Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2024 INSC 291
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • The First Schedule to the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923
  • Sections 168 and 169 of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923
  • Article 21 of the Constitution
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2024 INSC 291
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • The First Schedule to the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923
  • Sections 168 and 169 of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923
  • Article 21 of the Constitution
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Aabid Khan, sustained injuries in a motor-vehicle accident that occurred on 23 April 2013. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) awarded him compensation of Rs 87,700 with 7% interest per annum. Dissatisfied, he sought enhancement before the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Bench at Indore, which on 21 January 2019 increased the award to Rs 1,27,700, maintaining the same rate of interest. Contending that even this sum was inadequate, the claimant brought the present civil appeal (converted from SLP (C) No. 29227 of 2019) before the Supreme Court of India.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant/claimant is entitled to further enhancement of compensation.
  2. If so, what is the just amount of compensation payable?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar, (2011) 1 SCC 343 Tribunal must actively evaluate medical evidence and ascertain true disability; should not substitute expert testimony without reason. Used to criticise the Tribunal’s reduction of medically assessed disability from 17% to 10% and to restore the doctor’s assessment.
Laxman @ Laxman Mourya v. Divisional Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., (2011) 10 SCC 756 Victims with permanent disability should receive compensation covering physical injury, pain and suffering, loss of earnings and amenities of life. Invoked to justify enhancing amounts for pain, suffering, attendant charges and transportation.
Sidram v. Divisional Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd., (2023) 3 SCC 439 Courts must acknowledge the long-term physical, mental and dignitary impact of serious injuries and avoid “niggardly” awards. Reinforced the need to award fair and dignified compensation, influencing the overall enhancement.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Error in Assessing Disability: The Tribunal and the High Court reduced the medically certified whole-body disability from 17% (as testified by Dr. Alok Mehta, PW-5) to 10% without assigning reasons. Citing Raj Kumar, the Supreme Court held that such substitution of expert opinion is impermissible in the absence of contrary evidence.

2. Determination of Monthly Income: The claimant, a self-employed mechanic with over 30 years’ experience, was originally credited with Rs 3,500 per month. Considering the accident date (23 April 2013) and vocational background, the Court fixed a more realistic figure of Rs 6,500 per month.

3. Recalculation of Loss of Future Income: Applying the correct disability (17%), the income (Rs 6,500), multiplier of 7, and 12 months’ annualization, the Court computed loss of future income at Rs 92,820.

4. Non-Pecuniary Heads: The Court found the combined award of Rs 9,000 for attendant charges, pain and suffering, and transportation “abysmally” low. Guided by Laxman @ Laxman Mourya and Sidram, it granted a lump-sum Rs 1,00,000 under these three heads.

5. Itemised Award: Adding unchallenged medical expenses of Rs 49,300, the total compensation was recalculated to Rs 2,42,120.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; COMPENSATION ENHANCED TO RS 2,42,120 WITH 7% P.A. INTEREST.

Respondent No. 3 (the insurer) must deposit the balance amount with the jurisdictional Tribunal within six weeks. No order as to costs. The decision directly benefits the claimant by increasing his monetary relief; it does not establish new legal precedent but reinforces existing principles on deference to medical evidence and adequacy of compensation in motor-accident claims.

    AABID KHAN v. DINESH

    Reportable

    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

    CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

    CIVIL APPEAL NO. of 2024

    (@ SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 29227 OF 2019) AABID KHAN …APPELLANT

    VERSUS

    DINESH AND OTHERS …RESPONDENT(S)

    J U D G E M E N T

    Aravind Kumar, J.

    1. Leave granted.

    2. We have heard learned advocates appearing for the parties and perused the records.

    3. Challenge is laid in this appeal to the order dated 21.01.2019 passed in MA No.1614 of 2018 by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Bench at Indore whereunder the compensation awarded by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as 'tribunal') by award dated 04.12.2017 in a sum of Rs.87,700/- with interest @ 7% p.a. came to

    1

    be enhanced to Rs.1,27,700/- with same interest contending inter-alia that compensation so awarded by the High Court is on the lower side and same has to be enhanced.

    4. The occurrence of the accident, injuries sustained by the appellant/ claimant in the road accident that took place on 23.04.2013, consequential disability sustained, issuance of insurance policy to the offending vehicle and policy being in force on the date of accident are all undisputed facts. Hence, we do not propose to dwell into those aspects.

    5. The only question that would arise for our consideration is:

    "Whether the appellant/claimant is entitled for enhancement of compensation as urged? And if so, to what amount?"

    6. Perusal of the award passed by the tribunal as modified by the High Court, would reveal that claimant had sustained compound fracture in the left acetabulum and left rib. Dr. Alok Mehta (PW-5), who had examined the claimant had deposed that whole body disability suffered by the claimant was to the extent of 17% and this fact has been elicited in the cross-examination. However, the tribunal computed the compensation towards loss of future income by considering the whole body disability at 10%. On surmises and conjectures the percentage of disability has been reduced. No reason whatsoever has been assigned by the tribunal for

    2

    substituting its opinion to that of the expert opinion namely, the doctor who treated the claimant and examined as PW-5.

    7. This Court in the case of Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar and Another, (2011) 1 SCC 343 has observed:

    "16. The Tribunal should not be a silent spectator when medical evidence is tendered in regard to the injuries and their effect, in particular, the extent of permanent disability. Sections 168 and 169 of the Act make it evident that the Tribunal does not function as a neutral umpire as in a civil suit, but as an active explorer and seeker of truth who is required to "hold an enquiry into the claim" for determining the "just compensation". The Tribunal should therefore take an active role to ascertain the true and correct position so that it can assess the "just compensation". While dealing with personal injury cases, the Tribunal should preferably equip itself with a medical dictionary and a handbook for evaluation of permanent physical impairment (for example, Manual for Evaluation of Permanent Physical Impairment for Orthopaedic Surgeons, prepared by American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons or its Indian equivalent or other authorised texts) for understanding the medical evidence and assessing the physical and functional disability. The Tribunal may also keep in view the First Schedule to the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 which gives some indication about the extent of permanent disability in different types of injuries, in the case of workmen."

    8. In the case of Laxman Alias Laxman Mourya v. Divisional Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. and Another, (2011) 10 SCC 756, this Court observed:

    "15. The ratio of the above-noted judgments is that if the victim of an accident suffers permanent or temporary disability, then efforts should always be made to award adequate compensation not only for the physical injury and treatment, but also for the pain, suffering and trauma caused due to the accident, loss of earning and the victim's

    3

    inability to lead a normal life and enjoy amenities, which he would have enjoyed but for the disability caused due to the accident."

    9. Further, in the matter of Sidram v. Divisional Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. and Another. [(2023) 3 SCC 439] it was observed by this Court:

    "113. Before we close this matter, it needs to be underlined, as observed in Pappu Deo Yadav (supra) that Courts should be mindful that a serious injury not only permanently imposes physical limitations and disabilities but too often inflicts deep mental and emotional scars upon the victim. The attendant trauma of the victim's having to live in a world entirely different from the one she or he is born into, as an invalid, and with degrees of dependence on others, robbed of complete personal choice or autonomy, should forever be in the judge's mind, whenever tasked to adjudge compensation claims. Severe limitations inflicted due to such injuries undermine the dignity (which is now recognized as an intrinsic component of the right to life Under Article 21) of the individual, thus depriving the person of the essence of the right to a wholesome life which she or he had lived, hitherto. From the world of the able bodied, the victim is thrust into the world of the disabled, itself most discomfiting and unsettling. If courts nit-pick and award niggardly amounts oblivious of these circumstances there is resultant affront to the injured victim. [See: Pappu Deo Yadav (supra)]"

    10. In the light of the afore-stated position of law explained when the medical evidence tendered by the claimant is perused, we are of the considered view that tribunal and the High Court committed a serious error in not accepting the said medical evidence and in the absence of any contra evidence available on record, neither the tribunal nor the High Court could

    4

    have substituted the disability to 10% as against the opinion of the doctor (PW-5) certified at 17%. In that view of the matter the compensation awarded under the head 'loss of income' towards permanent disability deserves to be enhanced by construing the whole body disability at 17%.

    11. The monthly income of the claimant has been construed as Rs.3,500/- which is on the lower side particularly in the background of the fact that the accident in question having occurred on 23.04.2013 and the evidence on record disclosing that claimant was self-employed as a mechanic and had work experience of over 30 years. Resultantly his income has to be construed at Rs.6,500/- per month in substitution to Rs.3,500/- computed by the Tribunal and the High Court. Thus, the claimant/appellant would be entitled for enhanced compensation of Rs.92,820/- (Rs.6,500 X 12 X 7 X 17%) towards loss of future income.

    12. We are also of the considered view that compensation awarded by the Tribunal under the heads of Attendant charges, pain and suffering, transportation together in a sum of Rs.9,000 being abysmally on the lower side and same deserves to be enhanced and accordingly a lump sum compensation of Rs.1,00,000/- is awarded under these three (3) heads.

    13. In substitution to the award of Rs.1,27,700/- awarded by the High Court we enhance the compensation as under:

    Sr.No. Particular Amount

    5

    1. Loss of future income due to permanent disability Rs.92,820/-
    2. Medical expenses Rs.49,300/-
    3.  Transportation,  Attendant Charges,  Pain and Suffering Rs.1,00,000/-
    Total Rs.2,42,120/-

    14. We direct the Respondent No.3-Insurance Company to pay the balance amount of compensation with interest @ 7% P.A. as awarded by the Tribunal by depositing the same before the jurisdictional tribunal within 6 weeks from the date of this order.

    15. In the result, the appeal is allowed as aforesaid with no order as to costs.

    …….………………….J.

    (Sanjay Karol)

    …….………………….J.

    (Aravind Kumar)

    New Delhi,

    April 09, 2024

    6

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    AABID KHAN v. DINESH
    (Apr 9, 2024)