in this matter.

    In adjudicating this matter, the Commission has considered the submissions made by all parties involved, as well as the relevant provisions of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, and the Legal Metrology Act, 2009. The issues at hand pertain to the alleged violations of the Legal Metrology Rules, and the determination of whether the complainant is entitled to relief.

    The core dispute centres around the compliance of the product package labels with the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011. It is acknowledged that Rule 6(2) of the said Rules mandates that every package should bear consumer care details, including the contact information of the person or office to be reached in case of consumer complaints. These details are required to be legible and prominent on the package. The complainant contends that the e- mail address provided for customer care is not easily readable and that the required contact information is entirely missing.

    The opposite parties have asserted that the products in question conform to the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011. However, their contentions do not sufficiently address the complainant's concerns regarding the legibility and compliance of the consumer care details on the package labels. The legal provisions dictate that the details must be legible and

    13

    prominent, which ensures that consumers can readily access the necessary information. The opposite parties' argument regarding smaller font sizes on smaller packages due to space constraints does not excuse the non-compliance with the requirement of legibility and prominence, as mandated by the Rules.

    Furthermore, the complainant's assertion that Rule 7(5) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, does not exempt the size requirements for consumer care details, as stipulated by Rule 6(2), is supported by the provisions themselves. The proviso in Rule 7(5) only applies to certain declarations, and it does not extend to exemptions related to consumer care details. This interpretation is in line with the legislative intent of ensuring that consumers receive accurate and easily accessible information.

    The complainant has produced evidence, including copies of emails, and registered letters, the report from the expert commissioner (Exhibit C-1) photographs of products, and the purchase bill, which support their claim that the consumer care details are not adequately displayed on the package labels. These pieces of evidence strengthen the complainant's assertion that there is a breach of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011.

    Rule 18(1) of the Packaged Commodities Rules stipulates as follows:

    "18(1)- No wholesale dealer or retail dealer or importer shall sell, distribute, deliver, display or store for sale any commodity in the packaged form unless the package complies with in all respects, the provisions of the Act and these rules."

    Hence the 2nd Opposite Party dealer cannot be absolved from their liability of having sold to the complainant prepackaged commodities which bore thereon declarations that were not complying with the provisions of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011. In light of the arguments presented and the evidence provided, the Commission finds merit in the complainant's contentions. The violations of the Legal Metrology Rules, specifically Rule 6(2) regarding consumer care details, are substantiated by the evidence and legal provisions. This breach constitutes a deficiency in service and unfair trade practice as defined under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.

    In support of this conclusion, the Commission refers to the case of Hindustan Coca-Cola Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v. National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission & Ors.,

    wherein it was held that non-compliance with the legal provisions related to consumer protection and packaging requirements amounts to a deficiency in service and unfair trade practice.

    Moreover, the Commission takes into consideration the overriding effect of the Legal Metrology Act, 2009, as provided under Section 3 of the Act. This Act's provisions hold precedence over any inconsistent provisions of other enactments. Hence, the Legal Metrology Act, which governs packaging requirements, supersedes the provisions of the Drugs and Cosmetic Rules, 1945, concerning the subject matter.

    It is also self-evident that consequent to the said illicit practice on the part of the first Opposite Party manufacturer, agony and hardship were inflicted on a large number of consumers who are not conveniently identifiable. Hence a deterrent action, as envisaged under Sec 39(1)(k) of the

    14

    Consumer Protection Act,2019 also appears essential to meet the ends of justice. We find the issue Nos. (I) to (V) are also in favour of the complainant for the serious deficiency in service and unfair trade practice that happened on the side of the opposite parties. Naturally, the complainant had suffered a lot of inconvenience, mental agony, hardships, financial loss, etc. due to the negligence on the part of the opposite parties. The complainant in this matter is a senior citizen who has presented the case as the party in person. His diligent pursuit of this case merits special recognition by this commission. In conclusion, the complaint is upheld in favour of the complainant due to the proven violations of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, and the resultant deficiency in service and unfair trade practice.

    In view of the above facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the opinion that the opposite parties are liable to compensate the complainant.

    Hence the prayer is partly allowed as follows:

    I. The First Opposite Party shall rectify the defects in respect of the mandatory declarations made under the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, and also shall discontinue with immediate effect the unfair trade practice of manufacturing prepackaged commodities with declarations that do not conform to the standards prescribed under the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, within 45 days.

    II. The First Opposite Party shall deposit the sum of ₹25,000 (Twenty-Five Thousand Rupees Only) to the Legal Aid Fund maintained by the Registry of this Commission towards reparation for the loss suffered by the large number of consumers who are not conveniently identifiable, within 45 days.

    III. The First and Second Opposite Parties shall pay ₹10,000 (Rupees Ten Thousand Only) to the complainant for the deficiency in service and unfair trade practice committed by them, as well as for the inconvenience and mental agony caused to the complainant by the violations.

    IV. The First and Second Opposite Parties are further ordered to pay the complainant a sum of ₹25,000 (Rupees Twenty-Five Thousand Only) towards the costs of the proceedings.

    V. Furthermore, the Controller, Legal Metrology, Government of Kerala, under intimation to this commission, shall ensure that the 3rd Opposite Party incumbents, namely Sri. Muhamad Ismail K.M, Technical Assistant (in charge), Legal Metrology (CL), Ernakulam, and Sri. Saju M.S, Assistant Controller (in charge), Legal Metrology, Ernakulam, receive thorough training on the Legal Metrology Act, 2009, and the Rules made thereunder, with special emphasis on the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011. The training period shall comprise not less than 15 working days and be conducted under the tutorship of competent faculty

    15

    decided by the Controller, Legal Metrology. The Registry shall immediately forward a copy of this order to the Controller of Legal Metrology, Government of Kerala. The 1stand 2ndOpposite Parties are jointly and severally liable to fulfil the respective directions mentioned above within the stipulated time limit, failing which the amounts specified in points (III) and (IV) will accrue interest at 9% per annum, calculated from the date of filing the complaint (17-11-2021), until the date of payment.

    Pronounced in the Open Commission on this the 22ndday of May 2024

    Sd/-

    D.B.Binu, President

    Sd/-

    V.Ramachandran, Member

    Sd/-

    Sreevidhia.T.N, Member

    Forwarded by Order

    Assistant Registrar

    16

    APPENDIX

    Complainant's evidence Ext.A1: True Copy of the emails and registered letters dated September 23, 2021.•

    Ext.A2: Response received from O.P. 1 on October 9, 2021.•

    Ext.A3: photographs of products.•

    Ext.A4: copy of the bill dated September 07, 2021.•

    Ext C1: Expert Commission Report•

    .

    [HON'BLE MR. D.B BINU]

    PRESIDENT

    [HON'BLE MRS. SREEVIDHIA T.N]

    MEMBER

    17

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    VENUGOPALA PILLAI P.V v. APARNA KAMATH
    (May 22, 2024)