AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2024 INSC 186
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 16(1)(a)(i) read with Section 7 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954
  • Section 2(ix)(k) of the Act
  • Section 52, Subsection (1) and (2) of the Food Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 52 of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006
  • Section 16(1)(a) of the Act
  • Article 20(1) of the Constitution of India
  • the Act, 1954
  • The Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954
  • The Act or the Rules made thereunder
  • Section 16(1)(a)(i) read with Section 7 of the Act
  • Article 20 of the Constitution of India
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2024 INSC 186
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 16(1)(a)(i) read with Section 7 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954
  • Section 2(ix)(k) of the Act
  • Section 52, Subsection (1) and (2) of the Food Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 52 of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006
  • Section 16(1)(a) of the Act
  • Article 20(1) of the Constitution of India
  • the Act, 1954
  • The Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954
  • The Act or the Rules made thereunder
  • Section 16(1)(a)(i) read with Section 7 of the Act
  • Article 20 of the Constitution of India
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 06 December 2000, a Food Inspector inspected the shop/godown of the appellants—M/s A.K. Sarkar & Co. (appellant no. 1) and its partner (appellant no. 2)—at 71, Biplabi Rash Behari Basu Road, Calcutta. He purchased three packets (500 gms each) of sugar-boiled confectionery for analysis. The laboratory reported that although the confectionery was not adulterated, the packets failed to display the manufacturer’s complete address and the date of manufacture, thereby violating Rule 32(c) & (f) of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules, 1955.

A complaint under Section 16(1)(a)(i) read with Section 7 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954 was filed. The Trial Court convicted all three accused; appellant no. 2 and a third accused (Amit Kumar Sarkar) received six months’ simple imprisonment and ₹1,000 fine each, while the firm was fined ₹2,000. The District & Sessions Judge dismissed the appeal but acquitted the third accused. In revision, the Calcutta High Court upheld the conviction while reducing appellant no. 2’s sentence to three months’ simple imprisonment.

The present Criminal Appeal (arising out of SLP (Crl) No. 6095 of 2018) challenges those concurrent findings, primarily seeking alteration of sentence in light of subsequent legislation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Rule 32(c) and (f) of the 1955 Rules, invoked by the prosecution, actually governed labelling requirements amounting to misbranding at the time of the offence.
  2. Whether, after repeal of the 1954 Act by the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006—which prescribes only monetary penalty for misbranding—the appellants are entitled to substitution of imprisonment with a lesser sentence of fine.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The charge under Rule 32(c) & (f) was misconceived because those sub-rules did not pertain to misbranding.
  • Given the repeal of the 1954 Act and the more lenient regime under Section 52 of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006, only a monetary penalty should now be imposed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
T. Barai v. Henry Ah Hoe (1983) 1 SCC 177 Beneficial construction of penal amendments—an accused may claim benefit of subsequent legislation reducing punishment. Relied on to justify substituting imprisonment with fine because the new law prescribes only monetary penalty.
Nemi Chand v. State of Rajasthan (2018) 17 SCC 448 Follow-up application of the T. Barai principle; imprisonment under the old Act was replaced by fine. Cited as precedent for converting custodial sentence to fine in misbranding cases.
Trilok Chand v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2020) 10 SCC 763 Further affirmation that courts may impose lesser punishment available under new law. Used to reinforce the court’s discretion to impose a fine instead of imprisonment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia, writing for the Bench, held that:

  • On the date of the offence (06 December 2000), Rule 32(c) and (f) expressly required labels to state the manufacturer’s complete address and the month and year of manufacture. Non-compliance constituted misbranding under Section 2(ix)(k) of the 1954 Act. Thus, the appellants’ contention about wrong provisions was “totally misconceived”.
  • The court accepted the concurrent factual finding that the seized packets were misbranded; therefore, conviction under Section 16(1)(a)(i) read with Section 7 was unassailable.
  • Analyzing Article 20(1) of the Constitution, the Bench affirmed that while ex post facto laws imposing harsher punishment are barred, the Constitution does not prohibit application of a later, more lenient penalty.
  • The 1954 Act has been repealed by the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006, and Section 52 of the 2006 Act prescribes only a monetary penalty up to ₹3 lakh for misbranding with no imprisonment.
  • Invoking the principles in T. Barai, Nemi Chand, and Trilok Chand, the Bench concluded that it could—and should—substitute the custodial sentence with an appropriate fine, especially since twenty-four years have elapsed, appellant no. 2 is about 60 years old, and the court had earlier exempted him from surrender.

Holding and Implications

PARTLY ALLOWED. The conviction is affirmed, but the sentence is modified:

  • Appellant no. 2’s three-month simple imprisonment is replaced by a fine of ₹50,000, to be deposited within three weeks.
  • The firm’s fine of ₹2,000 is maintained.

Implications: The decision reinforces the judiciary’s willingness to apply the doctrine of beneficial construction in penal matters, granting the accused the advantage of lighter penalties introduced by subsequent legislation. While no new precedent is set, the judgment aligns with and further endorses the line of cases allowing substitution of imprisonment with monetary penalty in food-misbranding offences after the 2006 Act.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    M/S. A.K. SARKAR CO. v. THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL THE HOME SECRETARY

    2024 INSC 186

    1

    REPORTABLE

    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

    CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

    CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.__________ of 2024 SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CRIMINAL) NO.6095 of 2018 M/S A.K. SARKAR & CO. & ANR. ...APPELLANTS

    VERSUS

    THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS. …RESPONDENTS

    SUDHANSHU DHULIA, J.

    Leave granted.

    2. The present appeal arises out of a proceeding under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954 (for short 'the Act') where the present appellant no.1, its partners appellant no.2 and Amit Kumar Sarkar, were charged under Section 16(1)(a)(i) read with Section 7 of the Act and were convicted by the Trial court. Appellant no.2 and Amit Kumar Sarkar were sentenced to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of six months along with a fine of Rs.1,000/- each, whereas appellant no.1 was directed to pay a fine of Rs.2,000/-.

    1

    2

    3. The appeal of the appellants against the order of conviction and sentence by the Trial Court was dismissed by the District and Sessions Judge but the conviction of Amit Kumar Sarkar, the third accused in the case, was set aside and he was acquitted. In Revision proceedings, the High Court of Calcutta though upheld the concurrent findings of conviction but reduced the sentence of appellant no.2 from 6 months to 3 months simple imprisonment.

    4. Brief facts leading to this appeal are that on 06.12.2000, a food inspector while inspecting the shop/godown of the appellants at 71, Biplabi Rash Behari Basu Road, Calcutta took samples of some sugar boiled confectionaries, which were kept for sale and for human consumption. After payment, the food inspector purchased 1500 grams of sugar boiled confectionery contained in three packets of 500 grams each, and as per due process sent the samples for examination in a laboratory. The public analysis/Lab report shows that the food articles were not adulterated, but it said that the packets did not show the prescribed particulars such as complete address of the manufacturer and the date of manufacturing. Thus, there was violation of Rule 32(c)

    3

    and (f) of the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules, 1955 (for short 'Rules'). In view of these findings, the inspector filed a complaint before the Trial Court under Section 16(1)(a)(i) read with Section 7 of the Act.

    5. The plea of the appellants before the Trial Court was that they had not manufactured the food articles, instead Bose Confectionary, Calcutta had manufactured these items. All the same, the appellants could not show any valid proof of their contention and thus, the Trial Court and the Appellate Court (as well as the Revisional Court) did not accept this contention raised by the appellants. The appellant stood convicted of the offence under Section 16(1)(a)(i) read with Section 7 of the Act and appellant no.2 was sentenced to undergo 3 months simple imprisonment along with fine. While appellant no.1 was sentenced to pay a fine of Rs.2,000/-.

    6. Before this Court, learned Counsel for the appellants would argue that the entire case of the prosecution is liable to be dismissed for the simple reason that the appellants were charged under Rule 32 (c) and (f) of the Rules but these

    4

    provisions were not related to misbranding and were regarding something else.

    7. All the same, this contention is totally misconceived inasmuch on the date of occurrence i.e., 06.12.2000 when the samples were taken, the provisions which were applicable were Rule 32 (c) and (f) only (as the Rules had been amended vide G.S.R 422(E) dated 29.04.1987), and Rule 32 as per the Gazette Notification reads as under :-

    "32. Package of food to carry a label: --

    (a) …………

    (b) …………

    (c) The name and complete address of the manufacturer or importer or vendor or packer.

    (d) ………..

    (e) ………..

    (f) The month and year in which the commodity is manufactured or prepacked."

    Therefore, this contention of the learned counsel for the appellant regarding non-applicability of the provision is not correct. There are concurrent findings of three Courts below and there is absolutely no question of us having any measure of doubt as to the findings, inasmuch as that the packets which were taken from shop/godown of the

    5

    appellants were misbranded as defined under Section 2(ix)(k) of the Act, as they were not labelled in accordance with the requirements of the Act or the Rules made thereunder. The only question which now remains is of sentence. The plea here is of reduction of sentence and if only fine can be imposed, which is permissible as per the law currently applicable.

    8. Article 20(1) of the Constitution of India reads as under:

    "(1) No person shall be convicted of any offence except for violation of a law in force at the time of the commission of the act charged as an offence, nor be subjected to a penalty greater than that which might have been inflicted under the law in force at the time of the commission of the offence.

    (2) ……….

    (3) ………." The above provision has been interpretated several times by this Court and broadly the mandate here is that a person cannot be punished for an offence which was not an offence at the time it was committed, nor can he be subjected to a sentence which is greater than the sentence which was applicable at the relevant point of time. All the same, the above provision does not prohibit this Court, to award a

    6

    lesser punishment in a befitting case, when this Court is of the opinion that a lesser punishment may be awarded since the new law on the penal provision provides a lesser punishment i.e. lesser than what was actually applicable at the relevant time. The prohibition contained in Article 20 of the Constitution of India is on subjecting a person to a higher punishment than which was applicable for that crime at the time of the commission of the crime. There is no prohibition, for this Court to impose a lesser punishment which is now applicable for the same crime.

    9. The Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954 was repealed by the introduction of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 where Section 52 provides a maximum penalty of Rs.3,00,000/- for misbranded food. There is no provision for imprisonment.

    The provision, which is presently applicable, is as follows :

    "52. Penalty for misbranded food. (1) Any person who whether by himself or by any other person on his behalf manufactures for sale or stores or sells or distributes or imports any article of food for human consumption which is misbranded, shall be liable to a penalty which may extend to three lakh rupees. (2) The Adjudicating Officer may issue a direction

    7

    to the person found guilty of an offence under this section, for taking corrective action to rectify the mistake or such article of food shall be destroyed."

    Whether the appellant can be granted the benefit of the new legislation and be awarded a lesser punishment as is presently prescribed under the new law? This Court in

    T. Barai v. Henry Ah Hoe (1983) 1 SCC 177, had held that when an amendment is beneficial to the accused it can be applied even to cases pending in Courts where such a provision did not exist at the time of the commission of offence. It was said as under:-

    "22. It is only retroactive criminal legislation that is prohibited under Article 20(1). The prohibition contained in Article 20(1) is that no person shall be convicted of any offence except for violation of a law in force at the time of the commission of the act charged as an offence prohibits nor shall he be subjected to a penalty greater than that which might have been inflicted under the law in force at the time of the commission of the offence. It is quite clear that insofar as the Central Amendment Act creates new offences or enhances punishment for a particular type of offence no person can be convicted by such ex post facto law nor can the enhanced punishment prescribed by the amendment be applicable. But insofar as the Central Amendment Act reduces the punishment for an offence punishable under Section 16(1)(a) of the Act, there is no

    8

    reason why the accused should not have the benefit of such reduced punishment. The rule of beneficial construction requires that even ex post facto law of such a type should be applied to mitigate the rigour of the law. The principle is based both on sound reason and common sense." A reference to the above case was given by this Court in

    Nemi Chand v. State of Rajasthan (2018) 17 SCC 448 where six months of imprisonment awarded under the Act was modified to only a fine of Rs.50,000/-. The above principle was applied by this Court again in Trilok Chand v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (2020) 10 SCC 763 and the sentence of three months of imprisonment and Rs.500/- of fine for misbranding under the Act, 1954 was modified to that of only a fine of Rs.5,000/-.

    10. The present appellant no.2, at this stage, is about 60 years of age and the crime itself is of the year 2000, and twenty- four years have elapsed since the commission of the crime. Vide Order dated 06.08.2018, this Court had granted exemption from surrendering to appellant no.2. Considering all aspects, more particularly the nature of offence, though we uphold the findings of the Courts below regarding the

    9

    offence, but we hereby convert the sentence of appellant no.2 from three months of simple imprisonment along with fine of Rs.1,000/- to a fine of Rs.50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand only). The sentence of appellant no.1 which is for a fine of Rs. 2000/- is upheld. The amount shall be deposited with the concerned Court within a period of three weeks from today. Accordingly, the appeal is partly allowed.

    …...……………………………J.

    (SUDHANSHU DHULIA)

    …....……………………………J.

    (PRASANNA B. VARALE)

    New Delhi

    March 7, 2024.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/S. A.K. SARKAR CO. v. THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL THE HOME SECRETARY
    (Mar 7, 2024)