O R D E R
This Writ Petition is filed by the State challenging the order dated 22ndAugust, 2019 passed by the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal, Bengaluru (for short "Tribunal") in Application No.11022 of 2016 connected with Applications No.1881 and 2754 of 2019 (Annexure-A) whereby the applications filed by the respondents herein have been allowed setting aside the orders dated 18thNovember, 2013 and 06th August, 2014 (Annexure-A11 and A12), as well as, orders dated 16thOctober, 2015 and 11thJanuary, 2019 (Annexure-A10 and A21) and thereby, directing the petitioners herein to release the arrears and further consequential benefits with interest at 8% per annum to the respondents herein within a period of six months from the date of receipt of certified copy of the order.
4
2. The respondent No.1 was appointed as Primary School Teacher in the Government Model Higher Primary School, Hangatakatte, Udupi Taluk on 2ndMarch, 1977 and Respondent No.2 was appointed as a Primary School Teacher at Uppunda, Kundapur Taluk on 2ndNovember, 1982. As the respondents were eligible for one additional increment called Kannada Language Examination increment ("KLE increment" for short) for having studied in Kannada Medium till SSLC and the same having been denied, the respondent No.1 had approached the Tribunal in Applications No.7101 to 7232 of 2002 along with similarly placed persons and the said Applications came to be disposed of by the Tribunal on 30thMay, 2002 directing the respondent-authorities to consider Circulars dated 03rd November, 2000 and 12thSeptember, 2001 and to take a decision regarding grant of one additional increment to the applicants therein fixing the timeframe of six months from the date of receipt of that order. Pursuant to the said direction issued by the Tribunal, order was passed by the concerned authority extending one KLE increment to the respondent No.1. After the retirement of respondent No.1 on 31stMay, 2013, it
5
appears that the Accountant General has raised objection that the School Mata/Mothers are not entitled for additional KLE increment.
3. Similarly, Smt. Bhageerathi (Respondent No.2 herein) has approached the Tribunal in Application No. 9334 of 2015 being aggrieved by the denial of KLE increment and the Tribunal by its order dated 16thNovember, 2017 directed the authorities to re-examine the matter and pass appropriate orders. Though such benefit was extended pursuant to the order passed by the Tribunal, however, while fixing the pension after retirement of the said respondent No.2 on 31stDecember, 2014, Audit objections were raised and accordingly, it was ordered for recovery of KLE increment with effect from 31stDecember, 2014.
4. Being aggrieved by the recovery proceedings initiated by the official respondents, the respondents herein approached the Tribunal in Application No.11022 (Smt. Shobha) and in Applications No.1881 and 2754 of 2019 (Smt. Bhageerathi). The Tribunal allowed the applications while passing a common order as aforesaid. Hence, this writ petition is by the State.
6
5. Learned High Court Government Pleader appearing for the petitioner-State submitted that the Tribunal failed to appreciate the material aspects of the matter inasmuch as the Circular dated 06thFebruary, 2013 which clarifies that the Primary School Teachers are not entitled to one additional KLE increment and this clarification was issued considering the Government Order dated 22ndMarch, 1999 wherein subsequent to the abolition of the post of School Matas/Mother, they were absorbed in the Higher Primary School as Assistant Masters and it was made clear that they were not entitled for additional benefits and there was no change in the pay scale as well as Service Rules. In this regard, on certain representations received from the Teachers for granting them one additional KLE increment for having passed Kannada Language Examination, and as such it was clarified by the Government in the Circular dated 06thFebruary, 2013. This Circular having a binding effect, ought not to have been ignored by the Tribunal while allowing the applications filed by the respondents herein. The learned High Court Government Pleader submits that the Tribunal, further failed to appreciate the scope of the orders passed earlier
7
and its consequential effect qua the Government Order dated 22ndMarch, 1999 and Circular dated 06thFebruary, 2013. He also submits that the further direction issued by the Tribunal to release the arrears of increment and other consequential benefits with interest at the rate of 8% per annum, is wholly unjustifiable.
6. On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents in both cases, would submit that though the respondents were appointed as Primary School Teachers, they were no doubt, considered as School Matas/Mothers, but the said cadre of School Matas/Mothers was abolished with effect from 22ndMarch, 1999 and pursuant to the orders passed by the Government, they were absorbed in the nearest Schools as Primary School Teachers. Both the respondents have studied in Kannada Medium till SSLC as per Karnataka Civil Services (Service and Kannada Language) Rules, 1974 and accordingly they were entitled for one additional KLE increment which was rightly extended, subsequent to the Orders passed by the Tribunal. By misinterpreting the Government Order dated 22nd
8
March, 1999 and the clarificatory Circular dated 06thFebruary, 2013, recovery order was issued. Based on the same, Audit Objections were raised and consequentially recovery proceedings were initiated for recovery from the pension amount of the retired employees, i.e. after about 32 years (in the case of Respondent Shobha) and 36 years (in the case of Bhageerathi). The learned counsel submits that the Tribunal, having considered all these aspects, has rightly allowed the applications setting aside the impugned orders, which does not warrant any interference by this Court and accordingly, seeks for dismissal of the writ petition.
7. Having considered the rival submissions of the learned counsel appearing for the parties and on perusal of the material on record, we are of the considered view that the writ petition deserves to be dismissed for the following reasons:
8. Firstly, it is not in dispute that the respondents studied Kannada as First Language in SSLC, i.e. studied in Kannada Medium, and were exempted from passing Kannada Language Examination as per Karnataka Civil Services (Kannada
9
Language) Examination Rules, 1974 and as such they were eligible for one additional KLE increment. The Order dated 22nd March, 1999 would indicate that due to the proposal submitted by the Department of Education and after verification of the proposal, the Government has decided to depute School Matas/Mothers, to Government Primary Schools, however, they will not be entitled for any privilege/benefits available to the Primary School Teachers and there will be no change in their Grades and Service Rules. Interpreting that the phrase "not entitled to additional privileges/benefits" figured in the said Government Order dated 22ndMarch, 1999 would not preclude the stake holders seeking increment for having passed the Kannada Language Examination subsequent to abolition of School Matas/Mothers, representations were filed. On considering such representations made by the erstwhile School Matas/Mothers, the clarification dated 06thFebruary, 2013 has been issued by the Government, which is the basis for the Accountant General to raise objections for having extended one additional KLE increment to the respondents herein.
10
9. At the outset, the interpretation/clarification given by the Government in the Circular dated 06thFebruary, 2013 is vague and baseless. No reasons, much less valid reasons, are assigned for giving clarification that the Primary School Teachers are not entitled for one additional KLE increment, moreover the said clarification is not absolute denial, but would indicate that the said clarification is excluding the Government order dated 22ndMarch, 1999. As could be seen, the Circular dated 06th February, 2013 is not in the nature of clarification but creates more ambiguity with respect to the Government order dated 22ndMarch, 1999. Be that as it may, having complied with the order passed by the Tribunal in the earlier round of litigation which has reached finality, merely placing reliance on the clarification dated 06thFebruary, 2013, the recovery proceedings initiated by the authorities based on the objection raised by the Accountant General, is fully perverse and untenable. Sanction of one additional KLE increment is not an additional privilege/benefit extended to the Primary School Teachers.
11
10. It is well-established principle of law that the recovery proceedings initiated against the retired employees in Group-C and D cadre, is not maintainable. At this juncture, it would be profitable to refer to the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of SAHIB RAM v. STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS reported in (1995)1 SCC 18 wherein the Hon'ble Apex Court has held that a mistake committed by wrongly extending the revised pay to the employee by relaxing the prescribed educational qualifications even though the concerned were ineligible for the same, would not entitle the employee to require an employee to refund the wages of a higher post, against which he had wrongfully been permitted to work though he should have rightfully been required to work against an inferior post. Similarly in the case of STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS v. RAFIQ MASIH (WHITE WASHER) reported in AIR 2015 SC 696, the Hon'ble Apex Court has held thus:
" 18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship, which would govern employees on the issue of recovery, where payments have mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may, based on the decisions referred to herein
12
above, we may, as a ready reference, summarise the following few situations, wherein recoveries by the employers, would be impermissible in law:
(i) xxx
(ii) Recovery from retired employees, or employees who are due to retire within one year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) to (v) xxx xxx xxx
19. We are informed by the learned counsel representing the appellant- State of Punjab, that all the cases in this bunch of appeals, would undisputedly fall within the first four categories delineated hereinabove. In the appeals referred to above, therefore, the impugned orders passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana (quashing the order of recovery), shall be deemed to have been upheld, for the reasons recorded above.
20. The appeals are disposed of in the above terms."
11. In the light of these rulings, the recovery proceedings initiated against the respondents herein, who worked indisputably in 'C' group and for whom the benefit of one additional KLE increment was extended for a period of 32 and 36 years respectively, is wholly impermissible in law. The Tribunal considering all these aspects, has rightly allowed the Applications
13
setting aside the impugned orders and directed the concerned authorities to pay the arrears and consequential benefits accordingly.
12. We do not find any perversity or illegality in the order impugned. Writ petition is devoid of merit and accordingly stands dismissed.
Sd/-
JUDGE
Sd/-
JUDGE
lnn