Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2024 KHC 5173
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2024 KHC 5173
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Smt. Seethalaxmi, a retired government employee who served from 24.09.1980 until attaining superannuation on 31.10.2019, filed Writ Petition No.3674 of 2022 under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India. She challenged the denial of one Kannada Language Examination (KLE) increment. The immediate relief sought included quashing the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal's order dated 19.01.2022 in Application No.597/2021 and an endorsement dated 27.10.2020 issued by Respondent No.3, and a declaration that she was entitled to the KLE increment and related benefits. The petitioner asserts she studied up to SSLC in Kannada medium and was therefore eligible for the increment without passing a separate Kannada Language Examination. After notice, the respondents appeared through the learned AGA and opposed the petition. The matter proceeded to preliminary hearing before a Division Bench of the Karnataka High Court (Krishna S. Dixit, J. and G. Basavaraja, J.) on 7 February 2024.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner, having studied up to SSLC in Kannada medium (Kannada as a subject), is entitled to one Kannada Language Examination Increment (KLE increment) without passing the Kannada Language Examination.
  2. Whether denial of the increment to the petitioner constitutes discriminatory treatment violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India (principle of parity).
  3. Whether salary/emoluments or the right to receive increments constitute property under Article 300A and whether denial of the increment infringes that right.
  4. Whether delay and laches arising from the petitioner's retirement or the timing of the claim bars the grant of relief.
  5. Whether earlier decisions (including a Co-ordinate Bench decision in W.P.No.13242/2021 — State of Karnataka vs. Smt. P. Shobha — and earlier Tribunal orders) are applicable and bind the present claim.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner served a long and spotless service (24.09.1980 to 31.10.2019) and retired on attaining superannuation; she ought to have been granted one KLE increment owing to her academic qualification (studied up to SSLC in Kannada medium).
  • Singular denial of this benefit to the petitioner is discriminatory and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution (parity with similarly circumstanced employees).
  • The amounts payable by way of salary and emoluments (including increments) constitute property and denial amounts to violation of Article 300A; reliance was placed on K.T. Plantation vs. State of Karnataka (2011) 9 SCC 1.
  • Reliance was placed on a Co-ordinate Bench decision of this Court in W.P.No.13242/2021 (State & Others vs. P. Shobha & Another) where certain observations favored granting increments to similarly circumstanced litigants.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents opposed the petition, justifying the Tribunal's order dated 19.01.2022 which negatived Application No.597/2021.
  • They contended the petition should be dismissed on the ground of delay and laches, noting the petitioner retired on 31.10.2019 and the departmental decision rejecting the claim was dated 27.10.2020.
  • The respondents disputed the applicability/invocability of the Co-ordinate Bench decision relied upon by the petitioner.
  • The learned AGA argued that the Tribunal's order merely interdicted recovery of amounts which were previously paid (i.e., the Tribunal did not actually accord the increment but quashed recovery proceedings). The AGA sought to limit the effect claimed by the petitioner on this basis.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K.T. Plantation vs. State of Karnataka, (2011) 9 SCC 1 Used to support proposition that money payable as salary and emoluments constitute property protected under Article 300A. The petitioner relied on this authority to argue that denial of the increment affected her proprietary right; the court noted the petitioner's submission of this precedent while assessing Article 300A contentions.
STATE OF KARNATAKA vs. SMT. P. SHOBHA (W.P.No.13242/2021) — Co-ordinate Bench decision (order dated 23.10.2021) Interpretation of Government Order dated 22.03.1999 and Circular dated 06.02.2013 in the context of entitlement to one additional KLE increment for employees who studied Kannada in SSLC; principle of parity for similarly circumstanced employees. The Court treated the Shobha decision as directly relevant and persuasive. It relied on that decision's reasoning that the 06.02.2013 Circular was vague and that sanctioning one KLE increment was not an additional privilege excluding those re-deployed after 22.03.1999. The present court applied parity on Article 14 based on that decision.
Niranjanlall Agarwalla vs. Union of India, AIR 1969 SC 23 Principle that the State should not contest a good claim by raising unsubstantiated technical pleas; equitable approach in administrative litigation. The court quoted the judgment to support the proposition that the State should not defeat legitimate claims on mere technicalities and used it to justify granting relief to the petitioner despite procedural objections raised by the respondents.
Davis v. Mills, 194 U.S. 451 (1904) (quoted) General constitutional principle that constitutions preserve practical and substantial rights. The court cited this passage to underscore that constitutional protections are meant to preserve substantive rights and to justify a sympathetic approach towards a long-serving pensioner seeking a monetary increment and its pensionary consequences.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a stepwise analysis based strictly on the materials and prior decisions placed before it:

  1. Recognition of Facts: The court recorded the petitioner's nearly three decades of regular, spotless service (24.09.1980 to 31.10.2019) and that she retired on attaining superannuation and is now a pensioner drawing pension.
  2. Eligibility on Academic Grounds: It was not disputed that the petitioner studied up to SSLC in Kannada medium with Kannada as one of the subjects, and therefore employees in that category need not pass the Kannada Language Examination to claim the increment.
  3. Parity and Precedent: The court observed that similar benefits had been granted by the Tribunal in other identical matters (Application Nos.11022/2016 c/w 1881/2019 & 2754/2019 disposed by common order dated 22.08.2019). The Co-ordinate Bench decision in Shobha's case (W.P.No.13242/2021, order dated 23.10.2021) had affirmed such grants. Applying the principle of parity under Article 14, the court held that what applies to one similarly situated person should apply to others in like circumstances.
  4. On the Government Order and Circular: The court accepted the reasoning in Shobha's case that the Government Order dated 22.03.1999 (which redeployed School Matas/Mothers as Pre-Primary Teachers and stated no change in Grades/Service Rules) did not preclude entitlement to the KLE increment. The Circular dated 06.02.2013 was characterized (following Shobha) as vague and creating ambiguity; reliance solely on that Circular to deny the increment was found to be untenable.
  5. Rejection of Respondents' Technical Contentions: The court found difficulty in accepting the AGA's submission that the Tribunal only interdicted recovery and had not actually granted the increment; it relied on the treatment of the matter in Shobha's decision to hold that recovery proceedings based on the 2013 Circular were perverse where earlier Tribunal directions had attained finality.
  6. Delay & Laches: The court acknowledged the respondents' contention that stale claims should not ordinarily be entertained and reiterated that delay and laches are judicial doctrines designed to refuse belated claims. However, observing that the petitioner had pursued remedies soon after departmental rejection on 27.10.2020, and that the Co-ordinate Bench decision (Shobha) came only on 23.10.2021 (with the State's SLP rejected on 18.02.2022), the court concluded the petitioner was not a speculative litigant. The court emphasized that writ jurisdiction has no statutory limitation and that delay/laches cannot per se defeat a legitimate right where no third-party rights have intervened.
  7. Equitable Limitation on Arrears: Recognizing the modest monetary value of the KLE increment (noted as Rs. 2,900/-), and the equities involved for a retired pensioner, the court exercised its equitable power to confine the arrears claim to three years preceding the KAT application filed in February 2021. Concretely, the court directed that the increment be treated as having fallen due in February 2018 and limited arrears accordingly; any entitlement prior to February 2018 was to be foregone.
  8. Remedial Directions and Enforcement Mechanism: The court ordered quashing of the Tribunal order dated 19.01.2022 and issued a writ of mandamus directing Respondent Nos.2 & 3 to sanction the KLE increment w.e.f. February 2018, pay arrears limited to the three-year window, and re-fix and pay pension and terminal benefits within three months. The court provided a sanction for post-deadline interest at 2% per mensum and permitted the Government to recover any such interest paid from the officials responsible for delay.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

DISPOSITIVE RULING: The Writ Petition is allowed in part. A Writ of Certiorari is issued quashing the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal's order dated 19.01.2022. A Writ of Mandamus is issued to Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 to sanction one Kannada Language Examination Increment to the petitioner with effect from February 2018, pay arrears (subject to the temporal limitation described below), and re-fix and pay pension and all terminal benefits including arrears within an outer limit of three months.

Direct Consequences and Implementation:

  • The petitioner is to be granted the KLE increment effective from February 2018.
  • Arrears of the incremental value are to be paid, but the claim is confined to the period not earlier than three years prior to the KAT application filed in February 2021 (i.e., no entitlement for periods before February 2018).
  • Pension and terminal benefits are to be re-fixed and paid inclusive of the effect of the increment.
  • Payment must be made within three months; in default, interest at 2% per mensum will be payable, and the Government may recover such interest from the official(s) responsible for the delay.
  • No costs were awarded.

Broader Implications:

The court applied parity under Article 14 and relied on prior Tribunal rulings and a Co-ordinate Bench decision (Shobha) to grant relief. The judgment confines arrears on equitable grounds and emphasizes protecting legitimate claims of pensioners. The opinion does not state that it establishes a novel legal principle beyond application of existing authorities; its practical effect is to extend the KLE increment and related pensionary benefits to the petitioner in line with prior decisions for similarly circumstanced employees.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SMT.SEETHALAXMI v. STATE OF KARNATAKA

    - 1 -

    NC: 2024:KHC:5173-DB WP No. 3674 of 2022

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

    DATED THIS THE 7TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2024

    PRESENT

    THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE KRISHNA S DIXIT

    AND

    THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE G BASAVARAJA WRIT PETITION NO.3674 OF 2022 (S-KSAT)

    BETWEEN:

    SMT. SEETHALAXMI,

    W/O. U.LAKSHMINARAYANA VAIDYA,

    AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,

    RETIRED ASSISTANT TEACHER,

    R/AT: 'ANUGRAHA' KANNUKERE,

    TEKKATTE POST, KUNDAPURA TALUK,

    UDUPI DISTRICT - 576 231. …PETITIONER

    (BY SRI. VIGHNESHWAR. S. SHASTRI, ADVOCATE FOR

    SRI. GURURAJ. R., ADVOCATE)

    AND:

    1. STATE OF KARNATAKA,

    REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,

    PRIMARY AND SECONDARY EDUCATION,

    M.S. BUILDING, BENGLAURU - 560 001.

    2. COMMISSIONER OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS

    FOR PRIMARY EDUCATION,

    NEW PUBLIC OFFICE, NRAPATUNGA ROAD,

    BENGALURU - 560 001.

    3. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR (ADMINISTRATION),

    DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTION,

    UDUPI, UDUPI DISTRICT - 576 226.

    R

    - 2 -

    4. BLOCK EDUCATIONAL OFFICER,

    PUBLIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT,

    KUNDAPURA ZONE, KUNDAPURA,

    UDUPI DISTRICT - 576 231.

    5. ACCOUNTANT GENERAL (A AND E),

    KARNATAKA, BENGLAURU,

    P.B.NO.5329/5369,

    PARK HOUSE ROAD,

    BENGALURU - 560 001,

    BY ITS SENIOR ACCOUNTS OFFICER.

    …RESPONDENTS

    (BY SRI. KHAMROZ KHAN, AGA)

    THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226

    AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE

    A WRIT OF CERTIORARI OR ANY OTHER APPROPRIATE WRIT,

    ORDER OR DIRECTION, QUASHING ORDER DATED 19/01/2022 PASSED BY HON'BLE KARNATAKA STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, BENGALURU IN APPLICATION NO.597/2021 AS PER ANNEXURE-C TO THE WRIT PETITION AND ENDORSEMENT

    DATED 27/10/2020 IN NO.Bi2/SHAA.MAA.KA.VE.BHA./20-21

    ISSUED BY THE RESPONDENT NO.3 AUTHORITY AS PER

    ANNEXURE-14 TO THE APPLICATION NO.597/2021 BY

    DECLARING THAT PETITIONER IS ENTITLED FOR KANNADA

    LANGUAGE INCREMENT AND ETC.,

    THIS PETITION COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING

    IN 'B' GROUP, THIS DAY, KRISHNA S. DIXIT. J., MADE THE

    FOLLOWING:

    - 3 -

    ORDER

    Petitioner, a pensioner is essentially grieving against the denial of one solitary increment which avails to all civil servants who have studied in Kannada Medium upto SSLC with Kannada as one of subjects in the syllabus.

    2. Learned Sr.Advocate appearing for the petitioner argues that the petitioner having put in a very long service has retired on attaining the age of superannuation; she ought to have been accorded one Kannada Language Examination Increment because of the academic qualification; not extending such a benefit singularly to the petitioner is discriminatory and therefore violative of Article 14 of the Constitution; the money payable as salary & emoluments are a property of the employee and therefore not paying amounts to violation of constitutional guarantee under Article 300A, vide K.T PLANTATION vs. STATE OF KARNATAKA, (2011) 9 SCC 1. He also places reliance on a Co-ordinate Bench decision of this court in W.P.No.13242/2021 (S-KSAT) between STATE &

    - 4 -

    OTHERS vs. P. SHOBHA & ANOTHER, disposed off vide order dated 23.10.2021 wherein certain observations are made about the entitlement of similarly circumstanced litigants being granted such increments.

    3. After service of notice, the respondents have entered appearance through the learned AGA, who vehemently opposes the petition making submission in justification of the Tribunal's order dated 19.01.2022 whereby petitioner's Application No.597/2021 has been negatived. Secondly, he seeks dismissal of the petition on the ground of delay & laches, petitioner having already retired from service on 31.10.2019. Lastly, he disputes the invocability of the Co-ordinate Bench decision supra.

    4. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and having perused the Petition papers, we are inclined to grant indulgence in the matter as under and for the following reasons:

    A. Petitioner worked as a regular employee during the period between 24.09.1980 and 31.10.2019 with

    - 5 -

    spotless Service Record. She demitted office on attaining the age of superannuation and now she is drawing pension. Admittedly, she has studied upto SSLC in Kannada Medium and Kannada happened to be one of the subjects in the syllabus. There is no dispute that such employees need not pass Kannada Language Examination, which others have to, for availing said increment. Said benefit has been accorded by the Tribunal to similar circumstanced persons in Application Nos. 11022/2016 c/w 1881/2019 & 2754/2019 that were disposed off by a common order dated 22.08.2019. One such order was put in challenge in W.P.No.13242/2021 (S-KSAT) between STATE OF KARNATAKA vs. SMT. P.SHOBHA disposed off on 23.10.2021 negativing the challenge. Therefore what applies to goose should apply to gander on the principle of parity enacted in Article 14 of the Constitution of India. B. It is not in dispute that petitioner was working as School Maatha earlier and after the abolition of said cadre vide Government Order dated 22.03.1999, she was re-

    - 6 -

    posted Pre-primary Teacher which post she was initially appointed to on 24.09.1980. She demitted this post on 31.10.2019 on attaining the age of superannuation. Thus she has put in nearly three decades of spotless service. The condition subject to which such employees were re- deployed as Pre-primary Teachers has been pooh-poohed by the Co-ordinate Bench in Shobha's case supra. Therefore learned AGA cannot much bank upon it to contend that the employees are bound by the same and as a consequence they cannot be granted any increment. C. The contention of learned AGA that what the Tribunal had done was not according the increment but only interdicting recovery of money wrongly paid on account of unlawful grant of KLE increment, is bit difficult to accept. The order of the Tribunal, as already mentioned above had quashed recovery of any amount, is true. However, when the matter was carried by the Government in Shobha's case supra, the Co-ordinate Bench observed as under:

    - 7 -

    "8. Firstly, it is not in dispute that the respondents studied Kannada as First Language in SSLC, i.e. studied in Kannada Medium, and were exempted from passing Kannada Language Examination as per Karnataka Civil Services (Kannada Language) Examination Rules, 1974 and as such they were eligible for one additional KLE increment. The Order dated 22nd March, 1999 would indicate that due to the proposal submitted by the Department of Education and after verification of the proposal, the Government has decided to depute School Matas/Mothers, to Government Primary Schools, however, they will not be entitled for any privilege/benefits available to the Primary School Teachers and there will be no change in their Grades and Service Rules. Interpreting that the phrase "not entitled to additional privileges/benefits" figured in the said Government Order dated 22nd March, 1999 would not preclude the stake holders seeking increment for having passed the Kannada Language Examination subsequent to abolition of School Matas/Mothers, representations were filed. On considering such representations made by the erstwhile School Matas/Mothers, the clarification dated 06th February, 2013 has been issued by the Government, which is the basis for the Accountant General to raise objections for having extended one additional KLE increment to the respondents herein.

    - 8 -

    9. At the outset, the interpretation/clarification given by the Government in the Circular dated 06th February, 2013 is vague and baseless. No reasons, much less valid reasons, are assigned for giving clarification that the Primary School Teachers are not entitled for one additional KLE increment, moreover the said clarification is not absolute denial, but would indicate that the said clarification is excluding the Government order dated 22nd March, 1999. As could be seen, the Circular dated 06th February, 2013 is not in the nature of clarification but creates more ambiguity with respect to the Government order dated 22nd March, 1999. Be that as it may, having complied with the order passed by the Tribunal in the earlier round of litigation which has reached finality, merely placing reliance on the clarification dated 06th February, 2013, the recovery proceedings initiated by the authorities based on the objection raised by the Accountant General, is fully perverse and untenable. Sanction of one additional KLE increment is not an additional privilege/benefit extended to the Primary School Teachers." D. AS TO DELAY & LACHES:

    (a) Petitioner lady served the institution as a regular employee from 24.09.1980 to 31.10.2019 and she has been superannuated, is not in dispute. We have seen above, the benefit of one KLE increment being given to

    - 9 -

    similarly circumstanced employees in other identical institutions. The Tribunal decided the dispute relating to increment in Application No.9334/2015 vide order dated 16.11.2017. The petitioner who was in the verge of retirement got her claim rejected by the Department on 27.10.2020 i.e., soon after her retirement. She had approached the Tribunal in Application No.597/2021. The Co-ordinate Bench decided Shobha's case only on 23.10.2021. Even State's SLP No.1668/2022 came to be rejected on 18.02.2022. Therefore it cannot be said that petitioner was a speculative litigant. She was fighting for her legitimate right to get the increment which is her property in the light of Article 300A of the Constitution.

    (b) Above being said, there is some force in the submission of learned AGA that Court should not ordinarily grant relief in stale claims. Law does not come to the aid of sleepy & tardy, is true. However, it is notable that our Constitution does not prescribe any limitation period for tapping the Writ Jurisdiction, the doctrine of delay &

    - 10 -

    latches being a judicial invention to turn down belated claims. This doctrine per se cannot defeat a legitimate right of a citizen, when no third party rights are created, since it does not operate as a Thumb Rule. After all, the State pensioners have to be handled with soft gloves, with sympathy & smile.

    (c) Added to the above, the value of KLE increment is only Rs.2,900/-. It is just nothing in these days when bread is costlier than blood. Equity can be worked out by confining claim of the petitioner to three years preceding the KAT Application that was filed in February 2021. In other words, she cannot claim anything three years anterior to February 2018, and thus the claim for the previous period, she has to forego. The arrears on the basis of this increment need to be paid to the petitioner and further her pension and terminal benefits have to be re-fixed reckoning the increment, as having fallen due in February 2018.

    (d) It has been a settled position of law of writs that a legitimate claim of a citizen cannot be defeated by the

    - 11 -

    State only by pleading technical grounds. The Apex Court in NIRANJANLALL AGARWALLA vs. UNION OF INDIA -AIR 1969 SC 23 has observed as under: "It does not behove the State to contest a good claim on the off- chance of success on some unsubstantiated technical plea". We cannot be oblivious to the fact that who is before the Writ Court is a poor lady who has served the State for about three decades on not much attractive salary; she did it in a very humble post namely Pre- primary School Teacher; may be she has shaped the fate of many children as 'School Maatha' in the Government School. She has retired from service and drawing not much pretty pension. The evening of life poses age related difficulties which may be arguably mitigated with the aid of money. Denying any relief in its entirety would do great injustice to the pensioner. Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes of U.S. Supreme Court, a century ago had said in DAVIS vs. MILLS, 194 U.S. 451 (1904):

    "Constitutions are intended to preserve practical and substantial rights, not to maintain theories…".

    - 12 -

    In the above circumstances, this Writ petition is allowed in part; a Writ of Certiorari issues quashing the Tribunal's order dated 19.01.2022; a Writ of mandamus issues to Respondent Nos. 2 & 3 to sanction one Kannada Language Examination Increment to the petitioner w.e.f. February 2018 and pay the arrears of incremental value and further to re-fix and pay pension & all terminal benefits including arrears, to the Petitioner within an outer limit of three months, failing which the delay would carry interest at the rate of 2% per mensum which the Government after payment can recover the same personally from the official/s responsible for brooking the same.

    Now, no costs.

    Sd/-

    JUDGE

    Sd/-

    JUDGE

    Bsv List No.: 1 Sl No.: 14

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SMT.SEETHALAXMI v. STATE OF KARNATAKA
    (Feb 7, 2024)