Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2024 INSC 16
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2024 INSC 16
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881
Smart Summary

Satish P. Bhatt v. State of Maharashtra & Anr.

Criminal Appeal (arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 7433 of 2019) — decided 3 January 2024

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant (Satish P. Bhatt) and the intervenor (Vishwanath R. Nayak) were Chairman-cum-Managing Director and Vice-Chairman, respectively, of M/s. Astral Glass Private Limited (AGPL). In 2011 the Trial Court convicted the company, the appellant, and the intervenor in three complaints under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, sentencing each individual to ten months’ simple imprisonment and directing cumulative compensation of ₹5 crores.
Three joint criminal appeals were dismissed by the Sessions Court in 2014, with one month granted to surrender. The appellant and intervenor then filed criminal revisions before the Bombay High Court. On 3 July 2018 they tendered an undertaking, based on a settlement, to pay the complainant ₹4,63,50,000, agreeing to equal payment obligations. Relying on that undertaking, the High Court suspended their sentences and released them on bail, fixing 8 October 2018 to report compliance and expressly barring any extension.
Payments were defaulted. On 20 March 2019 the High Court extended time once, warning that non-payment by 20 April 2019 would automatically cancel bail and sentence suspension. Default persisted, and on 23 July 2019 the High Court cancelled the suspension of sentence and bail. The present Supreme Court appeal challenges that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Bombay High Court was justified in cancelling the appellant’s bail and suspension of sentence for non-compliance with the monetary undertaking dated 3 July 2018.
  2. Whether the appellant’s payment of what he claimed was his “half share” (₹1,95,00,000) sufficed to prevent cancellation despite the outstanding balance owed to the complainant.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Out of the agreed ₹3,90,00,000 outstanding after initial payments, his share was only half (₹1,95,00,000), which he has already paid.
  • Therefore, the High Court erred in cancelling his bail and suspension of sentence.

Complainant's Arguments

  • ₹83,10,000 remains unpaid; the complainant seeks this amount with 12% compound interest from 15 March 2019 plus costs.

Intervenor's Arguments

  • The directors had an internal 60 : 40 liability ratio (appellant 60%, intervenor 40%).
  • He previously paid ₹73,50,000 and, after 3 July 2018, a further ₹1,11,90,000—satisfying his 40% share.
  • The appellant still owes ₹83,10,000; the intervenor suffers from the appellant’s default.
  • Alleges the appellant altered the undertaking from “as per their respective shares” to “equally.”

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. The Supreme Court examined the undertaking of 3 July 2018 and the High Court’s orders. Both documents expressly state that the appellant and intervenor agreed to pay the settlement amount “equally,” with a clause that default by either would attract prosecution.
2. Any internal arrangement between the appellant and intervenor is inter se; the complainant is entitled to the full settlement sum and is not bound by their internal ratio.
3. The High Court’s order of 20 March 2019 clearly provided that failure to pay the outstanding amount by 20 April 2019 would automatically revoke bail and sentence suspension “without reference to Court.”
4. The total agreed amount has not been paid. Consequently, the statutory trigger for cancellation of bail became operative, and the High Court’s subsequent order merely recognised that consequence.
5. The Supreme Court declined to apportion liability between the two directors, emphasising that the critical fact is collective non-payment of the agreed sum.
6. Given the complainant’s prolonged litigation since 2007 and the continued benefit enjoyed by the appellant and intervenor under this Court’s interim stay, the Court found “no infirmity” in the High Court’s order.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED WITH COSTS.

• The appellant must pay ₹5 lakhs in costs to the complainant within four weeks, in addition to the compensation already ordered.
• The appellant and intervenor are directed to surrender within four weeks to undergo their sentences; failing which, the High Court shall take coercive measures.
• The pending criminal revisions and related applications before the High Court shall proceed, and the High Court is to ensure full compliance with the undertaking.
Implications are confined to the immediate parties: bail stands cancelled, sentences must be served, and the complainant is to receive both compensation and additional costs. No new legal precedent was articulated.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SATISH P. BHATT v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

    2024 INSC 16

    Civil Appeal No.1598 of 2023 Page 1 of 17

    REPORTABLE

    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

    CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

    CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. OF 2024

    (@ SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CRL.) NO.7433 OF 2019) SATISH P. BHATT …APPELLANT

    VERSUS

    THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

    & ANR …RESPONDENTS

    J U D G M E N T

    VIKRAM NATH, J.

    1. The facts of this case bring to light a situation marked by a persistent disregard for judicial directives and a lackadaisical approach to legal and financial obligations. The behaviour of the Petitioner stands as a testament to how an

    1

    individual's nonchalant attitude towards financial responsibilities and court orders can undermine the essence of judicial efficacy.

    2. The High Court took a firm stance against the appellant's continued failure to fulfil his financial obligations, culminating in the cancellation of his bail and suspension of sentence. This decision, reflecting the frustration of the legal system with repeated non-compliance, sets the stage for our deliberation.

    3. Leave granted.

    4. The present appeal assails the correctness of the judgment and order dated 23.07.2019 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay cancelling the order of suspension of sentence and bail granted to the appellant as

    2

    also the intervenor (petitioner before the High Court) vide order dated 03.07.2018 as they violated the undertaking given before the High Court on 03.07.2018 and recorded in the order of even date and further violated the condition contained in paragraph 3 of the order dated 20.03.2019 granting extension of time to comply.

    5. The appellant-Satish P.Bhatt and the intervenor Vishwanath Ramakrishna Nayak were

    Chairman-cum-Managing Director and Vice- Chairman of a company by the name of M/s.Astral Glass Private Limited (in short the AGPL). The company AGPL as also the appellant and the intervenor were convicted for offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 18811vide judgment and

    1 NI Act

    3

    order of the Trial Court dated 26.08.2011 in three separate cases and were awarded sentence of ten months with total liability of Rs.5 crores cumulatively in all the three cases. The operative portion of the conviction and sentence as recorded by the Trial Court in one of the cases is reproduced hereunder:

    "I) Accused No.2 Mr.Satish Padamanath Bhat, aged 54 years and accused no.3 Mr.Vishwanath Ramakrsishna Nayak, aged 50 years both r/o.Borivali (E), Mumbai-400 066 are hereby convicted vide provisions under Section 255(2) of Cr.P.C. for offence under Section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act and they are sentenced to suffer Simple Imprisonment for 10 (ten) months each.

    II) Both accused shall also to pay in total Rs.1,10,00,000/- (Rupees one crore and ten lakhs only) as compensation to Complainant vide provisions under

    4

    Section 357(3) of Cr.P.C. within 3 months. In default to suffer further Simple imprisonment for 6 (six) months each.

    III) Cash security of Rs.3000/- of accused no.2 shall stand continued till appeal period is over and P.R. bond of accused no.3 stands cancelled…."

    6. Three appeals jointly filed by the appellant, the intervenor as also AGPL were dismissed by the Sessions Court vide common judgment and order dated 30.01.2014. The Sessions Court granted a month's time to surrender in order to undergo the sentence.

    7. Aggrieved by the same, they preferred three revisions before the High Court as originally there were three complaints. Before the High Court the appellant and the intervenor filed an undertaking based on a settlement on 03.07.2018 according to which it was agreed that a total sum of Rs.4,63,50,000/- would be

    5

    paid to the complainant-respondent no.2. Out of the said amount Rs.73,50,000/- had already been paid before the appeal Court. As such, the remaining amount of Rs.3,90,00,000/- was to be paid in installments. The payment schedule was also laid down in paragraphs 6 and 7 whereas paragraph 5 mentioned amount of settlement. Paragraph 8 of the settlement mentioned that the said amount would be paid equally by the appellant and the intervenor. However, in default of payment by either of them as per their agreed share in the settlement they would be held liable and would be prosecuted as per law.

    8. Based on the undertaking, the learned Single Judge of the High Court passed an order on the same day i.e. 03.07.2018 and granted interim protection by suspending the sentence of

    6

    imprisonment and they were directed to be released on bail on furnishing a personal bond in the sum of Rs.25,000/- with one or more sureties in the like amount. The Court further directed that no further extension shall be granted for payment of the settled amount and fixed 8thOctober, 2018 for reporting compliance.

    9. As per the undertaking, Rs.2 crores was to be paid on or before 30thSeptember, 2018, in addition to Rs.25 lakhs which was paid on the date of passing of the order. Remaining amount of Rs. 1 crore 65 lakhs was to be paid on or before 15thMarch, 2019. Thereafter the matter was taken up by the High Court on 20thMarch, 2019 by which time they had paid only Rs.82 lakhs. Further time was sought to pay the balance amount till 20thApril, 2019. The

    7

    counsel for the complainant pointed out that the amount due was Rs.1,69,10,000/-. The High Court on 20.03.2019 extended the time for payment of Rs.1,69,10,000/- till 20thApril, 2019 and further provided that if the said amount was not paid then the order granting bail and also suspending the sentence shall stand cancelled forthwith without further reference to Court.

    10. Thereafter it appears that the present appellant Satish P.Bhatt filed a criminal application in the pending revision on 16thApril, 2019 stating that he had paid his share of Rs.1,95,00,000/- being 50% of Rs.3,90,00,000/- as mentioned in the order dated 3rdJuly, 2018 and, therefore, he may be absolved of the charges and acquitted. On the said application, notice was issued to the complainant on 19thJune, 2019 fixing 10thJuly,

    8

    2019. On that date, it was adjourned to 16th July, 2019. Thereafter on 16thJuly it was adjourned to 23rdJuly, 2019. On 23rdJuly, 2019, the High Court passed the impugned order cancelling the suspension of sentence and bail granted vide order dated 3rdJuly, 2018 for non-compliance of the undertaking and in view of the order dated 20thMarch, 2019 wherein while extending the time it was observed that in case of default, the bail order and the suspension of sentence order would stand automatically withdrawn without reference to the Court.

    11. Learned counsel for the appellant has sought to argue that out of Rs.3,90,00,000/- his half share would amount to Rs.1,95,00,000/- which has duly been paid and, therefore, the order of the High Court cancelling his bail and

    9

    suspension of sentence was not warranted and deserves to be set aside.

    12. On the other hand, learned counsel for the complainant has submitted that as of date there is still an outstanding amount of Rs.83,10,000/- and has, therefore, claimed that the complainant would be entitled to receive Rs.83,10,000/- along with compound interest @ 12% p.a. from 15thMarch, 2019 till actual payment is made along with costs against the appellant as also the intervenor.

    13. The intervenor has also filed his response and according to him the partnership between the appellant and the intervenor was in the ratio of 60:40 and that they had actually agreed to pay the settled amount of Rs.4,63,50,000/- in that proportion as per their shares in the firm. It is also his case that the amount of Rs.73,50,000

    10

    had been paid by him alone prior to 03.07.2018 during the time when the appeal was pending before the Sessions Court and, therefore, he was entitled to adjustment of the said amount. Further his case is that out of the settled amount to be paid to the complainant i.e. Rs.4,63,50,000/- his share being 40%, the amount liable to be paid by him would be Rs.1,85,00,000/-. As he had paid Rs.73,50,000 earlier he was liable to pay a further amount of Rs.1,11,90,000/-. According to him, he has paid the said amount of Rs.1,11,90,000/- after the order dated 03.07.2018. The outstanding amount of Rs.83,10,000/- falls in the share of the appellant whose total liability being 60% of the settled amount would come to

    Rs.2,78,10,000/- and he having paid only

    11

    Rs.1,95,00,000/- there is a shortfall of Rs.83,10,000/- which the appellant should pay.

    14. It is further submitted that the intervenor is being unnecessarily suffering because of remaining amount not being paid by the appellant. It is also the case of the intervenor that as per the e-mails exchanged between them which have been duly placed on record prior to the undertaking dated 03.07.2018, it was decided and agreed between them that the amount would be paid as per their respective shares i.e. in the ratio of 60:40. The said exchange of e-mails and the draft settlement was also shared with the lawyer and the same was duly accepted. The intervenor was not dealing with the lawyer directly and it was the appellant who was dealing with the lawyer. The appellant has mischievously and fraudulently

    12

    altered the words "as per the respective shares"

    by substituting it with "equally". The intervenor was hurriedly made to sign the undertaking on the date it was being filed i.e. 03.07.2018 and he trusted the appellant and the lawyer who was appearing for both of them. It is further stated that the intervenor has also filed before the High Court by way of a modification application to deal with this aspect of the matter, which application is still pending.

    15. We have perused the undertaking dated 03.07.2018 as also the order dated 03.07.2018 and also the subsequent orders passed by the High Court. It is apparent from the same that the complainant was entitled to receive a total amount of Rs.4,63,50,000/-. The undertaking as also the order dated 03.07.2018 clearly mention that both of them will pay the amount

    13

    equally as agreed by and between them and it further contains a stipulation that in default of the payment by either of them as per their agreed share in the settlement, they shall be held liable and prosecuted as per law.

    16. The settlement between the two directors i.e. the appellant and the intervenor is inter se these two only and the complainant is not bound by the same. Complainant's agreement or consent was only to the extent of accepting

    Rs.4,63,50,000/- only. He was not a signatory to the agreement which was signed by the two parties. Admittedly, both the appellant and the intervenor were Chairman and Vice-Chairman of the company AGPL and, therefore, were convicted by the Trial Court and their conviction was affirmed by the Appellate Court.

    14

    17. We are not inclined to go into this question as to who is to pay how much amount. The fact remains that the total amount agreed to be paid has not been paid and as per the order of the High Court dated 20.03.2019 the revisionists being in default in payment of the agreed amount, the interim protection granted by way of bail and suspension of sentence, would stand withdrawn without reference to the Court. We find no infirmity in the impugned order.

    18. There is a protection provided by this Court vide order dated 26.08.2019 regarding stay of arrest, as a result of which the appellant and the intervenor have still not undergone the sentence. On the other hand, the complainant has still not reaped not only the fruits of the order dated 03.07.2018 but also of the order of the Trial Court dated 26.08.2011. He agreed to

    15

    receive a much lesser amount than he was entitled to under the order of the Trial Court. He has been litigating since 2007 almost 16 years by now.

    19. We, accordingly, do not find any illegality in the order passed by the High Court. The appeal is accordingly dismissed with costs quantified at Rs. 5 lakhs to be paid to the respondent No. 2 (Complainant) within four weeks from today. It is clarified that this amount of costs will not be adjusted against the compensation awarded to the respondent No.2 but will be in addition to it.

    20. It is further directed that the appellant and the intervenor to surrender within a period of four weeks from today to undergo the sentence. If they do not surrender, the High Court to take appropriate coercive measures to get the sentence executed. The revisions before the

    16

    High Court are still pending. The High Court will proceed to decide the revisions as also pending applications if any and ensure that the undertaking is fully complied with and the complainant is suitably compensated for the further harassment caused.

    21. Pending application(s), if any, stand disposed of.

    ………………………………………….J. (Vikram Nath) ………………………………………….J. (Rajesh Bindal) New Delhi,

    January 03, 2024

    17

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SATISH P. BHATT v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
    (Jan 3, 2024)