Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • MINES ACT 1952
  • ELECTRICITY ACT 2003
  • sub Section 15(2 u ) of the impugned Act,
  • Mines Act, 22 (1997) 2 SCC 42 73 1952
  • section i.e. Section 15 of the impugned Act,
  • Section H 2(g) of the impugned Act,
  • Property Act, 1882,
  • Electricity Generation Rules 2023,
  • Government of Ireland Act 1920 and Section 3 of the Finance Act (Northern Ireland) 1934, (1936) A.C. 352,
  • Land) Act, 1962 (User Rights Acquisition Act)
  • Sales C Tax Act
  • Section 2(g)
  • Section 2(c)
  • b-s. (1) of s. 3 of the Essential Commodities r Act,
  • provisions of the 99 Himachal Pradesh Water Cess on Hydropower Electricity Generation Act, 2023 and the Rules
  • Section 12 with Section 17
  • Mines Act, 1952 read with Section 2(ba) of the User i Rights Acquisition Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • MINES ACT 1952
  • ELECTRICITY ACT 2003
  • sub Section 15(2 u ) of the impugned Act,
  • Mines Act, 22 (1997) 2 SCC 42 73 1952
  • section i.e. Section 15 of the impugned Act,
  • Section H 2(g) of the impugned Act,
  • Property Act, 1882,
  • Electricity Generation Rules 2023,
  • Government of Ireland Act 1920 and Section 3 of the Finance Act (Northern Ireland) 1934, (1936) A.C. 352,
  • Land) Act, 1962 (User Rights Acquisition Act)
  • Sales C Tax Act
  • Section 2(g)
  • Section 2(c)
  • b-s. (1) of s. 3 of the Essential Commodities r Act,
  • provisions of the 99 Himachal Pradesh Water Cess on Hydropower Electricity Generation Act, 2023 and the Rules
  • Section 12 with Section 17
  • Mines Act, 1952 read with Section 2(ba) of the User i Rights Acquisition Act,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The present batch of writ petitions arises from challenges to the Himachal Pradesh Water Cess on Hydropower Generation Act, 2023 ("the Act"), enacted by the State of Himachal Pradesh. The petitioners are multiple power generation companies operating hydropower projects in the State. They contest the constitutional validity and legislative competence of the State Government to levy a water cess purportedly on the usage of water for hydropower generation. The petitioners argue that the levy is, in substance, a tax on the generation of electricity, which is beyond the State's legislative competence. The State defends the Act as a valid exercise of its powers under Entries 17, 18, 45, 49, 50, and 66 of List-II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India.

The petitions were heard together and decided by this common judgment due to the identical issues involved.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the levy imposed by the Himachal Pradesh Water Cess on Hydropower Generation Act, 2023, is a tax on the generation of electricity or a cess on the usage of water for hydropower generation.
  2. Whether the State Legislature has the legislative competence to enact the impugned Act under the Constitution of India.
  3. Whether the Act suffers from the vice of excessive delegation of legislative power by empowering the State Government to fix rates of water cess without laying down adequate guidelines or legislative policy.
  4. Whether the principle of promissory estoppel applies to preclude the State from levying the water cess.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The levy under the Act is, in substance, a tax on the generation of electricity and not on the usage of water, which is beyond the State's legislative competence under Articles 245, 246, and 265 of the Constitution.
  • The Constitution demarcates legislative powers through the Seventh Schedule, and no entry in the State List authorizes the State to levy tax or cess on the generation of electricity.
  • The levy violates Article 288 as the Act was not reserved for the President's consideration, and presidential assent was not obtained.
  • The Act encroaches upon the Union's exclusive power over inter-State rivers and water resources under Entry 56 of List-I.
  • The levy contravenes Article 300A by infringing vested rights of the petitioners under their agreements with the State Government.
  • The Act violates Articles 14 and 19 of the Constitution by being arbitrary and imposing excessive rates that render projects unviable.
  • The Act suffers from excessive delegation as Section 15 empowers the Government to fix rates by notification without any legislative guidelines or standards.
  • The levy lacks essential components of a valid tax statute, notably the "measure of tax" or value on which the rate is applied is unspecified.
  • The State is estopped from imposing the cess based on prior assurances that water would be freely available for hydropower generation.

State's Arguments

  • Water is a State subject under Entry 17 of List-II, and the State has legislative competence to impose cess or tax on water usage.
  • The levy is on the non-consumptive usage of water for hydropower generation and not on electricity generation per se.
  • The Act is enacted under Entries 17, 18, 45, 49, 50, and 66 of List-II, which empower the State to legislate on water, land revenue, mineral rights, and fees.
  • The levy is not retrospective but prospective and applies to existing and future hydropower projects.
  • The Act does not violate Article 300A as the petitioners do not have exclusive rights over water.
  • The Act contains provisions for registration, assessment, and recovery of water cess, and the cess proceeds are for development, management, and conservation of water resources.
  • The delegation of power to fix rates by notification is valid, as the legislature provided sufficient guidance and policy.
  • The levy is not arbitrary and the financial burden on the petitioners does not affect the validity of the legislation.
  • The State enjoys a presumption of constitutionality and the entries in the Seventh Schedule must be given liberal construction.

Union of India's Stand

  • The Union questions the State's competence to enact the Act, emphasizing the exclusive power of Parliament to legislate and levy tax on generation of electricity under Entries 84 and 97 of List-I.
  • The levy is a disguised tax on generation of electricity, which is outside the State's legislative domain.
  • The levy violates Articles 286, 287, and 288 by imposing tax on inter-State sale and consumption of electricity.
  • The Union Ministry of Power issued a letter directing States not to levy such taxes/duties, as they are unconstitutional.

Arguments of Senior Advocates and Counsel for Petitioners

  • Reliance on judicial precedents distinguishing tax, fee, and cess, emphasizing that the Act is a tax on electricity generation.
  • Invocation of constitutional provisions and entries in the Seventh Schedule to demonstrate lack of competence in the State Legislature.
  • Contestation of the validity of the delegation of power to fix rates without legislative policy or guidelines.
  • Highlighting the financial impact of the levy on small hydropower developers and the principle of promissory estoppel.

Arguments of Learned Attorney General and Senior Advocate for the State

  • Support for the State's competence under Entries 17, 18, 45, 49, 50, and 66 of List-II to legislate and levy cess on water usage.
  • Emphasis on the definition of water as a natural resource and mineral, and the inclusion of water in the concept of land for taxation purposes.
  • Assertion that the levy is on water drawn and not on electricity generation, with the head (height) being a factor for rate fixation.
  • Reliance on multiple Supreme Court judgments to support the validity of the Act and the power of the State to impose such cess.
  • Submission that the Act is prospective, and that financial burden does not invalidate the legislation.
  • Argument that the delegation of power to fix rates is constitutionally permissible with adequate guidance.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India and Another vs. Mohit Mineral Private Limited, 2019 (2) SCC 599 Distinction between tax, fee, and cess. Supported petitioners' argument that cess is a tax for all intents and purposes.
M.P. Cement Manufacturers Association vs. State of Madhya Pradesh, 2004 (2) SCC 249 State can tax sale and consumption of electricity but not generation. Affirmed that generation of electricity is under exclusive Union jurisdiction.
National Hydroelectric Power Corporation Limited vs. State of Jammu and Kashmir, 2005 (2) JKJ 5 State's competence to levy taxes on electricity generation. Followed in support of petitioners' challenge to the Act.
Bharti Airtel Limited vs. State of Assam, 2016 (4) Guahati Law Times 781 Interpretation of electricity as goods and respective taxing powers. Supported petitioners' position on legislative competence.
Navinchandra Mafatlal vs. The Commissioner of Income Tax, Bombay City, 1955 (1) SCR 829 Entries in Seventh Schedule to be construed liberally and broadly. Guided the Court's approach to interpreting legislative competence.
The Calcutta Gas Company (Proprietary) Ltd. vs. State of West Bengal, 1962 Suppl. (3) SCR 1 Harmonization of conflicting entries in Seventh Schedule. Used to reconcile entries related to water, land, and taxation.
Raja Jagannath Baksh Singh vs. State of Uttar Pradesh, AIR 1962 (SC) 1563 Liberal construction of constitutional entries conferring legislative power. Supported broad interpretation of entries but limited by nature of levy.
Khyebari Tea Co. vs. State of Assam, (1964) 5 SCR 975 Power to levy tax includes power to fix rates and prescribe recovery mechanisms. Clarified scope of legislative power and taxation essentials.
State of West Bengal vs. Kesoram Industries Ltd., (2004) 10 SCC 201 Measure of levy indicative of nature of tax, not determinative. Applied to analyze nature of water cess vis-à-vis electricity generation.
Ichchapur Industrial Coop. Society Ltd. vs. Competent Authority, ONGC, 1997 (2) SCC 42 Interpretation of water as mineral for taxation purposes. Distinguished; not applicable for interpreting Entries in Seventh Schedule.
Government (NCT of Delhi) vs. Union of India & Anr., 2018 (8) SCC 501 Widest amplitude to be given to legislative entries; balancing federal structure. Supported State's argument on legislative competence but subject to limits.
Gwalior Rayon Silk Mfg. Co. Ltd. vs. The Assistant Commissioner of Sales Tax, 1974 (4) SCC 98 Limits on delegation of legislative power; guidance required when fixing tax rates. Held that delegation without guidance is unconstitutional.
M/s Govind Saran Ganga Saran vs. Commissioner of Sales Tax and others, AIR 1985 SC 1041 Four essential components of a valid tax statute. Applied to hold the Act invalid for lack of "measure of tax".
Rajendra Diwan vs. Pradeep Kumar Ranibala and Another, 2019 (20) SCC 143 Harmonization of entries to avoid rendering any nugatory. Used to limit State's interpretation of "land" and related entries.
M.P.V. Sundararamier & Co. vs. The State of Andhra Pradesh and another, AIR 1958 SC 468 Distinction between general subjects of legislation and taxation powers. Held that taxation entries are distinct and exclusive.
The Corporation of Calcutta and another vs. Liberty Cinema, AIR 1965 SC 1107 Delegation of power to fix tax rates permissible with adequate guidance. Applied to assess validity of delegation under the impugned Act.
Pandit Benarsi Das Bhanot v. The State of Madhya Pradesh, [1959] SCR 427 Fixation of tax rates not an essential legislative feature; delegation allowed. Supported the principle that fixing rates can be delegated.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a detailed examination of the nature and character of the levy imposed by the Himachal Pradesh Water Cess on Hydropower Generation Act, 2023. The Court observed that the levy is not merely on the usage or drawl of water but is intrinsically linked to the generation of electricity, as evidenced by the tariff structure fixed based on the "head" or height from which water falls on the turbine. This measure is indicative of a tax on electricity generation rather than a tax on water usage.

The Court applied the principle of "pith and substance" to determine the true nature of the legislation, concluding that in substance, the Act imposes a tax on the generation of electricity, which is a subject exclusively within the jurisdiction of the Union Parliament under Entries 84 and 97 of List-I of the Seventh Schedule and Articles 245 and 246 of the Constitution.

The Court rejected the State's reliance on Entries 17, 18, 45, 49, 50, and 66 of List-II, holding that these entries either relate to regulatory powers or to taxes on land and mineral rights, none of which cover a tax on electricity generation or water usage linked to it. The Court found that the levy does not satisfy the twin conditions for a tax on land under Entry 49, nor can the non-consumptive use of water for hydropower be classified as taxing mineral rights under Entry 50.

The Court further held that the Act suffers from the vice of excessive delegation, as Section 15 empowers the State Government to fix the rates of water cess by notification without laying down any legislative policy, guidelines, or limits. The absence of a defined "measure of tax" or value on which the rate is applied renders the levy constitutionally infirm.

The Court noted that the Act does not provide for an opportunity of personal hearing in the adjudication process, violating principles of natural justice and Article 14.

The Court also observed that the principle of promissory estoppel raised by the petitioners was rendered academic in light of the above findings.

Holding and Implications

The Court held that:

  • The Himachal Pradesh Water Cess on Hydropower Generation Act, 2023, is beyond the legislative competence of the State Government under Articles 246 and 265 of the Constitution of India and is therefore ultra vires.
  • The Himachal Pradesh Water Cess on Hydropower Electricity Generation Rules, 2023, are quashed and set aside.
  • Sections 10 and 15 of the Act, as applied to existing projects, are declared ultra vires and are quashed and set aside.
  • Any amounts recovered by the respondents from the petitioners under the Act and Rules are ordered to be refunded within four weeks.
  • All letters, notices, and communications issued by the State Government or the Himachal Pradesh State Commission for recovery of water cess under the Act and Rules are declared illegal and quashed.
  • All pending miscellaneous applications stand disposed of.

The decision directly affects the parties by invalidating the levy and mandating refund of amounts collected. The Court did not set any new precedent beyond the application of well-established constitutional principles on legislative competence and taxation.

    NHPC LTD v. THE STATE OF HP AND OTHERS

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA

    CWP No. 2916 of 2023 a/w CWP Nos.

    2262, 2263, 2277, 2600, 2721, 2739,

    2855, 2864, 2869, 2913, 2917, 2918, .

    3083 to 3087, 3107, 3114 to 3117,

    3129, 3130, 3246, 3247, 3249, 32 . 60P,

    3300, 3410, 3897, 3898, 4105, 4111,

    4163, 4239, 5410 and 7 f 29 5 H of 2023. Reserved on: 20.12.2023 Decided on : 05.03 o .2024 1. CWP No. 2916/2023

    N.H.P.C. Ltd. r t ..…Petitioner Versu u s

    State of H.P. & ors. o …..Respondents 2. CWP No. 2262/2023

    Malana Powe r C C ompany Ltd. ..…Petitioner Versus

    iStag te of

    h H.P. & ors. …..Respondents

    3. CWP No. 2263/2023 H A.D. Hydro Power Ltd. ..…Petitioner Versus State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents

    4. CWP No. 2277/2023

    Nanti Hydro Power Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner

    1

    Versus State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents

    5. CWP No. 2600/2023

    .

    Everest Power Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner Versus P

    .

    State of H.P. & ors. …..Respon H dents

    6. CWP No. 2721/2023

    Sandhya Hydro Power Projects Balargh a P o vt. Lt

    fd. ..…Petitioner Versus

    t

    State of H.P. & ors. u r …..Respondents 7. CWP No. 2739/2023

    Bonafide Himachalies o Hydro Power Developers Association C

    ..…Petitioner Versus State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents

    8. g CWP h No2855/2023 i N.T.P.C. Ltd. ..…Petitioner H

    Versus State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents 9. CWP No. 2864/2023

    Bhakra Beas Management Board & anr. ..…Petitioners Versus

    2

    State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents

    10. CWP No. 2869/2023

    S.J.V.N. Ltd. ..…Petitioner

    .

    Versus State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents . P

    11. CWP No. 2913/2023

    H

    M/s Surya Kanta Hydro Energies Pvt. Ltd. ..… f Petitioner Versus

    o

    State of H.P. & ors. r t …..Respondents 12. CWP No. 2917/2023

    M/s Himshakti Projects Pv u t. Ltd. ..…Petitioner

    o Versus State of H.P. & o C rs. …..Respondents 13. CWP No. 2918/2023

    M/s Pa h tikari Power Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner

    i g Versus H State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents 14. CWP No. 3083/2023 M/s Gangdari Hydro Power Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner Versus State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents

    3

    15. CWP No. 3084/2023

    M/s Greenko Astha Projects (India) Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner Versus

    .

    State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents

    16. CWP No. 3085/2023 .P

    M/s Greenko Tarela Power Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner

    H

    Versus State of H.P. & ors. o …..R

    fespondents

    17. CWP No. 3086/2023

    M/s. Technology House (India) Pv r t. L t td. ..…Petitioner Versus State of H.P. & ors. u …..Respondents

    18. CWP No. 3087/20 o 23

    M/s Greenko T C ejassarnika Hydro Energies Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner

    h Versus

    iStag te of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents H 19. CWP No. 3107/2023 M/s Greenko Sri Sai Krishna Hydro Power Energies Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner Versus State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents

    4

    20. CWP No. 3114/2023

    M/s Greenko Sumez Hydro Energies Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner Versus

    .

    State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents

    P

    21. CWP No. 3115/2023 .

    M/s Greenko AT Hydro Pvt. Ltd. ..… f Pe tit H ioner Versus State of H.P. & ors. o …..Respondents

    22. CWP No. 3116/2023 t

    M/s Greenko Cimaron Construct r ions Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner

    o Versus State of H.P. & o C rs. …..Respondents 23. CWP No. 3117/2023 M/s Gre h enko Him Kailash Hydro Power Pvt. Ltd. g

    ..…Petitioner i Versus H State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents 24. CWP No. 3129/2023 M/s Greenko Anubhav Hydel Power Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner Versus

    State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents

    5

    25. CWP No. 3130/2023

    JSW Hydro Energy Ltd & anr. ..…Petitioner Versus

    .

    State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents

    26. CWP No. 3246/2023 .P

    Taranda Hydro Power Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner

    H

    Versus State of H.P. & ors. …..Rfespondents

    27. CWP No. 3247/2023 o

    Panchhor Hydro Power Pvt. Ltd. t

    ..…Petitioner Versus r

    State of H.P. & ors. o u …..Respondents 28. CWP No. 3249/2023

    M/s Ramesh Hy C dro Power Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner h Versus Sta g te of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents i 29. CWP No. 3260/2023 H

    M/s Kanchanjunga Power Company Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner Versus State of H.P. & Anr. …..Respondents

    30. CWP No. 3300/2023

    Tissa Hydro Power Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner

    6

    Versus State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents

    .

    31. CWP No. 3410/2023

    I.A. Hydro Energy Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner .P

    Versus

    H

    State of H.P. & ors. …..R f esp ondents 32. CWP No. 3897/2023

    Rajpur Hydro Power Plant Ltd. t o ..…Petitioner Versus State of H.P. & Anr. u r …..Respondents

    33. CWP No. 3898/20 o 23

    M/s Goodwill E C nergy Enterprises ..…Petitioner Versus State of h H.P. & Anr. …..Respondents

    i34g . CWP No. 4105/2023 H Himachal Sorang Power Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner Versus State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents 35. CWP No. 4111/2023

    M/s Greenko Budhil Hydro Power Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner Versus

    7

    State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents

    36. CWP No. 4163/2023

    M/s Luni Power Company Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner .

    Versus

    P

    State of H.P. & Anr. …..Respondents.

    37. CWP No. 4239/2023 H

    Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd. .. f …Petitioner Versus

    o

    State of H.P. & ors. r t …..Respondents 38. CWP No. 5410/2023

    GMR Bajoli Holi Hydro Pow u er Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. o

    ..…Petitioners Versus State of H.P. & o C rs. …..Respondents 39. CWP h No. 7295/2023 Pro g digy Hydro Power Pvt. Ltd. ..…Petitioner i Versus H

    State of H.P. & ors. …..Respondents Coram The Hon'ble Mr. Justice Tarlok Singh Chauhan, Judge. The Hon'ble Mr. Justice Satyen Vaidya, Judge.

    Whether approved for reporting? Yes

    8

    For the petitioner(s): Mr. Tushar Mehta, Sr. Advocate (through VC) with Mr. Vijay

    Kumar Arora and Mr. Avneesh

    Arputtham, Advocates, for the

    petitioner in CWP No. 2916 of 2023.

    .

    Ms. Shalini Thakur and Dr. Seema Jain (through VC) Advocates for the petitioners in CWP Nos. 2262 anPd 2263 and Ms. Shalini Tha.kur, Advocate, for the petitioner in CWP No. 2721 of 2023.

    H

    Mr. S. Ganesh, S o r. Ad f vocate (through VC) and Mr . Rajnish Maniktala, Senior Advocate with Mr. Naresh Kumar Verma, Advocate, for the petitione r r ( t s) in CWP Nos. 2277, 2600, 3246, 3247, 3249, 3300, 4105 an u d 4111 of 2023. Mr. Vikas Chauhan, Mr. Vishwajeet o Tyagi, Mr. Tarun Johri and Mr. Sarthak Mehta, Advocates, for the C

    petitioner(s) in CWP Nos.2739, 2917 and 2918 of 2023. Mr. K.D. Shreedhar, Senior Advocate h

    with Mr. Sameer Thakur, Ms. Sneh Bhimta and Mr. Adarsh Tripathi, g

    Advocates, for the petitioner(s) in i

    CWP Nos. 2855, 2913, 3083 to 3087, 3107, 3114 to 3117 and 3129 of H

    2023. Mr. N.K. Sood, Senior Advocate with Mr. Aman Sood, Advocate, for the petitioner(s) in CWP Nos. 2864 and 3410 of 2023 alongwith Ms. Vandana Gupta, Sr. Law Officer and Ms. Amandeep Kaur, Law Officer.

    Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi

    (through VC) and Mr. R.L. Sood,

    9

    Senior Advocates with Mr. H.S. Chandoke, Mr. Anant Garg and Mr. Janesh Gupta, Advocates, for the petitioner in CWP No.3130 of 2023. Mr. Sujit Ghosh (through VC), Mr. .

    Nishant Kumar, Mr. Virender Sharma, Ms. Anshika Agarwal (through VC) and Ms. Man . naPt Waraich, Advocates, for the H petitioner in CWP No.3260 of 2023. Mr. Tushar Mehta, Sr. Advocate (through VC) Mr. o K. D f . Shreedhar, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Shradha Karol, Mr. Vaibhav Singh Chauhan and Ms. Sneh Bhim t ta, Advocates, for the petitione r r(s) in CWP No. 2869 of 2023. Ms u . Shradha Karol and Mr. Vaibhav Singh Chauhan, Advocates, for the o petitioner in CWP Nos.3897, 3898 and 4163 of 2023.

    C

    Mr. Anand Sharma, Senior Advocate with Mr. Karan Sharma, Advocate, for the petitioner in CWP No. 4239 of h

    2023. g

    Mr. Ankur Sehgal and Janesh i

    Gupta, Advocates, for the petitioner in CWP No. 5410 of 2023. H

    For the respondents:Mr. Dushyant Dave, Senior Advocate, with Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General, Mr. I.N. Mehta and Mr. Yashwardhan Chauhan, Senior Additional Advocate Generals, Mr. Navlesh Verma, and Ms. Sharmila Patial, Additional Advocate

    Generals and Mr. J.S. Guleria,

    Deputy Advocate General, for the

    respondents-State, in all the matters.

    10

    Mr. Balram Sharma, Deputy Solicitor General ofIndia and Mr. Rajinder Thakur, Central Government Counsel, for the

    respondent- Union of India.

    .

    Mr. Anand Sharma, Senior Advocate with Mr. Karan Sharma, Advocate, for respondent No. 14 in CWP . NoP. 2855 of 2023 and for respondent No. 6 in CWP No. 2869 of 2023.

    H

    Ms. Sunita Sharma, f S r. Advocate, with Ms. Lalita S o harma, Advocate, for respondent No .6 in CWP Nos.2917 & 2918 of 2023 and for respondent No.8 in CWP t No.2869 of 2023. Mr. Ni r tin Thakur, Advocate, for res u pondent No. 7 in CWP No.2855 of 2023 and for respondents No.11 to 13 in CWP No.2869 of 2023. o M/s Satish Mukherjee, Abhishek C

    Kumar, Nived, Shubham Mudgil and Mr. Janesh Gupta, Advocates, for respondent No.11 in CWP No.2855 of 2023. h Mr. Shivom Vashishta, Advocate, for g

    respondent No.14 in CWP No.2855 of i

    2023 and respondent No.6 in CWP No.2869 of 2023. H

    Justice Tarlok Singh Chauhan Since, somewhat identical issues of fact and law are involved in these batch of writ petitions, therefore, they have been decided by this common judgment.

    11

    Case of the Petitioner(s):

    1.1. The petitioners are power generation companies .

    engaged in the production of the electricity by using river water. They own, operate and maintain the hydropo . wePr projects. The petitioners after entering into agre em H ents with the Government of Himachal Pradesh are f running the projects. The petitioners seek to assail the legislative competence, the constitutional validit y aond the vires of the

    Himachal Pradesh Water Cess on r H t ydropower Generation Act, 2023 (hereinafter to be refe u rred to as the "Act"), inter alia, on the following grounds:

    (i) The C State o lacks legislative competence/power as pe r Article 265 of the Constitution of India. (ii) h The legislative powers of the Union Government or g

    the State Government have been so demarcated i

    and specified by way of Seventh Schedule under H

    List-I known as Union List, List-II known as State List, List-III known as Concurrent List. Thus, the State Government has legislative powers under Article 265 of Constitution of India to levy any cess

    only if the same finds mention in List-II. However,

    12

    none of entries under List-II or the State List empowers the State Government to levy cess/tax on water usage for the purpose of generation of .

    electricity, as has been done by the State Government. .P

    (iii) Entry 53 of List-II empowers the State G H overnment to levy tax/cess in respect of electricity, however, that entry is not applicable and doefs not empower

    the State Government to t le vy ocess on water usage for the purpose of gen r eration of hydro electricity. (iv) The State cannot take recourse to entry No.17 of list-II for d o efenduing its impugned Act as the same firstl C y does not empower the State Govt. to levy a ta x or cess on water and secondly, even for the h sake of arguments, if entry No. 17 of List Il so g

    empowers the State Government, the impugned Act i

    cannot become operative in view of the non- H

    compliance of the provisions of Article 288 of Constitution of India. (v) The State Government by way of provisions of the Act has vested with itself non-consumptive usage

    of water of inter-state rivers, which amounts to

    13

    encroaching upon the legislative powers of the Union Government, as under List-I of the Seventh Schedule by way of entry No.56, it is only the .

    Union Government, which has the legislative powers with respect to interstate rivers and r . ivePr valleys. H

    (vi) The Hydroelectric Power Projects of f th e petitioners are Central Sector Hydroelectric Power Projects built over inter-state rive t rs, naomely, Ravi and Beas and its tributaries, w r ith the sanction of the Union Government a u nd, therefore, any restriction imposed b o y the State Government in the usage of wate C r flowing from the said rivers by way of seeking sa nction for non consumptive usage of river water h and further by way of levy of cess on such non- g

    consumptive use of inter-state river water for i

    generation of electricity, is wholly illegal and invalid H

    being beyond the legislative competence/power of the State Government. (vii) The Govt. of India, Ministry of Power taking note of the fact that some of the States have imposed

    taxes/duties on generation of electricity in the

    14

    guise of water tax/cess, vide letter dated 25.04.2023 had called upon all the Chief Secretaries of the State Governments and Union .

    Territories not to levy such tax/duty/cess being contrary to the constitutional provisions and . thPe same be promptly withdrawn. H

    (viii) Section 10 of the Act and Rule f 7 of Himachal Pradesh Water Cess from H ydro Power Generation Rules, 2023 (for short "t t he Ruoles") have impact of taking away the right r s that have been crystallized or vested on the u petitioners. The impugned Act has a retrospec o tive effect. Even though, the Legislature is en C titled to make an enactment with retrospective ef fect, but it cannot take away the rights that have h already been vested in the petitioners. g (ix) The provisions of the Act go to show that two i

    conditions are required to be fulfilled for levy of H

    cess. One is that water is drawn from the source and another is that drawl of such water is for generation of electricity. If one of the conditions is lacking, the levy of cess is not attracted. So, in

    "pith and substance" levy of cess is on generation

    15

    of electricity. The State lacks the competence to levy cess or tax on generation of electricity because this field is reserved for Parliament under entries .

    No. 84 and 97 of List-I of Seventh Schedule. This colourable exercise of power by the State . Pis unconstitutional. H

    (x) The impugned Act is also bad i f n l aw as it is violative of Article 300A of C on o stitution of India. (xi) The impugned Act is also hit by Article 288 of Constitution of India r as t it was not reserved for the consideration of the Hon'ble President and

    Presidential ascuent has not been obtained before

    enfo C rcing t o he impugned Act. (xii) Si nce, majority of the rivers and their tributaries, h over which the Hydro Power Projects have been g

    constructed, are inter-State, therefore, they are i

    covered by entry 56 of list-I of Seventh Schedule of H

    the Constitution. Thus, the State Govt. is not competent to make any law regarding inter-State rivers.

    (xiii) The impugned Act is repugnant to Section 62 read with section 79 of Electricity Act, 2003 as the said

    16

    Central Act of 2003 provides for the fixation of tariff for electricity is to be vested with the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission. .

    (xiv) The State of Himachal Pradesh lacks the legisla . tive competence to levy tax/cess on water use for thPe generation of hydro electricity since t he H said levy directly relates to the power generated and transferred outside the State o o f Him

    fachal Pradesh.

    (xv) No public purpose or t objective sought to be achieved has been p r rovided in the impugned Act and it has far-re u aching effects on the general public and is the o refore, liable to be struck down on this grou C nd as well. (xvi) Th e levy of tax/cess on use of water is contrary to h Articles 14 & 19 of the Constitution of India as the g

    said levy is arbitrary and; because extremely high i

    rates have been notified, it would render the H

    projects of petitioners totally unviable. (xvii) The impugned Act is framed as taxing the drawl of water, whereas, in essence, it is taxing the generation of electricity which is impermissible in

    law.

    17

    (xviii) The Act seeks to charge the water cess based the head of the turbine. Thus, the water cess sought to be charged is directly relatable to the head. The .

    levy of cess under the Act is based on the premise of higher the head, the more will be electr . icitPy generated for the same value of the w H ater used. Therefore, the impugned Act seeks to levy cess on the generation of the electricity/hfydropower and

    not drawl of the water alone . o

    (xix) There is no entry in r Li t st-II which empowers the State to levy u a tax on the generation of the electricity o and hence, impugned enactment is void abinitio.

    (xx) Ta x C is imposed on "user" who is the person, who h draws the water for generation of the electricity. g

    Therefore, taxable event is not mere drawl of water i

    but the drawl of water for the generation of H

    electricity. (xxi) The Act is unconstitutional since the charging section does not lay down any guidelines, limitations or safeguards. Therefore, such

    legislative architecture suffers from the vice of the

    18

    excessive delegation and thereby violative of Article 14 plainly and is thus void.

    (xxii) Since, there is no provision providing for an .

    opportunity of personal hearing, thereby the Act not only violates the principles of natural jus . ticPe but is violative and ultra vires of the Ar H ticle 14 of the Constitution of India.

    (xxiii) The impugned Act is otherwise illegafl as Section 30 thereof is in contradiction t to Soection 28. (xxiv) The Act otherwise is r liable to be struck down in absence of ther u e being any provision for having a judicial m o ember when admittedly the power to deter C mine the cess has been assigned or given to a Co mmission exercising quasi judicial functions. (xx h v) The impugned Act of the State is also contrary to g

    the principles of promissory estoppel as at the time i

    of investment of thousand of crores of rupees in H

    the setting up of the Hydro Power Projects in the State of Himachal Pradesh, the implication upon the petitioners was to provide 12% or 13% of the power generated free of cost to the home state, but

    at all material times, the entire basis of investment

    19

    in the State of Himachal Pradesh was that the basic and fundamental resource for hydroelectric power generation i.e. water would be freely .

    available to the petitioners and now the S . tate Government cannot turn around and is bound bPy the principles of promissory estoppel. H

    Defence of the State:

    2.1. Since water is a State's sub je o ct ma

    ftter and comes under entry 17 of List-II, therefore, the State has legislative competence to make law and henc t e there is no violation of article 265 of the Constituti u on of rIndia. 2.2. Cess has n o ot been levied on generation of electricity under entry No. C 53, but has been levied for usage charges on water under e ntry No. 17 of list-II. 2.3. h Further, under entries No. 17, 18, 45, 49 and 50 of Lis g t-II, t e State can also impose tax on water. As such cess is i not on electricity generation or on electric units, as alleged. H 2.4. Levy of cess on usage of water for hydropower generation is not in violation of Article 288 of the Constitution of India as the issue in the instant case is not about sale and purchase of water and electricity. Tax is not in respect of the

    water or electricity stored, generated, consumed distributed or

    20

    sold by any authority established by any existing law or for any law made by the Parliament for regulating or developing inter-State river or river valley as such it does not come .

    under entry No. 56 of List-I, rather it is a cess on n . on-consumptive use of water meant for usage of water by thPe hydropower projects, which does not fall under a rt H icle 288(1) of the Constitution of India and there is no violation of any provisions of The Rivers Boards Act, 1 f 95 o 6 and the Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956.

    2.5. Cess has been levied r by t the Act for usage/drawn storage under entry No. 1 u 7 of List-II, i.e. for development, management, maintenance and conservation of water resources of the C State o by creating additional revenue sources on this acc ount, as such directions, as contained in commun h ication dated 25.4.2023 (supra), being not mandatory, are g not required to be adopted by the State. i 2.6. The Act has come into force w.e.f. 10.3.2023, H whereunder existing and forthcoming hydropower projects/ registered users are liable to pay water cess under Section 10(1) and Section 10(2) of the Act for the water usage/water drawn w.e.f. 10.3.2023. Most of the projects have been

    commissioned since long back and debt servicing period of

    21

    these projects have been completed as such there will be no impact on the viability of project due to levying of water cess.

    2.7. The Act does not violate Article 300A of the .

    Constitution of India. The petitioners have no absolute and exclusive right over the water use for generation of . thPe hydropower. The provisions of the agreements signed H between the Government of Himachal Pradesh and Hydropower Projects allow it to build, own, operate &f maintain the projects, therefore, the petitioners cann oto claim exclusive and absolute right on water. t

    2.8. The Act does n u ot viorlate rights of the petitioners under Articles 14, 19 o and even 300A of the Constitution of India.

    2.9. Th e C Act levies cess on usage of water (non-consum h ptive use) on hydropower projects and is not in vio g lation of Articles 200 and 288(2) of the Constitution of i India, rather it is in conformity with the provisions as laid H down under entries No. 17, 18, 45, 48, 49 and 50 of List-II of Seventh Schedule. 2.10. The State Government is absolutely competent to legislate charges on usage of water under entry No. 17 of List-

    II from natural water resources situated within the territory of

    22

    the State Government and the Act does not create any dispute with regard to inter-State rivers water.

    2.11. Levy of cess under the Act on usage of water on .

    hydropower projects has been charged for developm . en P t, maintenance, management and conservation of water resources of the State by creating additional H financial

    resources for this purpose.

    2.12. All the provisions contained in thef impugned Act, more particularly, Sections 2, 10, 1 t 5, 16o and 17 are made in light with the objective of r the impugned Act for its implementation. The provisions of the Act do not violate the fundamental rights o of thue petitioners under Articles 14, 19(1)(g), 246 an C d 265 of the Constitution of India. Stand of the Union of India: 3.1. h The Union of India has filed short affidavits and on g e of such affidavits is found in CWP No.5410/2023, titled i as GMR Bajoli Holi Hydro Power Ltd. Vs State of H.P., H wherein it has questioned the competence of the State legislature in enacting the Act. It would be relevant to reproduce paragraphs 2 to 11 of the same, which read as under:

    "2. That the powers to levy taxes/duties are specifically stated in the VII Schedule. List -II of the VII Schedule

    23

    lists the powers of levying of taxes/duties by the States in entries-45 to 63. No taxes/duties which have not been specifically mentioned in this list can be levied by the State Governments under any guise whatsoever-as Residuary powers are with the Central Government. .

    3. That, Entry-53 of List-II (State List) authorizes th P e States to put taxes on consumption or sale of electr . icity in its jurisdiction. This does not include th H e power to impose any tax or duty on the genera f tion of electricity. This is because electricity generated withi n the territory of one State may be consumed in other States and no State has the power to levy taxes o /duties on residents of

    other States.

    4. That State Legislature un t der the List II of the Seventh Schedule of The C u onstit r ution of India, does not have the Legislative power or the Constitutional mandate to make or promulga o te any law pertaining to imposition of tax on the water drawn by any person much less for non- co nsu C mptive usage of water drawn for generation of electricity. h 5. That Article 248 of The Constitution of India, 1950, states as

    ig

    under "248. Residuary power of Legislation H

    (1) Parliament has exclusive power to make any law with respect to any matter not enumerated in the Concurrent List or State List. (2) Such power shall include the power of making any law imposing a tax not mentioned in either of those Lists."

    A reading of the above Article manifests, that the

    Constitution of India envisaged that in respect of any

    24

    matter which is not enumerated in the State List, the Parliament has the exclusive power to make any laws in respect of the said matter. The same includes the power of imposing a tax not mentioned in the State List or in the concurrent List. This ground is further cemented by the .

    provisions of entry 97 List I (Union List) Schedule . VII P -"Any other matter not numerated in List II or III including any tax not mentioned either of those lists).

    6. That no item provided either in the State H List or the Concurrent List, is pertaining to taxa f tion or taxes on usage of water or otherwise, o therefore the State Government of Himachal t Pra desh does not have the Legislative competence o r r mandate to make or frame any laws pertaining to imposition of taxes on the water drawn for the purposes of generation of electricity in the State of Himacha u l Pradesh. Hence the provisions of Chapters 3 o to 5 seeking to levy and impose Water Tax on generation of electricity are unconstitutional. Hence

    en ac C tment of the said Act and its consequent promulgation and notification is contrary to the h provisions of Article 245, 246 and 286 of The Constitution of India, besides other Articles of The

    ig

    Constitution of India mentioned first hereinabove. 7. That the State of Himachal Pradesh has imposed H

    taxes / duties on generation of electricity under the guise of levying a cess on the use of water for generating electricity. However, though the State may call it a water Tax/cess, it is actually a tax on the generation of electricity - the tax is to be collected ultimately from the consumers of electricity who may happen to be residents

    in other State.

    25

    8. That Article -286 of the Constitution explicitly prohibits States from imposing any taxes /duties on supply of goods or services or on both where the supply takes place outside the State.

    9. That the power to make a law imposing tax upon the .

    electricity sold outside the State, i.e. inter-State sale P s, has been vested exclusively under Entry 92A of L . ist-I read with Article 286 of The Constitution of H India, 24. Government, GOVT Purchase which contemplates taxes on to the Union the sale or of good s other than

    newspapers, where such sale or purchafse takes place in

    the course of inter-State trade or C o ommerce.

    10. That Entry 54 of r List-II of Schedule-VII of The Constitution of India contem t plates enacting a law by the State Government u in regard to imposition of tax on sale or purchase of goods other than newspaper subject to Entry 92A o of List-I, which entry in List 1 empowers solely the Union to make laws for levy of tax on Inter St ate C Sale of Electricity. Additionally none of the above two entries in List II contemplate levy of Cess/ Tax on h electricity generated. 11. That Articles-287 and 288 prohibit the imposition of

    ig

    taxes on consumption or sale of electricity consumed by the Central Government or sold to the Central H

    Government for consumption by the Government or its agencies. As per Entry-56 of the Union List of the Constitution of India, regulations of issues related to Inter-State Rivers come under the purview of the Centre. Most of the Hydro-Electric Plants in the State are located/proposed to be developed on inter- State Rivers.

    Any imposition of tax on the non-consumptive use of

    26

    water of these rivers for electricity generation is in violation of provisions of the Constitution of India."

    Question arising for determination:

    4.1. In order to better appreciate the arguments and .

    deliberations, this Court deems it fit to formulate points tha P t arise for consideration in these petitions and therea . fter deliberate and decide them. The argumen f ts h H ave been addressed by the respective counsel(s) appearing for the parties, some of which are overlapp in o g and repetitive in essence. t

    4.2. From the pleadings o r f the parties and arguments that have been addressed in u detail, some of the key challenges may be noted and sha o ll henceforth be referred to as points for consideration:

    1. It is C misnomer that the tax is levied on water, h whereas it is on generation of electricity, and g

    therefore, not a water tax. i

    2. The State Legislature is not competent to legislate the Act.

    H

    3. In the Act, there is no taxing provision. Tax has been imposed by way of notifications by the concerned Secretary to the Government of Himachal Pradesh. It is an executive act. It is not a tax levied by a statute. The act of levying

    of tax is an excessive delegation by the State

    Legislature.

    27

    4. The principle of promissory estoppel would apply in the instant case; therefore, the State is estopped to charge such a tax.

    Arguments of Mr. Tushar Mehta, learned Senior Advocate . for the Petitioners:

    P

    5.1. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners wo . uld urge that in order to enable the State Legislature t H o levy any tax, the field of legislation should explicitly f fal l within the purview of Articles 246 & 248(2) of th o e Constitution. The taxing entry should be distinct. Le t arn ed counsel would also argue that cess is a misnomer a r s it is a tax for all intents and purposes. u

    5.2. In order to buttress his arguments, he would refer to Sections 2(c) C ,2(h),2o(i)2(g),3,10,12,15,17 and 34 of the 'Act'. The learned counsel for the petitioners has also made a referenc h e to the notification dated 16.2.2023, which prescribes

    idifg ferent rates of cess depending upon the available head i.e. height, to urge that the cess is nothing but a tax as it provides

    H

    for different slabs of cess. In support of his arguments, learned Senior Counsel has referred to the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India and Another vs. Mohit

    28

    Mineral Private Limited1, wherein difference between tax, fee and cess has been culled out.

    5.3. During the course of the arguments, various .

    constitutional provisions have also been referred to by the learned counsel for the petitioner, like Articles 245, 246, 2 . 48P, 265, 286, Entry No. 42, 56, 84, 92A, 97 of List I, En H try 7, 17, 18, 45, 48,49, 53 of List II and entry No. 38 of f List -III. 5.4. It is urged that Article 286 deals with supply of goods outside the State and as per t the soettled law 'electricity' is a 'good' and is normally suppli r ed by the petitioners' projects outside the State. The wor u d used in the article is 'supply of goods' and 'not genera o tion of goods' and thus the State lacks competence to C enact the law. Even under entry 56 of List-I, this power is exclusively vested with the Union of India and as per entr h y 84 only the goods manufactured can at best be taxed an g d even the Parliament cannot impose tax on 'generation of i electricity'. H 5.5. It is then argued that taking the case of the State at its best, that it was under the residuary powers that the tax has been imposed, even then such power is not vested with the State and rather is expressly and exclusively vested

    with the Union of India under entry 97 of List-I. The reliance

    1 201 9 (2) SCC 599

    placed upon by the State on entry No. 17 of List-II is of no avail as tax entry has to be specific in any one of the lists and cannot be inferred. Under this provision the State can only .

    regulate the water but cannot tax it; for it is not a taxing entry. The State cannot even fall back on entry No. 51 as it does . noPt pertain to nor does it contain a reference to 'electricit H y'.

    5.6. Now, as regards entry No. 38 of list- f III, which is the concurrent list, the State can only r eg o ulate electricity, but cannot tax it. For this, there has to a specific provision contained in the Constitution its r elf. t The State can also not be permitted to fall back on en u try No. 47, as there has to be quid pro quo for being termed o as a 'fee' not a 'tax'. 5.7. In o C rder to buttress his arguments, further the learned Counsel has then referred to and placed reliance on the lette h r dat ed 25.04.2023 issued by the Union of India and ha g s vehemently argued that the State is not competent to i impose water tax and cess. The relevant portion of the letter H

    reads as under:- "It has come to the notice of the Government of India (Gol) that some State Governments have imposed taxes/duties on generation of electricity. This is illegal and unconstitutional. Any tax/duty on

    generation of electricity, which encompasses all

    types of generation viz. Thermal, Hydro, Wind,

    30

    Solar, Nuclear, etc. is illegal and unconstitutional. The Constitutional provisions are as follows:

    (i) The powers to levy taxes/duties are specifically stated in the VII Schedule. List II of the VII Schedule .

    lists the powers of levying of taxes duties by the States in entries-45 to 63. No taxes/duties whic P h have not been specifically mentioned in this list .can be levied by the State Governments under H any guise whatsoever - as Residuary power f s a re with the Central Government.

    (ii) Entry-53 of List-II (Sta te o List) authorizes the States to put taxes on consumption or sale of electricity in its jurisd r icti t on. This does not include the power to impose any tax or duty on the generation of ele u ctricity. This is because electricity

    generated o within the territory of one State may be cons C umed in other States and no State has the po wer to levy taxes/duties on residents of other States. h (iii) Some States have imposed taxes/duties on g

    generation of electricity under the guise of levying a i

    cess on the use of water for generating electricity. H

    However, though the State may call it a water cess, it is actually a tax on the generation of electricity the tax is to be collected from the consumers of electricity who may happen to be residents in other State.

    (iv) Article-286 of the Constitution explicitly prohibits States from imposing any taxes/duties on supply of

    31

    goods or services or on both where the supply takes place outside the State.

    (v) Articles-287 and 288 prohibit the imposition of taxes on consumption or sale of electricity consumed .

    by the Central Government or sold to the Central Government for consumption by the Government o P r its agencies. .

    (vi) As per Entry-56 of the Union Li H st of the Constitution of India, regulations of issu es related to Inter-State Rivers come under the f purview of the Centre. Most of the Hydro-E o lectric Plants in the States are located/ propos ed to be developed on Inter-State Rivers. Any im t position of tax on the non- consumptive use of r water of these rivers for electricity genera u tion is in violation of provisions of the Constit o ution of India. (vii) C Hydro Power Projects do not consume water to pr oduce electricity. Electricity is generated by directing the flow of water through a turbine which h generates electricity on the same principle as g

    electricity from wind projects where wind is utilized i

    to turn the turbine to produce electricity. Therefore, H

    there is no rationale for levy of "water cess" or "air cess". (viii) The levy of water cess is against the provisions of the Constitution. Entry-17 of List-II, does not authorize the State to levy any tax or duty on water.

    2. In light of the above constitutional provisions, no taxes/duties may be levied by any State under any guise on generation of electricity and if any taxes /

    32

    duties have been so levied, it may be promptly This has the approval of the Hon'ble Union Minister of Power and New & Renewable Energy".

    5.8. It is next urged by the learned Senior Counsel that .

    before executing the projects, the projects have entered . int P o power purchase agreements (PPAs), under whi ch H they are otherwise obliged to give 12% electricity free f of cost to the State Government and 1% towards rehabilitation making them liable to give 13% of the electricity s t o g en o erated free of cost to the State Government, therefor r e, the State Government is estopped from levying such u tax. Arguments of Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi, learned Senior Advocate for some of o the petitioners: 6.1. Lear C ned Senior Advocate, apart from endorsing the arguments a s addressed by Mr. Mehta, learned Senior

    Advocat h e, would argue that the State has no source of power

    ito g enact the 'Act' and in terms of article 265, there can be no taxation without authority. He would further urge that

    H

    taxation cannot be general but has to be under a specific entry under the Constitution of India and the enactment i.e., the impugned Act, in pith and substance, is a tax on 'generation of electricity' and not on 'drawl of water' and the enactment

    otherwise defies the very federal concept and structure of our

    33

    Constitution and thus is liable to be struck down. He has also referred to the 'objects and reasons' of the 'Act' and would argue that even financial demands of the State have to be .

    legitimate.

    Arguments of learned Attorney General: .P

    7.1. Learned Attorney General has contest ed H the claim of the State in enacting the Act and apart fro f m relying upon the reply filed on behalf of the Union of India has sought to draw support from the notification t da tedo 16.02.2023 issued by the Ministry of Power, Gover r nment of India (as extracted above).

    7.2. In addition theureto, he would argue that the Seventh Schedu C le of t o he Constitution of India provides for the substantive R egulatory Law and the taxing power separately. Taxing p h ower can otherwise not be inferred much less imposed by g implication. In particular, he has invited the attention of i the Court to entry No. 17 of list-II to urge that this entry only H

    regulates the power of the State Government with respect to water and not to impose tax thereupon. Entry No. 17 cannot be read expansively so as to include power to impose tax.

    7.3. He then invited our attention to entry No. 53 of the same list i.e., List No.II to contend that both the aforesaid

    34

    entries i.e., entries No. 17 and 53 have to be read independently and an equitable construction is not permissible in a taxing statute. Moreover, the tax even .

    otherwise can be imposed by the State Government within confines of the State. Even as per entry No. 53 of List -II " . saPle of electricity" as envisaged thereunder cannot mea H n and be construed as generation of electricity. Like sale f of coal will not include generation of electricity out of the use of coal.

    Arguments of Mr. Surjit Ghosh, Advo caote:

    8.1. Shri Surjit Ghosh, A r dvo t cate, apart from adopting the arguments of both the a u foresaid learned Senior Counsel(s), has assailed the o provisions of the Act as being unconstitutiona C l by referring to Section 15 urging that since this provision of law delegates the power to determine the rate of tax t h o the State Government without laying down any gu g idelines, limitation or safeguards, therefore, such legislative i architecture suffers from the vice of excessive delegation and H

    is thereby violative of Article 14 and is plainly void. 8.2. He further argues that the impugned Act fails to clearly lay down one of the critical components of taxing statute i.e. measure of tax and it is trite in law that in order to

    levy a tax so as to make both operative and valid, four

    35

    essential components must be provided in the enacting statute creating the tax/impost, i.e.:

    (i) the taxable event attracting the levy; .

    (ii) the person on whom the levy is imposed and who is obliged to pay the tax; P

    (iii) the rate at which the tax is imposed; and .

    (iv) the measure or value to which the r H ate will be applied for computing the tax l f iab ility. Whereas in the instant cases, though o three of essential components can be identified withi t n t he statute i.e. "taxable event", "the person liable t u o pa r y tax", and the "rate of tax", however, the impugned Act fails to identify the value and equally critical compo o nent i.e. "measure of tax" which is the

    value on whi ch C the rate of tax will be applied for computing the taxing liability. Section 15 of the Act though provides that the 'use h r' shall be liable to pay the water cess at such rates as

    ifixg ed by the Government, however, it fails to prescribe the H value or base on which such rate will be applied. 8.3. He also argues that adjudication of disputes fails to contemplate an opportunity of personal hearing thereby being in violation of the principles of natural justice and thus ultra vires of Article 14.

    36

    8.4. He would further contend that Section 30 of the impugned Act is in contradiction to Section 28 of the Act and is, therefore, bad in law. .

    8.5. Lastly, he would contend that absence of judicial member in quasi-judicial proceedings renders such qu . asPi- judicial proceedings bad in law. H

    Arguments of Mr. Naresh K. Sood, Senior Ad f voc ate: 9.1. Learned counsel for the pe titi o oner(s) in CWP Nos. 2864/2023 and 3410/2023, apart from adopting the arguments of all the aforesaid lea r rne t d counsel(s), would argue that his client i.e. Bhakh u ra Beas Management Board, is a creation of the statu o te after coming into force the Punjab Re-organization Act and has also preferred a representation against the im C pugned levy and till and so long the said represen h tation is not decided, the State cannot levy any cess. Ar g guments of Mr. Anand Sharma, Senior Advocate: i 10.1. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner urged to H contend that the respondents had no power to impose cess on the project i.e. Shanan Power Project, as the same came into existence and is operating for nearly a century now.

    37

    Arguments of Mr. K.D. Shreedhar and Mr. Rajnish Maniktala, Senior Advocates:

    11.1. Learned Senior Counsels for the petitioners have fully supported the arguments of other learned Senior .

    Counsels appearing for the petitioner(s) and have als P o addressed independent arguments assailing the competenc.e of the State to enact the impugned Act. They h f ave v H ehemently urged that the cess has not been imposed on the 'water drawn', but the same has been impose d o on the 'generation of electricity' and before amendmen r t o t f Entry-84 of List I of the Seventh Schedule, in the year 2016, 'electricity' was specifically held to be good u s within the meaning of Entry-84

    and consequently, it w o as only the Parliament, which could levy

    tax on genera tio C n of electricity. After the amendment of Entry-84, now the generation of electricity can only be taxed under Entry-9 h 7 i.e. conferring residual powers upon the Parliament

    iung der List I of Seventh Schedule and in order to buttress their H arguments, they have placed strong reliance on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in M.P. Cement Manufacturers Association vs. State of Madhya Pradesh 2 which judgment

    2 ( 2004) 2 SCC 249

    38

    in turn has been followed by the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir in National Hydroelectric Power Corporation Limited vs. State of Jammu and Kashmir3 and by the .

    Guahati High Court in Bharti Airtel Limited vs. State Assam4. . o P f

    Arguments of Dr. Seema Jain, Advocate: H

    12.1. Learned counsel for the petition f er, apart from adopting the arguments of all the afor esa o id counsel(s) for the petitioner(s), has separately addressed the arguments to contend that the State has no le r gisl t ative competence to enact the law as there is no en u try in the State List which may empower the State t o o impose a tax/cess on generation of electricity.

    Arguments o f M C r.Tarun Johri, Advocate: 13.1. h In addition to adopting the arguments of the afo g resaid learned counsel(s) for the petitioner(s), he would i argue that since his client is an association of Small Hydro H Power Developers, who have installed various projects with the capacity of 25 MW, the financial impact on substantial members of the petitioner due to levy of water cess under the said Act is approximately on an average 43% of total revenue

    3 2005 (2) JKJ 5

    4 2016 (4 ) Guahati Law Times 781

    earned by such projects in a financial year, therefore, it would not only put his client in financial distress, but the State otherwise is estopped from enacting and implementing the .

    impugned legislation.

    14.1. All the other learned counsels appearing for . thPe petitioners have adopted the aforesaid arguments H and have also separately argued, but the same being f on ly repetitive, need not be referred to.

    Arguments of Learned Advocate G t en eraol on behalf of State of Himachal Pradesh:

    15.1. The learned Advocate r General has sought to draw support to levy of water ces u s on the ground that the object of the Act is to conserve o the water and its management as well as to generate r ev C enue from alternate revenue resources as set out in the object of the Act.

    15.2. h He would contend that the petitioners are

    iung necessarily trying to confuse the issue by arguing that the H cess has been imposed on generation of electricity and not the water drawn by their projects for non consumptive use of water. He has taken us through the provisions of the Act, more particularly, provisions those contained in Sections 2(c), 2(g), 2(h), 2(i), 2(j), 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10 and 12 thereof. He is at

    40

    pains to argue that the petitioners are liable to pay cess on the 'water drawn' being its users.

    15.3. Additionally, he would argue that the State .

    Government has, in its reply, specifically clarified that it has imposed cess on 'water drawn' for 'use of hydropo . wePr generation'. The cess is levied under List-II o H f Seventh Schedule. It is the case of the State that entries N o. 17 and 18 are general entries qua field of legisla ti o on of

    f the Legislative Assembly of the State. Entries 45 t to 50 provide for field of legislation for imposing cess/tax r , whereas, entry No. 66 deals with fee.

    15.4. The State o has usubmitted the following points for the Court's cons C ideration. 1. The presumption of constitutionality is in h

    favour of the statute. g

    2. Entries in the list being fields of legislation i

    must receive liberal construction. H

    3. The impugned Act is within the purview of entry 49 'Lands and Buildings' of List II as water is covered under entry "land" being in and over the land.

    41

    4. The Act also falls within purview of entry 50 of List II, as the water is mineral and the State has right over the water flowing or .

    stored within its jurisdiction, which right includes right to tax or impose tax. .P

    5. The water being in and over th e H land, the income/revenue generated from water is the land revenue of the S ta o te un

    fder entry 45 of List II.

    6. The mode of ca r lcu t lation will not determine the nature u of the cess. 7. There o are no structural defects qua C delegation of power etc in statute so as to declare the Act as ultra vires to its h

    provisions/constitution of India. g

    8. Lastly, the public interest would prevail over i

    the private/individual interest. H Arguments of Mr. Dushyant Dave, learned Senior Advocate on behalf of the State of Himachal Pradesh: 16.1. On 13.12.2023, Mr. Dushyant Dave, learned Senior Advocate, appeared on behalf of the State and made additional arguments that:

    42

    (1) Even as per the pleadings of the petitioner(s), the water being consumed for generation of electricity belongs to the State of Himachal .

    Pradesh and the fact that the water belongs to the State and the consumption of wate . r Pis in Himachal Pradesh has been u ne H quivocally acknowledged by them. They have further claimed an unfettered rig o ht of

    fuse of water for the purpose of t t apping the potential for generating hydr r o energy as stored in the river water.

    (2) The S o tate uis not denying the petitioner(s) or C any one of them from using water and since the water falls in the List-II of the Seventh h

    Schedule, the State is well within its power to g

    levy fee, cess or tax, as the case may, on such i

    water or even its non-consumptive use as the H

    water originate from the land. He also invited our attention to Sections 3 and 10 of the impugned Act to convince that the cess is on the "water drawn and not generation of

    43

    electricity", and this, in fact, is the pith and substance of the entire Act.

    (3) Once it is established on record that the .

    impugned Act is a valid piece of legislation, then all the other prayers whereby . thPe petitioners have sought a declaratio H n that the impugned Act is beyond f th e legislative competence of the Sta te o in terms of Articles 245 and 246 of the Constitution, would fall like a pack of ca r rds t . (4) The Act i u s neither retrospective nor retro-active o and, therefore, the provisions of the Act C have been made applicable to the existing projects sought to be declared h

    unconstitutional, quashed and set aside, is g

    clearly fallacious as the Act is prospective. i

    (5) Under Articles 245 and 246 of the H

    Constitution, in particular, sub Article (3) of Article 246, the State has exclusive power to frame laws as regards List II of the Seventh Schedule i.e. State List and such entry must

    receive the widest interpretation. The State

    44

    not only enjoys the exclusive power but also ancillary power under Entry 17, List II, which deals with land and nowhere impinges upon .

    or touches Entry 56 of List-I i.e. Union List, as the tax is confined, as it does not deal w . itPh inter-State regulations, and s uc H h Act is confined to Himachal Pradesh only.

    (6) The Parliament has no o t en

    facted any law prohibiting the Stat t e from using water. (7) He then referr r ed to List-II, Entry 18, to contend th u at land includes water on its sub-terrain or nder land.

    (8) C He al o so referred to Entry 49, which empowers the State to impose tax on land and building h

    i.e. land and anything connected to the land, g

    which according to him, is the plenary power i

    of the State Legislature. H

    (9) The Act stands no judicial scrutiny, as even Entry 66 which deals with fees could be invoked by the State as cess can be taxed as also a fee and going by the latest trend in law,

    45

    even for a fee, there is no co-relationship required to be established.

    (10) He thereafter invited our attention to the .

    reply filed on behalf of the State to contend that the resources of the State are . verPy limited because the State has it H s natural limitation, therefore, the S f tate must be allowed to exploit its natural resources, for which the State t not only has the constitutional powers but also has a duty to

    exploit w u aterr resources. Any other interp o retation would be a narrow C interpretation. (11 ) According to him, the people of the State are h

    the stakeholders and shareholders of the g

    natural resources and the impugned i

    legislation is of a paramount public H

    importance. (12) The mere fact that the hydropower would become more expensive, is no ground to test its constitutional validity, more particularly,

    46

    when the rise in power would be passed on to the consumers.

    (13) It is more than settled that the financial .

    burden would be of no excuse much les . s P a ground to strike down a valid piece of legislation. H

    (14) The Constitution framers gav f e t wo rights to the State, i.e. one under Article 45 of the Constitution; to lev t y re veonue and other under Article 49 of th r e Constitution; to impose tax on land, a u nd thereafter vide Entry 50 confers right o on the State to levy tax on mineral C rights subject to the limitation imposed by the Parliament by law relating to mineral h

    development. The Mines and Minerals Act g

    does not impose any restrictions on the use i

    of minerals and water being a mineral is in H

    the exclusive legislative domain of the State Government. Furthermore, Section 2 of the Mines and Minerals Act does not impose any restrictions on State Government to levy tax

    on minerals.

    47

    (15) If there is a power under the Constitution, it could be traced under any of the Entries, given the fact that the land cannot be .

    interpreted in any narrow and pedantic sense. The impugned piece of legislation . Pis referable to Entries 17, 18, 45, 4 9, H 50 and 60 and does not suffer from any f constitutional vice.

    (16) The petitioner in o t ne of othe cases i.e. NHPC made a profit o r f more than Rs. 3,000 crores and even o u ther projects are earning hundreds of cro o res and, therefore, has no occasion to C complain. (17 ) After the imposition of General Sales Tax h

    (GST), the State must have complete power to g

    augment its resources and generate its i

    income and any narrow interpretation will hit H

    at the federal structure. (18) The petitioners cannot complain that they will not participate in the progress of the State by making the State prosperous and

    48

    will have to pay tax, which has been levied strictly in accordance with law.

    16.2. Mr. Dave, in support of his contention, urged that .

    the 'land' cannot be interpreted in a narrow and pedantic sense and referred to the following judgments of the Hon . 'bPle Supreme Court:- H

    1. Navinchandra Mafatlal vs. The Co mmissioner of Income Tax, Bombay City, 1955 f (1) SCR 829

    2. The Calcutta Gas Company (Proprietary) Ltd. vs. The State of West t B enogal and Ors. 1962 Suppl. (3) SCR 1

    3. Raja Jagann u ath r Baksh Singh vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. AIR 1962 (SC) 1563 4. Khyerba o ri Tea Co. Ltd. & Anr. vs. The State of Assam, 1964 (5) SCR 975.

    5. T C he Anant Mills Co. Ltd. vs. State of Gujarat and Ors. 1975 (2) SCC 175 h 6. The Government of Andhra Paradesh and Anr. vs. Hindustan Machine Tools Ltd. 1975 (2) 274 g

    i

    7. M/s Hoechst Pharmaceuticals Ltd. & Ors. vs. State of Bihar & Ors. 1983 (4) SCC 45 H

    8. Ichchapur Industrial Coop. Society Ltd. vs. Competent Authority, ONGC and Anr. 1997 (2) SCC 42 9. R. S. Rekhchand Mohota Spinning & Weaving Mills Ltd. vs. State of Maharashtra, 1997 (6)

    SCC 12

    10. W. B. vs. Kesoram Industries Ltd. & Ors.

    2004 (10) SCC 201

    49

    11. Government (NCT of Delhi) vs. Union of India & Anr. 2018 (8) SCC 501.

    16.3. According to Mr. Dave, the object of the Act is to .

    levy tax on the water drawn and consumed and in support of such contention, placed reliance on the judgment of Hon . 'bPle Supreme Court in Khyerbari Tea Co. Ltd. & Anr H . vs. The State of Assam5.

    16 .4. He would then contend that f le o gislature can levy tax and then prescribe machinery for th t e same. The tax collected from the producers does not mean that it is a tax on producers and for this purpose has placedr reliance on the Judgment of

    the Hon'ble Supreme o Courut in The Anant Mills Co. Ltd. vs. State of Gujar C at and Ors 6 , The Government of Andhra Paradesh an d Anr. vs. Hindustan Machine Tools Ltd. 7 and M/s Ho h echst Pharmaceuticals Ltd. & Ors. vs. State of Bihar & Ors. 8 i16g .5. He relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble H Supreme Court in Ichchapur Industrial Coop. Society Ltd. 5 1964 (5) SCR 975.

    6 1975 (2) SCC 175.

    7 1975 (2) SCC 274.

    8 1983 (4) SCC 45.

    50

    vs. Competent Authority, ONGC and Anr.9 to canvass that 'water' is a 'mineral' and it was so held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. .

    16.6. According to Mr. Dave, the issue in question as to whether land includes water has been authoritatively deci . dePd by three-judge Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Cour H t in R. S. Rekhchand Mohota Spinning & Weaving Mi lls Ltd. vs. State of Maharashtra,10 and such tax c o ould

    fbe recovered as arrears of the land revenue under E t ntry 45 and in support of such contention strong reliance has been placed upon Sections 42, 43, 44, 63(1) u (d)(e) rand Section 103 of the H.P. Land Revenue Act. Ac o cording to Mr. Dave, the cess is on water and generation C of electricity is only a measure. 16.7. He further relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Suprem h e Court in State of W. B. vs. Kesoram Industries Lt g d. & Ors. 11 to canvass that mere fact that the tax would be i a burden on the consumer, is no ground to assail the same. H 16.8. He would further argue that while interpreting the provisions of the Act, the federal structure is required to be borne in mind. The financial independence of a State is as important as its political independence or it will lose its

    9 19 9 7 (2) SCC 42

    10 1997 (6) SCC 12 11 2004 (10) SCC 201

    independence. In support of such contention, reliance is placed on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in

    Government (NCT of Delhi) vs. Union of India & Anr.12. . Discussions:

    17. Before giving point-wise findings to the . fouPr questions raised in these petitions, the well settled p H roposition of interpretation of law which will be nece ssary while examining the statute needs to be notic ed o .

    f Interpretation of Law:

    18. A Constitution Bench r of t the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Navinchandra Mafatlal vs. The Commissioner of Income Tax, Bombay City13o after uplacing reliance on the observations made by the the C n Chief Justice Gwyer in The United Provinces vs. Atiqa B egum 14 held that the entries in the Seventh Schedul h e of the Constitution should not be read in a narrow or res g tricted sense and that each general word should be held to i extend to all ancillary or subsidiary matters which can fairly H and reasonably be said to be comprehended in it. While construing an entry, the widest possible construction according to the ordinary meaning must be put upon the words used therein. The cardinal rule of interpretation, however, is that

    12 2018 (8) SCC 501

    13 1955 (1) SCR 829 14 1940 F.C.R. 110

    words should be read in their ordinary, natural and grammatical meaning subject to this rider that in construing words in a constitutional enactment conferring legislative power .

    the most liberal construction should be put to the words so that the same may have effect in their widest amplitude. .P

    19. In Calcutta Gas Co.( (Proprietary) Ltd H . vs. State of W.B.15the Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble S upreme Court observed that it may now be taken as well sfettled that every attempt should be made to harmoniz t e t heo apparently conflicting entries not only of different Lists r but also of the same List and to reject that construction which will rob one of the entries of its entire content and make it nuugatory.

    20. In Raja J o agannath Baksh Singh vs. State of U.P.16, the C on C stitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court held tha h t while interpreting the words used in the Constitution, it i g s an elementary cardinal rule of interpretation that the words i used in the Constitution which confer legislative power must H

    receive the most liberal construction and if they are the words of wide amplitude, they must be interpreted so as to give effect to that amplitude. It would be out of place to put a narrow or restricted construction on words of wide amplitude in a

    15 1962 Supp. (3) SCR 1

    16 (1963) 1 SCR 220

    Constitution. A general word used in an entry must be construed to extend to all ancillary or subsidiary matters which can fairly and reasonably be held to be included in it. .

    21. In Khyebari Tea Co. vs. State of Assam17, a Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court held tha . t itP is well settled that when a power is conferred on the Le H gislature to levy a tax, that power must itself widely be co f ns trued; it must include the power to impose a tax and select the articles, commodities for the exercise of suc t h p owoer and must likewise include the power to fix the rate r and prescribe the machinery for the recovery of the tax. u This power also gives jurisdiction to the legislature to mak o e such provisions as, in its opinion, would be necessary to C prevent the evasion of tax. Point No. 1:

    Nature h and e vent of taxation under the impugned Act: 22 g . In order to appreciate the rival contentions, it would i first be necessary to consider the nature and event of taxation H under the impugned Act. 23. The Statement of Objects and Reasons read as under:-

    "STATEMENT OF OBJECTS AND REASONS

    17 (1964) 5 SCR 975

    Himachal Pradesh has been blessed with the immense water resources of five major rivers Satluj, Beas, Ravi, Chenab and Yamuna. These rivers are endowed with immense water flow throughout the year which is being used for generation of hydropower. Further, for proper .

    water conservation and water management, the State P is spending huge amount of money on environment . and social impact mitigation. The developmental activities in the vicinity of hydropower projects are H increasing livelihood of the concerned people. Consider able potential has not been considered on hydropowefr development on this account of environmenta t l an d o social aspects. The State of Himachal P r radesh has very limited revenue generation resourc u es and there always remain financial constraints in the State. Hence, there is an urgent need to improve the o revenue generation in the State through alternate revenue resources. Flowing water in various rivers C and its tributaries in the State can be useful source of r evenue generation. The neighbouring State Uttrakhand h and the Union Territory Jammu & Kashmir have already imposed the water cess on hydropower generation. On the g

    same analogy the State Government has decided to i

    introduce such policy and also opt to impose the water cess to increase the revenue of the State.

    H

    The water cess on hydropower generation will be imposed based on consumption of water and head available in the project, which is considered difference in the level at entry and exit of water conductor system. At present 172 hydropower projects, with installed capacity of 10,991

    MW, have been commissioned in the State. In order to

    deal with the situation of serious financial constraints in

    55

    the State, it has been decided to make the provision to create additional financial resources by imposing water cess on hydropower generation.

    Since, the Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly was .

    not in session and the issue to create alternate revenue resources of the State could not be prolonged, hencPe, keeping in view of the urgency and importance of. the matter, the Governor, Himachal Pradesh, b H y invoking powers under clause (1) of article 213 of the Constitution of India promulgated the Himacha o l Prad f esh Water Cess on Hydropower Generation Ordinance, 2023 (Ordinance No. 2 of 2023) on 15.02.2023 which was published in Rajpatra (e-Gazette) on r t t he same day. Now, this Ordinance is requ u ired to be replaced by a regular enactment. This Bill seeks to replace the aforesaid ordinance with some modifications. This B o ill seeks to achieve the aforesaid objectives."

    24. Th e C Preamble to the Act provides to levy water cess on hydr h opower generation in the State of Himachal Pradesh. 25 g . The name of the 'Act' is The Himachal Pradesh i Water Cess on Hydropower Generation Act, 2023. Section 2 is H

    the definition clause and some of its sub-sections, as are necessary for the determination of this lis, read as under: (c) "Hydropower" is to mean a renewable source of energy that generates power by using water drawn from any water source flowing within the territory of

    the State;

    56

    (g) "User" is to mean any person, group of persons, local body, government department, company,

    corporation, society or anybody, by whichever name called drawing water from any source for generation .

    of hydropower;

    (h) "Water" is to mean natural resource flowing in a P ny river, stream, tributary, canal, nallah or any .other natural course of water or stipulated H upon the surface of any land like, pond, la f goo n, swamp or spring;

    (i) "Water Cess" is to mean th e o rate levied or charged for water drawn for gen t eration of hydropower and fixed under this Act; and;

    (j) "Water Source" is to m r ean a river and its tributaries, stream, nallah, u canal, spring, pond, lake, water course or o any other source from which water is draw C n to generate hydropower. 26. Se ction 3 provides installation of scheme for usage of water h and reads as under:

    ig "3. Installation of scheme for usage of water.—(1) No user shall draw water from any source for hydropower H

    generation except in accordance with this Act." 27. Section 8 deals with grant of registration certificate and reads as under: "8. Grant of registration certificate.—An user intending to use water (non consumptive use) for

    generation of hydropower shall be issued a registration

    57

    certificate after the execution of an agreement between the user and the Commission under this Act."

    28. Section 10 deals with the duties, obligations and responsibilities of the registered user and reads as under: .

    "10. Duties, obligations and responsibilities o . f t P he registered user.—(1) The registered user shall be liable to pay water cess for the water drawn for hydropower

    generation as per the provisions of this Act. H

    (2) Where any user has construct f ed a hydropower scheme, for the purpose of generation of hydropower, prior to the commencemen t t of th o is Act, such user shall, within a period of r one month from the date of commencement of this Act, apply for registration and the Commission shal u l pass an order to register the user within a per o iod of one month from the date of receipt of application in accordance with the provisions of this Act. (3) If C the user as mentioned in sub-section (2) fails to ap ply for registration within time stipulated therein, the Commission shall forthwith impose water cess without h registration on the basis of data of water usage provided g

    by the Directorate of Energy, Himachal Pradesh from the i

    date of commencement of this Act alongwith suitable penalty which may extend to rupees ten lakh and in case H

    of prolonged default with additional fine which may extend to rupees five thousand for every day. (4) Every registered user shall be under an obligation to ensure the safety of the life and property of inhabitants of the area by the operation of the scheme.

    (5) Every registered user shall be bound to allow the Commission or any other officer authorised by the Commission to have an access at any time to the scheme

    58

    for their satisfaction with regard to compliance of the provisions of this Act."

    29. Section 12 provides for assessment of water drawn by the user, which reads as under:- .

    "12. Assessment of water drawn by user.—(1) T P he Commission shall install or cause to be in H stalled . flow measuring device as per the specification s approved by the Commission within the premises of scheme or at such other place where the Commiss f ion deems fit for measuring the water drawn for hydropower generation or

    may adopt any indirect metho d o for assessment of water drawn by the user.

    (2) The expenditure incu r rretd on such installation shall be payable by the us u er." 30. Chapter IV o deals with "Water Cess" and Section 15 is the charging section C which reads as under:- "1 5. Fixation of water cess.—(1) The user shall be liable h to pay the water cess at such rates as the Government may, by notification fix in this behalf. g

    (2) The State Government may review, increase, decrease i

    or vary the rates of the water cess fixed under this section from time to time in the manner it deems fit."

    H 31. The procedure for assessment has been provided in Section 17 which reads as under: "17. Procedure for assessment.—(1) The assessment of water drawn by the user for hydropower generation and

    computation of water cess thereof, shall be carried out by

    the Commission.

    59

    (2) The user shall pay the water cess as assessed under sub-section (1) within such time as may be specified by the Commission.

    (3) If any user fails to pay water cess due on him, penalty shall be imposed on the user as determined .

    by the Commission. The user has to pay water ce P ss along with penalty within extended time H as ma . y be prescribed."

    32. It would be noticed that in the o Stat f ement of Objects and Reasons of the impugned Act, it w as stated that "the State Government has decided to introd r uce t such policy and also opt to impose water cess to increas u e the revenue of the State. The water cess on hydropower generation will be imposed based on consumption of water o and head available in the project, which is

    considered difference in level at entry and exit of water conductor

    system". C

    33. h As per Section 10(i) of the Act every registered user

    iis g liable to pay water cess for the water drawn for hydropower H generation. As per Section 12, the Commission shall install flow measuring devices within the premises of the scheme or may adopt any other indirect method for assessment of water drawn by the user.

    34. As per Section 15, the "user" is liable to pay water cess at such rates that have been fixed by the Government as

    60

    per the Notification and Section 16 provides for its recovery. Under Section 17 based on such assessment of water drawn by the user, computation on water cess is carried out. .

    35. It is more than settled that taxation under the List to the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution may with respe . ctP to an object or an event or may be with respect to both. H

    36. From the Preamble as also the various provisions of the impugned Act extracted above, it would bfe evidently clear that the impugned levy has not been t im posed on "water" but on a single inextricable event that i r s "water drawn for hydropower generation".

    37. Why we o o bservue so is because there can be no electricity gener C ation by a hydropower project without drawl of water. In abs ence of generation of electricity, no levy/cess is imposed h . 38 g . What would further be noticed from the impugned i Act is that it maintains complete silence on the measure of levy. H 39. The tariff of the water cess has been set out in the notification dated 16.02.2023, which is extracted below: "Government of Himachal Pradesh Jal Shakti Vibhag No.JSV-B(A)3-1/2022 Dated Shimla-171002, the

    16/02/2023.

    Notification

    61

    29

    39

    51

    52

    53

    54

    The Governor, Himachal Pradesh, in exercise of powers vested in him under Section 17 (1) of the Himachal Pradesh Water Cess on Hydro Power Generation Ordinance, 2023 (Ordinance No. 2 of 2023), is pleased to order the imposition of Water cess on all Hydro Power Projects in the State of Himachal Pradesh for use of water for power generation on the following .

    rates:-

    Sr.No. Head P Tariff
    1. For Hydroelectric project with head upto 30 mtr . Rs.0.10/m3
    2. For Hydroelectric project with head above 30 mtr and upto 60 mtr. R s.H0.25/m3
    3. For Hydroelectric project withf head above 60 mtr to 90 m. Rs.0.35/m3
    4. For Hydroelectric projecot with head above 90 mtr Rs.0.50/m3

    This shall come into f r orcet with immediate effect.

    u BY ORDER

    o Amitabh Avasthi Secretary (JSV) to the Government of Himachal Pradesh."

    40. It is C clearly evident from the aforesaid Notification that the h State Government has calibrated the cess keeping in

    ivieg w potentiality of the water i.e. the greater the height from which the water falls on the turbine, the greater the

    H momentum resulting in electromagnetic field causing the generation of electricity. Therefore, it is not essentially the quantum of water but rather it is the head-height, which has been taken into consideration by the State while fixing the rate

    of levy.

    62

    41. In other words, the power to tax is on generation of electricity and user of water is only incidental. The "user of water" is not being taxed and it is only the "user of water for .

    generation of electricity", who is being taxed. Therefore, it is a tax on generation of electricity. If it was the quantum of . waPter used, then the height from which the water woul H d fall as a measure to determine the rate of cess wou ld be wholly irrelevant. It is evidently clear from the aforefsaid notification dated 16.02.2023 that the quantificat iono is not based on the use of water, but is based on th r e h t eight from which the water falls. The "use of water" in fact does not go by the text of the impugned Act. It is "g o eneraution of electricity" that is the "bone" and "water dra C wn" is only the "flesh". The taxable event is "hydropower generation" and not the "usage of water" because if there is h no generation, then there is no "tax". Moreover, if the ces g s was on "usage of water", then how could the height, at i which the water falls on the turbine, be made the taxable event? H 42. It is settled principle of law that standard adopted as a measure of levy, although not determinative, is at least indicative of the nature of the tax. Weighed alongwith and in the light of other relevant circumstances, the method adopted by

    the legislature would be relevant in determining the character of

    63

    the impost. To be regarded as valid basis, the measure of the levy must maintain a nexus with the essential character, as held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of West Bengal v. . Kesoram Industries Ltd.18. It shall be relevant to extract the relevant observations as contained in paras 33 and 38, w . hPich read as under:- H

    "We now proceed to enter a deeper dimen sion in the field of tax legislation by considering o the p f roblem of devising the measure of taxation. This a spect has been dealt with in detail in Union of India t and Ors. v. Bombay Tyre International Ltd.,. T r racing the principles from the leading authority o u f Re.: a reference under the Government of Ireland Act 1920 and Section 3 of the Finance Act (Northern Ireland) 1934, (1936) A.C. 352, passing through Ralla Ram v. Province of East Punjab, 1948

    FCR C 207, oand treading through the law as it has de veloped through judicial pronouncements one after the h ether, this Court has made subtle observations therein. It has been long recognized that the measure employed for g

    assessing a tax must not be confused with the nature of i

    the tax. A tax has two elements: first, the person, thing or activity on which the tax is imposed, and secondly, the

    H

    amount of tax. The amount may be measured in many ways; but a distinction between the subject matter of a tax and the standard by which the amount of tax is measured must not be lost sight of. These are described respectively as the subject of a tax and the measure of a tax. It is true

    that the standard adopted as a measure of the levy may

    64

    be indicative of the nature of the tax, but it does not necessarily determine it. The nature of the mechanism by which the tax is to be assessed is not decisive of the essential characteristic of the particular tax charged, though it may throw light on the general character of P the .tax.

    38. In the Hingir-Rampur Coal Co. Ltd. v. Sta . te of Orissa, (1961) 2 (SCR) 537, the form in wh H ich the levy was imposed was held to be an impermissible test for defining in itself the character of the levy. It was argued that the method of determining the rafte of levy was by

    reference to the minerals produ o ced by the mines and,

    therefore, it was levy in the nat ure of a duty of excise. This

    Court held that the method t thus adopted may be relevant

    in considering the u char r acter of the impost but its effect must be weighed alongwith and in the light of the other relevant circumstances. Referring to Bombay Tyre Internation o al Ltd. (supra), the Court further held that

    it is clear that when enacting a measure to serve as a

    sta nd C ard for assessing the levy, the Legislature need not h contour it along lines which spell out the character of the levy itself. A broader based standard of reference is

    ig

    permissible to be adopted for the purpose of determining the measure of the levy. Any standard which maintains a H

    nexus with the essential character of the levy can be regarded as a valid basis for assessing the measure of the levy." 43. Applying the aforesaid principles to the instant cases, it would be evident that the impugned levy varies in

    quantum with the quantum of electricity generated but not the

    65

    quantum of water drawn and, thus, makes it clear that its character or nature is such that it is inextricable with electricity generation. Thus, we have no hesitation to answer Point No. 1 .

    in favour of the petitioners by concluding that by the impugned Act cess is sought to be imposed on "generation of electricit . y"P as against "water" and, therefore, it is a misnomer H that tax is levied on "water" and not "generation of electr icity", and is, therefore, not a water tax. f

    This point is answered a t cco rdoingly in favour of the petitioners.

    Point No. 2. r

    44. At the outset, uit is necessary to observe that normally it is the 'pith o and substance' of the taxing legislation which assum es C significance not to the question of bonafides or malafide h s but in examining the competence of the legislature be g cause the State, while promulgating a statute, might i purport to act within limits of its powers, yet in substance and H

    in reality, it may be transgressing these powers, the transgression being veiled by what appears, on proper examination, to be a mere pretense or a disguise.

    66

    Pith and Substance

    45. In determining whether an enactment is a legislation with respect to the given power, what is relevant is .

    whether in its "pith and substance", it is law upon the subjec P t matter in question. Therefore, it is necessary here to sub . ject the impugned Act to the test of "pith and su bs H tance" to ascertain its true intent and character, which f is relevant in determining as to which list it would fa o ll under and also to trace the State's competence to t have promulgated the impugned Act arises. As per Art r icle 265, no tax can be levied or collected except by autho u rity of law.

    Competence of the State to promulgate the impugned Act whether can be C trace o d to Entry 49 of List-II to the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution as contended by the State: 46. h Entry 49 of List II (State List) provides for "Taxes on lan g ds and buildings." i 47. The State has relied on Anant Mills Co. Ltd. vs. H State of Gurajat & others 19 , in the said case the question was with regard to assessment of property tax of large premises like textile mills and factories. The property tax, in that context, comprised (a) water tax, (b) conservancy tax, and (c) a general tax. It was argued in that case that the State legislature has no

    19 (1975) 2 SCC 175

    67

    competence under Entry 49 of List-II to enact a law for levying tax in respect of an area occupied by underground supply line. It was argued that the word land denotes the surface of land .

    and not the underground strata. Rejecting the arguments, the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that the word "land" inc . ludPes not only the face of earth but everything under or H over it and has in its legal significance an indefinite extent upwards and downwards giving rise to the maxim: e f ujus est sulum, ejus est usque ad column. Further, twin con t ditionos to qualify a levy as tax on lands and buildings i.e.:

    (i) Tax is directl u y improsed on lands and buildings; and

    (ii) Tax b o ears a definite relation to land were specified.

    48. Ho wCever, we find that State's competence to levy tax on wate h r drawn for hydropower generation in the instant case

    icag nnot be traced to Entry 49 of List-II, as the impugned levy H does not satisfy the above mentioned twin conditions. The levy of tax on water drawn for hydropower generation is definitely not a tax, which is directly on lands and buildings i.e. the land on which the hydropower plant is situated or the power generating units. Rather, as evidenced by the impugned Act

    itself, it is a tax on a "user" and is levied pursuant to

    68

    occurrence of an event/activity i.e. "for water drawn for hydropower generation", which cannot be regarded as having any relation to land, much less a definite one. .

    49. Furthermore, as prescribed by the charging section i.e. Section 15 of the impugned Act, it is indicative that tax . is Pon the registered user i.e. it is personal. Under Section H 2(g) of the impugned Act, "user" is defined to mean "any f per son, group of persons, local body, government de o partment, company, corporation, society or anybody, by whichever name called drawing water from any source r for t generation of hydropower". Therefore, the tax is on persons (whether natural or juristic) and not on lands or builudings as units. Therefore, in such

    circumstances, C the o reliance placed by the State on the judgment in A nant Mills (supra) is clearly misplaced. 50. h Even otherwise the expression "Land" cannot be log g ically interpreted to mean everything above and below it, as i that would cover everything on the earth and subsume all other H Entries in Seventh Schedule, as there are Entries in List-I and List-II, dealing with the subject on, above or below land. Some of the entries in List-I, which are connected to the land and buildings and which will be rendered otiose by the State

    Government wide interpretation are:

    69

    (i) Entry 7. Industries declared by Parliament by law to be necessary for the purpose of defence or for the prosecution of war .

    (ii) Entry 22. Railways.

    (iii) Entry 23. Highways declared by or unde . r lPaw made by Parliament to be national highw H ays.

    iv. Entry 24. Shipping and navig f ati on on inland waterways, declared by Pa rli o ament by way to be national waterways, as regards mechanically propelled vessels; the r rul t e of the road on such water ways.

    v. Entry o 26. uLighthouses, including lightships, beac C ons and other provision for the safety of shipping and aircraft.

    h vi . Entry 29. Airways; aircraft and air navigation; g

    provision of aerodromes; regulation and i

    organization of air traffic and of aerodromes; H

    provision for aeronautical education and training and regulation of such education and training provided by States and other agencies.

    vii. Entry 53. Regulation and development of oilfields and mineral oil resources; petroleum and petroleum

    70

    products; other liquids and substances declared by Parliament by law to be dangerously inflammable.

    viii. Entry 87. Estate duty in respect of property .

    other than agricultural land.

    ix. Entry 88. Duties in respect of successio . n Pto property other than agricultural land. H

    x. Entry 89. Terminal taxes on good f s o r passengers, carried by railway, sea or a ir; o taxes on railway fares and freight.

    51. It is well settled that w t hile the widest amplitude should be given to the l u anguarge used in one entry, every attempt has to be mad o e to harmonise its contents with those of other entries, so that the latter may not be rendered nugatory.

    52. In t C his regard, reliance can be placed on the judgmen h t of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Calcutta Gas Co g mpany (Proprietary) Ltd. vs. State of West Bengal and i others 20 , the relevant portion whereof reads as under: H

    "8……Before construing the said entries it would be useful to' notice some of the well settled rules of interpretation laid down by the Federal Court and this Court in the matter of construing the entries. The power to legislate is given to the appropriate Legislatures by Art. 246 of the Constitution. The entries in the three Lists are

    20 AIR 1962 SC 1044

    71

    only legislative heads or fields of legislation : they demarcate the area over which the appropriate Legislatures can operate. It is also well settled that widest amplitude should be given to the language of the entries. But some of the entries in the different List or in the same .

    List may overlap and sometimes may also appear to . be P in direct conflict with each other. It is then the duty of this Court to reconcile the entries and bring ab H out harmony between them….."

    53. In Rajendra Diwan vs. Prad o eep K f umar Ranibala and Another 21 , the Hon'ble Supreme C ourt held as under:-

    "50. While the widest am t plitude should be given to the language us u ed in r one entry, every attempt has to be made to harmonise its contents with those of other entries, so o that the latter may not be rendered nugatory."

    Competence to C promulgate the impugned Act whether can be traced to Entry 50 of List-II as contended by the State: 54. h Entry 50 of List-II (State List) provides for "Taxes on mi g neral rights subject to any limitations imposed by Parliament i by law relating to mineral development." H 55. The State's competence to impose impugned levy cannot be traced to Entry 50 of List-II as contended by it. Activity of non-consumptive drawl of water for generation of hydropower, where the water drawn is allowed to flow back to

    21 (2019) 20 SCC 143

    72

    its source, being a single inextricable event cannot be brought under the purview of taxing mineral rights.

    56. The State has placed reliance on the judgment of the .

    Hon'ble Supreme Court in Ichchapur Industrial Coop. Society Ltd. vs. Competent Authority, Oil & Natural . GPas Commission22, to contend that water is a mine ra H l, therefore, the rights in such mineral can be taxed by it.

    57. Adverting to Ichchapur's c as o e (su fpra), it needs to

    be noticed that Hon'ble Supreme C t ourt clarified that the term "Minerals" was being interpreted for the purposes of Petroleum & Minerals Pipelines (Acqu u isitionr of Right of User in Land) Act, 1962 (User Rights Acquisition Act) only considering the definition of the C terms o under the Mines Act, 1952. Further, the Hon'ble Supr eme Court held that the User Rights Acquisition Act ut h ilizes the device "Legislation by reference or inc g orporation", whereby the definition of Minerals" under Mines i Act, 1952 could be deemed to have been bodily lifted and H

    incorporated in the later act i.e., User Rights Acquisition Act (supra). However, the same ratio cannot be applied to the instant cases to hold that there is legislation by reference or incorporation under List-II of the Constitution insofar as

    definition of the term "Minerals" contained under Mines Act,

    22 (1997) 2 SCC 42

    73

    1952 is concerned. The Mines Act, 1952 was promulgated subsequent to the Constitution and the former cannot be interpreted with reference to definition clauses set out under .

    the latter. Moreover, it is trite in law that judgments cann . ot P be applied without appreciating their contest particularly, judgments must be read as whole, and the observa H tions are to

    be considered in light of the questions which f w ere before the Court leading up to the judgment as t o he decision takes its colour from the questions involved in a case in which it is rendered. (See: Haryana Financ r ial t Corporation and Anr. Vs. Jagdamba Oil Mills & Anr., (2002) 3 SCC 496, Paras 19 to

    21, Hon'ble three Judge Buench).

    58. Ther C efore, o the aforesaid judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Cou rt in Ichchapur's case (supra), which considered the limi h ted question as to whether water is mineral within the me g aning of Mines Act, 1952 read with Section 2(ba) of the User i Rights Acquisition Act, cannot be read as laying down a H precedent for interpreting Entry 50 of List-II of Constitution of List-II. In fact, neither the dictionary meaning of the word, nor the meaning judicially ascribed to a word (i.e., in unrelated judgments), can be invoked while interpreting the entries under

    the lists to the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution.

    74

    59. We may at this stage profitably refer to the observations of the Hon'ble Constitutional Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Godfrey Phillips India Ltd. & Anr. vs. State . of U.P. & Ors.23, wherein it was observed as under:-

    42. But theoretically 'luxuries' is capable of covering . eaPch of the several meanings ascribed to the word. H The question is how the word is to be construed in the Constitutional entry. Neither the dictionary meaning nor the meaning ascribed to the word judicially o (for th f e reasons stated) resolve the ambiguity. The solution must be found in the language of the Entry takin g into consideration the Constitutional scheme with t regard to the imposition of

    taxes and the collection o r f revenues.

    60. In view of o the a u bove discussion, even Entry 50 of List-II cannot be held to countenance the States' taxation on water drawl f or C generation of electricity. Competence to promulgate whether can be traced to Entry 45 of List-II:

    i61g.

    hEntry 45 of List II (State List) provides for "Land revenue, including the assessment and collection of revenue, the

    H maintenance of land records, survey for revenue purposes and records of rights and alienation of revenues". 62. In order to support its contention that the State has competence to enact the impugned Act, strong reliance is

    23 (2005) 2 SCC 515

    75

    placed on Entry 45 of List-II and also the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in R.S. Rekchand Mohota Spg. & Wvg. Mills Ltd. vs. State of Maharashtra24. .

    63. Adverting to the facts of the aforesaid case, it was the the Government of Maharashtra that had by wa . y Pof resolution dated 05.06.1973 (Resolution) under Se H ction 70 of the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, 1966 (Code) imposed water cess on use of flowing water from Riverf 'Wana' for non-

    agricultural purpose, specifically ind t ust riaol purpose. 64. In order to better app r reciate the aforesaid case vis-a-vis, the facts and the law in u volved in the instant case, it would be necessary to have a comparative analysis of the said case with the present case o and the same is set out in a table below:-

    Code and Res ol C ution Impugned Act and Notification A. Code A. The Impugned Act Section 7 h 0-Rates for use of water Section 2(c) defines "hydropower" as a g

    renewable source of energy that i "The State Government may authorise generates power by using water drawn the Collector or the Officer in charge of from any water source flowing within a survey or such other officer as it deems the territory of the State. H

    fit, to fix such rates as it may from time to time deem fit to sanction, for Section 2(g) defines "user" as any the use, by holders and other persons, person, group of persons, local body, of water, the right to which vests in the government department, company Government and in respect of which no corporation, society or anybody, by rate is leviable under any law relating whichever name called drawing water to irrigation in force in any part of the from any source for generation of

    State. Such rates shall be liable to hydropower. revision at such periods as the State Government shall from time to time Section 2(h) defines "ater" as natural

    24 (1997) 2 SCC 12

    76

    determine, and shall be recoverable as resource flowing in any river, stream,

    land revenue. tributary, canal, nallah or any other natural course of water or stipulated Provided that, the rate for use of water upon the surface of any land like, pond, for agricultural purposes shall be one lagoon, swamp or spring. rupee only per year per holder."

    Section 2(i) defines "water cess" as the .

    rate levied or charged for water drawn for generation of hydropower and under this Act.

    . fix P ed

    Section 10- Duties, obligations and responsibilities of t f he re gis H tered user: (1) The registered user shall be liable to pay water c o ess for the water drawn for hydropower generation as per the provi t sions of this Act.... S r ection 15 of the Act 2023 pertains to the Fixation of water cess: u (1) The user shall be liable to pay the water cess at such rates as the o

    Government may, by notification fix in this behalf. (2) The State Government may review, increase,, decrease or vary C

    the rates of the water cess fixed under this section from time to time in the manner it deems fit. h

    B. Resolution B. Notification i Sr. Non- Rate Unit Sr. Head Tariff Nog . Agriculture No. purpose H

    1. Industrial (a) Rs.8/- Per 1. For Hydroelectric Rs.0.10/ Purpose for the first 10,000 Project with head upto m

    3

    two years ctf. Pg 30 mtr water (b) Rs.10/- for the third -do- and fourth year

    (c) Rs.12.50 -do- for the fifth and

    77

    subsequent year

    2. Purpose for the Municipality Rs.5/- -do- 2. For Hydroelectric Project with head above 30 mtr and upto 60 mtr Rs.0.25/ m3
    s. .35/m3

    Municipality above 30 mtr and upto

    60 mtr .

    3. Purpose for Rs.12.50 -do- 3. For Hydroelectric Rs. the Railways Project with head 0.35/m3 above 60 mtr to upto P

    90 mtr .

    4. Domestic Use Nil 4. For Hydroelectric Rs.0.50/ (i.e. for Project with h H ead m3

    drinking above 90 mtr

    water)

    f

    65. Now, in case the aforesaid co o mparison is adverted to, it would be noticed that in R r ekc t han d case (supra), the levy was imposed on drawl of fl u owing water by artificial contrivance for industrial purpose o . The rates of such levy were specified under Resolution. It was on account of the definition of land under the Tra n C sfer of Property Act, 1882, which included right to water flowing therefrom, the said levy was sustained by the

    Hon'ble h Supreme Court under Entry 45, List-II.

    i66g . However, in the instant cases, the levy being H

    imposed on electricity generation and supply, which are inextricable parts of the single event which is taxed under the Impugned Act i.e., "water drawn for hydropower generation", which the State is not competent to do. It appears that the very definition of "water source" has been altered to include

    generation of electricity because the tax is not being imposed

    78

    merely on the drawl of water but for the generation of electricity and the levy in turn is based, as is evident from the quantum of levy, which is based on the head height and not on the water .

    drawn.

    67. Further, a perusal of para 12 of Rekchand's . caPse (supra), makes it clear that there are reference H s to other judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, which concern Entry 49 of List-II and specify the twin conditions beinfg:

    (i) tax is directly imposed on laond; and

    (ii) nexus between t r he t levy and the land to be satisfied in order to sustain a legislation under Entry 49, List-II.

    u

    68. As already o held above, the State's competence to promulgate the impugned Act cannot be traced to Entry 49 of List-II. There forCe, Rekchand's case (supra) is not applicable in the pres h ent case and the State's competence cannot be traced

    ito g Entry 45 of List-II. H

    Competence to promulgate whether can be traced to Entries 17 & 18 read with 66 of List-II as a "tax": 69. Entries 17, 18 and 66 of List II (State List) provide as under:-

    "17. Water, that is to say, water supplies, irrigation and canals, drainage and embankments, water

    79

    storage and water power subject to the provisions of entry 56 of List I.

    18. Land, that is to say, right in or over land, land tenures including the relation of landlord and tenant, .

    and the collection of rents; transfer and alienation P of agricultural land; land improvement and agricultural loans; colonization. .

    66. Fee in respect of any of the matters H in this List, but not including fees taken in any co f ur t."

    70. The State has relied on Ent rie o s 17 & 18 of List-II to demonstrate its competence to have legislated the Impugned Act. In this regard, it is a settled r prtinciple of law that taxation

    entries are distinct from ge u neral regulatory entries. Entries 1 to

    44 in List-II are regula o tory, whereas Entries 45 to 63 are taxing entries. Therefo C re, the legislative competence to impose any tax on water dra wn for hydropower generation cannot be imposed by the h State by referring to Entries 17 & 18 of List-II being

    iregg ulatory entry. 71. Reference in this regard can conveniently be made

    H

    to the judgment rendered by the Hon'ble Constitutional Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in M.P.V. Sundararamier & Co. vs. The State of Andhra Pardesh and another 25 , more particularly para 51 thereof, which reads as under:-

    25 AIR 1958 SC 468

    80

    "51. In List 1, Entries I to 81 mention the several matters over which Parliament has authority to legislate. Entries 82 to 92 enumerate the taxes which could be imposed by a law of Parliament. An examination of these two groups of Entries shows that while the main subject of .

    legislation figures in the first group, a tax in relatio P n thereto is separately mentioned in the second. T . hus, Entry 22 in List I is " Railways ", and Entry 89 is " Terminal taxes on goods or passengers, H carried by railway, sea or air; taxes on railway fares and freights ". If Entry 22 is to be construed a o s invoflving taxes to be imposed, then Entry 89 wo t uld be superfluous. Entry 41 mentions "Trade and c r ommerce with foreign countries; import and export across customs frontiers ". If these expressions are to be interpreted as including duties to be levied in respect of that trade and commerce, then

    Entry 83 w o hich ius " Duties of customs including export duties " would be wholly redundant. Entries 43 and 44

    re lat C e to incorporation, regulation and winding up of corporations. Entry 85 provides separately for h Corporation tax. Turning to List II, Entries I to 44 form one group mentioning the subjects on which the States

    ig

    could legislate. Entries 45 to 63 in that List form another group, and they deal with taxes. Entry 18, for example, H

    is " Land " and Entry 45 is "Land revenue ". Entry 23 is " Regulation of mines " and Entry 50 is " Taxes on mineral rights ". The above analysis- and it is not exhaustive of the Entries in the Lists-leads to the inference that taxation is not intended to be comprised in the main subject in which it might on an extended construction be

    regarded as included, but is treated as a distinct matter

    for purposes of legislative competence. And this

    81

    distinction is also manifest in the language of Art. 248, Cls. (1) and (2), and of Entry 97 in List I of the Constitution. Construing Entry 42 in the light of the above scheme, it is difficult to resist the conclusion that the power of Parliament to legislate on inter-State trade .

    and commerce under Entry 42 does not include a powe P r to impose a tax on sales in the course of such trade . and commerce."

    72. Similar reiteration of law can be found iHn a three- Judge Bench judgment of the Hon'ble Suprem f e Court in M/s Hoechst Pharmaceuticals Ltd. & Ors. vs o . State of Bihar and Ors.26, wherein after following t r he t judgment of the aforesaid Constitution Bench, it was observed as under:-

    "It would therefo u re appear that there is a distinction made betw o een general subjects of legislation and taxa C tion. The general subjects of legislation are dealt w ith in one group of entries and power of taxation ill a h separate group. In M.P. Sundararamier & Co. v. The State of Andhra Pradesh & Anr.(1) This Court dealt with the scheme g

    of the separation of taxation powers between the Union i

    and the States by mutually exclusive lists. In List I, H

    Entries 1 to 81 deal with general subjects of legislation; Entries 82 to 92A deal with taxes. In List 11, Entries 1 to 44 deal with general subjects of legislation; Entries 45 to 63 deal With taxes. This mutual exclusiveness is also brought out by the fact that in List Ill, the Concurrent Legislative List, there is no entry relating to a tax, but it

    only contains an entry relating to levy of fees in respect

    82

    of matters given in that list other than court-fees. Thus, in our Constitution, a conflict of the taxing power of the Union and of the States cannot arise. That being so, it is difficult to comprehend the submission that there can be intrusion by a law made by Parliament under Entry 33 .

    of List III into a forbidden field viz. the State s exclusiv P e power to make a law with respect to the levy . and imposition of a tax on sale or purchase H of goods relatable to Entry 54 of List II of the Seventh Schedule. It follows that the two laws viz. sub-s. (3) of s. 5 of the Act

    and paragraph 21 of the Control ordfer issued by the

    Central Government unde t r su o b-s. (1) of s. 3 of the Essential Commodities r Act, operate on two separate and distinct fields and both are capable of being obeyed. There is no question of any clash between the two laws and the question of repugnancy does not come into

    play." u

    o

    73. In v C iew of the above, considering the charging section, taxable event and nature of levying under the impugn h ed Act as well as subjecting the impugned Act to the test

    iof g "pith and substance", it is absolutely clear that the impugned Act imposes tax on generation of electricity and not merely on

    H water as a subject or on drawl of water, which the State is not competent to do. It also imposes an inter-State tax on inter-State supply of electricity for which again the State is not competent to do so.

    83

    Competence to promulgate whether can be traced to Entries 17, 18 read with 66 of List II as a "fee":

    74. It is also argued by the State in the alternative that .

    the impugned levy can be justified as a "Fee" on the basis of Entries 17 and 18 of read with Entry 66 of List-II. Howeve . r, Pwe find that the State lacks competence to levy the imp H ugned cess as a fee. The entire field of legislation conc erning water power/hydropower projects, declared as sucfh by Parliament under the Electricity Act, 2003, i t s o cc o upied by Parliament. Therefore, the State lacks compe r tence to levy any fee under the garb of water cess by relyin u g upon Entries 17 & 18, and 66 of List-II.

    75. Even C other o wise, it is settled that levy can assume the nature o f "Fee", if there are any services rendered by the State and, as such, there is quid pro quo, between the person pa g ying f h ee and the public authority which imposes it. Such quid i pro quo, although not required to be established with H arithmetical exactitude, must at least be established broadly and reasonably with some amount of certainty, reasonableness or preponderance of probability that quite a substantial portion of the fee realised is spent for the benefit of the payers.

    76. Moreover, a "Tax" recovered by a public authority goes into the consolidated fund, which is ultimately utilised for

    84

    all public purposes, whereas "Fee" is not intended to be, and does not become, part of the consolidated fund. A "Fee" is earmarked and set apart for the purpose of services for which it .

    is levied.

    77. The cess collected pursuant to the impugned . APct does not get into a separate earmarked fund. More H over, while there was no services rendered by the State in f the present case for the hydropower plants and in addit io o n thereto, the services claimed to be rendered by the State is incapable of being distinguished from public se r rvic t e. Seen even from this perspective, the impugned levy cannot be termed as "Fee".

    78. The Scope of Stuate's power to impose a tax on land has to be read C in the o context of Entry 18, List-II which defines Land as "La nd, that is to say, rights in or over land, land tenures h including the relation of landlord and tenant, and the co g llection of rents; transfer and alienation of agricultural land; i land improvement and agricultural loans; colonization." This H does not contemplate a river or flowing water as a part of land. Even the principle of leaning in favour of constitutionality of a provision will not be applicable as there is patent lack of legislative competence.

    85

    79. The reliance of the State on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of West Bengal vs. Kesoram Industries27 is entirely misplaced as the said judgment by .

    Hon'ble five-Judge Constitution Bench, to the extent relied upon by the State, has not attained finality, and has . bePen referred to a Constitution Bench of Nine Hon'ble Ju H dges of the Supreme Court.

    80. Thus, once it is held that the cefss sought to be imposed by the impugned Act is not o n tohe "water drawn" but on the "generation of electrici r ty", t then, it is the Central Government alone which u could levy tax on generation electricity.

    81. In co C ming o to such conclusion, we are duly supported by the judgm ent of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in M.P. Cement Manufa h cturer's case (supra), wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Co g urt was examining Entry 84 of List I and Entry 53 of List II of i the Seventh Schedule in the following manner:- H

    "9. The two competing entries in the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution are Entry 84 of List-I and Entry 53 of List- II. They respectively read: List-I 84. Duties of excise on tobacco and other goods manufactured or produced in India except-

    86

    (a) alcoholic liquors for human consumption.

    (b) (b) opium, Indian hemp and other narcotic drugs and narcotics, but including medicinal and toilet preparations containing alcohol or any substance included in sub- paragraph (b) of this entry. .

    List II P

    53. Taxes on the consumption or sale of electricity." .

    82. Noticing that electricity is goods (see CS H T vs. M.P. Electricity Board (1969) 1 SCC 200), the H f on 'ble Supreme Court observed that levy of State du o ty on production of electricity is covered with r th t e phrase "other goods manufactured" in Entry 84 of List I and this is within the exclusive jurisdiction of th u e Parliament. Consequently, it was

    declared that the Stat o e has competence to levy tax only on the

    sale and consumption of electricity (see Hoechst

    Pharmaceuti ca C ls Ltd. vs. State of Bihar, (1983) 4 SCC 45).

    Proceed h ings on this basis, the Hon'ble Supreme Court posed the

    iqug estion whether the State Legislature was competent to levy cess on captive power generation, through amendment of the

    H Madhya Pradesh Upkar Adhiniyam, 1981. After a detailed discussion, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the levy on generation of electricity is not within the legislative competence of the State.

    87

    Point No. 2 is accordingly answered in favour of the petitioners.

    Point No. 3. . Without prejudice, the impugned Act is unconstitutional P for it suffers from vice of excessive delegation:

    83. In order to appreciate the rival contention o.f the parties, it would be necessary to refer to the f cha rg H ing section, i.e. Section 15 of the impugned Act, wh o ich specifies that the user is liable to pay water cess at such rates, as the Government of Himachal Prades r h, m t a y fix vide notification. In terms of sub Section 15(2 u ) of the impugned Act, the State Government is empowered to review, increase, decrease or vary the rates of water fixe o d under Section 15 of the impugned Act

    from time to t im C e in the manner it deems fit. 84. Notably, the power of fixation of rates has been

    delegate h d to the Government of Himachal Pradesh i.e., the

    iexg ecutive by the State Legislature without any guidance. While H

    fixation of rates can be left to a non-legislative body, the legislature must provide guidance for such fixation as held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in The Corporation of Calcutta and another vs. Liberty Cinema 28 , more particularly, paras 21 to 26, which read as under:-

    28 AIR 1965 SC 1107

    88

    "21. It was then said that if S. 548 authorised the levy of a tax as distinct from a fee in return for services rendered, it was invalid as it amounted to an illegal delegation of legislative functions to the Corporation because it left it entirely to the latter to fix the amount of the tax and .

    provided no guidance for that purpose. We wish to . po P int out here that the contention now is that the section is invalid while the contention that we have just dealt with

    proceeded on the basis that the section wa H s valid as it

    provided for the levy of a fee in return for s ervices and as

    this necessarily implied a limit of o the lefvy, namely, that it had to be commensurate to the amount of the costs of the services, no guidance fo r r 491 f ixing the amount of the fee to be levied was required t t o be provided. That argument only challenged th u e resolution on the ground that it fixed the amount of the fee at a figure much in excess of the costs for the o services rendered. 22. H C ere again there is no dispute that a delegation of es sential legislative power would be bad. It was so held by this Court first in re The Delhi Laws Act.(1) The h principle there laid down has been summarised by Bose J. g

    in Rajnarain Singh v. The Chairman, Patna Administration i

    Committee, Patna(2), in these terms: "In our opinion, the majority view was that an

    H

    executive authority can be authorised to modify either existing or future laws but not in any essential feature. Exactly what constitutes an essential feature cannot be enunciated in general terms, and there was some divergence of view

    about this in the former case, but this much is clear

    from the opinions set out above: it cannot include a

    change of policy."

    89

    23. On the basis that s. 548 is a piece of delegated legislation, it has been contended on behalf of the Corporation that the rate of a tax is not an essential feature of legislation and the power to fix it was properly delegated to the Corporation as sufficient guidance for that .

    purpose was given in the Act. It is not in controversy, a P nd this indeed has been held by this Court, that if that . is so, the section would be unexceptionable. The question first is whether the power to fix the rate of a tax can H be delegated by the legislature to another authority; f whe ther it is of the essence of taxing legislation. The contention of the Corporation that fixation of rate s i o s not an essential part of legislation would seem to be supported by several judgments of this Court r to s t ome of which we now proceed to refer.

    24. First, th o ere is u Pandit Benarsi Das Bhanot v. The State of Madhya Pradesh ( 3 ) . That case was concerned with a Sales C Tax Act which by s. 6(1) provided that no tax would be payable on any sale of goods specified in a schedule to it. Item 33 of that Schedule read, "goods sold to or by the h State Government". Section 6(2) of the Act authorised the g

    State Government to amend the schedule by a notification. i

    In exercise of this power the Government duly substituted by a notification for item 33 the following: "Goods sold by H

    the State Government". The amendment of the schedule by the notification was challenged on the round that s. 6(2) was invalid as it was a delegation of the (1) [1951] S. C. R. 747 (2) [1955] 1 S. C. R. 290,301. (3) [1959] S. C. R. 427. 492 essential power of legislation to the State Government. Venkatarama Aiyar J. delivering the

    judgment of the majority of the Court sitting in a

    Constitution Bench, rejected this contention and after

    90

    having read what we have earlier set out from the judgment of Bose J. in Rajnarain Singh's case(1), observed at p. 435:

    "On these observations, the point for determination .

    is whether the impugned notification relat . es to what may be said to be an essential feature of P the law, and whether it involves any change of policy. Now, the authorities are clear that it is not

    unconstitutional for the legislatur f e t o leHave it to the executive to determine details relating to the working of taxation laws, such as the selection of

    persons on whom th t e tax i o s to be laid, the rates at which it is to b r e charg ed in respect of different classes of goods, and the like." The Act was a u statute imposing taxes for revenue purposes. This case would appear to be express authority for the proposition that fixation of rates of taxes may be

    legitim C ately oleft by a statute to a non-legislative authority, for we see no distinction in principle between delegation of h power to fix rates simpliciter; if power to fix rates in some cases can be delegated then equally the power to fix rates g

    generally can be delegated. No doubt Pandit Banarsi i

    Das's case(1) was not concerned with fixation of rates of taxes; it was a case where the question was on what

    H

    subject mater, and therefore on what persons, the tax could be imposed. Between the two we are unable to distinguish in principle, as to which is of the essence of legislation; if the power to decide who is to pay the tax is not an essential part of legislation, neither would the

    power to decide the rate of tax be so. Therefore we think

    that apart from the express observation made, this case

    91

    on principle supports the contention that fixing of the rate of a tax is not of the essence of legislative power.

    25. In regard to the observations in Pandit Benarsi Das's case(1) earlier quoted, it has been said that the authorities .

    on which they appear to have been based do not support it. It has been contended that as the observations do P not form part of the actual decision in the case, they nee . d not be given that weight which they would otherwise have been entitled to. In the High Court this contenHtion appears to have been accepted. The acceptance f of the contention would result in by-passing a j udgment of this Court and that is something which can t not in o any case be supported. We are furthermore of r opinion that the authorities to (1) [1955] 1 S. C. R. 290. (2) [1959] S. C. R. 427, 493 which Venkatarama Ai u yar J. referred fully support his observations. The first case relied upon by him was Powell

    v. Appollo C o andle Co. Ltd.(1). That case upheld the validity of a s C tatute passed by the legislature of New South Wales which conferred power on the Governor of that Province to impose duty on certain articles in the circumstances

    h pr escribed. The Governor under this power imposed the g

    tax and this was challenged. The Judicial Committee i

    rejected the contention that the tax had not been, imposed by the Legislature which alone could do it in the view that H

    "the duties levied under the Order in Council are really levied by the authority of the Act" see p. 291. Here, therefore, a power conferred on the Governor by the Legislature to levy a tax was upheld. It would follow that a power conferred to fix rates of taxes has equally to be upheld. The next case was V.M. Syed Mohamed v. State Of Madras(2). There a power to an authority to determine

    who shall pay the tax was upheld. On the same principle

    92

    a power to determine at what rate he will have to pay the tax has to be upheld. The last case was Hampton Jr. & Co. v. United States(3), in which the power conferred by a statute on the President to make an increase or decrease in the rate of customs duty was upheld. There it was said .

    at p. 630, P

    "It is conceded by counsel that Congress ma . y use executive officers in the application and enforcement of a policy declared in law by Congress a f nd auHthorise such officers in the application of the C o ongressional declaration to enforce it by regulation equivalent to law. But it is said that this never has been permitted to be done where Congress has exercised the t p ower to levy taxes and fix customs duties. The authorities make no such distinction.

    The same principle thart permits Congress to exercise its

    rate making o powe u r in interstate commerce by declaring the rule which shall prevail in the legislative fixing of rates, and C enables it to remit to a rate making body created in ac cordance with its provisions the fixing of such rates, justifies a similar provision for the fixing of customs duties h on imported merchandise." This therefore is clear authority g

    that the fixing of rates may be left to a non legislative i

    body. 26. No doubt when the power to fix rates of taxes is left to

    H

    another body, the legislature must provide guidance for such fixation. The question then is, was such guidance provided in the Act ? We first wish to observe that the validity of the guidance 1) 1 O. A. C. 282 (2) [1952] 3 S. T. C 367 (3) [1927] 72 L. ed. 624. 494 cannot be tested by a

    rigid uniform rule; that must depend on the object of the

    Act giving power to fix the rate. It is said that the

    delegation of power to fix rates of taxes authorised for

    93

    meeting the needs of the delegate to be valid, must provide the maximum rate that can be fixed, or lay down rules indicating that maximum. We are unable to see how the specification of the maximum rate supplies any guidance as to how the amount of the tax which no doubt has to be .

    below the maximum, is to be fixed. Provision for su P ch maximum only sets out a limit of the rate to be im . posed and a limit is only a limit and not a guidance."

    85. In addition to the above, it was nece ssHary for the legislature to have laid down Legislative Pol f icy, standard or guidelines in the Act or else it is b t oun d o to suffer from vice of excessive delegation as held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in

    Gwalior Rayon Silk Mfg u (Wv r g.) Co. Ltd. vs. The Asstt. Commissioner of Sales Tax and others 29 , wherein it was observed as under:- o

    "1 3. C It may be stated at the outset that the growth of the legislative powers of the executive is a significant h development of the twentieth century. The theory of g

    laissez-faire has been given a go-by and large and i

    comprehensive powers are being assumed by the State with a view to improve social and economic well-being of H

    the people. Most of the modern socioeconomic legislations passed by the legislature lay down the guiding principles and the legislative policy. The legislatures because of limitation imposed upon by the time factor hardly go into matters of detail. Provision is, therefore, made for delegated legislation to obtain flexibility, elasticity,

    expedition and opportunity for experimentation. The

    29 (1974) 4 SCC 98

    94

    practice of empowering the executive to make subordinate legislation within a prescribed sphere has evolved out of practical necessity and pragmatic needs of a modern welfare state. At the same time it has to be borne in mind that our Constitution-makers have entrusted the power of .

    legislation to the representatives of the people, so that P the said power may be exercised not only in the name . of the people but also by the people speaking through their representatives. The rule against excessive d H elegation of legislative authority flows from and is a necessary postulate of the sovereignty of o the fpeople. The rule contemplates that it is not permissible to substitute in the matter of legislative policy the views of individual officers

    or other authorities, how r eve t r competent they may be, for that of the po u pular 'will as expressed by the representatives of the people. As observed on page 224 of Vol. 1 in Coo o ley's Constitutional Limitations, 8th Ed. C "One of the settled maxims in constitutional law is, that the power conferred upon the legislature to h

    make laws cannot be delegated by that department to any other body or authority. Where g

    the sovereign power of the State has located the i

    authority, there it must remain; and by the constitutional agency done the laws must be Made

    H

    until the constitution Itself is changed. The power to whose judgment, wisdom and patriotism this high prerogative has been entrusted cannot relieve itself of the responsibility by choosing other agencies upon which the power shalt be devoted,

    nor can it substitute the judgment, wisdom, and

    patriotism of any other body for those to which

    95

    atom the people have seen fit to confide this sovereign trust."

    86. Furthermore, the impugned Act clearly fails to lay .

    down one of the critical components of taxing statute i.e. measure of tax. It is trite in law that in order to make a le . vy P of tax to be operative and valid, four essential components must be provided in enacting statute, creating the tax/i mHpost i.e.:

    (i) taxable event attractive the levy; f

    (ii) the person whom the lev y i o s imposed and who is obliged to pay the tax;

    (iii) the rate at which t r he ttax is imposed and; (iv) the measure u of value to which the rate will be applied for computing the tax liability.

    87. This was s o o held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in

    M/s Govind Sa C ran Ganga Saran vs. Commissioner of Sales Tax and h others 30 , wherein it was observed as under:- g

    "6. The components which enter into the concept of a i

    tax are well known. The first is the character of the imposition known by its nature which prescribes the H

    taxable event attracting the levy, the second is a clear indication of the person on whom the levy is imposed and who is obliged to pay the tax, the third is the rate at which the tax is imposed, and the fourth is the measure or value to which the rate will be applied for computing the tax liability. If those

    components are not clearly and definitely

    30 AIR 1985 SC 1041

    96

    ascertainable, it is difficult to say that the levy exists in point of law. Any uncertainty or vagueness ill the legislative scheme defining any of those components of the levy will be fatal to its validity."

    .

    88. In the instant case, three essential components c P an be clearly identified within the impugned statute, which . are taxable events, "the person liable to pay tax" an d H the "rate of tax". However, the impugned legislation fails f to identify the fourth and equally critical component i .e. o measure of tax, which is the value on which the rate t of tax will be applied for computing the tax liability. r

    89. Section 15 of th u e impugned Act provides that the user shall be liable to pay water cess at such rates fixed by the Government, it C fails too prescribe the value based on which such rates will be a pplied.

    90. h Here, we may note that it was in exercise of powers

    ivesg ted under Section 15(2) of the impugned Act that the State Government issued a Notification dated 26.08.2023 (supra),

    H whereby the tariff structure on water cess was fixed on the basis of "Head". However, even the said notification failed to prescribe the measure of tax and instead proceeded to prescribe tariff rate without any indication or measure on which such

    tariff rate will be applied. Moreover, measure of tax being vague,

    97

    based upon the "assessment" or water drawn, which would form the basis of the tax imposed is also vague and fraught with lack of adequate guidelines, as is evident from the combined .

    reading of Section 12 with Section 17 of the impugned Legislation (supra). .P

    91. That apart, even the Statement of O H bjects and Reasons as well as the preamble of the impugned Act does not lend any guidance for the delegate. The pfreamble of the impugned Act merely states that it t is a n oact to levy water cess on hydropower generation in the State of Himachal Pradesh, the Statement of Objects and rearsons merely states that the

    objective of the impugned Auct is revenue generation. Therefore,

    on account of h C aving o delegated power to fix rates of impugned levy to Gover nment of Himachal Pradesh without any legislative policy o h r guidance, the impugned Act is unconstitutional. g This point is accordingly answered in favour of the i petitioners. H 4. Promissory Estoppel: 92. In view of the aforesaid discussion, the question of promissory estoppel has been rendered academic and, therefore, need not be answered.

    98

    Conclusion:

    93. In view of the aforesaid discussion, all the writ .

    petitions are allowed in the following terms:- .P

    (i) The provisions of the Himacha f l P rad H esh Water Cess on Hydropower Electricity Generation Act, 2023, are declared to be b o eyond the legislative competence of the State Government in terms of Articles 246 and 265 o r f thte Constitution of India and,

    thus, ultra vires u the Constitution.

    (ii) Consequently, the Himachal Pradesh Water Cess on H C ydropoower Electricity Generation Rules 2023, are also quashed and set aside. h (iii) Sections 10 and 15 of the Himachal Pradesh

    ig

    Water Cess on Hydropower Electricity Generation Act, 2023, as have been made applicable to the H

    existing projects, are also declared to be ultra vires the Constitution and are accordingly quashed and set aside. (iv) The amount, if any, recovered by the respondents from the petitioners under the provisions of the

    99

    Himachal Pradesh Water Cess on Hydropower Electricity Generation Act, 2023 and the Rules framed thereunder are ordered to be refunded within .

    four weeks from today.

    (v) The letter/notice issued by the . StPate Government/Himachal Pradesh State C H ommission for Water Cess on Hydropower Gen f era tion pursuant to the impugned Act, Rules, seeking recovery of water cess from the petitioners, t ar e doeclared as illegal and are accordingly quashe r d and set aside. All pending mi u scellaneous applications shall also

    stand disposed of. o

    C (Tarlok Singh Chauhan) Judge

    h (Satyen Vaidya) 0 g 5.03.2024 Judge i (krt/pankaj/Sanjeev)

    H

    100

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    NHPC LTD v. THE STATE OF HP AND OTHERS
    (Mar 5, 2024)