Neutral Citation No. - 2024:AHC-LKO:17586
Court No. - 5 Case :- MATTERS UNDER ARTICLE 227 No. - 957 of 2024
Petitioner :- Ram Das Sahu
Respondent :- Dheeraj Agarwal
Counsel for Petitioner :- Yogesh Kesarwani,Shiv Nath Tilhari
Counsel for Respondent :- Abhishek Dhaon,Sankalp Mehrotra
Hon'ble Abdul Moin,J.
1. Heard Shri Yogesh Keshrwani, learned counsel for the petitioner and Shri Abhishek Dhaon, learned counsel for the respondents.
2. With the consent of learned counsel appearing for the contesting parties, the petition is being finally decided.
3. The instant petition has been filed praying for the following main relief:
"Wherefore, it is very respectfully prayed that this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to set-aside the judgement and order dated 06.01.2023 passed in old R.C. P.A. no. 2000005/13 (Dr Satish Chandra Agarwal vs Ramji Das Sahu) by the learned court of Judge Small Causes, Sitapur contained in Annexure No. 1 and the order dated 06.12.2023 passed in Civil Appeal no. 24/23 (Ramji Das Sahu vs Dheeraj Agarwal) by the court of learned Additional District Judge, court no. 2, Sitapur contained in Annexure No. 2 to the present petitioner"
4. The contention of learned counsel for the petitioner, who is a tenant, is that in the year 2013 a P.A. case was filed under provisions of Section 21(1)(a) of the Uttar Pradesh Urban Buildings (Regulation of Letting, Rent and Eviction) Act, 1972 (hereinafter referred to as the Act 1972) by Dr Satish Chandra Agarwal, who was the then landlord, for eviction of petitioner from the shop in dispute. Through the judgement and order dated 06.01.2023, a copy of which is annexure 1 to the petition, learned trial court directed for eviction of the petitioner, the tenant. An appeal was filed by the petitioner before learned
1
Additional District Judge, Sitapur which was registered as Appeal No. 24/23 in re: Ramji Das Sahu vs Dheeraj Agarwal. Incidentally Dheeraj Agarwal is the son of erstwhile landlord Dr Satish Chandra Agarwal. The appellate court vide the order dated 06.12.2023, a copy of which is annexure 2 to the petition, has dismissed the appeal of the petitioner and hence the instant petition.
5. The contention of learned counsel for the petitioner is that the appellate court has decided the appeal vide the impugned judgement and order dated 06.12.2023 per which the appeal has been dismissed. The appellate court has specifically recorded that the appellant is not present and placing reliance on the provisions of the Order 41 Rule 17 CPC and on certain judgments the appeal has been dismissed on merit.
6. The argument of learned counsel for the petitioner is that under Order 41 Rule 17 CPC in case the appellant is not present the appeal can be dismissed for default but the same cannot be decided on merit considering the explanation which has been inserted in Order 41 Rule 17 CPC which insertion has been done with effect from 01.02.1997.
7. Placing reliance on judgement of Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in Civil Appeal No. 6142 of 2008 arising out of Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 1583 of 2007 in re: The Secretary, Department of Horticulture, Chandigarh & another vs Raghu Raj decided on 17.10.2008 the argument of learned counsel for the petitioner is that Hon'ble Supreme Court after considering the said explanation as inserted in Order 41 Rule 17 CPC has categorically held that the appellate court would not have the power of deciding an appeal on merit in the absence of the appellant in as much as dismissal of an appeal on merit is not permissible.
2
8. Placing reliance on aforesaid judgement as well as judgement and order dated 06.12.2023 passed by learned appellate court the further argument of learned counsel for the petitioner is that even in case the appellant did not put in appearance before the appellate court and the specific observation of the learned appellate court was that the appellant is deliberately absenting himself from the proceedings in the appeal, consequently the only option open to the appellate court was to have dismissed the appeal in default but could not have decided the case on merit.
8. It is also contended that the judgements over which reliance has been placed by learned appellate court as finds place in the impugned judgement of this Court are of the years 1965 and 1966 i.e. prior to the explanation inserted in Order 41 Rule 17 CPC and thus the same would not have any applicability in the present case.
9. On the other hand, Shri Abhishek Dhaon, learned counsel for the respondent does not dispute the aforesaid legal position but states that seeing the conduct of the appellant / petitioner herein before the lower court, the appellate court had no option but to pass an order on merit.
10. However he does not dispute the position of law laid down by Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Raghu Raj (supra).
11. Considering the aforesaid, more particularly when Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Raghu Raj (supra) has already held that considering the explanation to Order 41 Rule 17 CPC the appellate court, in absence of appellant, cannot decide the appeal on merit as such it is apparent that the judgement and order dated 06.12.2023 passed by the appellate court would run contrary to the aforesaid proposition of law laid down by
3
Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Raghu Raj (supra).
12. Keeping in view the aforesaid discussion, the order impugned dated 06.12.2023, a copy of which is annexure 2 to the petition, is set aside.
13. The matter is remitted to the appellate court to pass a fresh order after hearing all the parties concerned in accordance with law.
14. Let an order in this regard be passed expeditiously.
15. Shri Yogesh Keshrwani, learned counsel for the petitioner also submits that no adjournment would be sought by the appellant before the appellate court either by the appellant himself or by his counsel.
Order Date :- 27.2.2024 J.K. Dinkar
4