Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This Letters Patent Appeal challenges the Single Judge's judgment dated 26.11.2019 in Special Civil Application No.1226 of 2018, which set aside the Deputy Collector's order dated 30.09.2015 and the Chief Revenue Controlling Authority's order dated 06.11.2017, and directed refund of Rs.18,92,757/- deposited by the writ petitioners.

Brief chronology drawn from the opinion:

  • 05.06.2010: Respondent No.1 initially registered as a Partnership Firm.
  • Partners decided to convert the Partnership Firm into a Private Limited Company; Registrar of Companies issued certificate of incorporation dated 15.07.2014.
  • 26.11.2014: Application to Mamlatdar to record conversion in revenue records; file referred to Deputy Collector, Stamp Duty Valuation Department.
  • 28.07.2015: Respondent No.1 informed Deputy Collector that no transfer occurred and no stamp duty was payable.
  • 28.09.2015: Show cause notice issued proposing recovery of stamp duty Rs.18,92,007/- plus penalties.
  • 29/30.09.2015: Deputy Collector ordered payment of Rs.18,92,757/- (including penalties).
  • Appeal No.76 of 2015 to Chief Revenue Controlling Authority rejected on 06.11.2017, confirming levy on ground that conversion amounted to change of ownership.
  • Respondent filed Special Civil Application No.1226 of 2018; Single Judge set aside the two orders and directed refund; State filed this Letters Patent Appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conversion of a Partnership Firm into a Private Limited Company, under the Companies Act, 2013, amounts to a "transfer" or "conveyance" within Section 2(g) and charging provisions (including Article 20(1) of Schedule I) of the Gujarat Stamp Act, 1958, thereby attracting stamp duty.
  2. Whether the Memorandum of Association and Articles of Association effect or evidence a transfer/consideration sufficient to compute stamp duty on conversion.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (State)

  • The Company is a separate juristic person distinct from the Partnership Firm; transfer/vesting of property in the Company is liable to be treated as conveyance under Section 2(g) of the Gujarat Stamp Act, 1958, attracting stamp duty.
  • The Memorandum and Articles stating that assets and liabilities "vest" in the Company amount to a transfer covered by Section 2(g); relied on Union of India and anr. vs. M/s. Mahalaxmi Saw Mills P. Ltd.

Respondent(s)' Arguments

  • Conversion was a statutory reconstitution under Section 366 of the Companies Act; partners became directors in same ratio, no change in business, no addition/deletion of persons, and no transfer of property to any individual.
  • Memorandum and Articles do not transfer assets inter vivos or specify consideration; therefore Article 20(1) and Section 2(g) cannot be invoked to compute stamp duty.
  • Provisions of Companies Act, Income-tax Act and Transfer of Property Act support that assets vested automatically on conversion and do not constitute a stampable transfer; relied on Anup Industries vs. State of Gujarat (2003(1) GLR 434).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India and anr. vs. M/s. Mahalaxmi Saw Mills P. Ltd. rendered by the Delhi High Court in Letters Patent Appeal No.2514-15/2005 on 23.12.2015 Authority relied on by the State to support that vesting/transfer to a company on conversion can constitute a conveyance attracting stamp duty under Section 2(g). The court distinguished this decision: Mahalaxmi involved changing constitution of partners and leasehold property with persons who were not partners at acquisition; hence it was not applicable to the present facts.
Anup Industries vs. State of Gujarat reported in 2003(1) GLR 434 Authority relied on by respondents to show conversion does not amount to a transfer attracting stamp duty where assets vest automatically and no consideration is paid. The court held this precedent to be squarely applicable to the present facts and relied upon it in upholding the Single Judge's decision.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined factual and legal aspects and proceeded as follows:

  1. Found that on conversion the Partnership Firm became a Private Limited Company with the same business, same ownership ratio, and the partners becoming directors; there was no change in composition, no addition or deletion of persons, and no transfer to any individual director.
  2. Noted that all assets, liabilities, contracts and obligations of the Partnership Firm "vested" in the Company on incorporation and that no consideration was paid for such vesting.
  3. Concluded that Article 20(1) of Schedule I (and the charging provisions) cannot be applied because the Memorandum and Articles did not record any consideration necessary to compute stamp duty; without consideration stated in the instruments, computation under Article 20(1) is not possible.
  4. Distinguished Union of India v. Mahalaxmi Saw Mills on its facts (change in constitution and leasehold with intervening partners) and found it inapplicable.
  5. Accepted that Anup Industries is applicable and supported the view that conversion under the Companies Act does not constitute a stampable transfer in the circumstances of this case.
  6. Concluded that the Single Judge had correctly considered the relevant provisions and law; no error was shown in the impugned order.

Holding and Implications

Letters Patent Appeal dismissed.

Consequences for the parties:

  • The impugned judgment and order of the Single Judge (which set aside the Deputy Collector's order dated 30.09.2015 and the Authority's order dated 06.11.2017 and directed refund of Rs.18,92,757/-) stands confirmed.
  • The civil application for stay is disposed of and there is no order as to costs.

The opinion does not set out any broader binding precedent beyond its application to the facts; its direct effect is limited to the parties and the orders under challenge.

    STATE OF GUJARAT v. JP INN PVT LTD

    C/LPA/413/2021 ORDER DATED: 20/09/2023

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

    R/LETTERS PATENT APPEAL NO. 413 of 2021 In R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1226 of 2018 With

    CIVIL APPLICATION (FOR STAY) NO. 1 of 2021 In R/LETTERS PATENT APPEAL NO. 413 of 2021

    ==========================================================

    STATE OF GUJARAT

    Versus

    JP INN PVT LTD

    ========================================================== Appearance:

    MS HETAL PATEL AGP for the Appellant(s) No. 1,2,3 MR RC KAKKAD(389) for the Respondent(s) No. 1,2 ==========================================================

    CORAM:HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MRS. JUSTICE

    SUNITA AGARWAL

    and

    HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIRUDDHA P. MAYEE

    Date : 20/09/2023

    ORAL ORDER

    (PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIRUDDHA P. MAYEE)

    1. The present Letters Patent Appeal impugns the judgment and order dated 26.11.2019 passed in Special Civil Application No.1226 of 2018, whereby the learned Single Judge has set aside the order dated 06.11.2017 passed in Appeal No.76 of 2017 by the Chief Revenue Controlling Authority, as well as the order dated 30.09.2015 passed by the Deputy Collector, Stamp Duty Valuation Department, and further directed the appellants herein to refund the amount of Rs.18,92,757/- deposited by the writ petitioners.

    Page 1 of 9

    2. The brief facts giving rise to the filing of the present Letters Patent Appeal are as follows :-

    2.1 The respondent No.1 was initially registered as Partnership Firm under the provisions of the Indian Partnership Act with effect from 05.06.2010. As per the terms & conditions of the agreement between the partners, it was agreed that the property of Hirenkumar Kishorkumar Sodha - respondent No.2 herein situated at Plot Nos.2 and 3, Revenue Survey No.92/2, T. P. Scheme No.21, 150 ft. Ring Road, Rajkot admeasuring 2205.60 sq. mtrs. will be utilized for carrying on the business as his share in the capital of the Firm.

    2.2 That, the partners of the Firm unanimously decided to convert the Partnership Firm into a Joint Stock Company to form an Incorporated Company Limited by shares to be registered in accordance with the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013 for the purpose of furtherance, development and advancement of its business. The Firm, therefore, applied for registration as a Company under the Companies Act before the Registrar of Companies, Ahmedabad together with the Memorandum and Articles of Association duly executed and stamped under the provisions of the Gujarat Stamp Act, 1958. That, the Registrar of Companies, Ahmedabad, approved the application of the Firm and issued the certificate of incorporation dated 15.07.2014. The fixed capital of the company is held by the members, who were the partners of the Partnership Firm in the same manner as per their share in the Partnership Firm. The main object of the company was to continue to carry on the business of the Partnership Firm and to get all its assets, liabilities, existing contracts, engagements and obligations

    Page 2 of 9

    vested in the company on and from the date of its incorporation.

    2.3 The respondent No.2, accordingly, gave an application on 26.11.2014 to the Mamlatdar, Rajkot City for the purpose of making entry in the revenue record with regard to the conversion of Partnership Firm into a Private Limited Company, and requested to show the land in question in the name of Private Limited Company in the record of rights. The Mamlatdar, Rajkot City, forwarded the file along with the application to the Deputy Collector, Stamp Duty Valuation Department, for levy of stamp duty on the land in question along with the construction thereon as per the provisions of the Gujarat Stamp Act, 1958. The respondent No.1, vide letter dated 28.07.2015, submitted a letter before the Deputy Collector, Stamp Duty Valuation Department, claiming that there is no transfer of property in the present case and therefore, the same is not liable for any levy of stamp duty. It was further stated that only the Partnership Firm was converted into a Private Limited Company in accordance with the provisions of the Companies Act and thus, the respondent No.1 company is not required to pay any stamp duty, and further requested the appellant No.2 to give a direction to the appellant No.3 to make necessary entries in the revenue record, and show the land in question in the name of Private Limited Company.

    2.4 That, the appellant No.2 issued a show cause notice dated 28.09.2015 to the respondent No.1 to show cause as to why the stamp duty of Rs.18,92,007/- with the penalty of Rs.250/- and further penalty as per Section 39(1)(a) should not be recovered from the respondent No.1 company. The respondent No.1, vide letter dated 29.09.2015 replied stating that the respondent No.1 is not

    Page 3 of 9

    required to pay any stamp duty, as no transfer has taken place, and the existing Partnership Firm is converted into a Private Limited Company. However, the appellant No.2 passed the order dated 29/30.09.2015 directing the respondent No.1 to pay the stamp duty of Rs.18,92,007/- with the penalty of Rs.250/- and further penalty of Rs.500/- as per Section 39(1)(a), totaling to Rs.18,92,757/-.

    2.5 Being aggrieved by the order dated 29/30.09.2015 passed by the appellant No.2, the respondent No.1 company preferred Appeal No.76 of 2015 before the appellant No.1 authority under Section 53(1) of the Gujarat Stamp Act, 1958 for quashing and setting aside the order passed by the appellant No.2, and requested for refund of the amount so deposited before filing of the appeal. However, the appellant No.1, vide order dated 06.11.2017, rejected the said Appeal and confirmed the order dated 29/30.09.2015 passed by the appellant No.2, holding that the Partnership Firm and Private Limited Company are constituted under the different Acts and therefore, any conversion of the Partnership Firm into a Private Limited Company will come under the definition of change of ownership, and therefore, the stamp duty is payable by the respondent No.1. Aggrieved, the respondent No.1 preferred Special Civil Application No.1226 of 2018 in this Court. By the impugned judgment and order, the learned Single Judge has set aside both the orders passed by the appellant No.1 and appellant No.2 and ordered to refund the amount so deposited by the respondent No.1.

    3. Ms. Hetal Patel, the learned Assistant Government Pleader appearing for the State submitted that the learned Single Judge has failed to appreciate that the respondent No.1 Company is a separate legal entity and a juristic person than that of a Partnership Firm

    Page 4 of 9

    which was in existence, and legally, the same stands on different footing. She further submitted that the respondent No.1 Company being a distinct person, any property, movable or immovable transferred or vested in the Company is liable to come within the definition of conveyance under Section 2(g) of the Gujarat Stamp Act, 1958. She submitted that such a transfer of land with the construction thereon from the Partnership Firm to the Private Limited Company would amount to transfer to another person, and therefore, was liable for stamp duty under the Stamp Act. She further submitted that Memorandum and Articles of Association also clearly stipulate that the assets and liabilities of M/s. J. P. INN shall become the properties of Company, and shall stand vested in the Company by virtue of Section 368 of the Companies Act, 2013. She submitted that the term "vested" used in the Memorandum and Articles of Association of new Company would be included within the meaning of Section 2(g) of the Gujarat Stamp Act, and therefore, the same would be considered as conveyance and hence, liable for stamp duty. In support of her submissions, she has relied on the decision in the case of Union of India and anr. vs. M/s. Mahalaxmi Saw Mills P. Ltd. rendered by the Delhi High Court in Letters Patent Appeal No.2514-15/2005 on

    23.12.2015.

    4. Per contra, Shri R. C. Kakkad, the learned advocate appearing for the respondent Nos.1 and 2 - writ petitioners argued that there were seven partners in the Partnership Firm. In the revenue record, the name of the Partnership Firm was shown as occupant with respect to the land in question. That, the partners of the Firm unanimously decided to constitute the Firm as Joint Stock Company as defined under Section 366 of the Companies Act, and

    Page 5 of 9

    accordingly, the name of the Partnership Firm M/s. J. P. Inn came to be converted into a Private Limited Company M/s. J. P. Inn Private Limited. It was submitted that the partners in the Partnership Firm are now Directors of the Private Limited Company. There is no addition of any director or deletion of any old partner. There is no change in the business of actual Partnership Firm after conversion into a Private Limited Company, and that no transfer of the property has taken place. He submitted that the Memorandum of Association and Article of Association do not effect transfer of any asset from Partnership Firm to any individual person, and the only objective of these instruments was to declare that the business of the Partnership Firm and its administration and management would be governed by the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013. The learned advocate further submitted that for obtaining registration under the Companies Act, 2013, it is essential for the Partnership Firm to comply with the provisions of the Companies Act, and to adopt a specific capital and issue shares within the prescribed limits of such capital. He submitted that a reference to Section 2(g) of the Stamp Act treating the Memorandum of Association and Articles of Association as a conveyance is erroneous since the said instruments do not transfer any property or vest any property in any other person, and no such instrument could be said to be inter vivos and therefore, the respondent Nos.1 and 2 are not required to pay any stamp duty. The learned advocate for the respondents also relied upon the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013 to point out that the conversion of the Partnership Firm into a Private Limited Company would not result in any transfer of asset, as all the movable and immovable properties of the Partnership Firm automatically vested in the Private Limited Company. Further reliance is placed on the provisions of Income-Tax Act, 1961 to assert that there is no

    Page 6 of 9

    transfer of any liability and assets on conversion of Partnership Firm into a Company. He has also relied upon the provisions of Section 5 of the Transfer of Property Act that there is no transfer which takes place when the Partnership Firm is converted into a Private Limited Company in accordance with the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013. In support of his submissions, the learned advocate for the respondents relied upon the judgment of this Court in the case of

    Anup Industries vs. State of Gujarat reported in 2003(1) GLR

    434.

    5. Heard the learned advocates for the parties and perused the documents on record.

    6. In the present case, the Partnership Firm has converted itself into a Private Limited Company. There is no change in the business, no change in the ratio of shares and all the assets, liabilities, existing contracts, engagements, obligations of the Partnership Firm came to be vested in the Private Limited Company on and from the date of its incorporation. All the partners of the Partnership Firm have become the Directors of the Private Limited Company in accordance with their ratio in the Partnership Firm. There is no transfer of the property from the Partnership Firm to any individual person or to any individual director in the new Company. The Partnership Firm itself has become a new entity as Private Limited Company by getting itself registered under the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013. It would be pertinent to note that the property of the Partnership Firm has vested in the Private Limited Company, and no consideration has been paid for the same. Therefore, Article 20(1) of Schedule-I to the Stamp Act as relied upon by the appellants would not apply in the present case. The

    Page 7 of 9

    provisions of the Stamp Act have to be read together with the charging Sections of the Stamp Act so as to arrive at the computation of the stamp duty. The present case would not fall under the charging sections of the Stamp Act, as there is no consideration mentioned in the instruments of Memorandum of Association and Articles of Association, and therefore, it will not be possible to compute the stamp duty under Article 20(1) of Schedule-I of the Stamp Act. The stamp duty in the present case will have to be computed in relation to the amount of consideration as would be mentioned in the instruments of conveyance, which, in the present case, are Memorandum of Association and Articles of Association. On conversion from the Partnership Firm to a Private Limited Company, in the present case, there is no change of composition and no any consideration has been transferred to any of the partners.

    7. With reference to the judgment relied upon by the learned advocate for the appellants in the case of M/s. Mahalaxmi Saw Mills P. Ltd. (supra), the same is not applicable in the present case, as in the said case before the Delhi High Court, the constitution of the Partnership Firm had changed from time to time and no intimation thereof was given to the relevant authority. The property sought to be transferred to the company in the said case was a leasehold property, which had undergone change of composition of the partners till its conversion from Partnership Firm into a Company, and certain persons, who were not partners at the time of acquiring the leasehold rights, had also become the partners on the date when the said Firm changed into a Company. Therefore, the reliance placed on the said decision will be of no avail to the appellants herein.

    Page 8 of 9

    8. The reliance placed by the learned advocate for the respondents in the case of Anup Industries (supra) is squarely applicable in the facts and circumstances of the present case.

    9. No error could be pointed in the impugned order by the learned advocate for the appellants. We are of the opinion that the impugned order has taken into consideration all the relevant provisions and the position of law. The present Letters Patent Appeal is thus devoid of merits and is accordingly dismissed.

    10. The Civil Application for stay does not survive and the same is accordingly disposed of.

    No order as to costs.

    (SUNITA AGARWAL, CJ )

    (ANIRUDDHA P. MAYEE, J.)

    cmk

    Page 9 of 9

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    STATE OF GUJARAT v. JP INN PVT LTD
    (Sep 20, 2023)