ORDER:
Saroj Bala Bohra, Presiding Member:
1. Brief facts of present complaint are that complainant Jyoti (since deceased) was pregnant and was in advance stage of pregnancy. The delivery was due on 05.02.2014, so she was got admitted in the hospital of OP on 05.02.2014 by the husband of complainant and on checking, OP proclaimed that delivery will be done normal. The complainant was at the advance stage of the pregnancy and she was crying for labour pain, so complainant requested the OP to get the delivery as Caesarian by calling some doctor. Complainant has
1
alleged that the OP due to greediness and to extract money did not allow complainant to leave the hospital. However, complainant remained in the OP hospital and gave birth to a child on 05.02.2014 at 7:27 P.M. Complainant alleged that OP was very much negligent while delivery of the child as there was huge bleeding to the complainant and her body became standstill and thus became unconscious. On being such condition, complainant was referred to Hisar on the same night at about 12.30 a.m., and OP taken Rs.8500/- from the complainant. It has averred that doctor of Rachna Hospital, Hisar referred the complainant and then she was taken to Jindal Hospital, Hisar at about 3:00 P.M. and from there she was taken to CMC Hospital, Hisar and remained admitted there from 05.02.2014 to 19.02.2014 where three units blood was given to complainant. On 06.02.2014, complainant gained consciousness and doctor of CMC found both the kidneys of complainant damaged and was not curable. Complainant has submitted that there was no much improvement in the condition of complainant so she was taken to Geetanjali Hospital, Hisar on 05.03.2014 and after treatment, complainant was discharged in improved and stable condition on 07.03.2014. She was again admitted in the said hospital on 09.03.2014. On deteriorating the condition of complainant, she was shifted to ICU and was on Hemodialysis. Complainant extubated on 12.03.2014 at 10:00 a.m., Gynae check up was done by Dr. P.Shrarma, Adv. vaginal wash and opinion from PGIMER Chandigarh was also taken on 22.03.2014 and advised followed and complainant was discharged on 24.03.2014 in stable condition. Complainant went to PGI, Chandigarh and admitted in emergency, treatment done and was extubated on 02.04.2014 and on 07.04.2014, patient was referred to PGIMER Chandigarh for further opinion and management. Complainant has alleged that this
2
condition of complainant was due to high negligence of OP and as a result thereof, both the kidneys of complainant became damaged and thereby had to undergo dialysis for a long time. Further, male child of complainant also expired after one year because the complainant could not care and feed him properly. As such, complainant suffered set back in the matter. As per complainant, more than Rs.10.00 lac spent on the treatment. Complainant moved an application to the SSP, Bhiwani on 03.06.2014 but no action was taken against the OP being influential person. Hence, the present complaint has been preferred seeking directions to OP to pay Rs.10.00 lacs as compensation on account of treatment expenses as well as for harassment and humiliation etc. alongwith interest @ 24% interest per annum till its realization. Further to pay Rs. 11,000/- as litigation expenses and Rs.15,000/- towards counsel's fee. Any other relief to which this Commission deems fit has also been sought.
2. Opposite Party on appearance filed the written statement and submitted that complainant was admitted in the OP hosapital on 05.02.2014 and delivery was happened on the same day. Delivery was normal without any complications. The OP is a BAMS from the recoganized institution namely Shri Krishna Govt. Ayurvedic College, Kurukshetra. She has also done the internship for 8 months in Ayurvedic training from 22.04.2002 to 21.03.2003 and 4 months Alopathy and Emergency training from 20.03.2002 to 21.07.2002 at Civil Hospital, Rohtak. A Notification has also been issued by the Central Council of Indian Medicines, New Delhi dated 9.4.2002 and 12thApril 2004 issued by the Govt. of Haryana that an I.S.M. Graduates can treat the patient of Gynecology
3
and Obstetrics. The OP has been issued a licence of practice as a BAMS No. 2534 dt.14.12.2004.
The complainant was having some pain as it is natural process to a lady when she birth a child and a male baby was born on the alleged day and was advised to keep the complainant in the hospital till the next day for proper care and examination/treatment. Prior to this, husband of the complainant was compelling the OP to conduct the delivery by way of Caesarian, whereas the OP advised the husband of the complainant there is no any problem and why you compelling the OP for Caesarian. He was adamant as and when the delivery is over then he and his mother who were attending the complainant were satisfied but after sometime they wanted to take the complainant to their home but the OP again advised them not to took away the complainant from the hospital today and she will be discharged on next day after proper examination. However, mother of complainant compelled to take the complainant and she was issued the statement that they are taking away the complainant at about 8.30 PM on 5.2.2014 at their own consent and responsibility for further treatment and were satisfied with the treatment of Dalal Nursing Home. mother-in-law of complainant signed the statement. However, the husband of the complainant requested for refer to complainant to any other hospital for further examination of their satisfaction. As such, the patient was referred. After that, the OP has no knowledge about the further treatment etc. of the complainant as neither any notice was issued by any competent authority or any board of any negligence against the OP. OP has averred that there was no negligance on the part of OP as delivery was normal and no instruments of any kind was used while the getting the delivery and when no instrument
4
was used then no negligence can be attributed on the part of the OP. The amount of Rs.8500/- taken for medicines and service etc. have been admitted by the OP. The averments of greediness etc. have been denied. In the end, prayer for dismisal of complaint has been made.
3. In evidence of complainant, evidence affidavit of Sh. Naveen Kumar Ex. CW1/A alongwith documents Annexure C-1 to Annexure C-68 has placed on record and then closed the evidence on 14.02.2020.
4. On the other side, evidence affidavits of Dr.Pooja Dalal Ex.RW1/A and Sh. Gyan Singh as Ex. RW2/A alongwith documents Annexure R-1 to Anneuxre R-15 placed on record and clsoed the evidence on 18.02.2021.
5. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record carefully. Written arguments on behalf of complainant filed.
6. It was admitted case of complainant Jyoti (deceased) that she was admitted in the OP hospital on 05.02.2014 and gave birth to a male child at 7:27 p.m. and the doctor concerned taken Rs.8500/- as delivery charges. The grievance of complainant was that after delivery there was huge bleeding and because of which, she became uncounsicous, therefore, she was referred for another hospital on the same day at 12:30 a.m. (during night). Thereafter, she suffered more medical complicacies resulting into mental pains & physical harassment as well as huge monetary loss. The counsel in order to substantiate his case has placed on record medical treatment/tests record Annexure C-1 to Annexure C-67. Learned counsel for complainant has argued that both the kidneys of complainant were damaged due to negligence of OP-doctor while treatment in their hospital. Learned counsel
5
for complainant to support his case has relied upon a case law delivered by Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in case titled V. Krishan Rao Vs. Nikhil Super Speciality Hospital & Anr. passed in Civil Appeal No.2641 of 2010 (arising out of SLP (C) No.15084/2009), decided on 08.03.2010 wherein it has observed that "Medical Negligence-Claim of petitiioners cannot be rejected only on the ground that expert witness was not examined to prove negligence of Doctor- It is not required to have expert evidence in all cases of Medical negligence. A. Consumer Protection Act, 1986, Sections 23 & 3- Medical negligence-Claim of petitioners cananot be rejected only on the ground that expert witness was not examined to prove negligence of Doctor-It is not required to have expert evidence in all caes of medical negligence.
7. The defence of OP is that the delivery was normal and no complicacy occurred on that day during hospitalization of complanant in their hospital. OP has placed on record a certified copy of judgment dated 03.05.2017 passed by the learned court of Sub Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Tosham (Annexure R-1) which reveals that complainant Jyoti had fild a complaint under section 337,338,323 & 506 IPC read with section 34 IPC against Dr. Pooja and & Anr. and the same was dismissed observing therein " Though it is an established principle of law that in order to succeed in the summoning of the accused persons, the complainant is only expected to prove a prima facie case of herself but from the material on record, even a prima facie case is not being proved in the presnet case since it is not being established that accused No.1 had comitted gross medical neglience resulting into the sufferings of the complainant. Accordingly, the complaint was dismissed." Further, the OP has placed on record medical treatment summary of
6
complainant dated 05.02.2014 (Annexure R-11 & R-12) wehrein Smt. Bimla reportedly mother-in-law of complainant Jyoti has made a statement that they are taking away the complainant at about 8.30 PM on 5.2.2014 at their own consent and responsibility for further treatment and were satisfied with the treatment of Dalal Nursing Home. She signed the statement. This statement reveals that the patient-complainant was taken by her family members in a stable condition and no medical complicay was there at that point of time. OP has also placed on record affidavit (Ex. RW2/A) of Mr. Gyan Singh who was Lab Technician in OP Hospital at the relevant time. He has averred that Mrs.Jyoti gave birth to a male child and mother & baby both were OK. However, complainant Jyoti was suffering from blood insufficiency and it was apprised to the complainnat's husband. Upon this, her husband taken away the complainant from the hospital of OP.
8. Learned counsel for OP has argued that prior to filing of this complaint, no legal notice was ever issued to OP which causes a serious lapse to the case of complainant. Furhter, no negligence against the OP doctor has been attributed in Medical Board's report (Annexure R-10). Perusal of this document reveals that a Medical Board was constituted by the CMO/PMO on police request dated 16.06.2014, having Dr. Sudha Garg and Dr. Agya Rathor. "…………Pt. develop PPH for which Pt. was refer to higher center. Pt. was admitted at CMC Hissar on 05.02.2014 and advised cysposcoty and Laprotomy but notes of above procedure are not in the file. However, patient was advised to take opinion from PGIMER. In view of that suggested to constitute further board including Physician/Nephrologist,Pathologist." As such, no medical negligence was seen agaisnt the OP doctor.
7
9. Learned counsel for OP has drawn our attention towards a document placed on record by complainant (Annexure C-19), a discharge slip issued from CMC, Hospital, Hisar which reveals that patient gradually improved. Discharge on request.
10. After having heared learned counsel for both the sides and perusing the record minutely, we are of the view that the delivery to complainant Jyoti of a male child was normal and complainant as well as her family members, after the delivery, were apprised to keep the patient for one day in the hospital care but they under a writing got discharged her from the OP hospital. From the record, during the hospitalization of complainant in hospital of OP, no medical negligence has come into light agianst the OP doctor. The facts and circumstnaces of the case law (supra) relied upon on behalf of complainant are not helpful in the situaton of this case. Accordingly, finding no merits in the complaint, the same is hereby dismissed with no order as to costs. Certified copies of this order be supplied to parties concerned, free of costs, as per rules. File be consigned to the record room, after due compliance.
Announced.
Dated:14.12.2023.
(Shashi Kiran Panwar) (Saroj Bala Bohra)
Member Presiding Member
District Consumer
Disputes Redressal
Commission, Bhiwani.
8