ORDER
1. In this original application, Applicant has prayed for a direction to the respondents to frame guidelines for identification of Clarias gariepinus (Exotic Magur) and Clarias Batrachus (Indian Magur) and has also sought a clarification relating to ban on culture, breeding, transportation and import of Clarias gariepinus and that of its hybrid. The plea of the Applicant is that there is confusion with regard to identification and differentiation between different varieties of cat fish (Magur) and genus Clarias. Considering the potential threat to health and aquatic biodiversity, Govt. of India has banned the culture, breeding, transportation, and import of Clarias gariepinus (Exotic Magur).
2. Learned Counsel for the Applicant has submitted that the authorities taking action against illegal farming of Clarias gariepinus are not able to differentiate it with the Clarias batrachus or hybrid Clarias, therefore, appropriate directions are required to be issued by the Tribunal.
2
3. This very issue has already been considered by the Tribunal in the order dated 05.04.2024 while dismissing OA No. 347/2024 by holding as under:
"3. The allegation of the applicant is that officials of the State Government are unable to identify the difference between Clarias gariepinus and Clarias batrachus as both look similar and they destroy even the farms of Clarias batrachus.
4. Having heard the learned Counsel for the Applicant and on perusal of the records it is noticed that this issue has already been examined by the Tribunal in detail in order dated 22.01.2019 passed in OA No. 435/2018, Hussain Khan v. Fisheries Department & Ors. and connected matters, wherein the Tribunal held as under:-
"6. The case of the applicants is that they are breeding Indian Cat fish which is not a banned fish and therefore, they should be allowed to rear them in their ponds. Applicants have also submitted that the Respondents are under a mistaken belief that the cat fish being reared by them are Clarias gariepinus. They have submitted that Thai cat fish and Indian cat fish are the same species of fish i.e. Clarias batrachus and the Respondents have wrongly labelled Thai cat fish i.e. Clarias batrachus as African cat fish. The applicants have, therefore, requested the Tribunal to issue appropriate direction or orders refraining Respondents from taking any coercive action against rearing, cultivation, storage and transportation of Thai Cat fish.
7. The Respondent States have submitted that the applicants are breeding banned fish i.e. Clarias gariepinus
under the fake shadow of Indian catfish i.e. Clarias batrachus which has been confirmed by the test report of NBFGR (a unit of ICAR). The Counsel appearing for the State of Uttar Pradesh has categorically stated that the fish being cultured in the ponds of Hawal Madopur, Dist. Hapur is absolutely banned fish i.e. Clarias gariepinus. A similar submission has also been made for the Ld. Counsels appearing for the State of Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh and Telangana.
8. There is no dispute whatsoever, that the breeding of Indian catfish i.e. Clarias batrachus is allowed in our country and breeding of exotic catfish i.e. Clarias gariepinus
(Thai Magur) and its hybrids is banned in all the States and the Union Territories. In the facts and circumstances, we direct as follows:-
(1) The breeding and culturing of exotic cat fish or its hybrids (Thai Magur etc.) i.e. Clarias gariepinus is prohibited in all the States and the Union Territories. The existing stock will be destroyed forthwith. For this purpose concerned District Collectors/ District Commissioners will take
3
necessary action by forming inspection teams of officials of the fisheries Department for inspection of fish ponds and proper identification of prohibited
Clarias gariepinus i.e. Thai Magur which are being reared and to destroy such stocks forthwith.
(2) All the cat fish breeders shall be required to source their fish from State Fisheries Department or from the agencies which are authorized by the Department for this purpose.
(3) Compliance report of this order shall be filed by the Directors of Fisheries Department of all the States and Union Territories within a period of one month."
5. In the aforesaid matter, the Tribunal has already issued the necessary directions. That part, the State Governments are also well equipped to identify the species based on their biometrics and morphology. All State Governments, including the State of Maharashtra, Kerala, have department of fisheries which carry out such identification based on guidelines and destroy the aquaculture farms of Clarias gariepinus. Hence, no case is made out to accept the prayers made in the OA.
6. OA is accordingly dismissed."
4. The above order duly takes into consideration earlier order of the Tribunal dated 22.01.2019 passed in OA No. 435/2018 wherein the requisite directions were already issued.
5. In the above circumstances, we are of the view that the issue raised in this OA is covered by the earlier orders in OA No. 347/2024 and OA No. 435/2018.
6. Hence, no further order in this OA is required which is accordingly dismissed.
Prakash Shrivastava, CP
Dr. A. Senthil Vel, EM
May 06, 2024
Original Application No. 509/2024
DV