Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • SECTION 4 SICK INDUSTRIAL COMPANIES SPECIAL PROVISIONS ACT 1985
  • Section 7Q and 14B of the Employees' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952; Page 2 of 49 (ii)
  • section 8 of the EPF & MP Act, 1952
  • section 14(B),
  • provisions conferred u/s 8F of EPF & MP Act 1952
  • Section 7-Q
  • section 17, 6 [the Central Provident
  • Employees' Provident Fund & Misc. Provisions Act, 1952 (EPF & MP Act, 1952)
  • sub- section (2) of section 15 4 [or sub- section (5) of section
  • provisions of the Employees' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1948 (for short'the Act')
  • no.4. 2.Rule
  • Section 111 Clause (3) of Indian Companies Act, 1956
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • SECTION 4 SICK INDUSTRIAL COMPANIES SPECIAL PROVISIONS ACT 1985
  • Section 7Q and 14B of the Employees' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952; Page 2 of 49 (ii)
  • section 8 of the EPF & MP Act, 1952
  • section 14(B),
  • provisions conferred u/s 8F of EPF & MP Act 1952
  • Section 7-Q
  • section 17, 6 [the Central Provident
  • Employees' Provident Fund & Misc. Provisions Act, 1952 (EPF & MP Act, 1952)
  • sub- section (2) of section 15 4 [or sub- section (5) of section
  • provisions of the Employees' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1948 (for short'the Act')
  • no.4. 2.Rule
  • Section 111 Clause (3) of Indian Companies Act, 1956
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Vishv Enterprise, is a partnership firm engaged in providing manpower services such as housekeeping, security, and para-medical services. Since 2011, the petitioner has been supplying manpower to respondent No.4, Gujarat State AIDS Control Society (SACS), a society established by the Health & Family Welfare Department of the Government of Gujarat for providing free medical aid to AIDS patients. The petitioner deployed approximately 800 employees under outsourcing agreements with respondent No.4, of which around 350 employees were covered under the Employees' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 ("the Act").

Initially, employees of respondent No.4 were exempted from the Act until March 2015. Subsequently, the Central Government withdrew the exemption and mandated applicability of the Act to employees of SACS and similar organizations, with additional funding to be provided to cover the increased financial burden. Respondent No.4 directed the petitioner to deposit provident fund contributions accordingly, and the petitioner made deposits as funds were made available.

The petitioner participated in the Employees Enrollment Campaign, 2017, a voluntary disclosure scheme allowing employers to declare previously uncovered employees without incurring damages under Section 14B of the Act, subject to certain conditions. The petitioner claimed compliance with the scheme and deposited the requisite amounts. However, respondent No.1 (Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner) issued orders dated 20.05.2019 imposing damages and interest under Sections 14B and 7Q of the Act, alleging non-fulfillment of scheme conditions by the petitioner. The petitioner challenged these orders by filing the present writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, seeking quashing of the impugned orders and related reliefs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned orders passed under Sections 14B and 7Q of the Employees' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, imposing damages and interest on the petitioner, are valid and sustainable.
  2. Whether the petitioner was provided with a reasoned and speaking order in compliance with principles of natural justice before imposition of damages and interest.
  3. Whether the petitioner was entitled to waiver of damages under the Employees Enrollment Campaign, 2017, and whether the conditions of the scheme were fulfilled.
  4. Whether the petitioner should be relegated to the alternative remedy of filing an appeal before the Employees Provident Fund Appellate Tribunal or whether writ jurisdiction is maintainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The impugned orders dated 20.05.2019 passed under Sections 14B and 7Q of the Act are contrary to principles of natural justice as they were passed without assigning any reasons.
  • The petitioner complied with the Employees Enrollment Campaign, 2017, and thus should be entitled to waiver of damages as per the scheme.
  • The delay in depositing the provident fund contributions was due to delayed receipt of funds from respondent No.4, who in turn was awaiting funds from the Central Government.
  • The impugned orders did not consider the petitioner's reply explaining the delay and failed to specify which conditions for waiver were not met.
  • The petitioner sought directions for respondent No.4 to provide necessary funds to comply with the orders of respondent No.1.
  • Reliance was placed on decisions of this Court and the Supreme Court to support the petitioner's contentions regarding waiver of damages and the requirement of reasoned orders.

Respondent No.4's Arguments

  • Respondent No.4 submitted that it repeatedly requested funds from the Government of India to comply with directions of respondent No.1 but had not received any funds to date and thus was unable to provide funds to the petitioner for depositing with respondent No.1.

Respondent No.1's Arguments

  • The impugned orders were passed in accordance with Sections 14B and 7Q of the Act after giving sufficient opportunity to the petitioner.
  • The petition is not maintainable as the petitioner has an efficacious alternative remedy of appeal before the Employees Provident Fund Appellate Tribunal under Section 7-I of the Act, which ought to be exhausted before approaching the High Court.
  • The petitioner failed to fulfill the conditions of the Employees Enrollment Campaign, 2017, specifically failing to remit interest and damages within 15 days of declaration, thereby rendering the declaration void and liable for normal interest and damages.
  • The petitioner defaulted in timely payment of provident fund dues despite repeated opportunities and notices, including 30 proceedings of which the petitioner appeared only on nine occasions.
  • The orders passed are speaking orders based on the enforcement officer's report and applicable legal provisions, and the recovery action including attachment of bank accounts under Section 8F of the Act was lawful.
  • Reliance was placed on various judgments of this Court and the Supreme Court to emphasize the statutory scheme and procedural requirements under the Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Star of Gujarat Textile Mills Ltd. Vs. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Ahmedabad, 1992 (2) GLR 1630 Requirement of speaking orders and application of mind in imposing damages under Section 14B of the EPF Act. The Court relied on this decision to hold that the impugned orders were vague, without proper reasons, and lacked application of mind, making them unsustainable.
Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner PFO and another Vs. Management of RSL Textile India Pvt. Ltd., 2017 3 SCC 110 Legal principles relating to maintainability of writ petitions and availability of alternative statutory remedies under the EPF Act. The Court noted this precedent in considering the preliminary objection regarding the availability of an alternative remedy of appeal before the Appellate Tribunal.
Regional Provident Fund Commissioner Vs. Hooghly Mills Co. Ltd., (2012) 2 SCC 489 Judicial discretion regarding entertaining writ petitions despite existence of alternative statutory remedies. The Court referred to this judgment to acknowledge the principle that ordinarily statutory remedies should be exhausted but writ jurisdiction may be entertained in exceptional circumstances.
Arcot Textile Mills Limited Vs. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner and Others, (2013) 16 SCC 1 Nature of orders under Sections 7A and 7Q of the EPF Act and their appealability. The Court considered this ruling to clarify that orders under Section 7Q are not appealable and the composite nature of such orders under the Act.
RPFC Vs Shibu Metal Workers, 1964-65 (27) FJR 491 Interpretation of the EPF Act in favor of furthering its social security objectives. The Court cited this to emphasize that the Act should be construed to achieve its social welfare purpose.
State Vs Girdhari Lal Bajaj, 1962 II LLJ 46 (Bom. DB) Statutory interpretation harmonizing with the object of the legislation. Referred to support the purposive interpretation of the EPF Act.
Organo Chemical Industries & Anr. V. Union of India & Ors., 1979 (II) LLJ 416 Requirement of speaking orders containing reasons when imposing damages under Section 14B. Emphasized the need for the authority to consider relevant factors and give reasons while imposing damages.
K. A. Subramaniam v. The Commissioner, Regional Provident Fund, Tamil Nadu & Pondicherry States & Anr., 1979 Labour and Industrial Cases 981 Distinction between penalty and damages; requirement to assess and record reasons for imposition of damages. Used to highlight the necessity for reasoned orders and consideration of facts before levying damages.
State of Uttaranchal Vs. Sunilkumar Singh Negi, 2008 (11) SCC 205 Judicial scrutiny of administrative orders and principles of natural justice. Referred to underscore the importance of reasoned orders and fair hearing.
Kranti Association Pvt. Ltd. and Anr. Vs. Masood Ahmed Khan And Others, 2010 (9) SCC 496 Necessity of giving reasons by quasi-judicial authorities for their decisions. Applied to reinforce the principle that orders must be speaking and disclose reasons.
A.K. Kraipak and others vs. Union of India and others, AIR 1970 SC 150 Requirement of reasoned orders by authorities affecting rights of parties. Cited to affirm the blurred distinction between administrative and quasi-judicial orders and the need for reasoned decisions.
Kesava Mills Co. Ltd. and another vs. Union of India and others, AIR 1973 SC 389 Importance of speaking orders and clarity in administrative/quasi-judicial decisions. Referenced to stress that orders must not be obscure but must clearly state reasons.
Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. vs. Shyam Sunder Jhunjhunwala and others, AIR 1961 SC 1669 Requirement of recording reasons to dispel allegations of arbitrariness and mala fides. Invoked to highlight the necessity for reasoned decisions to withstand judicial scrutiny.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court observed that the impugned orders passed by respondent No.1 under Sections 14B and 7Q of the Act were devoid of proper reasoning and were passed without due application of mind. Although the petitioner was given opportunities to be heard and filed replies explaining the delay in payment and compliance with the Employees Enrollment Campaign, 2017, the orders merely referenced the petitioner's reply without substantive consideration of its contents.

The Court noted that the enforcement officer's report and the impugned orders found that the petitioner failed to meet the conditions of the Employees Enrollment Campaign, specifically the timely remittance of interest and damages within 15 days, which rendered the petitioner's declaration under the scheme invalid. Consequently, normal interest and damages were levied.

However, the Court emphasized the established legal principle that orders imposing damages under Section 14B must be "speaking orders" containing clear reasons and consideration of relevant factors such as the number and frequency of defaults, period of delay, and the amount involved. The Court cited precedents illustrating the necessity for reasoned orders to ensure fairness and transparency.

Given that the impugned orders lacked detailed reasons and merely made vague statements without addressing the petitioner's explanations, the Court found them unsustainable in law. The Court also addressed the preliminary objection regarding the availability of alternative remedies, noting that while ordinarily appeals before the Employees Provident Fund Appellate Tribunal should be exhausted, the present case warranted judicial interference due to the defective nature of the orders.

Holding and Implications

The Court made the rule absolute and quashed and set aside the impugned orders dated 20.05.2019 passed under Sections 14B and 7Q of the Employees' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, as well as the consequential order dated 14.06.2019 under Section 8F.

The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioner is relieved from the recovery of damages and interest based on the impugned orders, which were found to be legally unsustainable due to absence of reasons and application of mind. No costs were imposed. The Court did not set any new precedent but reaffirmed the settled legal principles regarding the necessity of reasoned speaking orders by quasi-judicial authorities and adherence to procedural fairness under the Act.

    VISHV ENTERPRISE v. ASSISTANT PROVIDENT FUND COMMISSIONER

    NEUTRAL CITATION

    C/SCA/11091/2019 JUDGMENT DATED: 17/10/2023 undefined

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

    R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11091 of 2019

    FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:

    HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BHARGAV D. KARIA Sd/-

    ==========================================================

    1 Whether Reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment ? No
    2 To be referred to the Reporter or not ? No
    3 Whether their Lordships wish to see the fair copy of the judgment ? No
    4 Whether this case involves a substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution of India or any order made thereunder ? No

    ==========================================================

    VISHV ENTERPRISE

    Versus

    ASSISTANT PROVIDENT FUND COMMISSIONER

    ========================================================== Appearance:

    MR DIPAK R DAVE(1232) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1 MR HARSHEEL D SHUKLA(6158) for the Respondent(s) No. 3 MS E.SHAILAJA(2671) for the Respondent(s) No. 1 NOTICE SERVED for the Respondent(s) No. 5 SERVED BY RPAD (N) for the Respondent(s) No. 2 SWAPNESHWAR GOUTAM(9051) for the Respondent(s) No. 4 ==========================================================

    CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BHARGAV D. KARIA

    Date : 17/10/2023

    ORAL JUDGMENT

    Page 1 of 49

    1.Heard learned advocate Mr.Dipak R. Dave for the petitioner, learned advocate Mr.Harsheel D. Shukla for the respondent no.3, learned advocate Ms.E.Shailaja for the respondent no.1, learned advocate Mr.Swapneshwar Goutam for the respondent no.4.

    2.Rule returnable forthwith. Learned advocates appearing for the respective respondents waives service of notice of rule. 3.Having regard to the controversy in narrow compass, with the consent of the learned advocates of the respective parties, the matter is taken up for hearing.

    4.By this petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India the petitioner has prayed for the following reliefs:

    "(A) This Hon'ble Court may be pleased to issue a writ of mandamus and/or a writ in the nature of mandamus and/or any other appropriate writ, order or direction

    (i) to quash and set aside two separate orders both dated 20.05.2019 passed by the respondent no.1 under Section 7Q and 14B of the Employees' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952;

    Page 2 of 49

    (ii) to hold and declare that action initiated by respondent No.1 against the petitioner is nothing but malicious in law and vexatious and accordingly be pleased to quash and set aside the same by awarding the exemplary cost against the respondent No.1;

    (iii) to direct respondent No.2 and 3 to immediately look into affairs of respondent No.1 and be pleased to direct appropriate action in the matter against respondent no.1;

    IN THE ALTERNATIVE

    (iv) to direct respondent No.4 to immediately provide funds for the purpose of depositing the same with the respondent No.1 in pursuance of two separate orders dated 20.05.2019 passed under Sections 7Q and 14B of the Act;

    8(v) to quash and set aside order/ notice dated 02.06.2019 passed by the respondent No.1 under Section 8F of the Act;

    (B) Pending the admission, hearing and final disposal of the petition, this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to stay the execution, implementation and operation of the impugned orders dated 20.05.2019 at Annexure-A passed by respondent No.1 under Section 7Q and 14B of the Act; (BB) pending the admission, hearing and final disposal of the petition, this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to

    Page 3 of 49

    stay the execution, implementation and operation of order/notice dated 02.06.2019 passed by the respondent No.1.

    (C) Pending the admission, hearing and final disposal of the present petition this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to direct respondent No.1 not to take any against pursuance dated the of coercive action petitioner in the impugned orders 20.05.2019 passed by it under Sections 70 and 14B of the Act;

    (D) Pending the admission, hearing and final disposal of the present petition, respondent Nos. 2 and 3 may be directed to take appropriate action against respondent No.1 and action taken report may be directed to be placed on record of this case;

    (E) Any other and further relief or reliefs to which this Hon'ble Court deemed fit, in the interest of justice; may kindly be granted;" 5.The brief facts of the case are as under:

    5.1. The petitioner is a partnership firm. The petitioner started its operations in the year 2004. The petitioner is providing manpower service for the purpose of housekeeping, security service, para-medical service etc. It is the case of the petitioner that the

    Page 4 of 49

    petitioner has been engaged by respondent No.4 for the purpose of providing officers, divisional assistants, contractual laboratory consultants, counselors, technicians and other staff working under NACP- III. Thus, some of the work to be undertaken by respondent No.4 society has been outsourced to the petitioner. For the purpose of such outsourcing, agreement has been entered into between the petitioner and respondent No.4.

    5.2. In the year 2011, petitioner was engaged for the purpose of supplying manpower to the respondent No.4 through outsourcing and since then from time- to-time, agreement entered into between the petitioner and respondent No.4 has been extended. First such agreement was entered on 30.07.2011. Thereafter on the same terms and conditions, agreement was extended. It is submitted that by letter dated 27.04.2018, extension has been granted until new agency is being appointed.

    5.3 Respondent No.4 is a society established by Health & Family Welfare Department of Government of Gujarat. The society has been established for the benevolent purpose of providing free medical aid to the persons

    Page 5 of 49

    suffering with AIDS for which grant is also provided by the Central Government and is fully controlled by the State of Gujarat. 5.4.For the purpose of carrying out its activity, respondent No.4 entered into an agreement with the petitioner by which certain officers and para- medical staff are required to be deployed by the petitioner. It is the case of the petitioner that salary and other benefits to be paid to such employees are being reimbursed by the respondent No.4 to the petitioner. For the purpose of providing manpower through outsourcing, about 800 such employees have been deployed by the petitioner in the establishment of respondent No.4. Out of such 800 employees, about 350 employees are covered under the provisions of the Employees' Provident Fund and

    Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1948 (for short'the Act') since other employees than such 350 employees are drawing salary more than Rs.15,000/- per month.

    5.5.It is the case of the petitioner that earlier i.e. until March, 2015, by Notification issued under Section 16 (2) of the Act, Central Government had exempted employees

    Page 6 of 49

    working in the establishment of the respondent No.4 as also in such similar establishments as National AIDS Control Organisation (NACO) and State AIDS Control Society (SACS) were exempted from the provisions of the Act and exemption were being granted from time-to-time until 31.03.2015. Central Government thereafter decided that since NACO and SACS are carrying out benevolent activities and since the provisions of the Act is to provide social security, it is considered appropriate that the provisions of the Act be made applicable to the employees working under NACO and SACS. It has been decided that additional burden being accrued by virtue of applicability of the Act shall be provided to respective organizations. It was conveyed to all concerned by the concerned Ministry that since total outlay on account of regulation of contractual staff/ employees by the society is Rs.450 Crore, paying of Employees Provident Fund at the rate of 12.58 will incur an additional amount of Rs.56 Crore per annum. It is mentioned in the letter of concerned Ministry dated 03.02.2016 that the amount cannot be provided for within the existing budget, therefore an additional

    Page 7 of 49

    outlay to this extent was requested to be provided at the stage of final estimates for NACO during the current financial year. Thereafter by letter dated 02.05.2016, the concerned Ministry informed all Divisional Heads of NACO to extend the provisions of the Act and to provide statutory liability to the concerned employees drawing salary below Rs.15,000/- per month.

    5.6. Pursuant to the said letter, respondent No.4 addressed letter dated 03.10.2016 to the petitioner inter alia directing the petitioner to prepare necessary chart and the amount to be deposited with the EPF Authorities.

    5.7. Pursuant to the letter dated 03.10.2016 of respondent No.4, certain clarification was asked by the petitioner from respondent No.4. Petitioner thereafter immediately provided data of all concerned employees drawing salary below Rs.15,000/- per month and the amount which was required to be deposited with Provident Fund Authorities.

    5.8.Thereafter as and when funds were made available by the Central Government to the

    Page 8 of 49

    respondent No.4, respondent No.4 in a phased manner provided funds to the petitioner for the purpose of depositing the said amount with respondent No.1. It is the case of the petitioner that since the Act came to be made applicable to the employees working under SACS and NACO with effect from April, 2015, difference of amount from 01.04.2015 to 31.03.2017 was required to be deposited with the respondent No.1.

    5.9. In the meanwhile respondent No.3 came out with a scheme by which employers were asked to voluntarily come forward and declare details of all such employees who were though entitled for the provident fund membership but could not be covered for any reason and it was provided in the scheme that Central Government shall not levy any damages under Section 14B of the Act upon such disclosure. In fact, the damages which were required to be levied under Section 14B of the Act for such disclosure was restricted to Rs.1/-. It is the case of the petitioner that though initially the time limit for such declaration was to be made from 01.01.2017 to 31.03.2017, the said scheme of disclosure was extended until June, 2017. Vide letter dated

    Page 9 of 49

    04.01.2017 certain clarifications in pursuance of the said scheme were made by the EPFO Head Office, New Delhi.

    5.10. The petitioner made declaration with regard to the uncovered employees in May, 2017 with the respondent No.1 and it was specifically conveyed to respondent No.1 that declaration may kindly be considered under the Employees Enrollment Campaign, 2017, under which there was promise by the Central Government not to levy any damages.

    5.11.Respondent No.4 provided funds to the petitioner for the purpose of depositing provident fund with the respondent No.1 in phased manner. No sooner the funds have been made available to the petitioner, by preparing challans, the said amount of provident fund came to be deposited with respondent No.1 by the petitioner.

    5.12. It is the case of the petitioner that after the amount came to be deposited, the petitioner received notice under Section 14B of the Act. In pursuance of the said notice, petitioner appeared before respondent No.1 and pointed out that petitioner has in fact

    Page 10 of 49

    deposited amount of the employees working under respondent No.4 under the Employees Enrollment Campaign, 2017 and there is no provision to levy damages under the said scheme. The petitioner also pointed out that combined notice has been issued by the respondent No.1 wherein employees other than one who are working with respondent No.4 are also included while assessing such damages. In fact, for the employees other than who are working under respondent No.4, separate proceedings under Section 14B and 7Q of the Act were initiated and for those employees, payments are already made. The petitioner has already paid amount of Rs.03,28,061/-. The amount of Rs.34,55,118/- which is under Section 14B and 70 of the Act is with respect to the employees working under respondent No.4.

    5.13. The petitioner also pointed out to the respondent No.1 that employees working with respondent No.4 deployed by the petitioner and who enrolled under the Employees Enrollment Campaign, 2017 are enrolled as new employees under the Act. The declaration made under the Employees Enrollment Campaign, 2017 is therefore not subjected to any proceedings

    Page 11 of 49

    under Section 14B of the Act. 6.Learned advocate Mr.Dipak Dave for the petitioner submitted that the impugned order passed by the respondent authority under Section 14B and 7Q of the Act is contrary to the principles of natural justice as the same is passed without assigning any reason.

    7. Learned advocate Mr.Dave in support of his submissions referred to and relied upon the decision of the Division Bench of this Court in case of Star of Gujarat Textile Mills Ltd. Vs. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Ahmedabad reported in 1992 (2) GLR 1630 as well as the decision of this Court in case of

    Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner PFO and another Vs. Management of RSL Textile India Pvt. Ltd. through its Director reported in

    2017 3 SCC 110.

    8. It was further submitted by learned advocate Mr.Dave that this Court by order dated 19.01.2022 has also considered the alternative prayer in para 8(iv) whereby the direction is sought from the respondent no.4 to provide the funds for the purpose of depositing the same with the respondent no.1

    Page 12 of 49

    as per the impugned orders. However, thereafter no further instructions were received from the respondent no.4 and accordingly the matter has remained pending.

    9. It was further submitted that as per the provision of the scheme, the petitioner has complied with the condition but belatedly. It was submitted that the funds were to be received from the Central Government to the respondent no.4-Gujarat State AIDS Control Society who has to provide the funds to the petitioner so as to deposit with the respondent no.1. It was therefore submitted that as soon as the funds towards the employers and employees contribution is received on withdrawal of the exemption, the same were deposited with the respondent no.1 and there was no intention on the part of the petitioner to cause any delay in making the payment as required on withdrawal of the exemption and therefore, the impugned orders passed by the respondent authority without considering such fact and mentioning vague statement that "certain conditions were required to be met to give the waiver of the damages" is only mentioned in the impugned order without specifying as to which

    Page 13 of 49

    condition was to be met and which condition is not fulfilled by the petitioner to get the waiver as per the scheme dated 17.11.2017 (page 60 Annexure J of the petition).

    10. On the other hand, learned advocate Mr.Goutam appearing for the respondent no.4 submitted that the respondent no.4 has time and again requested the respondent no.3- Government of India to provide the funds to comply with the direction of the respondent no.1, but till date no further funds are received and therefore the respondent no.4 is unable to give the funds to the petitioner so as to comply with the order of the respondent no.1.

    11. Learned advocate Ms.E.Shailaja for the respondent no.1-authority submitted that the respondent no.1 has passed the impugned order in view of the provisions of section 14B and 7Q of the Act. It was further submitted that there is a preliminary objection with regard to maintainability of the petition as the petitioner has alternative efficacious remedy to file an appeal challenging the impugned orders before the appellate authority. It was further submitted that while passing the

    Page 14 of 49

    impugned order respondent no.1 has considered the reply of the petitioner and thereafter the impugned order is passed. In support of his submissions reliance was placed on the following averments in the affidavit-in-reply filed on behalf of the respondent nos.1 and

    2.

    "2. The Employees' Provident Fund & Misc. Provisions Act, 1952 (EPF & MP Act, 1952) is a legislation for providing social security to employees working in any establishment engaging 20 or more persons on any day. It provides for compulsory deduction of provident fund from employees and a contribution from the employer which is deposited in the worker's account in the EPF office.

    Similarly, the Act, also provides for providing insurance and pensionary benefits to the employees. The provident fund and other contributions have to be deposited by the employer by the 15th of the next month in which the employee has worked in the establishment and the dues become payable to him, because the worker has already performed the employment upto last day of the previous month. The contributions have to be deposited by the

    employer/establishment only after beneficiary worker has already worked and thus earned this amount in terms of the contract of employment and the

    Page 15 of 49

    provisions of the Act. As such, any efforts by the employer to deny employees the legitimate dues which they have rightfully earned in terms of the provisions of the Act, need to be looked upon with suspicion, whatever the reason given by such employer/establishment. In case of failure to deposit the legitimate dues of workers, the EPFO under section 7-A of the Act initiate recovery action for the purpose of compelling the employer to deposit the legitimate dues of the worker. Through a quasi-judicial process, the dues of the workers under section 7A of the Act is assessed and the

    employer/establishment is asked to deposit the amount.

    Subsequently, after deposit of the principal amount, action is initiated to levy penalty and damages under section 7Q and Section-14 of the Act to provide for the interest on the delayed payment by the employer and also act as deterrence for them.

    It is often seen that

    employer/establishment resort to filing the petition in the Court at once the recovery process has been started, which in any case start after default of the legitimate dues have been committed by such employer. The employers file such cases with a view to defeat the object of the social security legislation, which provides for a lump sum payment of the employees on their retirement so that they can spend their retired life with some element of comfort.

    Page 16 of 49

    The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter RPFC Vs Shibu Metal Workers, 1964-65

    (27) FJR 491 upheld that in construing the material provisions of the Act, if two views are reasonably possible, the courts should prefer the view which helps the achievement and furtherance of the object. In the matter of State Vs Girdhari Lal Bajaj, 1962 II LLJ46(Bom.DB) the Hon'ble Court observed that when there is doubt about their meaning, it is to be understood in the sense in which it best harmonizes with the subject of the enactment and the object which the legislature has in view. It is, therefore, prayed that the Hon'ble Court may kindly consider the purpose behind the legislation (EPF & MP Act, 1952) as enumerated above while considering the petition of the employer.

    3. Before I deal with the petition parawise hereinunder I hereby take a preliminary objection regarding challenge in the petition to the orders dated 20/05/2019 passed under Section 14B and 7Q of the EPF & MP Act, 1952 by the Respondent No.1 along with the Sec8F order dated 14/06/2019 (issued pursuant to the aforestated order dated 20/05/2019) by way of a direct petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India before this Hon'ble Court mainly on the following counts:

    The respondent No.1 passed the order dated 20/05/2019 under Section 14B & 7Q after giving sufficient opportunities to the petitioner herein for putting across its case in compliance to the provisions of the EPF & MP Act 1952, now if at all the petitioner desires to

    Page 17 of 49

    challenge the order so passed it ought to have filed an Appeal under Section 7-I before the Employees Provident Fund Appellate Tribunal being a statutory, alternative, efficacious remedy available under the Statute to the petitioner and only after exhausting such a statutory appeal can the petitioner move this Hon'ble Court. The same has been laid down by this Hon'ble Court in SCA. No.30921 of 2007 in the matter between Swati Enterprises v. APFC which was followed in SCA No.7303 of 2008 in the case of Cookvel Foods(I) Pvt. Ltd & Anr v. Union Of India and Ors as also in SCA 1962 of 2013 in the case of Deeya Gems v. Comm.Employees Provident Fund…. where even the Letters patent Appeal N0. 970/2013 filed by Deeya Gems was withdrawn vide order dated 13.08.2013.

    Similar view was also taken recently while rejecting a direct petition being SCA 2988 of 2015 filed by BSNL while upholding the above said preliminary objection of the respondent PF authority. Again in SCA 5801 of 1998 and SCA 8336 of 1998, this Hon'ble Court vide Judgment and order dated 21.03.2016 upheld the above preliminary objection of the PF authority while relegating the petitioners therein to file appeal before EPFAT under section 7I of EPF & MP Act, 1952. The respondent is also seeking reliance on a judgement and order of the Hon'ble the Apex court in the case reported in (2012) 2 SCC 489 (Regl. Provident Fund Commissioner Vs. Hooghly Mills Co.Ltd.) which has settled the law regarding entertaining the petition in writ jurisdiction despite non-availing of the alternative, efficacious, statutory remedy under the EPF & MP Act. In

    Page 18 of 49

    fact under para 21 of the very judgement the Hon'ble Apex Court has opined as under:

    "….The impugned order was passed in the year 2004 and thereafter the writ petition was entertained by the two Benches of the High Court and after that the matter is pending before us. Now we are in 2012. To dismiss the order of two Benches of the High Court interalia on the ground that the writ petition was entertained despite the existence of a statutory remedy and then send it back to the remedy of appeal after a period of eight years, would not, in our judgement, be a correct exercise of judicial discretion. However, we are of the opinion that normally the statutory remedy of appeal should be availed of in a situation like this." Reliance is also placed on another judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court given in the case of:

    Arcot Textile Mills Limited Vs. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner and Others reported in (2013) 16 SCC 1 wherein, under para 21, it was held as under:

    "At this stage, it is necessary to clarify the position of law which does arise in certain situations. The competent authority under the Act while determining the monies due from the employee shall be required to conduct an inquiry and pass an order. An order under Section 7-A is an order that determines the liability of the employer under the provisions of the Act and while determining the liability the competent authority offers an opportunity of hearing to the establishment concerned. At this stage, the delay in payment of the dues and

    Page 19 of 49

    component of interest are determined. It is a composite order. To elaborate, it is an order passed under Sections 7- A and 7-Q together. Such an order shall be amenable to appeal under section 7-

    I. The same is true of any composite order a facet of which is amenable to appeal and Section 7-I of the Act. But, if for some reason when the authority chooses to pass an independent order under Section 7-Q the same is not appealable."

    Hence, on this ground alone this petition requires to be dismissed in limine.

    4. At the outset, I deny all the averments and contentions taken by the petitioner in the petition except those which are specifically admitted by me hereinafter. No dealing of any of the averments/contentions

    5. I humbly submit that the petition deserves to be dismissed since number of mis-statements have been made and the petitioner has tried to misguide this Hon'ble Court by making incorrect and false statements and on the said ground alone, the present petition deserves to be rejected.

    6. The reply affidavit herein is filed only with a view to bring forth correct facts before this Hon'ble Court which led to the passing of the impugned orders dtd. 20/05/2019 and order dated 14/06/2019 issued under Sec 8F.

    7. The deponent briefly states herein below the facts as it emerges from the

    Page 20 of 49

    record of office of the deponent which led to issuances the orders impugned:

    The petitioner a covered establishment vide Code No. P.F. No. GJ/AHD/50712 defaulted in complying with the provisions of the EPF & MP Act, 1952. This led the office of the deponent to initiate various steps in conformity with the provisions of law against the petitioner to ensure compliance.As part of one such step undertaken by the office of the deponent necessary proceedings were initiated u/s 14B and 7-Q vide notice No:

    GJ/AHD/0050712/000ENF514/ DAMAGES/1605

    DATED 27/11/2017 (Annexed hereto as Annexure Z1) for the period 01/11/2015 to 31/10/2017 for amount of Rs. 2386283 /-(Damages) and Rs. 1396896/- (Interest) (Total of Rs. 3783179/-) was issued to the establishment to appear either in person or through authorized representative on 06/12/2017 to show cause as to why damages u/s 14B and Interest u/s 7Q of the Said Act may not be levied and recovered for the default committed in delaying in remittances. A letter dated 01/01/2018 was received from the petitioner establishment that the notice dated 27/11/2017 u/s 14B and 7Q was not received by them. Subsequently the copy of the same was handed over to the establishment in the proceedings.

    The petitioner establishment vide letter dated 02/02/2018 submitted that they had deposited some dues under the Employees Enrollment Campaign 2017 and thereby penalty u/s 14B and 7Q of the

    Page 21 of 49

    Act should not be levied on them in r/o the dues deposited under the Employees Enrollment Campaign.

    Further the petitioner establishment vide letter dated 12/2/2018 informed that the petitioner establishment has already paid Rs. 3,28,061/- u/s 14B and 7Q for the period 01/11/2015 to 31/10/2017 in reference to notice dated 27/11/2017 and that the remaining amount of Rs. 34,55,118/- was related to the dues deposited under Employees Enrollment Campaign 2017.The office of the deponent has issued a letter to the enforcement section-IV to depute area enforcement officer to verify the details/representation submitted by petitioner establishment as per GAZETTE Notification issued by the head office in respect of EMPLOYMENT ENFORLLMENT CAMPAIGN- 2017.The Enforcement Officer vide report dtd. 29.10.2018 submitted as under:

    1 There are three conditions stated in the notification to make the declaration under scheme valid. The employer shall within 15 days from the date of furnishing declaration remit :

    (i) The employer's contribution payable in accordance with provisions and employees' contribution deducted and

    (ii) Interest payable in accordance with section 7Q of the Act and

    (iii) Damages as per para 8(b) of the notification.

    (iv) Further in para (6) of notification, it has been stated that if all the above three conditions are not fulfilled then, the declaration made under employees' Enrolment Campaign,

    Page 22 of 49

    2017 shall be deemed to have not been made under the scheme. This is also clarified in FAQ at point no. 11 &12.

    (v) Since the petitioner establishment has neither fulfilled the

    condition (2) nor the condition(3) stated above under Employees' Enrolment Campaign, 2017, hence the declaration made by the petitioner establishment may be deemed to have not been made under the Employees' Enrolment Campaign,

    2017.

    Therefore, in light of the notification and the FAQ, the petitioner establishment is liable for interest and damages at normal rate as per the provision of the Act and Schemes framed under it.

    Moreover under the Employees Enrollment Campaign 2017 an employer, whether already covered or yet to be covered, can enroll employees who remained un- enrolled for any reason between 01.04.2009 and 31.12.2016 by making a declaration of such employees during the campaign period.

    Also the salient features of the Employee's Enrolment Campaign, 2017 are as follows:

    (i) The Employees' share of contribution if declared by the employer as not deducted, shall stand waived.

    (ii) The damages to be paid by the employer in respect of the employees for whom declaration has been made under this campaign shall be at the rate of Rupee 1(one) per annum.

    Page 23 of 49

    (iii) No administrative charges shall be collected from the employer in respect of the contribution made under the declaration.

    (iv) A declaration can be made under the campaign for the period for which no inquiry under section 7A has been initiated.

    (v) if the employer fails to pay within 15 days of the date of making the declaration, the dues, interest and damages payable by him in respect of the declaration made under this campaign, such declaration shall be have not been made under this campaign. In this regard a section 82A related to Special Provision in respect of Employees' Enrollment Campaign,2017 of EPF Scheme 1952 was inserted in EPF Scheme 1952 (Annexed hereto as Annexure Z2).

    Futher the competent authority issued adjournment notice to the petitioner establishment from time to time to represent the case/matter on 06/12/2017, 22/12/2017, 09/01/2018, 17/01/2018, 02/02/2018, 12/02/2018, 22/02/2018, 21/03/2018, 16/04/2018, 26/04/2018, 11/05/2018, 25/05/2018, 11/06/2018, 25/06/2018, 09/07/2018, 27/07/2018, 14/08/2018, 31/08/2018, 17/09/2018, 03/10/2018, 18/10/2018, 12/11/2018, 04/12/2018, 28/12/2018, 21/01/2019, 04/02/2019, 19/02/2019, 07/03/2019, 08/04/2019, 30/04/2019. The petitioner establishment vide their letter dated 03/05/2019 submitted that they have paid Rs. 91,912/- on 09/02/2018 and Rs. 2,51,234/- on dated 30/04/2019. And that the amount of damages and interest totaling Rs. 34,53,667/- pertained to the declaration made under Employees Enrollment

    Page 24 of 49

    Campaign. On 30/04/2019 the competent assessing officer (RPFC-I) decided to close the inquiry and dispose the case on the following ground.

    The petitioner establishment has submitted that the delayed contribution made were as per the Employees Enrollment Campaign 2017 and where in there was provision not to levy damages, However it was found that certain conditions were required to be met to get the waiver of the damages.After examining the matter it was submitted by the Area Enforcement Officer that the petitioner establishment has failed to fulfill all the conditions required for waiver of the damages as per the Employees Enrollment Campaign 2017.Therefore the delayed payments, interest and damages will be levied on the petitioner establishment as levied in the normal cases of delayed remittances.

    Further even after having got sufficient opportunities the petitioner establishment failed to even appear in the case but the petitioner establishment is not interested in pursuing the case and contesting the matter.

    Moreover out of 30 proceedings/hearings held in this matter the representative of establishment. appeared only on 9 occasions.

    This office has issued a speaking order

    Page 25 of 49

    vide No: GJ/AHD/DAM/C-22/50712/730 DATED 20/05/2019 and vide No: GJ/AHD/DAM/C- 22/50712/731 DATED 20/05/2019. And same has been sent to the petitioner establishment on their registered mail address on 20/05/2019.

    On receipt of acknowledgement in respect of above speaking order and owing to non deposition of outstanding dues as per the said order this office has issued a notice u/s 8F of the act to their registered bank i.e. DENA BANK, RAJMAHEL ROAD BRANCH, MEHSANA Vide Letter No: GJ/AHD/DAM/C- 22/50712/1142 dated 14/06/2019 and acknowledgement in respect of the same has been received herewith from dena bank and from the petitioner establishment also on 26/06/2019.

    Under the facts and circumstances narrated above as also the applicable provisions in the facts of the case the petition is required to be dismissed with costs.

    8. So far as averments made by the petitioner in the Para 1 are concerned, I have no comments to offer being formal in nature.

    9. So far as to the averments made by the Petitioner in Para 2 are concerned, the same are denied in toto as far as it relates to the orders passed by the office of the deponent against the petitioner are concerned. It is further reiterated that A notice no. GJ/AHD/0050712/000/Enf 514/Damages/1605 dated 27/11/2017 for levy of Damages and Interest amount of Rs.3783179/-(Damages-Rs. 2386283/- and Interest- Rs.1396896/-) on account of late payment of PF dues made during the period 01/11/2015 to 31/10/2017 was issued to the

    Page 26 of 49

    employer ( petitioner establishment herein ) to show cause why damages and interest on such belated payment be not levied as envisaged under section 14 B and 7Q of the Act. A month-wise and account- wise statement of late payments was also annexed to the show cause notice to enable the petitioner establishment to cross verify its records. The employer was given sufficient opportunities in the interest of Natural Justice during proceedings held on 06/12/2017, 22/12/2017, 09/01/2018, 17/01/2018, 02/02/2018, 12/02/2018, 22/02/2018, 21/03/2018, 16/04/2018, 26/04/2018, 11/05/2018, 25/05/2018, 11/06/2018, 25/06/2018, 09/07/2018, 27/07/2018, 14/08/2018, 31/08/2018, 17/09/2018, 03/10/2018, 18/10/2018, 12/11/2018, 04/12/2018, 28/12/2018, 21/01/2019, 04/02/2019, 19/02/2019, 07/03/2019, 08/04/2019, 30/04/2019. The contention of the petitioner establishment relating to waiver of amount of damages had not been considered because the petitioner establishment did not fulfill the terms and conditions of the Employees' Enrolment Campaign 2017 according to which if the employer fails to pay within 15 days of the date of making the declaration, the dues, interest and damages payable by him in respect of the declaration made under this campaign, such declaration shall be deemed to have not been made under this campaign.

    10. So far as to the averments made by the petitioner in Para 3.1 TO 3.8 are concerned I have no comments to offer for the presents, though it reserves its right to raise appropriate contentions if and when any of the averments and assertions of the petitioner made in the aforesaid paras transpire to me false and/ or

    Page 27 of 49

    incorrect based on the records that might be available with the office of the deponent.

    11. So far as to the averments made by the petitioner in Para 3.9 and 3.10 are

    concerned it is to state and submit that based on petitioner establishment's submission in the inquiry proceeding regarding no liability of damages for dues deposited under Employees enrollment Campaign an Enforcement Officer was also deputed to verfy the facts of the case. The Enforcement Officer vide report Dt 29/10/2018 submitted that the petitioner establishment has neither fulfilled the condition of remitting Interest payable in accordance with section 7Q of the Act and Damages as per para 8(b) of the notification (2) within 15 days from the date of furnishing declaration hence the declaration made by the petitioner establishment may be deemed to have not been made under the Employees' Enrolment Campaign, 2017 and therefore in light of the same, petitioner establishment is liable for interest and damages at normal rate as per the provision of the Act and Schemes framed under it.

    It is to further state and submit that the petitioner establishment's representative asked for the copy of the Enforcement Officer's report in the proceedings held on 19/02/2019 and the same was provided to the representative. No Counter reply/comments were received from the petitioner establishment and the petitioner establishment even failed to appear in the proceedings after 19/02/2019. Also the salient features of the Employee's Enrolment Campaign, 2017 are as follows:

    (i) The Employees' share of

    Page 28 of 49

    contribution if declared by the employer as not deducted, shall stand waived.

    (ii) The damages to be paid by the employer in respect of the employees for whom declaration has been made under this campaign shall be at the rate of Rupee 1(one) per annum.

    (iii) No administrative charges shall be collected from the employer in respect of the contribution made under the declaration.

    (iv) A declaration can be made under the campaign for the period for which no inquiry under section 7A has been initiated.

    (v) If the employer fails to pay within 15 days of the date of making the declaration, the dues, interest and damages payable by him in respect of the declaration made under this campaign, such declaration shall be have not been made under this campaign. Further as per sub Paragraph (3) of Para 82A-Special Provision in respect of Employees' Enrollment Campaign,2017 of EPF Scheme 1952 " The employer shall, within fifteen days from the date of furnishing the declaration referred to in subparagraph (2), remit the employer's contribution payable in accordance with the provisions of this Scheme and the employee's contribution deducted from the employee's wages along with interest payable in accordance with section 7Q of the Act and damages : Provided that employer shall not be required to pay the employee's contribution if the same has not been deducted from

    Page 29 of 49

    the wages of the employee. Further as per sub Paragraph (6) of Para 82A of EPF Scheme 1952 " If the employer fails to remit the contribution, interest and damages payable by him as referred to in sub-paragraph (3), then, the declaration sent by the employer under sub-paragraph (2) shall be deemed to have not been made by such employer under this Scheme." Thereby, since the petitioner establishment failed to remit the interest and damages payable by it in respect of the declaration made under the campaign such

    declaration was deemed to have not been made under this campaign and accordingly damages and interest were levied on the petitioner establishment and a well reasoned, speaking order was passed by the competent quasi - judicial authority taking into account the facts of the case, applicable provisions and submission of the appellant petitioner

    establishment.

    12. So far as to the averments made by the petitioner in Para 3.11 are concerned, I have no comments to offer. Further though assuming without admitting the say of the petitioner, irrespective of the availability of funds the petitioner was under obligations to fulfill its liability as a covered establishment and employer in consonance with the provisions of EPF & MP Act, 1952 and the Schemes framed there under from time to time in a timely manner.

    Page 30 of 49

    13. So far as to the averments made by the petitioner in Para 3.12 and 3.13 the same are denied in toto . It is further reiterated that the petitioner establishment is independently covered with P.F. No. GJ/AHD/50712. Hence, it was the responsibility of the petitioner establishment to deposit the PF dues as per EPF & MP Act within 15 days of the close of every wage month and as per the terms and conditions of the Employees Enrolment Campaign 2017 since the petitioner establishment failed to remit the interest and damages payable by it in respect of the declaration made under the campaign such declaration was deemed to have not been made under this campaign and accordingly damages and interest were levied on the petitioner establishment and a well reasoned, speaking order was passed by the quasi - judicial authority taking into account the facts of the case, applicable provision and submission of the petitioner establishment.

    Further no such submission

    regarding employees being engaged by the petitioner establishment. at Gujarat state aids control society was made by the petitioner establishment during the proceedings before the Inquiry Authority of the office of the deponent and hence, the said contention being now taken for the first time is a clear after thought merely made to escape the statutory liability.

    14. So far as to the averments made in para 3.14 is concerned the same are denied in toto. It is to further state and submit that totally false and baseless averments are being made by the petitioner before the Hon'ble Court. The petitioner has not approached this Hon'ble Court with clean hands. The petitioner establishment was

    Page 31 of 49

    provided reasonable opportunities and all the submissions made by the petitioner establishment were taken into account and a judicious order was passed as per law. Out of 30 proceedings held in this matter the representative of establishment appeared on 9 occasions. Annexed hereto as Annexure Z3

    is a copy of the order sheets of proceeding before the Inquiry Authority. Moreover, it is to be appreciated that admittedly at no stage when the inquiry was pending before the competent authority did the respondent raise the contention of absence of "mens rea" in the defaults committed by the respondent and the said ground is being taken for the first time before this Hon'ble Court which ought not be permitted under the aforesaid glaring facts as stated above . Further, as per Employee's Enrolment Campaign, 2017 if the employer establishment fails to pay within 15 days of the date of making the declaration, the dues, interest and damages payable by him in respect of the declaration made under this campaign, such declaration shall be considered as one that have not been made under this campaign and accordingly damages and interest were levied on the petitioner establishment and a well reasoned speaking order was issued by the quasi-judicial authority after considering all the facts and submissions raised by the employer during the proceeding u/s 14B. Further no such submission regarding employees being engaged by the appellant establishment. at Gujarat state aids control society was made by the appellant establishment during the proceedings ever before the competent authority. Hence, it is denied actions against the petitioner have been taken for any veiled reasons or object or to harass the petitioner establishment. The petitioner is required to be put to strict proof qua his allegations made in this

    Page 32 of 49

    para. Moreover EPF & MP Act is meant to provide social & financial security to the downtrodden section of the society at the time of their retirement, death during service, Medical treatment etc. The EPF & MP Act is a social welfare legislation under which the employer is duty bound to make the provident fund contribution on time and in case of any default the employer is liable to pay damages and any delay in payment of amount u/s 6 of the EPF Act causes a loss to Fund being administered by the office of the respondent PF authority and its functionaries and ultimately to the beneficiary of the schemes under the EPF & MP Act . Thus, it is submitted that the impugned orders issued are just and within the mandate of section 14B and 7Q of the EPF and MP Act 1952. Further it is to state that owing to the non-compliance to the provisions of the EPF and MP Act 1952 by the Petitioner the Respondents were constrained to pass the appropriate consequent orders for recovery also under challenge in the present petition. The petitioner company is whiling away its time and money in vexatious litigation to obtain favorable orders by misleading the Hon'ble Judicial/ quasi judicial Forums instead of catering for the social security of its own workers

    15. So far as to the averments made in para 3.15 and 3.16 are concerned I have no comments to offer being unrelated to the office of the deponent. Further its reiterated that irrespective of the availability of funds the petitioner was under obligations to fulfill its liability

    Page 33 of 49

    as a covered establishment and employer in consonance with the provisions of EPF & MP Act, 1952 and the Schemes framed there under from time to time in a timely manner.

    16. So far as to the averments made in para 3.17 is concerned, the same are denied in view of what has already been stated in the preceding para the same being not repeated here for the sake of brevity. It is to further state and submit that as stated above interest and damages have been levied as per the EPF & MP Act. The orders impugned in the petition are well reasoned, speaking order passed by the quasi- judicial authority taking into account the facts of the case and submission of the appellant petitioner establishment. Further the appellant petitioner establishment is independently covered with P.F. No. GJ/AHD/50712 and it was the responsibility of the petitioner establishment to deposit the PF dues within stipulated time.

    17. So far as to the averments made in para 3.18 is concerned it is to state and submit that as since the petitioner establishment failed to deposit the assessed amount within the stipulated period of 15 days of the receipt of the order, as advised in impugned orders dated 20/05/2019. Therefore the provisions conferred u/s 8F of EPF & MP Act 1952 were invoked by competent authority and order U/ s 8F was passed directing the bank to attach the bank account and remit the outstanding dues.

    Moreover sufficient opportunities were provided to the petitioner establishment for presenting their facts in this matter. The orders u/s. 14B and & 7 Q of the EPF & MP ACT, 1952 is a well

    Page 34 of 49

    reasoned, speaking order passed by the quasi-judicial authority after considering all the facts, applicable provision of law, submissions raised by the employer during the proceedings before it.

    18. So far as to the averments made in para 3.19 the same is denied in toto in view of the preliminary objection raised in Para 3 of this reply, the same is not being repeated here for the sake of brevity.

    19. So far as to the averments made in para 3.20 and 3.21 are concerned it is to state that the same is denied in toto as the same is misleading and mischievous, made only with a view to shirk away from its liability from the mandatory provisions of the EPF & MP Act, 1952 and the Schemes framed there under as has been elaborately demonstrated in the preceding paras, the same being not repeated here for the sake of brevity. It is to further state that all the facts stated by the petitioner in these paras are disputed and recovery action by the respondent is totally legal and as per the provisions of EPF & MP Act, 1952. Additionally it is also pertinent to note that the impugned assessment orders clearly mentioned that if the amount was not paid within 15 days of receipt of the order, further action as provided under section 8 of the EPF & MP Act, 1952 will be taken. One of the modes of recovery as provided under section 8F of the Act is attachment of bank accounts of the defaulting employer. As a matter of routine the same was done by the impugned order issued to the bankers of the petitioner company as the assessed amount was not deposited by the petitioner company. However, strangely, the petitioner is expressing shock and surprise

    Page 35 of 49

    to the consequences which logically & legally followed as a result of its own violations of a law enacted by the Parliament of India. In its letter dtd. 28.08.2008, the establishment has itself submitted that it slipped on making timely remittances. The same was accepted by the establishment throughout the proceedings and in fact the order dtd. 25.05.2019 itself mentioned that the establishment partly paid some amount towards interest under section 7Q and 14B during the proceedings itself.

    20. With respect to the Grounds of the Petition in Para 4 under para here in under it is to state as under:

    (a) To (c): With respect to ground (a) to

    (u) the same are denied in toto in view of what has already been contended in detail in the preceding paragraphs and the same is not being repeated for the sake of brevity. It is to further state and submit that the vague, general statements of the petitioner have been effectively countered in the impugned order which speaks for itself. Now on the basis of the same generalizations coupled with misstatement & concealment of facts, the petitioner company has approached this Hon'ble Court trying to mislead when facts and settled principles of law state otherwise.

    (d) With respect to ground (d) the same are denied in toto in view of what has already been contended in detail in the preceding paragraphs and the same is not being repeated for the sake of brevity. It is reiterated and as is evident from the

    Annexure Z3 to this reply that out of 30 proceedings held in this matter the representative of establishment. appeared on 9 occasions. The impugned assessment

    Page 36 of 49

    orders are well reasoned, speaking order passed by the quasi- judicial authority taking into account the facts , applicable provisions and submissions of the petitioner.

    (e) and (i) With respect to ground (e) to

    (i) the same are denied in toto in view of what has already been dealt in detail in the preceding paragraphs especially paras 12 to 14 amongst others and hence, the same is not being repeated for the sake of brevity. It is to further state and submit that it is a perfunctory submission made by the petitioner only to buy time as the real interest of the petitioner company lies in obtaining a stay order for the time being and ensuring that this case goes. Further this is nothing but taking advantage of one's own wrong which is not permitted in law. It is to further state that all the facts stated by the petitioner in these paras are disputed and recovery action by the respondent is totally legal and as per the provisions of EPF & MP Act, 1952. Additionally it is also pertinent to note that the impugned assessment orders clearly mentioned that if the amount was not paid within 15 days of receipt of the order, further action as provided under section 8 of the EPF & MP Act, 1952 will be taken. One of the modes of recovery as provided under section 8F of the Act is attachment of bank accounts of the defaulting employer. As a matter of routine the same was done by the impugned order dtd. 14.06.2019 issued to the bankers of the petitioner company as the assessed amount was not deposited by the petitioner company. However, strangely, the petitioner is expressing shock and surprise to the consequences which logically & legally followed as a result of its own violations of a law enacted by the

    Page 37 of 49

    Parliament of India. In its letter dtd. 28.08.2008, the establishment has itself submitted that it slipped on making timely remittances. The same was accepted by the establishment throughout the proceedings and in fact the order dtd. 20.05.2019 itself mentioned that the establishment partly paid some amount towards interest under section 7Q and 14B during the proceedings itself.

    21. So far as to the averments made in para 5 is concerned the same is denied in toto and it is to state that the provision under the EPF & MP Act 1952 clearly envisages that in case of being aggrieved against the order passed under section 14(B), the remedy available under the EPF & MP Act 1952 is required to be exhausted by the petitioner by filing appropriate proceedings in the appellate tribunal."

    12. Referring to the above averments it was submitted that the petition deserves to be dismissed as is devoid of any merit.

    13. Having heard learned advocates for the respective parties and having considered the submissions as well as the documents placed on record; it is apparent that the respondent nos.1 and 2 have passed the impugned orders without assigning any reasons to fasten the liability under section 14B and 7Q of the Act towards the damages and the interest respectively upon the petitioner.

    Page 38 of 49

    14. It would be therefore germane to refer to the provisions of Section 14B and section 7Q of the Act, which reads as under:

    7Q. Interest payable by the

    employer.—The employer shall be liable to pay simple interest at the rate of twelve per cent. per annum or at such higher rate as may be specified in the Scheme on any

    amount due from him under this Act from the date on which the amount has become so due till the date of its actual payment:

    Provided that higher rate of

    interest specified in the Scheme shall not exceed the lending rate of interest charged by any scheduled bank.

    14B. Power to recover damages.—Where an employer makes default in the payment of any contribution to the Fund 3 [, the 2 [Pension] Fund or the Insurance Fund] or in the

    transfer of accumulations required to be transferred by him under sub- section (2) of section 15 4 [or sub- section (5) of section 17] or in the payment of any charges payable under any other provision of this Act or of 5 [any Scheme or Insurance

    Scheme] or under any of the

    conditions specified under section 17, 6 [the Central Provident Fund Commissioner or such other officer

    Page 39 of 49

    as may be authorised by the Central Government, by notification in the Official Gazette, in this behalf] may recover 7 [from the employer by way of penalty such damages, not exceedingthe amount of arrears, as may be specified in the Scheme:] [Provided that before levying and recovering such damages, the employer shall be given a reasonable opportunity of being heard]:

    [Provided further that the Central Board may reduce or waive the damages levied under this section in relation to an establishment which is a sick industrial company and in respect of which a scheme for rehabilitation has been sanctioned by the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction established under section 4 of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985,subject to such terms and conditions as may be specified in the Scheme.]

    15. On perusal of the above provisions Section 7Q applies for charging of interest when the employer who is liable to deposit the amount as specified in the scheme has not been able to deposit the amount as per the scheme. Whereas Section 14B refers to the damages to be paid by the employer as per the order passed by the respondent-Authority

    Page 40 of 49

    where an employer makes default in payment of any contribution to the fund. As per first proviso to Section 14B before levying and recovering damages, the employee is required to be given reasonable opportunity of being heard. Considering the material available on record the petitioner was provided opportunity of hearing and the petitioner filed the reply but in the impugned order only reference is made to the reply dated 27.11.2017 without considering the contents of the reply as to why there was a delay in making the payment in depositing the amount of the contribution to the fund, the same is not considered by the respondent-authority in detail, no reasons are assigned and only vague reason is assigned in the impugned order which is reproduced herein below:

    "In reply to the notice sent to the establishment vide letter no: 1605. dt 27/11/2017 the establishment submitted that the delayed contributions made were as per the Employees' Enrollment Campaign 2017 and wherein there as a provision not to levy damages. Based on that they requested to waive the damages. However it was found that certain conditions were required to be met to get the waiver of the damages. After examining the matter it was

    Page 41 of 49

    submitted by the EO that the establishment has failed to fulfil all the conditions required for waiver of damages as per the Employees Enrollment Campaign 2017. Therefore for the delayed payments, interest and damages will be levied on the establishment as is levied in normal cases of delayed remittances. After that also, the establishment requested for time to submit counter reply. However even after taking sufficient opportunities the establishment failed to even appear in the case. Therefore it seems that the establishment is not interested in pursuing the case and contesting the matter."

    16. Verbatim same reasons are given for fastening the liability of interest under Section 7Q of the Act which reads as under:

    "In reply to the notice sent to the establishment vide letter no: 1605 dt 27/11/2017 the establishment submitted that the delayed contributions made were as per the Employees' Enrollment Campaign 2017 and wherein there as a provision not to levy damages. Based on that they requested to waive the damages, However it was found that certain conditions were required to be met to get the waiver of the damages. After examining the matter it was submitted by the EO that the establishment has failed to fulfil all the conditions required for

    Page 42 of 49

    waiver of interest as per the Employees' Enrollment Campaign 2017. Therefore for the delayed payments, interest and damages will be levied on the establishment as is levied in normal cases of delayed remittances. After that also, the establishment requested for time to submit counter reply. However even after taking sufficient opportunities the establishment failed to even appear in the case. Therefore it seems that the establishment is not interested in pursuing the case and contesting the matter."

    17. Considering the so called reasons which are assigned to fasten the liability of damages as well as interest upon the petitioner, it is apparent that the respondent-authority has without application of mind and without considering the contents of the reply of the petitioner has passed absolutely vague orders. The Division Bench of this Court in case of Star Of Gujarat Textile Mills Limited Vs. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Ahmedabad in such circumstances has held as under:

    "3. The fact remains that, apart from the sweeping statement in the summing up paragraph of the impugned proceedings, factors which have been set down as relevant to be considered while assessing the question of imposition of damages, have

    Page 43 of 49

    not been discussed at all by the 1st respondent. In the pronouncement in Organo Chemical Industries & Anr. V. Union of India & Ors., 1979 (II) LLJ 416 the Supreme Court observed:

    "xxx Having regard to the punitive nature of the power exercisable under Section 14B and the consequences that ensue therefrom, an order under Section 14B must be a 'speaking' order containing the reasons in support of it. The guidelines are provided in the act and its various provisions, particularly in the word "damages" the liability for which in Section 14B arises on the "making of default". While fixing the amount of damages, the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner usually takes into considerations as he has done here, various factors, viz., the number of defaults, the period of delay, the frequency of defaults and the amounts involved. Xxxxx"

    Here, we find that, it is not a case of total omission to make the contributions. There had been only delayed contributions. The periods are different and the days of delay are also different. A glance at the statement of damages, annexed to the impugned proceedings, shows that the day of delay range from a minimum of 7 days to a maximum of 47 days, but, a flat rate of 25% has been adopted by the 1st respondent; and certainly, we cannot commend the impugned proceedings on the ground that the application of the norms, as set down by the pronouncement of the Supreme Court, referred to above, has been done. This only exposes lack of application of mind on the part of the 1st respondent. As to how the functionary under Section 14B of the Act should discharge the obligations has been

    Page 44 of 49

    expatiated by S. Natarajan, J., as he then was, of the High Court of Madras in K. A. Subramaniam v. The Commissioner, the Regional Provident Fund, Tamil Nadu & Pondicherry States & Anr., 1979 Labour and Industrial Cases 981, in the following terms :

    "xxx The authority empowered to impose damages has to, first of all, decide whether the facts of a case warrant the imposition of damages. If his assessment of the situation results in a finding that imposition of damages is called for then he has to determine the quantum of damages with reference to relevant factors such as the loss suffered by the affected party, the hardship caused to the beneficiaries, the efforts taken by the enforcement machinery to collect the defaulted payments etc. There is, therefore, a clear line of distinction between imposition of penalty which is penal in nature and imposition of damages which is compensatory in nature. We, cannot straightway say that what has been done by the 1st respondent by the impugned proceedings does respondent by the impugned proceedings does conform to what has been recapitulated by the learned single Judge in the above pronouncement. The petitioner has been declared as sick unit and the 1st respondent declines to take note of it for any consideration on a peculiar reasoning that the concerned authority BIFR has not specifically recommended for partial or total waiver of penal damages under the Act. When we take note of these features, we have no other alternative but to interfere in writ powers. Accordingly, this Special Civil Application is allowed and the matter stands remitted back to the file of the 1st respondent for him to reconsider the whole question, taking note of the norms set down therefore by the pronouncements, referred

    Page 45 of 49

    to above, as well as other pronouncements throwing light on the subject."

    18. It is a trite law that the reasons to be given by any authority, more particularly, a Quasi Judicial Authority are nothing but the heart of the order which is required to be considered in the order to be passed. The Honorable Supreme Court in the following decisions has emphasized the importance of giving reasons by the quasi judicial authority:

    (1) In case of State of Uttaranchal Vs. Sunilkumar Singh Negi reported in 2008 (11) SCC 205 held as under:

    "5) In order to find an answer whether the impugned order of the High Court is sustainable, it is relevant to refer to the assertion made by the State of Uttaranchal in their petition before the High Court. It was stated that though respondent No 1 therein was engaged as daily wager on 07.09.1987 and thereafter when the work was available, he did not work for 240 days in any calendar year. Pursuant to the award of the Labour Court dated 23.07.2001, the Horticulture Department deposited an amount of Rs.6,000/- and the workman was asked to work as daily wager in Government Food Preservation Centre, Pauri under the Department of Horticulture and Food Processing. He

    Page 46 of 49

    did not join the work as requested but he approached the Assistant Labour Commissioner by filing a petition and lodged a claim of Rs.92,842/-. The Assistant Labour Commissioner himself advised the workman to join place of work at Pauri. However, the worker ignored the advice of the Assistant Labour Commissioner. Thereafter, the very same officer directed the Department to pay Rs.92,842/- holding that the Department ought to have reinstated the worker at the same place where his services were terminated. In several paragraphs, the Department highlighted that the worker alone was guilty of not joining the place of work despite repeated letters sent by them as such there was no justification to award a claim of Rs.92,842/-. With these particulars and other details, the Horticulture and Food Processing Department filed a writ petition NO. 820 of 2005 before the High Court, Uttaranchal."

    (2) In case of Kranti Association Pvt. Ltd. and Anr. Vs. Masood Ahmed Khan And Others

    reported in 2010 (9) SCC 496:

    "15. The necessity of giving reason by a body or authority in support of its decision came up for consideration before this Court in several cases. Initially this Court recognized a sort of demarcation between administrative orders and quasi- judicial orders but with the passage of time the distinction between the two got blurred and thinned out and virtually reached a vanishing point in the judgment of this

    Page 47 of 49

    Court in A.K. Kraipak and others vs. Union of India and others reported in

    AIR 1970 SC 150.

    16. In Kesava Mills Co. Ltd. and another vs. Union of India and others reported in AIR 1973 SC 389, this Court approvingly referred to the opinion of Lord Denning in Rigina vs. Gaming Board Ex parte Benaim [(1970) 2 WLR 1009] and quoted him as saying "that heresy was scotched in Ridge and Boldwin, 1964 AC 40".

    17. The expression `speaking order' was first coined by Lord Chancellor Earl Cairns in a rather strange context. The Lord Chancellor, while explaining the ambit of Writ of Certiorari, referred to orders with errors on the face of the record and pointed out that an order with errors on its face, is a speaking order. (See 1878-97 Vol. 4 Appeal Cases 30 at 40 of the report)

    18. This Court always opined that the face of an order passed by a quasi- judicial authority or even an administrative authority affecting the rights of parties, must speak. It must not be like the `inscrutable face of a Sphinx'.

    19. In the case of Harinagar Sugar Mills Ltd. vs. Shyam Sunder Jhunjhunwala and others, AIR 1961 SC 1669, the question of recording reasons came up for consideration in the context of a refusal by Harinagar to transfer, without giving reasons, shares held by Shyam Sunder. Challenging such refusal, the transferee moved the High Court contending, inter alia, that the

    Page 48 of 49

    refusal is mala fide, arbitrary and capricious. The High Court rejected such pleas and the transferee was asked to file a suit. The transferee filed an appeal to the Central Government under Section 111 Clause (3) of Indian Companies Act, 1956 which was dismissed. Thereafter, the son of the original transferee filed another application for transfer of his shares which was similarly refused by the Company. On appeal, the Central Government quashed the resolution passed by the Company and directed the Company to register the transfer. However, in passing the said order, Government did not give any reason. The company challenged the said decision before this Court."

    19. Considering the above conspectus of law when the respondent-authority has failed to provide any reasons for recovery of damages and interest, such orders are not sustainable and are accordingly quashed and set aside. Rule is made absolute. No order as to cost.

    Sd/-

    (BHARGAV D. KARIA, J)

    URIL RANA

    Page 49 of 49

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    VISHV ENTERPRISE v. ASSISTANT PROVIDENT FUND COMMISSIONER
    (Oct 17, 2023)