ORDER
1] Heard finally, with the consent of the parties.
2] This contempt petition has been filed by the petitioner for non compliance by the respondents, of the orders dated 14.06.2022, and 26.09.2022, passed by this Court in F.A. No.799 of 2022.
3] In brief, the facts of the case are that the petitioner had filed a civil suit for declaration and injunction against the respondent No.1, who is her mother and respondent Nos.2 and 3, who are her sisters in respect of the suit property, viz., a house situated at 25 Palasia, Main Road, A. B. Road, Indore. as mentioned in the Will of the petitioner's father, late Shri Sharad Kumar Sanghi. The aforesaid suit was dismissed by the trial Court on an application filed by the respondents/defendants under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC, which gave rise to the filing of First Appeal No.799 of 2022 by the present petitioner, in which, this Court has passed an interim order dated 14.06.2022 restraining the respondents from alienating the property in
3
question. This order was further reiterated by this Court on 26.09.2022, while admitting the appeal has made the interim order absolute restraining the respondents from alienating the property.
4] The petitioner is aggrieved by the respondents' action of alleged alienation of the movable properties from the house situated at 25 Palasia, Main Road, A. B. Road, Indore.
5] Counsel for the petitioner has vehemently submitted that despite there being an order, whereby this Court had restrained the respondents from alienating the property in question, the respondents have removed the valuable articles from the said house worth crores of rupees, which is in clear violation of the order passed by this Court.
6] Shri Abhinav Malhotra, Counsel for the petitioner has also submitted that the objection raised by the respondents that instead of the contempt petition, the petitioner ought to have filed an application under Order 39 Rule 2A of CPC has no legs to stand and has relied upon a decision rendered by the Allahabad High Court in the case of
Cantonment Executive Officer, Cantonment Board, Meerut and Ors. Vs. Pushpa Devi and Ors. passed in Contempt Application No.380 of 2001 dated 29.01.2014. Reliance is also placed on a decision rendered by the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh in the case of Ghulam Ahmad Dar & Ors. Vs. Mushtaq Ahmad Shah & Ors. reported as AIR 2006 J&K 91, wherein it is held that the status quo would mean that the existing position at the time of order should not be changed, which means that in no way the features or character of the subject should be altered or changed.
4
Counsel has also relied upon a decision of Supreme Court in the case of Delhi Development Authority Vs. Skipper Construction Co. (P) Ltd. and another reported as (1996) 4 SCC 622 paras 17 to 21 to submit that the petition is maintainable.
7] The prayer is opposed by Shri A. K. Sethi, Senior counsel for the respondents and it is submitted that there is no contempt committed by the respondents and no interference is called for as this Court has never passed any order of status quo, and on the contrary the order was only restraining the respondents from alienating the property in question in any manner and the respondents have not alienated the property in question either movable or immovable and only because they have changed their place of residence that they were required to shift the movable items to their new residence at 66/1, Sanghi's House, Bicholi Hapsi Main Road, Near Calorie Gym, Indore. It is also submitted that even otherwise, contempt petition itself is not maintainable in the light of the provisions of Or.39 R.3A of CPC.
8] Heard. On due consideration of submissions and on perusal of the documents filed on record, including the photographs filed by the petitioner, it is apparent that many valuable items, artifacts, paintings etc. earlier keptin the house in question have been removed, but respondents in their reply have made a categorical statement that none of the items have been alienated in any manner.
9] So far as the orders passed by this Court on 14.06.2022 and 26.09.2022 are concerned, the same read as under:-
5
"Order dated 14.06.2022:-
Appeal is admitted for final hearing. Let record of the court below be requisitioned. Issue notice on I.A.No. 3488/2022 which is application for grant of injunction to the respondents except respondent No.2 who is already representing, on payment of P.F. by both modes within 7 working days returnable within 4 weeks. Counsel for respondent No.2 prays for and is granted 4 weeks time to file reply to the said application. Till next date of hearing, the respondents are restrained from alienating the property in question.
List on 18.07.2022."
Order dated 26.09.2022:-
"Heard on IA No.6368/2022. This Court while admitting the appeal has already passed the interim relief restraining the respondents from alienating the property in question which is mentioned in the plaint. The said order was by-party, therefore, the same is confirmed.
IA No.6368/2022 for interim relief stands disposed off."
10] It is apparent from the aforesaid order that this court has only directed the respondents not to alienate the property in question. Thus, the question before this court is whether the removal of movable items from the house in question would also amount to alienating the property. So far as the word 'alienate' is concerned, in legal parlance, it means to transfer the ownership of property or title to another person. As per Legal Glossary issued by the Government of India, the word "alienate" means 'to transfer one's interest to another'. Similarly, as per Oxford English Dictionary the word "alienate" means, to transfer ownership of (property rights) to another.
11] Thus, a case of contempt can only be made out if it is proved that the ownership of the property in question has been transferred in any manner. In the present case, the petitioner does not know that if
6
the items in the house have actually been sold or otherwise transferred to some other person as the petitioner's contention is that the items are missing from their usual spots but in the considered opinion of this court, removal/shifting of the movable items to some other place would not amount to alienating the same, in view of the same, it cannot be said that the respondents have violated the orders passed by this court which is against the alienation of the property only.
12] Resultantly, the petition being devoid of merits is hereby dismissed.
13] No costs.
14] Also heard on IA No.7298 of 2022 which is an application for appointment of local commissioner to make the inventory of the movable properties as stated therein.
15] On due consideration of the same, this court is of the considered opinion that it is not necessary to embark upon that exercise of appointment of local commissioner to make the inventory of the movable properties, especially when the appellants suit has been dismissed on an application filed under Order 7 rule 11 of CPC and the final disposal of the appeal is also in the offing as the F.A. No.799 of 2022 has already been listed for final hearing in the week commencing 20.02.2023. If the appellant's appeal is allowed, if so advised, she can file such an application before the trial court.
16] Also heard on I.A. No.7297 of 2022, which is an application under Section 151 of CPC seeking direction of maintaining status quo in respect of the properties forming part of the suit.
7
17] Considering the fact that the first appeal is still pending and there is already an order passed by this Court restraining the respondents from alienating the property in question, and the appeal is to be heard in the near future, no such order needs to be passed at this juncture.
18] Accordingly, I.A. No.7297 of 2022 stands disposed of.
19] Accordingly, the contempt petition is hereby disposed of. (Subodh Abhyankar)
Judge
Pankaj